I was there. It was COMPLETELY live. Her voice is so soft and clear that it seems like it´s a produced track from a cd. But NOT! It was live and gave me goosebumps,
I LOVE LOVE THIS SONG! I fell in love with this song since 1998 when I got her #1's album as a Christmas present. This was definitely all live! I can't wait to see her in concert whenever she's touring again!
Mariah é uma das maiores cantoras do mundo , com uma brilhante carreira cheia de altos e baixos , o que faz dela uma mulher guerreira digna de admiração e respeito , porem a qualidade de sua voz tem caido muito suas cordas vocais estão velhas e cansadas e seus whitles tem falhado muito , inclusive a sua tecnica vocal que é extremamente dificil a própria tem dificuldade de executar ,observe o haha...... no final mas mesmo assim eu sou um eterno fã durvalfilho_84@hotmail.com
I really think she tried to hit D7 because i can hear it, becuase she hits it and then it stops and then she goes to the original note D6?? so i don't know!
I have known her part lipping abilities for awhile. Usually you see you her hands go more erratic than normal and sometimes she covers her face with it. Also, her head shakes a lot. Looking at the video, you can see her lips not matching in some parts.
@AngelVII77 4:22 - 4:45 is not lipped listen its very different, this part isnt 4:49 - 5:00 and that last part seriously no... when she moved the moc away the sound faded c'mon only part I agree with u on is 3:16 - 4:09
@AngelVII77 WHO CARES???? she can OBVIOUSLY do it live, she CAN OBVIOUSLY STILL SING HER OLD SONGS, SHE OBVIOUSLY STILL HAS RANGE. does it really matter??? no..
And I can easily tell which part is lipped because the tone shifts as well as the audio is the same as the CD version. I've heard this song so many times as well as her live performances. I know what I'm talking about.
and she's not even singing on the same key on some parts as the studio versions,and her voice made that hoarse/cracking sound in places that it usually didn't on the studio version.
and at the end of the belting parts where she says i still believe,she missed several falsetto notes.
@aquamarine11500 doesnt matter..she still has the same voice she did when she recorded "i still believe"...only her voice is actually clearer here than the studio record.
Only a really Mariah fan whose not a hater knows the difference. This is totally 100% live. The proof the high note at the end is complete different, she lost a little bit of her breath at the 5:20 mark and just add the words "Ooh boy" which is NOT PART OF THE SONG.
I love Mariah, but this was not completely live. There's a huge difference in audio quality when she's singing live and when she's not. Compare 4:07 to 4:11. Plus, when she's lipping, her movements are WAY more exaggerated, including her mouth. 3:16-4:10- Lipped. 4:11-4:31- Live. 4:32-4:34- Live. 4:35-4:40- Lipped. 4:41 and 4:47-4:49- Live 4:50-4:57- Lipped 4:58-5:02- Live 5:03-5:11- Lipped 5:20-5:35- Live The high note is live. Don't believe me? Compare the parts to the studio version.
ok I don't know how anyone thought this was even a bit live, she was taking gigantically loud breathes the entire time and sang only about 10% of the song like the original, she changed the whole thing, even the freakin' high note was different. the brazilian fans r lucky, Mariah gave them her all and she deserves complete crdit for her performance!
@RiPcOrDz83 okay. IDK how someone can memorized when the lipped part is suppose to come and when they are suppose to sing live. That looks very hard to do.
um luxo,o agudo saiu um poukinho estranho. Mas luxo!!! Amei
hairammanzon 2 days ago
100% LIVE. GO HOME HATERS.
hurtboy83 6 days ago
Cantaaa mtooooo *-*
mcolluci 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I was there. It was COMPLETELY live. Her voice is so soft and clear that it seems like it´s a produced track from a cd. But NOT! It was live and gave me goosebumps,
blessedhearted 1 month ago
Comment removed
blessedhearted 1 month ago
I LOVE LOVE THIS SONG! I fell in love with this song since 1998 when I got her #1's album as a Christmas present. This was definitely all live! I can't wait to see her in concert whenever she's touring again!
NelsonY 1 month ago
It's completely live, only deaf/blind haters will say otherwise. But what is with the weird whistle note at the end... it sounds wrong.
BBQJester 5 months ago
hard to believe it was more than a year agoooo
iiAmitx3 5 months ago
gotta love the trademark Mariah Carey "hand flailing" from 3:35-3:50 ! =)
VocalRuns 8 months ago 4
eu amo essa mulher, / I LOVE THIS WOMAN
dsp736 10 months ago
This has liv parts , but some parts seems like is lipped. But she did it great at all! I loove you Mc !
MarcosDiaswow 1 year ago
@MarcosDiaswow This is 100 live
pedy19 4 weeks ago
We all know fo sho that the D6 is live. Stunning.
calvin999999999 1 year ago 4
MARIAH CANTA MUUUUITO, HUMILHA QUALQUER EU DISSE QUALQUER uma.
ailtonsribeiro 1 year ago
lmfao ppl c'mon now you know she sang this completly live.
Antboogie0828 1 year ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
Mariah é uma das maiores cantoras do mundo , com uma brilhante carreira cheia de altos e baixos , o que faz dela uma mulher guerreira digna de admiração e respeito , porem a qualidade de sua voz tem caido muito suas cordas vocais estão velhas e cansadas e seus whitles tem falhado muito , inclusive a sua tecnica vocal que é extremamente dificil a própria tem dificuldade de executar ,observe o haha...... no final mas mesmo assim eu sou um eterno fã durvalfilho_84@hotmail.com
minharazaodeviver007 1 year ago
I really think she tried to hit D7 because i can hear it, becuase she hits it and then it stops and then she goes to the original note D6?? so i don't know!
swipper925 1 year ago
She part lipped the a big section midway and at the end.
Lipped: 3:16 - 4:09
4:22 - 4:45
This seems kind of live to me but probably lipped:
4:49 - 5:00
Lipped:
5:03 - 5:10
I have known her part lipping abilities for awhile. Usually you see you her hands go more erratic than normal and sometimes she covers her face with it. Also, her head shakes a lot. Looking at the video, you can see her lips not matching in some parts.
AngelVII77 1 year ago
@AngelVII77 4:22 - 4:45 is not lipped listen its very different, this part isnt 4:49 - 5:00 and that last part seriously no... when she moved the moc away the sound faded c'mon only part I agree with u on is 3:16 - 4:09
TheMickj23q 1 year ago
@AngelVII77 WHO CARES???? she can OBVIOUSLY do it live, she CAN OBVIOUSLY STILL SING HER OLD SONGS, SHE OBVIOUSLY STILL HAS RANGE. does it really matter??? no..
jaypaidincash 1 year ago
@AngelVII77 no she didn´t you can hear small breaks in her voice:) 100 live sugar
pedy19 4 weeks ago
@AngelVII77 none of this was lipped.
Crzymofo69 1 week ago
And I can easily tell which part is lipped because the tone shifts as well as the audio is the same as the CD version. I've heard this song so many times as well as her live performances. I know what I'm talking about.
AngelVII77 1 year ago
Comment removed
AngelVII77 1 year ago
amazing.
carolvegas 1 year ago
amo i still believe axo q foi uma das milhoes de cançoes de mariah q marcaram mesmo
329777242 1 year ago
wow she sounds amazing!
feverhigh 1 year ago
and she's not even singing on the same key on some parts as the studio versions,and her voice made that hoarse/cracking sound in places that it usually didn't on the studio version.
and at the end of the belting parts where she says i still believe,she missed several falsetto notes.
aquamarine11500 1 year ago
@aquamarine11500 doesnt matter..she still has the same voice she did when she recorded "i still believe"...only her voice is actually clearer here than the studio record.
jaypaidincash 1 year ago
@jaypaidincash I know i'm jus letting the haters kno...
aquamarine11500 1 year ago
Comment removed
Chimier 1 year ago
Only a really Mariah fan whose not a hater knows the difference. This is totally 100% live. The proof the high note at the end is complete different, she lost a little bit of her breath at the 5:20 mark and just add the words "Ooh boy" which is NOT PART OF THE SONG.
mariahfan202 1 year ago
@mariahfan202 You can't base an ENTIRE performance over ONE small section. That makes no sense at all.
Chimier 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love Mariah, but this was not completely live. There's a huge difference in audio quality when she's singing live and when she's not. Compare 4:07 to 4:11. Plus, when she's lipping, her movements are WAY more exaggerated, including her mouth. 3:16-4:10- Lipped. 4:11-4:31- Live. 4:32-4:34- Live. 4:35-4:40- Lipped. 4:41 and 4:47-4:49- Live 4:50-4:57- Lipped 4:58-5:02- Live 5:03-5:11- Lipped 5:20-5:35- Live The high note is live. Don't believe me? Compare the parts to the studio version.
Chimier 1 year ago
@Chimier Was 5:12 to 5:18 lipped?
LoboAscuridad 1 year ago
@LoboAscuridad Nope. It was live.
Chimier 1 year ago
Comment removed
Chimier 1 year ago
Comment removed
Chimier 1 year ago
"I was only twelve, but..." :D haha
MarilynFinland 1 year ago
@MarilynFinland That was funny! Lol
LoboAscuridad 1 year ago
Who the flip think this is lipped??? It's clearly live!!
She did it super different! And she song it awesomee!!
Love you Mimi!! Can't wait for the Christmas CD this fall! :]
lalandxcore 1 year ago
Omg she sounds awesome! PLEASE post make it happen if you have a video
aderonke 1 year ago
*sry I meant a bit lipped
lamb4eva 1 year ago
ok I don't know how anyone thought this was even a bit live, she was taking gigantically loud breathes the entire time and sang only about 10% of the song like the original, she changed the whole thing, even the freakin' high note was different. the brazilian fans r lucky, Mariah gave them her all and she deserves complete crdit for her performance!
lamb4eva 1 year ago
Fuck!! I Was Sure Watching An Other Video Of This Performance That It Was All Live But I Can Clearly See Here That It's Not!!!! I Was So Happy....=(
RiPcOrDz83 1 year ago
@RiPcOrDz83 Are you sure it's not live? I thought 5:12 to 5:18 proved it was live and not lipped.
LoboAscuridad 1 year ago
@LoboAscuridad Not Entirely Lip,Just Part Of It...
RiPcOrDz83 1 year ago
@RiPcOrDz83 okay. IDK how someone can memorized when the lipped part is suppose to come and when they are suppose to sing live. That looks very hard to do.
LoboAscuridad 1 year ago
@LoboAscuridad Mariah Does It Often Though,So She Use To It...
RiPcOrDz83 1 year ago
I LOVE U MARIAH
CyprusHot 1 year ago
Soo amazing. Her singing techniques and placement are impeccable. Hmm makes me cry. :P
tipofmytongue1024 1 year ago
Thankyou so much for uploading this!
pbaxmc2 1 year ago
Comment removed
teom44 1 year ago