Added: 4 years ago
From: sonia1234321
Views: 57,311
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (296)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • you call yourself an honour band?!?!?!  My band in seventh grade sounded better......

  • I want my school to perform this that would be EPIC!

  • Are any of you (that are bad mouthing this band) even remotely considering that the mic on that camera is crap cuz these kids are really good.

  • FAIL!!!!!!!!!!!

  • nice... nice,,,,,,,,,,,

  • What a Gutsy Effort with a MOST difficult piece of (famous) Music ! Well Done :)

    From the alternating subtle&delicate-to-strong strings & woodwinds, to dynamic brass&percussion leads&mixes, multi-harmonies & changing lilt overall,

    this is a most challenging composition for ANY Band or Orchestra - considering

    Joel Goldsmith SIMULATED a real 80-piece symphony orchestra(via SYNTHESIZER palette) for the TV series ie.no human error.Always room for Improvement tho.Keep Practising & check tuning :)

  • Jaffa kree! 

  • WAT!?

  • nice you ruined a song

  • This is the honor band?!

  • what the frak wa that???!!! it sounded like some sort of elementary school music class trying out random instruments in "music time."

  • JESUS...JUST stop....

  • that i wanna hear in a opera :D

  • gd attempt but the second bit of music after the theme is not part of it

  • @dazlovescarter The second part after the Main Theme is part of the music from the pilot of the TV show. I have TV CD and they're playing the music part where Samuels and his driver are pulling up to Jack's house. At least that's what I see in my head when I hear it. LOL Other than that, yes, it was a good attempt to play it.

  • @BoothsLuver yea i know the second part was when jack was on his roof lookin at the stars

  • Sorry, I correct myself on Tip 4. It's not the oboe player that needs replacing. But the trombones need to pick up their act. And coming from a trombonist of over 10 years... saying that makes me sad. My high school band won awards... we'd have never settled for anything like this.

  • Tip 1: Make sure you have all tuned to the concert band C Major first (Bb major for some instruments.)

    Tip 2: When it says 'forte' that does not mean everyone. I can't hear half the parts because another section (woodwind anyone?) is drowning them out. Do they even have a trombone player playing?

    Tip 3: The conductor needs to learn balancing of instruments.

    Tip 4: Replace the oboe player.

    Tip 5: Practice a lot more using tips 1, 2, 3 and 4. A LOT.

  • @Neferlue Haha ! Trumpet players need to practice too because they seem a little...shy ^^

    But you're right, all instruments are not tuned, and the arrangement is not perfect...

    Anyway, good idea to play the Stargate theme with a "junior" band ! :)

  • I say tune and sync, I say!

  • Not too terrible at all.

  • Comment removed

  • Bravo très bien jouer!!! ;)

  • I'm glad they tried because I L-O-V-E anything Stargate, but they need WAY more practice.

  • Good attempt...

  • God I fucking miss SG-1

  • Better than that God awful Halo one.

    Still awful, though.

  • Props to the Oboe player... =)

  • That's a bit strange, but I like it

  • PARE LA BANDA DI SANTU COSIMO E DAMIANO. THEME STUPENDO ROVINATO!

  • Cool. To all who clicked dislike: Make a better SG-music-Video, then complain

  • Horrible

    

  • @Nandian90 A ver, tanto como horrible tampoco. Si tenemos en cuenta los instrumentos que se han utilizado y que la joven edad de los miembros de la orquesta, está bastante bien. Lo cierto es que no cabe esperar una mejor interpretación.

    Desde mi punto de vista, lo han hecho muy bien.

  • My ears are bleeding. XP

  • really you are going to do this song and you even didn't go into the high register. it was ok

  • lol , is very good XD

  • I will admit it is a good effort.

    Well done. Not perfect but hey...

  • This is high school band. Not exactly the best sound or professional, but big deal. I wished I had an opportunity to play this.

  • StarFail

  • This was very well done :0 Good job!

  • 61 people have no taste in music

  • Professor needs to work with them more on keeping things in tune. Pretty good otherwise, I wish we'd played stuff like this when I was taking band.

  • Look all thoose haters! This is actually pretty good for a highschool band, I find it good. some of them played some parts wrong and yes awful but in general this is really good for a school band.

    And the best part is the chef letting students play something cooler then classic shitty high school band musics.

  • @napalmstrike2007 ...not really. My school's band would be embarrassed to play like this. My god this is reedy.

  • @DraikSpectre maybee you are right :D I was also playing clarinette 5 years ago(before I started the high school) and I was better than these kids. but still, some of them have some potential(maybee)

  • Too. Many. Woodwinds.

    Brass needs to come out a lot more to compensate for low numbers. And it could flow a lot better.

    That being said...yay Stargate!

  • Even an elephant can sing better.

  • I can tell that band is pretty heavy in being terrible.

    Ugh. Thanks for ruining it.

  • I can tell that band is pretty heavy in woodwinds.

  • wooo squawky sax at the beginning lmao

  • strange, but its ok :D

  • Why am I reading this and seeing people compare this to the quality of the theme on tv? Do you people honestly think what looks to be at best a highschool honor band could come close to that? Just enjoy the young musicians and their efforts rather than taking some uselessly critical perspective.

  • Pain in the ass

  • ahhhh! my ears!

  • Ugh ugh ugh

  • He might be the worst conductor I've ever seen. *I think I do it by waving my arms randomly* Aside from him, I think they might've done better.

  • I personally really like this, thanks for putting this up. Still, I think the SG-1 version on television is much better, mostly because it has better instruments (though I don't even really know what they are). Though I think themes are usually too short (since I love them so much...) I think this version is really dragged out (since its twice as long as the TV version) and goes for 40 seconds after I thought it ended.

  • @ValosTaonas this isn't the tv version, it's the piece from the original film, not too bad for a high school group methinks.

  • @wilddoguk Oh, I feel kind of ignorant. I HAVE watched the original film though.

  • Listening to this makes me want to run through a stargate away from this lol

  • @redstormfighter29

    It makes you run trough the stargate on the wrong side... :D

  • LOVE this!

  • Nice, good job, but, why is it communists who are playing?

  • good on them for picking up a stargate theme, could use more practice but definitely cool

  • ufff they need more Practice...

  • THIS is an Honor Band? this is TERRIBLE!!! they killed the song. out of tune, not all together, bad balance!

  • not bad.. its to slow. but not bad

  • they played this theme song at my school it was awesom

  • you killed the show!!!

  • have they ever heard of a tuner?

  • lmaol i love it.. i have that theme song on my phone lol (yes im a proud nerd)

  • Oh god I love it :D

  • this is the worst what I heard about stargate

  • I wonder what was the teacher thinking...

  • @TheCoCkTa1l "kill me, kill me now!

  • @TheCoCkTa1l I thinks he commited a suicide... lol

  • good job

  • : )

  • it's a gathering of the nerds, i need to go there now, ilo use some asgard beaming te chno, i dont listen to japansise

  • deosnt sound the same

  • That's because they arent using professional recording equipment or mics n mixing. It's cam corded lol

  • It isn't perfect by anyone's means, but it is still incredible. I wanna see more videos like this one!

  • That is sooo cool, i wish we did it in our band

  • GREAT!!!!!!

  • good job! i LOVE stargate sg-1!!!!

  • Great nice band!

  • Not bad but the wind instruments at the beginning, i.e the trumpets should have been a little more dominant =-/

  • Thank you. This is GREAT!!!

  • They have done such a great job! God, i rememeber when i was in the school brass band, those were the days

  • Not that bad for a school band. Not too bad at all :|. Maybe they could've done the second half faster.. but not bad.

  • I wish I had this music for euphonium! Im first chair in centx and this would be so cool to play with the other Brass Players and Clarinets!!! Amazing!!!!!!!! :D

  • great job, but its not a Band, its a Orchester

  • Did you mean:

    Orchestra?

    Also, in Junior and High schools, "Bands" are anything that doesn't have singing or string instruments.

  • Just an FYI, I'm not seeing any strings, what do you mean orchestra. 2ndly, a string bass is often added to bands in high school and they are still bands.

  • I agree with most of these guys. I think it was a god attempt, but they weren't on time, were a little slow, and were a little out of tune. But I want my schools band to attempt it.

  • Oh it seems so great, please record it with something better.

  • Their good, the cancorder was bad.

  • This was really good! To all you fucking haters out there, the microphone on the camcorder is what is fucking up the sound quality... know your sound recording before flame talented musicians.

  • Here here! :D They have done a great job!

  • This is honor band?? They need to work on playing in sync..then again it looks like it is hs so....

  • lol this sounds really bad! they need a lot more training.

  • I love this song but they were really bad at keeping toegher tune and it was really slow! Sorry I give you a thumbs down :(

  • too slow lol.

  • I don't want to hurt anymore, the music is great and all but they are really BAD!!!

  • indeed

  • @csrtitus Best joke ever.

  • ... now that the tuner has been perfected i think they'll be fine

  • Stargate ftw.

  • pretty good.. but they played very slow

  • Lol, that reminds me so much of my conductor. Pretty good, opening was a little shaky, and too much clarinet, but good.

  • @WammyHouseProduction It's a high school band I'm guessing. There is ALWAYS too much clarinet.

  • very impressive

  • this rocks on very good way

  • adorei! parabéns!

  • Wow.......for some students at a random school.....how they played it kicks ass,i loved it :D

  • EPIC!

  • :) this is excellent.

    stargate = love

  • harry potter playing the clarinet on the left

  • @chk428 lol

  • @chk428 really?

  • @chk428

    lol you are so damned right there..lmao :)

  • Ow my ear it hurts. A tha tha

  • AWESOME

  • THATS FROM SG1 CHILDREN OF THE GODS

  • i am a massive stargate fan that was amazing, CAN YOU DO STARGATE ATLANTIS,THANKS

  • Really painful. have shattered the song.

  • im trying to get my orchestra to play this...the conductor is looking for it at the mo...

  • we'd rock this out

  • The original theme song also had violins in there, too.

  • wow,im in symphonic band right now, so i can honestly say that this was bad, and i'm also a clarinet, and can say...too much clarinet, lol

  • Yuck. Bad. I mean, it is OK for the age group (by looks anyways) but it really does needs improvement. Woodwind tambour is terrible.

  • awful, too many instruments, and dam clarinets

  • >.> whats wrong with clarinets? if there isnt a lot of them you can't hear us!

  • can't help stopping all the volunteers wanting to play this awsome piece though.....

  • 'twas very coolio! :D

    The  main part was amazing. The rest, shaky but good!

    Loved it!

  • .....Needs some work. Lol

  • wow...too much clarinet.....

  • maybe should have been an little higher but still good 4*

  • Actually, I thought about it, and it would do with some improvements. My ears kinda hurt the second time I heard it.

  • Cool. Nice. Stargate fans?

  • I wonder who's idea this was. Very well done, but there's always room for improvement! :D

  • Why didn't they use a Flute!!!

  • It's okay, just VERY out of tune and needs a lot more work

  • My ear drums just ruptured listening to this...they need LOTS more practice xD

  • That's because of the lacky recording :-(... I bet the play was good ;o!

  • oh mein gott!

    des klingt in meinen augen scheiße

    einsätze verpasst

    falsche töne

    keine gleichbleibende geschwindigkeit.....

    OMG^^

  • Great effort, but the band at my middle school could have done better.

  • Comment removed

  • it needs to be more higher pitched and more on tone

  • its ok just 2 years more practise!

  • wow. that's bad. my high school band is way better than this. i have vids on my profile. check us out!

  • The music they are reading is wrong.

    They are playing the theme from the show but with the notes from the movie.

    In the SG-1 theme, the next to last note in the repeating part of the main body should be a whole-step higher than they play.

  • Just curious... where was this?

  • ouch!

    just, ouch

  • Comment removed

  • Kotzgurke2 vllt iegts an den aufnahmen (ich hoffe es)

  • lol good effort.

  • I agree,good effort.

  • die spielen in mill nich tin in dur wie das stück eigentlich gespielt werden sollte

    Its in moll and not in dur.

  • die spielen aber nicht sehr gut

  • where can i buy the sheet ?

  • Not only is nobody in tune, none of the instruments play together.

  • give 'em a break. they're just kids :P

  • great!

  • OMFG theyre out of time as well

  • awful

  • something in this band is not in tune can't put my finger on it

  • It is slightly off, on the tempo and many of the blowing instruments (don't know which ones). It could have used more spirit and fine tuning. As a whole it was alright though.

  • Schoolbands ALWAYS sound out of tune.

  • Bleh, if I was a music director of a school band I could make them sound good...

  • its all of it

  • um Gottes willen ist der Dirigent taub oder was...

  • Good work :D

  • rockin

  • wow good job

  • Hamma!

  • grausam!!!

  • Sorry, aber da muss ich zustimmen, vollkommen grausam!