Added: 8 months ago
From: imSarahSnitch
Views: 3,559
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (265)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ...in this one! Donna is sassy enough to keep the Doctor in check, but she is also HUMAN and GOOD enough to keep him in check. She can be a bit cheeky, but she has a really good heart and it's because of that that the Doctor needs her around so badly. (Ex. Fires of Pompeii, Planet of the Ood.) And she is SOOO smart, but you don't get a chance to see it often because she's stuck as a temp, thinking that she's not intelligent and worth nothing, so therefore, that becomes how she is seen by many.

  • Yes. YES. Donna is my favorite companion as well, and I often use the arguments for her that she is the only companion to not fall in love with the Doctor and that she and the Doctor are just such good friends and that her ending is so heartwrenching and insane. HOWEVER, I think she's a lot more intelligent than she gets credit for, and a better person than she gets credit for. I don't have enough characters to explain in this comment, so I shall continue...

  • Donna Noble FTW no contest :)

  • This is hard. Like, I love Rose, and Bad Wolf Bay is heart wrenching.. Donna on the other hand, well at first sight I didn't like her at all. When he asked her to come aboard on the Tardis after the Runaway Bride episode, I was like: "No, I don't want her as companion!" But when she came back after Martha, I adored her! The Adipose episode was great, and over all Donna was one bad-ass companion. But let's not forget Rory! I mean, he died, woke up, died, woke up, died woke up. He is awesome.

  • DONNA!

  • DONNA IS MY FAVOURITE TOOO

  • OMG I am SO glad that someone else appreciates the fact that Donna doesn't fancy the Doctor!!!!!

  • but overall i think sarah jane smith was the best rip elizabeth sladen 

  • u look like ally steel

  • Favorite Doctor Who Companion, Donna MF Nobles!!!!

  • Donna is my favorite female lead character and Rory is my fave male lead.

  • I'm going too politely disagree and say, three way tie between Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart, Rory Williams, and Sarah Jane Smith.

  • Donna, without a doubt. Even more than friends, they're like brother and sister. And she's just friggin' awesome. After all that emotional turmoil at bad wolf bay, seeing the Christmas Invasion with Donna being like, "I'm getting married so bite me alien boy!" is just so refresing. She's absolutely the best.

  • I think Donna's story is so sad! I would argue that her time with the doctor makes her such a better person; she gets a new perspective on life, her priorities change and she decides to care about much more important things. Then the doctor has to leave and she has to forget and she goes back to being superficial and generally annoying and shallow. I also think this is super sad for the Grandfather who was able to see what she had grown into and she can never be that again and he cant tell her.

  • You do realise I love you even more now I know that you love Donna?

  • I may be the only one, but Martha is my favorite. Rose will always be special because she was the first. But Martha is so smart. She's the only companion that comes close to keeping up with the doctor intellectually. And even though she really likes the doctor, she's smart enough to get out before she's in too deep. She loves adventures with him, but realizes they won't last forever. And doesn't want her life to be left in shambles when one day he takes off without her for some noble reason.

  • I can't make a choice yet as I need to catch up more. Also the doctor is totally Ace! Ace being the short hand for asexual/asexuality. He is kind of a Ace icon. :3

  • I feel like this is an unpopular opinion..but.. I love them ALL. Each of them. I do not dislike one. Honestly. Rose might just be my favourite though. But then there's Rory and Amy too so I'm really not sure. Haha.

  • Donna.

    "It doesnt need saying"

  • Donna Noble is God. FACT.

  • Rory! Amy! Sarah Jane!

  • Donna Noble is my favourite too! I love her!

  • I was more annoyed by rose then Martha, shes defiantly my favorite companion!

  • Donna Noble was my least favorite companion... She was annoying, not very smart, and arrogant. I believe that for me it's Amy or no-one. I mean not only do the actors work well together, but Amy has known of the doctor for all her life, he's her imaginary friend and has had the universe pored into her brain... Besides Rory also rocks a lot more than Donna, sorry.

  • I just saw the end of Donna.

    Oh my GOD.

    You were completely right, I adore her now. The "end" of her was so emotionally draining though! For me, however, Rose still remains my favorite companion- but Donna is soooo close.

  • What about Sarah Jane?!

    

  • captain jack harkness

  • I like Amy and Rory together as companions. They're funny together plus Amy can kick butt and take names like nobody's business and Rory is adorable. ^_^ Donna comes right behind them, though! Love Donna. And I will admit that it's definitely refreshing to have a companion that doesn't try to get any kind romantic response out of The Doctor.

  • Donna.

    Does it need any explaining? no.

  • Team Captain Jack!

  • Donna is for sure the best. I agree so much about her story line being so tragic because it always breaks my heart when i go back and rewatch it.

  • I HATE ROSE! she is sooo freaking annoying! DONNA KICKED ASS! woot!

  • I only understood some of this (I'm not as caught up as you) but YOUR EXCITEMENT IS INFECTIOUS, GIRL!! Love it!!

  • Donna is my FEKKING favorite

  • I think Donna's kind of annoying... :/ sorry. I like Rory and Amy because Amy makes me laugh and Rory rules.

  • Martha is my favorite companion. For me, there was no other companion who was expected to do more and had to live up to a standard than Martha. People are so hard on her because she fell in love with the Doctor, but I'm sorry, I can't really blame her. Martha had to single handedly save the world on so many accounts, namely human nature/family of blood and the season 3 finale. And then she didn't get credit for it. I love all of the companions, I just think Martha rose to every challenge set.

  • Rose and Donna are so close for me. I would put more stuff about why I love both but I just woke up and my head isn't working. I will say that While Rose is first, Donna is an EXTREMELY Close second.

  • HOW DID I MISS THIS VIDEO BEFORE?!!

    I love and miss Rose but I agree that Donna is frikken badass!! And I really wanna know what River knows about her because she knew her when they met in Silence in the Library.

  • i just love allllll the companions!

  • Donna all the way. You just get me.

  • My favorite companion is Rory ^_^ Followed by Donna of course :D

  • DONNA NOBLE/ Catherine Tate = my favorite Person EVER! Most definitely subscribed and Favorited!!

  • So much Martha hate! I liked her a lot :)

  • I think Donna's story is a little more tragic because she can't remember all the stuff that happened to her! She really grew as a person over her series and then she had to go back to basically just being the person she was before. At least Rose got to get it on with "the Doctor" (still not quite sold on Doctors 1 + 2 being the SAME person, but close enough...). I do think that the Season 2 finale was definitely sadder than Season 4's finale (which was still totally tragic), though.

  • @belleglass Also, Rose totally got more badass whilst she was away from the Doctor. Obviously it's awful that they got separated, but at least she didn't lose all her experiences and new-found badassness from her time with Nine & Ten. I mean, she's freaking practically running the alternate-universe Torchwood! That is impressive.

  • When I saw that this video was a rant about Donna Noble I thought you were going to be ranting about your dislike for her. This was a very nice surprise because she's my favorite also! I love to see all of the Donna love in the comments too.

  • Rory, hands down. And I hate Rose. That is all.

  • DONNA she's soooooooo awesome

  • I love Donna, Amy and Rory. I like Amy because she was the first companion when I really started getting into Doctor Who and Rory is just super sweet and a badass. And Donna is hilarious and awesome and great.

  • I can't pick a companion as my favorite. They're all special for their own reasons and I honestly like them all so far. I really need to get into the ongoing 6th season before I fall too far behind...

  • I totally love Donna for just being the doctor's friend too!!! ^_^ I totally agree with you about Donna. She is awesome!!!! My fav... lets see ALL OF THEM!!!! I can't pick. I love them all for different reasons. Rose was so sweet and normal. Her love for the doctor was so innocent. Martha was amazing in the season 3 finally. Donna same reasons as you. Amy is so sassy and ROY is just so very amazing!! I want one. Oh and Jack is just the bestest ever!!!!!!!

  • Donna is definitely my favorite for all the reasons you gave. Rory is my second favorite even though he deserves way better than Amy. Rose is just like "meh" to me and I never really believed in her and the Doctor. I love Martha, and I don't understand why everyone hates her. I hate Amy. THAT'S THE END.

  • I can't pick a favourite. They're all too awesome to choose.

  • Rory = badass.  your argument is invalid. ;3

  • Donna is my favourite companion, she's great, mostly because the fact that she and The Doctor are only friends.

  • I watched the seasons out of order, and Martha was the first companion I saw, so I didn't really like Rose. I thought Donna's ending was far more sad. At least Rose got to keep the memories. Donna had to go back to the life she was unhappy with and not know how she had grown, and not know the great friendship she had. Donna is my favorite for the reasons you listed, and because the dialogue between her and the Doctor was consistently entertaining.

  • DONNA is mine for the exact reasons that you have. And contour was awesome!

    Yay Glow stick girls. Thats right! seat dancing with glow sticks.... stupid girls in front didn't even use em!

  • My favourite companion is Amy Pond. Honestly, I didn't like Rose much. She got on my nerves...

  • I thought that Donna's ending was more heart-wrenching for me, because she doesn't even get to live with the experience. She grew so much as a person throughout the season and to lose all of that. I was definitely sobbing when it happened. At least Rose still had her memories (and then, you know, the "other" doctor).

  • I so agree!  Donna Noble is my favorite too. I hate that all my friends (guys...) like her least, simply because she's "not hot" WTF? And these are not teenage guys, but 25-year-olds...>< Donna is great, end of story.

  • I can't decide who my favourite is, either Donna or Rose. A week or so ago I would have said Amy but upon reflecting on older series I decided that it was either Rose or Donna. Also I used to hate Martha but upon watching half of the third series non-stop, I began to love her.

    Also could you please make a video about your favourite Doctor?

  • Amy is without a doubt my favorite companion. Donna is a close second. Rose was okay. Martha just flat out annoyed me.

  • DONNA NOBLE!! Can you think of anyone more kick-ass than her? Amy is my second choice. What can I say? I love me some redheads! ;)

  • Donna FTW!

    Everyone else is waaay too obsessed with The Doctor.

  • I suppose the dreamy Jack Harkness doesn't count as a companion? Then I pick Amy. There's just something about her guts that I really like. She jumps in and takes the risks and I love it.

    Donna is a VERY close second. I think perhaps the only reason she isn't at the top is that I'm head over heels for Matt Smith's Doctor and that colors the companions a little. I think Donna is smarter than she lets on and I love her attitude. The friendship they have is great and season 4 finale is my fav.

  • My favorite companions (in order):

    1. Rose

    2. Amy/Rory (I consider them one in the same)

    3. Donna

    4. Martha

    Although, Amy and Rory are slowly creeping their way up to the number 1 spot!

  • I love Rose, Donna, and Amy. Rose being my favorite out of those three. I just flat out hate Martha. Martha is the pits.

    AH! The NYC ConTour date just got like x10 better! I'm so excited to meet you there!

  • SUSAN FOREMAN FTW! xD

  • Donna has such amazing chemistry with the doctor, and shes hilarious. Donna ftw

  • eeeew Donna...

    MARTHAMARTHAMARTHAMARTHA!!!!!!­!!!!!

  • I say Rory! He's great and the Donna/Rose are a close tie for second.

  • I love Donna. Seriously. I love her so much

  • Donna all the way, because Catherine Tate is immense!

  • Donna is definitely my favorite companion! My friend cosplayed as her during Akon

  • DONNA!

  • AMY

  • I LOVE Donna! She's BRILLAINT!!! Amy is great but Donna, i Miss her, SO MUCH still... possibly more then i miss ten

  • (Con't) FINALLY, Rory. I can't even describe my love for him, he is a very close second favorite companion. He loves Amy so much, and he would do anything for her. He is the definition of a BAMF, I think. There are a lot of awesome tumblr posts about him that pretty much sum up how I feel about him.

    Sorry for spamming your comments with my opinions, Sarah! :/ I talk wayyy too much about the things I love.

  • (Con't) Amy, my favorite companion. The Doctor has been in her life for years, and I think that makes their relationship very unique--Amy feels like she really knows the Doctor, since he's been in her life for so long, and that makes her less in awe of him than the others. Also, she is really brave and pretty much a bamf whenever she's in danger, with her Donna-esque way of telling people off. She also is good with relating to people, even though she has a bit of an attitude...

  • (Con't) I think Donna's ending might even be a tiny bit more tragic than Rose's (I can hear the cries of the angry mob already), because she forgot everything she saw with the Doctor, all the things they did, all the people she helped. She forgot how the Doctor showed her how special she was. For Donna, none of the wonderful S4 moments that we cherish happened at all. It's like the expression "'It is better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all"-Rose has memories, Donna doesn't.

  • (Con't) I agree with everything you said about Donna- she definitely has her bad qualities, but she has wonderful ones that overshadow those. I love the relationship between her and the Doctor- they really are the best of friends, just having fun together, exploring and appreciating the wonders of the universe. She is not afraid to tell anyone what she thinks, but she is also anxious to help everyone in need.

    She's definitely the funniest companion.... (cont)

  • (Con't) Fans tend to be hard on Martha, but I think she is incredibly intelligent, really nice to everyone, and a she is still a great friend to the Doctor, regardless of the "unrequited love." I think a lot of people hate her because of that but can you really blame her? The Doctor is amazing (and attracitve!), we all know that.

    Plus, Martha was brave enough to save the world almost single-handedly and then she was strong enough to reject more traveling with the Doctor. That takes willpower.

  • Okay, prepare for a multi-comment response, because Doctor Who is my second favorite thing (after Harry Potter). :)

    I'm going to go companion by companion:

    Rose is amazing. She brought out the best in both the 9th and 10th Doctor. She has such a loving and caring heart, and even though is not the most intelligent, she has great intuition and can interact well with pretty much everyone they meet. Her ending was incredibly tragic. Doomsday makes me sob like a baby every single time. (con't)

  • It's deff a tie between Rose and Donna. The first episode of Doctor Who I ever watched was Stolen Earth and so I instantly liked Donna. And this blonde girl starts running towards the Doctor and I was like WTF?! And thennn I watched the rest of the series and fell in love with Rose. So it's a tie for me. Catherine Tate was so amazing in Doctor Who!

  • I love Donna, i used to like Rose the best but as of like six months ago i kinda like Donna more. I don't hat Martha like a lot of people and Amy is alright. I also really like Rory hahaha (but is he counted as a companion?)

  • I do like Donna, mainly because it's so fun to say her name. But my favorite is Amy.

  • Donna Donna Donna.

  • The first episode that Donna appeared in, the Christmas special, I absolutely hated her. But then when she came back as a full time companion I loved her. Also, now I'm even more excited for going to ConTour in NYC.

  • Rose is the best. I miss her.

  • I'm more of a Donna and Amy person. Rose was good, but... eh. I still like Donna and my over Rose. And Martha... Martha was just a.. No.

  • I LOVE donna. She is hilarious and brings a lot of heart to the show. She sees things from a human and ethical (what's right and fair) standpoint. and YES the Doctor and Donna have this friendship chemistry that cannot be beat.

    I'm guessing you'll be at the Atlanta stop? Can't wait to meet you :]

  • Honestly I would say that hands down Donna's story is the MOST tragic storyline. Her song is even called "The rueful fate of Donna Noble!" It breaks my heart more then Rose ever could (and I REALLY love Rose) because at the very least Rose had a happy ending that wasn't marred by her loosing everything she gained in knowing the Doctor.

  • I can't choose between Donna, Amy, Adric and Martha... there are so many, it's impossible... but those are my top four. :)

  • i skipped the whole middle section because I haven't caught up yet...

    but i'm SUPER pumped your videos are back up!

  • Donna is definitely my favorite female companion. She's just so awesome and such a BAMF and I just love her. However, I think Rory is my favorite overall. I do love me some Rory Williams-Pond.

  • Donna is awesome. I still can't get over the Doctor and Rose's relationship, though. But they're my favorites.

  • THANK YOU! SOMEONE WHO AGREES DONNA IS SUPREEEEEEEME!

  • I've only ever seen like two or three Doctor Who episodes. Besides Doctor Who, I don't know anyone's name.

  • Donna is definitely my favorite. I just adore her and all her sass! Hope to see you at leakycon!

  • I love Donna she's awesome and a great contrast to the other companions but Amy is my favourite I don't know why but i just think she's awesome! ;')

  • WHOOP WHOOP. see you in austin texas!

  • I like all the companions in their own right (except I'm not a huge fan of Amy...she's okay but she just seems like the writers tried to smash Rose, Martha, and Donna into one person)

    but yeah, I don't know if I could pick a favorite. I do love Donna, especially for the reason you mentioned, how she never falls for the Doctor. I love that and it's so much more enjoyable to watch Doctor Who when the companion is not pining after the doctor. Plus Catherine Tate is genius and comedy gold.

  • I love all of the companions. At least, the companions in the new series (I haven't seen the old ones). I think I'm alone in that, haha xD

  • I'm not sure if she "counts" yet, but River's definitely my favorite companion so far, with Donna admittedly as a close second and Amy third. Donna and River are both really brilliant (in their own ways) and aren't afraid to stick up to and be a force of opposition to the Doctor when he lets his weaknesses get the better of him (like being seduced by power even for good reasons, letting his "fury" reign, etc). They both see beyond this front of wonder and mystery and interact w/ him as a person

  • i hate donna with a flaming passion. i also really wish i looked exactly like you... that is all.

  • I never really liked rose :/

    Martha and Donna are awesome :)

  • Although I haven't seen all of Doctor Who, I hate Rose!!

    Martha is okay.

    I like Donna a lot. (Catherine Tate is awesome.)

    But my fav is definetly Amy. The combination of her, Rory and the Dr. is perfection :)

  • DONNA NOBLE! She's my favorite companion, too. She's just... brilliant. She brings a lot of control for the Doctor. Such as that one episode with the creature on her back, since she turned left she wasn't there to stop the Doctor from just standing there and dying.

    I dunno, she's just amazinglybrilliantawesomepheno­menalDOCTORDONNA

  • So sad you aren't going to be at the earlier shows, I'm going to be at the Toronto show, but I know a bunch of the Toronto youtubers will be there so and the show is going to be amazing either way.

    Also I love Donna, Catherine Tate is just wonderful.

  • also I'm going to ConTour in NYC so I'll get to meet you! :D

  • DONNA IS MY FAVORITE TOOOO :D

  • Rose is my favourite companion but I do like Donna for the fact that she never wants more than friendship from the doctor! :)

  • I'm a Martha gal, but I LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE Donna :)

  • what about the doctor? which doctor do you like the most?

  • I was just thinking the other day that I think the directors chose to have Donna Noble as the next companion coz we all needed a bit of a laugh after what happened with Rose.

    Donna made everything much brighter and the Doctor much happier :)

  • Comment removed

  • I really really DON'T like Rose. :|

    Martha's my favourite :D

    Donna & Amy are tied.

    RORY IS AMAZING.

  • I want to be friends!!! I think you are like the coolest person ever!!!! Oh and I love Martha. I feel like she was a wasted character because I only really enjoyed about half of her season. I love her because she knew when to leave. She knew she was in an awful one sided relationship and in the end she did what was best for her mental health. I loved Donna too. Donna and the doctor didn't have drama. They just had a lot of fun.... so basically she is awesome

  • Donna is my favorite forever!!! <333

    She will always be the best companion of all time.

    Next to Sarah Jane.

    Catherine Tate is an amazing actress, my fav, wah I want her to come back to the show.

    I miss the DoctorDonna duo.

  • Donna Noble is my favorite as well. Rory is my second, Rose is my third, then Martha, then Amy... I don't like Amy that much... Though The Master is my absolute favorite character! End of Time would be the saddest episode for me. I cry every time I watch. (Which is sad because the Master is in it, and I love him so much!)

  • Oohhh gosh. Hate me for it, but i dont like catherine tate at all, so donna has always been annoying. I do love that she wasnt in love with the doctor. But my fav companion? Her father in the last two david tennant episodes. He was just so faithful when the Doctor needed anything and that even ended up killing the Doctor, and relieving him of all this pressure the Doctor had built up emotionally. So Donna's father ultimately helped the Doctor get passed the heartbreak he felt for hurting and we

  • @MetalheadVic12 I loved him too but he was her grandfather, not her dad. :)

  • I agree completely! They really are like Fred & George! I guess the only thing I didn't like about her was that she kept changing her mind about travelling with the Doctor being like "Doctor, this is wrong!" yeah. Other than that, Donna was my fave ^___^

  • i love Martha Jones she is amazing. but Donna is my very very close second. all those reason that you listed is correct. But Martha is still my favorite

  • My favorite was Rose, but Dona is a close second. It made me so happy watching you freak out over Doctor Who, though. :D

  • rose was really annoying to me in the beginning but then idk when but it switched and she really grew on me and when he lost her it was tragic but it made up for it in a really sad happy way, i love amy too just cause of her nature

  • Yay you're back! I completely agree with everything you said in this video. Rose was my number 1 favorite and then Martha just annoyed me to no end and then... DONNA!! Ah! Love Donna. I think her ending may be more tragic than Rose's. Rose knew the Doctor, lost him, but could still remember him and have those memories, while Donna knew the Doctor, was better and happier with the Doctor, and has had all that taken away with no way of remembering it or tapping into the person she could be. :(

  • I love Donna! She was the best.I think Rory is pretty amazing too though!

  • I'd argue that Donna isn't conventiionally intelligent but she's actually just so smart and the most wonderful thing about her adventures with the Doctor is that she realizes how intelligent she really is and the biggest tragedy of her story is that she is capable of so much and she doesn't know it anymore. UGH I ALSO LOVE DONNA NOBLE. She doesn't shoot the shit she just GETS IT DONE.

  • Ah, Donna Noble. The bit where her and the Doctor are communicating through the window about Adipose is absolutely hilarious.

  • Donna is by far my favorite companion. No one else even comes close.

  • I love Rose, of course, but Donna...gosh, that was the best season to watch. Heart-breaking, yet freaking hilarious! I never liked Martha, and Amy...I don't really care for her that much. I have yet to watch an episode where I was like, "OMG. Amy. You are the best." (Although, I LOVED Amy's Choice...) But RORY. Rory is another story. I love him!!

  • I also really like Donna, but i don't get why so many people liked Rose, mine goes 1. Rory. 2. Donna 3. Amy 4.Rose 5. Martha (yes, Rory gets his own section, i don't count two people as one companion, and he is far better than Amy, though i really do like her, she kinda a whore though.)

  • OH THANK GOD YOU'RE BACK.

    I WAS SO SAD.

    AHHH.

  • Donna is my least favorite companion. I see her faults as... well, faults. I like season 5 Amy best, then Martha, then Rose, then season 6 Amy, then Donna. Why do people have such an issue with Martha for liking the Doctor? He's an amazing guy.

  • Martha is my favourite and I really don't understand it when people don't like her, I'm yet to hear a good reason.

  • @kirbyjayne35 I know right?

  • DONNA!!! I agree on all counts. I literally cried for ten minutes after the Season 4 finale was over, I just couldn't believe what had happened to her. I love that she got to come back for End of Time, though. I do love the Amy/Rory combo, but Donna will always win in my mind.

  • Donna. Obvi. For all the exact same reasons as you. Asdfghjkls I love you

    Are you coming to the Toronto show by any chance? :)

  • We are still watching you. Don't screw up again.

  • Donna Noble~ I just love everything about her. I did cry for her and the Doctor at the end of season 4. Its just Donna Noble. Donna Noble and the Doctor to me were kinda like brother and sister to me. -sigh- Donna Noble. Jeez I love that season and that Christmas special. Oh and Rory. I like him also.

  • I'm an Amy Pond fan!

  • THANK YOU!

    These are ALL the reasons I love Donna as well, I don't know if she's my favorite, but I really dislike when people hate on her!

  • Rose. :) But Donna's sarcasm and attitude are fantastic!

  • Rose, Donna, Amy/Rory, Martha.

    I like all of them, though. :) There really isn't a character that I dislike. Even if there is something I don't like, the show overall always wins me over.

    I also loved the season four finale. :) I found the last couple episodes of season four so exciting.

    I found Donna's ending just as tramatic as Rose's in season two - but of course, in a completly different way. Both have made me cry. :(

    Wish you were coming to Toronto on The ConTour!

  • Rose is my favorite, but Donna and Rory are super, super close seconds. After that, Amy, then Martha (I really, really don't like either of them very much. Actually Martha I don't like at all...).

  • Donna Noble is totally my favorite companion!! I never really liked Rose. I guess it was because she was so clingy. She just couldn't live without the Doctor. Martha kinda liked him, but when he left she got back up and went on with her life. It's hard to explain why I don't like Rose, I just don't. And Donna is the best because she really is the only companion (in the new series) that was just as brilliant as the Doctor. Donna is just simply amazing. Buuut I also love Rory.

  • RORY! :D

  • It's interesting to see where people stand, people that I know who watched the series didn't seem to see doctor who the way I did. My closest friend shares my love for Rose Tyler but others describe her as "annoying" and it breaks my heart. However I can't deny my love for the other companions, and Donna Noble is just amazing. I will admit though, I have paused on Season 5 episode 3 because after three weeks I'm still traumatized by Season 4 finale...for Donna and Rose. :'(

  • I just finished season three. I have spoiler phobia, so I'll watch this video when I have seen the rest.

  • I think Donna's story is more tragic. There 's that saying "its better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all." In a way Donna was to deal with both of these. She doesn't remember all the good times she had with the Doctor but she still feels sad/empty because somehow knows there is something missing. If that makes any sense. 

  • Rose. Or possibly Amy. I waver on this. Glad you got your videos back up and that you are making awesome videos again.

  • YAY Donna! My Donna action figure is cheering for an awesome fellow fan!

    No, Donna's story is the most tragic for me. She became a complete person and was 'the most important woman in the universe' for a moment to not be able to remember being important for one moment of your insignificant life is horrible.

  • See... I feel like I really missed something in the Whoverse because... everyone loves Donna, even if she's not their favorite, and I just.... can't seem to connect with her. Guh.... I hate that! I want to connect with her so bad!

  • DOCTAH! DONNA!

  • Thanks for coming back! Will you inform us on what happened anytime soon???

  • Donna and Amy ftw! On a side note, why is it when a tour comes to Texas, it is always Dallas and never Houston? I so dearly wish I could go.

  • @doglover32993 Well, we are going to Austin and Dallas, so thats more stops than any other state has! Except Florida.... :(

  • Thanks for praising Donna SO MUCH! Also, I can't wait to see you in New Orleans!

  • I'd have to say it's a tie between Donna and Rose..

    

  • Comment removed

  • i loveeee donna. my whovian friends are either rose or amy lovers. but i mean, come on. shes donna noble!

    "OI SPACEMAN"

  • Donna is amazing! She is hilarious, witty, out spoken, and all around a bamf.

    To me, her story is more tragic than Rose's. Rose got keep her family-and later on, her own Doctor-, but Donna got nothing. She couldn't even keep the memories of the time she had with the Doctor.

  • I love Donna to pieces and actually she's my second favorite companion after Amy Pond (LOVE her) I have a thing for sassy redheads! By the way you are a sassy redhead and you remind a bit of Donna ; )

  • Finally. Someone with my EXACT feelings and opinions about Donna. It's so great to know other people loved her too, as she gets quite a lot of hate sometimes.

  • Yes! I will be seeing you on the OKC stop! Wooot! It's my birthday and I'm super excited about spending it seeing some of my favorite YouTubers and listening to my favorite songs LIVE.

    Amy is my favorite, but there aren't enough characters remaining to tell you why. Believe me. I've tried several times.

  • Donnaaaaaaaaaaa! Yes ! I love her (:

    I do miss her ><

  • Rose, Martha, Donna, Amy, Rose. (Rose is my fave and least fave. I think Donna may be second, but I looove the Master season finale so that correlates with Martha just beating Donna for second.) Oh and see you at leakycon/contour!

  • hell yeah donna!!! i cried so hard after journey's end because of donna. i really like rory and captain jack harkness too, but donna is hands down the best of the main companions

  • Nice. I love Donna, Amoary is a close second though. I couldn't stand Rose though, I have no valid resoning... but yeah.

  • Sarah you're back! I missed you!

    I have to say that Donna and Rose are equal in my book because they don't have