Beethoven 'Tempest' Sonata - 3 - Natasha Pikoul

[kaizersolza]

the tempo is too fast.........

[kaizersolza]

if you really want to listen to beethoven tempest 3rd movement........listen to wilhelm kempff......

[aburoza]

too fast, but still great!

[gabdcceddlappy]

In my opinion she played this movement better then Kempff as it was played much quicker than Kempff played it which gave it that windy feeling. Like a tempest . Very Expressive. Well done!

[TheAshKane]

i love this tempo and your playing =!! OMG

[MattTheOak]

Seems way too fast to me, but then I've only watched wilhelm kempffs performance before this

[Thaladredxym]

OMG, can't believe why there would be 32 deaf!

[richtomes]

@Thaladredxym sad to say about half of those thumbs down belong to our stalker..

[Thaladredxym]

@richtomes any way, thanks for the piece.

[signinname41]

i'd sell that piano for crack.

[quinto34]

Wonderful! Love the left hand!

[euphorbium88]

awesome!

[OtakudiMD80]

30 people are deaf.

Well done.

[xPorcelainLolitax]

I've seen quite a few versions on YouTube and yours is the one that impressed me.

You're fantastic! :)

How long have you been playing ?

[mivalguriashi]

very good playing, but the start is a few fast

[watanak]

Very strange and wonderful!

[Timmytimtimtm]

incredibl

[divadokas2008]

Your interpretation of this sonata is captivating - the best I´ve seen on youtube. Thank you for posting this!!

[bach9079]

You play very clear,I like it.

[andyemail]

the start is too fast...

[DarthRC51rider]

Okay I take back what I said after listening to this Sonata various versions all night long practically. For my taste this is one of the best ones I found.

[idealhomesrealestate]

Yes, it starts off really fast and then after about 30 seconds or so settles to a slower pace. Slower than most other pianists play it, but personally I prefer it played at this slightly slower pace, it allows the listener to pick up each note more clearly. I myself would play it at this speed (when/if I get around to learning it!). Overall I thought it was a really nice performance - good job.

[scottg4life]

great! please check out my tempest and my other piano videos! please comment and rate. thanks!

[deathblade909]

very nice.

[keatsaenea]

I like very much your performance! Well done! Just, baybe sometimes you modified the time... but i think that the piece works well anyway ;)

[DanielRicardoCA]

It's curious how she slowers the time throughout the work

[whateverpianogenius]

LOL I have a little cousin named Natasha but she's just learning how to play piano!

[hadrian3689]

BOTH her and Kempff did a wonderful job

[nicktcher74]

Wilhelm Kempff is playing much better this thing

[KingHarkinian]

Well Kempff plays better than all others in my opinion, however that doesn't mean she didn't do a great job, i'm hoping to play this one day.. might wanna learn to read notes.. xD

[DanielRicardoCA]

I fully agree.

[deerodchan]

@KingHarkinian

Come on kempffs a pro pianist. Kempff should play this piece better for anyone else becuase he is known to give the BEST BEETHOVEN interpretation.

[KingHarkinian]

@deerodchan I know, that's why i said she also did very good, and alot better than me for sure xD

[jirachi91]

you play it beautifully! THX

[amandasklim]

tq for teaching me how to use demper better through this vedeo.

[CyberAngel484]

amazing

[jjuan54]

amazing sonata, one of my favorite beethoven's piece, have you seen barenboims interpretation?, you can make it even better if you work out the dinamic and expression a little more,...congratulations !!

[moonsician]

Why are all coments with red negative rates?

[richtomes]

We have a stalker

[undercovermatriaal]

for the best and perfect watch kempff

[mozartiikodesu]

Your music is gushing out like fountain.

It is that God (Muse)wished.

Congratulations Natasha.

[yogevcohen]

you have the gift of music. I envy that.

perfect performance. better than most videos out there, great names included.

[iorwiss]

very well played....great job...

[dokuzok]

perfect!!! thanks

[richtomes]

dokuzok said... perfect!!! thanks

[xVeroniqueX]

wonderful.

[richtomes]

xVeroniqueX said... wonderful.

[Dimipoke1]

I love the very beginning of this song!! It's so beautiful! I want to learn it!

[richtomes]

Dimipoke1 said...I love the very beginning of this song!! It's so beautiful! I want to learn it!

[netmendo]

Genial. Muito mais um registo de beethoven do que interpretações faraónicas que abusam do pedal

[richtomes]

netmendo said... Genial. Muito mais um registo de beethoven do que interpretações faraónicas que abusam do pedal

[ibancito1]

Thank you for such a beautiful rendition Natasha!

[richtomes]

ibancito said... Thank you for such a beautiful rendition Natasha!

[marieantoinette2008]

e' semplicemente meravigliosa

[richtomes]

marieantoinette2008 said... e' semplicemente meravigliosa

[furiasha]

I lurv this song and songs without words are usually lurvley. Long lurv the SONG

[richtomes]

I lurv the second movement

[qwertyasdyaln]

Your truely amazing most people don't play fast enogh or way to fast This is the perfect tempest. welldone

[richtomes]

qwertyasdyaln said... Your truely amazing most people don't play fast enogh or way to fast This is the perfect tempest. welldone

[chiodosfreak]

Great work! I am currently working on this song now, and I wanted to see how other people tackled certain sections of the song... I really liked your version because you have really really good technique...

eventually hope to post my own video of the song :D

beautiful

[usukekill]

Beautiful song!

:)

[costaspro]

great recording...very touching approach of the piece...

[oqla2000]

great................

[petie32]

You also missed the syncopation at 1:15 or so; see Kempf, van Gennip, Richter.

[petie32]

Outstanding, precise. Like if Bach played Beethoven. Please see van Gennip for what might be a bit over emotional version equally good technically. Somewhere in between.

Really excellent and my compliments. Also a good studio for solo piano.

[afiadan]

hey

you cut a big part of this beautiful piece

[N3ji415]

Just Beautiful

[gantzmetallica]

fantastic ...

[BeammeupSpotty]

Very Nice Job. I just watched Kempff which is sublime and I complained that he didn't seem engaged with the keyboard. It's nice to see you so connected with the instrument. The sound, clarity and performance is excellent.

[jorgenhorstink]

One should be connected to the music. Staring at the keys doens't mean one plays well. This is a great recording though.

[LoveleyVideos]

more Rubato !

[Danster185]

Wow! You play so smooth and nice.

One of the best versions I ever heard :D

[frankozb]

THE best I have ever heard!

[lstp0136]

very nicely played!

[anyothernickistaken]

didnt feel anything. no excitement. remember this is called "tempest". no dynamics, it didnt flow.

though i must say everything was very accurate, perfect in that matter.

[Admster]

Terrific. The people have voted and compare this to G. Gould. 'Go and wipe your shoulders off.' But hit the accent notes harder and hold while playing a tad faster.

[PowerForGood]

Excellent! I would remove some of the stacato in certain areas and smooth it out. I would also speed it up a bit more... but that is all personal taste and interpretation. Probably because I like Glen Gould's playing of this movement. Hey anway, you are obviously very talented and I enjoy listenning to your playing. Keep up the good work.

[genini555]

too fast but very good

[websterlips]

o.m.g brilliant, i could listen to you play the piano all day. keep it up.

[chanmix51]

thank you

[00ayumi]

Great!

[turxxx]

Well played!

[Nineteen80Nine]

Not as good as Gould but still brilliant

[mozartiikodesu]

Hi Natasha!

I always respect you!!

Your play takes me to his great music world.

You have expressed this music classically without taking dynamics effect.

[takacx]

excellent

[Rodrigorror]

Very, very good....

Is a nice guy....

I love the Tempst...

Excelent

[ldyxlo]

love this interpretation

[taghazog]

ok, in fact, that's especially at the beginning, this is better after!

apart from using a bit more the pedal at some parts.

[taghazog]

good performance and good skills!

But too fast, like Fazil, I prefer the Kempff's interpretation, much touching, and less as a dance.

[natlissits]

Just listenned to your interpretation of this movement, hasti2006. Now I understand what your comment is about :-)

[kstaylor98682]

very, very nice!! I agree with some people that it could use a bit of variation when it comes to dynamics and lacks a little in the emotion, but only slightly. Play it with your eyes closed and feel the piece, getting lost in it and letting it control your movements somewhat like a leaf being moved about in an ocean.

[romymistique]

how amazing, I should try that too!

[suhaATTA]

how does she do that!! great i wish if i could play better like her

[ColinMeloy91]

Absolutely amazing.

[markcornwell]

Musical and involving.

Bravo!

[acasale]

Well done...

To criticize this interpretation would be enigmatic to the work of Beethoven himself.

Superb.

[romymistique]

I agree! I think it's very impressing that even though she uses pedal, it sounds so neat and excellent, the dynamics are good, I reckon

[chanmix51]

A bit fast at beginning, but once you re in it that's beautifull...

bravo !

[gos77]

Une très belle interprétation, bravo..

[rbrice1981]

this is wonderful - a talent I wish I could have had. very nice work.

[soldier2119]

Wahou ! I hope someday I'll be able to play like her ! Since when does she play piano (it is to know how many years he remains me before playing this Sonata ^^) ?

PS: Sorry for my bad English... ^^

[NOphoff]

Great! I would have liked some more pedal though. :)

[spacetimewarp]

This was inspiring. Just what we need in these troubled times. Beethoven no doubt had been inspired in his troubled times also. Thanks for playing this lovely music so well and making it available.

[joseramonv]

Good pianist and better piano..lol

[jonwithjen]

Good Job!

[churrte]

A great performance, only I can make a remark. I think that the only weak point of that interpretation is the dynamics. I think that the cause of the lack of the expression I prefer with Beethoven sonatas.

Of course, it's my opinion and I'm only an amateur pianist.

I think there's no problem with tempo, and Natasha can play it fluently and it's an acceptable tempo.

[milliexmarie]

I love this.

[Aogv96]

Excellent performance

[richtomes]

Natasha says thanks - yours are pretty good too, but you don't look 19, as it says on your channel.

[Aogv96]

Thanks,

I didn´t created this account

[kumiko808]

I love the external extension Beethoven randomly added at the end. We're led to believe the work will come to an end with the standard subdominant-dominant-tonic circle progression, but then there's a play on everything!

And I love this pianist's interpretation and execution.

[falves15]

Simplesmente perfeito!!!

Meus parabens!!

grande abraco, voce tem muito talento!

[wongtungching]

Excellent Performance!! Bravo!!

[1iFbYLand2ifBYc4KIDS]

great touch, dynamics and BravA! thanks and peace from japan. ~eLi G., piaNOwarist.

[Rampalamp1]

incredible

[eMyZeTa]

di interpretazioni della "tempesta" ne ho sentite parecchie, da parte di dilettanti e di grandi, e posso dire che, a parte quella insuperabile di glenn gould, questa per me sia la migliore che abbia incontrato. bravissima. tecnica ed espressione sono ben miscelate e soprattutto finalizzate..molto spesso si trova in giro tecnicismo sterile o, al contrario, interpretazioni apparentemente volitive ma a ben vedere fuori luogo.

[stedama]

Ma sei proprio sicuro di quello che scrivi?

[pianofolle]

Le ultime 9 parole non hanno nessun senso. che vuoi farci 'stedama', è talmente generico che il fatto che sia o no sicuro non ha nessuna importanza.

[Beethoven1216]

sono d'accordo con te !!

[Phantapia]

allora prova a sentire un attimo fazil say, kempff, ashkenazy...giusto tre tra i mille.a me, vabbè,viene l'ansia perchè non riesco a capire dove va...e mi sembra un pochino pesante...sarà una mia opinione personale, ok, ma quello che scrivi tu mi sembra inaccettabile. e giusto questi pianisti che ti hio citato sono pieni di tecnicismo sterile o interpretazioni fuori luogo? se lo dici tu..

[Phantapia]

ho sbagliato, questa doveva essere una risposta a EmyZeTa..pardon

[eMyZeTa]

di quelli che nomini tu ho già sentito kempff e ashkenazy..il primo mi piace molto (ashkenazy lo preferisco con ravel) però io non concepisco questo 3o tempo come lo esegue kempff...fermo restando che lui è un interprete di grande profondità, questa pianista si avvicina di più all'idea che ho IO del 3o movimento..ma ribadisco la soggettività dell'opinione

[chanmix51]

bravo !

[lucassalazar]

Well done. What passion!!!

[pianochick1]

Absolutely beautifully played!

[spabunker21]

Complimenti ma il piano sembra un po' scordato...

[PalfraDK]

seems awfully fast compared to Kempff.

[pianofolle]

so what?

[MrJones1337]

congratulations !

that was amazing !

[mozartiikodesu]

Foi impressionado por este desempenho.

É maravilhoso. spasibo!

[luy1983]

great

[zemoraes000]

Parabéns! Muito bom!

[switz37]

U have played well!..u brought out e dynamics n it sounds great! hm..im currently workin on this piece n mayb u can give some comments too..that is when i finally upload it..haha:) cheers!

[mohamedtexas]

wow

[EPENAEED]

Congratulations, excellent performance, great hands, soft touch and full of Beethoven's power at the same time!!! 5/5 as also the video is very good and good quality, I enjoy it a lot!!!