it's getting ridiculous. i'd say the first two films were pretty accurate, the third wasn't so bad, but after GoF they started cutting too much out. i mean, obviously they can't fit the entire book into two and a bit hours, but like nat says, they cut out the most crucial parts because they claim there's not enough time, yet they add it pointless scenes that weren't in the book to begin with. and, if remus and tonks are together in HBP, why is her hair still brown?!
The part when Tonks called Lupin "sweetheart" didn't really make sense in the middle of the 6th movie.....because they weren't, like......until the end.......They should have kept Bill getting attacked by Fenrir so then Tonks could have yelled at Lupin in the hospital wing. And they were in one scene! ONE!
She is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
lol she leaked tht there was no funeral for dumbledore in the film :P and totally agree with her, wot were they thinking taking out lodes of stuff from the book, then just adding extra crappy stuff,
I'm gonna kill somebody,they cut out Dumbledore's funerel,and Tonks is only in one scene,the Warner Brothers are gonna get it,if it's the last thing I do!
the film is good but it is dissapointing how much stuff they mised out and the action i was looking forward to especially the whole tonks and lupin thing coz if u just watch the films and not really read the books then you would be like "huh?" when tonks called lupin "sweetheart"
WHAT NO DUMBLEDORE FUNERAL SCENE HELL NO I WILL NOT STAND FOR THIS I NEED THAT ANGST SCENE NAO!!!!!!! *calms self down* I knew this was going to happen they always cut out the good parts T_T
yeah thats good about the seventh book though that they keep everything cus everything in the 7th book is important, and that was my fave of all the books.
omg, i hate when people say the books are better. obviously they are, but they only have about 2 hours to put as much information into the movies as they can. they cant get it perfect..
okay well they don't need to keep EVERYTHING! but they should put in some important parts and take out some parts that arent necessary. and like the 5th movie... when they made it so that Cho was the one to rat out the order of the phoenix... they can't get it perfect... you're right... but they can do better. all their other movies were better than the 5th and that one was short so they had the space. they just didnt use it.
There was no Cedrics funeral in the movie. That was Dumbledores End of Term speech which WAS in the book.
But cutting Dumbledores Funeral is pure nonsense. It's the perfect Ending for any Movie, and a lot of things are decided in that Scene, that lead to Deathly Hallows. Plus you gotta see Dumbledores Tomb for the Story about the Elder Wand. I'm so mad at WB right now.
SERIOUSLY! It's DUMBLEDORE's furneral they are cutting away!!! DUMBLEDORE's, Do you hear?? DUMBLEDORE'S!!!!! ;(
Tonks only in one scene!!!! This is just getting worse.. I agreee, I sort of watching HP because of Tonks to (and dobby, but they have taken him away as well!!) ÅHH, i'm so angry about this!!! LOVE THE HP BOOKS! <33
AHHH! Only in one scene *cries* I'M GOING TO TEAR SOME THROATS OUT FOR THAT! how coud they do that! I already know I'm only seeing HBP BECAUSE of Tonks. And she's only in one scene. That's so mean-and to cut out the funeral TOO! WHAT THE HECK! And I can barely understand her, can someone translate who knows what she's saying?
Sounds like WB is cheapin' out... now I could be wrong but HBP is about the size of the first two books, which were covered quite well (most to all very important scenes were there), but the funeral signifies alot in The Harry Potter series, Dumbledore was the last bastion and hope of defense from Voldemort to many people.
LOL "Dumbledore's funeral" HUUUHH???
KeswickCamp08 1 year ago 5
**GASP** I cant hear her! lol.
PureNatalia 1 year ago
Can I get a transcript of what she said? I can barely understand a word!
AlbinoMonkeyC 1 year ago
it's getting ridiculous. i'd say the first two films were pretty accurate, the third wasn't so bad, but after GoF they started cutting too much out. i mean, obviously they can't fit the entire book into two and a bit hours, but like nat says, they cut out the most crucial parts because they claim there's not enough time, yet they add it pointless scenes that weren't in the book to begin with. and, if remus and tonks are together in HBP, why is her hair still brown?!
BelectiveDuck 1 year ago 5
@BelectiveDuck Curious. WTF? Now I sound like Ollivander!!! haha
PureNatalia 1 year ago
The part when Tonks called Lupin "sweetheart" didn't really make sense in the middle of the 6th movie.....because they weren't, like......until the end.......They should have kept Bill getting attacked by Fenrir so then Tonks could have yelled at Lupin in the hospital wing. And they were in one scene! ONE!
ANLpr0ducti0ns 1 year ago 4
@ANLpr0ducti0ns Yeah, that was the best part of the book!
alluvermin 1 year ago
all i heard was "dumbledore's funeral" come out her mouth lol
PunxLover 1 year ago 2
well its a good thing i already knew that...
GLopezWebkinzVmkLove 1 year ago
man she is hot expesially in the order of the phenix
stevieman333 2 years ago 2
I absolutely love tonks!
emopinata12345 2 years ago
She is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
abelopez123 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
LOL "Dumbledore's funeral" (GASPS) "When did HE die?" lol
KeswickCamp08 2 years ago
I WAS PISSED.
yamahadrummergirl 2 years ago 2
lol she leaked tht there was no funeral for dumbledore in the film :P and totally agree with her, wot were they thinking taking out lodes of stuff from the book, then just adding extra crappy stuff,
clares567 2 years ago
what is she(tena) saying?
oooooRachelooooo 2 years ago
i did not hear one part of theat Q& A lol
atlantisb34 2 years ago
DO NOT CLICK LINK IN SIDEBAR!! you will get blasted with spyware.
thanks very much douchebag.
longliveluigi 2 years ago 2
i didnt heard all what she was saying some one please tell me ... :(
depjojo 2 years ago 2
I'm gonna kill somebody,they cut out Dumbledore's funerel,and Tonks is only in one scene,the Warner Brothers are gonna get it,if it's the last thing I do!
BlazeROCKS101 2 years ago 4
WHAT???? That's fucking... WHAT?? Are they so dumb?
And Nat Tena is hot.. ONE SCENE??
davidsundbaum 2 years ago
I know,the the sixth Harry Potter movie is going to suck!
BlazeROCKS101 2 years ago
YOU SHUT YOUR MOUTH!!
ShamooGames 2 years ago
Okay,it's partially gonna suck. Happy?
BlazeROCKS101 2 years ago
it doesn't suck, it's actually a good movie
babydancer07 2 years ago
It's not fair,everyone's seen it,me and my family.... Hopefully,we can get enough money to see it soon.
BlazeROCKS101 2 years ago
the film is good but it is dissapointing how much stuff they mised out and the action i was looking forward to especially the whole tonks and lupin thing coz if u just watch the films and not really read the books then you would be like "huh?" when tonks called lupin "sweetheart"
Bullet2Margera 2 years ago 18
I know,in the book,she was crying over him through the whole thing,but in the movie,there seemed to be alot of romance between them.
BlazeROCKS101 2 years ago
OMG. THATS EXACTLY WHAT I SAID.
i was soooo mad.
if they dont have tonks and lupin in the last two movies...arghhhhhhhh
xjustalilmore 2 years ago
tonk and lupin die in the last book :[
PunxLover 1 year ago
@Bullet2Margera I did that, even though I read the books. I was like, wtf? She shouldn't show emotions yet! lol.
PureNatalia 1 year ago
WHAT NO DUMBLEDORE FUNERAL SCENE HELL NO I WILL NOT STAND FOR THIS I NEED THAT ANGST SCENE NAO!!!!!!! *calms self down* I knew this was going to happen they always cut out the good parts T_T
Sunkist02 2 years ago 2
pretty much, yeah
the true story about book adaptations! haha
HermyG13 3 years ago
So they kept Cedric's funeral, which wasn't in the book, but they cut Dumbledore's funeral, which IS in the book? >:|
missvicky123 3 years ago 2
i hate when they do that! the fifth movie sucked! the books are sooo much better.. hopefully the sixth movie is good cus the book is awesome.
NickEliJBCS 3 years ago
Yeah, hopefully. At least we know that the seventh is going to keep everything.
missvicky123 3 years ago
yeah thats good about the seventh book though that they keep everything cus everything in the 7th book is important, and that was my fave of all the books.
NickEliJBCS 3 years ago
omg, i hate when people say the books are better. obviously they are, but they only have about 2 hours to put as much information into the movies as they can. they cant get it perfect..
ShamooGames 2 years ago
okay well they don't need to keep EVERYTHING! but they should put in some important parts and take out some parts that arent necessary. and like the 5th movie... when they made it so that Cho was the one to rat out the order of the phoenix... they can't get it perfect... you're right... but they can do better. all their other movies were better than the 5th and that one was short so they had the space. they just didnt use it.
NickEliJBCS 2 years ago
or they could make it into a 3 or 4 hour movie, cause isn't Lord of the Rings like 4 or 5 hours long?
babydancer07 2 years ago
Hehe I'm one of them, but I agree with you.
chrisibzu 2 years ago
There was no Cedrics funeral in the movie. That was Dumbledores End of Term speech which WAS in the book.
But cutting Dumbledores Funeral is pure nonsense. It's the perfect Ending for any Movie, and a lot of things are decided in that Scene, that lead to Deathly Hallows. Plus you gotta see Dumbledores Tomb for the Story about the Elder Wand. I'm so mad at WB right now.
Wurzelknecht 3 years ago 3
Where did you hear about the cut??
Wowbagger86 2 years ago
This is so funny! She just gave away everything!! I love her!
NymphadoraLupin13 3 years ago 4
I am officially protesting Warner Brothers as well as J.K. Rowling they have no respect for the Tonks and Lupin relationship ugh I'm gonna kill them!
KAMKLV 3 years ago 29
@KAMKLV HELL YEAH!!!
PureNatalia 1 year ago
SERIOUSLY! It's DUMBLEDORE's furneral they are cutting away!!! DUMBLEDORE's, Do you hear?? DUMBLEDORE'S!!!!! ;(
Tonks only in one scene!!!! This is just getting worse.. I agreee, I sort of watching HP because of Tonks to (and dobby, but they have taken him away as well!!) ÅHH, i'm so angry about this!!! LOVE THE HP BOOKS! <33
TheFreeElf 3 years ago 3
AHHH! Only in one scene *cries* I'M GOING TO TEAR SOME THROATS OUT FOR THAT! how coud they do that! I already know I'm only seeing HBP BECAUSE of Tonks. And she's only in one scene. That's so mean-and to cut out the funeral TOO! WHAT THE HECK! And I can barely understand her, can someone translate who knows what she's saying?
ActingFireAqua 3 years ago 2
LOL, I love how everyone gasps at the exact same time.
MissRJLupin 3 years ago 2
Sounds like WB is cheapin' out... now I could be wrong but HBP is about the size of the first two books, which were covered quite well (most to all very important scenes were there), but the funeral signifies alot in The Harry Potter series, Dumbledore was the last bastion and hope of defense from Voldemort to many people.
Victisomega 3 years ago
omg at the funeral but lol poor natalie
yeh people you should go onto leaky
rockinfluff 3 years ago
omg! david yates sucks he cuts everything out!!!
GoodMorningDupa 3 years ago 2
the funeral *collective gasp* lmao where the fuck have these douches been
VJones44 3 years ago
Well, the funeral is a short and expansive scene... I think WB want take this money and make more scenes in the film.
XluizaX39 3 years ago
how can they not have the funeral??
gothgirl16 3 years ago 4
WAIT WAIT WAIT. When she said that...does that mean THATS NOT IN THE MOVIE!!!! I hope i heard that wrong...
TonksThePotterNerd 3 years ago
can anyone tell me what she said too?
TottiReDeRoma 3 years ago
tonks is hardly in the hbp, only one scene. that sucks D:
omgitsjayjay 3 years ago
I can't hear what she's saying.. I wasn't there.. so sad T_T Can anyone tell me what she said?
Kukkiess 3 years ago
Poor Natalia....that does piss me off about Dumbledore's funeral though. Damn WB....
kamikoe 3 years ago