Haley Scarnato-Tell Him

[ladyspleaser]

I am still in love with her, what an amazing performance, I hope I can hire her to come and sing for me on my next birthday.

[wicaco]

When showing off your legs, "it's all about prayer." How... Christian of her?

[officialmidnightdj]

The perfect song and an excellent performance!

All the best Haley!

[boba31400]

shes got a butter face but thos legs can be wrapped around me anytime!!

[hororka666]

She looks like Lois from Smallville while singing this song. Do you agree? :D

[HeeHuh]

This was a really good performance. It was a solid vocal and of course she's a gorgeous gal. Amazing body.

[michaelwjimenez]

you were awesome and should have went further in the competition. you are also very beautuful and sexy. vive la raza

[crazyasianman07]

something stuck out to me besides her voice. She has really nice legs!! xD

[goyanks13240]

This was the perfect song for her. She did a great job. She definitely is a great performer and she knows how to work the crowds.

[osahju914]

yeah...all singers have the ability to be great...it's a matter of finding the right song for THEM

[kimwildelover]

Dear Haley ... Beautiful Haley ... my tongue awaits you! :)

[JFDtwitter]

one word: disastrous

[seank135]

she is soooooo fit

[drumstyx901]

She's actually a great singer. You don't have to belt to be good.

[Kab0087]

@drumstyx901 agree 100%

[pac232]

you suck... it.

[hesterdabombdabomb]

oh cheesy girl haley i hope u cheesy dwell so cheesily i hope u gets et on fire in the desert u have such a cheesy face and body u should be cheesy dwelling

[anzekenk]

i absolutely love this performance, shes not a good singer but she knows how to perform and work the crowds, love it!

she could be a model =o

[MyFinalHeaven18]

@anzekenk she could be model or cheerleader something pretty

[yankeesandjetsrule]

I was almost stunned when I watched this live...

she pretty much got away with stripping on TV...and I LOVED IT! Woo!

[YankeesGooner]

haha yeah

[pokethunderdude]

She's got a nice voiec, and she has this cool energy about her. She's very good.

[jl2279]

This is why American Idol sucks. Tell Him was originally sung by The Exciters in 1962. Billie Davis did a cover in 1963.

[codeblue2187]

yeah right

[19DJD]

yep ur right this was sung by the exciters

[IckyVicky231]

bestest ever

[DashX88]

Oh, and I totally love Simon's reply. I wish he'd say that about me.

[theherooftime2]

more yummy for my tummy =====>0

[nadi1010]

Butter face.

[brasileiro2010]

yum yum yum yummy.......

[vfgjhj]

when she sang it sounded like cheesy karaoke, Melinda Doolittle got completely ripped off, she didn't look good enough but her voice was CLEARLY the best! She didn't have one off week.

[doubleDdog09]

i bet that would have been awesome to sit up close and have haley dance right in front of you, like @ 2:33. i bet they got a great show.

[lesterhotel]

I think shes great. Oh and for those who make rude comments about her Treat others were kindness and they will treat you with kindness back.

[unsexynstupid]

I agree. These people are either

A) Jealous females who despise her because she's prettier than they are

B) Upset males who can't have sex with her.

She rocked that night. I also liked her version of "If My Heart Had Wings". That was awesome also.

[Simpledreamer]

I agree. This was her night!!

[DashX88]

Yes, that was really amazing! So great, completely perfect. She did it so sexy and with so much confidence, but still not in a too cocky way. I loved it. And no, I'm not a guy, I am a woman. And I'm not a lesbian either.

[xxsexyberryxx]

she's amazing and pretty and lulu was sweet to her too :D xx

[sithhunter5000]

She thinks she's so pretty doesnt she? im not sayin she's not

[michiganer9666]

i like her but i like gina glocksen better! but i wish phil stacey went home! he stayed instead of haley and gina glocksen! PHIL STACEY SUX!

[irfanulhaq1]

she has a nice body that dunt mean she can sing

[bballgal104]

omg i love when she sings this song shes sounds so good! shes pretty and i <333 her voice i dont no why a lot of ppl think shes horrible shes terrific!!

HALEY'S AWESOME:)

[JesusRokks]

i'm one of the many ppl who thinks she's horrible :)... mainly good for showing off her legs. that's not talent.

[NYChica23]

I know what you mean. As the weeks went on, her skirts kept getting shorter

[RAGEINGMORA]

not true it once went longer by a centimetere and a half

[osahju914]

yea, the next week, she did a ballad, kinda losing her fanbase, and another ballad losing more votes, and then losing more votes with a song too fast for her and she murdeered vicki sue robinson, that is the end

[RAGEINGMORA]

haha

[osahju914]

btw, she did do ballads before, like her top 24 and top 12 performances but she lost sympathy after this performance because it was so "good(BLECH!)"

murdering whitney in the top 20 and faith hill in the top 16 with upbeats got her sympathy votes, in addition to every vocal she did before this one. this one earned her voted she DESERVED! haley rocked this one, and true colors frankly, but that was it!

[RAGEINGMORA]

right

[jpowell99]

nice legs!

[fangal88]

she sucks she only on the show cuz of her stupid legs! SHE A BITCH!

[TommyGDub]

Wow. You're seriously an idiot.

[bonchan110]

to nop011: u r the whore

to S3Li22: no she didn't

go Haley go

[aquariandy]

She's a nice girl. Not all her performances are good, but this one's the best for me.. She looks comfortable and enjoying her singing.. I love her with this song..

[RCmack]

One of the guys I work with feels Haley is ugly.

I told him he's nuts. Haley's HOT! and she's not a bad singer, either!

[k2thedd]

SHE SHOLD HAVE COME IN FRONT OF SANJAYA

[osahju914]

true

[AndrewSa888]

SHE IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!

[nop011]

She was such a WHORE! She and sinjaya were responsible for too many good singers being sent home. but, she is kinda hot, unlike sinjaya.

[Abberrzz]

um no im pretty sure YOU PEOPLE are responsible for other singers being sent home! its not THEIR fault YOU didnt vote! so stop blaming them!

[TommyGDub]

Gosh, she was soooo underrated. I'd take her over Jordin Sparks any day of the week.

[S3Li22]

that was good, but I heard that she was using her legs to get votes

[whitty4u]

This was pretty good!

[KingBrandonC]

i love this !!

[andrenalyn]

I like her, she has a very adorable voice....Good Luck on your career...

[AssumptionsFinest]

^_^ She's pretty and she CAN sing. And I like her shoes :P

[SofiaShower92]

she doesnt looks any special but she sing s very openhearted and i like it :)):)

[unsexynstupid]

Then graceful must be blind!

[GracefullTiger]

She is ugly..in my opinion

[SofiaShower92]

lovve this version of this song!! im gonna sing it soon in stockholm =)=) it was this clip that inspired me to sing it actually :P

[pytko3]

She was at least the contestant who had the best looking legs! There are only 2 singers that I think have the best legs, Gwen Stefani and Amerie. If Haley Scarnato had won, I would have said that there are now 3 singers that have the best legs.

[CheapSushi]

Yeah. ha. My tounge is calling. hee hee hee....

[acedup]

Disney's calling.

[richmondteng]

katelyn's performance is way a lot better

[sandy92995]

I think dis is her best performance 4 me:P

[rudy712]

Nice legs, mmmmm

[AnnPatriceM17]

Ha! Ha! that's exactly what I said!!!!!! her fionce is very lucky to have her!

[JVBIV]

she's got star quality written all over her. too bad Sanjaya cost her one more week on the show. she can put her 6" pumps under my bed anytime :)

[rocknrollprincess07]

i luv haley.

plus shes from sa town and i want some1 from my town 2 win!

[duffnationusa]

I would like to personally thank all of you Idol fans for voting for Haley "Hot Legs" Scarnato thus keeping her on the show. Good job! We need eye candy!-RP

[oosnij]

That was SEXY! She may not have the voice to win but that was a hot performance. Definately the hottest girl in the final 12. BTW have you seen Katmcphee lately. She's SMOKIN

[TheBlackHalo9]

this is definitely her best so far

[mcwardy]

why dont we have babes like this in our uk pop idol :/ id hit that any day

[S14DGENER8]

i agree with jack, she is from san antonio and even the local news here said she won because of short shorts

[kimwatts]

I think Lulu got it right. Haley has her own place in this competition, she delivered a nice show. It's impossible to compare her to Jordin or Melinda, just too different styles.

[JOLLYJILL123]

i agree with you chukers11 :]

your totally right. if she doesnt win though

i DEFFINATLY was blake lewis hes my favorite boy. haleys my favorite girl :]

[chukers11]

she's great!!!! I really hope she wins this competition because she would be a great role model. if you agree with me post a comment

[JackTraven2525]

so hot.

[harvey1963]

Bounce Bounce Bounce its all about the bounce. Its too bad she did not make top 10....would have been a great concert when they go on tour!!! Good luck Haley

[harvey1963]

OOPS!!! Haley did make top 10 and she will make the tour a huge success. Keep up the good performances Haley you are working hard!!!

[kimwatts]

nice try !!! lol

[harvey1963]

Now I can't get that song out of my head!!! What an impression she has made on many male viewers.