I don't think this version is better just because it is composed by Ivana herself. There are a lot of composers out there who can't sing well.
However, Ivana is definitely a better singer, technique-wise and voice-wise, than Fiona. The way Ivana interpreted this song is very touching and more fitting to the lyrics, whereas Fion's version is like a very generic CantoPop song.
王菀之比Fiona更加唱出首歌既慘
H3I96 4 months ago 7
很久沒聽這首歌 突然今天想起 然後專登找王苑之既板本聽 聽後發覺 原來這首歌真的作得很好
max0715 6 months ago 5
her voice is good but I like fiona's version so much more. x
cws555 7 months ago
好过原唱
kailongque 7 months ago
佢唱得唔似pop~
如果當初係佢唱可能首歌冇咁紅~
樂壇就係咁...
yantan0109 7 months ago
各有各好啦;
Fiona唱得甜d ; Ivana唱得薄d但系五弱
不過我都系鍾意Fiona唱多d `
0315Jan 9 months ago 3
佢本身個demo係國語版
我好開心佢用返比較major feel o既呢個旋律
o係o的細微o既地方會聽得出
整體黎聽就會不知不覺咁好聽左:)
加上之之把聲真心好好聽同埋呢首歌係佢作
真心好正呀之之i love you hehe:D
ilub903 11 months ago 4
I don't think this version is better just because it is composed by Ivana herself. There are a lot of composers out there who can't sing well.
However, Ivana is definitely a better singer, technique-wise and voice-wise, than Fiona. The way Ivana interpreted this song is very touching and more fitting to the lyrics, whereas Fion's version is like a very generic CantoPop song.
cheszeman 11 months ago
Ivana's version is better;]`
IAMcandiiiii 1 year ago 7
of course its better than Fiona. This song is composed by Ivana herself.
wingwing0404 2 years ago 30
i think so
elvis2383 2 years ago 7
better than Fiona= ='
DantemaycryX 2 years ago 75
@DantemaycryX 不同的風格,
advchung 7 months ago