secondly, i remember that night he sang it, and gordon lightfoot cried, saying that kalan seemed to interpret the song and lyrics so well...so many covers of this song miss how heart-wrenching and tragic it is. great job kalan!!
when I was 11 years old I was convinced I was going to marry this guy lol I burst out crying when he won.. I was crazy obsessive Kalanadian back then lol. Its so good hearing him again now though. He's really very talented. Can't believe its already been 6 years since he won!
i don't blame u for being obsessed with kalan. when he performed this song, i'm sure every girl in the audience wanted to marry him. its' the way he sings.
This is a little immature interpretation of the song but his voice is awesome. It's the kind of song you have to experience first before you fully understand.
the original was much deeper and meaningful, had that somber sound that gives you that gloomy feeling. this version is too pop, singer chose the wrong song. stick to britney spears
Ok kalan does a good job but please, he doesn't even come close to lightfoot's original. Just listen to it, lightfoot especially when he was younger was just totally magic.
This kid is great, I am American and I don't think residency has jack shit to do with anything! Canadian Idol, American Idol, who cares!!! the kid is awesome!!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
just my opinion, Im a canadian and Canadian Idol's vocals sound a little weird compared to American Idol, cept for mikey bustos. And josiah leming was one of the worst, and i think hes better, as well as robbie carrico.
i actually think most American Idol contestanets are waaayyy less talented then Kalan. Kalan has such a great and strong voice. I say him live a couple days ago and he is still amazing
@obsessedwithkalan WOW if i have to pick someone to listen to other than mr lightfoot, this is it :) he is AMAZING. that voice = wow. is DEFINATELY going places
Kalan manages to make this song sound as haunting as the sound of a loon on an early morning steaming lake - he really does Gordon Lightfoot proud. His #1 Fans - BD & Zest Marie, Toronto, ON
first of all, he's totally adorbs.
secondly, i remember that night he sang it, and gordon lightfoot cried, saying that kalan seemed to interpret the song and lyrics so well...so many covers of this song miss how heart-wrenching and tragic it is. great job kalan!!
phatsince87 3 months ago
Wow! That young man has a beautiful voice. He did a great job on that Gordon Lightfoot classic.
CeridwenLynne 1 year ago
when I was 11 years old I was convinced I was going to marry this guy lol I burst out crying when he won.. I was crazy obsessive Kalanadian back then lol. Its so good hearing him again now though. He's really very talented. Can't believe its already been 6 years since he won!
SingerChick4Life 1 year ago 2
@SingerChick4Life ikr? i remember my mom cheering him on, and when we rushed out to buy his single. hes so awesome <3
auqablue400 10 months ago
i don't blame u for being obsessed with kalan. when he performed this song, i'm sure every girl in the audience wanted to marry him. its' the way he sings.
udaan8 1 year ago
The only person who has done Gordon's songs ANYWHERE close to Gordon IS KALAN. AMAZING.
SaskBirdies 1 year ago 2
I voted for Theresa from beginning to end in that season . . . but this was fantastic. It gets my vote as his best performance.
And, yes, that was Mr. Lightfoot clapping at the end of the clip.
uncleartie 2 years ago
the kid has some talent, but he picked the wrong song. Im sorry but this rendition doesn't sway me emotionally as much as
gordon's does
graidstin 2 years ago
I must admit he is really good. Great talent
dicks5001 2 years ago
like a gazillion times better than Kaleb ...
sarahtakaki 2 years ago 2
This is a little immature interpretation of the song but his voice is awesome. It's the kind of song you have to experience first before you fully understand.
karengurl101 2 years ago
because he's just better?
JaniceJolo 2 years ago
Every time Mr Lightfoot sings this live at a concert, I cry. Tears are in my eyes now as I listen to Kalan.
SaskBirdies 3 years ago 8
frodo baggins
bhutanmanclan 3 years ago
AHAHAHA! I was thinking the same thing! But i think he sings decently, despite his comical appearance.
FrozenPandaPops 2 years ago
Wow, he's really good! Never heard him before
GlitterFlame89 3 years ago 21
He's awesome
tuskbear 3 years ago 9
I like
JaniceJolo 3 years ago 5
Excuse me, but is that not Gordon Lightfoot clapping at the end of this clip? Kudos to the singer but THE MAN was ultimately the better performer.
jhairyface 3 years ago 2
That INDEED is Gord, in the burgundy blazer!
LongTallYamlaJay 2 years ago
I CAN SING THIS SUPER GOOD
sexycutiepie1314 3 years ago
what happened to the stage? its so small now!
marcob21 3 years ago
Kalan is amazing!! This young man is going places.Picked him from the 1st song on Idol!! So young,far beyond his years of talent,Sweet You go Kalan
lostinthought46 3 years ago 16
This has been flagged as spam show
the original was much deeper and meaningful, had that somber sound that gives you that gloomy feeling. this version is too pop, singer chose the wrong song. stick to britney spears
electrodinobot 3 years ago
Have this song on my ipod.
makes me cry when I listen to it Haha.
so beautiful. Kalan is amazing
Sunshey 3 years ago 9
hes good
1970sullivang 3 years ago 11
Very superior to the original. Doing its writer's justice.
Very good!
thunderlightningboom 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
r u kidding me?
electrodinobot 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yeah, this version is garbage, and this is coming from a Porter fan.
marcob21 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SO bad
thedood332 3 years ago
thedood332 is SO BAD....agreed!
thunderlightningboom 3 years ago 4
he's good!!
couponsexpired 3 years ago 7
It's a shame they chose the "hits" and not the really really great Gordon Lightfoot songs never or seldom played on the radio.
sigh...
azpiri12 3 years ago
Ok kalan does a good job but please, he doesn't even come close to lightfoot's original. Just listen to it, lightfoot especially when he was younger was just totally magic.
torgoth74 3 years ago
I just watched gordon's version and I think Kalan's is superior. what a voice!
ccj1997 3 years ago
cool
ejbeaud 3 years ago
Hey Nice Job Your Good
lol:P
RyEm167 3 years ago 2
kalan porter vs. david archuleta ...
Debstarr 3 years ago
This kid is great, I am American and I don't think residency has jack shit to do with anything! Canadian Idol, American Idol, who cares!!! the kid is awesome!!!!
alliegot 3 years ago 8
Lol
Seeing both of them perform (only in Youtube though XD) I'll go with Kalan Porter. <3
xbadax 3 years ago
im going to see him in concert in 9 days!!=)
123leah123 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow when u look at american idol alot,
Like Canadian Idol is shit compared to it. Like holy shit how did he win? The worst of the top 24 in american idol is better than this kid.
cityncolor 3 years ago
r u jokin he's way better than the worst on american idol
trevor8930 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
just my opinion, Im a canadian and Canadian Idol's vocals sound a little weird compared to American Idol, cept for mikey bustos. And josiah leming was one of the worst, and i think hes better, as well as robbie carrico.
cityncolor 3 years ago
i actually think most American Idol contestanets are waaayyy less talented then Kalan. Kalan has such a great and strong voice. I say him live a couple days ago and he is still amazing
hutchmurr 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
better than clay aiken? david archuleta?
cityncolor 3 years ago
hell, yeah...but it's obvious you prefer clay and david, then good on you - let them know, post "nice" comments on their vids
pfqueen2007 3 years ago 5
k my bad
cityncolor 3 years ago
The resemblance to Leif Garrett is striking!
tommiej3 4 years ago
Did he win,,he's cute and has a really good voice?
evegpt 4 years ago 10
yes, he won =)
obsessedwithkalan 4 years ago 6
@obsessedwithkalan WOW if i have to pick someone to listen to other than mr lightfoot, this is it :) he is AMAZING. that voice = wow. is DEFINATELY going places
yamahonkawazuki 10 months ago
beautiful ; he is truly incredible !
love his smile at the end :)
mally1993 4 years ago 2
Kalan manages to make this song sound as haunting as the sound of a loon on an early morning steaming lake - he really does Gordon Lightfoot proud. His #1 Fans - BD & Zest Marie, Toronto, ON
BDMarieHughes 4 years ago 4
good cover
ynrtfln 4 years ago 5
agree, Gordon Lightfood even invited Kalan to sing this very song at a tribute show for him (Gordon).
pfqueen2007 4 years ago
the song is greatt...he's awesome
caroluvlass 4 years ago 2