My dear lord!!! u are amazing!!!! he it is really nice to see you playin drums, i´ve seen many guys like you playing those songs, but no one put the effort and showed love for drums as you do in every song... thanks for that and pleas don´t stop playing...
No man its so great work....i 98% perfect keep up the good work...i used to play dream theater covers but u better than me...keep going but work more on triplets but u're great man..i swear...good luck bro
hi man!! nice covers... i see all your dream theater's covers jeje are so nice...hey man a question ¿have you a band? it's to listen your own work, because yo are so nice drummer but i want to listen your work with a band or solitary, but your own songs! thanks man, keep working!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
well he gone widely out with the time... understandable anyways... what's really bad it's that he screws up in practically every fill of the song... unless that is just his interpretation
you have the best dream theater covers on you tube by far.Its cool you also dont copy everything portnoy has,paiste cybals are a way better choice than sabian.
dude u are awesome =) and awesome kit too =S..sounds perfect and ur cymbals mate..really sounds perfect.which cymbals u using?! especially the ride =)
Sweet! That is always my favorite one to play along to. It's almost like you watch his drum video and he gives all the secrets away, and learning it yourself isn't fun anymore. Nice work!
Lets see The Dance of Eternity next plz. You are good, but all this can be accomplished by watching Portnoy's video, the ease of learning the time signatures, etc. Good job none-the-less!
That's real nice I just discovered that song and it's a gold mine for drumming onto. perhaps its even harder to memorize it than playin it. Youre doing both great anyway!
your doing a great job man..im 16 years old and i drum dream theater songs too...its a great way to improve my drum technique...but im curious if you know who are meshuggah...you should try to drum there stuff...there drummer is insane..since i play there songs im a much better drummer...and if you can do a video of you playing meshuggah it would be great...continue your nice work!
you are amazing.. nice job anyway.. some of the comments in here are rude, or can I say jealousy? lol.. please look at your self before you post something bad and give bad rating.. because not so many people can do like he did.. cheers..
awesome man! =) like someone mentioned earlier, mike himself would be dazzled by this, doesn't get any closer to perfect than this, I'd say Almost even better than the original xD
jajajaja... it is joking man... you are such a GREAT DRUMMER... the drummer of my band play that song too... but.. i dont think he do it better.... i will upload a video soon so u can see iy.. keep up man.. you really have talent... you ARE a drummer
Amazing man, even though it's not perfect, but who is?lol. As far as rythm, it's very good, you see the effort made, timing, little off at parts, but it's very not that much noticeable for non-musicians:P Keep up the nice work mate
You fucking moron, youtube it's not a privilege place, you don't have to be good in what you do to post a video, it's for common people to show their asses to the rest of the world from their living rooms, so shut the fuck up and go practice yourself if you even play drums. By the way, great video!
This is for Crazydrumer: It's increidible how in every guitar/drums/whatever video in youtube, there's always some asshole criticizig just for the sake of it...and I bet my balls most of them are north americans.
some of you have no clue.. even though between 6:00-6:15 is kinda funky, the rest of it is high quality stuff. I'd agree that it's a different feel from mike, but then again this isn't recorded in the same environment either. fatal tragedy was an awesome choice and this greatly exceeded my expectations!
dude, you haters have no idea how hard that stuff is. He's just doing what he loves and sharing it with people. Just because it's not perfect doesn't mean it's not awesome. Better than 99% of any of the drummers I see on youtube showing their stuff. Way to go man!
Dude,do you know what "rythm" means?You can't play the riffs too!And you're out of the rythm too many times!Sorry,but that's the truth.You are doing good on the bass drum.
what for, if you know what is wrong, just practice it to correct, you I don't play drums, but believe that I know what music is about, not mentioning I know all Dt songs by heart. I'm playin' guitar though
Don't mind XxFadxX. He's probably like a guy (Tristenpaul) who put me down on one of my videos and told me he would show me how it's done...I'm still waiting for his video a full month later...
For someone who learns by ear and remember by heart all those parts, you rock!!
The only thing I could suggest, is maybe get a little more tight on the timekeeping...
MAN!! you are fucking awesome , keep on rockin!
GuitarSkash 10 months ago
this is why pearl is the drums to play
drummerchris22 1 year ago
My dear lord!!! u are amazing!!!! he it is really nice to see you playin drums, i´ve seen many guys like you playing those songs, but no one put the effort and showed love for drums as you do in every song... thanks for that and pleas don´t stop playing...
chelaco 1 year ago
good JOB BROW!
Metallboy 1 year ago
Yo ur mad good, but part of being a good drummer is knowing when to shut the fuck up... shut the fuck up in the first 30 seconds lol
symphox1 2 years ago
..but only a transition....
d1ez3 2 years ago
haha loving the quote there
SystematicChaos08 2 years ago
Amazing!
jesuspisto 2 years ago
You're just... amazing... Deep respect for this man... keep on' playing...
Yebanoshi 2 years ago
5:12
Facunddo 2 years ago
my fave song from album
LeetGuitar 2 years ago 5
Fucking good! And in 1 scene!!! But... be more enthusiastic. show fun.
TDesaster 3 years ago
though i usually dont like that song that much
you made me actually loving that song :D
GREAT!!!
Marc28031984 3 years ago
awesome as always
and here in this video you could hear the doublebass much better
Marc28031984 3 years ago
¿?¿
julio11090 3 years ago
the last minute: amazing
ngenechen 3 years ago 2
thats a cute mistake at 3:55
CHABIEPORTNOY 3 years ago
3:55 haha ^^
d4p1p0 3 years ago
hmm your base drum sux but the rest is pretty good, good job man!
keep on drumming
martinmetall 3 years ago
ya not good. timing was off and cymbals were not right along with double bass.:(
ashrox0793 3 years ago
awesome job! you like Mike Portnoy! :)
CheckinLee 3 years ago
Great job bro, sick drumming
BigLittleMidget 3 years ago 2
shrink and grow ! :)
japeto1 3 years ago 2
No man its so great work....i 98% perfect keep up the good work...i used to play dream theater covers but u better than me...keep going but work more on triplets but u're great man..i swear...good luck bro
18891889 3 years ago
Not perfect.(Mainly about speeds)
But 50% good.
akashijustin 3 years ago
the time change at 1:57 is so epic!
and i bet its hard 2 play!
awesome job :)
peachy901 3 years ago
yeah men you are awesome fantastic drummer congratulations
petrucciadapta 3 years ago
hi man!! nice covers... i see all your dream theater's covers jeje are so nice...hey man a question ¿have you a band? it's to listen your own work, because yo are so nice drummer but i want to listen your work with a band or solitary, but your own songs! thanks man, keep working!
aaaaaaa2002 3 years ago
You call that messing up? Sounds good to me.
blacky156 4 years ago 3
not "messing up" but he could definitely tighten up the screws a bit. Overall not bad though
skater15153 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well he gone widely out with the time... understandable anyways... what's really bad it's that he screws up in practically every fill of the song... unless that is just his interpretation
MikePortnoyz 3 years ago
its always the best parts you mess up on
3:47 has to be tighter man
i think you should do this one again
tdrummer123 4 years ago
you have the best dream theater covers on you tube by far.Its cool you also dont copy everything portnoy has,paiste cybals are a way better choice than sabian.
engiejoe 4 years ago
just not portnoy...=\ but still very nice!
Gudes69 4 years ago
There is no substitute.
weefek 4 years ago
dude u are awesome =) and awesome kit too =S..sounds perfect and ur cymbals mate..really sounds perfect.which cymbals u using?! especially the ride =)
441greenleaf 4 years ago
Thank you! My cymbals are listed on my channel page.
gspot27 4 years ago
soo cool
amundead 4 years ago
does it sound dis much amazin widout an amplifier system ????!!
Ahmedmagdi 4 years ago
ahaha love the drum solo intro thingy xD
Nighthawk919 4 years ago
excellent !
very nice :-)
dt & mike r rockin' !
mikespike8 4 years ago
that was really pro dude, you producin???
basslova 4 years ago
maestro la tocas igualita felicitaciones
49871151005 4 years ago
im more of a guitar person but that seemed qutie good, are you in a band? 'cos you should be, i dunno how you can stay sane with playing like that!
jargen07 4 years ago
i liked it, 5 stars =D
gori914 4 years ago
good dude
Funebresto 4 years ago
It's OK, but you could have been a lot tighter at some points.
Arkii123 4 years ago
not bad........but I've seen better
Cross6666 4 years ago 2
perfect.
bodybreak01 4 years ago
you rock man........keep up the good work
Budsoda 4 years ago
Nice performance,have you seen tony royster jr?
go and check it out
plastickosoul 4 years ago
he is crap compared with dave weck antonio sanchez and dennis chambers.. for mentioning a few...
luismtz87 4 years ago
Great :)
Teknibaal 4 years ago
that was effin SICK bro, awesome work
illinifan05 4 years ago
nicely played! ...now go check out my version ;)
metalhansen 4 years ago
Sweet! That is always my favorite one to play along to. It's almost like you watch his drum video and he gives all the secrets away, and learning it yourself isn't fun anymore. Nice work!
NYspeedDrummer 4 years ago
Lets see The Dance of Eternity next plz. You are good, but all this can be accomplished by watching Portnoy's video, the ease of learning the time signatures, etc. Good job none-the-less!
NYspeedDrummer 4 years ago
Check out my channel page. I did The Dance of Eternity almost a year ago.
Thanks for watching.
gspot27 4 years ago
Man, are you the God?!
glebuccio 4 years ago
dude your cymbals sound great! what are they?
restedante 4 years ago
Check out my channel page for my cymbal setup.
Thanks for watching.
gspot27 4 years ago
really tight dude, awesome job, love your kit
LOGdrummer500 4 years ago
damn you are almost the new mike portnoy!! good work
NelisTheGreat 4 years ago
That's real nice I just discovered that song and it's a gold mine for drumming onto. perhaps its even harder to memorize it than playin it. Youre doing both great anyway!
daifuku74 4 years ago
your doing a great job man..im 16 years old and i drum dream theater songs too...its a great way to improve my drum technique...but im curious if you know who are meshuggah...you should try to drum there stuff...there drummer is insane..since i play there songs im a much better drummer...and if you can do a video of you playing meshuggah it would be great...continue your nice work!
deththeater 4 years ago
AWESOME!!!!
nexusdejavu 4 years ago
Good job man. I admire your entire work. Keep going!
WolfFenrir 4 years ago
that was tight. when did u do this vid, its a different angle (and kit?) to ur other videos. still, ur fast becoming my hero lol.
JohnnyF18 4 years ago
Back in July '06. It is the same kit just set up a little differently.
Thanks man! I am seriously considering doing this one and Overture 1928/Strange Deja Vu over again from the opposite angle.
gspot27 4 years ago
how long have you been drumming gspot27?
mOrtpengu1n 4 years ago
25+ years
gspot27 4 years ago
you play very well.
coheed09cambria 4 years ago
you are amazing.. nice job anyway.. some of the comments in here are rude, or can I say jealousy? lol.. please look at your self before you post something bad and give bad rating.. because not so many people can do like he did.. cheers..
flekzout 4 years ago
A few slip-ups here and there, but overall it was an excellent performance.
SweetJesusItsJack 4 years ago
Nice job, you didn't overdo it like all the other amateurs! ;)
omglolffs 4 years ago
wow..that was pretty awesome
mOrtpengu1n 4 years ago
good work dude! at last i find a descent amateur drummer
restedante 4 years ago
dont try to be like mike portnoy. create your own style. and btw you wont get as good as him in your whole life
b1tchplzthxcu 4 years ago
I am not trying to be MP. I just happen to love his playing and DT's music.
gspot27 4 years ago
has this guy ever looked at how many guys play dream theater on drums?
there's a ton of people who do,
a lot of the stuff i play is dream theater, it's because it's more challenging and sounds better than the majority of metal music
another perfect video gspot,
i used to always do the same "psych" too, lol
lgeoghegan 4 years ago
the death is not the end - but only the beginning
XxCarCrashHeartsxX 4 years ago
wow i noticed i said that wrong. i'm such an idiot
XxCarCrashHeartsxX 4 years ago
holy crap that was amazing
XxCarCrashHeartsxX 4 years ago
Thank you!
gspot27 4 years ago
your welcome. it's more like your welcome master drummer man. :] haha. if that made any sense
XxCarCrashHeartsxX 4 years ago
MY!!! nice timing sometimes it get a bit slow but is very impresive
ANlevant 4 years ago
WOW MAN !! ur awsome....shit i'm impressed !
Too bad i cant cover any mike portnoy's tracks cause i have no stax.....
kerdani28 4 years ago
awesome man! =) like someone mentioned earlier, mike himself would be dazzled by this, doesn't get any closer to perfect than this, I'd say Almost even better than the original xD
Magus2002 4 years ago
is that you mike ???? you changed alot
adil36 4 years ago
LOL..nope, it's just me.
gspot27 4 years ago
that's tight drumming dude. nice tight dbl bass. i'm impressed with you cover. drum on my fren! =)
jarthe 4 years ago
damn
jungmans90 4 years ago
very cool
ccole1981 4 years ago
nicely done. My bro can play dream theater stuff on drums also. Too bad I cant play the guitar part to acompany him :(
anyway, good job, sounded great.
SSMarrow 4 years ago
awesome!! thats a challenge... :D
Stereotypus 4 years ago
VERY VERY NICE!!!!
alangranadeiro 5 years ago
Very nice! Mike himself I believe would be proud of that performance!
vtxmann 5 years ago
Oh! man, you are the best drummer that I see in You Tube. I play drums too and I can assure that you are THE BEST!.
Post more videos please.
alexdrummerspain 5 years ago
not bad... not perfect, but not too bad..
KillerKeyboards 5 years ago
Amazing...first person I've watched drumming this song and im impressed. Could never do that haha. Keep it up!
grahammoorhead 5 years ago
Thank you!
gspot27 5 years ago
This is not solid.
Siamon19281928 5 years ago
jajajaja... it is joking man... you are such a GREAT DRUMMER... the drummer of my band play that song too... but.. i dont think he do it better.... i will upload a video soon so u can see iy.. keep up man.. you really have talent... you ARE a drummer
SpeedGuitar19 5 years ago
Nice.... but... the drummer of my band play it better and he is just 15 xD
SpeedGuitar19 5 years ago
Cool! I'd like to see a video!
gspot27 5 years ago
Amazing man, even though it's not perfect, but who is?lol. As far as rythm, it's very good, you see the effort made, timing, little off at parts, but it's very not that much noticeable for non-musicians:P Keep up the nice work mate
DarkEnchantress 5 years ago
Thank you very much!
gspot27 5 years ago
my favorite dream theater song..and still is
fomb19 5 years ago
Very nicely done. Have you ever tried Dance of Eternity?
JerkStoleMyName 5 years ago
Looks like you found it.
gspot27 5 years ago
You fucking moron, youtube it's not a privilege place, you don't have to be good in what you do to post a video, it's for common people to show their asses to the rest of the world from their living rooms, so shut the fuck up and go practice yourself if you even play drums. By the way, great video!
Godines83 5 years ago
Thanks, bro!
gspot27 5 years ago
This is for Crazydrumer: It's increidible how in every guitar/drums/whatever video in youtube, there's always some asshole criticizig just for the sake of it...and I bet my balls most of them are north americans.
Godines83 5 years ago
some of you have no clue.. even though between 6:00-6:15 is kinda funky, the rest of it is high quality stuff. I'd agree that it's a different feel from mike, but then again this isn't recorded in the same environment either. fatal tragedy was an awesome choice and this greatly exceeded my expectations!
liminaldust 5 years ago
Thank you!
gspot27 5 years ago
please stop saying hes not playing it right, he can't his kit is too small and he has no double bass.
hellboyjc 5 years ago
Best part of Scenes from a Memory.
GJ!
doisneau 5 years ago
Thank you!
gspot27 5 years ago
dude, you haters have no idea how hard that stuff is. He's just doing what he loves and sharing it with people. Just because it's not perfect doesn't mean it's not awesome. Better than 99% of any of the drummers I see on youtube showing their stuff. Way to go man!
tizzdizz 5 years ago
Thanks for getting my back on this. It's better coming from someone other than me!
gspot27 5 years ago
power toms fucking rule, i hate those shallow tom kits, they suck.
thispagesux 5 years ago
Dude,do you know what "rythm" means?You can't play the riffs too!And you're out of the rythm too many times!Sorry,but that's the truth.You are doing good on the bass drum.
crazzzy93drummer 5 years ago
if only you had the emotion that mike has..but ur good..
onuraltunsaray 5 years ago
great man!!
dalkavuk2 5 years ago
Far from Mike's feel...But this still a fucking great effort!! Top notch mate!!
Andinator 5 years ago
out of rythm many times too many times..u must work
darknessjack 5 years ago
you are grate!
keep it! =]
guyglick 5 years ago
what for, if you know what is wrong, just practice it to correct, you I don't play drums, but believe that I know what music is about, not mentioning I know all Dt songs by heart. I'm playin' guitar though
fixxx3r 5 years ago
1 thing to point out, too many times you're out of rythm
fixxx3r 5 years ago
Let's see your perfect video performance. I bet you don't have one. I don't. I even poke fun at myself sometimes. Tell me something I don't know.
gspot27 5 years ago
far from perfection
fixxx3r 5 years ago
Thanks for your comment. Could you be more specific? I like constructive criticism.
gspot27 5 years ago
oh, sorry i didn't know that. i'll check next time. i'm surprised you knew what i was talking about.
dojo123 5 years ago
when you were hitting the mini chinas, he only hits one
dojo123 5 years ago
That wasn't a mess up, that was intentional. I added a little of myself in there. I have had some very positive comments on what you are refering to.
Thanks for watching.
gspot27 5 years ago
you messed up on the shrink and grow part of the song
dojo123 5 years ago
really? which part exactly?
gspot27 5 years ago
great man reaaaally great. And some parts were like improvised right?
it wasn't like PERFECT PERFECT , but man! really CLOSE xD
awesome I say!
maxulyses 5 years ago
drums were a lil overpowering agenst the song, but what i could hear sounded straight on, good job and keep it up
deadaim713 5 years ago
nice
siilentt 5 years ago
very very good...question for you..is it possible to have original music without the drum part on it...thanks! merci beaucoup
biggm89 5 years ago
Thank you! No it is not possible. I am just playing over Mikes drums.
gspot27 5 years ago
great
monaso 5 years ago
waton culiao malo.
0MachucA0 5 years ago
FANTASTIC DUDE! how long did you take to learn all those Dream Theater songs?
apokolips 5 years ago
very nice dood... the final part was sick! u played it perfectly =)
have u ever tried playing some Angra stuff? i love that band and aquiles priester is the shit!
keep up the good work !
RanulfoKnox 5 years ago
dude...this was totally perfect....such a pleasure to see this...excellent...
failureobject 5 years ago
What's with all them boxes? I thought you moved like over a year ago? :-D
darylld911 5 years ago
Just stuff that's in boxes that we haven't done anything with!!
gspot27 5 years ago
"What a phenomenon"... :D
Very nice work there on the so called "Shrink & Grow" section, dude!
ddteagleeye 5 years ago
Come on!!!!!! This is PERFECT*!!!!!!!!!!!!
mcbabe526 5 years ago
Reminds me of Bobby Jarzombeks kit set-up, hahaha. Nice job.
Septicaemia 5 years ago
man
iv been lernin theis song for like 3 weeks and its fuckin hard work lol
u make it look easy!
your amazin
olliegraham 5 years ago
woooooow...very nice dude
yurileo 5 years ago
Dude, that is one insanely nice drum rack!
And of course - your drumming, is nothing short of spot-on and spectacular. Good job..
FremontMetalHead 5 years ago
Thanks dude!
gspot27 5 years ago
so many drums...and clean...yummmy :)
cconnors98 5 years ago
Very nice!
vberga 5 years ago
ass kicking
very nice
congrats!!
ducorrea 5 years ago
what kind of snare head is that? sounds just like mike's.
shinedowner1 5 years ago
It is a PowerStroke 3 coated w/sound control dot w/Remo Slam pad. I added the slam pad that came with my new kick drum head recently.
gspot27 5 years ago
Thanks everyone!
gspot27 5 years ago
Your so awsome defintly one of my drum heros haha and someone I can say hey I wanna be like him because hes the shiz!
MetalHeadXi158 5 years ago
Don't mind XxFadxX. He's probably like a guy (Tristenpaul) who put me down on one of my videos and told me he would show me how it's done...I'm still waiting for his video a full month later...
For someone who learns by ear and remember by heart all those parts, you rock!!
The only thing I could suggest, is maybe get a little more tight on the timekeeping...
thealien666 5 years ago
Good drummer, man...
Thirdgen83 5 years ago
sounds good....but can i ask what your middle splash is (between your 2 rack toms)
benji2112 5 years ago
Thanks! It is a Sabian AA 10" China Splash.
gspot27 5 years ago
cool....sounds oddly cleane and yet trashy i like it....oh btw i know you are on the mp forum (me too...i am benji aka the octobarn boy)
benji2112 5 years ago
an overall god job, but somtimes you were a little bit sloppy and missed some drum parts
but good job!
Zildjian232 5 years ago
killing song you know, by the way the bass drum sounds good.
Knightmetal 5 years ago
yeap.. uploading my vid it very very soon... and hey.. nice drums.. and DT bros man.. its hard to find ppl who plays DT... \m/
XxFadxX 5 years ago
Hey dude, nice watching your video that you uploaded.
xiong937 5 years ago
Nothing good.i can play what you play dude.. Anyway.. keep it up.. cheers...
XxFadxX 5 years ago
Thanks for commenting. I would like to see your video then, yes?
Keep on jammin'!
gspot27 5 years ago
wow man! that was fucking AWESOME! congrats (y)
nitaportnoy 5 years ago
leave the solo stuff for the end, not the beginning
GrimReaper69 5 years ago
I'm not really soloing, just kinf of messing around during the intro to FT. I was going to cut that part out but decided to keep it for some reason.
Thanks!
gspot27 5 years ago