Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (291)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she needs to go on tour in the us now!

  • I already told you this years ago: you're beautiful, boy who was recording

  • @MsAuntMary YYeah!! tonight..you became a monster!

  • @missauntmary she does smoke on accasion. But I love this song and like always it gives me chills when she's live! I wonder if that outfit was uncomfortable to move around in!?

  • daddy i'm sorry, we just like to party.' :P

  • Omg...i got chills. :O i love her so much!

  • Chill with the smoking drama, she doesnt inhale. she only SMOKES marijuana :p Go Green!

  • I love when Gaga smokes!

  • LADY GAGAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA <3

  • this was on my birthday... such a sign ;)

  • stop smoking!

  • BANG! BANG!.... were beautiful and dirty rich (beautiful, dirty, dirty, rich, rich, beautiful, dirty_, rich)

  • BANG! BANG!.... were beautiful and dirty rich (beautiful, dirty, dirty, rich, rich, beautiful, dirty_, rich

  • lol cat daddy

  • i was thereee! :)

  • as much as i belive celebrities should be honset and real i think its not ok to smoke on stage a lot of people might be encorouged...or saying that she smokes pot ...i mean yes be hosnest but always say thta you think that smoking sucks and you wish you'd never starte din the first place and say thta pot is dellusional and might get you addicted...glamorizing those things just causes bad karma gaga

  • can someone send me the remix of beautiful dirty rich ? i havent I Tunes... mail me please... LOVE YOU MOTHER MONSTER

  • Gaga= AMAZING!!! Smoking + Gaga= :'0 lady gagas my favorite artist but I think she should go into rehab PLEASE. Don't smoke at least not on stage

  • @Hzlflm96

    she should go to rehab for smoking a cigarette? LMAO.

  • Ahhhhh!!! I can't wait to see her on Sunday!!!!

  • @BreakingAtheist FACT.

  • does anyone know where i can find the studioversion of this version?

  • @InviCibLeCoRe itunes

  • Dang ! I wanna cigarette lit on a stage while performing <3 =)

  • @ShamanicRocker And I klove the way the fans all scream when she starts smoking =)

  • How does she wear those awful costumes when she is on her period? And please spare me the jokes about her not having periods cause she's a man.

  • @IAmPlaysWithSquirrel I'm not really sure about that. But she probably has a tampon. Probably a sports one because she moves around a lot.

  • She's halfway naked! D: I like it xD

    She's beautiful, I love her! (: and her cute dancing ! :DDD

    Hopefully I can see her this march, at the oracle arena ! x(

  • i hate that she lost weight. im glad she gained it back. but this song and the video she recorded and did before just dance, the video for this song made jimmy ivine notice her.

  • I Love Choregraphy !

  • i love you, but please stop smoking!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • For this mp3 goto audofier doht cohm.

  • this mix is so nuts. looove it.

  • Gaga you have such a good voice stop smoking please <3

  • haha cool outfit

  • whoa rly i didnt knw it was her first song. its my all time fav of her.

  • @nerrrrr

    really? on a website it said poker face was her first song =O

  • wow they all go crazy over every thing she does hahaha a cigarette made her fans go crazy xD

  • /watch?v=I2uodMe6cg8

  • audio difficulties in the beginning. haha i love how she just keeps on going~!

  • Just out of curiousity, how much were your tickets?

  • @conman33313 mine were about $100 dollars on the top balcony

  • Does Lady Gaga smoke on a daily basis?

  • I LOVE U LADY GAGA

    btw that was a fake fag:)

  • @devilanddiva no it wasn't.

  • i want her to save herself. please mother monster smoking can kill! I'LL NEVER TALK AGAIN IF YOU DIED!

  • @ladyXgagaXmonster she doesnt smoke regularly its a stage thing it is just a show she doesnt really smoke tho

  • @officialconnerashley Well I know she doesn't smoke that much. Just sayin'. I don't want her to die.

  • @ladyXgagaXmonster Why do you think she is so skinny ?

  • @sexxihoe101 She is very skinny because she's on tour. She's constantly working on music and performing and dancing and if you listen to her in this video, she's breathy heavily.

  • Fucking amazing gotta b honest

    I LOVE YOU GAGA <3 <3 <3 XXXXXXXX

  • Wow, she looks and seems a LOT different from The Fame. At least she still lets her fans do cool stuff with her too. Like singing! It's cool she lets her fans sing too!

  • Wow, she looks and seems a LOT different from The Fame. At least she still lets her fans do cool stuff with her too.

  • smoking is fucking nasty

    which i gotta say it makes me like her even less.

    ewh.

  • @toshiaTOKYO I LOVE SMOKING BITCH haha no offense

  • @Cutiebearism lol okay.

  • @toshiaTOKYO xD

  • this version is sooooo much better!

  • she kept loosing track at the beginning the poor thing.

  • god she has a nice body. think of the work that takes.

  • lady gaga is cool

  • @silencedable she actually doesn tsmoke she just does it for the stage effect idk i heard she only did it occasionally on stage

  • @caseypoo984 you son of a bitch! how dare u think that britney is better than gaga! u suck ass! i actually am a fan of britney but gaga is like way f*cking better. and at least she's not afraid 2 express herself even if it does end up with her wearing weird clothes (no offense gaga) and i respect her for that

  • We just like to party like to pa pa pa yeah

  • I love this song !!

  • LOVE HER

  • is she really being compared to britney spears? britney wishes she had the talent lady gaga has. can britney play the piano? does she sing that well live? did she get famous for talent, or wearing a school girl uniform? lady gaga is amazing. britney sounds like a dying cat. that is all.

  • do you hear everybody in the background, they know that song.

    I thought the song "The Fame" was her first hit before she got famous, besides beautiful, dirty, rich has a music video which is hot.

  • AWESOMEEEE

  • OMGGGGG I LUV LADY GAGA SOOO MUCHHH <3

  • @xtina643 okkkkkayy first off I'M A GIRL and secondly BRITNEY is the queen and you need your shrink to adjust your meds if you think gaga is the queen. gaga is trashy and fake and no way in hell would i pay to see her in concert after seeing this.

  • @caseypoo984 are you ON SOMETHING. I've been a Britney fan all my life but it's just plain ignorance to say she's better than gaga. the ONLY they she can prolly do better is dance and she barely does that anymore. Gaga actually sings, definitely has a better, stronger voice, and is a true ARTIST. she writes ALL Her own shit and even helps create the beats, the images, EVERYTHING. don't be ridiculous and close-minded. GAGA is the new queen.

  • @trecrazychoreography you're insane. gaga sounds like a MAN. britney wrote all but 2 songs on In The Zone smart one.and she wrote My Baby on circus. britney has imput on EVERYTHING she does. they don't just give her a song and she sings it get your facts straight. BRITNEY is forever the Queen and no one will EVER take that away from her. Gaga could be the king if she wanted. but that would require her to come out and admit that she has a penis(:

  • @caseypoo984 TWO SONGS out of she actually wrote 10 of 17 on in the zone (when you cont the bonus tracks) and a whole whopping THREE on blackout and 3 of 15 on circus ONE OF WHICH GAGA WROTE!! on in the zone. get YOUR SHIT straight.

    Gaga is credited for EVERY. SINGLE. TRACK. go look at the tracklistings and credits for each and compare. britney maye be a great performer (used to be) but gaga sings, plays, and dances live. watered down dancing. but movement and vocals nonetheless

  • @caseypoo984 hahahahahahahaha! OMG! and by britney, do u mean britney spears??? i dont think lady gaga went to rehab for drug abuse, and shaved her head. HA! plus lady gaga's songs have deeper meaning than what they seem like. and why would she have sold out concertss so much and great reviews on them if she just lip syncs? so xtina643 is 100% right. you, in fact, are not.

  • @LFkmoo2 first of all are you kiding me? lady gaga is like the definition of a slore bag druggie. and yeah britneyshaved her head and went torehab but you have NOT A CLUE of whatshe was going through so don't be so quick to judge. oh yes "i want to take a ride on your discostick" that has SUCH deep meaning. meaning. BRITNEY IS THE QUEEN. it's just a known fact. i dolike lady gaga's music and i think she's a really good songwriter. she wrote quicksand for britney and i love it. just not a singer

  • @caseypoo984 Hahahah.. Britney doesn't even sing LIVE! Lol. At least Lady Gaga sings live and write her own shit. She doesn't have to pon songs off of other artists/producers. That is not art. Lady Gaga.. that's art. BTW, I feel ashamed that my name is Casey.

  • I Was There

    Best Show Ever!!

  • Great performance, just wish she didn't smoke. ):

  • @NightNinja9 true, but i think she only does in her shows, but i could be wrong. like, i dont think its a habit for her, and something she always does. but ya never know :/

  • wow. i was really excited to buy tickets for this but then as i watch videos on here it makes me less and less enthused to go. i mean seriously she always screams things like "now dance you motherfuckers" and she's smoking a cigarette on stage? and she sounds like shiiiiiiiiiiit. i wish she would lip sync then i might be more convinced to go.

    if you went to the britney tour (which i did and it was AMAZING!) tell me how this compares.

  • and yes she does smoke in real life. not just on stage...

  • I love Gaga SO MUCH. but i wish she wouldnt smoke!!! :( its disgusting and besides that it WILL ruin her beautiful voice if she keeps the smoking up through the years. Plus it is bad for her health and her lungs...i want her to be able to breathe when she is singing and dancing, i dont want her to run out of breath or worse yet not be able to dance anymore!!! im only saying this cuz i care about her SO much i just want her to have a long and healthy career!! :)

  • @Panicfan1234567890 Her voice is beautiful 'cause she smoke!!!!! The smoke is really helpful for singer... but it isn't for their health!!!....

  • I love you GaGa, but please, stop smoking bitch!

  • I remember in early 07 wen I saw her in new york she was so fucking cool an drunk singing that song.

  • this outfit and that hair isjust beautifuul

  • Lady Gaga é demais, tomara que ela venha logo ao Brasil.

  • damn matthew your sexy. xoxo

  • Disguisting, seein her smoking. She is hurting herself putting that shit in her mouth. HATE THAT!!

    She fucks her voice doing that.. STOP SMOKING GAGA!!

  • that guy with the green/blue eyes is goergeous(;

    and of course Lady GaGa is amazing as always(L)

  • lol i love how that guy is giving the finger at the end

  • uuuuhhhhh... she;s so cool!!

  • wow what camera did you use? i'm seeing her in december in barcelona and want to have it forever

  • i can't wait till i see her in july

  • what kind of camera do you have? it has really good quality and can handle sound... im going to her concert in sept and i want to be able to remember it forever

  • @silencedable ya and they sound crappy :/

  • Awesome song, love it. Great performance

    And who gives a fuck about the smoking? Seriously people get over your PC bullshit. She can do whatever she wants and still crank out the hits.

  • yeah. i think the smoking is only for the stage becuase alot of her songs involve cigarettes and other stuff and yeah. the song says it too. she'd be stupid if she smoked in real life because she'd loose her awesome voice in a matter of months.

  • she smoke just for the song IDIOTS!

  • Maybe her smoking was just a stage stunt because i think she trying to say that because he song is callled beautiful dirty rich alot of beautiful and dirty and rich people smoke

  • I love gaga but her smoking wasn't cool

  • @jocelyna38 i totally agree

  • 1:20 but i got no money ... thats true! lol

  • i love lady gaga *w* <33

  • I love her =)

  • copy and paste

    2. send this to 2 other videos.

    3. hold your breath for 10 seconds.

    4. press refresh twice.

    3. LOOK AT YOUR HANDS 5

  • I cant get on her for smoking cuz my mom and my grandma smoke.. oh well. LITTLE MONSTERS 4EVER.

  • i didn't like the "cigarette" thing...

  • @dhm80 ya me neither! i didnt even know that she smoked!

  • @womanizer0690 don't know where you got that, but she doesn't smoke, used to

  • Amazing !

  • cool!

  • hahaha really amazing i love remix, and lady gaga is so sexy i love gaga

  • bang bang bang :D <3

  • 3:11-3:15 u 2 are adorable

    i cant wait to see her

  • Honest question, why does is matter if she smokes?

  • Well, I don't care whether she does or not except that it isn't good for her voice, and I don't know why she would do anything that could compromise it with as valuable as it is to her.

  • @callayndanae Maybe she doesn't smoke as much as people think. I don't think its going to do anything to her voice, I beleive she knows how to handle the balance.

  • @MavenDawn Or maybe it was just a stage stunt, to simulate her burning & smoking the dollar bill like a cigarette in the video for this song.

  • @ctti

    Rofl I truly don't even understand why everyone shits over this anyway.

  • @MavenDawn Eh, my point exactly. It's probably just a stage stunt. And even if she does smoke, big fucking deal.

  • i only found out she was smoking this year

  • ho cares that she smokes like yall diddnt smoke dont try to be a angel shes good at singing

  • she used to do drugs too. no surprise she smokes

  • @SLEMONSTER she used drugs???

  • @mbas97

    that was long before she was famous, but it was justpot. she doesnt anymore/

  • I love watching this video

  • wow...fail..

  • I WANNA BECOME A MONSTER LOL!!

  • Does she really want people to think she was poor? She went to the same exclusive private school that Paris Hilton attended.

  • yea while thatz tru you also have to take into condsideration that she broke away from her parents for a little while, when she started to become "Lady Gaga" her father didnt understand it there 4she was cut off in and she (assuming) and she put all of her self into her art!!! BTW her parents had money!!! dosent mean she did!! Ima college student and my mom is loaded but im broke as hell.

    TRU STORY!!!

  • @bonn777 her parents payed. she didnt have money. her parents did, so essentially SHE was poor, but her parents werent

  • Listen, I get the fact that she chose to make it on her own & that's admirable. But, it's nice to know that your parents can contribute if needed. Regardless, I love her & love this song. Wouldn't it be great if she brought Paris Hilton on stage to perform it with her?

  • other than the smokin it was good

    im not gettin on her for it.....

    but still

  • I dont care if she smokes I just think it ruins her beautifull voice. I dont think any singer should smoke.

  • This was the shit

  • This was the fuk it was beast

  • wow she doesn't have a penis (OBVIOUSLY SHE NEVER DID) I NEVER BELIEVED THAT SHE HAD ONE ANYWAY she rocks! go gaga!

  • Yeah...I hope she doesn't lose weight either. I love her all round and hot and sexy...but after doing that thing with Madonna, any girl would get paranoid ! Madonna needs a tube down her throat and 3 square meals a day...lol

  • i love gaga

  • Gaga thats not good! No no you do not smoke Cigerettes!!!

  • That or that's how it's supposed to be. But uh, if it was a mess up...she did a good job covering it up!

  • no she changed the song different live.

  • No she missed out some lyrics haha

  • going to see her in Feb this year.

    CANT WAIT!

  • I loooooooove this song as much as I love this woman,

  • Man she smokes god damn it. I wish I didn't see that

  • O_O you're gorgeous >>> the boy in the video :D

  • i wanna make out with all her dancers and gaga in a huge group orgy my fantasy without even takin shower with all that sweat and clothes

  • @AFGRULZ26 HAHAHA! I LOVE IT! Same here.

  • that out fit looks like it hurts

  • Dude shut your bible for five seconds and dance dang.

  • the guy that's with you, is pretty hot :)

    ahaha & I LOVE LADY GAGA !

    wish i went to this concert !!

  • nice ass

  • What kind of Camera did you film this with????

  • Que podre eu gosto muito da Gaga más o show da Britney e bem melhor !!

    Shit! I like so much Gaga but the Britney Show is better! so much better!

  • nip slips of gaga?? - Nakedladygaga(.)com

  • amazing. lady gaga. is. amazing.

  • what did she said after 2:02 ??

  • love her wig

  • Please don't smoke, Gaga! Your voice!!

  • I was thinking the same thing Pinkin1211 I don't want her voice to get messed :( I love her

    <