Added: 3 years ago
From: RazOrFisT20
Views: 89,605
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (224)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • he has the same thing i loved about gerald butler as the phantom.... the rock and roll edge to his voice.... amazing

  • last good american idol to me

  • i wish he was my phantom <3

  • this is where i honestly fell in love....

  • David Cook can sing ANYTHING.

  • it sucks that he could only win once

    

  • he sings great, don't get me wrong, but i still prefer gerard butler on this song :) sorry david, you rock, but this song belongs to gerard

  • cant believe he sang this, one of my favorite songs from Phantom

  • The end gave me goosebumps

  • OMG DAVID U CAN SING ANYTHING! pop, rock, ballad, broadway songs... CAN U RAP TOO???

  • BEAUTIFUL! As our beloved Phantom would say, "Bravisima!"

  • @RaySingh87 "bravissima" is italian for "excellent job" but directed to a female. "bravissimo" would be directing to a male

  • O.o this was so un-expected when he did phantom of the opera...

  • i have goosebumps...

  • i like his voice...where is David Cook now???

  • when he sings "Be" *heart explodes*

  • This song is the reason he won idol.

  • If You think this is good then yu should search - Music of the night (kevin wong) .... He is soo good :D

  • what the crap what that at the end???

  • His voice is so beautiful!

  • He messed up the lyrics... otherwise, beautifully done with the exception of the end...

  • He is amazing. I'm not an idol fan, but wow. From a phanatic- he deserved to win. Almost as good as Gerry... almost.

  • @MissMarianParoo But... he did win! :)

  • omg...amazing<3

  • I love him and this song verrry much!

  • This is my favourite cover of the song.

  • David Cook would be amazing in the role of the phantom. He has class, the 'look' and the voice that can gives goosebumps . I've seen the movie version, and I hate to say, as much as I love Gerard Butler...David put him to shame. The high notes were impeccable, and the soft verbrato was amazing. I could..and have...watched this over and over again. I was very, very impressed.

  • @toadytoni No one can beat Gerard Butler at this song,Gerard Butler is most likely a Baritone which their the most talented of the guys because they can sing low and high. But still he did pretty good not as good as Gerard though

  • haha ... no .... Gerard Butler did a better job on this song. but i agree no one compares to Michael Crawford

  • they suck!! John Cudia is the best phantom of all time.

  • i have not heard him yet so i can not say

  • That actually wasnt to good, some notes were like slightly off. It was good overall tho

  • he is really awesome........... no doubt..

    guys there, you are just insecure!! haha!! LOL

  • He sang the song well in terms of emotion and pitch, but I wouldn't say his voice is suited for this song. To me his voice has more of a southern country rock feel to it, which doesn't belong in theater.

  • just beautiful...

  • @inesandrade1990 1:10 goosebumps.

  • @AlannahClaire OMG me too! he is so awesome!

  • OMG. I cried a little. But then again, I always cry during any Phantom of the Opera songs. There is just so much  emotion packed in.

  • he sonds better than the guy whos this song is

  • what the fuck are you saying?! you've obviously never seen phantom of the opera!!!! mcicu4ever

  • WHAT?!?!?! No one.... NO ONE can compare to michael crawford.

    And, David Cook ruined the song at the end, when he got all rocker on a musical theater song. I'm sorry, but its true

  • he should do a full version track to this song! or cast in the production or something!

  • They do full version tracks to the song after each performance....look up David Cook - Music of the Night Studio Version.

  • It's like his rocker voice is gone for a new, cliche idol voice...until the end =D

  • omg!!!!!!!!!!!just like the phantom!!!!!!!!!

  • hes done so well in the last year

  • i came here deliberately to diss idol contestants for ruining ALW's legendary music.

    But this is good. Probably the best idol singer when it comes to an ALW song. :)

  • it's been a year... wow

  • Favorite performance of his, for me. Maybe that's just because I like Phantom of the Opera, idk. But he did good :)

  • i have heard many people sing this song.

    But i gotta say he's one of the best

  • did you guys know that he lost his brother yesterday.

  • omg! the look he gives you at 1:23 could make anyone melt. David cook is sooooooo sexy!

  • I actually cried when I saw this live.

  • David completely had me with this song. Such a beautiful performance. Gorgeous song, gorgeous man.

  • His voice is so sexy..SERENADE ME <3

  • He totally blew it on the end

  • i don't guess i see what you mean... it only sounds... FANTASTIC

  • He's pretty hot in this video. LOVE IT

  • omg, david cook is my obsession <3

  • goosebumps!!!

  • Different interpretation, but a very good one! Anybody who has tried to sing this song knows that it is REALLY hard.

  • The final notes he hits of this song are sang in the song Avalanche on his CD. Pretty wicked

  • i like it,...who tells that it sucks ?that shows only that cook is a versatile singer

  • let your soul take you where you long to BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

    GOOSEBUMPS.

  • This is the song that made me sure he would win the competiton. Beautiful David! Bravo!

  • It just adds that he is so cute but then he goes and surprises everyone with this beautiful song! That is when I actually watched american idol and LOVE DAVID COOK!

  • This guy sucks. Will Feroh does a better job

  • will feroh... never heard of him.

  • He has a good voice, don't get me wrong, but he suits pop songs. He's not got a voice that would suit a musical.

    And no one can beat Gerard Butler or Colm Wilkinson as The Phantom.

  • Michael Crawford can. The original phantom. But those men are good too. I agree he suit pop songs but he did pretty good.

  • yes, but can gerard perform live? thats the big question.

  • goosebumps <3 love him

  • I think I just fell in love all over again. <3

  • the main redeeming factor in this performance is the gloriousness which is the last note. lovely.

  • This is definetly one of American Idol's best performances, this is simply amazing:)

    Love it and def. favoriting it :D

  • so david cook was my favorite contestant last year and lately I've been wondering why because I listened to a lot of david archuleta's songs and they're really good.... but this song reminds me why cook won. this is simply... amazing.

  • DO YOU KNOW HOW MANY TIMES I VOTED FOR HIM BECAUSE OF THIS SONG?????????????? he could totally be the phantom!!!!bet andrew lloyd webber was really proud that night

  • my mom and i thought that exact same thing! i remember we turned to each other after he finished this (both of us had goosebumps and my mom was practially crying) and she said to me "i bet you a million dollars that someone is calling andrew lloyd webber right now to get phantom back on broadway with david cook in it".

    haha.

  • Phantom is STILL on Broadway.... ;)

  • he sang this beautifully

  • he's so amazing and talented! i wish i had bought this when it was still on itunes! :( i miss him! everyone this season is ok but no tops him-i want david back!!! well, favorited!

  • he's amazing

  • This is a great song and he performed it well.

  • omg i love david cook and phantom of the opera

    DAVID COOK +PHAMTOM THE OPERA = AMAZING

  • What a beautiful man.

    He has never looked hotter than he does in this video.

    Favorite!

  • i miss watching him every week :(

  • Wow. o.o I didn't know someone would sing it.

  • What makes this song so great is that he actually feels and believes the song

  • this is officially the best song he has done, i am a major david cook fan, he is the best american idol in my opinion, hes an amazing singer, he hits the high and low notes--what a RANGE on that man!!--and it doesnt hurt that hes hot as hell! this literally gives me shivers when i hear it, i love his new album, love him, love this performance. DC ftw, even though hes already won. <3<3<3

  • I think I'm in love... :) He's soooo talented!

  • *Squeeee* I love it!

  • Speachless

  • What makes him even better is that he is from Blue Springs, Missouri. Gotta love David Cook.

  • What an exceptional voice and an ultimate talent - there could be no idol after him that could compare!!!

  • IK!! I keep telling my freinds that becauseit is so true!!!!! He has such an amazing voice and hes soo sweet!!!!! I luv him!!!!!

  • I didn't watch American Idol that season until I heard a snippet of this on Y100 and instantly became a David Cook fan. I got chills when I heard this!!

    (I love Phantom)

  • As much as I hate American Idol and Phantom, this is amazing

  • wow.

    personally david cook is my favourite american idol

  • ok, im an archuleta fan, but this.... wow! blown away!

  • wow...I remember when I first saw him perform this. He is so amazing. I love this song, and he sings it so wonderfully. I was so happy when he chose this song to sing. The night he sang this I knew it was either him or david archuleta.

  • 0_0

    ...*drools*....

  • ..he's pretty.

  • I definately like his version of this song. He tries to hard to make it pretty tho and does not capture the evil seductiveness of the phantom (this is a singing competition though)..Good Job

  • If this impresses you try Creep ( Bad language for the youngsters) by David, u will cry.........totally melt down awesome!

  • Kinda hard to watch idol this year....Cook has put the bar so high up that i wonder if someone can come close....but he is the total package...

  • He's up there with Bocelli...WOW!!

    When my husband I saw this we knew he was going to win the whole thing!

    The guy can literally sing anything.

  • just about anything. He has to practice it for a couple of minutes first... BUT, you are right. The dude is awesome. I would not be surprised if he decided to try Celine Dion or Whitney Houston song. Imagine what the possiblities would be like for him. Props for David Cook!!!

  • Dude, David cook is an awesome singer. He has the type of kinda rocky/deeper voice that the phantom tends to have. Thats probably why he sang the song best, because of his rock-esque voice. Still phenominal.

  • The first and only performance that comes close to the London original. I felt strongly, that I was looking - and listening to - the winner of A.I. 7 - and after checking the web, I realised I was. Well done - I am now on my way to buy a cd!!!

  • i was a total archuleta supporter up until this performance.

    after that high note? totally changed my mind haha.

    david cook is AMAZING.

  • i kinda like daiv darchuleta better but this david ROCKS MY SOCKS OFF too.

  • I know EVERYONE else is saying this too but...

    this song made me a Cook fan!

    i love at 0:35 when he looks at the camera and then glances down and looks at it again.

    he is pure genius. and it takes a real man to hit that high note :]

  • Unbelievable!

  • This is a very difficult song to sing. Serious props, especially for American Idol.

  • oh my goodness when he says "be" is the best i've ever heard him sing. it sounds AMAZING!

  • Um, he was the best that auditioned! This is the song that made me a Cook fan!

  • This is def. the song that made me a David Cook fan. I only wished he'd sing the rest of the Phantom's songs as he has to do the best job out of all the Phantom's I've ever heard.

  • he sounds sorta like the movie.

  • its okay! ^_^

  • I honestly think that this is the best performance by any Amreican Idol contestant. Ever.

  • this song converted me to a david cook fan

  • Who want the other David when you can have this one? He's pretty hot

  • unbelievable! so enchanting and yet it rocks too! I didn't think those two traits could be so complementary He does an awesome job

  • absolutely one of my FAVORITE performances he ever did on American Idol.

    I could listen to this over and over and over and over again.

    =]

  • that was AMAZING!!

  • perfect.

  • omg he is so cute and he was amazing singing this song!

  • would love to see Davisd as the phantom on broadway some day. this was amazing.

  • Please tell me Simon loved this? I live in Norway, so I have a hard time follow AI :p

    But David Cook is amazing<3 I always check out top three after it's over ;D

  • great performance =)

  • he really deserved to win and i am so glad he did!

    even though i originally wanted michael johns to win!

  • Hes way too hot for his own good...and mine! lol Great Job

  • I'm so glad he won!

    This is a spectacular performance! (:

  • Sipmly BREATHTAKING!

  • oh my gosh...it's gorgeous I have been obsessed ever since he sang it *melts*

  • Phantom of the Opera is my all time favorite play, I'm in love with the man who sings for phantom and Music Of The Night is one of my all time fave songs from the play. so I was nervous about David Cook singing it because I was scared he would butcher it. but wow, as soon as he started singing I was enthralled, incredible preformance and I was truly impressed when he hit that big note at the end of the song. so many people sing it a few octaves down and then it sounds wrong, truly beautiful

  • The lyrics already make this a great song, but with David Cook singing it, it's fabulous!

  • Not a Cook fan, but I LOVE LOVE LOVE hits.

  • I have watched this video about 16 million times and IMHO, in 7 seasons of AI there is not a single performance that even comes close to this. Absolutely breathtaking.

  • In my opinion the reason this is your most watched video is specifically due to the last two notes. I thought it was an unexpected, incredible ending and wish the studio verion was the same as the show version.

  • the beginning is different??

    Awesome job

  • thanks everyone!!

    this is my best video due to its ratings, views and of course comments. try to check my other videos tnx, u guys rock!

  • David Cook is truly amazing. My one (and only one) disappointment of this song is that he had to go up at the end. He didn't have to stay exactly with this song, but I felt that by going up it totally changed some of the feel of the song. I think everyone on American Idol feels that they have to make a powerful statement at the end by showing off how high they can go, when really, sometimes ending on a soft note can have an even more powerful effect.

    Awesome job though, I'm glad he won.

  • As much as I want to disagree with you on this.. I think you're right.. I loved the first high note because there was more emotion after it, but ending the beautiful song with a high powerful note kinda ruined it a little... Would have said a lot more to end softly.. I agree 100% sadly.. Good point.

  • oh I dont know, it defenitly changes the feel of the song but lets remeber that this isnt an opera its american idol. I see your point, but I kind of like how he changed it up and I'm like the biggest Phantom fan ever so... yeah. on that note, the only thing that bugs me is the lyrics to the song are

    "floating, falling sweet intoxication"

    he said "falling, floating sweet intoxcation"

    that just irritated me a little. but enthralling spectacular preformance and I agree, I'm so glad he won

  • 1:10. awesome.

  • i love it when he sings " i write"

    he truly gives yuh goosebumps :]

  • 'Let your darker side give in.'

    I really wish I could...

  • so powerful and tender.

    *g*o*o*s*e*b*u*m*p*s*

  • Randy made a comment one night that David is a rocker and should sing rock songs. excuse me but does that mean that a rocker shouldn't aspire to be anything but a rocker??!! boy does this song prove Randy wrong. great going David!

  • too true!

  • i know, seriously!

  • I love anyone singing Music of the Night, it's my favorite song! He did very well on this, very modern, love it. <3

  • ohmigod i almost cried during that. it's beautiful

  • HIS VOICE IS BEAUTIFUL

  • I really think he should consider broadway.

  • O.O omg that was just sooo....... amazing.....

  • the phantom of the opera is sooo good singed by him ^^

  • I ♥ him. This song is so amazing. He makes it sound so HOT. he is wayyyy better and I'm glad he won. =)

  • please look at my other videos of David Cook, the new American Idol, and tell me what you guys think, oh and tell me what you think about my profile

  • i love him.

  • chack out my other videos of David Cook's performances in American Idol

  • honestly when i heard that he was going to sing this song i thought he was going to kill the song,, but boy was u wrong, my jaw drop when i heard him sing and now i have it on my ipod...

  • David Cook's numbers tonight are:

    866-436-5701

    866-436-5703

    866-436-5705

    please vote..it does not cost any money, btw!

  • cool

  • i can rili feel his soul in dis song...

  • I LOOOOVE David Cook! I and got this song after he sang it, and he sounds better than the guy who sang it for "The Phantom of the Opera". I seriously hope he wins. The sad thing is that it is basically a popularity contest. David C. is a much better singer than David A.

  • HE WILL WIN. YES!

    i am just worried.

  • wow o my goodness this guy will win i mean it he is amazing i love him!

  • i can still never forget this! he SHOULD win but...

    (i hate him though) archaletta is going to win because it is just a popularyity contest.

    ~tear~ :(

  • WOW i lvoe love loved this!!! i so want him to win now!!!!!! i still like Gerard Butler better though

  • OMG!!!! SOOOOOOOOO AMAZING! HE WAS SERIOUSLY AWESOME!!!! kinda pop-ish but still WOW!

  • Good video. I like it when ppl just cut the video right to the singing.

  • DC is all kinds of awesome.

    Rock on, babe.

  • I LOVED him on this song! you go david!

  • u know what fuck u. u are just jealous of him. He is part of my family, maybe. We both have the last name cook so I'm defending the family name. we are all charming AND rockers. u r just an asshole bitch

  • I think I'm in love!! haha XD that was Amazing! (He should win)