I like both Versions (Carrie and Kelli), they both sing it amazingly....and they both sung it different! I however prefer Carrie's version, just because i like her arrangement of the song better! But Kelli also did an amazing job!!! I wish Kelli would sing more songs like this because they show off that amazing voice of hers!
never compare both of 'em.they are totally good and they prove it.how about u guys?did u guys prove it anyway?what?none??..so sad..so just keep ur mouth shut and watch..
There is no way this version is better than Carries. Carrie does a much better job of singing this song. I don't know why people are such Carrie haters.
You people bashing Carrie really need to shut up i love them both and everyone knows Kelly is best singer American Idol has ever had, but seriously Carrie is the original so show some respect.
I agree with Esquire magazine!! Kelly IS the best singer who ever lived!! And that's saying a LOT!!! I LOVE this song done by her!! I can't wait to see her in Grand Prairie, TX!! And I also wish she would make a concert video/CD of this tour!!
its not just the song shes good at its her talent if u watch like every youtube video of kelly clarkson (like me) u will see her talent and ull see she can sing ANYTHING!!!!!! and so dont compare her dont judge her just watch those videos and ull be glad u did it will make u love music 5 times more trust me and those people teasing her out there probley want 2 watch her and there probley on this website secretly watching kelly clarkson. ull see how nice and talented she is
@Breevandekamp20 hmmmm I have taught music for over 20 years. Her vocals are spot on and she is practically crying during her falsetto. She is one of the best spinto sopranos around today. Horrible is not a word to describle this performance. I suspect you have a personal issue with the singer. I would bet her and Carry are good friends and I am sure Carry would say its ok and healthy to enjoy other talented singers.covering her music
@LetYourSoulShine99 you tell him/her. @Breevandekamp20 You really don't know what talent is if you're saying this is crap!!! I'm sorry but I think you need to go see a doctor immediatley!!
@Breevandekamp20 hahaha.. insecure jealous carrie fan.. kelly made it her own.. and she sang it in higher key.. just demolish carrioke underwood's bland vocals.. let carrie do some kelly covers showcazing upper register like.. since u been gone.. hazel eyes.. why dont you try.. for sure she will commit sucide
@carshe209 This is actually in a lower key lol. Kelly just hit a higher note. Carrie can hit that note though, on "your VOIIIICE anywhere"...it's F#5.
@Elphaba88 I hope for a live concert DVD for this tour too! Since she's not coming to my city for the tour, I won't be able to see her live so I'm hoping she going to be releasing a DVD version! By the looks of it though, it looks like it's going to be one of her best tours yet!
I was at the show last night and when she did this song I was totally blown away! Thank you for recording it and posting it to Youtube! Wish I would have been as close to her as you were!
I hope there is a live CD/DVD of this concert with all the requests cause I have never heard her sing half of these songs live. So epic. Hope to see her in Greenville SC. Thank you for posting.
She came out on stage and she sang this song and I loved it. I was like, 'Oh, I wish I had a song like that.' So since I don't, I'm just gonna steal hers." Ha ha! I love Kelly.
Both versions are great.. They do a duet with this song! :)
xianjay2000 3 hours ago
I can't see Jason:'(!
JadynThompson 6 hours ago
kelly still the best.
frankzy89version2 3 days ago
I like both Versions (Carrie and Kelli), they both sing it amazingly....and they both sung it different! I however prefer Carrie's version, just because i like her arrangement of the song better! But Kelli also did an amazing job!!! I wish Kelli would sing more songs like this because they show off that amazing voice of hers!
Bigherm380 6 days ago
I'm waiting for Carrie to acknowledge Kelly singing this song. I don't think she has yet.
MarleneAug2010 1 week ago
i love them both!! both sing amazing and arer just as powerful but dofferent voice seriously people have to grow up
Lover93music 1 week ago
I gotta say these are two of my favorite singers if anything my only two...
I love Kelly Clarkson version but it doesnt beat Carrie's. Both are wonderful singers!
TheFries1 2 weeks ago
never compare both of 'em.they are totally good and they prove it.how about u guys?did u guys prove it anyway?what?none??..so sad..so just keep ur mouth shut and watch..
xerd2405 2 weeks ago
at last nights show she said when she heard Carrie sing this she was like "whaaat?! that's MY song!" lol too true Kelly, too true.
cladue07 1 month ago
Wow - comparisons between Carrie and Kelly. How shocking. Both are great. Can we leave it at that?
atomcrush 1 month ago 5
There is no way this version is better than Carries. Carrie does a much better job of singing this song. I don't know why people are such Carrie haters.
austentylerpratt 1 month ago
can somebody please tell me what key this song is in? i know it's lower than the Carrie Underwood version, but how much lower? Thanks!! :)
cuteface8581 1 month ago
You people bashing Carrie really need to shut up i love them both and everyone knows Kelly is best singer American Idol has ever had, but seriously Carrie is the original so show some respect.
Figurean 1 month ago
I agree with Esquire magazine!! Kelly IS the best singer who ever lived!! And that's saying a LOT!!! I LOVE this song done by her!! I can't wait to see her in Grand Prairie, TX!! And I also wish she would make a concert video/CD of this tour!!
GMom100 1 month ago
she's superduper!
sozensational 1 month ago 2
Kelly is such a better pure singer then Carrie ever was or ever will be!
Mine2955 1 month ago 4
Love it! Going to 3/22 concert in Seattle! Just don't understand why people scream during a song!! Just ruins it but oh well.
chelsiemay65 1 month ago
its not just the song shes good at its her talent if u watch like every youtube video of kelly clarkson (like me) u will see her talent and ull see she can sing ANYTHING!!!!!! and so dont compare her dont judge her just watch those videos and ull be glad u did it will make u love music 5 times more trust me and those people teasing her out there probley want 2 watch her and there probley on this website secretly watching kelly clarkson. ull see how nice and talented she is
enbs2000 1 month ago 12
I do love Carrie Underwood and I even like when she sings this but Kelly is a thousands times better at it. Her vocals matches the song much better.
William31389 1 month ago 16
i want a Duet NOW!!!!
omares 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Horrible!! She cant sing that song good at all!! Kelly you aint no Carrie Underwood girl! Stick to ur own songs.
Breevandekamp20 1 month ago
@Breevandekamp20 hmmmm I have taught music for over 20 years. Her vocals are spot on and she is practically crying during her falsetto. She is one of the best spinto sopranos around today. Horrible is not a word to describle this performance. I suspect you have a personal issue with the singer. I would bet her and Carry are good friends and I am sure Carry would say its ok and healthy to enjoy other talented singers.covering her music
LetYourSoulShine99 1 month ago 2
@LetYourSoulShine99 you tell him/her. @Breevandekamp20 You really don't know what talent is if you're saying this is crap!!! I'm sorry but I think you need to go see a doctor immediatley!!
karta480 1 month ago
@Breevandekamp20 hahaha.. insecure jealous carrie fan.. kelly made it her own.. and she sang it in higher key.. just demolish carrioke underwood's bland vocals.. let carrie do some kelly covers showcazing upper register like.. since u been gone.. hazel eyes.. why dont you try.. for sure she will commit sucide
carshe209 1 month ago 3
@carshe209 This is actually in a lower key lol. Kelly just hit a higher note. Carrie can hit that note though, on "your VOIIIICE anywhere"...it's F#5.
mellynumerounoo 1 month ago
@carshe209 I agree with you, I don't think Carrie would ever dare to cover a Kelly Clarkson song!hahaha
TheGodroks 1 month ago
@TheGodroks
Nobody can cover a Kelly Clarkson song. She is one of a kind! Her voice surpasses all others.
kc1rockqueen 1 month ago
she has the same shirt from when she last performed this song lol!! i love carrie and kelly :)
Lover93music 1 month ago
This made me teary
bavery00 1 month ago
this was the one song i recorded that nite haha love it <3
dAguerreri 1 month ago
I love the run she does on 'sound'. Such an incredible vocalist.
alicelavender93 1 month ago
wow wow. so clear! thanks!
SyafiqClarkson 1 month ago
@Elphaba88 I hope for a live concert DVD for this tour too! Since she's not coming to my city for the tour, I won't be able to see her live so I'm hoping she going to be releasing a DVD version! By the looks of it though, it looks like it's going to be one of her best tours yet!
NancyLok16 1 month ago
I like this version better than Carrie's
LeighBarrymore 1 month ago in playlist More videos from wacky4alanis
I was at the show last night and when she did this song I was totally blown away! Thank you for recording it and posting it to Youtube! Wish I would have been as close to her as you were!
triforcenicholas 1 month ago
I hope there is a live CD/DVD of this concert with all the requests cause I have never heard her sing half of these songs live. So epic. Hope to see her in Greenville SC. Thank you for posting.
Elphaba88 1 month ago
She came out on stage and she sang this song and I loved it. I was like, 'Oh, I wish I had a song like that.' So since I don't, I'm just gonna steal hers." Ha ha! I love Kelly.
MissChanandlerBong12 1 month ago