I see what you trying to do and agree with you that some muslims behavior is unacceptable even damaging our image but please try to understand the situation in which muslims are, they are getting bombed, their livelihood getting destroyed, their country is invaded and their economy is collapsed and some how US has to do with it dont you agree?
spot on! And these 'mino's'- our Prophet taught us to speak with manners and in such a way to not offend others. What are the Muslims if we, ourselves are going against Islam?
Guiltyofbeingmuslim, when i see people like you I can't help but wonder why Bret is siding with muslims, the only answer is Bret is such a kind, nice, person. that is why i guess...
You and i and other muslims don't do as much as Bret does for islam, instead of critising him we should be shame of ourselves...
i shouldnt need to be a muslim scholar to befriend and support muslims.you are right that i shouldnt judge but are you judging my perceptions more harshly because im not muslim? if i was a muslim would you have challenged my words?
and are you telling me that im wrong for suggesting that mohammed would not approve of cruel pornographic racist nationalistic hate speech aimed at me and my muslim friends? i shouldnt have to be muslim to be right about this..facts are facts
again im not making islamic assumptions..christians say"what would jesus do"
cant muslims ask "what would mohammed do?" without requiring everyone to read up to answer the question? fairness and kindness are universal traits amongst most faiths and cultures and i hope youre not trying to convince me that the prophet mohammed was something other than kind and fair
no i dont know everything but i have studied a lot more of islam than bret has and if he says something wrong i'm going to point it out. it seems your too busy pointing at your brothers who speak truth than to point at something that is clearly wrong.
maybe you should educate yourself a bit. and if bret is your prophet then dont call yourself a muslim open up a new religion.
non of us are flawless and when i see something that goes against quran and sunnah then its my duty to point it out
insinuating that i am a false prophet or trying to be a prophet is a simple diversionary technique that takes us further from the reality of the discussion. its a way to humilate someone without fact...wheres the beef?whay is unholy in my words?
that message about you being a prophet wasnt directed at you
it was directed a muslim.
because if a person values your words and actions more than the prophets, or Allahs (words) then he has, maybe without realising, taken you as a prophet, taken your way as a religion, instead of islam
this is like the hadeeth that talked about how people took their preists and rabis as gods instead of allah.. continued
a christian who became a muslim asked the prophet how that could be since he never called his priest a god, the prophet explained that this was because the people took what the priests said was forbidden as forbidden, and what they said was permitted as permissible, even though this contradicted the religion of Allah at that time.
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
it bothers me when you say 'would the prophet agree with you' or phrases like that.
you dont have a very in depth understanding of the life of the prophet. you have a limited understanding of islamic jurisprudence - and you are most of the time wrong when you assume what the prophet PBUH would have done.
i wont enter this discussion for many reasons but you are wrong bret
i think you raise an interesting point here. i ask the question for you to answer. Would the prophet agree with me? would he? what do you think? im just asking so i can learn. i do make assumptoons about what the prophet would do based on basic tenets that muslims have taught me..i do the same with my perception of jesus..i must be able to make some assumptions based on reason? what do you think?
i think its important for you to pick up a book detailing the life of the prophet PBUH
if you want to make assumptions on islam without proper knowledge of it you can only expect that you'll make a lot of mistakes. you cant even really rely on your friends.
islam can only be islam if it is based on evidences from quran and sunnah. if someone is behaving in a way that opposes quran and sunnah, even if you approve of it, it isnt islam anymore
..was mohammed kind and fair? do muslims strive to behave like mohammed? if you answer yes then i know some things about islam that should be undenyable.
if a man steals from you is that islamic behavior? if a man helps a starving child is that islamic behavior? you know the answers i bet..how are non muslims supposed to understand islam if the tenets arent based in common sense?if you deny me using my logcal mind based on my perception of goodness then islam loses.
man i wish prophet mohammed was here right now to watch you teach me about how that nasty immature porno behavior was somehow better than my honest polite kuffarness.
i never approved of his swearing, but at the same time i left his swearing at the level of a sin, which is what swearing is, its a sin. it doesnt make you a fake muslim, it doesnt take you outside the fold of islam.
whereas some of the other stuff that people do which you would play down, is not only a sin but takes you outside the fold of islam.
and yes if you were a muslim i'd tell you the same thing. i'm not treating you in any special way
in fact if you were a muslim i'd be far more harsh.
and btw there are times when harshness is necessary. which you dont seem to get. no offence intended.
there was a time when abu bakr RA swore at one of the leaders of quraish because he insulted the prophet PBUH, the prophet PBUH did not rebuke him, he approved of it. because in that time and place it was justifiable. there was a time when the muslims killed in the forbidden months and this was excused because of the circumstances
if i saw an american soldier i'd spit in his face, even if he calls himself a muslim. thats what you call a MINO muslim.
well i'd want to, but then i'll probably get arrested and thrown somewhere no one would find me. or i'd be splashed all over the news for disrespecting the 'wonderful' soldiers.
i wouldnt do anything. i'd just do what i'm doing now and shut my mouth and eat crap and ask Allah every day to take me to a place wehre i'm surrounded by muslims and living under His law, in peace
The ideal is not to be in US army right now, but remember this not every thing is black not everything is white in life and there are shades of gray and ALLAH is aware of those shades not you!!! not me!!! he knows all the details of this soldier and his family and etc.
Allah will judge these people and this soldier according to the facts that only and only he knows .
We may as well shut up...Let the ALL-Knowing handle everytthing...
in islam there is such thing called a judge and there are many ahadeeth detailing how to be a good judge and what defines a judge that will be in hellfire
there is nothing wrong with judging so long as it is done according to quran and sunnah.
i cannot see what is in someones heart therefore i judge by what is apparant. this is perfectly acceptable and even in a lot of cases fard in islam.
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
what Bret is saying is contrary to quran and sunnah, i know the prophet PBUH would not agree with what he is saying because what he is saying is not in line with quran and sunnah.
simple
we can know what the prophet PUBH aproved of and didnt approve of through his sunnah.
its very simple
and if you say that to me,t hen why didnt you say that to bret when he said the prophet PBUH wouldnt approve etc etc?
im dying to know..what did i say that was contrary to the quraan? please.. i want to know specifically which statement other than my "labeling somebody" was anti islam?
labling someone isnt against quran and sunnah. but you labled him in a manner that was against quran and sunnah.
if i call someone a fake muslim, and i have proof of that, then this labling is ok. for example if i see someone calling himself a muslim but he is praying to a statue, then i can lable him and say he is not a muslim.
if see someone swearing and say he is a fake muslim then i myself have fallen into sin because he is not a fake muslim, he just sinned everyone sins
.when you first challenged me i agreed that this label of him was inappropriate. i shouldnt have done it. as soon as i was aware that it was a bad idea i immediately edited that video. i agree with you 100 percent. i said clearly that i am not qualified to challenge whether or not someone is a true muslim but there is behavior that i consider unmuslimlike...like the nasty language he used..i will try to keep my challenges on a secuar plane from now on.thank you
if you want to learn about the life or the prophet, his conduct and actions, get your hands on a copy of a set of cds called the life of the prophet PBUH, there is a set on the meccan period and a set on the madinan period. it is recorded by anwar al awlaki.
and before anyone jumps up and says 'hes an extremist', when these videos were recorded every muslim had a copy, and every bookstore sold them no matter what flavour muslim they were
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
i understand..i think..i edited my video to apologize for labeling thst man as a mino..i shouldnt ever label anyone..his behavior was wrong though and i cant imagine any scenario where mohammed would have approved his message..im no expert but i hold mohammed in high esteem and expect him to support what is right..obscenities are never right in a dialogue...ive been obscene myself when i was enraged but i knew it destryed the content of my message
bret, what is 'Right'? what you think is right is different to what i think is right, right?
and someone else might jump in with a totally different opinion on what is wrong and what is right?
i'm not saying his swearing was right, i'm not saying that this brother acted with hikma (wisdom). but what i'm saying is that as a muslim i would sooner be down the throat of a "muslim" in the american army, than a muslim swearing a bit.
maybe if he didnt swear he would have conveys his message better
"And the swine, though he divided the hoof, and be clovenfooted, yet he cheweth not the cud; he is unclean to you.
"Of their flesh shall ye not eat, and their carcass shall ye not touch; they are unclean to you." andHoly Qur-an 2:173
"He has thus forbidden you only what dies of itself, and blood, and the flesh of swine, and that over which any other (name) than (that of) Allah has been invoked..."
" A Muslim is the one with whom people feel safe from abuse by mouth or hand; and a migrant is one who abandons what God has forbidden. (Related by Al-Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawood and Al-Nassaie).
Notice here that the Prophet spoke of harm by mouth first, before adding physical harm caused by hand. This is due to the fact that most abuse is caused verbally.
I appreciate your attitude, but I find your interference is kinda offending because you talk about stuffs in Islam in a wrong way, I don't know what you know about Islam but obviously you're telling info about Islam in a bad way, you're not making any help (if this is your intention!).
I know that my deeds will help me of course!
Again, supposing you have good intentions, your interference is not helping, you better make much investigation about Islam, otherwise, you're an offender!
American Muslims should not join the U.S. army. Quran clearly urges Muslims not to take non-Muslims as Awliya. A Muslim should not put himself in a situation where he has to comply with orders of non-Muslims. Allegiance to Islam must supersede allegiance to ones own country. The U.S. is engaging in wars against Muslims. The U.S. is occupied by Zionists and the army follows the orders of these Zionists.
Obey the civilian laws of the U.S., but do not join the U.S. army.
Some of those "Minos" I believe are most likely JTF bots, unfortunately they have the task of spewing hatred under the guise of being Muslim...although some could be real delusional 'Muslims'...
Let's just say.....if BRET the so called KAAFIR ever needed water and I only had 1 cup to spare between him and a MINO....I would give it to him than to someone I knew was a MINO!
I wouldn't invest anytime trying to change the min of a 5 year old. I would say Bret you're giving him attention more than he deserves. I understand his point about the solider who is killing people of his own but there are ways to go about delivering that same message and also it is up to the Muslim solider and his god, not up to us to judge.
thats funny you mention that. people get weird around money too. and the more the money the stranger they behave. a real estate deal or an inheritance deal are the biggest money deals for most folks, hence people turn into pigs and crooks around these deals..some still have integrity though..
With all do respect, I CARE for 'Muslims' because I care for people. I could give a crap whether you need it, my feelings have nothing to do with your need. As far as interference goes, I am afraid my friend, that the reality is Shahadah does not change you. Shahadah does not validate you. Your deeds do. I am not interference, my friend, I am part of the Chorus--and my voice is just as important as yours. Welcome to reality.
Do Muslims also strike terror in the hearts of Muslims in Iraq who want to vote and control their own fate? Do Muslims justify killing Muslims in Iraq who fight because they believe the Muslims of Iraq deserve a safe and secure country? When the Mujaheddin are killing Iraqi policeman--are they fighting in the cause of Allah? Give me a break. And if you don't think Muslims should fight Muslims--whose side are you on?
Looks like you "care" for Muslims. Thank you for this feeling, but we actually don't need this kind of "feeling" or "interference" with our affairs, it is mainly the factor that brought chaos and destruction to Iraq in the first place, so Elder, thank you, we don't need your interference or any similar attitude.
Most (if not all) the accidents of killing Muslims in Iraq are made by "Black Water" mercenaries or foreign intelligence agencies spies, not to say that a Muslim won't help an invader.
I really can't tell If they are Muslims or not, it's the internet!
it is a strange thing that a Muslim would curse in a similar situation, it is not the manner of Muslims to curse at all. I don't know why I doubt the identity of those guys being Muslims and I don't know why I feel that there's something in the air!
This is the first time I feel you're disturbed a little bit when shooting your video, Bret. I'm really sorry for any bad experience you had with our brothers.
and for those Muslim Brothers, please watch Bret's videos before judging him or his attitude. You won't gain any thing by cursing, NOTHING in Islam justifies the cursing at all. If you guys have a point, you will lose your creditability by cursing. I don't think Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) would do what you did in a similar situation.
dear bret as I know you are learning arabic , so here is one of the many sentences we have to describe your situation with this guy ( القافلة تسير والكلاب تنبح )
and that's mean ( the caravan still passing, and the dogs still barking )
Bret - my friiend, that's a hater of Islam rather than a supporter. More than that, if he is giving this long speech about the definition of islam then he should start by teaching himself first...a True practicing Muslim, does NOT curse and use the "F" word specifically. He is a hypocrit.
did you just write that what your friend did wrong was to call me a kaffir?
i have no problem with being called kaffir..i have a problem with a man who calls himself a muslim wishing others to burn in hell and calling people whores and using language that is pornographic...do you condone pornographic language? he claims to west is sick when his words are grotesque immature and offensive..i still love you both..
stop it. you're making me blush with your abundant love declarations:)
it's odd you don't mind being called a disbeliever yet my brothers and sister are judging their brother for that. it' a world gone mad. lol
people say things in anger, i will not forsaken him for that. i understand his emotion. he's still my brother no matter what your or any other "nonmuslim" says.:)
Therefore, if you call other Muslims "kafir" or "mushrik" without discrimination, you could find that you have left Islam, according to the words of the Prophet (s.a.w.), in less than a second.
About calling other Muslims "kafir," we read the following hadith: It is reported on the authority of Ibn `Umar that the Prophet (may peace and blessings be upon him) said: Any person who calls his brother: O Unbeliever! (then the truth of this label) would return to one of them. If it is true, (then it is) as he asserted, (but if it is not true), then it returns to him (and thus the person who made the accusation is an Unbeliever). [Muslim]
I saw him call that particular person a hypocrite for going to Iraq. I see a couple of dozen muslims here calling him that because he called Brett a kaffir and was cursing at another american soldier. Didn't see you any where condemning that. No matter what though, the hadith does not tell you to call him kaffir.
I love it how you completely bypassed your own error- the takfir.
But anyways, I disagree with your unbalanced praise of Brett. This video is the reason why so many muslims-who were not even there last night- are here today to backbite their own and call the brother a dog and a kaffir. To defend Brett.
Brett is not a muslim, it is good of you to see that at least.
As for you last question I do not want to see ANY muslim fighting against muslims in Iraq.You want me to aprove of that because you claim the muslim american will maybe hesitate before he kills an Iraqi?? A muslim should not be killing a believer at all
Honest to God, I don't get what is so hard for you to understand about that!
It's not right to call a Muslim a Kafir for sure. Judging Bret situation is not of our business, no body can tell if Bret is a Muslim or not, it's something between Allah and him.
Our attitude is simply what Muhammad (pbuh) ordered us to do when he said (" support your Brother whether he is oppressed or unjust" sahaba said "how we support him when he is unjust?" Muhammad (pbuh) said "by preventing him from being unjust").
Bret is a peaceful man who loves Muslims, this is true.
Brett is not a Muslim. We are not having this discussion, please.
And I haven't seen any support here. If any muslim wished to give the brother naseeha they should have talked to him in private. Not ridicule him on this video because Brett called them to stand against their own brother.. Muslims should be defending their brother against such a call not siding with Brett because he is so likeable.
I can't ridicule this Brother of course, actually I can't ridicule any body else. I have to treat him respectfully of course, I don't think that I ridiculed him at all. I'd love to talk to him in private if he allowed me to :)
We have to be fair when dealing with non Muslims too Sister and I think you know this for sure, I'm not defending Bret only, I'm also defending my Brother from being unfair to Bret.
Bret is not a muslim? Really? Tell me something I don't know.
My respect to him is not making me blind do not worry, i don't remember which surah but ALLAH says in the quran when a muslim is right, you be on the side of the muslim, when a non muslim is right you be on the side of the non muslim regardless of their belief, so stop saying bret is not muslim, that won't change the fact that the way we deal with the subject according to quran of course.
Islamonly: i don't remember which surah but ALLAH says IN THE QUR'AN when a muslim is right, you be on the side of the muslim, when a non muslim is right..
[004:135] PICKTHALL O ye who believe! Be ye staunch in justice, witnesses for Allah, even though it be against yourselves or (your) parents or (your) kindred, whether (the case be of) a rich man or a poor man, for Allah is nearer unto both (them ye are). ...
I will never debate Quran with you or anyone, I am not in the position to give tafseer on verses so don't start that please. I am not a scholar and neither are you.
However I am at ease in defending my brother in this youtube hackle. Brett was standing up for american soldiers and now is calling on muslims to stand up against another muslims who got upset with an american soldier. I am simply defending my brother's honour as I understand I should.
UBAX: I will never debate Quran with U or anyone, I am not in the position2 give tafseer on verses so don't start that please. I am not a scholar and neither are U.
Peace,
I merely produced da Qur'anic verse becoz IslamOnly1 forgot.. I don't personally know da specifics of this 'youtube hackle'. Don't feel intimidated in ur defence of da brother!
No Muslim has the right to call any non-Muslim a kaffer. By definition a kaffer is a "non-believer" ie. someone who doesn't believe in the one true God. By this definition, Jews and Christians can't be called kaffirs/kaffirs because they, by definition, believe in one true God.
PS - MINO, nice acronym. I'll make sure to use it.
@Clevon..be careful it could be a wolf in sheep clothing my be acting like a Muslim and not really one....trying to make Muslim look stupid and ignorant...i have a beautiful Sister who is in the army reserve join before the war broke out....she has to honor her commitments. mindful of not fighting Muslims that did nothing to her she works desk.
When we call someone a 'Kaafir', it means that we are passing a judgment about that person's acceptance or rejection of the Truth as he has perceived and understood it. Obviously, no human being is qualified to pass this judgment. Only God, with His absolute knowledge about each and every individual, can pass the judgment as to whether or not that individual has lived his life according to the Truth, which that individual has understood.
From the perspective of the life of this world 'non-Muslim' is primarily a legal term implying a person, who does not ascribe to the Islamic faith. In contrast, the word 'Kaafir' - literally: rejecter - is used by the Qur'an for people, who are guilty of rejection or non-acceptance of the truth, even after it has become fully apparent to them.
a Muslim may offer himself for recruitment in any army of the world, as long as he is aware of the fact that all his actions shall be guided by the principles of equity and justice. Even while serving a Muslim army, he cannot afford to be careless of this fact.
A just action taken by the army of the United States is as commendable as a just action taken by a Muslim army. And an unjust action taken by a Muslim army is as condemnable as an unjust action taken by any other army of the world.
this mino doesnt represent anyone but himself those guys ruined our faith and they are trying to hijack our religion an turn it out to a set of weird and stupid practices you gotta be stupid to think that you're a good muslim because you eat with your right hand and enter the bathroom with your left foot, and hey Minus ill call him minus, let me tell you that you know sh* about Islam first of all the word Kafir have been used in the Quran only five times one of them to describe Satan but ...
How can he stop us? He can only bark or bite, but I am immune to the disease of rhetoric and hate, the rabid distrust and aggression of this bully. This is radical peace. This is our video. Let them kill us--when we are gone they will soon follow. This disease he suffers from isn't radical Islam--it is the disease which tries to justify itself under the name of all ideologies and all groups--it is Hate. It deceives to gain victims and to curtail man's tendency towards co-existence.
This man cannot matter, because the world he envisions does not matter. The world which hate will win is not a human world. Not a humane world. Whether it is called an Islamic world, a christian world, a democratic world...it will be a lie--because nothing good is born of hate. We would rather be victims than murderers. Because a world where men are brave enough and strong enough to not take up arms is a world of peace--is the world we must make, already.
Sir, Im sorry, but I think you haven't made one single true point against Islam...
You going to be shocked, because I know very well your version of the so called Truth.
first you need to accept the fact that you might be totaly wrong, and stop being arrogant. Im accepting your challenge when you release yourself from hate.
The problem when you take it as a challenge, it becomes personal instead of making it for learning.
You dont know anything so dont act as if you do, If you would just check that the info I have told you is true, you will find out that its true for yourself instead of immediately dismissing my every point as a lie, Its not hate - i dont have hate, its concern that brings me to talk about things like this, nothing less and nothing more - so please, dont stereotype the anti-hater stance against me, dont make assumptions and judgements that are incorrect, you dont know anything.
How can you dismiss my points as lies yet deny the challenge? - If you had of said what you said - yet not dismissed my points as lies, your lies would have had some credability, and maybe I would believed that you actually thought i hated.... You took away all your credability when you done that, You do realise that dont you?
'one who avoids harming the people with his tongue (e.g. using abusive language) and hands.'
I don't support those Muslims who fight in illegal wars and kill fellow Muslims, but I don't condone Muslims who use bad language. Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) respected everybody.
@irenigma888------man! u should find a psychologist.......or get some therapies....u are wasting ur time and brain......in addition, dont waste it...! if u sell ur brain,u will get a good price cuz ur one is an unused brain :PPP
your comment was a common flamer autocomment, I expect you have been the victim of it many times, I doubt you have the i.q to think of your own, laters... :)
. by the way i didnt study in a "Quarrel and Win" School like you..............CAn u plzzzzz stoppppppppppppp!!!!!!! ....i am fed up.......i will shut up if u shut up.............u are just adding petrol on a fire!!!!.......ok dude...i am an asshole,fool, dumbass.....HAPPY??? now plzzzzzzzzzzzz stop...i dont wanna QUARREL!!!!!
you know come to think of it im the biggest stupid wrong fool there ever was. lets end the argument that im wrong or devush you and i can both be wrong together?my friend potenza says "do you want to be right? or do you want peace?
bret
bravo devushi admire your ego concession for peace
Da word "KaFiR" is misused by Muslims & non-Muslims alike! WIKI it 2 understand a bit of what it means. It also means "TO ATONE" as (كفارة من الله) KAFFARAH (pronounced cuff-faarah). Young Muslim married couples usually have problems fasting Ramadhan! & so they "atone" (make a KAFFARAH).
As 4 these VULGAR "Muslims", most R FAKE ones masquerading as Muslims. Qur'an & Sunnah forbid VULGARITY!
Hebrew cognate "KOFER" means "APOSTATE". Arabic for latter is "MURTAD" not "KAFIR"
love this video.man! i hope u were here so that we could have a nice chat on this topic.
i hv seen 100s of comments on sum videos in YT.
Sum of them said,"Muslims bend to the devils"+some1 said "Fucking Allah-".i was laughing>i was feeling sorry for them instead of getting angry cuz hatred got filled in their brains so much that the brain is not getting enough space to "relax and think over it".
i wont say anything against Jesus cuz he is our prophet.i respect him&y shud i say even if he wasnt?
Of course, its the strategy of hatred to create a monster so one can become the slaying hero. You are not unique nor first to do such an act. Whatever propaganda you spread though - it wont make it the truth. Truth shines by itself and lies will always decline. Some people will do anything to maintain a racially ordained strata in the world and that is what is killing the planet. Forging history is just one part.
Actually you are speaking of the poet that was awarded by the abaya of the prophet himself. Thats kinda basic knowledge that cannot be turned into something else.
Those types, they are the hypocrites. Unfortunately they are increasing in fold and are very influential and in powerful positions in the Muslim world.
They are close minded freaks that know only misery and hate everybody. To them, you are a Muslim if they see you pray and read Qur'an, but if you have an opinion, they declare holy war on you.
Arent you lying about the history at this moment? U know, all creatures choose their battles and one criteria is that they know when they are getting into a battle they wont win. Are you really choosing your battle here by lying? Or is it the provocation by lying that gets you off, like some kind of a pervert?
Why just don't you tell us what is the poem all about, there were many poets who insulted the prophet personaly but none of them was punished.
The truth is those 3 poets whom the prophet punished, were actualy not insulting the prophet, but they were inciting war and genocide against all muslims.
Do you know what the CIA will do to someone who incite war and terrorism against american?? you tell me.
Bro don't bother yourself with those parasites, I've seen a comment calling one of the best known Islamic preacher Kafir just because he preach in a snoking suit, I told him to stop, and he told me that I will have problms if I don't mind my own business....Frankly, in real life, I ve never seen real person doing this, I live in a muslim country...I have a big doubt if they are muslims in the first place or just some haters of Islam who wants to give a bad impression about it.
Prophet Muhammad forgave all of them although the non muslim meccans smacked him, spit at him, chased him & his followers out of their homes & city without allowing them to take their properties with them. The meccans killed his followers & tortured them to the extent that no one could ever imagine & yet he forgave all of them on the day muslims had conquered Mecca.
Find the history book on the conquest of Mecca & read it for yourself.
On the day of the Conquest of Mecca, Prophet Muhammad SAW said to the Meccans who were non muslims:"O you people of Quraish! What do you think of the treatment that I am about to accord to you?" They replied:"O noble brother & son of noble brother! We expect nothing but goodness from you." Upon this Prophet Muhammad SAW said:"I speak to you in the same words as Yusuf (Prophet Joseph) spoke unto his brothers: "No reproach on you this day," [Al-Qur'an 12:92] go your way, for you are freed ones."
I think the guy you said had gotten a piece of your mind with regard to the right and left hands and pork (if he watch your video)......but i'm sorry for you, because of your stance you have to face a hard times. I hope you are okay.
Wow, that guy sounds like a grade A wacko. I just don't get that. It's always those kind of people that want to tell everyone else what to believe and what to do and what to think.
Next time you get called a kuffar explain to them that a kuffar is someone who knows islam is real but hides the truth, but nobody knows that islam is real thats why muslims have 'faith' - if they knew then they wouldnt need faith because you would know 100%, the word kuffar is absolutely worthless, take care.
@IRENIGMA888 I agree that the truth means giving up a lot even though I don't agree with your concept of truth, LOL.
sometimes you just gotta live and let live ya know? people have brains and a wealth of information at their finger tips through the Internet. we can each find the truth ourselves if we are looking for it.
I see what you trying to do and agree with you that some muslims behavior is unacceptable even damaging our image but please try to understand the situation in which muslims are, they are getting bombed, their livelihood getting destroyed, their country is invaded and their economy is collapsed and some how US has to do with it dont you agree?
mashriqie 4 months ago
Comment removed
mashriqie 4 months ago
what a mino but the muslim who insolted you probably brain washed
siralswidi 4 months ago
i half agree with that bully muslim
his way and attitude is not acceptable but sayying that you're kafr is true
kafr = who doesn't believe of the existent of god
and the wrong thing he did that we dont fight or attack ,we defend
about being in usa army ,there's no problem of joining them unless if they headed to iraq or pakistan where your muslims brothers getting killed
that what he meant by usa army i guess ,but its okay if it wasnt against another muslim who aren't a terrorist like iraqie
ineedhack2 5 months ago
Ur a asshole u no nothing about the deen and ur najaas
007dawud 7 months ago
spot on! And these 'mino's'- our Prophet taught us to speak with manners and in such a way to not offend others. What are the Muslims if we, ourselves are going against Islam?
muslimahmayy 7 months ago
he is really a mino .
dont worry of what he said because its obvious that he is an ignorant person and you are right and you are acting more Islamic than he is
my allah bliss you Bret
essa07 1 year ago
Bret,You always in the right way,
You know what,You know Islam more than some idiots called them selves Muslims,
I am sure if your videos got translated you will find millions of Muslims/Christians/Jews/Hindu/Budhists..etc watching them and supporting you 100%
I am thinking of this project seriously.
Hezam123 1 year ago
@Hezam123
thank you my friend
clevonamerica 1 year ago
Guiltyofbeingmuslim, when i see people like you I can't help but wonder why Bret is siding with muslims, the only answer is Bret is such a kind, nice, person. that is why i guess...
You and i and other muslims don't do as much as Bret does for islam, instead of critising him we should be shame of ourselves...
islamonly1 1 year ago
you have no idea what i do for islam
the fact that i am here and correcting falsehoods about islam means i'm doing more than you.
may allah forgive us and guide us, may he accept from us the good we do and cover the bad, and He is the source kindness, Knowledge and Wisdom.
like i said, i follow Rasool Allah, i know his deen is perfect. so when soemone says something contrary to is, i'm not going to let it slide.
i have never been rude to bret, whats your problem?
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
you arent qualified to lable this person as a muslim in name only, bret. you dont have an understanding of what would make soemone a mino.
you dont know what sins are just sins, and was sins are kufr and what sins are shirk.
yeah he swore - and that might be a sin, but it doesnt make you a "MINO"
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
this is a great point...you are correct that labels are bad and wrong and i made a label.
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
i shouldnt need to be a muslim scholar to befriend and support muslims.you are right that i shouldnt judge but are you judging my perceptions more harshly because im not muslim? if i was a muslim would you have challenged my words?
and are you telling me that im wrong for suggesting that mohammed would not approve of cruel pornographic racist nationalistic hate speech aimed at me and my muslim friends? i shouldnt have to be muslim to be right about this..facts are facts
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
again im not making islamic assumptions..christians say"what would jesus do"
cant muslims ask "what would mohammed do?" without requiring everyone to read up to answer the question? fairness and kindness are universal traits amongst most faiths and cultures and i hope youre not trying to convince me that the prophet mohammed was something other than kind and fair
bret
;)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
guiltyofbeingmuslim;
"Bret you don't know this, Bret you don't know that"
In your mind you know everything right!!!
WRONG!!!!'
islamonly1 1 year ago
no i dont know everything but i have studied a lot more of islam than bret has and if he says something wrong i'm going to point it out. it seems your too busy pointing at your brothers who speak truth than to point at something that is clearly wrong.
maybe you should educate yourself a bit. and if bret is your prophet then dont call yourself a muslim open up a new religion.
non of us are flawless and when i see something that goes against quran and sunnah then its my duty to point it out
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
insinuating that i am a false prophet or trying to be a prophet is a simple diversionary technique that takes us further from the reality of the discussion. its a way to humilate someone without fact...wheres the beef?whay is unholy in my words?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
that message about you being a prophet wasnt directed at you
it was directed a muslim.
because if a person values your words and actions more than the prophets, or Allahs (words) then he has, maybe without realising, taken you as a prophet, taken your way as a religion, instead of islam
this is like the hadeeth that talked about how people took their preists and rabis as gods instead of allah.. continued
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
a christian who became a muslim asked the prophet how that could be since he never called his priest a god, the prophet explained that this was because the people took what the priests said was forbidden as forbidden, and what they said was permitted as permissible, even though this contradicted the religion of Allah at that time.
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim @GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim @GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
bret
with all respect
it bothers me when you say 'would the prophet agree with you' or phrases like that.
you dont have a very in depth understanding of the life of the prophet. you have a limited understanding of islamic jurisprudence - and you are most of the time wrong when you assume what the prophet PBUH would have done.
i wont enter this discussion for many reasons but you are wrong bret
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
i think you raise an interesting point here. i ask the question for you to answer. Would the prophet agree with me? would he? what do you think? im just asking so i can learn. i do make assumptoons about what the prophet would do based on basic tenets that muslims have taught me..i do the same with my perception of jesus..i must be able to make some assumptions based on reason? what do you think?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
no he wouldnt agree with you
i think its important for you to pick up a book detailing the life of the prophet PBUH
if you want to make assumptions on islam without proper knowledge of it you can only expect that you'll make a lot of mistakes. you cant even really rely on your friends.
islam can only be islam if it is based on evidences from quran and sunnah. if someone is behaving in a way that opposes quran and sunnah, even if you approve of it, it isnt islam anymore
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
..was mohammed kind and fair? do muslims strive to behave like mohammed? if you answer yes then i know some things about islam that should be undenyable.
if a man steals from you is that islamic behavior? if a man helps a starving child is that islamic behavior? you know the answers i bet..how are non muslims supposed to understand islam if the tenets arent based in common sense?if you deny me using my logcal mind based on my perception of goodness then islam loses.
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
man i wish prophet mohammed was here right now to watch you teach me about how that nasty immature porno behavior was somehow better than my honest polite kuffarness.
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
now you put words in my mouth
i never approved of his swearing, but at the same time i left his swearing at the level of a sin, which is what swearing is, its a sin. it doesnt make you a fake muslim, it doesnt take you outside the fold of islam.
whereas some of the other stuff that people do which you would play down, is not only a sin but takes you outside the fold of islam.
and yes if you were a muslim i'd tell you the same thing. i'm not treating you in any special way
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
in fact if you were a muslim i'd be far more harsh.
and btw there are times when harshness is necessary. which you dont seem to get. no offence intended.
there was a time when abu bakr RA swore at one of the leaders of quraish because he insulted the prophet PBUH, the prophet PBUH did not rebuke him, he approved of it. because in that time and place it was justifiable. there was a time when the muslims killed in the forbidden months and this was excused because of the circumstances
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
if i saw an american soldier i'd spit in his face, even if he calls himself a muslim. thats what you call a MINO muslim.
well i'd want to, but then i'll probably get arrested and thrown somewhere no one would find me. or i'd be splashed all over the news for disrespecting the 'wonderful' soldiers.
i wouldnt do anything. i'd just do what i'm doing now and shut my mouth and eat crap and ask Allah every day to take me to a place wehre i'm surrounded by muslims and living under His law, in peace
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
gulityofbeingmuslim;
The ideal is not to be in US army right now, but remember this not every thing is black not everything is white in life and there are shades of gray and ALLAH is aware of those shades not you!!! not me!!! he knows all the details of this soldier and his family and etc.
Allah will judge these people and this soldier according to the facts that only and only he knows .
We may as well shut up...Let the ALL-Knowing handle everytthing...
islamonly1 1 year ago
in islam we judge by what is apparant
in islam there is such thing called a judge and there are many ahadeeth detailing how to be a good judge and what defines a judge that will be in hellfire
there is nothing wrong with judging so long as it is done according to quran and sunnah.
i cannot see what is in someones heart therefore i judge by what is apparant. this is perfectly acceptable and even in a lot of cases fard in islam.
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim @GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
Comment removed
islamonly1 1 year ago
GBMuslim;
You can not tell what Prophet Muhammed would agree or not, you can not...
You can and I can not tell if Prophet Muhammed (puh) would agree with him or not.
islamonly1 1 year ago
what Bret is saying is contrary to quran and sunnah, i know the prophet PBUH would not agree with what he is saying because what he is saying is not in line with quran and sunnah.
simple
we can know what the prophet PUBH aproved of and didnt approve of through his sunnah.
its very simple
and if you say that to me,t hen why didnt you say that to bret when he said the prophet PBUH wouldnt approve etc etc?
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
im dying to know..what did i say that was contrary to the quraan? please.. i want to know specifically which statement other than my "labeling somebody" was anti islam?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
labling someone isnt against quran and sunnah. but you labled him in a manner that was against quran and sunnah.
if i call someone a fake muslim, and i have proof of that, then this labling is ok. for example if i see someone calling himself a muslim but he is praying to a statue, then i can lable him and say he is not a muslim.
if see someone swearing and say he is a fake muslim then i myself have fallen into sin because he is not a fake muslim, he just sinned everyone sins
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
.when you first challenged me i agreed that this label of him was inappropriate. i shouldnt have done it. as soon as i was aware that it was a bad idea i immediately edited that video. i agree with you 100 percent. i said clearly that i am not qualified to challenge whether or not someone is a true muslim but there is behavior that i consider unmuslimlike...like the nasty language he used..i will try to keep my challenges on a secuar plane from now on.thank you
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
thanks bret
dont take offence to what i say
if you want to learn about the life or the prophet, his conduct and actions, get your hands on a copy of a set of cds called the life of the prophet PBUH, there is a set on the meccan period and a set on the madinan period. it is recorded by anwar al awlaki.
and before anyone jumps up and says 'hes an extremist', when these videos were recorded every muslim had a copy, and every bookstore sold them no matter what flavour muslim they were
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim.right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim @GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
no offense taken. thanks..one thing though. if you would want to spit in the face of any american soldier then you may need some help. each soldier is his own man with his own heart. they are pawns in the war. you must consider you could love a usa soldier if he was kind to you as he would and should love a kind muslim..right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
i wish we could get clear if i am contradicting the quraan. im willing to look at my words and consider if i am incorrect
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
that you'll have to investigate yourself by reading a bit about the life of the prophet PBUH.
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
@GuiltyOfBeingMuslim
i understand..i think..i edited my video to apologize for labeling thst man as a mino..i shouldnt ever label anyone..his behavior was wrong though and i cant imagine any scenario where mohammed would have approved his message..im no expert but i hold mohammed in high esteem and expect him to support what is right..obscenities are never right in a dialogue...ive been obscene myself when i was enraged but i knew it destryed the content of my message
thank you my friend
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
waiting for your reply on the other video on the Islam/death/apostasy issue. :D
kenny5822 1 year ago
@kenny5822
im sorry i cant find that quote you made..was yours the quote about your great sorrow for demonizing innocent muslims?? i think that was you..right?
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@clevonamerica, no, not me. Its on the Kimdonesia video.
kenny5822 1 year ago
bret, what is 'Right'? what you think is right is different to what i think is right, right?
and someone else might jump in with a totally different opinion on what is wrong and what is right?
i'm not saying his swearing was right, i'm not saying that this brother acted with hikma (wisdom). but what i'm saying is that as a muslim i would sooner be down the throat of a "muslim" in the american army, than a muslim swearing a bit.
maybe if he didnt swear he would have conveys his message better
GuiltyOfBeingMuslim 1 year ago
Leviticus 11:7-8
"And the swine, though he divided the hoof, and be clovenfooted, yet he cheweth not the cud; he is unclean to you.
"Of their flesh shall ye not eat, and their carcass shall ye not touch; they are unclean to you." andHoly Qur-an 2:173
"He has thus forbidden you only what dies of itself, and blood, and the flesh of swine, and that over which any other (name) than (that of) Allah has been invoked..."
same thing right
lilnas313 1 year ago
The Prophet Mohamed said:
" A Muslim is the one with whom people feel safe from abuse by mouth or hand; and a migrant is one who abandons what God has forbidden. (Related by Al-Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawood and Al-Nassaie).
Notice here that the Prophet spoke of harm by mouth first, before adding physical harm caused by hand. This is due to the fact that most abuse is caused verbally.
sabi79797 1 year ago 8
great response bret! looks like you have a better understaning of islam that the mino...
waleed2055 1 year ago
waleed
thanks ..of course you cant teach minos because threy already know everything...unlike me..hehe
Bret
*)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
ElderOfTzion
I appreciate your attitude, but I find your interference is kinda offending because you talk about stuffs in Islam in a wrong way, I don't know what you know about Islam but obviously you're telling info about Islam in a bad way, you're not making any help (if this is your intention!).
I know that my deeds will help me of course!
Again, supposing you have good intentions, your interference is not helping, you better make much investigation about Islam, otherwise, you're an offender!
MrBeego2 1 year ago
An American Muslim may show his patriotism by:
1.Letting authorities know about terrorist plots against innocent civilians, but should not work as a spy to entrap innocent Muslims.
2.Supporting organizations that aim to reveal the truth about 9/11
3.Voting & running for public office.
4.Exposing the Zionists & illuminatis control of U.S. government.
DiscoveringIslamOrg 1 year ago
I am against initiating disrespect or insulting remarks, bullying, obscene name calling, etc.
DiscoveringIslamOrg 1 year ago
American Muslims should not join the U.S. army. Quran clearly urges Muslims not to take non-Muslims as Awliya. A Muslim should not put himself in a situation where he has to comply with orders of non-Muslims. Allegiance to Islam must supersede allegiance to ones own country. The U.S. is engaging in wars against Muslims. The U.S. is occupied by Zionists and the army follows the orders of these Zionists.
Obey the civilian laws of the U.S., but do not join the U.S. army.
DiscoveringIslamOrg 1 year ago
u are kinda right! i would have resigned if i were in US army cuz i dont wanna kill innocent ppl!
devushka88farah 1 year ago
Some of those "Minos" I believe are most likely JTF bots, unfortunately they have the task of spewing hatred under the guise of being Muslim...although some could be real delusional 'Muslims'...
watch?v=xpgVk3RVGiA
asteroide 1 year ago
asterode
im sorry if they are and i fell for it
bret
:0
clevonamerica 1 year ago
Let's just say.....if BRET the so called KAAFIR ever needed water and I only had 1 cup to spare between him and a MINO....I would give it to him than to someone I knew was a MINO!
Job well done Bret!
nyznicca 1 year ago
nyznicca
and of course we would sit down togeher and the three of us would share that cup. thank you for your enduring support my friend
bret
:)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
Nice video Bret...when did u become a da'i? :)
Keep up the good work!
djking2003 1 year ago
djking
please forgive me i dont know what a "da'i" is...
bret
:)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@Bret
Da'i means someone who engages in Da'wah, spreading the message of or more literally, 'inviting' people to Islam.
MissSamothy 1 year ago
"mino" you're right bret. these minos are so frustrating, make people think all muslims are hateful and unreasonable, illogical and angry. :(
baseemahAli 1 year ago
basseemahali
and the minos are unhappy too.noone wins
:(
clevonamerica 1 year ago
I wouldn't invest anytime trying to change the min of a 5 year old. I would say Bret you're giving him attention more than he deserves. I understand his point about the solider who is killing people of his own but there are ways to go about delivering that same message and also it is up to the Muslim solider and his god, not up to us to judge.
koya25555 1 year ago
koya2555
thank you koya but ive witnessed five year olds suddenly sprout a decade or two of instant growth when watered with love and compassion'''hehe
:)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
people will be mean, it's just worse when there's a greater cause being represented
eurasianchica 1 year ago
eurasianchica
thats funny you mention that. people get weird around money too. and the more the money the stranger they behave. a real estate deal or an inheritance deal are the biggest money deals for most folks, hence people turn into pigs and crooks around these deals..some still have integrity though..
bret
:)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
MrBeego2,
With all do respect, I CARE for 'Muslims' because I care for people. I could give a crap whether you need it, my feelings have nothing to do with your need. As far as interference goes, I am afraid my friend, that the reality is Shahadah does not change you. Shahadah does not validate you. Your deeds do. I am not interference, my friend, I am part of the Chorus--and my voice is just as important as yours. Welcome to reality.
ElderOfTzion 1 year ago
i recently subscribed to you clevon, i really enjoy watching ur videos keep them coming!
akhan71192 1 year ago
because fact is, no matter what Muslims should do, they are killing one another. Seems like some people are blaming Bret for that.
ElderOfTzion 1 year ago
Do Muslims also strike terror in the hearts of Muslims in Iraq who want to vote and control their own fate? Do Muslims justify killing Muslims in Iraq who fight because they believe the Muslims of Iraq deserve a safe and secure country? When the Mujaheddin are killing Iraqi policeman--are they fighting in the cause of Allah? Give me a break. And if you don't think Muslims should fight Muslims--whose side are you on?
ElderOfTzion 1 year ago
Looks like you "care" for Muslims. Thank you for this feeling, but we actually don't need this kind of "feeling" or "interference" with our affairs, it is mainly the factor that brought chaos and destruction to Iraq in the first place, so Elder, thank you, we don't need your interference or any similar attitude.
Most (if not all) the accidents of killing Muslims in Iraq are made by "Black Water" mercenaries or foreign intelligence agencies spies, not to say that a Muslim won't help an invader.
MrBeego2 1 year ago
I really can't tell If they are Muslims or not, it's the internet!
it is a strange thing that a Muslim would curse in a similar situation, it is not the manner of Muslims to curse at all. I don't know why I doubt the identity of those guys being Muslims and I don't know why I feel that there's something in the air!
MrBeego2 1 year ago
This is the first time I feel you're disturbed a little bit when shooting your video, Bret. I'm really sorry for any bad experience you had with our brothers.
and for those Muslim Brothers, please watch Bret's videos before judging him or his attitude. You won't gain any thing by cursing, NOTHING in Islam justifies the cursing at all. If you guys have a point, you will lose your creditability by cursing. I don't think Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) would do what you did in a similar situation.
MrBeego2 1 year ago
dear bret as I know you are learning arabic , so here is one of the many sentences we have to describe your situation with this guy ( القافلة تسير والكلاب تنبح )
and that's mean ( the caravan still passing, and the dogs still barking )
I hope I translate it right
archisami 1 year ago
*covers ears* My ears can't stand that kind of language.
Oh and I'm so stealing 'mino'.
MissSamothy 1 year ago
what you are saying is obsolutely true
easyjammin 1 year ago
Bret - my friiend, that's a hater of Islam rather than a supporter. More than that, if he is giving this long speech about the definition of islam then he should start by teaching himself first...a True practicing Muslim, does NOT curse and use the "F" word specifically. He is a hypocrit.
mnbisbis 1 year ago
The brother cussed the american soldier on the forum, you he just called a kaffir which is accurate.
It's wonderfull to see so many muslims willing to attack the brother and even claim he is not a muslim or what not. All for your sake Brett.
Clapity clap for this masterpiece of muslim brotherhood.:)
Ubah007 1 year ago
Ubah007
my sarcasm meter is disabled today so..thank you my friend for giving me the clap...
bret
:)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
Ubah007
did you just write that what your friend did wrong was to call me a kaffir?
i have no problem with being called kaffir..i have a problem with a man who calls himself a muslim wishing others to burn in hell and calling people whores and using language that is pornographic...do you condone pornographic language? he claims to west is sick when his words are grotesque immature and offensive..i still love you both..
bret
:)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
stop it. you're making me blush with your abundant love declarations:)
it's odd you don't mind being called a disbeliever yet my brothers and sister are judging their brother for that. it' a world gone mad. lol
people say things in anger, i will not forsaken him for that. i understand his emotion. he's still my brother no matter what your or any other "nonmuslim" says.:)
Ubah007 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The world is full of people from the category "in name only" and of course we can find some brothers and sisters that belong to it.
What a shame that "mino" brings us.
RayaAmmani 1 year ago
Comment removed
RayaAmmani 1 year ago
Therefore, if you call other Muslims "kafir" or "mushrik" without discrimination, you could find that you have left Islam, according to the words of the Prophet (s.a.w.), in less than a second.
islamonly1 1 year ago
About calling other Muslims "kafir," we read the following hadith: It is reported on the authority of Ibn `Umar that the Prophet (may peace and blessings be upon him) said: Any person who calls his brother: O Unbeliever! (then the truth of this label) would return to one of them. If it is true, (then it is) as he asserted, (but if it is not true), then it returns to him (and thus the person who made the accusation is an Unbeliever). [Muslim]
islamonly1 1 year ago
@ islamonly1 This hadith does not give you permission to call the brother a kaffir, which is exactly what you did.
Ubah007 1 year ago
@Ubah007
Correct me if I am wrong but he also called the person "kafir" just because the person is in the US Army thouht the person calls himself a "muslim"
islamonly1 1 year ago
I saw him call that particular person a hypocrite for going to Iraq. I see a couple of dozen muslims here calling him that because he called Brett a kaffir and was cursing at another american soldier. Didn't see you any where condemning that. No matter what though, the hadith does not tell you to call him kaffir.
Ubah007 1 year ago
@Ubah007 I have tremeondous amount of respect to Bret and people like him because they help more to our religion than most of muslims put together.
He is not a muslim but SO?
Secondly; why wuld he call someone a hypocrate?
Because they are a soldier!?!
Would you rather see a muslim in Iraq verses a mad, brianwashed muslim hater? Which one would kill an Iragi easily?
islamonly1 1 year ago
Islamonly1
I love it how you completely bypassed your own error- the takfir.
But anyways, I disagree with your unbalanced praise of Brett. This video is the reason why so many muslims-who were not even there last night- are here today to backbite their own and call the brother a dog and a kaffir. To defend Brett.
Brett is not a muslim, it is good of you to see that at least.
Ubah007 1 year ago
As for you last question I do not want to see ANY muslim fighting against muslims in Iraq.You want me to aprove of that because you claim the muslim american will maybe hesitate before he kills an Iraqi?? A muslim should not be killing a believer at all
Honest to God, I don't get what is so hard for you to understand about that!
Ubah007 1 year ago
If this muslims wants to be in Iraq, he should be fighting againts those mad, brainwashed muslim haters you speak of... not for them.
Ubah007 1 year ago
:)
Dear Brother,
It's not right to call a Muslim a Kafir for sure. Judging Bret situation is not of our business, no body can tell if Bret is a Muslim or not, it's something between Allah and him.
Our attitude is simply what Muhammad (pbuh) ordered us to do when he said (" support your Brother whether he is oppressed or unjust" sahaba said "how we support him when he is unjust?" Muhammad (pbuh) said "by preventing him from being unjust").
Bret is a peaceful man who loves Muslims, this is true.
MrBeego2 1 year ago
Fist, I am a sister.:)
Brett is not a Muslim. We are not having this discussion, please.
And I haven't seen any support here. If any muslim wished to give the brother naseeha they should have talked to him in private. Not ridicule him on this video because Brett called them to stand against their own brother.. Muslims should be defending their brother against such a call not siding with Brett because he is so likeable.
Ubah007 1 year ago
:)
Sorry Sister, I didn't know so.
I can't ridicule this Brother of course, actually I can't ridicule any body else. I have to treat him respectfully of course, I don't think that I ridiculed him at all. I'd love to talk to him in private if he allowed me to :)
We have to be fair when dealing with non Muslims too Sister and I think you know this for sure, I'm not defending Bret only, I'm also defending my Brother from being unfair to Bret.
Thank you Sister
:)
MrBeego2 1 year ago
ubah007, you are the first one who called Bret "likeable"
islamonly1 1 year ago
ubah007,
Bret is not a muslim? Really? Tell me something I don't know.
My respect to him is not making me blind do not worry, i don't remember which surah but ALLAH says in the quran when a muslim is right, you be on the side of the muslim, when a non muslim is right you be on the side of the non muslim regardless of their belief, so stop saying bret is not muslim, that won't change the fact that the way we deal with the subject according to quran of course.
islamonly1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Islamonly: i don't remember which surah but ALLAH says IN THE QUR'AN when a muslim is right, you be on the side of the muslim, when a non muslim is right..
[004:135] PICKTHALL O ye who believe! Be ye staunch in justice, witnesses for Allah, even though it be against yourselves or (your) parents or (your) kindred, whether (the case be of) a rich man or a poor man, for Allah is nearer unto both (them ye are). ...
Garabsare 1 year ago
I will never debate Quran with you or anyone, I am not in the position to give tafseer on verses so don't start that please. I am not a scholar and neither are you.
However I am at ease in defending my brother in this youtube hackle. Brett was standing up for american soldiers and now is calling on muslims to stand up against another muslims who got upset with an american soldier. I am simply defending my brother's honour as I understand I should.
Ubah007 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
UBAX: I will never debate Quran with U or anyone, I am not in the position2 give tafseer on verses so don't start that please. I am not a scholar and neither are U.
Peace,
I merely produced da Qur'anic verse becoz IslamOnly1 forgot.. I don't personally know da specifics of this 'youtube hackle'. Don't feel intimidated in ur defence of da brother!
Peace!
Garabsare 1 year ago
No Muslim has the right to call any non-Muslim a kaffer. By definition a kaffer is a "non-believer" ie. someone who doesn't believe in the one true God. By this definition, Jews and Christians can't be called kaffirs/kaffirs because they, by definition, believe in one true God.
PS - MINO, nice acronym. I'll make sure to use it.
thetornado99 1 year ago
@Clevon..be careful it could be a wolf in sheep clothing my be acting like a Muslim and not really one....trying to make Muslim look stupid and ignorant...i have a beautiful Sister who is in the army reserve join before the war broke out....she has to honor her commitments. mindful of not fighting Muslims that did nothing to her she works desk.
isnumo 1 year ago 2
isnumo
this is great advice i will remember these angry muslims may not be muslims at all
bret
clevonamerica 1 year ago
When we call someone a 'Kaafir', it means that we are passing a judgment about that person's acceptance or rejection of the Truth as he has perceived and understood it. Obviously, no human being is qualified to pass this judgment. Only God, with His absolute knowledge about each and every individual, can pass the judgment as to whether or not that individual has lived his life according to the Truth, which that individual has understood.
THEGREATESTUMMAH 1 year ago 2
From the perspective of the life of this world 'non-Muslim' is primarily a legal term implying a person, who does not ascribe to the Islamic faith. In contrast, the word 'Kaafir' - literally: rejecter - is used by the Qur'an for people, who are guilty of rejection or non-acceptance of the truth, even after it has become fully apparent to them.
THEGREATESTUMMAH 1 year ago 2
a Muslim may offer himself for recruitment in any army of the world, as long as he is aware of the fact that all his actions shall be guided by the principles of equity and justice. Even while serving a Muslim army, he cannot afford to be careless of this fact.
A just action taken by the army of the United States is as commendable as a just action taken by a Muslim army. And an unjust action taken by a Muslim army is as condemnable as an unjust action taken by any other army of the world.
THEGREATESTUMMAH 1 year ago 2
Mashallah that is true!
sumayahrose 1 year ago
but never for jews and christians those are belivers we may not agree with them but still.
let me tell you minus that you can take your hate and shove it up you A*
sorry bret
hostaden 1 year ago
this mino doesnt represent anyone but himself those guys ruined our faith and they are trying to hijack our religion an turn it out to a set of weird and stupid practices you gotta be stupid to think that you're a good muslim because you eat with your right hand and enter the bathroom with your left foot, and hey Minus ill call him minus, let me tell you that you know sh* about Islam first of all the word Kafir have been used in the Quran only five times one of them to describe Satan but ...
hostaden 1 year ago
How can he stop us? He can only bark or bite, but I am immune to the disease of rhetoric and hate, the rabid distrust and aggression of this bully. This is radical peace. This is our video. Let them kill us--when we are gone they will soon follow. This disease he suffers from isn't radical Islam--it is the disease which tries to justify itself under the name of all ideologies and all groups--it is Hate. It deceives to gain victims and to curtail man's tendency towards co-existence.
ElderOfTzion 1 year ago
@ElderOfTzion
This man cannot matter, because the world he envisions does not matter. The world which hate will win is not a human world. Not a humane world. Whether it is called an Islamic world, a christian world, a democratic world...it will be a lie--because nothing good is born of hate. We would rather be victims than murderers. Because a world where men are brave enough and strong enough to not take up arms is a world of peace--is the world we must make, already.
ElderOfTzion 1 year ago
Thats some pure evil right there!
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
@IRENIGMA888
Sir, Im sorry, but I think you haven't made one single true point against Islam...
You going to be shocked, because I know very well your version of the so called Truth.
first you need to accept the fact that you might be totaly wrong, and stop being arrogant. Im accepting your challenge when you release yourself from hate.
The problem when you take it as a challenge, it becomes personal instead of making it for learning.
Let's debate on emails, not enough space
God bless you
AnInvitationToTheTru 1 year ago
You dont know anything so dont act as if you do, If you would just check that the info I have told you is true, you will find out that its true for yourself instead of immediately dismissing my every point as a lie, Its not hate - i dont have hate, its concern that brings me to talk about things like this, nothing less and nothing more - so please, dont stereotype the anti-hater stance against me, dont make assumptions and judgements that are incorrect, you dont know anything.
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
How can you dismiss my points as lies yet deny the challenge? - If you had of said what you said - yet not dismissed my points as lies, your lies would have had some credability, and maybe I would believed that you actually thought i hated.... You took away all your credability when you done that, You do realise that dont you?
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
Some people asked Allah's messenger:
'who is a very good Muslim?'
He replied:
'one who avoids harming the people with his tongue (e.g. using abusive language) and hands.'
I don't support those Muslims who fight in illegal wars and kill fellow Muslims, but I don't condone Muslims who use bad language. Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) respected everybody.
lovepeacerespect89 1 year ago 6
@irenigma888------man! u should find a psychologist.......or get some therapies....u are wasting ur time and brain......in addition, dont waste it...! if u sell ur brain,u will get a good price cuz ur one is an unused brain :PPP
devushka88farah 1 year ago
Why do you say that?
That was a random comment from a random internet fool right? :)
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
i think u are talking abt urself ...dude>>>my comment makes sense at least not like urs..........BULLSHIT
devushka88farah 1 year ago
your comment was a common flamer autocomment, I expect you have been the victim of it many times, I doubt you have the i.q to think of your own, laters... :)
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
. by the way i didnt study in a "Quarrel and Win" School like you..............CAn u plzzzzz stoppppppppppppp!!!!!!! ....i am fed up.......i will shut up if u shut up.............u are just adding petrol on a fire!!!!.......ok dude...i am an asshole,fool, dumbass.....HAPPY??? now plzzzzzzzzzzzz stop...i dont wanna QUARREL!!!!!
devushka88farah 1 year ago
@devushka88farah
you know come to think of it im the biggest stupid wrong fool there ever was. lets end the argument that im wrong or devush you and i can both be wrong together?my friend potenza says "do you want to be right? or do you want peace?
bret
bravo devushi admire your ego concession for peace
clevonamerica 1 year ago
@bret: it is Devushka--[russian ]meaning "BEautiful girl" my ex bf used to call me that. :PPP
devushka88farah 1 year ago
@devushka88farah
what a great name...in arabic beautiful girl is Jameela..
Bret
:)
clevonamerica 1 year ago
Peace,
Da word "KaFiR" is misused by Muslims & non-Muslims alike! WIKI it 2 understand a bit of what it means. It also means "TO ATONE" as (كفارة من الله) KAFFARAH (pronounced cuff-faarah). Young Muslim married couples usually have problems fasting Ramadhan! & so they "atone" (make a KAFFARAH).
As 4 these VULGAR "Muslims", most R FAKE ones masquerading as Muslims. Qur'an & Sunnah forbid VULGARITY!
Hebrew cognate "KOFER" means "APOSTATE". Arabic for latter is "MURTAD" not "KAFIR"
Garabsare 1 year ago
are u talking to me dude???...
devushka88farah 1 year ago
love this video.man! i hope u were here so that we could have a nice chat on this topic.
i hv seen 100s of comments on sum videos in YT.
Sum of them said,"Muslims bend to the devils"+some1 said "Fucking Allah-".i was laughing>i was feeling sorry for them instead of getting angry cuz hatred got filled in their brains so much that the brain is not getting enough space to "relax and think over it".
i wont say anything against Jesus cuz he is our prophet.i respect him&y shud i say even if he wasnt?
devushka88farah 1 year ago
Of course, its the strategy of hatred to create a monster so one can become the slaying hero. You are not unique nor first to do such an act. Whatever propaganda you spread though - it wont make it the truth. Truth shines by itself and lies will always decline. Some people will do anything to maintain a racially ordained strata in the world and that is what is killing the planet. Forging history is just one part.
Signalement 1 year ago
@Signalement
Siz Turk musunuz?
islamonly1 1 year ago
Actually you are speaking of the poet that was awarded by the abaya of the prophet himself. Thats kinda basic knowledge that cannot be turned into something else.
Signalement 1 year ago
Those types, they are the hypocrites. Unfortunately they are increasing in fold and are very influential and in powerful positions in the Muslim world.
They are close minded freaks that know only misery and hate everybody. To them, you are a Muslim if they see you pray and read Qur'an, but if you have an opinion, they declare holy war on you.
hamidious 1 year ago
Arent you lying about the history at this moment? U know, all creatures choose their battles and one criteria is that they know when they are getting into a battle they wont win. Are you really choosing your battle here by lying? Or is it the provocation by lying that gets you off, like some kind of a pervert?
Signalement 1 year ago
@ThePrimordialAtom
Why just don't you tell us what is the poem all about, there were many poets who insulted the prophet personaly but none of them was punished.
The truth is those 3 poets whom the prophet punished, were actualy not insulting the prophet, but they were inciting war and genocide against all muslims.
Do you know what the CIA will do to someone who incite war and terrorism against american?? you tell me.
BE blessed
AnInvitationToTheTru 1 year ago
asma bint marwan was stabbed while breastfeeding her child because she wrote poems about muhammed....
She only told the truth, He was a murderer and caravan robber.
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
btw, I really despise your name, In invitation to the true? an invitation to a lie!
If you knew the truth of religion then you would be free from it, as it stands you are a slave to it, wether you realise it or not, thats is truth.
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
Bro don't bother yourself with those parasites, I've seen a comment calling one of the best known Islamic preacher Kafir just because he preach in a snoking suit, I told him to stop, and he told me that I will have problms if I don't mind my own business....Frankly, in real life, I ve never seen real person doing this, I live in a muslim country...I have a big doubt if they are muslims in the first place or just some haters of Islam who wants to give a bad impression about it.
AnInvitationToTheTru 1 year ago
@AnInvitationToTheTru I think i saw some muslim calling Zakir Naik a kaffir
some muslims that i have seen even make fun of the hadiths claiming that all of them have been fabricated and we should only read the Quran
and the worst ones that I saw went as far as saying that parts of Quran have been changed later by human beings
Astaghfirullah!
MonzieStar 1 year ago
@MonzieStar
Exactly, those are MINOs as bro Bret call them....
The problem is, most of them don't want to debate or proof their case, all of them just brabel and keep spaming.
That's why Im doubting if they are actualy muslims in the first place, or Islam enemies disguised.
God bless you
AnInvitationToTheTru 1 year ago
5*****
salamalikoum1 1 year ago
Prophet Muhammad forgave all of them although the non muslim meccans smacked him, spit at him, chased him & his followers out of their homes & city without allowing them to take their properties with them. The meccans killed his followers & tortured them to the extent that no one could ever imagine & yet he forgave all of them on the day muslims had conquered Mecca.
Find the history book on the conquest of Mecca & read it for yourself.
citacitasejati 1 year ago 2
On the day of the Conquest of Mecca, Prophet Muhammad SAW said to the Meccans who were non muslims:"O you people of Quraish! What do you think of the treatment that I am about to accord to you?" They replied:"O noble brother & son of noble brother! We expect nothing but goodness from you." Upon this Prophet Muhammad SAW said:"I speak to you in the same words as Yusuf (Prophet Joseph) spoke unto his brothers: "No reproach on you this day," [Al-Qur'an 12:92] go your way, for you are freed ones."
citacitasejati 1 year ago 2
Bret,
I think the guy you said had gotten a piece of your mind with regard to the right and left hands and pork (if he watch your video)......but i'm sorry for you, because of your stance you have to face a hard times. I hope you are okay.
citacitasejati 1 year ago
Wow, that guy sounds like a grade A wacko. I just don't get that. It's always those kind of people that want to tell everyone else what to believe and what to do and what to think.
sonnygll 1 year ago 2
Next time you get called a kuffar explain to them that a kuffar is someone who knows islam is real but hides the truth, but nobody knows that islam is real thats why muslims have 'faith' - if they knew then they wouldnt need faith because you would know 100%, the word kuffar is absolutely worthless, take care.
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
oh and for that matter - faith is fraud...lol
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
@IRENIGMA888 your trying to make an argument but your argument has no basis so it falls apart.
Yyourself 1 year ago
The word faith falls apart, if you cant see it you are not intelligent enough, im sorry you cannot see this.
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
how are you doing, friend? still fightin for truth?
4ndiland 1 year ago
Yeah finally found it, Lol, Ill gladly share it to anyone who asks, But the truth isnt for everybody! :) you have to give up alot.
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
@IRENIGMA888 I agree that the truth means giving up a lot even though I don't agree with your concept of truth, LOL.
sometimes you just gotta live and let live ya know? people have brains and a wealth of information at their finger tips through the Internet. we can each find the truth ourselves if we are looking for it.
4ndiland 1 year ago
You dont know my version of truth :), do you?
IRENIGMA888 1 year ago
@IRENIGMA888 we've communicated, and I've seen your channel and comments. Like I said, live and let live :-)
4ndiland 1 year ago