Added: 2 years ago
From: Popperhannes
Views: 53,478
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (672)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Also she is standing way too close to the kinect. Normally Kinect demands you to keep a distance of at least 6ft in order to work.

  • This one video may be fake but look at kinect now.

  • i feel betrayed :(

  • Love the "and molyneux" part. The guy is clearly a scam and a liar and a hardcore xbot.

    Why would you come out and lie about stuff like that? Think about his reputation amongst other developers now. Nobody takes him serious anymore. And all of that for a Microsoft paycheck.

  • where is he now eh? even the BBC remove the article from their website, suspicions of this being fake were around a while and today 2 or more years later we now know the truth, bullshit is everywhere, from war for oil *cough* sorry freedom to phone-hacking, rigged TV phone-ins UFOs bigfoot whatever... many of you will 'believe' blindly... employ your critical faculties before we all have to suck the big apple I-cock as the standards of acceptability are lowered year in year out.

  • So... Claire is actually a schizofrenic lady who talks to a black TV?! lol sounds funny to me.

  • @Nexils No, Claire is just an actress or Lionhead employee, paid to do what she did. She was just taking orders.

  • although i partially agree with you, but kinect has two cameras and an infared sensor, so it know where you are in front of the camera, so a character can look in the direction where you are in front of the camera(s)

  • Claire's a slut.

  • Popperhannes hit Microsoft in its weak point and did MASSIVE damage

  • Comment removed

  • It ain't fake. Peter Molyneux himself explains by a different demo in front of a live audience.

  • @kooora18 I cant post the link. YT wont let me.

  • @kooora18 That demo was the real thing, and it was nowhere near as impressive. This demo was controlled by some guys in a back room. The distance she stands from the TV screen should be enough of a giveaway. Kinect needs more distance than that. But just observing his interactions with her, it's pretty clear that this tech is far too impressive to be plausible. For it to be real, Milo has to be AI. But his responses sounded scripted and voice acted out too well/naturally to be AI.

  • @lostn65 I think of it now and its absolutely ridiculous, the lady says "This is the first time that thousands of people are gonna see this," and milo replies, "Thousands of people" you can tell its scripted, how can he reply that quickly with the correct words unless its scripted. And who voiced him? I bet it's Peter Molyneux's son or nephew :P :P

  • Yeap this demo was a trick im pretty sure that Peter Molineaux told to the audience at the 2nd demostration. He told something like "Some people were thinking that this is a trick. And yes, its a trick. However its a trick that actually works". Welll...What he was trying to tell the people. "Okay this is a trick, you got me. If someone of you discover that this was all a fake you cant tell me that I was lying"

  • @popperhannes Have you ever heard of facial recognition in cameras? hand held cameras have it it recognizes faces in the area of view. So what makes you think that it is not possible for milo to look at peoples faces? he doesnt have to look at your eyes he just has to look at your face.

  • PEOPLE, THIS IS REAL. SHAA.

  • A pedophile's dream come true...

    say.... Milo....you feeling adventurous today???

    Isn't it too hot for that T-shirt boy??

  • wth just a bunch of kids saying that it is fake.....when it comes out we will see.....it said it was canceled or something maybe not milo but a game like this will come to xbox i am sure

  • @DreadMasterSora LOL it will never come out

  • you dont say, dumb shit they haven't finished it so they stuck a video on it retard

  • screw you guys. it is real motherfucking bitches . i have milo in my home. and it works very fine.

  • @batzaya99 Lol, its not released at retail. And don't give that bullshit "oh I work for microsoft, they told me to test it", your obviously lying.

  • @Vampdout wtf are you talking about? it released in 2010 november 24 ya troll

  • The biggest fail is that the xbox is off XD

  • milo looks in that direction becuse of the kinect 3d camer dumbass

  • @Maryanme2007 its fake..they even said so

  • When I first saw this I noticed the exact same thing... I thought that was pants-on-head retarded when they did that.

    Another thing (now that I own Kinect even after seeing this crap) The Kinect Sensor doesn't read that close. As soon as you get close too close to the sensor (about where she is) is where the two images it pics up start to look double in the little screen.

    1 more thing... Isn't it a little odd that the movie called "Mars needs Moms" has a kid just like this named Milo? <.<

  • no shit sherlock... thats not the only one thing that gives away their bullshit.. the whole video does that on its own...

  • Also why doesnt milo say hi to the camera

  • The guy that was looking straight at the camera was really freaky.

  • The guy that was looking straight at the camera

  • @0:15 woman is wearing sony headphones, MICROSOFT FAIL

  • This video was fake, but Milo is a real project.

  • The console is not even on ...

  • too bad nobody cares that you think its fake you just dislike the xbox your a stupid fanboy get a life

  • @GraniteGrenade909

    dude it is fake it has been proved by many people with very good evidence btw you say that he is a stupid fanboy and to get a life but you say that because you think he dislikes the xbox so wouldn't that make YOU a fanboy of xbox?

  • @poefred999 no im saying this cus he is riding on an issue NOBODY GIVES A FUCK ABOUT

    I DONT REALLY CARE IF MILO IS FAKE CUS DANCE CENTRAL AND THE REST OF KINECT ISNT

  • @GraniteGrenade909

    whatever this video is just to prove that it was a fake demonstration. btw dance central is a ripoff of just dance just without the wii remote and realistic graphics. i know you will flame me but i like games on wii better than on xbox and ps3. but i DO like the games on those systems but there are more games on wii i like than on xbox and ps3

  • @poefred999 it seems you make a valid point

    i have no reason to flame anybody

    i also love the wii but my sister took it

  • @GraniteGrenade909

    k thanks for not making a big deal about it like some other people do all the time

  • @BeginMust94

    Ormai fanno tutti Sti video per sfanculizzarlo in ogni modo visto che sono gelosi.

  • I dont think its cancelled,it is just postponed...maybe mankind isnt ready for this yet,the future is here but the XBOX 360...PS3..KINECT and all that was just a start but this Milo Project??? This is something else

  • The dosn't mean its not real!

  • vaffanculooooooo!!!!!!!!! il kinect è molto avanti !!!! w il kinect ma ammazzatevi rincoglioniti ke avete contro il kinect è bastardi!!!????????

  • It's a concept for a work in progress. Give me a fucking break. You put a lot of work into proving the eyes aren't looking at the actual person. Congrats on showing us this isn't a final actually working program.

  • Obviously this project is still in the testing phase but the camera angle wasn't. Good enough because milo isn't a person and he's not looking into an actual cam and even if that were the case u can't really tell much about the positioning of the kinect device or her but what I will say is that its a mix I doubt it works that well this early but I'm sure its real

  • W T F???? You r right in something, "A person NOT looking into a camera, will NEVER look at you" Milo "was looking" at Claire, NOT into the camera. So, No matter if you deform the picture to simulate another perspective, Milo WILL NEVER LOOK AT THE CAMERA, your second fact is contradictory with the pictures. The FAKE is this video. The only way to see milo looking at the camera on this video, is if the camera were on claire's face.

  • Oh no! It's Peter Molyneux! Now you know that this thing actually does nothing

  • KINECT IS BETETR IT COMES WITH A CAM AND A MIC, AND DOESNT USE A CONTROLLER

  • @ibrahim380 those are the exact reasons why kinect.......SUCKS ASSSSSSSS

  • @ibrahim380 finally someone on the same page

  • @ibrahim380 How gullable must you be to fall for this "you are the controller!" gimmick?

    In real life we USE TOOLS for better convinience; it actually IS the catalyst for human evolution. With Kinect "YOU ARE THE TOOL!" apparently.

    Also, because I'm going to go inside my car with it's invisibe steering wheel.

  • That sort of thong could be possible with a rapid response generator and database for expressions and words based on not only specific people but also having the generations vary as well.

  • very intelligent. 

  • that is very true

  • maybe shes wearing 3d contacts =D jk

  • Do you really fail? You say, a person that looks at the camera will never look in your eyes. Well same for a person NOT looks in the camera, will never look at a person. You can't say its faked cuz you only have seen 1 side.

  • heay has any body else notaced that the software that thay were using was freeware

  • Hooray, you just found out that milo wasn't looking directly at her. You're so smart.

  • noob

  • I think you make this video cous you have a ps3

  • @UAslan66 no... he has a ps3 because hes not a loser

  • Umm...yeah, why is the Xbox off?

  • yeah its fake cuz the xbox 360 is OFF

  • If you look at the original at E3 2009 you'll see that she goes up to the camera to give milo a picture yet with kinect your supposed to be around 6 ft away for it to work

  • I love how everyone is saying that it's fake. I take it no one has seen the latest video

  • Comment removed

  • @jakniphone What newest video?

  • @Oceanmistsupporter25 Type 'Kinect Milo 2010' into Youtube Search bar

  • Comment removed

  • Maybe they were using this to help people understand what the kinect can do. I don't doubt that it was fake. It is kind of weird how there hasn't been any newer announcement about Milo since the kinect was released. Maybe in the future of kinect we will finally get someone to step up to Peter and ask what happened to Milo?

  • the demo is for real, Microsoft even admitted in a broadcast that there movement of the "people" in the games can be a bit off, maybe if you people were actually at E3, you would know this.

  • is the xbox even turned on in this video??

  • wtf? warum sollten die in den ganzen vids von lügen sprechen? wer würde das machen? lol

    ich hab eine xbox 360 UND ps3 und bin happy

  • ah! sony products at 0:16 lol

  • but this isnt Claire POV so he cant look at u dumb...

  • WOw comparing a virtual boy to a real human on news that sick.

  • stop looking at me !!!!!!!!!!!

  • Peter Molyneux more like Peter Molestation trying to live out the ol days when he was molesting a kid named Milo that he kept in a storage shed by a lake

  • ... i got invited to go to the testing area when i went to china and i tried milo... its real..

  • @shervin333 sure

  • @Gatto927 dude, ur a fag shut up, this was supposed to make us believe it was real, wen it was debunked to being fake thats it, now shut the fuck up

  • its just a demo dipshit do u think theyll make all of it in a few months kinect isnt even out yet maybe this vid is fake but they made it so people new wot it was going 2 be like. it still isnt finished yet and yheyve allready brought out a new gameplay vid

  • @Gatto927

    then its not a demo its a lie that 360 fanboys fell for it. even peter said that milo project its canceled...why its that? bc they never could do it :)

  • @Gatto927 I completely agree with you, the only reason they would've cancelled milo is because what they advertised as 'currently working' was completely out of their reach the whole time. It's just like those early Natal commercial showing the perfect tracking and people playing while sitting down, which we all know now if very far from the truth.

  • that was a demo dipshit it was a year ago u think theyll make something like that in a few months yhey probably would notice it and change it when it comes out . they wouldent just bring a fake game out because they would lose money

  • I never thought Milo was for real, and recently they "canceled" it, IMO it was only a demo it was never real.

  • theres been no proof of this. this is the only video of milo

  • Someday Claire will be mine =3

  • Hehe I enjoy all comments! Positive and/or negative! I love when people do contradict to a possible theory. Fact is that Milo might still be in progress or is thought as a non profitable product to get official release yet. Since "kinect" is on its way but playstation move is still winning a lot of ground in the present market!!!!

  • thing is this is 3D not 2D so the picture looking at you thing won't fly because it can't happen with 3D

  • fail

    

  • AND YOU THINK JUST BECAUSE THAT THIS IS FAKE?!?!?!?!!?

    YOU ARE FAIL!!!

  • @pufixas Hello, moron.

  • @pufixas Dumb ass

  • Microsoft fail... again.

  • FAIL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • another Microsoft faked video, no surprise

  • @TheTenth666 i agree lol

  • they wount exactly adertise it if it was fake or else they'll get sued dumbass.

  • this is a pedos wet dream xbox fail ps3 move FTW!

  • steve jobs fail

  • wow your reatrd a ps3 fanboy trying to make xbox 360 look bad like always you fanboys just exaggarte alot oh it has rrod oh no

  • YOU GUYS ARE FUCKING RETARDS!!! WE DONT HAVE THIS TECH YET SO THEY CANNOT LOOK INTO YOUR EYES UNLESS YOU.... do the wii head tracking google it

  • That was like stupid

  • You must feel soooo stupid! The picture is in 3d which makes it look in your eyes dumbass!

  • @Hdyberg Sorry but the video have the true.

  • @Hdyberg dude ... just dont mind them .. they are just some idiotic ps3 fans....lets hope that the people be smarter..

  • I wonder if you can set the language.... Like british, aussie, American, black American, canadian eh.....

  • What if, it will be in 3-D and it will look like shes talking to him though that angle.

  • well see like this IF it is real. then we vill son hawe human like npcs. and wee will hawe werry realistic simulations . like first aid games fire department cop and solider games thats teatch you in a way thats culd save your life one day and ewen perhaps save others. wee allready got realistic phyc enviroments thats breaks wen you shoot it now its only the choises and npcs thats need the kick. so i think its great. another step in to the future.

  • Lol the 360 isn't even on.

  • your video is fake ...

  • @7giannhs Poor xbot QQ

  • they just made him look to the right to give it a sense of 3d space

  • You idoits do know this is not a game but new tech right? And it was on TED talks recently any intellegent person would know they talk about real things.

  • @MassiveTroll you idiot know that on TED he said and i quote ""its a trick but it works" , it IS a game, it might be the start of an idea that someday will come true but for now its a gimmick cashing in on the WII craze

  • Wow this is low. Even by microsofts standards.

  • and actually if you watch the entire video, you will notice after milo throws the goggles the bald guys says "did you notice how she reached down to catch the goggles? well everyone thats experienced that reached down". he can only recognise some things. but he still does.

  • i play 360 a lot and i dont think it will be a fail such as PSEYE and the wii fit

  • It is real, stop thinking you know everything !

  • @madlazza milo is real, but the demonstration isnt. They probably wernt ready to show it at this point

  • @randomvidsbymee Yeah but maybe he wasn't looking at her for THAT bit, in case you didn't notice his eyes were moving not stop!

  • @madlazza Just by saying that, you make it sound like you know everything. He has some valid points so let's hear yours.

  • Milo: Boredom Evolved

  • So apperently lionhead gave up making this little shit reality, probably because it was impossible

  • you see xbox sucks ass

  • This game is gonna be fun if you show your cook to the Milo.

  • hella going to buy this

  • your stupid your just trying to wreck a good product

  • If you can't do, what you can't do. DON'T DO IT. Microsoft succeeds in what they CAN do, but now they just wanna lie to their customers, Jesus.

  • Bunch of people crying wolf.

  • NOBODY BUY KINECT. Boycott that shit!

  • You can tell Milo is fake anyway; there is no way that Claire wasn't an actor. She knew exactly how to respond with Milo. I mean, you can look at it very simply at when she hands him the piece of paper; she knows instantly to hand it to the camera and then slide it out of the way quickly. The sentences were obviously prerecorded, the timing is perfect when she narrates her drawing for example. It doesn't look fun anyway. I don't see why the lied in the first place.

  • @MisterAlexUk of course she knew what to say,they didnt just put her in the fucking room and said

    "right talk to the tv and catch the googles"

    and when she narrates her drawing,what the hell are you going on about.she is showing the viewers that she is actually making a drawing of a fish and showing what the game can do.

  • WOLOLOLOL JUST NOTICED BUT IT'S A GOOD THING THEY MADE PROJECT NATAL (KINECT) DIFFERENTLY LOL

  • if they had put the picture like you say it would have been very stupid, you know cause then he looks at the viewer.

  • Everyone should've known it was fake when Molyneux opened his mouth.

  • Although I think it is fake, what's the point in faking it ?

  • @OCNXenthos To get people excited about Kinect and give them the idea that it will be a lot more advanced than it really is making them want to buy it more.

  • what if my voice changes and i cant use it no more

  • Coming soon:

    Molestation pack.

    Includes:

    Buttsecks add on

    Milo homosexual outfit

    Empty warehouse background

  • @pwndurface0824 LOOOOOOOOOOOL

  • you fuckin dont know a thing. clair looks left, milo looks right and how do u explain the lake part at the end of the real video. and by the way wont millions of companys sue microsoft for making a dumb video. get that u fuckin asshole

  • @arjun547655 jesus calm down. dont insult the man. hes just expressing his opinion. grow up

  • ok why dont we just wait until its released before we judge it. for all you know it might be real. but i might be wrong too. lets just wait and see

  • Okay now get a life.

  • Christ, there's a G in recognise. Molyneux says it like five times.

  • This wasn't present of other people. So they could've rehearsed it until perfect like the movies. Who actually went up to it in real life? This will work but in this generation? Probably not. Also the kinnect is priced around 50-100 bucks. Do you really think revolutional items cost that low?

  • @themastac 150 dollars

  • thats kinda strange.

  • Lol Own3D

  • your theory angle for me is wrong you should have seen the girl was kinda standing near the edge or tip of the table you tried rotating her and your dummy stands TOO far from the screen and the table too..

  • LOL smarty pantz...

  • your theory works with real cameras but with CGI there really is no camera. the kid is not looking into a camera is he....

  • @kickingdinisasin facepalm

  • @kickingdinisasin LOL OMG ur joking right?

  • @kickingdinisasin

    So he conveniently makes it look like he is looking at her like hes in real life? It is not hard at all to make him look at a freaking virtual camera... And yes there are cameras in games... Thats what they use to give you an angle on the game and send the video to your TV. They are invisible but they are visible to the developers when they are developing the game.

  • I think it's obvious they did this to make it better for the viewers. It might look wierd at the original angle..

  • is it just me or the tv is a sony bravia?

  • HAH! I saw right away it was an utter fabrication, voice generation and A.I technologies simply aren't at that level yet, but I hadn't noticed that! Great observation skills there!

  • Natal is now called kinect, and the camera moves. If you stand to the left, the boy looks left, stand in the middle? He looks at the game "camera" he should never look at the centre of the screen.

    Ha ha! I busted you're theory 

  • @mkt778

    The camera never moved when she moved.

  • Comment removed