Shaykh Khatri performs fake Wudu corrected by sunni wudu as our messenger sws performed it

[CCSF1999]

As far as I can see, 5X more people don't like your video than those who like it. Is this what your da'wa is about: Using insulting language toward our Ulama? This is why your so called Salafi da'wa is hated by so many Muslims around the world. Your fellow Salafis drove me away with they're lack of character from the time I became Muslim. It's a shame because you so called people of hadith missed the hadith: I was not sent but to perfect character.

[adamismailwanjor]

Salam to all. Pls do not argue anymore. If anyone is right its the people that has the best Sunah in attribute and in worshiping. Know that what is presented here in all the remarks are a misconception of the sunah in attribute totally.

[Mo987665]

you're jealous ...

[thsidky]

If you say that this brother's wude is the correct way, (as the Prophet SAAS performed himself) then I must disagree as does just about everyone else who has basic knowledge of Sunna.

When does this guy LOOK at the bottoms of his feet as did our Beloved Prophet??

When does he clean in BETWEEN his toes and fingers as did our Beloved Prophet?

I could go on, but I think you get the point.

I HAVE NEVER SEEN ANYONE PERFORM SUCH A PERFECT WUDU AS SHAYKH KHATRI FROM Mauritania!

MASHAALLAH

[saladinpublishing]

may Alla reward you for your Slander and ghibat JazakAllah ghair Khairuhaa

[Shareefllovekdj]

You can't "dear brother" your way out of this obvious player hating. Why do you people stay clocking Sunni scholars, when your Nedji "Oolamaah" are so blameworthy? Tail them around the "the kingdom" you will find plenty of munkar to focus your formidable biddah busting powers upon. And Peace.

[saadoune1425]

the mistake here that's not the place of cleaning nose so the nose is classed in 3 place after cleaning hands and mought and the correct way is simply to repeat wudu , the thid mistake is that sheikh rub his fingers ans some parts in his face , those acts explain the obsession so the sunni wudu is very very easy so why the seikh do those strong actions and make wudu very difficult . there are also a lot of mistakes as cleaning behind the neck and some words which he told when doing wudu...

[nasrudd2000]

@saadoune1425 Do you think study In University Madeenah for 4 - 6 years enough to become scholar and make such statements other scholars are wrong? Have you studied sacred law from 4 Mazhabs - Maliki, Hanafi, Shapiie, and Hambali and considered expert in this field to comment? I expect you will answer that are not neccessary because of you are referring to Quran and Hadith directly. However in actual facts, you are not able to do that but only taqleed to the way of IBn Tayimmah.

[saadoune1425]

Dear brothers lot of you tell that the skeikh khatry make maliki wudu and i confirm you unfortunately that sheikh khatri did a wrong wudu not maliki wudu , you see the mistakes in many acts the first one when he clean hands he clean the right hand 3 times and the lift hand 3 times and the true way is cleaning the two hands together not one by one the second mistake when he miss cleaning his nose he told that he'll come back and in the last he clean the nose ... (see the follow part ..) 

[nasrudd2000]

@saadoune1425 The Shaikh Khatry way of wudhu is different from what you learn in the University. Why not you become humble and learn Maliki schools to understand more. Why not learn Shapie, Hambali and Hanafi before you are ready to put out statements. They are salafis, learn more unless you consired the schools are not authentic. Are the authentic scholars only Ibn Tayimmah and Ibn Qayyim? Open your heart, do not only taqleed to this 2 scholars, there are not maksum.

[tuwaylib]

The title is a typical Madkhali one... proving they haven't studied fiqh. Learning fiqh from a salafi is like learning Tawheed from a Barelwi.

[YZTWR]

He's doing the Maliki Way of Wudu'. There maybe a slight difference between the other 3 schools.

But sure It's of benefit for them. To say that he's 'wrong' literally will be unethical. I'm sure He knows what He's doing.

[AbooLayth]

@YZTWR

I agree brother. The video is beneficial for those who are Maaliki and those who aren't. I mean, it made me review my books - walhamdulillaah. May Allah make us of those who implement what we learn and fallow the path of the Salaf, ameen.

Was-Salaam alaikum ikhwaanee.

Your brother.

(formerly oOTPOo)

[oOTPOo]

And Allah knows best, I know that the Shaykh is Maaliki, perhaps it has something to do with that.

But the video is beneficial no doubt. Even if, there are one or two things that some may disagree with. As long as that is based on sound knowledge.

BaarakaAllahu feekum jamee'an.

And Allah knows best.

[oOTPOo]

... (I believe it was Ibn Hajar) "he is "maqbool" (meaning excepted, it is a low level of trustworthiness) but he opposes what the "thiqqaat" (highest level of trustworthiness) have narrated." & he is alone in this narration on the authority of Talha (radhiaAllahu 'anhu). As we know in 'Ilmul Hadeeth, if a narrator who is trustworthy is alone in a narration & opposes those who more trustworthy than him & greater in number, than what he has narrated is not excepted.

I hope this helps Cmdaddy88.

[Cmdaddy88]

@oOTPOo

brother why are you talking about narrators and hadith? we are talking fiqh here, how is khatri's wadu wrong?

[AbooLayth]

@Cmdaddy88: Salam alaikum brother. (I'm oOTPOo - I just made a new user b/c the other 1 was old) The reason, dear brother, was just to clarify a position regarding rinsing ones mouth & cleaning ones nose. That's all. So to do so I had to mention certain Ahadeeth & their narrators so that I was being clear & not just being blindly critical. & b/c Fiqh is based largely on Hadeeth Sciences. I don't believe that his Wudhu was OUTRIGHT wrong, not at all. As I said, rather I benefited from it.

[AbooLayth]

Just expressing a difference of opinion in a respectable manner, I guess. I don't believe in just saying he's wrong and I'm right. No, I say that this is what I believe to be correct because Allah and His Messenger - sallaAllaahu alaihi wa sallam - said this and that, b/c this leaves room for me to also be corrected if need be - as I realize & am humble enough - walhamdulillaah - to know that I don't have a monopoly of the Truth when it comes to Fiqh issues - the matter is wide and encompassing.

[AbooLayth]

I hope that answered your question dear brother, inshaa Allah. If not, let me know and I'll be more than happy to comply, bi'ithnillaah.

And may Allah give you and I all the goodness of this world and the hereafter, ameen. And may He guide us to what He loves and is pleased with, ameen.

JazaakumuAllaahu khairan wa BaarakaAllaahu feekum.

[Cmdaddy88]

@AbooLayth

you said:

"The reason, dear brother, was just to clarify a position regarding rinsing ones mouth & cleaning ones nose"

can you clarify that position? what of rinsing mouth and nose?

[tryingtobegood1]

lol shaykh khatri is sunni. thats the 'amal of madina

[oOTPOo]

Dear brother,

I wouldn't say that they are bid'ah, Allah knows best. In Madeenah University where I study in the Faculty of Hadeeth, we studied these issues in detail & the Ahadeeth that relate to it.

The issue of making "madhmadha" and "istinshaaq" is where I think that there is en error, because of the ahadeeth that mention that they are to be done as shown in THIS video, i.e. together. The Hadeeth that narrates opposite to that is weak, due to Layth bin Sulayman who Ibn Hajar said : ....

[saadoune1425]

yes i am serious , this is the wudu which our messenger MUHAMED sws had performed and the wudu which shaykh khatri did is wrong

[Cmdaddy88]

@saadoune1425

can you please point out what was wrong with khatri's wadu?

[ismail4137]

@saadoune1425

If this is the wudu of Muhammad SAW, where's his miswak? and his sitting on a stool! Muhammad SAW never sat on a chair or a stool?

[saadoune1425]

@ismail4137 dear brother you must understand difference between acts which we do usually and acts which we do as worship (prayer) and we will judge only on worship acts .

[ismail4137]

@saadoune1425

1. you didn't answer my question, typical neo salafi already ducking and diving!

2. How come this guy is not using miswak? how come is sitting in a stool - your video is fake, shame on you!

3. I never lost a debate to a neo salafi!!!!

[rafchile]

Are you serious?