Added: 2 years ago
From: oblivionIIT
Views: 1,813,019
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,793)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • O__o

    Toni Braxton lost it. Her voice was not like before. Tsk tsk tsk

  • Only 1 i can say WOW Charice and Toni ^^

  • i love both

  • Damm..I just don't known what to say.I was just looking for TB..then Charice came on.

  • You know what..Though comparing one singer to another is bull, Charice being compared to Toni and other legendary singers, only shows how good she is..

  • i love toni braxton and i love charice too....:)

  • So proud of Charice! she is the best...

  • I like the way toni sang this song especially @ 2:17, even though it is off note, i still love it!

  • toni's voice cracks at times while Charice's is crystal clear.... crisp sound, soulful.... truly amazing for a 17 year old to render this song beautifully....

  • and by the way don't use OMG in your envious comment its blasphemy

  • @shannon360ify everyone is entitle in his/her opinion.that's chasters opinion even you kill yourself nothing you can do about it.go and kill yourself now

  • Charice is better than every single divas of the last 20 years according to her stans .OMG delusional at it best .They Claim that she better then: Celine ,Whitney ,Mariah, .

  • I love your Voice Charice! all the best from me to you!!

  • the best of all charice.

  • Charice is great, but Toni's voice is richer.

  • i love them both and think they are both amazinggg <3.

  • Charice and Toni both sung the song like their lovers has hit the road and abandoned them..he..he..he..

  • I'm sick of these people comparing great singers on YT!!

  • charise is great but i still prefer toni

  • that song is made for toni....she does a great job also...The thickness of toni voice fit the song better

  • A quick check of Charice's latest version of this song sung at David Foster & Friends at Mandalay Bay shows that she has now totally mastered this song far beyond the performance shown here. Check it out, it's worth the effort & your ears will thank you.

  • total command of the song!

  • She has total control and complete record of transitions between low and high ..... Smooth as silk ... I can not say that I know of any present or past musician who has control of both his vocals and that little remarkable. . and what is amazing about it. It is natural for her. Personally, I think Elvis Presley is the only comparable in this small geniu. His transitions are unique ... nobody else can do it .... Simply stunning. CHERICE BRAVO! BRAZIL!.

  • toni is the BEST

  • @MrDebashishMohannty And what science couse did learn that from, jackass?!!

  • Charice sounds dreadful!! she lacks the depth, spirit, and soul, and overall essence of the song!! Only thing she wins with  range!!

  • theyre both good and beyond us. let the entertainers entertain and we watchers/listeners just listen. enough negative comments on either of em.

  • 2:15

  • for me Toni Braxton is best,she has experienced voice

  • dhhhuuh!! how could you compare charice to ton braxton...???

  • Are you comparing the singer's voides - Charice uses maybe a minus 1 and she nails it considering this is a cover. Toni - though good - her voice broke in many places. And height is a factor - a big person can below easler - there is more spafe for the lungs. While Charice has to dig deep and train hard to get this.- so where is Toni now? any more hit songs?

  • i think toni is better because she has a deep voice kinda like anita baker and unbreak my heart was ment for her type of deep voice not charices deep voice and this is coming from an 11 yeared old but i still love charice and tonis voice

  • charice is better i think :)

  • The difference is that Charice sounds like a studio recording. Not taking away anything from Toni though...

  • awful! Charice was awfulllllllll. I completly agree that she's got an amazing voice, she can sing Dion, Carey, Whitney, but this song just isn't for her!!!! And I'm white, not black - sorry, but Toni kicks ass big time singing this song.

  • Why do some Filipinos keep on comparing others? fuckn retards!

  • nice

    

  • Toni

  • The song on the beginning is terrible. The rest of video is complete beatiful. Thanks for this.

  • This is Toni's song and she's stunningly sexy and definitely the way she sings is the reference point of how we listen to the song, however you can't take away the prowess and range of Charice's voice.

  • Oh I thought the first time she sung shes a gay, sorry toni but charice sing far way better than you.

  • nossa canta muito essa menina ..grande sucesso com certeza.

  • original is always the best but charice did a good job 2 thumps up ! love the both of u...cheer's !

  • Toni

  • a musica de abertura do video ficou tipo "nada a ve"

  • класс

    

  • Toni nuf said

  • amoooooooooo as duas.

  • Comment removed

  • original is the best.....

  • Great! Nice song! Charice has powerful voice can reach high notes. Lol!

  • You are so good and everything!amazing..!

  • Charice's version is unbelievable! Her voice is so strong and powerful... She's a great singer.

  • Comment removed

  • No ifs and buts, it's Charice the best version for me.

  • good....

    

  • Absolut have Charise the best and most powerfull voice, Toni dont even come close to it....

    Denmark

  • who ever sings this. The song is just great and both singers are amazing.

  • For God's sake, SHE'S ONLY 17 YRS.OLD ON THIS CLIP,LISTEN TO HER NOW AT 19 ON DAVID FOSTER'S CONCERTS.

  • amo toni braxton tbm mas acho que a Alexandra Burke cantou muito melhor essa musica que qqr outra pessoa que ja tenha visto

  • Charice is an awesome singer, but this song seems look like not fit with charice voice type.. Toni is better about this song.. :D

  • I love charice, not a big fan but she's a sweet heart

    Toni is, eh... but this is her one and only song that made her known all over the world. Classic and no one can replace that.

  • different voice quality,..but both good singer,..the original's much better of course...

  • 5:53 charice couldnt hold the note.... hands down there is only one winner... ms Toni Braxton

  • @TheDahl89 ya kidding me? on Toni's part it does'nt even exist!

  • i love charice!!!

  • I LOVE Charice, BUT this is definitely Toni Braxton's song !! I them both as artists !! -3

  • @MrDebashishMohanty  it's you again ,,,,,,fuck you ,,,,

  • @MrDebashishMohanty is this really relevant? what does this prove?

  • Comment removed

  • @leyhyde Charice is NOT a fat ugly girl, petite yes.

  • Not fair! Charice's video is of poor sound,see the DFF concerts!

  • @leyhyde Yo! this is not a beauty pageant,racist!

  • like seriously,Its Toni....hands down.com, Charice can kill this song but the way toni feel it and really dig deep is amazing....see Charice, it just comes to her and she sung it the same way the whole time, but with toni, she works her way up so that it seems gentle at first and then you got the crowd up and everything by the end....but thats just the way i feel.

  • Although I absolutely adore Charice overall, I think there's a certain flatness in her voice that doesn't make it fit this song. I don't know why people are complaining, about someone saying who's singing is better. Nobody can sing every song...

  • CHARICE IS MORE BETTER

  • NO HONEY THIS IS TONI BRAXTONS SONG AND THERE IS NO NO NO COMPARISON. SHE IS GOOD BUT NOT TONI

  • amazing voice Charice....

  • over acting!!!

  • toni's version is SOOO much more sensual and sexy, but charice's wide range is so much more impressive! i love both versions.

  • Charice is more talented than Toni Braxton...Thumbs up Charice...:)

  • i love charice ♥

  • nice charicE..uR fantastiC singeR

  • is that a flat in 2:16 ??

    or what do you call that?

  • @mrjace89 thats a flat by toni braxton. sori to say.

  • @penetrator52 uh oh.. but still it was a good performance,see the standing ovation? nothing beats the original version but charice's rendition is so amazing!! :)

  • Your such a loser Mohanty. Why keep ranting like a post-menopausal hormoned level bitch?

  • People, please, stop comparing the two singers. Can't people just enjoy the music and let the singers do what they do best, to sing! Fuck sake people, grow up!

  • Can't nobody sing that song like Toni, she put her signature on that-enough said

  • Charice...Charice..Charice - please unbreak my heart..

  • das ist einfach traum haf super

  • Toni Braxton sieht besser aus mti kurze haare!

  • Not fair,lousy poor instruments,this is not Charice best rendition,their in DFF.

  • what she try to dance Toni

  • hay charice... loveyou.. hay....

    

  • i love charice.... perfectoo .....

  • Charice own this song now....... PEACE.

  • I love Charice's voice...but this song is Toni's...sorry..hand's down

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @rosedoug This is a bad recording sound of Charice,watch the DFF versions of this song of Charice...AND THEN COMPARE!!!!

    watch?v=06dIlJA0rtE&feature=re­lated

    watch?v=iDBMdDw4BNs&feature=re­lated

  • PERFECT 

  • every song that charice sang always give me an emotion.even i do adore tony.but if to make comparison in this.charice absolutely win.

  • get the fuck out of here toni for gods sake

  • CHARICE! definitely charice

  • I love Toni,but sorry,not even close to Charice version,sorry to say that.

  • definitely the best song from Toni Braxton but Charice did an amazing job... you should check out her 2011 performance w/ David Foster: watch?v=Su38d9fd-Z0

  • each of them possesses different styles to express the song. you can feel the language of the soul and you can see the language of emotions.

  • watch her on DFF tour in Asia, she sang unbreak my heart ...she is really amazing 

  • everyone has is its own unique way of singing....and charice brings to have best of the best...that people most likely her...

  • Toni Braxton is unique; her style and her voice. You can't compare Toni to Charice.  Toni is the original of this song, soooo no comparison, please.

  • Wow omg she is great

  • SO AMAZING!! :D

  • Charice has no style of her own. Technically, yes she is perfection, though sometimes she has the Aguilera flatness in her tone that drives me crazy. But yes she is great. But what separates the Whitney's, Mariah, Celine's, Toni's and hell even Beyonce (yes I said it and I hate it LOL) is that they have their own unique sound. Charice is Kyla who Regine, who is Lani. Well, actually, I take that back. Lani definitely has a unique voice. They all have powerful voices, but they all sound alike.

  • @Vitaluv She's still young! Give her time to develop her "own style". These things come with age and maturity. Jeez.

  • @autumnsoliloquy her fans should understand that before they continue on with trying to compare her with people who had there own styles from the start

  • Comment removed

  • what up with the intro? lol

  • there is a big difference now on the version of charice....see her in dff at mandalay oct 1 2011 ///she covered it live and delivered it beautifully.......

  • For all the people who keep sayings "CHARICE" doesn't have her own song. Let me give you an insight  she does have her own song as a matter of fact she just release her second album in Japan called INFINITY. Some of the song from that album is actually all over YT. And for some of you who haven't seen the latest of Anbreak My Heart sang by Charice at DFF-Mandalay,Las Vegas Oct-10- 2011 Hurry and check it out for yourself... For you haters complain,complain and complain. Go F yourself.

  • Comment removed

  • I thing they have a beautiful voice and I love them.

  • ooooook, these two talented perfomer were just singing clean and having fun coz they were blessed with talentz.........but i don't know why people are judging whos the best one and whos not.........heeeellllooooo!!!!­!11

    plz don't be childish, just holler and sends your love, don't go around and busting onez carrer or morality coz itz not so cool.

    these two are both talented and i think we should give it to them...ok!

    stop judging who's the best and who's not!!!! come one people, thats SUCKZZ!

  • why people hating charice just because she has a good and wonderful voice ?very powerful its notjust she is an asian she can sing any songs of any artist, its because she has powerful voice its real.keep up your job charice were here to support you, thats a part of showbiznez.

  • Toni was the best

  • i love being asian. :) love you charrice! you deserve it!

  • given the fact that she's the best immitator.... she still sings better though.... better that the original singer.... How's that?

  • @jkcv071085 original je original tadyta asiatka jenom napodobuje je to kopírka, karaoke nezajímavá

  • love...love....love...love....­love

  • ...Charise is the best impersonator, immitator the world had ever known. However, should she be given her own signiture & original songs of her own, look out, she'll set the world on "fire"..!!!

  • she is the best singer ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • charice has a rich and full voice...watch this watch?v=5McgTNiep20

  • what is wrong with us being asian?? 

  • @junijuju hahha....nothing mate........there is nothing wrong wiht being asian......trust me, just let them haters hate coz nothing bad wont happen to you....ok??

    just chilax and headz up!!

    LOVE YOU ALL ASIANZ OUT THERE............CHARICE 4-EVER ALL DAY EVERY DAY!!!

    wooooooooohooooooooooo

    cant wait to come visit again........hehehhe

  • mas mgaling p c charice kesa s orig. singer..

  • Charice just released her second International album of original songs. The 1st was CHARICE in 2010 which made history breaking the US Billboard Top 10 by an Asian artist. It went Gold in Japan possibly Platinum by now. Charice's new album, INFINITY, was released in Japan last week and has been #1 on Japan iTunes sales all week. INFINITY releases in the US early 2012.

    Charice's concerts consistently sellout Worldwide & her 2 earlier Philippines albums both went Platinum there. Charice is great!

  • well from my investigations, most filipino celebrities hate charice because he had out done them in life, they can never get to her level in 200 years, she is the best, but they should be proud because a young girl from The Philippines got this far, now the only thing I hate about Charice is she does not have her own songs, she makes it out of other peoples songs, oh comon, real superstars sing their own songs, but anyway, she sings good, maybe she doesn't think she can make better songs.

  • You hate Charice? You prefer the original song?

    Now tell me, do you have that powerful voice like them? If you have, then make a video response here. Psshhhhh c'mon people. Shallow people!