Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (251)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • una versione meravigliosa piena di colori e di sfumature

  • This is a woman! A true!

  • i got shivers... amazing :)

  • .........where did my head go?

  • This is a mind blowing performance!

    Elaine Page made the gold standard for this song. It could not possibly get any better than what she did just now.♥

  • 12 people deaf....

  • Thak you, Elaine!!! The best Memories!

  • Its sooooo amazing :)

  • got me crying!

  • i <3 this song

  • Barbra Streisand does a great job with this song. But, Elaine Page owns this song. Just beautiful.

    pin

  • Wow!!! Just wow!

  • How wonderful is Elaine Paige!

  • yes,for me this is the best perform of this song,this woman is fantastic performer!!!!!

  • umm i almost cried...why is this soooo beautiful...i soooo touched...jus incredible!

  • I'm obsessed with this song. It is one of the most beautiful songs ever written, I can't stop tears from rolling down my face, this woman is absolutely magnificent. However, this is a different version than the one in the stage show, right? I like this one, far better.

  • shes just beautiful

  • some people only like the song, which is a shame because the musical is beautiful.

  • 12 dislikes? I'll chalk that up to 11 people with horrible hand-mouse co-ordination (although since this is 'Cats', you would think that percentage would be much better!) and one person with plain no taste in music!  What a powerful piece of musical expression this is ... listening to it many times in a row!

  • This song remember me a sun shine in a rain...

  • it is not fair that all this talent is packed into one person, this woman is a legend

  • that what life is- 1 Huge Memory

  • this was my grandads funeral song :{ however he hated the musical cats :}

  • very nice, I so enjoy drifting off to sleep to this soundtrack- If you have to ask whaat it means you just don't get it and never will. Shogunsama

  • de todas las versiones y cantantes que hicieron memory, la mejor lejos es la de Barbra Streisand, es una maestra.

  • @ 87100nic Best description would be to say her character (who has LIVED and is past it and destitute) is seeking a chance to be reborn

  • can someone please explain the emotion behind this song?

  • @87100nic Fading (dying) actress remembering her day in the sun.....

  • @87100nic "can someone please explain the emotion behind this song?" - if you were a cat ...you'd understand!

  • Supreme example of theatrical singing. Magnificent, thrilling, definitive.

  • Великолепно

    

  • I always loved this song, but I never understood anything else about "Cats". lol

  • @joeygsmom Same problem here XD

  • Brilliant actress and voice

  • Elaine Paige is amazing and no matter what will never be just a memory!

  • I remember i would always sing this song and my mom would ask me how i knew it haha . . . . memories

    

  • She does such a great job. Love her singing this song!

  • Simply the best!

  • special song and my favorit performer

  • This is so beautiful. I have "special memories" of this song. I was sitting on

    a beach in Hawaii....it "filled" the air...and I always will remember it...with a special love.

    viewpoints7

  • great!!!! :D

  • Damn. Best voice in the entire world.

  • Are we afraid to applaud or we'll break the spell? Don't you want the moment to last forever? A true performance!

  • she has the most amazing, astounding voice ESPECIALLY at 2:56!!!! It's so beautiful

  • This is rejection in the flesh. I cant say otherwise, What I understand is that Grizabella gets rejected. The text, the music, the very very good singer/performer it all fits perfectly and works perfectly, just like in a hand made watch. Very well done.

  • wonderful

  • I love Elaine Paige!

  • this is the best I've ever seen of elaine

  • Simplesmente maravilhoso a interpretação da Elaine Paige.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I love this song

  • bravo mrs elaine,your perform this role is best ever!

  • great job!!!what a beautiful voice !

  • This is absolutely beautiful. I couldn't stop tears rolling down my face :')

    2:56 is absolutely breathtaking. It gave me goosebumps.

    Elaine is what society should call a real performer.

  • Simplemente HERMOSO

  • Wow, the greatest version of this song I have ever seen!!

  • WOW.

  • Браво

  • just couldnt stop tears to roll down my cheek!!!

  • real actor real singer,she is performer!!! better than anyone,I like Barbra but Elaine is  a actor,Barbra is a singer.And please,do not disccuse about Susan or anyone else performing this composition!

  • Beautiful woman with a great voice. This brings tears to my eyes it is so beautiful.

    Elaine is a great performer.

  • I guess the unlike were clicked by people thinking thumbs down is a sign for downloading the song, I have never been to a live concert and I have decided that the only one I will go to will be EP;s one. I hope she will come to UAE soon

  • my papa sang this song before he died xx love u papa always remembered xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

  • I DONT THINK IF SUSAN BOYLE IS BETTER THAN ELAINE , BUT HER VOICE IS BEAUTIFUL..VERY SWEET. I LIKE BOTH OF THEM. ( sorry for my English, i speak spanish)

  • she sounds completly different in the musical. i never would have recognized that it was the same singer. i mean she sounds great in this video, but i still think in the musical she´s better. but maybe its just because she isn´t on stage

  • I love it

  • I guess.........I guess I prefer Betty's version because she sings it with more ease.

    Yes, Elaine's characterization is incredible. But I can hear the strain in her voice. Like she's......trying too hard? I don't know. I think Betty puts a whole new edge to the song. Her and Laurie Beechman.

  • @noodle0912 i don't hear her straining at all

  • You can try Susan Boyle....but nothing beats Elaine Paige.......least not at this song.....

  • i have chills. 

  • just great, she sings and plays the song 

  • she is good of that there is no question . but better than barbara i think not.

    Sorry miss streisand takes this to a new level alltogether .

    Its good though

  • She just took the gold standard away from Barbara Streisand with this performance!

    It could not get ANY better than this.

    Period!

  • Omgz I remember when Patty Ferrell sang this on Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Rodrick Rules. She was sooooooo wonderful an beautiful! It should have been called "Patty Rules". PATTY'S BETTER!!!

  • i loooove this!!

  • Weltklasse ist das!!!! "Gänsehaut"

  • does anyone here actually realize that Susan Boyle's dream was to sing like this? She would never say she was better than Elaine Page for the reason she is Susan's hero.

  • @MsOneiroi77 I so agree! I really believe that Susan looks up to Elaine, and looks to her for inspiration. They are both good singers, but I think Elaine is better - but Susane is very very good:)

  • elaine is amazing and gorgeous <3 and the performance was amazing too look how emotional she got at the end i nearly cried with her xxxx <3 xxxx <3 xxxx <3 xxxx

  • While I think Susan Boyle does a very good version, it's Elaine Paige as Grizabella who really owns this one. This version is excellent, but her singing as Grizabella on the DVD cannot be topped.

  • Amazing. 'nough said.

  • Her voice is haunting in her performance of this song. I am looking for a DVD of Cats...I wore out my VHS tape...

  • @KassidyKatherine I wore out my DVD...is that worse?

  • @KassidyKatherine i got my dvd off of walmart.com

  • like if u got goosebumps!!!

  • @prayan12345 not only goosebumps, lump in my throat as well :)

  • :D

    *Like*

    

  • Goosebumps! :D Twice in a row on this part 2:56

  • @MsGabyCamarillo oh gosh... 5 for me :O i didn't know that was possible lol (:

  • ohohoh goosebumps till my feet.. wonderful :)

  • I would love to hear Sarah Brightman and Elaine on the same stage.

  • so much feeling in her voice, learn from a musician ^^

  • I think she is so hot

  • It's just so beautiful, brings me to tears every single time. She inspires me.

  • Elaine Paige has 40 years of stage experience in, how to project her voice. Susan Boyle has a good voice. Any idea as to how many times Elaine Paige has sung this?

    She was born in 1948. She was 60 years old, and celebrating 40 years on the stage, when she sang this. Susan Boyle has found her voice, BUT, not like this.

    Wearing an evening gown, I close my eyes and hear Grizabella.

  • Over 9000/10

  • I get the chills everytime she yells 'touch me', it's so beautifull and full of emotions.

  • still gives me goosebumps every time,boy can she sing

  • 10/10

  • @chainmailart her name is Elaine not Ellen!! Ellen Paige was on Juno. Elaine Paige is one of the best performers to ever grace any stage.

  • Elaine has better presentation, more expression - she makes you believe in whats she singing, telling a story, Susan just sings. Though Susan does have a prettier sounding voice.

  • The woman is amazing. That's all I've got to say.

  • 5 people didn't go to The Heaviside Layer..

  • It should be remembered that Elaine Paige played the role on stage complete with costumes and a full cast. She is outstanding in her performance here and there should be no comparison between Elaine and Susan Boyle, though the latter has mega raw talent. Paige is an accomplished and experienced actress in the musical theater. Boyle is just starting out as a recording artist who will do concerts. I give them both credit for using the gifts God has given them respectively.

  • WOW!!!!!! best ever!!!!

  • Susan sang it fine, but nobody can sing it with such feeling as emotion as Elaine Paige. Susan, while good, sang it without emotion.

  • @Jaxstaa92:

    Well, I think the people you mentioned think Susan Boyle is better than elaine paige because when she sang in Britian's got talent, she was great and I don't think at that tiem, she hadn't gone through any proper training. Anyway, Elaine Paige is Susan's idol.

  • she really hits the "touch me" part PERFECTLY! i get goose bumps every time i hear that part! And of course the whole song is amazing. She is definitely the best singer for this song! :D

  • chills............

  • omg amzing BRAVA!

  • Wish there was footage of her performing in the theater- aside from the video version. That'd be truly amazing.

  • I love how when she says look, she actually performs the action. That's entertainment!!!

  • I'm doing this is singing lessons. YAY :D

  • My favorite part is 0:00 through 4:12

  • Anyone have a clue what key this is in?

  • I <3 Elaine Page

  • amazing!

  • it´s an diferent key from the original right? it sound better this way

  • Really? You wanna say that Barbra is better?

    2:54

    That is all I have to say on the matter.

  • A lot of musical theater performers could learn a thing from Elanie. I'm classically trained, and had some theater majors in my studio. I hate the "belty" tonality they worked to achieve...I think it takes away from the musicality, and everyone seems to sound the same. Her voice is powerful, identifyable, and the emotions just pour out of the notes when she sings.

    I absolutely love this song, and her singing it. Beautiful in cat costume or as Elaine.

  • 3 people are blind, def, and motor chaleanged.

  • Elaine Paige really did a great job. Besides her version, I also like the one sung by Sarah Brightman who is really the goddess of opera

  • This defines "Classic".

  • I hate Elaine... She made me have to redo my eye make up!! CRYING

  • Great voice but I liked her hair short better. Still a great performer. POWERFUL!!!

  • such talent..

  • Perfection... really, is there any other word to describe it? I think not.

  • Such a moving & powerful rendition of "Memory"! To top it off, her voice & facial expression made it even more touching! I absolutely & totally loved it ... again & again! Thank you!

  • 3 people should be commited immediately

  • An unforgettable production! - Cats Westend London - left the theatre walking on air.....humming away to all the brilliant music....1998

  • Brings tears to my eyes every single time. She is amazing.

  • wow what a voice.I only first heard it yesterday and now i know it off by heart

  • She is amazing - this rendition gave me goosebumps!!

  • Goosebumps for me, too...Elaine rules. She owns this song!

  • This is excellence personified! She is amazing! I love this song!

  • Comment removed

  • Elaine Page is a goddess

  • BRAVO!!!!

  • It just blew me away!!!

  • I saw her on broadway and about had my heart stop. This one song and they way she played it made you sad for your childhood. Even now it's almost to much to listen to.

  • I just finished watching Black Swan and, after watching Elaine in this video, I understand that true talent is forever. And may Elaine sing for us forever as well. Biggest kisses!

  • @AlwaysVegas2 What does Black Swan have to do with Elaine Paige? Not trying to argue, I'm just curious how you made the comparison.

  • @ValtronW he/she might mean about the struggle for perfection in terms of performing

  • Estimated friend, if you want to listen again this song and an endless number of successes of the love I suggest you to visit Radio MUSICA PARA MIMOS - looks for his direction URL in Google ( search Musica para Mimos in Google)-. best romantic music of all the times in Internet, is great, is very good ...!!!

  • truly incredible

  • No one sings this song better than Elaine Paige. She owns this song.

  • De cuando, donde y porque se dio este concierto? alguien lo sabe y me lo puede informar, se los agradeceré un monton; y me atrevo a preguntar otra cosa (dentro de ignorancia) este escenario es donde tambien se canto "El Fantasma de la Opera" por Antonio Banderas y Sarah Brightman????

  • I don't understand people who think Susan Boyle is better than this lady

  • @Jaxstaa92

    Who are these people?

    Source please.

  • @Jaxstaa92 i agree (: i think elaine paige's voice is a bit more trained however...i think susan boyle is very very good! and who knows how good she could have been if she had the same amount of training! so i agree w/ you but susan boyle is still very good (:

  • @Jaxstaa92 Susan is a natural talent, had no help from anyone to build her image and improve her voice...that's why!!Ellen is wonderful but without all that work of background behind, would she be so great??I dont think so!

  • @chainmailart Can Susan do this? I don't think so!

  • @Jaxstaa92 i see them both very very good, same level, don't forget, Susan said she is inspired by Elaine

  • @Jaxstaa92

    Nie martw się, ja też nie rozumiem. Uważam że wykonanie Elaine jest THE BEST!!

  • @Jaxstaa92 they don't really think that, they don't know..

  • Imagine seeing this live, I think I'd like melt in my seat or something.

  • i can't imagine how many times i've watched this video but 2:57 sends me into tears every. single. time.

  • How do you not like this performance? Elaine is pure magic.

  • So beautiful...

  • 2.57 was just... I have no words

  • wow... but give a look to SILVIA DOLFI SOUNDTRACKS THE CONCERT here on youtube... beautiful voice!

  • They chose this song well .

  • This performance makes me wanna cry

  • if at 2:57 you do not have chills from head to toe you clearly have no soul

  • ti adoro!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!

  • "i was beautiful then"

    no

    you was beautiful ever, Elaine.

  • @botijo lol, that made me smile, thank you ^^

  • I loved this, but I liked it better in the musical. Just my opinion

  • Have seen EP do this live, and it was amazing 

  • Which year was this performance?

  • @emloquace 1998