I hate the fact they overdubbed it, she did lip some parts, but it was mostly live. 3:24 for example, was live, and it's easy to hear the difference between that and the rest of the song.
@TopVersnelling Pay close attention. The video itself has been flipped. Not the audio. Notice the ABC logo is backwards as well as the ending credits.
@zmienna77 Mariah Carey is only human. Her weight fluctuates as does ours. And for the record, she is slim. Get your facts straight and do a little research befor posting such nonsense comments.. Being thin or thick doesn't matter worth a shit. Mariah could be obese and everyone will still love her. Who cares? Oh wait, did I mention this woman just had TWINS? Did you even know? Well now you do. Go to mariah daily dot com and drool over her 2011 skinny pics now:) Cuz thats what she is.
Great video! I actualy did a piano cover of this song on my channel. Doesn't have many views at all yet but I want to get the work out about it. I think its one of the better versions out there. Please check it out and let me know what you think. Hope you all have a Merry Christmas
@PastCineo yeah and she had a lot of life threatenning complications during pregnancy as well which made it neccessary for her to deliver those adorable babies prematurely at 35 weeks. some people ned to realize it's harder for a woman to sing when she's pregnant because the growing uterus compresses the lungs so it's harter to breathe
@ MrPul: yeah that awkward moment when sings like a super star as always, you should take some of your time to check on your grammar instead of being a HATER on here...
David foster envy us pinoys coz d best DIVA in the world is not found in there homeland it is in the philippines and it is regine velasquez. americans cannot accept that regine is the best DIVA in the world. even mariah or celine dion are no body compared to our song bird. David foster and oprah r only using charice to confuse us filipinos. THAT CHARICE IS WORLD CLASS SINGER BUT NO WAY! TRYING TO SHOW US THAT THEY APPRECIATE CHARICE AND NOT REGINE? they cannot fool us. MARIAH LOSTS HER VOICE!
@MrChrismaniego Regine is obviously a very good singer but she's not in the line of Mariah &she will never be.neither as a singer nor as a songwriter..Mariah's voice versatility is unique and her range is still amazing.Mariah knows how to beautify her songs and notes with her awesome voice and talent.Regine just knows how to belt..Don't keep on saying things like that cause it makes you sound jealous.Just respect and admire Mariah like Regine does.got it?
im a huge Mimi fan but this is not live. shes lipping to a prerecorded backing track...but she has been singing for over 20 yrs so she has earned the right to lip every now and then lol. love u mariah!
@dc3fan2003 Then you don't know wth you're saying! The concert is dubbed but this performance is live!
Parts of the song you can visually see that she is singing live unless you're retarded( there are many more but I have no patience) are
0:34-0:43, 0:50-0:52, 1:10-1:11, 1:18-1:28 the list goes on. She looks very comfortable singing this song and not cause it's lipped but because she's just doin her thing and enjoying herself.
@cersus trust me sir...i have every album shes ever made. im a fanatic. so i know a lipped mariah carey performance when i see and hear one. and this, my friend, is a lipped performance to a pre-recorded live backing track. theres no shame in it cuz like i mentioned previously..she has earned the right to lip every now and then. but to be in denial that she is singing this live is ignorant
@dc3fan2003 That's great! I know when she lips also and the one thing I do agree with you on, is that she can lip whenever she needs to w/o giving excuses or thinking twice. Her songs are ridiculously hard to sing especially in her key and very strenuous to her vocal chords. BUT this performance is LIVE! There's no denial whatsoever..when she lips, I almost always see it and I just don't say anything cause I don't care.
this was live however She has admitted to going back into the studio and dubbing her vocals because she is a perfectionist. This was shot last Oct/Nov but aired in December...
David foster envy us pinoys coz d best DIVA in the world is not found in there homeland it is in the phil. and it is regine velasquez. americans cannot accept that regine is the best DIVA in the world. even mariah or celine dion are no body compared to our song bird. David foster and oprah r only using charice to confuse us filipinos. THAT CHARICE IS WORLD CLASS SINGER BUT NO WAY! TRYING TO SHOW US THAT THEY APPRECIATE CHARICE AND NOT REGINE? they cannot fool us. MARIAH LOSTS HER VOICE!
You know you're a good singer when other people find it hard to believe that the beautiful sounds they are hearing are actually coming out of your mouth.
she should stop using autotune. Damnit Mariah, you used to be so great!
Anyway, I think the E5 she hit at 3:25 was live, because she laughed right after it and it sounded "connected" to the note. Part of this was live, but that stupid autotune backtrack ruined it.
@imafan123456 it really sounds like autotune to me. And anyway she's been using quite a lot of autotune lately. For example her whistles in "o come all ye faithful" are REALLY fake
@bixxius The only whistle that I would of said was adjusted in some way is the one in 'Oh Santa'. Autotune has a more jarring sound. Maybe you mean filters? Sorry, I don't mean to sound patronising, I just don't think she's done anything that devious.
@imafan123456 the one in O Come All Ye Faithful really sound fake to me...I really like the fact that you didn't immediately start insulting me, i really appreciate it.
@bixxius I guess this performance was overdubbed, but she was also lipsynching some parts, for example at 2:21 she hit an E5, sounding strained, but her face didn't show any sign of strain. Even in her prime that didn't happen.
Who gives a fuck if she sung it live its her goddamn song she sung it live before and im pretty sure this one isnt completely lipped. Regardless if she sung it live or not she was paid millions to be there so why are we getting all worked up over nothing.
@24mik She's not acting it like it's live singing.. It's really live. If you think about it, she badly lipped all performances in all her careers and now suddenly she can act on lipping? I don't think so. Is that make sense? =) Just a thought.
0:18 secods pa lang STANDING O na sila.... kaya na STAY IN LOVE ako sa boses nya.... OBSESSED na yung iba sa kanya... kasi isang tingin pa lang sa kanya parang ONE SWEET DAY na.......... napapa SHAKE IT OFF ako sa galing nya..... masasabi kong OH HOLY NIGHT ang gabi ko.... grabe parang syang HERO..... kaya kong makinig ng mga songs kahit THROUGH THE RAIN.... the end.......
Girls Generation were singing too!!
angle26571 4 weeks ago
wOw mariah is so fat, on clip Justin Bieber is very hot !
JuuriKO62 1 month ago
@JuuriKO62 she was pregnant...with TWINS..that's why she looks fat here!
debmonfre 1 month ago
wow, she sure is amazing. this would have been amazing to see live!!
TheTeaguin 1 month ago
was this recorded in xmas 2010?
TheTeaguin 1 month ago
I hate the fact they overdubbed it, she did lip some parts, but it was mostly live. 3:24 for example, was live, and it's easy to hear the difference between that and the rest of the song.
bixxius 2 months ago
@bixxius is live ,all.
perroelectrocutado 1 month ago
Comment removed
eduramos2 2 months ago
"SORRY ITS BACKWARDS! Had to do that so it wouldnt get blocked."
I don't get it. Music 'n video are fine...
TopVersnelling 2 months ago
@TopVersnelling Pay close attention. The video itself has been flipped. Not the audio. Notice the ABC logo is backwards as well as the ending credits.
MimisMan85 2 months ago
@MimisMan85 She used to be slim ... and now she is fat and her official web side shows something difereent ... photoshop ... sad thing........... :-(
zmienna77 2 months ago
@zmienna77 Mariah Carey is only human. Her weight fluctuates as does ours. And for the record, she is slim. Get your facts straight and do a little research befor posting such nonsense comments.. Being thin or thick doesn't matter worth a shit. Mariah could be obese and everyone will still love her. Who cares? Oh wait, did I mention this woman just had TWINS? Did you even know? Well now you do. Go to mariah daily dot com and drool over her 2011 skinny pics now:) Cuz thats what she is.
MimisMan85 2 months ago
@zmienna77 she was pregnant -_-
luc1880 2 months ago
Your an idiot! She was pregnant! & now she has lost all her baby weight & more. & looking great :)
999xander999 1 week ago
@zmienna77 Dude, she was pregnant when she made this show!
teganjovanka 1 week ago
Yes, MC can still sing!
KennyCrazy1 2 months ago
Great video! I actualy did a piano cover of this song on my channel. Doesn't have many views at all yet but I want to get the work out about it. I think its one of the better versions out there. Please check it out and let me know what you think. Hope you all have a Merry Christmas
rickiller59 2 months ago
You must watch the cover video of Vazquez Sounds for this song, is so amazing!!!
JUJO4588 2 months ago
Sure wish the audio level was higher... !!!
tracer740 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Confiram a versão da Música "Emanuel" do grupo voices feita por mim ;D
/watch?v=R_8HYU9W3MY
The1JE 2 months ago
.....wow.....the off beat clapping...
Istrawberrystarburst 2 months ago 4
@PastCineo yeah and she had a lot of life threatenning complications during pregnancy as well which made it neccessary for her to deliver those adorable babies prematurely at 35 weeks. some people ned to realize it's harder for a woman to sing when she's pregnant because the growing uterus compresses the lungs so it's harter to breathe
caligirl5285 2 months ago
That gingerbread man costume weirds me out
salasep 2 months ago
@ MrPul: yeah that awkward moment when sings like a super star as always, you should take some of your time to check on your grammar instead of being a HATER on here...
veronicafaasavalu 2 months ago 2
Comment removed
veronicafaasavalu 2 months ago
Where can I download this concert?
MNdivaaaa 2 months ago
/watch?v=8HyZle1Vv5c&feature=g-all
michael4546 2 months ago
That awkward moment when she looks like she ate santa. And had his reindeers for dessert.
MrPul 2 months ago
@MrPul well she was pregnant with twins, what did you expect?
pastcineo 2 months ago
@MrPul that awkward moment when you realize that your mom looked twice as big as she does when she carried your fat ass inside her womb.
truongphan90 2 months ago
@MrPul That awkward moment when someone didn't know Mariah was pregnant and gave stupid comments.
BBQJester 2 months ago
christmas mode activated
SuperMorolake 2 months ago 10
she's been singing for decades , people. Mimi just needs to rest her voice and it's ok again. this is perfection, Ms. Mariah! 'Love you!!!
MsDolo08 3 months ago 3
It really confused me when the credits were backwards... I thought it was foreign.. Nope.. I'm just a bit stupid. Lol. x
Higglewigglebiggle 3 months ago
@Higglewigglebiggle FLIP IT TO AVOID COPYRIGHT
antsthlondon 2 months ago
the sync issue is about piracy..lol...of course she is live!
Thenirvana71 3 months ago
this is live. it's just so dubbed, you can't fuckin tell.
GrimandBright 3 months ago
i can't wait!!
tynulkaaa 3 months ago
David foster envy us pinoys coz d best DIVA in the world is not found in there homeland it is in the philippines and it is regine velasquez. americans cannot accept that regine is the best DIVA in the world. even mariah or celine dion are no body compared to our song bird. David foster and oprah r only using charice to confuse us filipinos. THAT CHARICE IS WORLD CLASS SINGER BUT NO WAY! TRYING TO SHOW US THAT THEY APPRECIATE CHARICE AND NOT REGINE? they cannot fool us. MARIAH LOSTS HER VOICE!
MrChrismaniego 3 months ago
@MrChrismaniego Regine is obviously a very good singer but she's not in the line of Mariah &she will never be.neither as a singer nor as a songwriter..Mariah's voice versatility is unique and her range is still amazing.Mariah knows how to beautify her songs and notes with her awesome voice and talent.Regine just knows how to belt..Don't keep on saying things like that cause it makes you sound jealous.Just respect and admire Mariah like Regine does.got it?
felo4444 3 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@felo4444 AHHHH! DONT BE STUPID!!! MARIAH LOSTS HER VOICE AND WILL DIE SOON. SEE HOW SHE SINGS, ALWAYS CATCHING HER BREATH. BWAHAHA!
MrChrismaniego 3 months ago
im a huge Mimi fan but this is not live. shes lipping to a prerecorded backing track...but she has been singing for over 20 yrs so she has earned the right to lip every now and then lol. love u mariah!
dc3fan2003 3 months ago
@dc3fan2003 Then you don't know wth you're saying! The concert is dubbed but this performance is live!
Parts of the song you can visually see that she is singing live unless you're retarded( there are many more but I have no patience) are
0:34-0:43, 0:50-0:52, 1:10-1:11, 1:18-1:28 the list goes on. She looks very comfortable singing this song and not cause it's lipped but because she's just doin her thing and enjoying herself.
cersus 3 months ago 2
@cersus trust me sir...i have every album shes ever made. im a fanatic. so i know a lipped mariah carey performance when i see and hear one. and this, my friend, is a lipped performance to a pre-recorded live backing track. theres no shame in it cuz like i mentioned previously..she has earned the right to lip every now and then. but to be in denial that she is singing this live is ignorant
dc3fan2003 3 months ago
@dc3fan2003 That's great! I know when she lips also and the one thing I do agree with you on, is that she can lip whenever she needs to w/o giving excuses or thinking twice. Her songs are ridiculously hard to sing especially in her key and very strenuous to her vocal chords. BUT this performance is LIVE! There's no denial whatsoever..when she lips, I almost always see it and I just don't say anything cause I don't care.
cersus 3 months ago
@cersus its not live lol. but lets just agree on the fact that we both love mariah lol
dc3fan2003 3 months ago
@dc3fan2003 it IS live .
RUHTARD
trybeeMUSIC 3 months ago
@dc3fan2003 you are right!!But we love Mariah anyways.i'm gonna stay her fan till i die!
felo4444 3 months ago
@felo4444 same here. i love her still
dc3fan2003 3 months ago
love u mariah UR THE BEST
CyprusHot 3 months ago
everytime i hear this song i think of my bf and it brings me to tears
ItalianMama66 3 months ago
fab mariah you still got it girl the best voice in the world !!!!!!
bendybaz 3 months ago
This diva bitch makes me soooo jelly xD (jelly= jealous)
CmOn808 3 months ago
Queen of Christmas!!!! =)
MariahCareyAngel1 3 months ago 2
100% live! I was there!
playback : when christmas come
peliferj100 4 months ago
Why are all the backup dancers/singers and the people that play the instruments black?
SM114V 4 months ago
@SM114V thats her vrew she dont hate white people, shes close with her backup singers/dancers.......the lambs know they quite well now
TheGaybtm18md 4 months ago
this was live however She has admitted to going back into the studio and dubbing her vocals because she is a perfectionist. This was shot last Oct/Nov but aired in December...
eastcoastthriller 4 months ago
@eastcoastthriller LOL when did she admit that!?
iiAmitx3 4 months ago
1 person is not goin to get anything for christmas!!
victorious2115 4 months ago 2
are you people stupid she lipped part of it for her own safety and that of her unborn children
dembabydolls 5 months ago
lip sync
wjaniban12 5 months ago
this performance was pure live she doesnt need to lip sing she sounds just like she did when she wrote this
TheMeek24 5 months ago
hell yeah, queen of festiveness :D
pastcineo 5 months ago
is that @goonieman86 nick pitera at 2:16?
neinsager 5 months ago
i Love it..:))
GhenMariahyonce1995 6 months ago
Hit like if it you are watching this video in the summer just like I do now! :P
IldikoLaDiva 6 months ago 56
This has been flagged as spam show
David foster envy us pinoys coz d best DIVA in the world is not found in there homeland it is in the phil. and it is regine velasquez. americans cannot accept that regine is the best DIVA in the world. even mariah or celine dion are no body compared to our song bird. David foster and oprah r only using charice to confuse us filipinos. THAT CHARICE IS WORLD CLASS SINGER BUT NO WAY! TRYING TO SHOW US THAT THEY APPRECIATE CHARICE AND NOT REGINE? they cannot fool us. MARIAH LOSTS HER VOICE!
MrChrismaniego 3 months ago
You know you're a good singer when other people find it hard to believe that the beautiful sounds they are hearing are actually coming out of your mouth.
DOwnLee1 6 months ago 7
@ilovemariah124 i agree!
the09conradz 7 months ago
You can tell this one is pure live!! COME ON!!
cersus 7 months ago 46
@cersus Your Right This Is Live... DEFINATELY.. FOR A FACT! Jus Ask the People Who Went To The Tapping!!
MCJMC1 3 months ago
@MCJMC1 Yeah, you can tell it is.
cersus 3 months ago
This is LIVE! and Mariah is fantabulous!!!
MCMCMCMCMCMCMCMC!!!!
cersus 7 months ago
she should stop using autotune. Damnit Mariah, you used to be so great!
Anyway, I think the E5 she hit at 3:25 was live, because she laughed right after it and it sounded "connected" to the note. Part of this was live, but that stupid autotune backtrack ruined it.
bixxius 8 months ago
Comment removed
imafan123456 8 months ago
@bixxius What do you mean? No autotune is used... They've used a filter over the backtrack vocals, but not autotune.
imafan123456 8 months ago
Comment removed
bixxius 8 months ago
@imafan123456 it really sounds like autotune to me. And anyway she's been using quite a lot of autotune lately. For example her whistles in "o come all ye faithful" are REALLY fake
bixxius 8 months ago
@bixxius The only whistle that I would of said was adjusted in some way is the one in 'Oh Santa'. Autotune has a more jarring sound. Maybe you mean filters? Sorry, I don't mean to sound patronising, I just don't think she's done anything that devious.
imafan123456 8 months ago
@imafan123456 the one in O Come All Ye Faithful really sound fake to me...I really like the fact that you didn't immediately start insulting me, i really appreciate it.
bixxius 7 months ago
@bixxius I guess this performance was overdubbed, but she was also lipsynching some parts, for example at 2:21 she hit an E5, sounding strained, but her face didn't show any sign of strain. Even in her prime that didn't happen.
bixxius 7 months ago
@bixxius She wasn't lip syncing. What do you think dubbed is?
Raimundo91 5 months ago
@imafan123456 u confuse mariah with miley. miley needs to sing MARIAHS song autotuned, mariah can sing her own songs!
296218047 7 months ago
@296218047 Err what?
imafan123456 7 months ago
I was there and she was singing live.
taylorsmilez5 8 months ago
@taylorsmilez5 so can you confirm that they have over-dubbed it too much?
Judgeyy 8 months ago
@Judgeyy hell yeah
taylorsmilez5 8 months ago
abc did such a horrible job dubbing this performance -.-
hessounusual95 8 months ago
Es y sera siempre la mas grande te amo Mariah
alekguerrero 9 months ago
Who gives a fuck if she sung it live its her goddamn song she sung it live before and im pretty sure this one isnt completely lipped. Regardless if she sung it live or not she was paid millions to be there so why are we getting all worked up over nothing.
Tigga212 1 year ago 2
Loved this performance; I like how the musicians in the background just couldn't help it and started dancing in the end... lol. Soooo cute.
arinyfeehily 1 year ago
She's acting live singing very good :) Love the song !
24mik 1 year ago
@24mik She's not acting it like it's live singing.. It's really live. If you think about it, she badly lipped all performances in all her careers and now suddenly she can act on lipping? I don't think so. Is that make sense? =) Just a thought.
stewardlie 10 months ago
ABC DUBBED HER BEAUTIFUL VOICE FOR QUALITY
chesleycareystar 1 year ago
She is singing it in original key! :)))))) She used to always sing half a key lower during her concerts :)))))))
realthingrey82 1 year ago
all i really really want it hehehe love it
h0nie24 1 year ago
just accept the fact that mariah's strong n powerful n sweet vocals r bck, this time for real!!!!!!
dbly88888888 1 year ago
this is totally live plzzz, all of you all who said that this isnt live, maybe u shuld dig ur ears!!!
dbly88888888 1 year ago
If this is live I'm typing this from the dead .........
adamps16 1 year ago
0:18 secods pa lang STANDING O na sila.... kaya na STAY IN LOVE ako sa boses nya.... OBSESSED na yung iba sa kanya... kasi isang tingin pa lang sa kanya parang ONE SWEET DAY na.......... napapa SHAKE IT OFF ako sa galing nya..... masasabi kong OH HOLY NIGHT ang gabi ko.... grabe parang syang HERO..... kaya kong makinig ng mga songs kahit THROUGH THE RAIN.... the end.......
hihiwitchi 1 year ago
why is this listed under "live"? yes everyone is alive...i think... but this was hardly performed with live vocals.
hootied 1 year ago
I love Mariah!
But it couldve been better with the intro....
mclambglitters 1 year ago 2
I love Mariah!
mclambglitters 1 year ago
Comment removed
blackforest 1 year ago
@blackforest What do you mean?
MimisMan85 1 year ago
@blackforest This is her most famous Christmas song what do you mean???
bewander 1 year ago