like a boy vs if i were a boy (video premiere)

[SuperRainbowPride]

I have to go with Ciara, Beyonce has to many good songs let someone else have the spot light for once.

[1babylonian]

i love both, but beyonce video clip, shows the actually meaning to her lyrics <3

[tysonlover4eva]

ciara

[jayjay04star]

both are good so does it really matter!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[MisSwahShmicOi]

Both great artist but I'd have to go with Ciara coz basically it was a stronger message to de boys that we can play the game just as well :P

[uwillluvthelastdrop]

i liked ciara way better because she took the time to dress like a boy she did way better than beyonce

[shakeitlikeacholo]

You know its ciara..she can dance and stuff and i like that song better....beyonce is gudd but i like ciaras song better this time!!!

[CiaraMJJanetFan]

CIARA LIKE A BOY IS 5X BETTER THEN IF I WERE A BOY.

[amystonesbytch]

Cici , like be , but i have to say cici :)

[laxgreen10]

Ciara!!!!!!

[mar34iam]

i like both of them equal but beyonce won that cause she wants to be a boy :)

[mscandishopper]

ciara...but beyonce comes next 

[bahdest]

Ciara shawdiie.!!!

[TheTRAVISJUNIOR]

beyonce!!!!!!!! NYPD FTW

[iwannabeanonymous63]

- ciara duhh.

[Equus2011]

I love the " Like a Boy vid" Ciara know she can dance! My friends and I wanted to do what she did, we wanted to show the boys how it felt. Which is why i'm going for "Like a Boy" Love the vid and the song. Beyonce's was too sad/ depressing for me, it made me feel as if there wasn't a guy out in the world who could really treat you right.

[emandkim124]

They are both good for different situations. If you are pissed b/c of something he did, Ciara b/c you can turn it up loud and get the anger out. If you're upset and just feel like crying, Beyonce's song. I love them both.

[Vche86]

Sing goes to: "Like a Boy" Video goes to Beyonce: I like the concept for the video but I like Ciara's song better.

[DaniDiggory]

Ciara is way better!

[nov02khona]

CIARA is the BEST everybody knows

[Beca95ns]

C.I.A.R.A

[Chocogirl221]

i like ciara's more kuz it seems a lot more real but also you an dance to that a lot more easy

[kk20babii]

BEYONCE DUH BIH!

[CVMelanie2009]

i would choose ciara too coz she can dance nd i love dancing

[TheBria22]

I love Ciara !!!! grate video :) :)

[SuperQueenb1983]

That is hot....

[karenjesse10]

ciara all the way

[zxcvbnm123473]

@sweetteet 1

I totally agree Hella Ciara a good dancer and beyonce good singer but they both gud

[sweetweet1]

I dont knw which better cuz ciara is a really strong and gd dancer and she better thn beyonce, in dancin but then beyonce has a stronger voice than ciara so i not really sure

[dasharyba]

i think its wrong to compare these songs coz beyonce singings about how met dnt love women like they should and ciara singings that guys life is easier because they are care free and less is demanded from them

[2014DIVA]

ciara bt dey bith got da same concept bt ciara

[jaybaaby16]

ciara of course!!!!!!!!!!!  <3

[Hoeknew]

Beeyonceee

[stephaniewazhere]

CIARA way better!

[noelmsp007]

ciara's version was epic.

[sarahadelineramos]

CIARA!!!!!!! : P

but i like beyonce's voice

better but i like ciara's

song more

[wolf123rt]

u guys shut the fuck up no one cares what ur saying

[pune37tAnG]

i think ciara's lyrics were better even though it did have an up beat tempo.

[1ladycolts]

Reggie bush is sexy

[pitbulalshkirafan1]

ciara but if i were a boy it is still good!

[SuperHannah1209]

CIARA of course it seems like BEYONCE copied her

[xielanx1]

ciara

[scenegirl2008]

ciara WAY better and she hade the song first

[ahint0fhope]

ciara i love this vid so tru dang!!!

[soccer4ever28]

u guys just shut up...no one reely cares what ur sayin...k. thats what i thought. so just shut up

[Annalynn123x]

i love dem both but i like ciara's like a boy cuz its more up beat

[monaJolly]

ciara "like a boy" is waaaaaaay better

[mrsjonasbro98]

i dont really know. ciaras is more my type, but i prefer beyonces songs.

[blahblahblahxx333]

ciara

[mchick411]

like a boy! ; ) like them both but i like like a boy better

[saksaktut]

both the songs are practically the same and the music vids r in black and white!!!

[skaterchick11000]

ciara by far

[beberox101]

Beyonce love both

[Tho14mas]

i like beyonce's better because she prove's how much it hurts to be in that situation..true story

[mr2392]

Ciara all the way

[445568]

Well I can most definitely see the similarities, I just think that it's hard to compare the two. Both are in black and white but the content it totally different. Beyonce's is more from the perspective of how it looks and how much it hurt, Ciara is more of its unfair and I could do it to you, I do it. Subtle but different.

[noaru]

stoled or not, obviously beyonce's songs are way better, otherwise her new cd wouldnt sell.

Plus this Ciara seems like a hip hop madonna, all bombed up, I'd rather beyonce's legs.

[moekareVSshugochara]

its the other way around ciara is a tomb boy dummy

[lovellio]

ciara... beyonce steals all her ideas from other artists recently realsed songs but beyonce's song is still nice.. but what ciara's idea was way better.... more real

[ckingcarey]

both

[hungryallday]

CIARA she is betta and plus beyonce took the idea from here

[badboyshxtz]

dumbasx' beyonce didnt still the sonq from ciara she asked for it from BC jean [ithink] so it wasnt beyonce idea qet your facts togetha

[hungryallday]

your facts isn't betta because you

'think" she took it

[badboyshxtz]

when i said "think" i was talkin about the girls name i wasnt shore if here name was bc jean LOOK IT UP type in BC JEAN IF I WERE A BOY and yu will get your answer.

[xxiluvxbeachesxx]

CIARA!

[art15t]

hands down, BEYONCE!!!!

[alexdawg7]

beyonce is the shit..

no one should compare her to someone else that isn't even good enough..

:)

[CoyoteSly]

You can't compare an r&b song to a hip hop song.

[BillKaulitz89GR]

BEYONCEEEEEEEEE

[cctzesch]

ciara>beyonce

[singerandmoviestar]

Ciara to me has the better one

[xxkitaxx97]

i like ciara more than beyonce,i do stil think beyonce is ace jst ciara can dance whilst she is singin that is why wen she is live ciara sounds out of breath all the time ; ) lol : D

[dxmago]

hahah well, like i boy was cool too

the songs are completly different

but, beyonce is the best, she IS

and you know it

[NeNeBad08]

CIARA WON THAT!

[hersheys1997]

i lyke ciara better

i mean beyonce izz awesome but ciara can dance

[icepwiinceshx]

it's hard to say, yeah? i mean beyonce's a waaaay better singer than ciara but ciara's moves are damn hot (: i love both songs by the way.

[Treatment110]

beyonce got ciera no lie

[DimDancer13]

My favorite song!!!!!!!!!

[jordonevans]

BEYONCE

[SamSuicidal]

C-I-A-R-A!!!

[KingLild2010]

Ciara plus beyonce stole her song from BC jean

[noelmsp007]

and like a boy's video is INSANE!!!

[noelmsp007]

to me Ciara's was way better... its more fun to listen to!

[LMI1106]

CIARA ALL DAY EVERYDAY

[deluxelikear0cksztar]

like the lyrics from ciara better

[shamrockjorge]

well you really can't compare cuz ciara's is more of dancing. and beyonce tells a story. beyonce sings waaaaaaaay better but ciara is a good dancer. but this is about the songs. .... im gonna go with the QUEEN BEE.... BEYONCE

[Cocopops305]

Like a boy by ciara is more upbeat so it like it better :)

[jeejasso]

Please play me like a toy,So fuking sexy song.If were a TOY

[the1prinse]

well im a cici fan and love both songs but they are two different concepts.......like ciara has a more "get even"sound and beyonce is more of hurt girl.....they are both good but i like the creativeness of beyonces video and the dancing in ciaras video.

[lnieto1]

CIARA

GO CIARA

[mama199412]

vive ciara this is the beste =D

[AaliyahRocks22]

BEYONCE RULES!!!!!

[SH03ZFR3AK101]

its ok

[saltandpepper]

Ciara thought of it first, I am a huge fan of Beyonce but she totally ripped it from Ciara.

I like both songs though :)

[Andres0811]

haha r u serious there is no need to compare OBVIOUSLY CIARA WINS come on now. BEYONCE IS JUST BORING AND THE WORST SONG WAS IF I WERE A BOY FOR REALZ. CICI ALL THE WAY AND FOR EVER!!!

[alfcici]

C.I.A.RA!!

[jasmineholt18]

tha wat up aBOUT IF I WAS A BOZ

[honiicomb]

my GOD everybody is on ciara side! but anyways truthfully Ciara's Like a boy was better than Beyonce's If I were a boy which is bad english by the way it's suppose to be If i WAS a boy but the song is still nice although she lost this fight.

[bellaiglesias]

no, it's correct! if I "WAS" a boy is BAD english. you think that stupid people wrote that song?!!

[3sixteen6]

ciaras is better then beyonces

[raney150]

Ciara's "Like A Boy" is way better than B's "If I were a Boy" but I still like Beyoncé better

[Laurabiabis]

HAHAHA YOUR SOOOO FUNNY!!

[watevr48]

ciara cuz she knos how to what shes doing and saying in this vid

beyonce doesnt kno anything

[MiguelAngelThielman]

ciara more damnnnn beyonce more sweet but still ciara

[YamapiDaisuki02]

I thought it was too much of a coincidence that Beyonce put her version out not too long after Ciara. In the end I like a few songs from both but Ciara wins this hands down!

[Leezzyy]

ciara defnly better

[billKluvr14]

ciara is way better thatb beyonce!

[mermaid176]

ciara win is the only true answer

[seanlovespink]

CIARA wins - Like always...she knoes how to dance...

[Q8BritneyFan]

ciara wins !

[HersheyBest]

i love both but beyonce did copy becuz da ideo n black n white n she act just like a boy thats when ciara got her revenge back n wored da samething that Beyonce wored on her video *crazy* ciara video (never ever) my opinion!!

[hrconhferfe]

Ciara is on my side (:

[fresita1939483284538]

both are great songs but um ciara's is better by far!! makes me wanna dance

[CupcakeLovelys]

Ciara, fer sure.

[alimenka]

ciara wins hands down

[1998girl]

I luv both there both good theres not a fav but certain parts theres better things this could have been one of theres good days or bad days soo you cant tell unless that both of wm have a good or even a bad week of performing THATS TRUE THOUGH

[darcnite001]

there both good but you know CIARA WINS ITS OVER DING DING DING WINNER IS CIARA

[atebalate]

ayyye i like both..

beyonce song i like listening when i have a rough day or something.

ciara song is like when i feel like dancing or something..

but i totally wish that i was a guy..just to know what it feels like..and not an ugly guy...i wanna be a hot guy that is cool and understanding cuzz i know how it feels to be a gurl. yah know??

[darcnite001]

i know

[forfuns]

music n video n dance wise ciara totally wins n takes it.

in terms of voice...well yeh beyonce's better.

[ciaraSOsexii09]

ciara way betta yo

i mean beyonce even put her shit n black an white like ciara's video cum on now beyonce if yu so much asz a diva cum up wit ya own shit

[forfuns]

haha good point

[notthatgirl19]

and beyonce i way better looking as a boy

ciara i forget is a girl wearing those clothes

[notthatgirl19]

BEYONCE ALL THE WAY

if i were a boy if written & sung like it's coming straight from a girls soul

[Laurabiabis]

HA HA HA wow that is the stupidest thing i have ever heard. why the hell would beyonce mean what she is sayin if she happily married.Makes no sense doesit, that is exactly my point

[notthatgirl19]

just because the song was written and produced now doesn't mean she has never felt the emotion of a bad relationship, i am married as well but i have had other relationships that left me feeling hurt and confused

[LMI1106]

like a boy is better

[Laurabiabis]

THAT IS TRUE ALL THE WAY

[milmilou123123]

i hate beyonce but i love this song but the one of ciara is much better!

[GangstaBooDub1]

i meant nice body and bytches!!

[GangstaBooDub1]

ciara aint no man soo all yall hoes dat b hatin on her yes im talkin bout dez baldheaded bytched dat aint got hair wanna hate on cici wit dey jealous asses..cici is beautiful,nice boy, and she can dance her butt off and most gurls on this earth are haters and need 2 get a life.ya dig!!

[GangstaBooDub1]

like a boy is waaaaaaay betta den if i were a boy...even though bey is cool i dont like dat song. its just a bootleg version of ciara's like a boy...but like a boy sounds waay betta and is way betta...im not tryna b mean i like bey and her music its just dat i dont like dis song!

[AmericanGirlVideos6]

i love if i were a boy! it's soooooooo true!

[ESC70737]

ciara is better plus ciara finer sorry beyonce doesn't have ass nor breast just hips and curves not fine

[newthy8]

ciaras a man. fucking poof.

[ChloeSingstar]

beyonces bodys better

[u8myMnMs]

CICI DUH

[TeeWMixes]

Ciara's "Like A Boy". I could sit through the whole song without getting distracted or wanting to turn it off. However listening to Beyoncé's "If I Were A Boy", it just gets boring after a while.

[Drich18]

Ciara's "Like A Boy", that's my jam. Beyonce's version is good too thou

[z0ime]

i like ciaras more. cause she can dance :P

[CBWiiFeYY]

Both are winners for me. Ciara sings about wanting to be like a boy. Beyonce is singing about what she were to do if she was a boy. very similar but in a way different.

[soupaman08]

The Ciara one... dancing nice smooth vocals and lyrics crazy!

[NessaViiv12]

LIKE A BOY!!!!! CIARA ALLL THE WAY

[cattwm]

Ciara its hip hop and beyonce is just white

[flojoemprist]

Ciara all the way

[HeroBreakers]

Beyonce's!

[chriskong2684]

Ciara did here first bryonce stole her concept but she still made it hot

[supergiirl96]

i realli think you cant compare them .. look at ciaras completely different style + ciara has more of a hip hop to it ,, and if you listen to it she sesz ,, SUMTIMES I WISH I COULD ACT LIKE A BOY < it means that shed wunnah ACT LIKE a boy completely different.. Rihana sesz IF I WERE A BOY means shed change things to how boys re-act to things and shed about the girl ..or sumthing

[cabron88]

plain and simple...ciara did it first..

[triciakun18]

Ciara's song beyonce's video

[donnadiscachi]

Ciara hans down is way better because it has an edge, Beyonce's is boring and sounds like she is trying to be a confused man as oppose to Ciara who is defining an uncaring man

[vollygurl262]

love both songs even though like a boy is kinda old

[SUPAHdupa]

they're both good. personally, i like beyonce's more.

[4evamibae]

you cant really compare even though it has the same concept there completely differnt and its getting at the sitution in 2 differnt ways and i love them both

[acoop9071]

i like beyonces version MUCH better

[bribri1108]

i love beyonce and ciara's music but i believe between these two songs, ciara was the best

[cici1cool]

ciara of coarse!!!

[THECERA2]

i love ciaras version

[jodieeeeeexxx]

I like beyonces version better !!