the Phoenicians themselves (we should not use this word they were canaanites and the word phoenician has greek orgins and not semetic ones) were part of the ethnic fabric of the levant and middle east generally. and the canaanite language was replaced by firstly aramaic and then hellenic greek way before the arabic invasion.
@otzimate I also did not claim that, of course the last phoenician writting is from 200 ad written on a coin. arabic came later so 650 ad, even though there were arabic speaking christians already in the levant, like converted Nabateans, Ghassanids.
Phoenicain Sisters and Brothers, before you start firing comments at will (military term) please listen and compare between the spoken language in this clip, hebrew, syriac, and arabic. you will discover with some effort that death (mot) allah (allohim) ba3l (ba3l" male in arabic) ... are words of very similar languages. so before you start condemming arabs and syriacs and hebrews and assyrians for terminating your racial connection with your great ancestors (Phoenicians),
@otzimate I never claimed that there are racial semitic people,they dont exist,there is no arab, hebrew,aramaic,assyrian, akkadian,nor canaaanite gene.But to claim that phoenicians r of greek origins is also absurd,there is also no special gene only 4 greeks,also bulgarians have phoenican genes,persians to a small part,also the nabateans arabs,also native berbers of north africa in the sahara,who had never touch by punic traders. Canaanites,arabs,hebrews...r semitic speaking culturs,
@patronoro this withthe comparison is right but Baal is not Moloch, Moloch was always a differnt god but he got also the title "baal" but he was not the "baal". Child sacrifice is not really attested but hotly debated, there is no clear evidence and not even all cananaites did this, it was just a bad rumor by romans and hebrews and non-canaanite israaelites and greeks
@Malkibaal what are the greek counter parts to Baal, Dagon, mot, Molech and Asteraoth? Do the Canaanite gods have equivalent counter parts in the pre-islamic paganism? Alot, Manat and Al-Uzza. Is Al-Uzza the same as Asteroth?
@Malkibaal Thank you so much. I have been trying to find that out for years. You are very intellegent. How long have been speaking Canaanite? How did you learn it? Did you major in it at college?
@JohnTheHutDweller l learned it by myself my knowledge of lebanese arabic and little bit classic arabic and ancient hebrew helped me :) thank you :) I started to learn canaanite when was 17, 2006 :) now I am 22, 20011
@MiracleKD18 exactly you get my point, whihc the most people do not get and call it hebrew with arabic pronounciation, if the most westerners would heart a correct pronounced aramaic/hebrew or any semitic language correct pronounced they all would asssume it would be some kind of arabic/arabic dialect. :) But the sounds typical for arabic are also typcal for the rest of the semitic languages we cannot deny this. :)
@MiracleKD18 the only difference is that arabic is one of the few semitic languages with a broad sound system, while the rest of the semitic language lost many sounds, but there are also some exceptions: ancient ugaritic, ancient amoritic, ancient akkadian, sabaen language.
@MiracleKD18 thank you for your interest and questions, please check out my latest video , where I spoke better and more precise with exact consonant pronounciation, :) this is one of my first videos, of course I did not have so much experience but now I speak it much better please check it out :D
Unfortunately islam and some other samawi religions destroyed the whole semitic culture and replaced with a cruel one, sorry im not against you but you know that right...
Great job, nice phonecian, I reaserched this in much detail and I know that Anat and Astrate and Ashtrothe was the same goddess. Middle Eastern people had many names for their gods and goddesses. Even today there are supposed to be 99 names of Allah
Good effort must have put a lot of time into this. I have been gaining an interest in the Phoenicians through a Lebanese lady running a cooking course here in UK! Keep up the good work!
@5fingerdiscountx iluh, eluh is the old phoenician long form of the name god and means "god" in old arabic "ilah" , short form il, in ugaritic also "ilah", short form il
in late phoenician and punic we have just El /Il, ELim,/Ilim for the name for god.
@5fingerdiscountx you are right, in hebrew ELOHIM means god but it is in plural form (something that points to the fact that we were all pagan before turning monotheistic). god in single form is EL.
Interesting, but I thought Ashtaroth was the Hebrew version of the name, created by using the consonants of Ashtart with the vowels of the word "bosheth", "abomination/shameful thing" so that when "Ashtaroth" was read, it'd be read as "Abomination"
I am sorry this is not hebrew, I study the language of the canaanites, who worshipped Baal and Ashirat and Adun and El, I read many phoenician and punic inscriptions, I saw the words written in latin letters too, I am not an arab I am canaanite phoenician, I am lebanese, but I know hebree little bit too, this is not hebrew, modern hebrew is neither the oldest nor the latest stage of hebrew it is a mix of old and new, and many foreign words.
In lebanese arabic there are a lot of phoenician words which survived like "gmad or9" meaning freeze on the earth, "meaning stop", Beside that I started to learn ugarit too,if you have questions for this language ask me. THank you
@MalkiBaal Your videos are awesome but please, when you write the name of some ancient Deity, write it with a capital letter - show some respect for beliefs of our ancestors.
It's amazing ! I speak hebrew and I can understand a bit what u say without looking at the subtitles! It's like the same!!! That's such a pity that Lebanese do not talk this wonderful language anymore! This is another proof that Canaanites and Hebrews are not arabic!!!
is there any similarity in the words used between arabic and phoenician language? i know that this is phoenician language, but there are many words that sound like arabic jibberish to me.
I'm inviting everyone to my (youtube channel) where I have listed many information on the genetic marker of the Phoenicians known as -- haplogroup J2 (M172) Y-DNA -- as well as their history and culture and so much more.
How to get to my (youtube channel) you just click on my YOUTUBE SCREEN-NAME and it should take you right to my channel to learn real Phoenician history.
Thank you for posting this unusual work. A for the effort. But I just want to remind that the real Canaanite pronunciation is still unknown, and it's based mostly on the hebraic pronunciation, which I considered a bad reference, because the Hebrews took their language from Canaanites and not the reverse. Also I think that the real pronunciation should be closer to Arabic, especially for the sounds of the "vowels". Finally, just to remind that what we know about human sacrifices still not sure.
Yea , I am lebanese, my family name is "Kanaan", like the phoenician called their homeland and they called theirself canaanites, the name phoenican was the greek version. I live in bavaria you get much accent here hehe! BUt feel to express and thanks for the comment!
Very good Phoenician accent!
Salimgeo 1 day ago
the Phoenicians themselves (we should not use this word they were canaanites and the word phoenician has greek orgins and not semetic ones) were part of the ethnic fabric of the levant and middle east generally. and the canaanite language was replaced by firstly aramaic and then hellenic greek way before the arabic invasion.
otzimate 2 months ago
@otzimate I also did not claim that, of course the last phoenician writting is from 200 ad written on a coin. arabic came later so 650 ad, even though there were arabic speaking christians already in the levant, like converted Nabateans, Ghassanids.
Malkibaal 2 months ago
Phoenicain Sisters and Brothers, before you start firing comments at will (military term) please listen and compare between the spoken language in this clip, hebrew, syriac, and arabic. you will discover with some effort that death (mot) allah (allohim) ba3l (ba3l" male in arabic) ... are words of very similar languages. so before you start condemming arabs and syriacs and hebrews and assyrians for terminating your racial connection with your great ancestors (Phoenicians),
otzimate 2 months ago
@otzimate I never claimed that there are racial semitic people,they dont exist,there is no arab, hebrew,aramaic,assyrian, akkadian,nor canaaanite gene.But to claim that phoenicians r of greek origins is also absurd,there is also no special gene only 4 greeks,also bulgarians have phoenican genes,persians to a small part,also the nabateans arabs,also native berbers of north africa in the sahara,who had never touch by punic traders. Canaanites,arabs,hebrews...r semitic speaking culturs,
Malkibaal 2 months ago
لا إله إلى الله و محمد و كل الأنبياء رسل الله فترجمه باللغة الحميرية ولكن معروف بالاسم الفينيقية
DaLynxfighta 7 months ago
Hello, I think Baal is also called Moloch, Molech, Cronos, Jupiter, Jehova, Satan, etc. To worship Baal baby sacrifices must be done.
salutes
patronoro 7 months ago
@patronoro this withthe comparison is right but Baal is not Moloch, Moloch was always a differnt god but he got also the title "baal" but he was not the "baal". Child sacrifice is not really attested but hotly debated, there is no clear evidence and not even all cananaites did this, it was just a bad rumor by romans and hebrews and non-canaanite israaelites and greeks
Malkibaal 7 months ago
Hi Canaan! Hail from Lebanon, great work, big respect, can I contact u somehow? Email or smth?
BaalAnth 8 months ago
@BaalAnth I am open for everyone to give free sources and free material to learn the phoenician language
Malkibaal 8 months ago
This video is Awesome. What about Dagon and Molech? What were their roles? Didn't Baal get the name Zeus at one point?
JohnTheHutDweller 9 months ago
@JohnTheHutDweller you are right, the greek kronos was equated with the canaanite El also. :) thank you that you like this video
Malkibaal 9 months ago
@Malkibaal what are the greek counter parts to Baal, Dagon, mot, Molech and Asteraoth? Do the Canaanite gods have equivalent counter parts in the pre-islamic paganism? Alot, Manat and Al-Uzza. Is Al-Uzza the same as Asteroth?
JohnTheHutDweller 9 months ago
@JohnTheHutDweller Ba'l=Zeus, Moloc=Hephaistos, Dagon=Uranus,El(il,eluh)=Kronos,Aphrodite='ashtart, Ba'lat=dione,Mot=Thanatos or Apolllo, Eros=qatesh,Sidyq=Titanides,Heracles=Milcqart, Zeus=Adad,Adod,Hadad/ ,Hypsistus=El Elyun, :)
Malkibaal 9 months ago
@Malkibaal Thank you so much. I have been trying to find that out for years. You are very intellegent. How long have been speaking Canaanite? How did you learn it? Did you major in it at college?
JohnTheHutDweller 9 months ago
@JohnTheHutDweller l learned it by myself my knowledge of lebanese arabic and little bit classic arabic and ancient hebrew helped me :) thank you :) I started to learn canaanite when was 17, 2006 :) now I am 22, 20011
Malkibaal 8 months ago
Sounds like a cross between Hebrew and Arabic. But then, it was a Semitic language, it was supposed to sound like that, right?
MiracleKD18 11 months ago
@MiracleKD18 exactly you get my point, whihc the most people do not get and call it hebrew with arabic pronounciation, if the most westerners would heart a correct pronounced aramaic/hebrew or any semitic language correct pronounced they all would asssume it would be some kind of arabic/arabic dialect. :) But the sounds typical for arabic are also typcal for the rest of the semitic languages we cannot deny this. :)
Malkibaal 11 months ago
@MiracleKD18 the only difference is that arabic is one of the few semitic languages with a broad sound system, while the rest of the semitic language lost many sounds, but there are also some exceptions: ancient ugaritic, ancient amoritic, ancient akkadian, sabaen language.
Malkibaal 11 months ago
@Malkibaal
Aha.... Arabic and Phoenician sounds nice to me, but Hebrew sounds gross.
It's still hard to believe that the inventors of the Alphabet and the Carthagians (like Hannibal) spoke a language like this. It's just.... LOL
MiracleKD18 11 months ago
@MiracleKD18 thank you for your interest and questions, please check out my latest video , where I spoke better and more precise with exact consonant pronounciation, :) this is one of my first videos, of course I did not have so much experience but now I speak it much better please check it out :D
Malkibaal 11 months ago
Unfortunately islam and some other samawi religions destroyed the whole semitic culture and replaced with a cruel one, sorry im not against you but you know that right...
Metalicalypse 1 year ago 2
Great job, nice phonecian, I reaserched this in much detail and I know that Anat and Astrate and Ashtrothe was the same goddess. Middle Eastern people had many names for their gods and goddesses. Even today there are supposed to be 99 names of Allah
Onurius99 1 year ago
@Onurius99 thank you for this comment my friend and thank you that you like my videos and my work .
Malkibaal ! ^^
Malkibaal 1 year ago
I like it and most of all I'm glad I can find a video that sheds my ba'al in a positie light.
VladimirSegal 1 year ago
@VladimirSegal thank you :) you are welcome my friend.
Malkibaal 1 year ago
Good effort must have put a lot of time into this. I have been gaining an interest in the Phoenicians through a Lebanese lady running a cooking course here in UK! Keep up the good work!
strikeBHA 1 year ago
@strikeBHA thank you :) You will find a lot of surprising things about the phoenicians :)
Malkibaal 1 year ago
About 55 secs into the vid you say, "his complete name is iloh", is this where we get the ilohim from?
5fingerdiscountx 1 year ago
@5fingerdiscountx iluh, eluh is the old phoenician long form of the name god and means "god" in old arabic "ilah" , short form il, in ugaritic also "ilah", short form il
in late phoenician and punic we have just El /Il, ELim,/Ilim for the name for god.
Malkibaal 1 year ago
@5fingerdiscountx you are right, in hebrew ELOHIM means god but it is in plural form (something that points to the fact that we were all pagan before turning monotheistic). god in single form is EL.
shedmeraked 11 months ago
Next time without music but thanks you are genius!
MaBu888 1 year ago 3
Is this really Phoenician or Biblical Hebrew?
TheSexymonkey567 1 year ago
@TheSexymonkey567 this is the phoenician language, aka the language of the canaanites in the north of canaan(lebanon and akko, south west syria ) :)
Malkibaal 1 year ago
phoenician language came from lebanon.!!??
teto1708 1 year ago
@teto1708 that is right :) I am lebanese by myself I must know it :)
Malkibaal 1 year ago 2
So where did you learn Phoenician / Canaanite?
Nice work.
ManicEightBall 1 year ago
@ManicEightBall u can learn phoenician in universities in france lebanon and i think there is in the state aswell
nanushkas 1 year ago
Comment removed
VendPrekmurec 1 year ago 3
cool to hav you here I always love different believes, :D
what do you think of my work:D
Malkibaal 1 year ago
Great Vedio Dear
momia713 1 year ago 3
Interesting, but I thought Ashtaroth was the Hebrew version of the name, created by using the consonants of Ashtart with the vowels of the word "bosheth", "abomination/shameful thing" so that when "Ashtaroth" was read, it'd be read as "Abomination"
Thutm0sys 2 years ago
this is hebrew LOL
zeh ruk ivrit with an arab accent
VeritasTruthEmet 2 years ago
I am sorry this is not hebrew, I study the language of the canaanites, who worshipped Baal and Ashirat and Adun and El, I read many phoenician and punic inscriptions, I saw the words written in latin letters too, I am not an arab I am canaanite phoenician, I am lebanese, but I know hebree little bit too, this is not hebrew, modern hebrew is neither the oldest nor the latest stage of hebrew it is a mix of old and new, and many foreign words.
Malkibaal 2 years ago
In lebanese arabic there are a lot of phoenician words which survived like "gmad or9" meaning freeze on the earth, "meaning stop", Beside that I started to learn ugarit too,if you have questions for this language ask me. THank you
Malkibaal 2 years ago
@MalkiBaal Your videos are awesome but please, when you write the name of some ancient Deity, write it with a capital letter - show some respect for beliefs of our ancestors.
BabylonianSage 1 year ago 10
@BabylonianSage I am sorry for this I will do so, since even Baal is in my name :)
Please forgive me!
Malkibaal 1 year ago 2
@BabylonianSage heheheeh niceee
nanushkas 1 year ago
Comment removed
VendPrekmurec 1 year ago
@VendPrekmurec cool to hav you here I always love different believes, :D
what do you think of my work:D
Malkibaal 1 year ago
@VendPrekmurec @VendPrekmurec cool to hav you here I always love different believes, :D
what do you think of my work:D
Malkibaal 1 year ago
@VendPrekmurec cool to hav you here I always love different believes, :D
what do you think of my work:D
Malkibaal 1 year ago
@VendPrekmurec cool to hav you here I always love different believes, :D
what do you think of my work:D
Malkibaal 1 year ago
@Malkibaal u r good
keep on and ull find alot of things that will surprise u
the secret is in this small country :)
nanushkas 1 year ago
cool to have you here I always love different believes, what do you think of my work :D
Malkibaal 1 year ago
It's amazing ! I speak hebrew and I can understand a bit what u say without looking at the subtitles! It's like the same!!! That's such a pity that Lebanese do not talk this wonderful language anymore! This is another proof that Canaanites and Hebrews are not arabic!!!
dancehallking35000 2 years ago
shame that lebanon became arabized.. good thing that the language lingers and has not disappeared.
john2890 2 years ago
is there any similarity in the words used between arabic and phoenician language? i know that this is phoenician language, but there are many words that sound like arabic jibberish to me.
mjay22 2 years ago
news flash: canaanite-phoenician language is semitic, as arabic too and hebrew and babylonian and assyrian and aramaic.! :)
Malkibaal 2 years ago
Very very interessant ! I liked it, thank you very much ! But ancient phoenicians came from Yemen, from Socotra more exactly.
DaLynxfighta 2 years ago
blacks say phoenician was black people, yemeni say they were from yemen, and somalies ..... etc. WOW every one wants to be phoenician.
*Great job from Malkibaal as usual.
montezoma 2 years ago 8
Special thanks for this great job
faffunny 2 years ago 3
TO LEARN MORE ABOUT THE -- PHOENICIANS...
I'm inviting everyone to my (youtube channel) where I have listed many information on the genetic marker of the Phoenicians known as -- haplogroup J2 (M172) Y-DNA -- as well as their history and culture and so much more.
How to get to my (youtube channel) you just click on my YOUTUBE SCREEN-NAME and it should take you right to my channel to learn real Phoenician history.
_
PhoenicianGoddess 2 years ago
Thank you for posting this unusual work. A for the effort. But I just want to remind that the real Canaanite pronunciation is still unknown, and it's based mostly on the hebraic pronunciation, which I considered a bad reference, because the Hebrews took their language from Canaanites and not the reverse. Also I think that the real pronunciation should be closer to Arabic, especially for the sounds of the "vowels". Finally, just to remind that what we know about human sacrifices still not sure.
armenn88 2 years ago 4
Yea , I am lebanese, my family name is "Kanaan", like the phoenician called their homeland and they called theirself canaanites, the name phoenican was the greek version. I live in bavaria you get much accent here hehe! BUt feel to express and thanks for the comment!
Malkibaal 2 years ago
Very nice of you to speak in our old language. Despite your accent what you did is great. Are you of Lebanese descent? Thank you.
ahhc07 2 years ago 4
Wow, very cool.
Super
SehzadeTimurCan 2 years ago 3