Not bad. Not bad at all. Certainly not as bad as I expected.
I certainly do appreciate that some people regard sloppiness as a mark of artistic genius, and terrible recording quality as a sure sign of a great recording.
@Spiritakis Furtwanger's genius is not in his sloppiness, what would be stupid would be to either deny that sloppiness exists or to not be able to perceive the greatness of the interpretation because of it. The quality of the recording is irrelevant. There are plenty of terrible quality recordings of mediocre performances but this isn't one of them.
No. Not fully developed at least. But there is a measure or two of premonition. Remember, the Rheingold finances the construction of Walhalla, with disaterous results. Good listening, LMJ.
this is indeed such an amazing thing that you have done. you have allowed us (me) to capture in glorious sound the story line (various motifs) in a succinct and musical ordering of thought. thank you, as well!
Tolkien said something like "there's a ring in my book and in Wagner's opera, and that's the only thing they have in common." Oh puhlease! As far as I can tell LotR is much more similar to Wagner's version of the tale than to the original saga.
Not bad. Not bad at all. Certainly not as bad as I expected.
I certainly do appreciate that some people regard sloppiness as a mark of artistic genius, and terrible recording quality as a sure sign of a great recording.
Spiritakis 1 year ago
@Spiritakis Furtwanger's genius is not in his sloppiness, what would be stupid would be to either deny that sloppiness exists or to not be able to perceive the greatness of the interpretation because of it. The quality of the recording is irrelevant. There are plenty of terrible quality recordings of mediocre performances but this isn't one of them.
CzarDodon 1 year ago 4
For LMJ314142: the Walhalla is the theme of the scene immediately following!
2251813 1 year ago
... reines Gold ... Rheingold ...
RheingoldxxL 1 year ago
The video is great CAR. I' ve been listening to Solti before hearing this. Dear G. is on egotrip, compared to this.
dermotafan 2 years ago
Thank you car (pronounced tzar in my country).
dermotafan 2 years ago
I enjoyed very much your video.
SailorCostigan 2 years ago
Awesome! Rheingold is my fav opera
skoulikaki731 2 years ago
Wait, was that the Wahlhall theme at 8:15? What was that doing there?
LMJ314142 2 years ago
No. Not fully developed at least. But there is a measure or two of premonition. Remember, the Rheingold finances the construction of Walhalla, with disaterous results. Good listening, LMJ.
phil2u 2 years ago
Yes, Toxic finances :-) Wotan's dirty dealings ...... building castles in the air
CzarDodon 2 years ago
I always love 4:37.
LMJ314142 2 years ago 2
Nice way of broadening the audience, these translations...
Thanks!
------------------------
Greetings,
Rolf
Historical classical recordings
European Archive, Paris
EuropeanArchive 3 years ago
I really appreciated your effort mate, well done!
ludowicovan 3 years ago
I so love Gustav Neidlinger's Alberich!
Skukkuk 3 years ago
this is indeed such an amazing thing that you have done. you have allowed us (me) to capture in glorious sound the story line (various motifs) in a succinct and musical ordering of thought. thank you, as well!
billjhyt 3 years ago
The original lord of the rings! Love it.
kjlg74 3 years ago 2
Tolkien said something like "there's a ring in my book and in Wagner's opera, and that's the only thing they have in common." Oh puhlease! As far as I can tell LotR is much more similar to Wagner's version of the tale than to the original saga.
Skukkuk 3 years ago
This is simply epic stuff, my friend.
TheMediaMachine 3 years ago