A. Dyukov criticizes "Soviet Story" film

[CrimesAgainstHumanit]

50 years of Communist rule left Estonia on the verge of a demographic disaster. Estonians were becoming a minority in their homeland with their language replaced by Russian in official affairs, cultural life bound by censorship, people restrained and denied access to the outside world.

[kirpaftw]

The problem is: no one really cares about what happened, history is used for low speculations to acquire particular short-term political profit. That's why Latvian naSSi can lie all the way about it and virtually no one will notice it. Good thing is that professional historians like Dyukov can give expert reviews for such speculations. Maybe someone will just stop chewing propaganda stamps and will look at it from the new perspective.

[EstoniaANTICOMMUNIST]

Dyukov - braininvalid!

[kaz4334]

Russia has suffered from communist genocide the most: very few inteligent people have left...If this clown is considered an 'expert'..., is a clear evidence of genocide..., so sorry for russian people. Simple point: only bla bla- did not have a single proof of any 'fake' fact, just primitive retoric...so pathetic...

[SeptimusAugustusI]

Этот фильм для дебилов. И комментарии в большинстве своем тоже дебилов.

[piperprop3]

@SeptimusAugustusI почему? о чем имменно он врет?

[mschrissie25]

dear A. Dyukov,

russians don't have Lenin medals anymore, so you can stop trying whit all that propaganda.

best wishes from FREE Lithuania,

[EX-soviet union]

[BringBackMy9Os]

@mschrissie25

Free Lithuania? Good joke,

lithuania is just another EUssr Colony and NATO-playground :D

Yeah i guess it's free. Free from thinking, brains, development and culture.

[adiora]

this "historian" makes it sound like it is all about Russia's image, or Russian money, never mind that the soviets murdered millions of people!!!!!

[adiora]

how long is the russian gov. and "historians" going to deny the atrocities that happened during the soviet time? no matter how many lies they say the truth lives on not only in documents, but most importantly in the memory of the people and their descendants who suffered and continue to suffer because of the soviet politics.

[CrimesAgainstHumanit]

There are still people, who are trying to justify crimes of soviets. Everybody know about nazi crimes, now it is time to know about communist crimes. Unfortunately, this kind of "historians" as Dyukov, are trying to cover up the crimes against humanity, committed by soviets.

[Tapewormlatvia]

There is something about his face that totally attracts my fists.

Maybe those are the glasses that deserve being smashed, so his eyes would be full of glass shards. And then the rest of his face would deserve a total mayhem, made only by my fists. Well, I know... I could add a little boot-stomping, to make a better performance.

But that's me...

In any case. This surely is one punchable face. I'll tell you that! A face like his, don't deserve to be on this beautiful planet. :)

[piperprop3]

can someone please explain on what grounds this idiot is asserting "The Soviet Story" is a work of fiction. as far as i know it is a very accurate portrayal of the Stalinist/Leninist era. this dweeb keeps repeating "it is meant for western consumption" but never actually sites a major falsehood in the film. what is he talking about????

[BringBackMy9Os]

@piperprop3

Last year european council approved that Holodomor is just a biased ukrainian "nation building" myth, neglecting the lossess of others.

Ukrianians, Balts, Georgians and Muslims are treacherous nazi scum and idiots, whose '90s creationist myths are easy to expose.

[piperprop3]

@BringBackMy9Os on what basis? i am no historian but Holodomor is a well know historical fact caused by collectivization policies of the Stalinist era. where am I mistaken? what u say about ukranians, balts is also true as far as i understand but this is separate from the truth of Soviet Stalinist crimes. one truth doesn't negate the other.

[BringBackMy9Os]

@piperprop3

It's recognised as famine by the EU, but not as a ukrainian "Holodomor" nation creation myth.

[BringBackMy9Os]

@piperprop3

a meant a famine throughout the whole country, by no means only the ukrainian "nation" alone. There are old nostalgic ukrainian nazis and ignorants who present it that way though.

[piperprop3]

@BringBackMy9Os you are wrong. yes all of the soviet union suffered under Stalin. at different times the whole country was subjected to terror, mass murder, and deportations to Gulag camps, BUT the famine of the early '30's was very specific to Ukraine. there is little controversy over that. it isn't just nationalist Ukrainian propaganda.

[BringBackMy9Os]

@piperprop3

No, in Kasakhstan died more people during the famine, and Russia suffered equally from famine. The Kasakhs are not complaining about genocide, and the EU rejected ukrainian claims and fanaticism for genocide last year. It is ukrainian fascist propaganda, to excuse their athrocities during their Nazi-Times, committed against Poles, Russians and especially Jews (Jews who are made responsible to be the masterminds of NKVD etc.)

[DorelBPR]

fuck oll rushian

fuck oll rushian

fuck oll rushian

fuck oll rushian

fuck oll rushian

[MrVoloshenko]

вести хехе .. кароче клоуны. про коммунистов все уже знают своих же морили голодом. депортировали . говнуки!

[JohnyLettish]

He must be taking drungs, it's a scandal, that russian tv invites him! No actually it's normal in russa! Na zdarovie you amateur historian cunt

[maksims2009]

normal people just flush the toilet when they've done "the job"; Latvian politicians put the "outcome" on DVDs

[justtomA89]

Russian government just have inferiority complex, because Soviet union does no longer exist....

[zwerskij]

Istorik ? Krepko skazano.Kakoe otnoshenie etot vyperdysh imeet k istorii? K istorii fal´sifikatsii, da!

No eto uzhe drugaia opera.

[RolandsSmoked]

:D:D:D yes and this young Man wrote book "Genocide is myth". Great opinion by emptyhead.

[danutbold]

The soviets were criminals,even on his people,they must be condamned for mass crimes as the allies did in Nurenberg.

[skinier4u]

This is ridiculous what this guy is saying in this interview. I saw the movie and I loved it. It's all true, and even Russians historians who took part in this movie admitted it. Why simply not to admit, yes our ancesters made huge mistakes and acted horribly and try to solve it today rather than denying everything and calling Latvians propoganda makers. How is that possible that EVERY single country country involved in this story says it's true, except Russia...HOW? that makes me sad and angry!

[cyberrate]

@skinier4u What makes me sad is that only the countries who have installed presidents make films like that and have problems with Russia. Go ahead and vote for CIA agents. Can you explain why none of other ex-soviet republics have big problems Russia except for those who have presidents from America (Estonia,Latvia (ex-president) ,Lithuania,Georgia) ?

[kalx007]

@cyberrate

what makes me sad, is that soviet retards, like you, squeal like pigs every time the truth is spoken.

[cyberrate]

@kalx007 What truth? You have failed to provide any sort of proof of what you are saying. What you should be thinking about is what is going to happen in Estonia the next time there are presidential elections in US. Because just like Georgia Estonia has a president that was provided to us kindly by US. So are we going to attack Russia in 2012 just to make next "change" candidate look better than other ones?

[knuddelwuschel]

if you don't read is comments why do you answer him twice? You Sir, got owned.

[hopenata123]

Латвия, Украина, Польша, Молдова, Грузия и т.д. в один голос говорят о репрессиях, насилии, смертях... неужели это не заставляет задуматься...?!!

[hopenata123]

Хоть один русский историк, может что-то неодобрительное сказать о советской власти и о ее влиянии на страны которые попали в сферу ее интересов...

[hopenata123]

Хотелось бы услышать объективную оценку исторических событий советских времен. И не просто критикуя все и вся, мол антисоветская пропаганда и фальшивка, а признать те отрицательные факты и события которые имели место.

[gdasssskljlhbasdgh]

A. Dyukov suck suck suck !

[CrimesAgainstHumanit]

as we all saw, we have a real "intelligent history student" here, called KHANBALIQ..feel sorry for him..he is just brainwashed..Stalin killed most of the intelligent people of Soviet Union, because they were dangerous for communist regime..only not so bright people remained..as Khanbaliq...

[sidewwinder]

Фальшивки? Где ты их нашла, блондинко? Военный парад РККА и Вермахта в Бресте - фальшивка?

Профессура Кембриджа - не историки? Охуеть. Московские кандидаты ист. наук - вот это сила. Куда тому Кембриджу. Путинская история рулит. Пидарасы...

[latgalis144]

:D :D :D :D

of course the american revive is negative ... but only becaus the film is not so positive and happie like some holliewood shit....

the soviet storie is yust to hard and fore tham. thay can not belive that whoat the russians have do with eastern europe is posible...

[kinaskatinaszalia]

not all the truth is in the history books dear

[kinaskatinaszalia]

probably from a russian university where they ALWAYS TELL THE TRUTH! yeah, right....

[kinaskatinaszalia]

like you would know that.

[Edgarssprogis]

Lol this guy is so slim, and he is just puting bananas ir your ears. It is useless to enlight Russians they all have the poision of exUSSR they think they are the heroes all thy did was killed, raped etc. The last stupid thing they did were the war of Georgia, saying that Georgia is a thrat to 'allmighty' russia :D :D

[kinaskatinaszalia]

funny cause i'm thinking the same about you!

[kinaskatinaszalia]

seems that you yourself don't know the facts dear!

[igorsova]

Heil Putin

[ipiloot]

"... because at the time of excistance of SS ther was no KGB ..."

Shameless lie in a public TV. That man pretends to be historian?

[AIA0007]

Чуть не вырвало на монитор.

Ленин жил, живет и будет жить!

Вперед к идеям великого Чучхе!

[Pomponab]

Quel crétin cet "historien", quels mensonges!

Poutine = Staline!

[eikitnahui]

но вот бей молотком по голову русскому он все равно поет свою пропагандистскую песню-ФИЛЬМ ОСНОВАН НА СЕКРЕТНЫХ ДОКУМЕНТОВ КГБ! А таких документов полно осталось в странах ссср! годность таких документов 75 лет! начинаем обратный отчет до полного стыда

[romamaxim]

Браво!!! Правильно!!! Эта политика России со временем становится яснее и убедительнее

[zwerskij]

A. Dyukov - kloun kremlevskikh tualetov.

[nagileon]

Yes they do, but those guys don't agree with this falsification theory so (ras)Putin decided that if they speak then he will send them to the GULAG.

[Velaspulvers]

Doesn't russia have any other "expert" except this A. Dyukov?! This fuck is in every interview about "falsification of history."

[fashistputin]

Dyukov - tipichnyj KGB-eshnik-dezinformator, putinskaja suchka.

[preslis]

fucking liar A.Dyukov

[Borbola99]

psc skoka etumu kozlu kremlj zaplatil wtob sovratj v premom efire on krome zaikatsa i vratj ne4o drugova neumejet!

[dancefloorcontrol]

SS s NKVD hehe a ne KGB

[dancefloorcontrol]

nu da,,...vse pirisssalji! bled naidut ruskije i perestrelajut nahui :D :D :D

Da nea....zabeiti na etu huinju, prosto nebudte nacistimi i chitajte knizhke!!

a esli vi tak k serdcu eto berote tgd po hodu eto pravda - priukrashinaja no pravda!