Added: 4 years ago
From: PUNXandDRUNX
Views: 8,233
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (124)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Fuckin' awesome

  • its sad how such a great band with such great idologies can be stareotyped into a subculture of people (skinheads) who are not anywhere near on the same level as this band

  • @Bakery994

    It's also sad that people don't know the roots of the skinhead culture enough to know that it was never a racist movement.

  • DIY video as fuck! Thanx for doing this! loved the song always!

  • This song is so fucking true.The "Hate Crime Laws" in place, discriminate against white people. The law is a hate crime itself.

  • Your right you personally have nothing to do directly with what happen before being born, but it doesn't mean that you can't learn to think in the same way your recent ancestors did. And that's why I think AA's are angry to begin with. After the brave sacrifice by Caucasian and African-Americans. AA's had to struggle continuously til this day. Even though you may not notice the systematic imbalance toward Minorities in general it doesn't,however,make it disappear.

  • I'm genuinely sorry that some of you feel that way. I mean back in the day when black people were fighting for freedom there were white people there fighting on their side and dying along with them. I hope for the day that all of this crap is just left in the past. We can't change what happened only what will happen.

  • 15 years ago I went to summer school after my 9th grade year, in a high school in my area. I was the ONLY white kid there. O N L Y People there knowing I had a black stepdad nearly got me lynched. A half-black baby sister,.. yup almost got me and her killed on more than 1 occasion. My sister caught hell from blacks, whites, and everyone in between. Racism is a stupid tool no matter who is using it, and it's only use is to control people dumb enough to follow it's manipulator.

  • man this is great i go to a school that's like 50-70% black I don't know really but this is how I feel.

  • @GATORSLP31 Thats the plan. If you havent noticed there is a smear campaign against white males. 

  • You're also guilty of writing a terrible song and for inspiring this kid to make a video to go along with it.

  • aside from petty arguing, the song kicks ass.

  • also hitler was jewish

  • aaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­h:

    NO!  NO! and like:

    No!

    What?

    Go catch a book, stop watching what ever made you belive that sort of moron bullshit.

    and anyways : THIS whole Discussion is not about 3.Reich , it`s about Slave- Labours .

    In the U.S. of A.

    The ones that freed my Country from Nazi-Scum.

  • for you idiots talking shit abotu the song, numebr one its by Minor Threat, number two it was writen because the singer grew up in a neighborhood that treated white people as slave owners, and number 3 the song isnt for being white, its for being open minded and not racist, and four slavery hasnt been banned, at least not in all the world, no matter what they say.

  • you're right, all peoples have been wronged at some time or another. I am of American Indian descent, and my mother and grandmother have explained to me that some of our ancestors were slaves.

  • lol not really pissedOFFTV..... this song is actually beccause hitler he was white and he was killing all the jewss, so they say that white people dont like black or brown or yellow or whaterver sayin that there rasict and because of hitler he says minor threat says that dont call um racist because it was like a million before he was born white people ar diffrent people now and thats the song about im sorry for something i didnt do. because it was hitler and years before hewas born white ar diff

  • but wasnt it the guy who wrote the song that explained what i said in american hardcore? and he explaind the song and then said how some white pride dumbass thought it was abotu white pride

  • well not really how your accplaining it. it is however like what ur sayin but i just said all the wrest that u missed lol

  • fuck it, its too damn impossable for anyone to ever agree on any of the history on punk rock ha

  • lol true dat bro

  • all the races have had slavery of all other races at one time or another. white people are the first to be in total control and relinquish it. that's why i don't feel guilty, besides the "it happened a hundred years ago" reason.

  • that's not true. It was much more prevalent in the Orient than it was in the Europe OR the new world.

  • Not ALL white people wanted slavery.

    Blaming white people for racism is stupid unless the person truely is a racist.

    Nice song though 5/5

  • ...for some odd reason this vid is really entertaining. :/

  • who care's when it was bannend ? it's over 100fucking years ago let it go.... get over it ! get a life !

  • "115 years, 3 Month, 2 Days , 8 hours and 17 seconds before i was born "........... pfffff. Fuck It.

  • ok banned in 1965. Mbaey he should say " 115 years before i was born" it wouldnt work saying that

  • 100 years?

    slavery was legally banned in 1865 but it continued in the form of 'sharecropping' in the South.

    things only got better since the 1960's during Civil Rights Movement and stuff...

  • The guy who wrote the song was born in the 1960's and he is taking about slavery not indentured servitude. Extremely different.

  • don't worry all white people get generalized for being racist towards blacks just like all blacks get generalized for being hooligan gangsters who where chains like 50 cent, the truth is its only some individuals who do this but then everyone gets blamed.

  • I am apperently guilty of being white.

    Don't know why, maybe because I was, you know, born white, so I'm automatically labeled as the uber-racist, PLUS Im blonde, so I'm considered perfection in the eyes of Nazis.

    WOW, great time to be I guess :D!!!

  • And the guy who wrote this thought his 70% black classmates were being racist twoards him for being white and in the song he explains its not his fault 100 years ago fucking hicks did stupid shit. so please shut the fuck up and go watch soul plane.

  • ian mckaye wrote it because he went to a junior high where he was 1 of 10 percent white people while the others were black, then his high schoo where he was in 25 percent white people,,, its an anti racist message...

  • It anti racist fuckin tard

  • Great video ! I'm more of a slayer fan so i dig there version but its just what you like .. Unless you know what the guy was thinking at the time he wrote the song you cant say it is racist or not , But all in all its a kick ass song and your video for it is well thought out so PROPS! FUCKIN' SLAYER FOR LIFE !

  • hey makes this vid of an anti racist song yet he listens to screwdriver wtf

  • Good song! I have it on my Ipod. Tried to play along with it but it's a little hard for me.

  • songs awesome and the vandals rock

  • that was rad

  • that dude has a vandals shirt on, does anyone remember the original v singer stevo? not that jackass idiot,he's a celebri-not. i saw minor threat back in da day..wow i'm old..

  • Probably one of the best Minor Threat songs.

  • now thats punk at its finest

  • I don't apologize for slavery. Pretty much every group of people has gotten screwed over real bad at some point in history. Some much worse than american black slaves.

  • right!

  • damn good effort. Great video.

    And Slayer, the lyrics are "Guilty of being white", not "guilty of being right".

  • The last line is "Guilty of being right"

  • in the slayer version it is... ian mackaye was pissed that they did that

  • Yeah, I was trying to reply to the guy talking about Slayer.. Didnt quite work out.

  • No, that's the Slayer verson.

  • This was killer ! 5 STARS , I LOVE THIS SONG , SLAYER COVERED THIS SONG AND DID A KILLER JOB .. HATE

  • I do find being white has this status of things are given to me, but I have worked really hard everyday even being stricken with a disease that I know I could just sit on my butt and draw money from the government, but I want more out of life! On the other hand being ripped from a homeland to be a slave for generations is a hole I would never understand! Get song as it makes you think!

    PeaceouTy!

    TAMMpON

  • Ian McKay grew up in DC where in his High School he was the minority... He got beat up by some of his black classmates after they learned about slavery in his class. He wrote this song as an anti-racism song.... it has been largely misinterpreted.

  • spasthaxen, you are wise beyond your years. My hat's off to you.

  • Hey PUNKXandDRUNKS you should post IN MY EYES!!  I really like your slide video!! Got Black Flag?

  • I dont give a shit what anyone says! This song FUCKIN ROCKS!! and I'm BROWN!!! funny shit I still have this LP!

  • nice shirt man

  • this song is not giving an excuse to be racist it is simply stating were tired of hearing all the whining about the past like white people are the only ones to ever invade a country or to own slaves what about the moores invasion of sicily or when the persians were on the rampage to take over the world if your gonna bring up the past bring it all up or let it all alone thats just my opion take it or trash it

  • wish everyone has the knowledge you have.. sadly they don't...

    you bring up good points but we live in AMERICA and ONLY AMERICANS care about AMERICAN HISTORY and sadly AMERICAN HISTORY is violent and has known facts of owning black slaves.. so arguing the facts of other countries history won't fly over these ignorant minds

    I'm African-American myself.. and some of these folks that play off slavery from the past to modern day White Folks as racist is just plain wrong

  • Thank god, at least there is one of you.

  • ummm english had slaves too dude thats where the fuck we cam from

  • it seems like this song is giving an excuse to be rasist...hmmm...but i agree not only white people can be racsist DUH!

  • imho white race is in danger. wake up! imagine earth 30 years later... do you want to be a slave?!

  • stfu u nazi piece of shit this is an anti racism song u fuck

  • Why is it that only white people are racist? Have you ever heard of a black racist? A mexican racist? A chinese racist? No, because its always big, bad, WHITE BIG BROTHER that's running everyone down.

    Bullshit.

    Good song.

  • america's fucking insane. dats y im goin 2 tokyo when i turn 18.

  • If you can pass level 1 JPLT, good luck to you. Otherwise, join the military, get stationed there, and start learning Japanese while you're at it.

  • i agree tokyo is so much better at least it's not ignorant! lol..and their fasion is GREAT! l0l!

  • you said it. pinoymetal, leave me alone.

  • no, tokyo is shit, i've never met so much racism as when being in tokyo. osaka is finer, people are way more open and don't judge your skin color too much.

  • OH, whatever. I'm hungry! Can someone make me a sandwich?

  • PUNXandDRUNX: You retard, you dont understand this fucking song...... leftwring brainwashed idiot

  • Yea. I know. As an avid Minor Threat fan for about 12 years, I feel stupid that I couldn't understand the subtle meanings of this song. I don't know how to deal with life anymore. Could you tell me how it feels to misread things Mr. Take everthing at face value. SIR.

  • because of this comment and only this comment.. your now my hero

  • minor threat themselves this is not rascist..they talked about how they got letters from skinheads stating how they were proud about the song...harrymay77 you sir need to research something out of your bigoted right wing nonconservative George Bush loving bubble.

  • im putin this vid on ma myspace profile

  • awesome vid, and people should seriously chill.

    we all agree racism is fucking stupid; and if you think its right then go fuck yourself, youll get more pussy anyways

  • half my family was in El Salvador when slavery was going on and the other half was in France, and yet i get called out for slavery at school...wtf?

    thank you Ian Mcayae, uve been my idol since i was like 10

  • excuse me Ian "Mackaye"

  • ha. i just like the idea of this vid.

    *****

  • This is the excuse MODERN DAY RACIST USE FOR BEING RACIST. The thought that white people are the only ones capable of racism. We can't fight it though, because its embedded in people's psyche. White people = racist.

  • I don't. Anyone who thinks only White People can be racist is stupid.

  • im gonna demand reparations for the italians forcing my family to work for them in roman times (im dutch)as should pretty much all of europe lots of the middle east and northern africa

    yes its sarcasm

  • Actually, reverse racism is impossible to achieve, since by definitions racism is any differential treatment based on race. I hate how people think racism only applies to black people.

    And to Panaceamedia, I have experienced what your feeble mind understands as "reverse racism" firsthand. Think before you shoot your mouth off.

  • If you live in a typical Southern area, then not by a "colored" person you haven't. And definitely not to the degree that many white kids living in certain parts of Cali go through.

  • how about guilty of wasting a shitload of paper... :|

  • I have a job. I can afford it.

  • I love Minor Threat. If you live in the south and "relate" to this song, no...no you don't. Just because Sharpton is a dick through the TV doesn't mean you have experienced "reverse racism".

  • ahaha I used to go on about this in school before I even knew this song. In Australia we have 'sorry day' where we all have to 'say sorry' to the Aboriginals for fucking them up 200 years ago and my ancestors didn't come to Australia til about 100 years ago.

  • are you kidding? i've never heard of that, it sounds totally ridiculous. i wish everyone was the same color so i wouldn't have to hear all this crap. at least in the US i believe everyone has the chance to succeed.

  • but if everyone was the same race it would be BORING! lol..that's why tha u.s. is cool because everyone is different just because your the same race doesent meen that your the same that follows up on rascsim and stereotypes as well just because a white person listens to country music that doesent meen EVERY WHITE PERSON LISTENS TO COUNTRY MUSIC or if a black person listens to rap music that doesent meen ALL BLACK PEOPLE LISTEN TO RAP MUSIC

  • Hopefully you Aussies will not have to pay mandatory reparations to the Abos for simply being white. Here in the states there are a few radical black groups who demand that all people of caucasian heritage pay "compensation" to "redeem" themselves of the misdeeds of a bunch of long-dead Anglo Saxon slave owners who they probably aren't related to anyways.

  • well yeah they do get special benefits/compo paid to them by the Government which get there money from Tax payers that include me so... yeah... and in school for exams you have the option of ticking a box that says if you are Aboriginal and you instantly get higher marks.

  • What a bunch of morons you all are, your probably such a twatish amount of yobs that you think this song is not an anti-racist song. its irony you twit, its not even abt being white, if anything it would be guilty of being british.

  • ah your just one of those fucks that don't have any videos of themselves and goes around trying to start shit lol go to the pub and get into a real fight you freak

  • Wow your articulation neveer ceases to amaze. Inbred.

  • ur a fuckin convict, you have the mental retardation of not being able to get over we sent you to a penal colony and its not really your homeland, the entire country should be in the hands of the natives.

  • FUCK the natives... there just fucking petrol sniffing fuckwits anyway

  • That's right, play into his hands.

  • amen to that dave

    my dads side owned slaves

    my moms family didnt even come here till 1900

    its in the past deal with it

  • I'm lookin for a job. Is your dad's side still hiring?

  • US slavery should no longer be relevant unless you were a slave or slave owner. Historically, just about everyone has been a slave so we should all shut up about it.

  • this is a comment way ahead of it's time, even for now.

  • WHAT A bloody tard

  • i'm not racist, really not. just think people can be racist to "white people" and get away with it. other things to just don't want to get into it.

  • Whomever says only White People can be racist is seriously stupid.

  • guilty of being white is not a racist song.... listen to ian nexttime he talks aboutthe song... he was one of the originators of anti nazi punk.... and the godfather of straight edge.... thank you spicy...i miss spicy...

  • lol =)

  • I knew some ignorant fuck would comment eventually. This is the kind of person this video is for. The dumb fucking morons like you.

  • God, Your a fucking idiot.

  • why is that?

  • wait.... Did I comment you to that?

    Sorry, Ment tell it to that fucking moron Zillaroo

  • We got blamed for it because were white. Only because of that. You think all white people hate blacks even though we dont. When Ian McAye wrote this song it was meant to be an anti-racist song. He says it in American Hardcore. It means I'm only guilty of being white, don't judge me by the clor of my skin. It's so clear.

  • yea, I mean, he played with the Bad Brains. I think its "smart" to have a racist song while playing in DC... with the next band up a bunch of Black guys. Yea real smart. Dumbass.

  • Yeah that's right. I'm sure he owns a plantation and has a an overseer whipping folks working out in the cotton fields. You're a fucking idiot

  • Who me?

  • No, the guy who said he's "still practicing slavery"

  • wow im black and i dont know what to say, honestly its really just one of those things where if you havent taken a walk in someone elses shoes then you really couldnt possibly understand. sorry that you feel sorry you shouldnt feel sorry for being white but in this country your more guilty if you happen to be not white.

  • Fuck yeah. >5<

  • that was great minor threat is pretty righteous

  • But even worse than the fact that it happened so long ago, is the fact that all white people are harrased for this. My family didn't even live in this country when slavery happened.

  • I know neither did mine my dad's side was all in Lebanon and my mom's side was all in Germany(no I'm not a nazi I'd kill a nazi if I could.)

  • I agree this shit happened over hundreds of years ago and some people are still blaming us for this.I have a lot of black friends, and I can't possibly see how anyone can be racist sometimes.

  • good job m8 like the video like the song. 5 stars

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more