According to the Auschwitz Museum the tattooing of numbers on prisoners did not start until the arrival of Soviet POWs at Auschwitz in 1941 almost a year after Pilecki's remarkable mission began. The tattooing of earlier numbered prisoners in the camp did not start until 1943 just before Pilecki escaped so it is highly unlikely he was ever tattooed! He never mentioned being tattooed in any of his 3 reports only that he had received an inmate number!
A true hero. I have never heard of him; but I won't forget what he did. As a Jew; I hold a special place for him as one of the "Righteous Gentiles" in our history. But more than this; as a human being i place him in the small ranks of True Heroes in history.
Well, it's false to state that only communist jews sentenced him to death and executed him. Even if there were comparatively more jews involved, the vast majority of "communists" involved were ethnically speaking "Polish".
But what would I say if I were a jew? Well, condemn this deeds and prosecute the responsible individuals because they broke the law as individuals.
@MrFiatlux2004 Men who executed Witold Pilecki was Staff Sergeant Piotr Śmietański. Śmietański – nicknamed by the prisoners, the "Butcher of the Mokotow Prison" he emigrated from Poland to Israel in 1968. Many so called Polish communists after 1945 has Russian and Jewisch ethnicity. Whole Russian units started to be Polish after orders of Stalin. 60% of officers was Soviets and 40% of soldiers. Many officers of UB was Jewisch.
Please don't lecture me.... I know something about history. I and nobody denies that jews were involved....but so are "poles", russians, ukrainians etc etc etc...The vast majority was non-jewish. See the writings of Tadeusz Piotrowski, Norman Davies.
As I commented before, the quilty ones, whatever their "ethnicity" should be prosecuted. Simon Wiesenthal wanted exact that: prosecuting those "communist" jews who commited crimes.
@MrFiatlux2004 Maria Dąbrowska was leftist writer, cooperative promotor. She wroted in 1947 "UB, Courts are completly in Jewisch hands. Durning last 2 years any Jew haven`t any political case. Jews judge and punished the Poles." She wasn`t antisemite. Jews played dominant irole in communists ranks after war. It was a fact. They judged Polish patriots as fascists. Because in eyes of communists patriotism is a fascism.
I know about this. Tadeusz Piotrowaski writes about this too. And although there were relatively speaking many commi's of jewish-polish origin, some of them having leading positions in certain camps and for example the UB, still they weren't the dominant, the all mighty who ruled. Don't forget that also Polish hardcore commi's who survived the cleansings by Stalin and co. hated the anti-communist "secret state" members and collaborated with the occupying soviets.
To speak about jewish-polish collaboration and to correct certain untrue "alleged" anti-jewish actions during and after the war it's very important to stick to facts and to do it on a non-racist way of thinking. But also it's very important that attrocities done against jews in the war by poles should be acknowledged. But nobody should make statements about a people based on individual cases, no matter how many there are.
@MrFiatlux2004 I not say that "all" and "completely" but many. Among officers something about 50%. There was many Jews in so called "Polish UB" and if someone say something about it he is antisemite of course. Józef Światło (first name Izaak Fleischfarb) - high rank He was nicknamed "Butcher" – the torture master Ministry of Public Security of Poland prisoners. Salomon Morel Colonel in the political police, comandant of Zgoda labour NKVD camp... many others...
If you and others stick to the facts then nobody will say you are an anti-semite. But if you and others try to use this information to judge a people in general, in this case the jews or polish jews..., or to excuse attrocities done to jews by other Polish citizens then I think this is wrong... I'm concinced that also many jews suffered under communist/stalinist oppression, were killed. tortured by jewish commies.
@MrFiatlux2004 Facts is that I was read many about Polish antisemitism but nothing about Jewisch antipolonism. All this facts are banned in profesional historiography. Jews are under care bacause of holocaust. Poles are not. They was also killed by nazis but who cares of it? They was just "stupid Polish antisemites" so let`s do some Polish jokes about Them... and this is my point there are equal and more equal...
Well mr 'Licikaviki', I think very many people care about Polish citizens of non-jewish origin being killed by the soviets and nazis in the Netherlands (many Dutch from towns as Breda, Arnhem and Driel remember the Poles and know about their lost homeland. There are many historians (for example Davies, Karski, Stachura, RC Lukas, Zamoyski, Piotrowski, Timothy Snyder. And what do you mean by "under care"?
I'm convinced that there are many articles about Polish-Jewish relations and the ethnic tensions between them. But most certainly on a scientific factual level which tries to explain the racist tendencies on both sides in broad context. Exagerations by certain scholars (some of jewish origin) which are maybe mainstream in western Europe and the US are hopefully counterbalanced and corrected. And please, jokes are only jokes.... don't take it seriously!
Please, believe, I love Poland and I'm very proud of what many Poles (including other Polish citizens of different ethnicity) did. But that doesn't mean that all the romantic ideas about the suffering polish nation and that all Poles were heroes and the underground state did "all" they could to help and save their Polish jewish fellow citizens are less romantic and not that all true. As Karski states: Poles suffered immensely, but the jews suffered much much more (generally speaking)
@MrFiatlux2004 Not all Poles was heroes some was traitors and NKVD agents. They was Soviets with Polish ethnicity like Dzierżyński.... Poland wasn`t free state after WWII because was setup by Red Army, NKVD, Soviets of different nationalities and by Polish traitors and I always be opposed to calling this state Poland and generalization that "Poles" are guilty of some crimes colectivelly. It wasn`t Our state - We just lived under occupation.
I'm not generalizing. There were to many Poles who collaborated either with the soviets or nazis wherever they came from. For example gen. Berling. I and many don't state that Poles are guilty of crimes collectively. But that doesn't change the fact that there were to many Poles who did terrible things to their fellow citizens by killing, denouncing, blackmailing jews and Poles who helped them. So did some jewish citizens too.
@MrFiatlux2004 Jakub Berman - Joseph Stalin's right hand in the People's Republic of Poland, Anatol Fejgin - commander of the Stalinist political police at the Ministry of Public Security of Poland, Helena Wolińska-Brus (born Fajga Mindla Danielak), was a military prosecutor in Poland with the rank of lieutenant-colonel, Roman Romkowski (Natan Grünspau [Grinszpan]-Kikiel) Berman's Ministry of Public Security (MBP) during 1940-1950....
@MrFiatlux2004 Józef Różański (b. Josek Goldberg) member of the Soviet NKVD and later, colonel of the Stalinist Ministry of Public Security of Poland. Julia Brystiger "Bloody Luna" was a direct reference of her Gestapo-like methods during interrogations... Jerzy Borejsza (b.Beniamin Goldberg) brother of "Różański" -chief of the communist press, censorship and propaganda...
@MrFiatlux2004 Yes there was also many communists of Polish ethnicity like Komintern agent and later agent NKVD Bolesław Bierut, Stanislaw Radkiewicz Polish descent - born in Soviet Union and with Soviet citizenship. He lived in Soviet Union first and started to live in Poland after entry of Red Army...
@MrFiatlux2004 but nothing was wroted about Jewish antipolonism before and after war. Critic of Jews in any case is antisemitism? They are all saints? Many UB communist persecutors emigrated from Poland after end of stalinism and played role "victims of Polish antisemitism" like Helena Wolińska-Brus (orginally Fajga Mindla Danielak) military prosecutor in Poland. She ordered death to Home Army comander gen.Emil August Fieldorf very known "fascist and antisemite".
Of course not all jws are saints. They are human beings, like Poles. I don't say Polish Jews didn't have any role in those persecutions. And I don't say there wasn't any anti-polish sentiment in certain jewish circles before and during and after the war.. And it's true that many "expelled'" communists of Polish-Jewish origins who did terrible things changed face. But the vast majority of jews didn't have anything to do with, how many examples of jews you give!
@Pankracyogame He was executed by the communist. Sadly some were Jewish, but the overall idea is Poland was bullied by many countries over the years and under communist rule it didnt represent the true spirit of Poland he loved. Most polish jews were killed in the holocaust or left during.
Poland was the only country to try and stop the German invasion of their country on main land Europe. This man ipitimized their struggle. He is a first rate WWll hero. His decendents should be so proud. As a decendent of polish family I am proud he is a relative in spirit.
It's ok to be proud. But it is untrue to state that Poland was the only country or nation to stop the German invasion. For example France, the Netherlands, Belgium and eventually the Soviet Union (ok, at first Stalin signed the non-agression pact stabbing Poland in the back and afterwards a treaty of friendship).
Córka rotmistrza Pileckiego w wywiadzie dla radia Plus poinformowała, że Witold Pilecki został odznaczony pośmiertnie przez prezydenta prof.Kaczyńskiego Orderem Orła Białego. Nie obyło się bez komplikacji - trzech z pośród 4 członków kapituły było przeciw, a w kapitule wówczas zasiadali: Władysław Bartoszewski, Bronisław Geremek, Tadeusz Mazowiecki i jako przewodniczący Prezydent Lech Kaczyński, którego głos przesądził o odznaczeniu.
Przez 20 lat w wolnej Polsce rodzina Pileckiego domagała się skazania winnych, protestowała przeciwko utrudnieniom ze strony sądów, nie skazano ludzi odpowiedzialnych za jego śmierć, a zrehabilitowano go z wielkim trudem..
Obecnie dzieci Pileckiego, a także córka gen. Fieldorfa są przedstawiane przez środowisko Gazety Wyborczej za oszołomy, antysemitów, ludzi chorych z nienawiści.
To antypolskie środowisko.
Dziękuję za przywracanie pamięci naszym bohaterom.
Są ludzie, którzy całkowicie zniszczyli w sobie pragnienie prawdy i gotowość do kochania. Ludzie, w których wszystko stało się kłamstwem; ludzie, którzy żyli w nienawiści i podeptali w sobie miłość. Jest to straszna perspektywa, ale w niektórych postaciach naszej historii można odnaleźć w sposób przerażający postawy tego rodzaju. Takich ludzi już nie można uleczyć, a zniszczenie dobra jest nieodwołalne: to jest to, na co wskazuje słowo piekło
@PolishAmericanDC Każdy człowiek ma wolną wolę i ta wolnosc może prowadzić na wyżyny człowieczeństwa jak i w otchłań .Wybór należy do nas. Tylko i wyłącznie do nas. To najpiekniejsze jak i najstraszniejsze wyzwanie w życiu każdego człowieka.Nasze sumienie jest czymś w rodzaju czarnej skrzynki,ktoś kiedyś bedzie z niej czytał....Pozdrawiam Przyjaciół.
I judged the Poles by their enemies. And I found it was an almost unfailing truth that their enemies were the enemies of magnanimity and manhood. If a man loved slavery, if he loved usury, if he loved terrorism and all the trampled mire of materialistic politics, I have always found that he added to these affections the passion of a hatred of Poland. She could be judged in the light of that hatred; and the judgment has proved to be right."
I judged the Poles by their enemies. And I found it was an almost unfailing truth that their enemies were the enemies of magnanimity and manhood. If a man loved slavery, if he loved usury, if he loved terrorism and all the trampled mire of materialistic politics, I have always found that he added to these affections the passion of a hatred of Poland. She could be judged in the light of that hatred; and the judgment has proved to be right."
Krakowska Fundacja Paradis Judaeorum skierowała wniosek do ministra kultury i dziedzictwa narodowego o odwołanie Piotra Cywińskiego ze stanowiska dyrektora Państwowego Muzeum Auschwitz-Birkenau.
Fundacja, która prowadzi akcję Przypomnijmy o Rotmistrzu, zarzuca dyrektorowi Muzeum, że sprzeciwiał się wybiciu przez Narodowy Bank Polski monet z wizerunkiem rotmistrza Witolda Pileckiego z okazji 65. rocznicy wyzwolenia obozu KL Auschwitz.
Man... All of a sudden, i feel so cold inside. Imagine what misery this man must have seen around him in his lifetime. And after all that, he was hung like a criminal... Good thing you made this clip. I never heared of him before.
I read up Pilecki after I had seen Auschwitz with my 84 year old survivor grandfather. It just amazes me how this man, a gentile, would volunteer, create resistance, and escape. He is a true hero, far beyond Rambo or any other overly idolized action hero. Hollywood needs to do a movie on him, get his story out before it dies.
@measwel i like the spirit of your statement but unfortunately his story only came to light after the fall of the wall and even now it is not common knowledge. Poland has a history of being bullied and occupied so i cant place much stock in the survival of a free-poland.
@evillmonky Pilecki's heroism was the subject of a best-selling book in 1975 (well before the fall of the wall) published in English and Polish it was entitled: " Fighting Auschwitz : The resistance movement in the concentration camp." published in London by Friedmann, 1975. The author was Polish historian Dr.Jósef Garlínski. There is new book about Pilecki's Auschwitz report due out in April 2012—"The Auschwitz Volunteer: Beyond Bravery".
@evillmonky - sorry, I pressed the wrong thumb! I meant the "up" one you should have 22 ups by now - I agree with you totally, Hollywood needs to cop on to the "real" stories that need to be told. - sorry again - I'm old. - Blessings - Rene
@ferdovit they did Defiance about the polish partisans. And one of the brothers has been charged with a sex crime. if they can make a hollywood blockbuster about them, they can do it about pilecki easily.
@evillmonky ... you must be joking! Defiance is about the Jewish partisans who collaborated with the soviets, harrased and plundred local population and these who opposed they massacred, like in the Polish village Nailiboki.
Hollywood never did and will not do a movie about Pilecki or anything that pictures the Polish secret state, goverment on exile, army or the occupied country, except for holocaust of course. Honestly, i don`t care why.
I would like to thank you for making a video in memory of Polish heros. They are forgotten in text books. where all you learn is bullshit collective identities.
it warms my heart to see that Polish people did extraordinary things and are not forgotten
my heart goes out to all of you who know your history =D
Rotmistrz Pilecki był dobrowolnym więźniem KL Auschwitz, organizatorem obozowej organizacji ruchu oporu (informował świat o zbrodniach nazistowskich Niemiec), uciekinier z obozu, żołnierz Powstania Warszawskiego. Zydokomuna zamordowała go po wojnie.
Bo był polskim patriotą.
Polecam książkę Kazimierza Piechowskiego"Byłem numerem", wyd.s.Loretanek, 2004.
A amazing man, whose story was only ever made public in 1989! After all he went through in Auschwitz, and after he informed the Allies of the attrocities, he was accused of exaggerating, and nothing was ever done! It defies belief!
You could have added at the end of the video that it is rumoured that his dead body was dumped on a rubbish tip...what an undignified end for a true hero.
Rozpoczynał się[...]"okres błędów i wypaczeń".W istocie rzeczy jednak chodziło w nim o zakrojone na szeroką skalę represje polityczne skierowane[...]w żołnierzy Podziemia walczącego z Niemcami, mordowanych bezprawnie w "majestacie prawa". Chodziło także o dalsze zniszczenie i wyeliminowanie z życia społecznego inteligencji polskiej, zniszczenie samodzielnych myśli ekonomicznych i społecznych, zdeptanie kultury, zastraszenie ludzi /P. Stachiewicz, "Parasol")
Pamięć o człowieku, którego całe życie podporządkowane było jednemu celowi, walce o niepodległą Polskę, po dziś dzień nie znajduje należytego miejsca. W podręcznikach szkolnych postać Pileckiego traktowana jest marginalnie. Dziwna niemoc w kwestii poruszania tematów związanych z najnowszą historią Polski trwa od lat. Jest to tym bardziej zaskakujące, że życiorys Witolda Pileckiego to gotowy scenariusz na film sensacyjny w najlepszym tego słowa znaczeniu.
A nawet na kilka filmow sensacyjnych. Mowiac kolokwialnie scenarzysci z Hollywood nie wymysliliby takiego scenariusza, jaki los zafundowal Pileckiemu. Polecam jego biografie "Ochotnik do Auschwitz" autorstwa Andrzeja Cyry. Niezwykly czlowiek, niezwykla biografia.
Czytałem i zgadzam się. Facet był jak superman tyle, że naprawdę. Każdy kto zrobi dobry film o Pileckim ma oskara w kieszeni. Byle nie Wajda... najlepsze czasy ma za sobą.
Brytyjski historyk Michael Foot zaliczył go do jednego z sześciu najodważniejszych ludzi ruchu oporu podczas II wojny światowej. Niestety postać rotmistrza Witolda Pileckiego ciągle jeszcze nie znalazła godnego miejsca w historii Polski.
Unbelievable example of dedication and courage. No one never ever has impressed me that much. I wish I could shake his hand.
He survived so much... WWI, the Polish-Soviet war in 1920, the September Campaign in 1939, German occupation of Poland, over 2 years long volunteery imprisonment in Auschwitz, the Warsaw Uprising in 1944, German POW camps... just to be tortured and eventually shot dead in the back of the head by a Polish communist security officer three years after the war.
Na google video jest w całości teatr telewizji o procesie Pileckiego. Gorąco polecam. Facetowi należy się film i ulica z nazwiskiem w każdym mieście. Pojawił sie pomysł, że Mel Gibson mógłby to nakręcić...ciekawe.
Na stronie IPN jest dużo informacji na ten temat. Wychodzi na to, że największy wpływ na wydanie wyroku śmierci miał Cyrankiewicz, który był także w Auschvitz, a Pilecki miał na niego prawdopodobnie kwity świadczące o jego kolaboracji z obozowym gestapo.
"he was arrested by Polish security service" well... not exacly, Poland in 1947r. was under soviet ocupation (till 1989r!) and there was no "Polish" security service, it was run by KGB, and murderred meny Poles who wanterd to fight with russian ocupation
It is not fair to blame Poland for his death as Poland was no more. This was "Communist" run Poland in May 1947. Many polish died at the hands of "Soviets". My Grandfather was in the 2nd Polish corps and Polands free Army. In 1951 he knew going into Poland was a death sentence and he came to the USA.
"Witold Pilecki" was a hero but did not die in Poland, he died in "Communist run Poland" under the Soviet brutal dictator, "Joseph Stalin". Poland is now free to tell. God Bless Poland
Encouraged by Rabbi Israel Singer's, the General Secretary of the World Jewish Congress, statements in 1996 such as " If Poland does not satisfy Jewish claims, it will be publicly attacked and humiliated in the international forum." So it is a plan to deliberately slander Poland's name and manipulate the American public's opinion against Poles. It was permitted to slander Poles now
I live just a block from him, on Aleja Wojska Polskiego, he is a true hero for me, a symbol, a devotion to what you really believe in, the truth, love and duty. If I could I would have a last supper with him.......to meet him and discover his beauty
Ci ludzie mieli rodziny,które miały tylko ich! Masowe groby...smierć tysięcy oficerów! Śmierć milionów Polaków! Tylko dla ambicji, które i tak nie przetrwały!postanowili wymordować bo walczyliśmy do końca!nie tylko Nas-ludzi ale kulturę, język i historię! Przetrwalismy... dzięki takim ludziom jak Ci,którzy lezeli martwi w Katyniu!Do końca walczyli za Polskę za Nas!
Thanks for this video. I would like to invite you (all of you) to the campaign "Przypomnijmy o Rotmistrzu" ("Let's Reminisce About Witold Pilecki"). For details search in google and/or at my websites. Greetings
According to the Auschwitz Museum the tattooing of numbers on prisoners did not start until the arrival of Soviet POWs at Auschwitz in 1941 almost a year after Pilecki's remarkable mission began. The tattooing of earlier numbered prisoners in the camp did not start until 1943 just before Pilecki escaped so it is highly unlikely he was ever tattooed! He never mentioned being tattooed in any of his 3 reports only that he had received an inmate number!
A truly heroic man & story nonetheless!!
fourthskorpion 1 month ago
Chwała i wieczna pamięć bohaterom Polski jak Witold Pilecki !
Hańba zawszonym komuchom !
Glov00 5 months ago in playlist Więcej filmów od użytkownika electronautpl
Biggest heroes of all, staid loyal to Poland till the end, If I ever could even be half of a man he was Id die as a happy man.
AzzHunterbunny 8 months ago
Chwała Bohaterowi.
Właśnie o takich osobach powinniśmy uczyć nasze dzieci, bo na media nie mamy co liczyć. W mediach wywyższani są ludzie pokroju che fujary...
NiePrzeklinaj 1 year ago
Comment removed
pawel085 1 year ago
A true hero. I have never heard of him; but I won't forget what he did. As a Jew; I hold a special place for him as one of the "Righteous Gentiles" in our history. But more than this; as a human being i place him in the small ranks of True Heroes in history.
TheSteveb189 1 year ago
@TheSteveb189
So as a jew - what will you say about jews who sentenced him to death and jews who executed him?
Pankracyogame 1 year ago 17
@Pankracyogame
Well, it's false to state that only communist jews sentenced him to death and executed him. Even if there were comparatively more jews involved, the vast majority of "communists" involved were ethnically speaking "Polish".
But what would I say if I were a jew? Well, condemn this deeds and prosecute the responsible individuals because they broke the law as individuals.
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 Men who executed Witold Pilecki was Staff Sergeant Piotr Śmietański. Śmietański – nicknamed by the prisoners, the "Butcher of the Mokotow Prison" he emigrated from Poland to Israel in 1968. Many so called Polish communists after 1945 has Russian and Jewisch ethnicity. Whole Russian units started to be Polish after orders of Stalin. 60% of officers was Soviets and 40% of soldiers. Many officers of UB was Jewisch.
licicaviki 1 year ago
@licicaviki
Please don't lecture me.... I know something about history. I and nobody denies that jews were involved....but so are "poles", russians, ukrainians etc etc etc...The vast majority was non-jewish. See the writings of Tadeusz Piotrowski, Norman Davies.
As I commented before, the quilty ones, whatever their "ethnicity" should be prosecuted. Simon Wiesenthal wanted exact that: prosecuting those "communist" jews who commited crimes.
May I remind you what Jan Karski wrote about
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004
May I remind you what Jan Karski wrote about anti-semitism in some factions of the AK?
Ans also I want to remind you that 100.000 polish jews fought in the Polish army in the tragic september campaign of 1939 to defend their motherland.
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 Maria Dąbrowska was leftist writer, cooperative promotor. She wroted in 1947 "UB, Courts are completly in Jewisch hands. Durning last 2 years any Jew haven`t any political case. Jews judge and punished the Poles." She wasn`t antisemite. Jews played dominant irole in communists ranks after war. It was a fact. They judged Polish patriots as fascists. Because in eyes of communists patriotism is a fascism.
licicaviki 1 year ago
@licicaviki
I know about this. Tadeusz Piotrowaski writes about this too. And although there were relatively speaking many commi's of jewish-polish origin, some of them having leading positions in certain camps and for example the UB, still they weren't the dominant, the all mighty who ruled. Don't forget that also Polish hardcore commi's who survived the cleansings by Stalin and co. hated the anti-communist "secret state" members and collaborated with the occupying soviets.
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@licicaviki
To speak about jewish-polish collaboration and to correct certain untrue "alleged" anti-jewish actions during and after the war it's very important to stick to facts and to do it on a non-racist way of thinking. But also it's very important that attrocities done against jews in the war by poles should be acknowledged. But nobody should make statements about a people based on individual cases, no matter how many there are.
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@licicaviki
Head of the UB was "Stanislaw Radkiewicz, a ethnic Pole. Boleslaw Bierut, an ethnic Pole.
Please give me evidence that "all" the courts during the Stalin terror were completely dominated by Jews. Numbers, names etc...
Please give me names of Poles of jewish decen who were killed. tortured by so called "jews"....
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 I not say that "all" and "completely" but many. Among officers something about 50%. There was many Jews in so called "Polish UB" and if someone say something about it he is antisemite of course. Józef Światło (first name Izaak Fleischfarb) - high rank He was nicknamed "Butcher" – the torture master Ministry of Public Security of Poland prisoners. Salomon Morel Colonel in the political police, comandant of Zgoda labour NKVD camp... many others...
licicaviki 1 year ago
@licicaviki
If you and others stick to the facts then nobody will say you are an anti-semite. But if you and others try to use this information to judge a people in general, in this case the jews or polish jews..., or to excuse attrocities done to jews by other Polish citizens then I think this is wrong... I'm concinced that also many jews suffered under communist/stalinist oppression, were killed. tortured by jewish commies.
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 Facts is that I was read many about Polish antisemitism but nothing about Jewisch antipolonism. All this facts are banned in profesional historiography. Jews are under care bacause of holocaust. Poles are not. They was also killed by nazis but who cares of it? They was just "stupid Polish antisemites" so let`s do some Polish jokes about Them... and this is my point there are equal and more equal...
licicaviki 1 year ago
@licicaviki
Well mr 'Licikaviki', I think very many people care about Polish citizens of non-jewish origin being killed by the soviets and nazis in the Netherlands (many Dutch from towns as Breda, Arnhem and Driel remember the Poles and know about their lost homeland. There are many historians (for example Davies, Karski, Stachura, RC Lukas, Zamoyski, Piotrowski, Timothy Snyder. And what do you mean by "under care"?
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@licicaviki
I'm convinced that there are many articles about Polish-Jewish relations and the ethnic tensions between them. But most certainly on a scientific factual level which tries to explain the racist tendencies on both sides in broad context. Exagerations by certain scholars (some of jewish origin) which are maybe mainstream in western Europe and the US are hopefully counterbalanced and corrected. And please, jokes are only jokes.... don't take it seriously!
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@licicaviki
Please, believe, I love Poland and I'm very proud of what many Poles (including other Polish citizens of different ethnicity) did. But that doesn't mean that all the romantic ideas about the suffering polish nation and that all Poles were heroes and the underground state did "all" they could to help and save their Polish jewish fellow citizens are less romantic and not that all true. As Karski states: Poles suffered immensely, but the jews suffered much much more (generally speaking)
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 Not all Poles was heroes some was traitors and NKVD agents. They was Soviets with Polish ethnicity like Dzierżyński.... Poland wasn`t free state after WWII because was setup by Red Army, NKVD, Soviets of different nationalities and by Polish traitors and I always be opposed to calling this state Poland and generalization that "Poles" are guilty of some crimes colectivelly. It wasn`t Our state - We just lived under occupation.
licicaviki 1 year ago
@licicaviki
I'm not generalizing. There were to many Poles who collaborated either with the soviets or nazis wherever they came from. For example gen. Berling. I and many don't state that Poles are guilty of crimes collectively. But that doesn't change the fact that there were to many Poles who did terrible things to their fellow citizens by killing, denouncing, blackmailing jews and Poles who helped them. So did some jewish citizens too.
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 Jakub Berman - Joseph Stalin's right hand in the People's Republic of Poland, Anatol Fejgin - commander of the Stalinist political police at the Ministry of Public Security of Poland, Helena Wolińska-Brus (born Fajga Mindla Danielak), was a military prosecutor in Poland with the rank of lieutenant-colonel, Roman Romkowski (Natan Grünspau [Grinszpan]-Kikiel) Berman's Ministry of Public Security (MBP) during 1940-1950....
licicaviki 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 Józef Różański (b. Josek Goldberg) member of the Soviet NKVD and later, colonel of the Stalinist Ministry of Public Security of Poland. Julia Brystiger "Bloody Luna" was a direct reference of her Gestapo-like methods during interrogations... Jerzy Borejsza (b.Beniamin Goldberg) brother of "Różański" -chief of the communist press, censorship and propaganda...
licicaviki 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 Yes there was also many communists of Polish ethnicity like Komintern agent and later agent NKVD Bolesław Bierut, Stanislaw Radkiewicz Polish descent - born in Soviet Union and with Soviet citizenship. He lived in Soviet Union first and started to live in Poland after entry of Red Army...
licicaviki 1 year ago
@MrFiatlux2004 but nothing was wroted about Jewish antipolonism before and after war. Critic of Jews in any case is antisemitism? They are all saints? Many UB communist persecutors emigrated from Poland after end of stalinism and played role "victims of Polish antisemitism" like Helena Wolińska-Brus (orginally Fajga Mindla Danielak) military prosecutor in Poland. She ordered death to Home Army comander gen.Emil August Fieldorf very known "fascist and antisemite".
licicaviki 1 year ago
@licicaviki
Of course not all jws are saints. They are human beings, like Poles. I don't say Polish Jews didn't have any role in those persecutions. And I don't say there wasn't any anti-polish sentiment in certain jewish circles before and during and after the war.. And it's true that many "expelled'" communists of Polish-Jewish origins who did terrible things changed face. But the vast majority of jews didn't have anything to do with, how many examples of jews you give!
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
@Pankracyogame He was executed by the communist. Sadly some were Jewish, but the overall idea is Poland was bullied by many countries over the years and under communist rule it didnt represent the true spirit of Poland he loved. Most polish jews were killed in the holocaust or left during.
evillmonky 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a story for Hollywood.. What I say... they prefere stupid Stalinists' stories made for dirty spoiled money, produced for idiots...
fromcliffs 1 year ago
This is a story for Hollywood.. What I say... they prefere stupid Stalinists' stories made for dirty spoiled money, produced for idiots...
fromcliffs 1 year ago 3
Poland was the only country to try and stop the German invasion of their country on main land Europe. This man ipitimized their struggle. He is a first rate WWll hero. His decendents should be so proud. As a decendent of polish family I am proud he is a relative in spirit.
mischak49 1 year ago
@mischak49
It's ok to be proud. But it is untrue to state that Poland was the only country or nation to stop the German invasion. For example France, the Netherlands, Belgium and eventually the Soviet Union (ok, at first Stalin signed the non-agression pact stabbing Poland in the back and afterwards a treaty of friendship).
MrFiatlux2004 1 year ago
Córka rotmistrza Pileckiego w wywiadzie dla radia Plus poinformowała, że Witold Pilecki został odznaczony pośmiertnie przez prezydenta prof.Kaczyńskiego Orderem Orła Białego. Nie obyło się bez komplikacji - trzech z pośród 4 członków kapituły było przeciw, a w kapitule wówczas zasiadali: Władysław Bartoszewski, Bronisław Geremek, Tadeusz Mazowiecki i jako przewodniczący Prezydent Lech Kaczyński, którego głos przesądził o odznaczeniu.
amabeline 1 year ago 7
Przez 20 lat w wolnej Polsce rodzina Pileckiego domagała się skazania winnych, protestowała przeciwko utrudnieniom ze strony sądów, nie skazano ludzi odpowiedzialnych za jego śmierć, a zrehabilitowano go z wielkim trudem..
Obecnie dzieci Pileckiego, a także córka gen. Fieldorfa są przedstawiane przez środowisko Gazety Wyborczej za oszołomy, antysemitów, ludzi chorych z nienawiści.
To antypolskie środowisko.
Dziękuję za przywracanie pamięci naszym bohaterom.
amabeline 1 year ago 5
Są ludzie, którzy całkowicie zniszczyli w sobie pragnienie prawdy i gotowość do kochania. Ludzie, w których wszystko stało się kłamstwem; ludzie, którzy żyli w nienawiści i podeptali w sobie miłość. Jest to straszna perspektywa, ale w niektórych postaciach naszej historii można odnaleźć w sposób przerażający postawy tego rodzaju. Takich ludzi już nie można uleczyć, a zniszczenie dobra jest nieodwołalne: to jest to, na co wskazuje słowo piekło
PolishAmericanDC 1 year ago
@PolishAmericanDC Każdy człowiek ma wolną wolę i ta wolnosc może prowadzić na wyżyny człowieczeństwa jak i w otchłań .Wybór należy do nas. Tylko i wyłącznie do nas. To najpiekniejsze jak i najstraszniejsze wyzwanie w życiu każdego człowieka.Nasze sumienie jest czymś w rodzaju czarnej skrzynki,ktoś kiedyś bedzie z niej czytał....Pozdrawiam Przyjaciół.
pawel085 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I judged the Poles by their enemies. And I found it was an almost unfailing truth that their enemies were the enemies of magnanimity and manhood. If a man loved slavery, if he loved usury, if he loved terrorism and all the trampled mire of materialistic politics, I have always found that he added to these affections the passion of a hatred of Poland. She could be judged in the light of that hatred; and the judgment has proved to be right."
Gilbert Keith Chesterton
divustitus 2 years ago 5
@divustitus
I judged the Poles by their enemies. And I found it was an almost unfailing truth that their enemies were the enemies of magnanimity and manhood. If a man loved slavery, if he loved usury, if he loved terrorism and all the trampled mire of materialistic politics, I have always found that he added to these affections the passion of a hatred of Poland. She could be judged in the light of that hatred; and the judgment has proved to be right."
Gilbert Keith Chesterton
editgrin 1 year ago 2
Zbrodniczym prokuratorem oskarżającym Pileckiego był major Czesław Łapiński
Zmarł on w 2004 r. na chorobę nowotworową w warszawskim szpitalu.
Szpital ten jest przy ul. Rotmistrza Witolda Pileckiego!
SemperFidelisPolonia 2 years ago 11
@SemperFidelisPolonia buahahahah co za ironia losu :D
Sebastianek1990 9 months ago
Krakowska Fundacja Paradis Judaeorum skierowała wniosek do ministra kultury i dziedzictwa narodowego o odwołanie Piotra Cywińskiego ze stanowiska dyrektora Państwowego Muzeum Auschwitz-Birkenau.
Fundacja, która prowadzi akcję Przypomnijmy o Rotmistrzu, zarzuca dyrektorowi Muzeum, że sprzeciwiał się wybiciu przez Narodowy Bank Polski monet z wizerunkiem rotmistrza Witolda Pileckiego z okazji 65. rocznicy wyzwolenia obozu KL Auschwitz.
Pytanie za 10 zł: Czy Cywiński jest obrzezany?
SemperFidelisPolonia 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
panhus11 2 years ago
Comment removed
panhus11 2 years ago
Right before his murder(!) he said to his wife: "make our children read Thomas s Kempis' "De imitatione Christi"
I never heard of this book before I found out who Pilecki was...
Thank you also for that!
Pankracyogame 2 years ago 7
Kroniki Auschwitz - Najdluzszy Apel was removed why?
PolishAmericanDC 2 years ago 5
why the other fils like "Kroniki Auschwitz - Najdluzszy Apel" were removed?
PolishAmericanDC 2 years ago 5
Glory to the true heroes and defenders of the faith!
kswujek 2 years ago 8
Now thats a HERO! My hat goes off to the man, and I bow.
nikiforberg 2 years ago 9
I am so sorry about this - Grüße aus Deutschland
zeitkoenig 2 years ago 16
Me too. - Blessings - Rene
mammyoriordan 2 years ago 4
Well, dont be its not your fault :)
Rotmistrz Pilecki bez watpienia jednym z najwartosciowszych Polakow w naszej historii.
Chwala i czesc prawym poleglym.
markzen582 2 years ago 5
Eine Lebensgeschichte mal zum Nachdenken.Tut mir leid...
Video ist Super, vielen Dank!
henschelina 2 years ago 16
Man... All of a sudden, i feel so cold inside. Imagine what misery this man must have seen around him in his lifetime. And after all that, he was hung like a criminal... Good thing you made this clip. I never heared of him before.
Troublesome2008 2 years ago 16
Witold was like Superman... but in reality.... All the best to You from Poland.... Always listen Your heart...
ferdovit 2 years ago 11
actually he was shot...but it doesn't mane a difrence
SnoopDom22 2 years ago
So very brave and nobel.
mystic90210 2 years ago 21
I read up Pilecki after I had seen Auschwitz with my 84 year old survivor grandfather. It just amazes me how this man, a gentile, would volunteer, create resistance, and escape. He is a true hero, far beyond Rambo or any other overly idolized action hero. Hollywood needs to do a movie on him, get his story out before it dies.
evillmonky 2 years ago 24
It will never die. Not as long as Poles live.
measwel 2 years ago 16
@measwel i like the spirit of your statement but unfortunately his story only came to light after the fall of the wall and even now it is not common knowledge. Poland has a history of being bullied and occupied so i cant place much stock in the survival of a free-poland.
evillmonky 1 month ago
@evillmonky Pilecki's heroism was the subject of a best-selling book in 1975 (well before the fall of the wall) published in English and Polish it was entitled: " Fighting Auschwitz : The resistance movement in the concentration camp." published in London by Friedmann, 1975. The author was Polish historian Dr.Jósef Garlínski. There is new book about Pilecki's Auschwitz report due out in April 2012—"The Auschwitz Volunteer: Beyond Bravery".
fourthskorpion 1 month ago
@fourthskorpion I had no idea, I will look into obtaining copies of both books you mentioned.
evillmonky 1 month ago
@evillmonky - sorry, I pressed the wrong thumb! I meant the "up" one you should have 22 ups by now - I agree with you totally, Hollywood needs to cop on to the "real" stories that need to be told. - sorry again - I'm old. - Blessings - Rene
mammyoriordan 2 years ago
Hollywood liked more the plastic herous I`m afraid... and He is a Pole... So They probably invent Polish jokes about Him ...
ferdovit 2 years ago 9
@ferdovit they did Defiance about the polish partisans. And one of the brothers has been charged with a sex crime. if they can make a hollywood blockbuster about them, they can do it about pilecki easily.
evillmonky 1 month ago
@evillmonky ... you must be joking! Defiance is about the Jewish partisans who collaborated with the soviets, harrased and plundred local population and these who opposed they massacred, like in the Polish village Nailiboki.
Hollywood never did and will not do a movie about Pilecki or anything that pictures the Polish secret state, goverment on exile, army or the occupied country, except for holocaust of course. Honestly, i don`t care why.
MaximusProteus 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
panhus11 2 years ago
AMABELINE MA RACJE
divustitus 2 years ago
How different this man was from me and anyone I have known; how much better! Is one born with such energy & valor? Can one learn it?
jmm194709 2 years ago 72
Comment removed
ferdovit 2 years ago
Nazi and commie - one big shit
Pampalini77 2 years ago 8
I would like to thank you for making a video in memory of Polish heros. They are forgotten in text books. where all you learn is bullshit collective identities.
it warms my heart to see that Polish people did extraordinary things and are not forgotten
my heart goes out to all of you who know your history =D
adaspolakk 2 years ago 51
God, everytime I read up on this guy's story I can't help but tear up.
What a hero, there are no other words to describe this man. He was one of the greatest heroes this world will ever know.
blah1017 2 years ago 74
a jaruzelski ma 10tys emerytury zawsze wierny sowietom
tom123ek 2 years ago 7
nie tylko on... wielu "patriotów" szkolonych przez NKVD wisi na ZUSie i doi kasę za swe wybitne "osiągnięcia".
ferdovit 2 years ago 6
Polecam lekturę " Raport Witolda Pileckiego".
Jest do poczytania w internecie. Google.
Rotmistrz Pilecki był dobrowolnym więźniem KL Auschwitz, organizatorem obozowej organizacji ruchu oporu (informował świat o zbrodniach nazistowskich Niemiec), uciekinier z obozu, żołnierz Powstania Warszawskiego. Zydokomuna zamordowała go po wojnie.
Bo był polskim patriotą.
Polecam książkę Kazimierza Piechowskiego"Byłem numerem", wyd.s.Loretanek, 2004.
Wstrząsające lektury.
amabeline 2 years ago 31
Proberly one of the bravest men to ever live!
yugster78 2 years ago 47
Real Hero. Brave Human and Soldier.
Witold Pilecki.
Better dead than red!
Poland forever!!!
P19S48 3 years ago 11
Well said. much love from the USA
thetachi136 3 years ago 23
Honour to this heroic and brave Soldier.
I was really impressed by his incredible story.
I hope someone will make a movie about him...he really deserve it.
arkiere from Italy
arkiere 3 years ago 16
Pani Minister Katarzyna HALL z Rzadu Tuska Protestujemy w sprawie zabierania literatury patryjotyczno-narodowej z naszych szkol.
Chce pani z kosmopolizowac, wypatroszyć nasza świadomość narodowa.
Ojczyzna to wspólna sprawa to mowa, ziemia, pamiec. To laczy nas w jeden narod.
Kultywacja mowy I pamieci to nauka historii.
PolishAmericanDC 3 years ago 5
A amazing man, whose story was only ever made public in 1989! After all he went through in Auschwitz, and after he informed the Allies of the attrocities, he was accused of exaggerating, and nothing was ever done! It defies belief!
You could have added at the end of the video that it is rumoured that his dead body was dumped on a rubbish tip...what an undignified end for a true hero.
limitlessoptimism 3 years ago 7
Rozpoczynał się[...]"okres błędów i wypaczeń".W istocie rzeczy jednak chodziło w nim o zakrojone na szeroką skalę represje polityczne skierowane[...]w żołnierzy Podziemia walczącego z Niemcami, mordowanych bezprawnie w "majestacie prawa". Chodziło także o dalsze zniszczenie i wyeliminowanie z życia społecznego inteligencji polskiej, zniszczenie samodzielnych myśli ekonomicznych i społecznych, zdeptanie kultury, zastraszenie ludzi /P. Stachiewicz, "Parasol")
wolnoscnieokielznana 3 years ago 5
Created a fan page on facebook and made a link on this very good video. Please become a fan of this true hero.
Eljeii 3 years ago 6
Niesamowita historia. Czesc Jego pamieci.
pawel085 3 years ago 2
Prokurator who accused Witold Pilecki in 1948 was Czesław Łapiński. In 2004 He died in hospital... on Witold Pilecki street.
ferdovit 3 years ago 13
Witold Pilecki is my personal hero. A man who stared pure evil in the face and NEVER blinked. My respect for his awesome bravery knows no bounds.
OneEyePI 3 years ago 13
Pamięć o człowieku, którego całe życie podporządkowane było jednemu celowi, walce o niepodległą Polskę, po dziś dzień nie znajduje należytego miejsca. W podręcznikach szkolnych postać Pileckiego traktowana jest marginalnie. Dziwna niemoc w kwestii poruszania tematów związanych z najnowszą historią Polski trwa od lat. Jest to tym bardziej zaskakujące, że życiorys Witolda Pileckiego to gotowy scenariusz na film sensacyjny w najlepszym tego słowa znaczeniu.
amabeline 3 years ago 4
A nawet na kilka filmow sensacyjnych. Mowiac kolokwialnie scenarzysci z Hollywood nie wymysliliby takiego scenariusza, jaki los zafundowal Pileckiemu. Polecam jego biografie "Ochotnik do Auschwitz" autorstwa Andrzeja Cyry. Niezwykly czlowiek, niezwykla biografia.
peem10 3 years ago 5
Czytałem i zgadzam się. Facet był jak superman tyle, że naprawdę. Każdy kto zrobi dobry film o Pileckim ma oskara w kieszeni. Byle nie Wajda... najlepsze czasy ma za sobą.
ferdovit 3 years ago 2
Polanski by zrobil.
pawel085 3 years ago
Brytyjski historyk Michael Foot zaliczył go do jednego z sześciu najodważniejszych ludzi ruchu oporu podczas II wojny światowej. Niestety postać rotmistrza Witolda Pileckiego ciągle jeszcze nie znalazła godnego miejsca w historii Polski.
amabeline 3 years ago 4
In my live I have only one real hero - Witold Pilecki.
kshywho 3 years ago 5
SŁAWA I CHWAŁA NA WIEKI!!!!!
Jacol23 3 years ago 3
Wat A Man
JamiePilecki2008 3 years ago 4
1948-2008 - 60 years of oblivion. Until 1989, information on his exploits and fate was suppressed by the Polish communist regime.
They try erased You from our memory. We never forget.
ferdovit 3 years ago 4
Amazing guy, amazing story. He deserves to be remembered; thanks so much for making this.
coulie27 3 years ago 9
Thank you very much. Real Hero. Brave Human and Soldier.
Maczekgeneral 3 years ago 7
Unbelievable example of dedication and courage. No one never ever has impressed me that much. I wish I could shake his hand.
He survived so much... WWI, the Polish-Soviet war in 1920, the September Campaign in 1939, German occupation of Poland, over 2 years long volunteery imprisonment in Auschwitz, the Warsaw Uprising in 1944, German POW camps... just to be tortured and eventually shot dead in the back of the head by a Polish communist security officer three years after the war.
peem10 3 years ago 6
Czapki z glow! Dziekuje, panie Pilecki...5/5
polaka03 3 years ago 10
unfortunate this man did not live to know of the Polish pope who began the liberation from communism and the downfall of the Soviet Union.
granskare 3 years ago 6
Please all go by the You higher standards with Your comments !
This is real hero and all pass our honor to him. Great of the Great.
we all own him so much
PolishAmericanDC 3 years ago 5
It´s very good you tell this story here in the west we need to know the truth of this real hero!
Amatherasu1789 3 years ago 9
This guy has been through alot. That's what I call a real soldier.
TheGeneralHimself92 3 years ago 5
A Great Person!
KingPeterI 3 years ago 6
Na google video jest w całości teatr telewizji o procesie Pileckiego. Gorąco polecam. Facetowi należy się film i ulica z nazwiskiem w każdym mieście. Pojawił sie pomysł, że Mel Gibson mógłby to nakręcić...ciekawe.
JohnWeirdoe 3 years ago 2
Dziekuje za ten film. Kto wydał wyrok śmierci na PIleckiego??
pawel085 3 years ago
Na stronie IPN jest dużo informacji na ten temat. Wychodzi na to, że największy wpływ na wydanie wyroku śmierci miał Cyrankiewicz, który był także w Auschvitz, a Pilecki miał na niego prawdopodobnie kwity świadczące o jego kolaboracji z obozowym gestapo.
JohnWeirdoe 3 years ago 4
What a great man.
LVG31 3 years ago 6
"he was arrested by Polish security service" well... not exacly, Poland in 1947r. was under soviet ocupation (till 1989r!) and there was no "Polish" security service, it was run by KGB, and murderred meny Poles who wanterd to fight with russian ocupation
kkkkrackers 3 years ago 12
Never saw a bigger hero...
Superman is nothing against him
Jacubensis 3 years ago 12
It is not fair to blame Poland for his death as Poland was no more. This was "Communist" run Poland in May 1947. Many polish died at the hands of "Soviets". My Grandfather was in the 2nd Polish corps and Polands free Army. In 1951 he knew going into Poland was a death sentence and he came to the USA.
"Witold Pilecki" was a hero but did not die in Poland, he died in "Communist run Poland" under the Soviet brutal dictator, "Joseph Stalin". Poland is now free to tell. God Bless Poland
Stashahere 3 years ago 13
Encouraged by Rabbi Israel Singer's, the General Secretary of the World Jewish Congress, statements in 1996 such as " If Poland does not satisfy Jewish claims, it will be publicly attacked and humiliated in the international forum." So it is a plan to deliberately slander Poland's name and manipulate the American public's opinion against Poles. It was permitted to slander Poles now
PolishAmericanDC 3 years ago 11
Chwała bohaterom!!
Sądzę, że znaczny wpływ na jego śmierć miała wiedza, którą posiadał, że "Cyrankiewicz" był kapusiem w Oświęcimiu.
Pankracyogame 3 years ago 5
From the U.S.A.:
Very beautiful. A GREAT HERO overlooked in the post War history.
hpofficejet6310 3 years ago 10
I live just a block from him, on Aleja Wojska Polskiego, he is a true hero for me, a symbol, a devotion to what you really believe in, the truth, love and duty. If I could I would have a last supper with him.......to meet him and discover his beauty
arwena55 3 years ago 5
On the biggest scene ever......
arwena55 3 years ago 4
It is unbelievable story of a self-made man, the Bravest of the Brave. His life is a perfect scenario for the movie, I wish I will see it one day.
arwena55 3 years ago 10
Ci ludzie mieli rodziny,które miały tylko ich! Masowe groby...smierć tysięcy oficerów! Śmierć milionów Polaków! Tylko dla ambicji, które i tak nie przetrwały!postanowili wymordować bo walczyliśmy do końca!nie tylko Nas-ludzi ale kulturę, język i historię! Przetrwalismy... dzięki takim ludziom jak Ci,którzy lezeli martwi w Katyniu!Do końca walczyli za Polskę za Nas!
Cobalt4you 3 years ago 3
He was interrogated and tortured for many months. His finger nails were pulled out and his collarbones broken and he could hardly walk.
He never “talkedâ€.
After his process, which was a simple farce, he was sentenced to death by a firing squad.
There was no firing squad though.
The executioners dragged him the basement of the Security Headquarters building, into the boiler room.
They shot him with a single slug
His body was never found.
Cobalt4you 3 years ago 5
Witold Pilecki escaped from Auschwitz on the Easter Monday 1943, he also survived the Warsaw Uprising an the German POW camp in Germany.
He returned to Poland after the war and started organizing resistance
against the communists.
When he learnt that the Allies would not help to liberate Poland from the Soviets he started demobilizing the military underground organization.
It was then, that the communists arrested him.
Cobalt4you 3 years ago 2
Thanks for this video. I would like to invite you (all of you) to the campaign "Przypomnijmy o Rotmistrzu" ("Let's Reminisce About Witold Pilecki"). For details search in google and/or at my websites. Greetings
michaltyrpa 4 years ago 3