Need to bring out brass more on the closing segment. Other than that, sounds pretty good. Rushing here and there. But thats typical for this song. I love it, and am playing it now.
This is good to be concert band but instead of playing level what 5 music, work on posture!! That killed me, that's probably why some of the notes were cracking and slurs were not as long. Good song though.
The flutes in the beginning need to stagger breath and connect the measures more. Ending a slurred phrase doesn't mean it's acceptable to insert a rest, even a short one. Bar line breathing is a no-no. A high school band should know that, I'm surprised the director didn't correct it.
we're playing this in band this year... I'm the timpanist and vibraphone player. Hmm... this is rather insightful. though I think that we sound better... >.> not meant to hurt anyone's feelings
this song is a minefield; no joke, and of all the high school renderings i've heard of it on youtube, this one escaped with the most limbs still attached to its body, stability is still questionable though...
In our last concert my band played this. I'm 1st chair alto sax and a certain part that had the whole section playing, our director had me play a solo.(ie 2:44)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Your band teacher is stupid. Bass clarinet cannot play low D. The only way you could get it is to take the mouthpiece out by a VERY PRECISE amount. You shouldn't have to though; bass claris simply cannot play low D fingering-wise.
it really suprises me that this is a level 400 piece to compete with. We are playing it this year and I was expecting much more complexity. It reminds me too much of the witch and the saint (although it is the same composer?)
It's a high school band. What do you expect? My band played this song and we did do a better job, but we're a 6A school. It was a relatively good performance compared to others on youtube! And what are you, asian? Im in banda, we aplay mucha beta
OK...Overall good performance! The ballad part should have been more emotional, and you should have bought out the diffrent sections, and various points in the song. But it was a good peice.
Need to bring out brass more on the closing segment. Other than that, sounds pretty good. Rushing here and there. But thats typical for this song. I love it, and am playing it now.
LBonney96 4 days ago
we are playing this in wind ensemble for competition, it consists of 7th, 8th,and 9th graders.
yaytennis 3 weeks ago
Slightly messy. But its good :)
hihibai 1 month ago
This is good to be concert band but instead of playing level what 5 music, work on posture!! That killed me, that's probably why some of the notes were cracking and slurs were not as long. Good song though.
QueenJada1 1 month ago
The flutes in the beginning need to stagger breath and connect the measures more. Ending a slurred phrase doesn't mean it's acceptable to insert a rest, even a short one. Bar line breathing is a no-no. A high school band should know that, I'm surprised the director didn't correct it.
Also, VI-BRA-TO PLEASE~!
But I mean, it was good, otherwise.
AfterFeelings 1 month ago
Go piccolo!! :D We're doing this song in honor band this year and hopefully I'll get the picc part
PiccoloPlayer232 1 month ago
Wow that first horn solo gave me goosebumps O_o
ThOmAsSs55 2 months ago
Does this ensemble even have any Bass Clarinets, because I can't hear them if they're there.
MsMurderousThoughts 3 months ago
Trumpet solo (2nd one) was a little rushed.
Super3794 8 months ago
im in 7th grade band and we are playing this song, the sax's in this are amazing tho
rlcourtney1 10 months ago
im in 7th grade band and we are playing this song
rlcourtney1 10 months ago
Comment removed
hyperboy95 1 year ago
Comment removed
pdog00 1 year ago
I like the snare part but it is difficult to play when you first try it.
condomface622 1 year ago
french horn messed up...hahhahaha
christinaaa36 1 year ago
that i did :] one of my slides fell out right before the solo started haha and it made me so upset that i completely botched it
VAP2009 1 year ago
@VAP2009 yea were playing this song now....and that happens to me like 2 times during the song.......lol
ThOmAsSs55 1 year ago
we're playing this in band this year... I'm the timpanist and vibraphone player. Hmm... this is rather insightful. though I think that we sound better... >.> not meant to hurt anyone's feelings
InnocentSinnerinHell 2 years ago
@InnocentSinnerinHell That's how I feel about my band this year! 7th graders do it better xD
lonestarbaby12 11 months ago
not bad guys!!! :D i love this song, played it in highschool :)
samsamsam123190 2 years ago
The elementary school is playing this band... and i am wondering , with yours, WHERE ARE THE ALTOS! i cann''t hearr them!
RainbowMarshmallow13 2 years ago
we are playing this, our band consists of combined 8th and 9th graders.
angelkitty2009 2 years ago
too bad my solo with nathan sucked the millionth degree that night
my face was soo gone by this point haha
VAP2009 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
your playing sucks, interpretation has a lack of imagination! YOU SUCK!!!
i6m6m6a 2 years ago
i just got done playing this song in band i play the baritone and this song is really easy to learn and kicks so much ass
bagon180 2 years ago
this song is a minefield; no joke, and of all the high school renderings i've heard of it on youtube, this one escaped with the most limbs still attached to its body, stability is still questionable though...
paradis31ost 2 years ago
In our last concert my band played this. I'm 1st chair alto sax and a certain part that had the whole section playing, our director had me play a solo.(ie 2:44)
Kratos9945 3 years ago
@Kratos9945
im first chair alto too but our whole section is pretty good so we all played it
HollywoodInsight 2 years ago
Hell of a bari sax player...
breakdancinwez 3 years ago 15
(i.e. 2:40)
breakdancinwez 3 years ago
i am playing this now in band and i love this song but i have trouble on measures 96-100&194-202but over all im good at playing this song
virgoChick094 3 years ago
Comment removed
JBgals 3 years ago
the bass clarinet part is so intense. does anyone know how to play low d, my band teacher said i need to play it at the beginning.
Mohrf24 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Your band teacher is stupid. Bass clarinet cannot play low D. The only way you could get it is to take the mouthpiece out by a VERY PRECISE amount. You shouldn't have to though; bass claris simply cannot play low D fingering-wise.
dimsimlord 3 years ago
the flutes were too loud when they first came in.. you could barely hear the brass when they came in four measures after..
trombonechickx 3 years ago
it really suprises me that this is a level 400 piece to compete with. We are playing it this year and I was expecting much more complexity. It reminds me too much of the witch and the saint (although it is the same composer?)
ilovelamp070 3 years ago
my director said it was the "twin brother of the Witch and the Saint"
ihcatiuchiha1989 3 years ago
wow, i played this as on 8th grader, in a 7th, 6th, and 8th grade symphonic band but none the less a middle school and we sounded a lot better.
DeezFuzzies 3 years ago
Comment removed
RricaXoX 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
a shit! i aplay in a band. we play this way better
36953695 3 years ago
It's a high school band. What do you expect? My band played this song and we did do a better job, but we're a 6A school. It was a relatively good performance compared to others on youtube! And what are you, asian? Im in banda, we aplay mucha beta
ProvenKilla 3 years ago 3
@ProvenKilla I'm in 7th grade and we are playing this xD
lonestarbaby12 11 months ago
@ProvenKilla Your weird!!! they're pretty good and where's yur proof tht yur any better than them!!!
RJPeaceQueen15 3 months ago
@ProvenKilla racist huh? So where you from?
hihibai 1 month ago
could use mroe 1st TBone throughout. but oveerall great performance. Monarch High School Brass Captain, Brian M.
KiLLeRsLaYeR69 3 years ago
OK...Overall good performance! The ballad part should have been more emotional, and you should have bought out the diffrent sections, and various points in the song. But it was a good peice.
nicetea18 3 years ago
i performed this at my high school, i love this song
prlife11 3 years ago