Marilyn Manson Personal Jesus Live Mtv rock

[aquileschillo]

si canta bn chido en vivo no se por k el play pack

[VictorSimplePlan10]

It's playback because of the shit of MTV stupid guys Marilyn Manson always sing in real!

[BullsNay]

im so turned on..

[alexanrios]

Orgullo Gay, super gay¡

[666cafe666]

Satan has left

[lesliburton]

I am not a fan, but i must say that this song has really got something... awesome!! :)

[SkullOfBlueDiamonds]

No se como se deja actuar en playback

[pankamyk]

I'm a fan of MM but playback will be always just playback

[1992punkk]

gay tu mama oe tarao que ablas...¡¡ si no te gusta para que carajos miras

[gianthrasher]

WTF playback!!!!



[eueuezzzzz]

O GAY MAS ADMIRADO DO MUNDO.

[Slikrik1212]

Kid in the front row there has a kind of "Clockwork Orange" thing going on...lol.

[pepevergalarga]

QUE INMUNDICIA, NADA QUE VER CON DEPECHE MODE

[mmsidwilson]

@pepevergalarga y obvio ,son 2 bandas totalmente diferentes.

[davidolivosjardines]

@pepevergalarga mira si no tegusta no andes de inche criticon de ........

[annYeManson]

@pepevergalarga ¬¬ Obvio no tiene nada que ver con depeche mode porque ellos cantan electronic, MANSON ES METAL INDUSTRIAL! lml POSEEEER! :D

[toppinen19]

Poxa...Colocaram playback....mas antes colocar a versão de quando ele cantou lá na mtv...

[fazolin21]

play back

u.u

[ffffrfify]

ridiculo esse cara



[toppinen19]

@ffffrfify ridiculo é o senhor que não sabe o que realmente é música

[TheZanches]

aaaaa t amo pero por ke coños ases playback

[inmacic]

che bestia sto merylin mason,ma muori stanico di merda

[261290]

@inmacic Marilyn manson satanico ahahaha

[JosephGarza07]

Lip singing?



[Diegomanson666]

EL MANSOOOOOOO TEMAAAAAAAA...!!!

[fuldeusuariocreado]

es un gran artista ste pavo

[BruceDead7]

logiko q é play back G_G

[metalman375]

eh...playback....

[luisin23able]

play back but very realistic and exciting

[luisin23able]

volta pro brasil manson back to brasil maaaanson I LOVE YOU FOREVER

[OffyWarner]

o mi god....Manson is very sexy!!!!!

[comadocometa]

QUE GAY SE VE

[GloowWhiite]

Playback ou montage ? .__. Ca s'voit trop que c'est pas du Live ! XD Il a une voix de droguer quand c'est du live :) Enfin bref , si c'est un montage , bravo , ça fait très réaliste ! :D

[lechatrockeur]

c du playback ou un montage?

[pezapesta]

puro playback. No es en vivo

[hustler1babe]

WOW I WOULD OF THOUGHT MANSON WOULD HAVE FUCKED IT UP REAL GOOD LIKE DO A "ASHLEY SIMPSON" ON PURPOSE :( DISAPPOINTING MR.MANSON :(((

[H4CKCID]

MM always sings in real. I guess this time he had a problem with his voice. Try to do 1/50 of what he did and then you'll be able to critic. Bbiaatch.

[hustler1babe]

@H4CKCID yeah maybe youre right

[Vertigo9907]

@H4CKCID I've been trying to find one of him not lip syncing this song and I've already found three in different places that he was.

[PsychoDragon18]

@H4CKCID

he never sings personal jesus live ;p always playbacking it. he did it without playback only once ^^

[RAMSEY1987]

i have flagged this up as inappropriate under the heading of spam miming in deed how shameful, everyone seems to say well its MTV what do u expect, but just type Depeche Mode live MTV it is not the channel but the artist choice to sing live or not.

[romulo1delgado]

Será que ele tá cantando mesmo?

[TheKuroiSheep]

Don't tell me he lip synced in this one. D:

[ThePSIKUS]

Bleh...playback



[131patriick]

sou do brazil e axo esse cara foda eele é mtt foda

[molkicebo]

Live versions are better.

If Brian's voice hasn't got a problem, they never do playback.

[ChrisCode97]

PlayBack!!!!

[RockOneDream]

1:17 Girl look like of video "tainted love"

[jennadesalvo]

I can not believe it but is true....all the audience are retarded!

[rolex182]

this is not MTV this is VIVA and VIVA is one of the bad music channels

[MrDeedra]

cos'e'?la caricatura 50enne di se stesso?? ma come lo conciano scusate? a me piace pure l'effetto del suono di come canta (perke' non e' la sua voce pulita) pero' mamma mia troppa roba ..troppo trucco troppo rosso,,,stendendo un velo pietoso sul completo

[electrizzadooo]

manson♥



[yannkomi]

I prefer DM version ... cause is not playback

[flowers1041]

love the song



[luissgonzalez96]

playback!!!

[murin1]

its just a fuckin plastic show for the fuckin plastic mtv for fuckin plastic people with fuckin plastic minds.

[brandon999bass]

wheres the bassist?

[DbaldyRAMMSTEIN]

@brandon999b

DEAD

[brandon999bass]

@DbaldyRAMMSTEIN :( was that a joke or for real

[DbaldyRAMMSTEIN]

@brandon999bass

no i was joking i don't even know who he is :)

[MrZorro7]

si vede lontano 30 km che canta in playback!!!

[MsBIBIBE]

хоть фанера но я я в ахуе)мля

[xXKittyTVXx]

aw D: NOW I'M SAD i think they forced him to do playback ..

[marckmcnevin]

@xXKittyTVXx

No1 forced him to playback anything he had the option to mime or not if he wanted to! Have you not seen the MUSE mtv video where they play "Feeling Good" and completly take the piss!? This whole video was complete bullshit, ginger fish was the only one doing any work! Manson was happy to mime away and the crowd loved it, shows the standard of todays society.

[blacklight141]

at 1:56

a piano in the camera

[SleepyBearAngomer]

Sry, but Depech Mode much better ;(

[lilbesho]

@SuperShayNicole too bad that now all the girls are listening to fucked up shit

[n2taki]

he had to do playback cus if ur so blind u cant see that they dont have bass player in this video.

[lilbesho]

whaaaaaat?! there were teen girls that actually listen to manson!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Mike0R2]

9 pessoas são grandes filhos da puta

[steinvader]

que FRESA

[Olivia7Shan]

i wish i could see his live concert someday

[Floudeuh]

This.. Is.. PLAYBAAAAAAAAAAAACK

[electracc]

Playback or no...I still love Ginger.

[RealShitCrew11]

love mason hate payback -.-

[Cherilyn20]

Marilyn ROCKKKKKKKKKKKKKS !

[Miomega122]

I would much rather listen to him perform the song live without any of this mtv editing shit.

God dammit, mtv.....

[BorrachoPuto]

It's not playback mtv edited it for tv... as usual.

[DeadKold]

everything is fake on MTV! DERP

[ikristyful]

Oh sooo hot!!!

[Giax3]

shit...playback

[alexxxbunocu]

best MM

[sunkadelic]

Some of you told this is playback but remember that tv often change real audio with recorded. This video doesn't any proof of fake voice. It's recorded video after postproduction. That's all.

[YesIam97M]

when you just miming to a already recorded song.

[TwilfsMind]

I love how the keyboard is on a swing

[stokventje]

mtv would never take the risk of live perfomances as it can fuck up the show , unless it's a live show ofcourse

[Antichrist2000]

Someone stop Ginger from nearing the edge of the stage!!!

[MrAnubuis]

he has to playback, cuz thats not his song, and if he dose sing it, and mess up he can get sued, i think.

[kenny131369]

@MrAnubuis nahh

[Titanikable]

Yes it can be playback but a song is very coool!M.M ruleeeeeeeeeez!=)

[V19torrent]

I don't know why, but he always uses a playback for this song. anyway marilyn manson should come back and do something big again! its hard to believe MTV actually used to play his stuff like 10 years ago.

[gothben]

What is he really lipsinging :O!!!!

[gorboy]

@gothben It's the show's editing. Sometimes they switch live audio with studio audio if the live audio doesn't sound like it should, which could be for a variety of reasons.

[Khryztyan5]

@1:56 looks like Gacy broke the camera LOL!!!

[elorie16lollee]

very cool!!!

[SatanasAngel]

a lot of european stations and mtv do the playback shit, manson surely didn't say "OH YEAH DO A FUCKING PLAYBACK" think about it.

[ema19zila]

You can see when you are injured ginger??? !!!

[shittybullshit]

Ginger Fish looks awesome in this

[XxHirohitoxX]

playback =P

[FollyxXxFallen]

He looks like a sexy Hugh Hefner. I wish they would stop zooming to that fucking kid with the hat on

[mrJabada]

i prefer depeche mode

[ninjaturtle7861]

@mrJabada well we prefer marilyn manson.

[AUSSIE90ify]

fucker it's a joke !!!!

[laXcarozon]

man is he awesome and talented in his own way

[DMFanXD]

omg ist 1:55 geil :D

[elpadre90ify]

saw saw saw SHOW SHOW !!!!!

[TheSilentAngel04]

is he lip-syncing?

[maynardsgaylover]

I think he's lip-synching. 

[xDkyubi666]

i love playback XD

[whatupdude96]

gingers drum set is fucked

[MexicanMolina]

1:55 EPIC STUPID FAIL XD!

[MexicanMolina]

0:55 That girls are... F u c k i n g?

[allthewaysaidnothing]

0:56 Those chicks look like they're ready to fuck. Thats why I love goth chicks.

[autenticoydecadente]

raios esto es un playback

[parisiteinfect]

girls say hes sexy because there wannabe emos and think cause something bad happened they hate life im not emo and manson rocks

[bootworked]

playback is so fake.... i wouln't accept to do it.

[Nuage13]

5stars !!!!

[LestatandBerial]

Skold's also doing back-up vocals on this.

[PEQUEDELAM]

Play Back!!!♦♫♫♫↓

Buuuu!!!

[MultiSpiT]

its not the original song

[NovacCky]

playback ;/;/;/;/

[Neverwinterman]

@NovacCky Its MTV, what would you expect? :/

[6633alex]

They recorded the song set?

[nenizandmicker]

Marilyn manso0n!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!

[xalver81]

jajajajajaja straoarctica10...me pregunto agobiantemente sin dormir con hojeras y una caja de klennex en mi mano y tirado en cama...seras jay lenno o acaso eres oprah o no mejor dicho el papa benedicto...porque con tu comentario me hace pensar que sip...terminaras con la carrera del reverendo...no ....no ....no ... no lo hagas por amor de dios no lo lo hagas...pedaso de invecil jajajajajaja

[fanofa7x]

Damn why did he playback!?

You didn't need to do that Manson...

[VenaVenable]

@fanofa7x

Because it is on television. Viva told him to sing with playback. I read it somewhere...

Big sorry for my grammar...

[rammstein2001]

@fanofa7x Ever thought he could have a cold? Rock stars are human. in that day maybe he couldn`t sing well, who knows

[bmxrider4ever]

@fanofa7x MTV does that for everyone

[ninjaturtle7861]

@fanofa7x mtv does that with all live bands. its stupid :/

[ElWeasle]

@fanofa7x All the live versions I've found of him doing this on Youtube are just mimed. The Letterman one has live vocals but most if not all the instruments are mimed. It's actually really fucking annoying.

[TheUnofficialTruth]

@fanofa7x

What is "Playback" ?

[cleven]

@fanofa7x mtv did that, it was probobly live to begin with

[brandon999bass]

@fanofa7x whats playback

[PanchoSlipknot97]

playback

[mandybabe555]

MM<3

[25Blugga25]

Why did you put the track on the live preformance? I wanna here this live, I can listen to the track on my iPod...

[IL10IN3IL19]

his lip singing py attention to the video u will see

[weemadjake]

nice performance.

[metalista6]

not playback!

[Gingersnap2323]

metalisa6 yes it is playback, are you stuck on stupid? I would also like to see him siging this "live"...because he isn't here...

[Stratoarctica10]

puto manson ya vi 5 videos de el por lo menos haciendo playback el jodido

esto va de cabeza a el documental de la caida de manson que estoy preparando :D

[m4r1lynm4n50n]

@Stratoarctica10 estas preparando un documental que se llama la caida de manson?? no, por favor!! no lo hagas, vas a terminar con su carrera!! no seas cruel!!

sabes la influencia que tendrias sobre todo esto? eres tan importante y reconocido que tu documental traspasaria fronteras y el vaticano te tomaria como su arma principal!!

no, la verdad que no...

*te mete el pene en la boca*

[shaggisvideos]

noo hijo de puta vendido de mierda jaja.

coimo va a hacer playback

buen.

[BEBESCY]

super¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

muy bueno

[IAmShobu]

was tim playing bass or guitar? There was no guitarist/bassist, depending what tim plaid :--D and i think its pogo? who is beating up the camera at 1:55-2:00

[ultrabagon]

I am pretty sure that Tim played bass here - this model of instrument he his holding during this performance is his Gretsch bass.

I also think that camera was hit by swinging keyboard:)

And this drumset is odd, as for me

[edgeoftheworld12]

Is this the performance Ginger got hurt at?

[elgrantubi]

y ke tiene ke sea play back hijos de puta ?

[godistv]

El playback se come al arte, a la música. Es como comprar un cuadro de Dalí falso. Aunque si haces esa pregunta, no creo que entiendas nada de música.

[Pi8ikorockas96]

this is playback!!

[slpk1109]

@Pi8ikorockas96 what do you mean wiht playback??

[Pi8ikorockas96]

@slpk1109 lyp-sync... im not beign judgimental, though, it's wasn't his choice. a tv-program has some rules

[Lemmingmurderer]

@slpk1109 its playback its obvious

[slpk1109]

@Lemmingmurderer ow now i get what you say wiht payback YEAHH dude is fucking fuck off:s

[robin310193]

jaja playback total!!!

[godistv]

menuda mierda, playback.

[EvELiNhAdAOsCuRa]

me ncanta mm es el mejor

superstar

[MarilynMM16]

no ma super 5 estrellas

nu me encanto super super video