Added: 5 years ago
From: scruffyonion
Views: 414,053
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (716)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • where did it all go wrong? some critics said be here now was bad... how wrong is the story of where did it all go wrong?

  • Feelin Supersonic while Rocking in your Rocking Chair. Bring it on.!

  • @0Kian0 i said to her to dont go away because she is eletric and i wanna talk tonight everything i didnt on the sunday morning call :) i tried

  • Where's Liam? .... I dont care.

  • Poor Liam... He will never be anything compared to Noel

  • @Davidbensonxyz this is true. I have much respect for Noel.

  • @supersesqui lol, you being here commenting on something that you suposedly don't like shows that there's a lot more than taste involved. Resentment? Envy? Why is that man? You sound like if the Gallaghers raped you when you were a baby, killed your dad and ran away with your mom. Like it or not, Oasis is a band with a big fuckin name in music history, and you whining on youtube about how theyre just a pair of "gobshites" wont change that fact one bit.

  • It´s Great! Noel Respect!

  • Abit like  The Beatkes song YESTERDAY, no one sings just listens to the woeds, GENIUS. Noel Gallagher should be a SIR.

  • @GODlikeGALLAGHERS

    Well he is nearly a Sir.....but with different spelling. He is a cur, along with the other mutant.

  • Geezer can sing

  • where did it all go wrong ?

    It started when their parents didnt use contaception and produced these two mancuntian twats !

    One twat trying to imitate John Lennon but without the talent or brains.

    Gobshites, the both of em.

  • @supersesqui Those "Gobshites" have gone further in the music industry than you have so, I don't mean to be rude of course, go fuck yourself.

  • @NeilK96

    Justin Beiber has gone further than I have, bet you like him too. He is a little twat.

    They are still gobshites. And you have been rude....so now you are an eejit too.

  • @supersesqui Being an eejit seems to be a habit of mine..... and no I do not like Bieber and I too think he is a gobshite. Your opinions on oasis are crap but I suppose I can't change them. Quick question though, why did you watch this if you don't like them?

  • @NeilK96 @NeilK96

    Volume was turned down(obviously)......

    and thought it was the puppet from Thunderbirds that had been animated.

    Realising it wasnt ......I just thought I would opine.

    As you are in the NE I suppose most things would pass for entertainment ? lol

    But I do suggest you look back at the last 80 years of European music to get an eclectic overview.

  • @supersesqui How is he trying to immitate John Lennon? Lets face it, you dodged his question with a weak sarcastic remark, your clearly watching the video in the first place because you wanted to hear the song, otherwise you just wouldn't have clicked it. Me hints a little wift of jealousy.

  • @itsonlyjammy

    Liam Gallagher claims he has been touched by Lennon's spirit and insists working at the Fab Four's Abbey Road studio was spritual.

    William John Paul "Liam" Gallagher (born 21 September 1972).

    Patsy Kensit bore Gallagher a son named ''Lennon'' Francis in September 1999.

    Now, ...go back and look at your question....

  • Comment removed

  • i want to use a transform button , to switch on and to brainwash all the fuckers that didnt like this

    NOEL i want to marrie you!!!!! youre brilliant!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!1

  • i love this man

  • Noel you beaten The Beatles, your our God, We honuor you KNIGHTED.

  • A musical wizard at work, picked my life back up.

  • AMAZING!

  • God, it's just so beautiful....

  • JUST PERFECT.

  • Anyone else just sitting in the kitchen drinking and smoking and listen to old ass oasis? I´ll be doing this in 40 years, and I´m 30 now lol.

  • listening to Noel gave me goosebumps...he's sooooo good

  • by fuck this song is just so good!

  • Amazing this song, it should be one of his biggest hits!

  • precious 

  • And people say this album was shit...this is some of his very best work.

  • ooooohoho brilliant stuff. his new song is one of the best he's ever written but i like listening to the tunes that never really took off. like this, sunday morning call, gas panic, ect ect

  • beermusic

  • haha ! Amazing :p I have been listening to this EXACT version of the song for years. And this is the first video I see of the song ^^

  • The voice in the chorus is hitting my hart so hard!

  • The best !!

  • amazing song ,amazing singer!

  • why did he sing behind his brother all those years?

  • Comment removed

  • Noel's voice is better, but he's not even close to having the same edge as Liam does. Liam sings rock'n'roll songs better than anyone, atleast he used to.

  • The best voice in the whole world.

  • to this day i still don't understand why this album got slated..it's fucking amazing!

    i think it was because of liams little james effort,,which was pretty shit,

  • this man changed my life and helped me get out of a really hard time in life! live forever noel! thank you sir noel!

  • It's a nice sounding song, but the lyrics are pretty spiteful hahahaha

  • type in "repeat" after youtube and before dot com. and you can listen all day <3

  • @halknut Noel is Oasis ;)

    Don't take it so bad, i'm just kidding and that's what I think, you can think whatever you want.

  • Haunting.

  • poetry init

  • This is why Noel is amazing! He's in a room full of people, hours away, in another decade...and yet it's like he's right here singing to me....time and distance has no affect on this man....words can not explain....

  • My favorite song from Standing on the Shoulders. I think it's one of the most underrated albums of all time. This song, this version, it's spectacular for sure.

  • @Jrryjnsn22

    yeah great song,sunday morning call was my fave out the 2 though.

  • I mean seriously...what a tune. Totally underated

  • This is amazing acoustic. Love it more than the recorded one. I will never get tired of Noel's voice.

  • wow, this is perfection. oh my god.

  • Hope Noel's new album whenever it comes out is just pure acoustic!

  • Who's Liam? What's a Beady eye? Noel all the way!!!

  • @sa65cn1 haha, I agree Noel >>>> Liam, and to prove that I even thumbed you up... but come on let's be fair here, Beady Eye has more than half of the personnel of the band that made Oasis and although Noel's missed sorely you've gotta admit that Beady Eye's brought out some good dough too...

    After all there's Gem Archer, Andy Bell and Chris Sharrock in there with Liam too aren't they?

  • @sa65cn1 Fuck off bitch and don't make sides!

  • @sa65cn1 oasis all the way

  • @sa65cn1 hahaha

  • @sa65cn1 o come on noel was an ass whole

  • @sa65cn1

    who the fuck are you ? all the thumbs down!

  • @sa65cn1

    Liam is the DUDE who made OASIS ROCK SENSATION

    GO GET A COCK

  • @DurtyHarrys

    you fucking twat

    get the facts right

    Noel Made Oasis

    Liam with hes voice made OASIS SENSATION

  • @sa65cn1

    you fuck off with your comment ALL THE WAY

  • He is wonderful. Not sure of cause for fights with brother. Liam comes off as a jerk.

  • Superb track. Stunning version.

  • how amazing. Love this.

  • From the fall then...Magic starts.

  • NOEL= GOD.

  • Oasis > Beatles > Jesus

  • noel gallagher has written so many great songs, the critics never give him enough credit, his songs means more to me than any of todays crap bland pop music ever could, he changed my life, his music spoke to a generation, gave us all hope. Noel Gallagher you are a legend! and i look forward to the solo album :)

  • Oasis were the band of this generation, their records will be played for a very long time unlike most of todays so called musicians ie Britney Spears etc.

  • Comment removed

  • @e1994y nonsese, he wrote one great album, one good one, then a load of very average stuff that people criticised and lost in interest in during his lifetime. They'll be at the top end of the B list, no more, no less.

    They weren't able to innovate enough or release new, challenging music to be in the A list. Especially the last few albums, which were basically, with a few songs excluded, a self-parody.

  • @THthefirst Bullshit. Self-parody my ass.

    Don't Believe the Truth and Dig Out Your Soul were great albums. And Dig Out Your Soul, in particular was a far step from what they had done previously.

    Only the ignorant would say differently...which would be you.

  • @THthefirst You dont know what your talking about you muppet. I could go on but I cant be arsed.

  • @noeski100 wow, what a well expressed counter-argument and comeback you make. Well done.

    And by the way, that view on Oasis is hardly controversial - one great album (DM) one good album (WSMG) and the rest being hit and miss, with people apart from the hardcore fans losing interest (as evidenced by the record sales reducing) and the band splitting. Lots of other people have said the same thing, so get over it. And "muppet" - what, are you a mockney in Lock Stock or something?

  • @THthefirst Here we go, yet another idiot with too much time on his/it's hands, fishing for arguments on the net.... While your wasting your life away on your PC, your missus is getting served by the next door neighbour mate... If she hasn't left you already.....Bet she's loving it............

  • @noeski100 It takes two people to have an argument and you've contributed to it with your replies.  Just accept that I have a different opinion to you, which is fine, as it's a free country. You can think what you like about Oasis. I disagree. If you can't deal with that, on you tube for god's sake, then you're the one that needs to get a life.

    I wouldn't say a 20 second post is exactly wasting my life away, either.

  • @noeski100 It's "you're", by the way. Why is that every advocate of Oasis who claims they are the best band ever, is also normally unable to master simple English.

    I bet you find grammar and correct spelling boring, don't you? Probably why you failed at school.

  • @THthefirst We could argue about the concept of great, good, or bad. But that's subjective. About the sales, if you use your head, just a little bit, for...Lets say: Think. You would realise, that something like, well...The internet. Would, I don't know, well, remotelly...Reduce. Album sales, for, lets say...Well, basically, everyone.

  • @Luk3892 I used to love Oasis - in the early days, I mean - and when I listen to stuff from around 95-96 (ie. Def Maybe, the B sides and some morning glory stuff) I see a massive difference in quality, passion, meaning and integrity from the stuff they did in the last few years. That's not to say the recent stuff was bad, I don't think it was, I just think they lost their way and repeated similar ideas and became obsessed (esp Liam) with Lennon, which was embarrasingly tedious.

  • @THthefirst The early stuff is amazing. But, both "Be Here Now", and "Standing On The Shoulder of Giants" are amazing aswell. Songs like this one from the video, and "Gas Panic!", are as good or better than the ones from the first two albums. But they are in fact, a lot less comercial. "Heathen Chemestry" and "Don't Believe The Thruth" are almost a "self-parody", as you said. And "Dig Out Your Soul" is a good album, different from everything they made before.

    But I got your point.

  • @Luk3892 It's subjective, though, isn't it? You think BHN was "amazing", which is fine, but the band, esp NG detest it, saying it was written on coke and there was no quality control, so that NG got to the point where he couldn't be bothered to finish songs and just said "that will do". It also sold far less than the other two albums (though did well) and was critically panned for being bloated, pretentious and lacking in soul. I thought BHN was the self-parody album to be honest.

  • @THthefirst Noel was never a good referencial on what's is good or bad on his own stuff, take "The Masterplan" as an example of that. He hate Be Here Now because it reminds him of the time he as addicted to coke.

    Definitely Maybe is Rock N' Roll, with elements of hard and punk rock. (WTS)MG is pure Britpop. But BHN is pratically all psychedelic.

  • @THthefirst If we have in mind that, the last Oasis album before napster sold, I don't know, lets say something like, over one millions copies in the first two weeks. We could consider that my crazy idea, makes a little bit of sense.

  • What do sales have to do with anything? The Spice Girls sold lots of records, it doesn't make them good. The Sun outsells the Times 5-1 but it doesn't make it better, and if Hamlet was performed by the RSC on BBC2 at the same time as Eastenders, the latter would have many more viewers.

    Even if you look at sales, you see that even Oasis fans bought fewer albums at the years went on.

  • @THthefirst You brought sales to the subject, not me.

  • @THthefirst Sorry sunshine. I dont agree. 99.9 % of bands could make a great living from the B sides that Oasis have released. You are wrong, they are colossal. Discuss.

  • Noel >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> GOD

  • I don't know how he does it, but noel seems to find away to make even the most sad song, sound oddly uplifting?

  • I was at this show as well. Won my tickets on Radio 1. The first of many times I saw them over the next 9 years.

  • Do you keep the receipts..... for the friends that you buy....

    lyrical genius.

  • :)

  • watch?v=46CNp89_52Y

  • how cuould 19 people not like this,its fucking amazing

  • Lush!! remember back home watching this years ago... I'm sure Liam was suppose to be there with you but he was to out of it... Noel You Rocked it Mate... as always...Please get the music back on.. I'm now living in the U.s now ..and eveyone knows you.. But it's always the same thing.... Liam caused to many issues here... Give it a go again... : )

  • @leighandcallum liam was there,this is the later with jools holland show not MTV Unplugged where liam didnt sing....I was at both of them shows too!!!! i'm on the end of this vid,guy with shaved head clapping!!!! yeahh.

  • @uglybus7 woooooooow i admire you really....unfortunately i could never see oasis in argentina cos i started to listen to them just after they split up.

    hope noel is gonna do a solo career.

  • Dai, come non si fa a mettere mi piace è folle...

  • Although everyone prefer Noel, I think Liam's songs are much better...

  • @annMarieWow

    erm yeah...like the 1 or 2 that liam wrote...please

  • @zarni000 well Im sure they meant, songs Liams sings not necessarily wrote. But your another naive idiot who thinks the only songs Liam wrote are Songbird and Little James, aren't yer? ha'way man.

  • @GavOasis

    well thanks for calling me names. even if i thought so that doesn't make me one. it does make you look like a twat for assuming that though.

  • i lost my verginity with this song....O.o

  • genius!!!

  • I bought an epiphone hummingbird after watching this, obviously the frontier was slightly beyond my budget

  • @TheMrDobbins I got a hummingbird really dont like it, find it heavy and nothing special to play. I the nicest guitar I got is an old 1970's MIJ acoustic nice woods paid £20 for it with a broken bridge nicer than the custom OM i got to

  • @rhysvw I'm not a huge fan of it either but after 10 years i've become quite attached to it. The crappy sratchplate had to go though...

  • Fantastic. Beautiful. Stupendous. Epic. Amazing. The few words that came into my head when I heard this. LOVE YOU NOEL.

  • A lot of reverb on the guitar solo, maybe too much, it could be louder too.

  • Just amazing!!! Maybe this version better!!!

  • This man isn't given the credit he deserves. His songs uplifted a generation. Living legend.

  • @onlyeye1 he is totally given the credit he deserves, anyone with a brain know that oasis were the best rock and roll band in the world, truly amazing lyricist with an amazing voice - come on Noel we need your solo material! nothing out there can touch your talent. boring summer without you. x

  • hurry up and get new tunes out noel, the music scene is a fucking shambles just now

  • Love the acoustic version!

  • amazing performance , amazing song, amazing lyrics, amazing vocals...this song just kills me...this man is pure class...he just sings it from the heart....long live noel gallagher

  • New and upcomming Indie pop rockers!

    youtube.com/user/mylittleempir­e2010?feature=mhum

    Check us out and subscribe!

  • Beautiful ;D

  • All went wrong when you left Oasis!!!

  • @UtwoOneMaster He will make better things without Oasis. Im sure i would of done the same thing being around a CUNT like Liam.

  • @TheUnknownGeezer

    I'm sure. I wait his solitary album........;) I don't have very hope in beady eye...

  • only 280,000 views ......Shame on you!

  • God!

  • @Ironchefpizza shut up.

  • GOD 

  • Could listen to Noel do acoustic all day long.

  • @Dillinger1977 I have.

  • @Nayyfz if you havent already search for setting sun/fade in out, at budokan uploaded by basszamegpeti, its superb.

  • @Dillinger1977 I've seen that and then learnt it on guitar! Absolutely brilliant stuff.

  • @Dillinger1977 I could listen to Noel take a shit all day long.

  • "you know that feeling you get when you feel your older than time " that tells me get up and do what the hell you want now and dont leave it for it gets to late!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • The solo in this song is awesome

  • fantastic lyrics!!!!! Thankyou Mr Gallagher

  • fantastic lyrics!!!!!

  • ryan,,,,,,, FULL ON ? should of been on this album come on who have 2 b messing a b side thats about it oh it was a b-side just about it was getting scrapped it was put on instead of a remix of 1 of there sondgs

  • Gênio!!

  • love this song!

  • first time i hear this song and.. WOW...I'm impressed!

  • this is the first time i ever heard this song before and i already love it!

  • in noel gallagher we trust.. he is a true legend and best of songwriter of my generation

  • love this song

  • this is proper special, loving it!!!

  • /watch?v=p7hGCYcfk0I

  • This song is so personal. We all have the occasional "where did it all go wrong" moment. Sometimes you can have it all and realize that it's not what you thought it would be. Beautiful.

  • il piu grande cantautore degli ultimi 20 anni......

  • @GabryC1979 hai detto proprio bene,cazzo ci so cresciuta con loro XD

  • flashbax, the fame and i will believe are all class songs.i guess they should have replaced i can see a liar and put your money where yer mouth is on SOTSOG.but then again i love the feel of the album.so mellow and chilled out compared to (the brilliant) be here now which is full of in your face guitar riffs

  • this is fukn amazing, noel is the greatest

  • SOTSOG is such an under-rated album

  • absolute genius 1 of ma fav songs ever

  • Why this wasn't the album version is beyond me.

  • Liking the piano in this version...gives the song a haunting sound, beautiful stuff!

  • I've listened to quite a few Oasis tracks to see what all the fuss is about and if I'm being generous it seems they've 'written' about two songs- most of the stuff is very much samey. How they think any comparison between them and the Beatles can be made just shows how up their own backsides they are.

  • @Modonaut57 Ssshhhhh.

    You suck.

    Noel is a genius.

  • @Modonaut57 seriously sounds the same to you? im mean they have a few songs that do sound alike but i would NOT say they have 'written' 2 songs. you need to listen to some other albums then. It's also jus tthe sounds they have.

    or maybe it's just cuz i love them so much but im sure im not the only one.

  • @Modonaut57

    2 songs? you dickhead

  • Am I gonna mis his whining git of a brother - think not!!!

  • Ive listened to oasis for time but this past year it has really changed my life it sort of become my life ive never heard this song but man its spine tingling noel gallagher is such an inspiration amazing how one man and his guitar can captivate you and hold you there in the palm of his hand truely truely amazing what a legend. thank you.

  • Rock Today Is Dead I Think Oasis Was The Last Real Rock Band (The Best One Too!)

  • B-e-a-utiful.

  • shivers down my spine

  • shivers down my spine...

  • Noel Gallagher - the most talented man ever