It is a great video. Much better than the common one. One of the best Nautilus songs, indeed. By the way, it has an alternate mix of the song (I dont' know where it comes from, but it is different from the version that's on the Foreign Land album and in the other video).
The lyrics may be interpreted in various ways. And it is great.
to each it's own... That is the bottom line of the song. Andrey was invited to the cross, but he could not achieve, what Christ went through...Being a human, Andrey takes fish from the water, that is the destiny of human. If he would die on the cross, meaning, living his life with the greater purpose, and dying for it, he will not need to know the secret, because this is the secret. He is called fool for it, for just not being capable to live and die with the purpose. I think....
Someone who wants to save others, should be ready to sacrifice themselves. That's what this song. And this is what was trying to say Savior and then Andrew could not understand. In metaphor.
@kblcuk Andrey can not believe that ...Solders have "corns of devil" ! So Jesus is angry BECAUSE Andrey doesn't believe in god + Andrey can not love people with sin.
Walks on water = it's eternity with Jesus ! it's a trust on God and love.
this song gives an explanation of a biblical episode of crucifixion and that Jesus continued to love us.
@kblcuk Во-первых не дураком, а чудаком. Сердится по тому, что он хочет получить все так просто, а просто в нашей жизни нечего не бывает (по этому и сердится). Он не предлагает убить себя, а "повисеть на кресте". Под "повисеть на кресте" подразумевается гораздо большее и это большее для каждого своё. Для меня например это маленькая жертва для чего очень грандиозного. Но опять же кто как понимает текст песни.
can somebody please tell me what this song means, I have read the translation, but why does Jesus call the man a fool? and get angry? And what does he mean "hang on the cross"? kill himself?
Andrew is comparing himself to The Savior, and asks him what's the secret to become like him.
So The Savior tells him that there is no secret, or basically, shows him that there is a place for everyone in the world, and that you can't become something without making the proper sacrifice. I think the proof of that, is that he didn't mention his name was Jesus, but rather The Savior, meaning he already have achieved this status.
Not at all, Jesus was angry because of the fact that Andrew not to understand the truth. In life there are no easy ways and not all knowledge (secrets) can convey in words. Many things can be learned only experienced at first hand. Therefore, Jesus and says ... To understand me you need to go my way ... to be humiliated, disgraced, dead ... and forgive all the people ... take care of all their sins ... and become a saint ... only and not the other way
@heylo232 I want to explain you a song. Apostle Andrey fished and has seen, how Jesus went on water and rescued the lost people. Andrey begged the savior to open to it a secret - how to do these miracles. Jesus has answered it that in it there is no miracle. He speaks: "you See, there on a grief a cross, hang on it. And when will bother, come to me, to walk on water together".
@heylo232 So here you have a lot of metaphorical phrases ...Jesus who saves people from the" sea" - it's a salvation after death - He saves our souls!
Andrey wants to follow Jesus he asks his secret - How to Love those who crucified you?
Jesus says ; There is no secret ! You see the cross? Under the cross there are solders! hang on the cross -> sacrifice everything for them - hang on the cross - Love them!
Andrei takes walking on the water miracle for some trick, when he asks about 'the secret', he wants the explanation of the trick. The god's answer is ironical/sarcastic - 'the trick is simple, go hang for a while on the cross, and when you're bored of hanging - come to me and we will go for a walk on the water'.
@heylo232 to each it's own... That is the bottom line of the song. Andrey was invited to the cross, but he could not achieve, what Christ went through...Being a human, Andrey takes fish from the water, that is the destiny of human. If he would die on the cross, meaning, living his life with the greater purpose, and dying for it, he will not need to know the secret, because this is the secret. He is called fool for it, for just not being capable to live and die with the purpose. I think....
@heylo232 This is probably a little late, but Andrei wants to learn how to walk on water, and Jesus tells him to go hang on the cross, and when he gets tired he can come back and walk on water with him. The thing is, that's crucifixion, after the first chorus Andrei tells Jesus to spare an idiot, teach him the secret later, and he'll hang on the cross later. Jesus is speechless, kicks him, and remarks that he probably is stupid. The moral is that basically you need hard work to get things. Tada!
@heylo232 IMHO, the meaning of the song is, that man should overcome many difficulties, prove that his soul is clear to be saint (to join the Jesus). He called Andrey a foul, because Andrey was impatient, he didn't want face any difficulties, just became saint instantly, so Jesus got angry. "Hang on the cross" means do smth hard, what can prove your trust.
I believe my explanation will be helpful for somebody.
@heylo232 i think "hang on the cross" means here that before be a saint you must became a martyr. In case of Jesus be crucified.So here "hang on the cross" means be crucified.
Andrew wanted Jesus to tell him the secret, how he could walk on water. Jesus said that there is a hill, and there a cross, surrounded by soldiers, if Andrew will be crucified, then after some time he will return and will be able to walk on water.Andrew said that he is a fool and wants to know answer without be tortured.
@thekillerfoxable not Andrew, It was Jesus who got angry and said: "You really are a fool" as the answer to Andrew's request: "Tell me now [about the secret], teacher, spare a fool and forget about the cross for a while ".
Apostle Andrei fished from the harbor And the Savior walked on water And Andrei took gudgeons out of water And the Savior of lost people And Andrei cried I shall leave the harbor if you reveal the secret to me And the Savior answered: Settle down, Andrei, there is no secret here see there on the mountain towers a cross under it ten soldiers, hang on it and when you get bored come back to walk on water, to walk on water to walk on water with me
Нет, это именно другая версия, другое исполнение, а не только качество звука. Другой голос (в смысле Бутусова, но более ранний), другие интонации, и вместо "и Андрей в слезах" он поёт "и Андрей зарыдав".
It is a great video. Much better than the common one. One of the best Nautilus songs, indeed. By the way, it has an alternate mix of the song (I dont' know where it comes from, but it is different from the version that's on the Foreign Land album and in the other video).
The lyrics may be interpreted in various ways. And it is great.
CutToSleep 7 months ago
to each it's own... That is the bottom line of the song. Andrey was invited to the cross, but he could not achieve, what Christ went through...Being a human, Andrey takes fish from the water, that is the destiny of human. If he would die on the cross, meaning, living his life with the greater purpose, and dying for it, he will not need to know the secret, because this is the secret. He is called fool for it, for just not being capable to live and die with the purpose. I think....
nataliapopova 8 months ago
It means that the person should go a narrow way to paradise. By sufferings and deprivations. By struggle with itself. With powers of darkness...
To be crucified on a cross-means work for rescue of the soul.
ruas70 11 months ago
моя любимая песьня!
Deraleksander 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Someone who wants to save others, should be ready to sacrifice themselves. That's what this song. And this is what was trying to say Savior and then Andrew could not understand. In metaphor.
targetAccepted 1 year ago
Comment removed
targetAccepted 1 year ago
Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ
DieKaiserin13 1 year ago 3
@DieKaiserin13 ?
kblcuk 1 year ago
@kblcuk
elbrus714 1 year ago
@kblcuk Andrey can not believe that ...Solders have "corns of devil" ! So Jesus is angry BECAUSE Andrey doesn't believe in god + Andrey can not love people with sin.
Walks on water = it's eternity with Jesus ! it's a trust on God and love.
this song gives an explanation of a biblical episode of crucifixion and that Jesus continued to love us.
Marina42539 11 months ago
@kblcuk Во-первых не дураком, а чудаком. Сердится по тому, что он хочет получить все так просто, а просто в нашей жизни нечего не бывает (по этому и сердится). Он не предлагает убить себя, а "повисеть на кресте". Под "повисеть на кресте" подразумевается гораздо большее и это большее для каждого своё. Для меня например это маленькая жертва для чего очень грандиозного. Но опять же кто как понимает текст песни.
TeplovozMen 3 months ago
@TeplovozMen Может быть и так.
kblcuk 3 months ago
ГЕНИАЛЬНО!! еще молодой он тут)) искренний
ALGRIUM 1 year ago
can somebody please tell me what this song means, I have read the translation, but why does Jesus call the man a fool? and get angry? And what does he mean "hang on the cross"? kill himself?
heylo232 1 year ago 3
@heylo232 It's a bit hard to find "what does author mean". Each persons understanding of lyrics differs.
As for "hang on the cross", it probably stands for "become a saint", crucified... I think so.
Which translation did you read, btw?
kblcuk 1 year ago
@kblcuk i'm just wondering what andrew means by "tell me the secret" and why Jesus tells him to go hang on the cross.
heylo232 1 year ago
@heylo232 Probably Andrei wants to know, how Jesus is walking on water :)
kblcuk 1 year ago
@heylo232
I can tell you that is all about faith.
He tells Andrew to go and hang on a cross to test him.
blinkyuee 1 year ago
@kblcuk he means that you have to 'hang on the cross', to suffer, in order to be able to walk on water and save people, that its the price to pay
norimmel 1 year ago
@heylo232 It's very simple actually.
Andrew is comparing himself to The Savior, and asks him what's the secret to become like him.
So The Savior tells him that there is no secret, or basically, shows him that there is a place for everyone in the world, and that you can't become something without making the proper sacrifice. I think the proof of that, is that he didn't mention his name was Jesus, but rather The Savior, meaning he already have achieved this status.
DdoommakerR 3 months ago
@heylo232 Перевод: русский > английский
Not at all, Jesus was angry because of the fact that Andrew not to understand the truth. In life there are no easy ways and not all knowledge (secrets) can convey in words. Many things can be learned only experienced at first hand. Therefore, Jesus and says ... To understand me you need to go my way ... to be humiliated, disgraced, dead ... and forgive all the people ... take care of all their sins ... and become a saint ... only and not the other way
ioruta 1 year ago
@ioruta thanks man, i never actually figured it out until now, wow, that's beautiful... thanks again :)
heylo232 1 year ago
@heylo232 I want to explain you a song. Apostle Andrey fished and has seen, how Jesus went on water and rescued the lost people. Andrey begged the savior to open to it a secret - how to do these miracles. Jesus has answered it that in it there is no miracle. He speaks: "you See, there on a grief a cross, hang on it. And when will bother, come to me, to walk on water together".
Mari7264 11 months ago
@heylo232 So here you have a lot of metaphorical phrases ...Jesus who saves people from the" sea" - it's a salvation after death - He saves our souls!
Andrey wants to follow Jesus he asks his secret - How to Love those who crucified you?
Jesus says ; There is no secret ! You see the cross? Under the cross there are solders! hang on the cross -> sacrifice everything for them - hang on the cross - Love them!
Marina42539 11 months ago
@heylo232
Andrei takes walking on the water miracle for some trick, when he asks about 'the secret', he wants the explanation of the trick. The god's answer is ironical/sarcastic - 'the trick is simple, go hang for a while on the cross, and when you're bored of hanging - come to me and we will go for a walk on the water'.
11111111001101 10 months ago
@heylo232 to each it's own... That is the bottom line of the song. Andrey was invited to the cross, but he could not achieve, what Christ went through...Being a human, Andrey takes fish from the water, that is the destiny of human. If he would die on the cross, meaning, living his life with the greater purpose, and dying for it, he will not need to know the secret, because this is the secret. He is called fool for it, for just not being capable to live and die with the purpose. I think....
nataliapopova 8 months ago
@heylo232 This is probably a little late, but Andrei wants to learn how to walk on water, and Jesus tells him to go hang on the cross, and when he gets tired he can come back and walk on water with him. The thing is, that's crucifixion, after the first chorus Andrei tells Jesus to spare an idiot, teach him the secret later, and he'll hang on the cross later. Jesus is speechless, kicks him, and remarks that he probably is stupid. The moral is that basically you need hard work to get things. Tada!
DamienJackal 8 months ago
@heylo232 IMHO, the meaning of the song is, that man should overcome many difficulties, prove that his soul is clear to be saint (to join the Jesus). He called Andrey a foul, because Andrey was impatient, he didn't want face any difficulties, just became saint instantly, so Jesus got angry. "Hang on the cross" means do smth hard, what can prove your trust.
I believe my explanation will be helpful for somebody.
GlebMozgolom11 7 months ago 2
@heylo232 it means only that you will be able to walk on water after you hang some time on that cross (like Christ did).
niagarah7 7 months ago
@heylo232 i think "hang on the cross" means here that before be a saint you must became a martyr. In case of Jesus be crucified.So here "hang on the cross" means be crucified.
Andrew wanted Jesus to tell him the secret, how he could walk on water. Jesus said that there is a hill, and there a cross, surrounded by soldiers, if Andrew will be crucified, then after some time he will return and will be able to walk on water.Andrew said that he is a fool and wants to know answer without be tortured.
thekillerfoxable 7 months ago
@thekillerfoxable not Andrew, It was Jesus who got angry and said: "You really are a fool" as the answer to Andrew's request: "Tell me now [about the secret], teacher, spare a fool and forget about the cross for a while ".
malicesgossips 5 months ago
@heylo232 because no body cand do something without experience .Jesus want give a
chance Andrey for a gift Andrey was a fool and cant understand that He can only cantching a fish
Sorry bad eng im from ukraine)
floyd840 4 months ago
6 человек промахнулись по кнопке )))
McDonkeyDance 1 year ago 2
@McDonkeyDance Хехе, не иначе ((%
kblcuk 1 year ago 2
@McDonkeyDance Я попал)
7apaHouk 1 year ago
pesnya detstva,...skol'ko let etu versiyu iskala!!! spasibo
LadyOfSchranzZz 1 year ago
помню когда эту песню первый раз услышала...аж онемела, настолько понравилась...а еще "Князь тишины".... автор молодец....побольше бы таких песен...
Lynnetka 1 year ago
Я любил эту песню когда был маленький.
dolphin1911 1 year ago
клип слабый,но самое обидное-искажение голоса Бутусова, критиковать конечно просто,90-е ,всё понятно-НО...
hronos69 1 year ago
lyublyu etu pesnyu
bfung1972 1 year ago
Какой он молодой ещё в клипе то!
juggels2000 2 years ago
@juggels2000, так клипу двадцать лет уже. Конечно молодой (:
kblcuk 2 years ago
15 лет назад мой кореш исполнял эту тему на гитаре, щас услышал опять,супер. где он щас хз. Эх хорошее время было.
автору зачет.
bogatir1 2 years ago 5
это лучшее средство поймать кайф
Sergej607 2 years ago 2
огромное спасибо
amigoarg 2 years ago 2
спосиво вам огромноe...
Vermenigvuldiging 2 years ago 4
давно искала именно этот клип, эту видеоверсию песни! спасибо!!!!
elfiya 2 years ago 7
Не за что (:
kblcuk 2 years ago
Спасибо!!!
MsCelt 2 years ago 7
Спасибо тебе ! Нау бессмертен...
Stranger960 2 years ago 13
garver4 2 years ago 41
But Teacher, horns shine on the helmets
A black raven circles above the cross
Tell me now, pity the fool,
and leave the crucifixion for later
The Savior was stunned and stomped
On the waters surface with his foot
You truly are a fool and Andrei in tears
went on home.
garver4 2 years ago 19
супер супер супер! большое спасибо из америки
arkhangelsk 2 years ago 10
i love nautilus pomelius songs. they are my childhood! thank you!!!
moohavamp567 2 years ago 3
Музыка со смыслом, который можно понять в отличии от попсы.
sausagerus 2 years ago 15
Nautilus eto konechno russkiy rock god. Posle Kino i Tsoya konecheno. DDT toje tyda vhodit, Agata Kristi toje mojet.
DinaStrange 2 years ago 2
Илье Кормильцеву вечная память.
viorel4ik7 2 years ago 16
Илье Кормильцеву вечная память.
Ssykun 2 years ago 15
Красавчики! натурально одни из воздвиженцев супер музыки и слов!
tepitametr 2 years ago 5
Великолепная песня!
DuekBJ 2 years ago 11
Все песни Наутилуса- это нечто!!
AlinkaUkrainka 2 years ago 9
В Золотой фонд его песни!
dilyara04poland 3 years ago 28
А кто объяснит почему к песне гудбай америка отключены комментарии?!
Что за нафик?!
klouns9 3 years ago
То видео загружал не я, отключал комменты, соответственно, тоже. Так что даже и не знаю (:
kblcuk 3 years ago
хорошая песня...
kibitka 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Красноярск рулит
barhatowo 3 years ago
Отлично
saatol12 3 years ago
Рок - сила. Старый рок - мудрость. А Наутилус ДДТ Ария и др что-то между)) эти песни вечны
Ki2L 3 years ago 8
I love this song I haven't heard it in 10 years, I have tears in my eyes lol
ps3u 3 years ago 5
the best song ever!!!! thanks
UKR46 3 years ago 6
thanks to the authors of the song. (:
kblcuk 3 years ago
:( i don't understand any russian.....im trying to learn it :)
Synochra 2 years ago 12
dude,this song about Christ and his follower-pupil apostle Andrey.
Nautillus Pompilius-is the legend of russian rock.
ADOBARD90 2 years ago 5
супер! большая спасибо! поздрав из польшы!
torleif666 3 years ago 10
да не за что (:
kblcuk 3 years ago
ПРОсто СУПЕР))эхх как бы вернуться лет на 7 назад...дворовые песни..ммммм
Izrailtianin 3 years ago 8
да, я примерно тогда же нау начал слушать (:
kblcuk 3 years ago
по-моему, я тоже в детстве видел этот клип, а не тот, который с мальчиком... во всяком случае, когда его посмотрел, внутри как будто ёкнуло что-то.
этот клип мне более симпатичен, и видеоряд как-то больше сочетается с аудио.
в общем, спасибо автору за такой раритет!
BETAJlb 3 years ago 2
не за что (:
kblcuk 3 years ago
pisnja zaebis. ne kto tak nespoet tak kak on ;)
REDMAFFIA 3 years ago
Я в детстветолько этот клип видел, а не тот, что про мальчика. =)
walentainYan 4 years ago
этот гораздо лучше.... и версия песни вроде немного другая
wanishe 4 years ago
версия чтоли не оцифрована кажется
unsobill 4 years ago
скорее всего с кассеты какой-нибудь. не помню уж, как она у меня на компьютере оказалась
kblcuk 4 years ago
там даже в одном месте текст другой немного) точнее одно слово =)
wanishe 3 years ago
Нет, это именно другая версия, другое исполнение, а не только качество звука. Другой голос (в смысле Бутусова, но более ранний), другие интонации, и вместо "и Андрей в слезах" он поёт "и Андрей зарыдав".
kloratis 3 years ago 6
"and it was at that age...
poetry arrived in search of me..."
kicsimo 4 years ago
Nado bilo sdelat' imenno etot klip dominantom,a ne tot drugoi ,kotoriy vse videli.Zdes' yarche otobrazhen smisl pesni chto-li...
Romariog1980 4 years ago
Ser`ezno, cto li, "rare video"? Dazhe ne znala, chto obladayu raritetnym klipom. 10-12 let nazad zapisyvala lyubimye pesni-klipy na kassetu s teleka. Kasseta vsegda so mnoi. :))
Routo 5 years ago
nu, naskolko znaju, etot klip pochti ne pokazyvali po televizoru, v osnovnom drugoj. (:
kblcuk 5 years ago
i've been looking for this. thanks!
osanova 5 years ago
be my guest. (:
kblcuk 5 years ago
wow... never even knew about this... thank you!
redmenace 4 years ago