Added: 2 years ago
From: cgiuk
Views: 212,547
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (325)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Beautiful!:)

  • no offense but i can tell you are not playing this. the fingers and notes dont match up. just to let u know, i play 8th grade piano. i'm not lying

  • OMG, so beautiful! Made me cry! Thanks for sharing!

  • Dokonalé

  • Are you really Alexandre Desplat? :o

  • can u please send me the piano sheet? len_blackpieces77@live.com

  • great ! ;)

  • wow u learnt that all from ear? your so good beautiful :) im just starting to learn it now hopefully ill be able to play it as well as you one day

  • This song is so beautiful

  • Hey, i think you play it very good, and it sounds just like the original, which by my opinion is REALLY hard to achieve. Great work! :)

  • you are AWESOME !!!!

  • nice very good job dude!

  • la cancion es bonita pero el actor haciendo playback aun mejor! viva el playback tabakon

  • I'm playing this for my GCSE. (Or if your American I think its a deploma? I dont know XD) So I hope I score good! I can play up to where you finish off at 1:46...Though I play it slightly different than you at some points :P I'll keep watching your video to make sure I learn everything in time for the exam!

  • @labbiabbi Hey, thanks for the comment and good luck with the GCSE. To be fair, this was my first attempt at it - I did another video which is WAY closer to the one you hear in the film - check that one out...it's probably closer to yours :)

  • @labbiabbi nice, once you learn after that it gets REALLY fun(:

  • Such lovely music never hate this:)

  • you are really good... =•]

  • Your left hand is not curved when you play; I have the same problem. My teacher sometimes poins it out. Pain in the arse. The flat hand, not my teacher; she's lovely. Like your playing here :o)

  • Beyond beautiful...

  • lovely but a bit faulty with the sound as you play lol look at your left hand!

  • is it me or the sound is not sync?

  • dude your totally faking i noticed that you toched a key and it didnt make a noise at the begging. You cant even try to trick me

  • wow. just wow. love it so much. you are amazing. i'm sure it's pretty hard. congratulations, really.

  • your amazing this is soo good.. :P

  • too bad the sound's too soft.... its so beautiful.... :')

  • One Word: PERFECT!!

    You're awesome

  • Hi, I just wanted to say, I listened it again today (yours) and... wow, it's gorgeous!!

    You don't want to make a tutorial...? My version (which I've got from a tutorial here on youtube) doesn't sound like yours, and maybe I'm just not playing it well, but...

    Well, anyway, I would love if you wanted to, but it's your choice + time! Thanks anyway for playing this!

    Elaine

  • Hi, I just wanted to say, I listened it again today (yours) and... wow, it's gorgeous!!

    You don't want to make a tutorial...? My version (which I've got from a tutorial here on youtube) doesn't sound like yours, and maybe I'm just not playing it well, but...

    Well, anyway, I would love if you wanted to, but it's your choice + time! Thanks anyway for playing this!

    Elain

  • awesome playing!!!!

  • Amazing!

    You took piano lessons?

    Ive been struggling with the synchrony between left and right hands part.

    Cheers

  • It's good. but the video is a liitle slow, first you hear, than you see.

    It's terrific playing, I'm learning this one too!

    :)

  • #WTF sehr gut gespielt

  • Can you please tell me which notes you´re playing at 0.17 ??

    I always play c-a-d-c, d-a-d-e, d-g-b-d, etc. etc.

    And with my left hand 6 times a-c-e, etc... however how do you play it, please?

    How many times are you doing the notes on your left in that part? (I mean till 0.28) So would you please tell me? I really like your version...

  • @ElineeSama12 Thanks for the compliment

    Right ok..without notating this, it's tricky to explain.

    In this version - Left hand is doing this at 0.17

    (each of these notes is a quaver) -

    BAR 1 - A, E, C, E, C, E, C, E

    BAR 2 - A, F, C, F, C, F, C, F

    BAR 3 - G, D, B, D, B, D, B, D

    BAR 4 - Ab, E, B, E, B, E, B, E

    This then wraps round again into bar 1. It's a basic running left hand. The right melody hand uses virtually the same notes to form the melody. Just play around with it :)

    Sam :)

  • @cgiuk Thank you very much!! I sure will :)

  • Great work.

  • Comment removed

  • oooo nice (: I did a cover for this too :D

  • It sounds very nice ;) This is the first song i go to play on the piano, and i am very far in this song now, i play now for 4 days piano:D

    Normally i play guitar.. for 10 years now.

    And it look really strange that the video is coming faster then the sound :P

    But very Good ;)

  • um..ur not really playing this..?

  • @equinejumper356 Then who is?

    Because this person really is.

    It's just the camera's out of sync with the mic. If you pay attention to where his hands are on the piano, you'd know he's really playing it.

  • @TheTrollAmongUs its a track in he background. and no. i can play tthis song and its NOTHING like that

  • @equinejumper356 If you don't believe that I'm playing then that's fine. All I can say is, if your version doesn't look like mine above then it sure doesn't sound like mine either :)

  • love that song

    

  • amazing...how can you work this out by ear????

  • Hej! Przecież to się w ogóle nie pokrywa! Czy on tak po prostu sobie puścił z magnetofonu utwór i udaje, że gra? Czy tylko mu się nie spasował dźwięk z grafiką? Bo jest tak jakoś troszkę inaczej...

  • właśnie o tym samym pomyślałam

  • this is so awesome!! wow! can't stop listening =D

  • That was awesome. Which piano model is this?

  • @ghosty264 It's a Roland V Piano connected to Genelec speakers

  • its awesome ! and i like ur shirt , rob has one ^_^

  • Simply beautiful, I wish I could have turned it up louder but you did a wonderful job!

  • Das ist echt schön gespielt, aber leider zu leise :(

  • The picture is faster than the sound, and it came out to quiet. Did you have it any where near the speaker? Right next to it is bad, but near it would be good.

  • i play it and i can assure that you play it too :)

    very beautiful version, despite some mistakes, which aren't really mistakes because it sounds great :)

  • sei bravissimo e questa canzone e bellissima complimenti

  • thats what i thought your were kinda off when playing i saw your a beat or two behind

  • i think its really good, and your rEALLY TALENTED so id keep going with it. its also an amazing song choice, dont listen to anymone else your good!!Cxx

  • beautiful recording sound, wish it were louder

    bravo

    douglas

  • Its soooooo beautifull!!!!<3 i almost cry every time i hear it!! this song makes me think about my life and all the bad and good things ther is happent in it!!!!

  • Wow! Amazingness- by ear too... 0.0

  • You aren't even playing it!!!! Around the end of the video, you are not even playing the right notes or playing at all!!!!! Wow...

  • try using protools to record it i just uploaded the same song with youtube and protools and it was in sync.

  • you are sooooo good at piano!!!!

  • wow...O.O sounds almost like the original (except for a few mistakes) but otherwise all i have to say is wow good job =D

  • why do you play so quiet

  • @TheMw2209 It's not me playing...its the recording. For some reason came out quiet.

  • @cgiuk great job :o

  • if i haven't already commented on this amazing piece then all i have to say is AMAZING!!! i wish i was as good lol

  • That is really good! Well done :)

  • Je suis époustouflé, vraiment. Bravo. J'ai trouvé la partition, et je ne le joue pas aussi bien que cela. Félicitation. Je suis toute émoustillé :) et écoute ce morceau en boucle.

  • Je pense que l'intro de cette musique est incontestablement copiée sur une musique de film du grand Michel Berger "tout feu tout flamme" à écouter d'urgence !!

    à bientôt !

  • Perfect and beautiful.

  • oh i love this, you are soo talented. Thanx for uploadin this.

    And i believe tht u are really playin the notes :)

  • Great job.

  • Sorry a few mistakes in that last comment lol

  • I have the notes and in going to learn how to play over the summer nut the guy was really awsome

  • wow thats really amazing =)

  • ESSA MUSICA É LINDA DE MAIS

  • i know how to play the song similarly to you. don't listen to all of the other people saying it's not you playing. i can tell by the noted you're playing that it's really you.

  • Superb. I know this guy - and I know how genuine and determined he would be to nail this. Excellent!

  • you are really great :)

  • Great .... :D

  • Wow. It sounds exactly like the orignal. Great job:)

  • wow! You are incredible! Can not you make a video where you play a bit slower so we can see how you're doing ... I always wanted to teach me this song is so beautiful! Please, a little more slowly

  • that's really good! great job!

  • You're amazing!

    Beautiful song!! :)

    Love it!

  • I like it 2 but i can't find the notes anywhere can you please give a link or send it to me cause i want to play it 2 =3

  • @NikhilHayeso1 it 2hours and 4 mintues!!!!!!!!!

  • @NikhilHayeso1 The Movie Is 125 Minutes.. Soo I guess you havn't seen it.. Spammer! xD GO TWILIGHT!!!

  • No one has the notes i think because it's still under copyright, people only learn to play it by ear which is impressive :)

  • Don't worry, I believe you played this on your own. Your hand movements are swift and go along with music.. the timing is just off. Very beautiful!

  • Wow ..

  • Wow, you worked it out be ear. This is the closest one I've heard so far! Cool.

  • cool... got to learn how to play it!!! know some of it.....u have inspired me!!! lol : )

  • BEAUTIFUL & ALSO MAGNIFICENT

  • Great i know how to play this song too and it isnt hard, but it isnt easy too :D

  • Wonderful... 5 Stars for you

  • perfect

    marry me??

    :P

  • the song as been completely wasted on the twilight serie

  • I really liked this cover! It sounds just like the one on the movie. Beautiful. Marvelous. Excellent. ;) ♥

  • such an emotinal song! and you play it perfect, i love it just like the movie! thanks dude!

  • That was beautiful you did an amazing job I love this song .

    You are very talented it sounds wonderful keep up the good work.

  • great!!!

    P.D: your have beautiful hands!

    kisses from Spain.

  • Very well played! Check out my cover of "The Meadow" on my profile!

  • The playing is lovely, but there was a slight sound delay and it was too distracting for me to finish watching. I am a bit anal, lol! But lovely it was :D

  • beautiful.

  • soooo perfect of the piano play, and i love this theme as well

  • OMGOODNESS<3 i wish i could do that .-.

  • i think i could learn this..wish someone would teach me...thi is what i like to play in piano..the fingers are always moving..i dunno why but i like it when the fingers plays fast or always moving..i just dont know how to explain it..it just feels good when you play..great cover man...

  • wow............that was outstanding! best cover I've seen so far!

  • wow!! u r really gd!

  • worked it out BY EAR? oh my gosh, you are really good in this!! and i love this song so much, i cry every time i listen it

  • @MrsMillaCullen me too!!

  • Ich wünschte ich könnte auch so Piano spielen, das ist wunderschön!

  • This is Really Good !!!

  • this is really good,

    nd the camera like delays a bit but i dnt care

    this is like really amazing i loved it!

  • This is very amazing. I love this. And you worked it out by ear? Even better.

  • seriously dude that was AMAZING!

  • this is New moon...without the triangle love saga

  • it's really beautifull. Where did you get the notes? I just can't find then anywhere.

  • Worked it out by ear.

  • @cgiuk great job :o

  • @sakrauz555 i couldn't find them too, but if you have pianolessons just ask the teacher :)

  • beautifully done

  • i belive you Cguik....cuz i can see that you are playin it...youtube probably screwed it up...it happens....BTW! you play awsome!!

  • wow u are 2 good ooh i love your work amazing

  • i believe you :)

  • Strange, the notes this person is playing don't match the music at all. This video was definitely altered, they might know how to play it in real life but when they recorded the video they over-layed a professional recording of the song which then threw the timing of the entire thing off.

  • Or Youtube put the video out of sync....it happens..

  • I promised myself that I wouldn't reply to any more of these 'he's not really playing' type posts but I felt i'd just gotta defend myself on this one. I have so far tried 2 different cameras and 4 different initial formats before upload and STILL youtube screws up the sync. The notes are correct, slow it down and copy it on a piano and you'll see that I am playing this.

  • @Jelyphish86 This sometimes happens on videos. Its not that he is not playing the music...It is the phsyical movements are not matching up with the music which more than likely recorded direct. If you noticce, the timing of the notes not matching up is exactly the same all the time. If one were to try and play along wiht something, they time lapse would be more random. This is accurate.

  • @Jelyphish86 ...yeah you can tell at the end....I just started learning piano about two months ago and I can tell...

  • @jeterlover03 ....ooops sorry just read your earlier reply...please disregard this comment...sorry

  • you are not really playing !?

  • precious

  • Ahh sorry but your hands dont seem to be in time with the music ? And the music sounds a little TOO good. Are you sure you are playing this and have not just put the real music in the video over the top of your own ?

    Sorry.

  • Check out my other video

  • wouaouuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu you are amazing

  • this is beautiful! very well done..im incredibly amazed

  • wow, this is awesome!

  • you are playing so beatifull

    amazing song,really =)

  • where did u get the sheet mucis for this??

    i've tried 2 look for it, but i cant find it!!!

    :)

  • I didn't use sheet music, worked it out by ear

  • @cgiuk I playing piano too and I want your Ears!! 5P

  • Almost better than the original Woah =D

  • wow that very beautiful... :-)

  • Im the other way round with this piece, i cant play the left hand correct but my right is fine

    I dont play chords in the left hand i play broken chords xD

  • Wow this sounds really good!

  • omgosh...you really learned it without a piece of sheet music??? Ö ;-)

  • did you know this is the same song they used in the corpse bride movie?

  • amazing ...

  • What a Beautiful song

  • amazzingg <3x

  • i only know the right hand

  • Beautifully ahh.. because it's more than just sound <3

  • I don't know how to play the piano, but i promised myself that this will be the 1st song I will learn to play when I do get a piano.

  • I love this song thank you

  • i loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee the songgggg

  • this is great. hope you should how to play. the sound of the music calms you when your hearing it. it beautiful

  • Well done!

    Do you have any score for it?

    maybe some midi data?

    or did you just play it by ear?

  • Just by ear

  • koool

  • Thanks to everyone who has commented and rated so far. I've made a new video which i'll post early next week. It's the new version which I think is much closer to the original than this one. Just trying to decide whether or not to drop a little something else in there to prove that it's me playing :)

  • You can definalty play the song your doing all the right notes...but it sounds to much like the orginal! like i mean exactly the same! Even the dynamics are the same!

    Any way it dosnt matter whether there is music playing, you can still play the song, you can tell by your fingering!

  • AWESOME!! love it <3

  • love it!

  • ehm... könntest du mir die noten zukommen lassen?^^;

    Ich find, du hast das gut gespielt,... so viele fehler waren es gar nicht^^

  • i read your answer on the: "why doesn't the sound come at the same moment as you are playing?", but dude, it doesn't seems like you're even playing the right targets sometimes... but i suppose i'm wrong, it's hard to see as the piano is showing from the opposite side... but at least it sounds good, and you seem to have a talent, so keep it up boy :)

  • It is nice Music, I love it.

  • that's so cool....im gonna cry...

    can u send me the piano sheet?? PLEASE!!!!

    Thanks a lot!!!!

  • It makes me cry..

  • OMG Awesome! That's really good:D

  • I love this song is sooooo beautiful :*:*:*

  • this isn't even you playing! take a look at the keys she i playing people, or no? playing. at the start she turns the volume right down so it looks like it. seriously/

  • Don't know why i'm even bothering to reply but just so you know..this is me playing. FIrstly..i'm a guy. Secondly, at the beginning of the video, i've just pressed record on the camera. You can see both of the volume controls...one on the V-Piano on the left hand side, the other on the mixer. LIke a huge number of videos on Youtube, there is a delay between the video and audio..that's why it looks like i'm playing the notes at the wrong times.

  • can i have the sheet music please?

    and u served that guy who told u off. xD