He is certainly a good song writer, with a great voice, but I hope he is not neglecting mastering his talent, (namely his timing and vocal mastering) because of his 'ill gotten' fame, because of his friend, who is obviously that guy off twilight, judging by all the other comments. This song is good, but it could be great...if sung properly....
@wolfgirlbabe ok from your name your hating on rob because of jacob...relax, marcus does alright but I agree Rob's version has more feeling in it ...sorry That's just the way it is.
lol whatever Robsessed. This is the true version. Rob just tries to copy Marcus when he sings I am Broken and it sounds rasty and fake. If Rob wasn't famous no one would even take note of it. He tries to copy all his friends when he sings THEIR SONGS. Its just a way for him to try to get some fame as a fake musican by singing their songs on a Twilight soundtrack.
@wolfgirlbabe That's not true, Rob doesn't try to copy... He sings it his way, which is with a lot of soul, and passion. And ALL of his fans like his music, because they like his music. Not just because he's a celebrity. Even if that is the reason at least 50% of his fans found him, there is still the other 50%....some people like that style of music. AND there are only 2 songs by Rob on any of the twilight soundtracks.
Heard Rob's version more than a hundred times. Allways thought it was amazing. I can't say wich one is better. But one thing this gave me and what rob's didn't was enormous chills.
I like Rob Pattinson as much as the next girl but I wonder how many people would say Rob's was better if they were COMPLETELY unbiased. They're both equally amazing!
I think both his and Rob's versions are incredible. For me personally, I heard Rob's first so am more used to it. I guess if I heard Marcus' first I probably would have preferred it. Vocally, Marcus is probably better but I'm sure he's had more professional training than Rob and the passion Rob brings into his singing takes my breath away. It's a on outstanding song and both versions are equally good!
Everyone is comparing this to Robert Pattinson. They are both wonderful versions of the song and both completely different. Their aim was to not sounds the same, they just wanted to have their own interpretation. And I think they are both great. So just appreciate this. If you don't like it, don't watch it. Simples.
Love this video :) The ruckus have seen him play this live a few times and I love it. Can't listen to Rob singing it as his voice annoys me so much, so thanks for putting this up <3
Love this video :) The ruckus have seen him play this live a few times and I love it. Can't listen to Rob singing it as his voice annoys me so much, so thanks for putting this up <3
comparing this to robert pattinson's cover, this sounds like it's out of tune when he says "now I'm found"...he should admit that robert sings this better and just write songs for him since he's obviously a better singer.
he wrote a very good song. i love it. when i heard rob sing it though i fell in love with it. if i had heard it here first, i wouldnt have thought twice about it
It's true that there is a level of emotion and improvisation in Rob's version that is moving but I prefer Marcus simply because he can play the guitar in rhythm. Rob isn't exactly the best guitar player...or even a good one. That doesn't mean he doesn't have an awesome voice though. If Marcus played the guitar while Rob sang I think it would be unstoppable.
It's true that there is a level of emotion and improvisation in Rob's version that is moving but I prefer Marcus simply because he can play the guitar in rhythm. Rob isn't exactly the best guitar player...or even a good one. That doesn't mean he doesn't have an awesome voice though. If Marcus played the guitar while Rob sang I think it would be unstoppable.
@forbes39 if i wrote a song and sang it, then i give a better singer my lyrics i wrote and they sang it better, then thats like this but thats my view on it maybe you like this better i duno i prefare rob pattinson
I love the two versions but i love rob's one !!!!!! Marcus have a very good voice too !!
Twilighteuseinfos 2 months ago
Marcus is bringing sexy back ;)
London2521 2 months ago
Omg i though i was in love with Rob but i guess he is my new husband
poochicuddle 2 months ago
he should get more attention, he got the amazing voice, so talented
twitter0418 3 months ago
He is certainly a good song writer, with a great voice, but I hope he is not neglecting mastering his talent, (namely his timing and vocal mastering) because of his 'ill gotten' fame, because of his friend, who is obviously that guy off twilight, judging by all the other comments. This song is good, but it could be great...if sung properly....
ozmaorigrl 4 months ago
I like roberts rendition of it better, but it was still really good :) love you Robbb -3
xchadloverx 5 months ago
Love you Marcus, almost as much as Rob!
ransomfan 5 months ago
A great singer he is. Thanks Dude I love you, there is hope indeed
Whistlejocket 5 months ago
Thanks to Perez (jerk) , I don't think i would have heard this song and it would have been a big shame.
maiden35 5 months ago
He's my new obsession.
hsmluva11 5 months ago
@wolfgirlbabe ok from your name your hating on rob because of jacob...relax, marcus does alright but I agree Rob's version has more feeling in it ...sorry That's just the way it is.
bossyboo32 5 months ago
sweet i was 16,000th viewer
ethanpok 6 months ago
For this song to be written and sang this way.. I'd say he is still broken <3
tamikacyrus 6 months ago
lol whatever Robsessed. This is the true version. Rob just tries to copy Marcus when he sings I am Broken and it sounds rasty and fake. If Rob wasn't famous no one would even take note of it. He tries to copy all his friends when he sings THEIR SONGS. Its just a way for him to try to get some fame as a fake musican by singing their songs on a Twilight soundtrack.
wolfgirlbabe 6 months ago
@wolfgirlbabe That's not true, Rob doesn't try to copy... He sings it his way, which is with a lot of soul, and passion. And ALL of his fans like his music, because they like his music. Not just because he's a celebrity. Even if that is the reason at least 50% of his fans found him, there is still the other 50%....some people like that style of music. AND there are only 2 songs by Rob on any of the twilight soundtracks.
tmts95 6 months ago
@tmts95 I meant "And not ALL of his fans
tmts95 6 months ago
@themrspatzy i actually think Robs voice got more to it, though Marcus is an amazing singer aswell...
MesaTheinsane 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like it. No comparisons necessary.
BlueChelleRose 6 months ago
I like it. No comparison's necessary.
BlueChelleRose 6 months ago
Damn nice!! awesome voice mate!
MesaTheinsane 6 months ago
loooove this! nd robs version<3333
brontegrace11 7 months ago
This is written by Marcus and sang like Marcus wanted it to sound like... I wish people would stop comparing it to Rob's COVER of this song!!!!
mazdarexseven 7 months ago
goood song.
ArthurRiggs 7 months ago
Heard Rob's version more than a hundred times. Allways thought it was amazing. I can't say wich one is better. But one thing this gave me and what rob's didn't was enormous chills.
phille950331 7 months ago
I like Rob Pattinson as much as the next girl but I wonder how many people would say Rob's was better if they were COMPLETELY unbiased. They're both equally amazing!
rhiandotra 8 months ago
i love rob's version.... but this is marcus's song... so i prefer the original to rob's remake...
pingwenfriend 8 months ago
Thank you so much for uploading this. :) Marcus is pretty amazing.
xCarlinee 8 months ago
I think both guys did a fantastic job. :)
0LittlemissLola 10 months ago
I think both his and Rob's versions are incredible. For me personally, I heard Rob's first so am more used to it. I guess if I heard Marcus' first I probably would have preferred it. Vocally, Marcus is probably better but I'm sure he's had more professional training than Rob and the passion Rob brings into his singing takes my breath away. It's a on outstanding song and both versions are equally good!
TheMrspatzy 11 months ago 24
absolutely amazing i dont think we should be comparing this to robbie because they both sound fantastic
missari13 1 year ago
Everyone is comparing this to Robert Pattinson. They are both wonderful versions of the song and both completely different. Their aim was to not sounds the same, they just wanted to have their own interpretation. And I think they are both great. So just appreciate this. If you don't like it, don't watch it. Simples.
gemzee82 1 year ago 2
He is great!
truebloodgrl 1 year ago
He sings it ok But rob was much better!!! xD
Shazbar95 1 year ago
Great song but Robert Pattinson sang it much better.
Meg6109 1 year ago
Eh...Robert was better -.-
AfricaSmith 1 year ago
i honestly like the way rob sings it i think there voice is similar but i like robs marcus is a great singing though
lilbit902 1 year ago
@theherdmentality no offense but Rob and Marcus sound pretty similar. If you dont like Marcus then you dont like Rob.
London2521 1 year ago
@London2521 Not really, they have a different style of singing. Rob can go for it much more! :)
tralala08x 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love this video :) The ruckus have seen him play this live a few times and I love it. Can't listen to Rob singing it as his voice annoys me so much, so thanks for putting this up <3
theruckusblog 1 year ago
Love this video :) The ruckus have seen him play this live a few times and I love it. Can't listen to Rob singing it as his voice annoys me so much, so thanks for putting this up <3
theruckusblog 1 year ago
comparing this to robert pattinson's cover, this sounds like it's out of tune when he says "now I'm found"...he should admit that robert sings this better and just write songs for him since he's obviously a better singer.
theherdmentality 1 year ago
@theherdmentality I couldn't disagree with you more! Marcus is an amazing songwriter & musician.
mylobster27 1 year ago
@theherdmentality Negatory.
KristaynuhTriesAgain 1 year ago
@theherdmentality Honestly I think Marcus sings this song WAY better than Rob & I love Rob but lets face facts Marcus does it better.
bbwraven 1 year ago 2
Holy Crap.. I didn't think he could sing like that, when I first saw him in this video.. But really, this is amazing!
JustTheAndrea 1 year ago
UR VOICE IS AMAZINGLY BEAUTIFUL I LOVE IT I LOVE THE SONG GOSH SOO AMAZING
MsBRICKCITYPRINCESS 1 year ago
Geezz he's funny
RubyPearson 1 year ago
Whow.. I love this.
xxJoanLeyten 1 year ago
he wrote a very good song. i love it. when i heard rob sing it though i fell in love with it. if i had heard it here first, i wouldnt have thought twice about it
666neveragain 1 year ago
Perfect!!!!!!!!!!! (From Brazil) @nabespaloff
Natoddynho 1 year ago
It's true that there is a level of emotion and improvisation in Rob's version that is moving but I prefer Marcus simply because he can play the guitar in rhythm. Rob isn't exactly the best guitar player...or even a good one. That doesn't mean he doesn't have an awesome voice though. If Marcus played the guitar while Rob sang I think it would be unstoppable.
dheinen81 1 year ago 2
@dheinen81 i think your highly underestimating roberts guitar playing, he is hardly out of time, just a different style....
forgetwhatyoudontkno 1 year ago
It's true that there is a level of emotion and improvisation in Rob's version that is moving but I prefer Marcus simply because he can play the guitar in rhythm. Rob isn't exactly the best guitar player...or even a good one. That doesn't mean he doesn't have an awesome voice though. If Marcus played the guitar while Rob sang I think it would be unstoppable.
dheinen81 1 year ago
How the hell can anyone think Pattinson does this better????? Absolute bloody morons!
joag95 1 year ago
@joag95 no have you even heard robert pattinson verison it is amazing, but everyone has there views :)
13stoddart 1 year ago
i think robert pattinson was better at this song but on the postive side it is a good version :)
13stoddart 1 year ago
@13stoddart how can robert pattinson bebetter at a song that marcus foster wrote?
forbes39 1 year ago
@forbes39 if i wrote a song and sang it, then i give a better singer my lyrics i wrote and they sang it better, then thats like this but thats my view on it maybe you like this better i duno i prefare rob pattinson
13stoddart 1 year ago
Robert Pattinson absolutely killed this song.
EricaDarke 1 year ago
Why does he sound so perfect? I love it! lol
JSBoredProductionz 1 year ago
My god, he is so amazing! The way his voice almost breaks, but he keeps singing! So powerful! SUCH a good singer. Love his style, too.
loveuJhonny 1 year ago
Im with joag95
brennygeegeegee 1 year ago
I'm sorry, but anyone who thinks Rob is better with any song than Marcus has to be deaf!
joag95 2 years ago
Love this song, and love Marcus Foster... BUT Rob is better in this song !!
bettepuz 2 years ago
i cry when i hear this song :')
thesaramazing 2 years ago
I'm a sucker for the original but i'm converted. With those lyrics and that emotion in his voice, he can do it however he wants!
juceweazel4 2 years ago
This looks so clear! what knda cam did you use?
brennygeegeegee 2 years ago 3
Thanks. I just used my lil Canon PowerShot SD770. It's a handy lil camera. :)
echo7723 2 years ago 4
Love Marcus singing this song! Amazing! Chills!
blairbuckler 2 years ago 12
Love Love LOVE, this version! Thanks for posting!
timber110 2 years ago 4