just wanted to join all the thankyou's. It's been a pleasure to watch all these gems from R.E.M. especially from the monster tour, which hold a special place in my heart. Hope to see you again in the future when you'll have more time.
Thanks Heidi for this video and all of your wonderful videos. Your channel's fantastic and I hope that someday you'll again start uploading videos. You've brought joy and happiness to more people than you'll ever know.
I have this bootleg concert CD. Great to see the video. Written so many years ago and yet its still a beautiful song. Amazing how REM are able to extract such emotion with their music. Thank you for uploading this video and all the other amazing videos you have shared with REM fans all over the world. We GREATLY appreciate it.
It's crazy to think there was a time when Stipe was shy and uncomfortable "up front"! seems pretty comfortable at the Mic here! lol
1surfrider4life 2 weeks ago
Best performance of best song ever
rem80s 1 month ago
Gorgeous.
fireflyfan1 1 month ago
Wow...what a performance. Love the song, but the performance takes it to another level
bernlin2000 1 month ago 2
Whats not to love? What a wonderful, wistful and evocative song.
CaptainKubla 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
CaptainKubla 1 year ago
best song on murmur in my opinion
gruhaf 1 year ago 2
God I love this song! This brings back memories. I've really missed out on nothing.
aberdown 1 year ago
he is so softly, even his stomach is shaved...beautiful
max47277 2 years ago
One of the most beautiful I have ever heard.
herbfletcher 2 years ago
hard to believe a drummer wrote this song
nick1137 2 years ago
I love it when Stipe and Mills bicker
redpaul79 2 years ago
told you this before, but Heidi i think I love you
johnnymarrplayguitar 2 years ago
thank you for kind comment :)))))
heidigretel 2 years ago
just wanted to join all the thankyou's. It's been a pleasure to watch all these gems from R.E.M. especially from the monster tour, which hold a special place in my heart. Hope to see you again in the future when you'll have more time.
elbartostrikes 2 years ago 5
thank you for kind words. you are very welcome :)))))
heidigretel 2 years ago
R.E.M. are the best!! Very nice video. Are you going on holidays? I`ll miss your videos. Don`t stop upload.
CrazyCat9898 2 years ago 7
thank you CrazyCat. I stop upload because I have not any free time. In future I again may upload. But for time being I must stop uploading videos :)
heidigretel 2 years ago
" I'm talking to a friend "...." Oh, ok "
funkydafunker 2 years ago
Berry was an awesome songwriter
Darknightdriver 2 years ago 4
yes I agree :)
heidigretel 2 years ago
Thank you so much Heidigretel for all your videos - a perfect one to end on.
Stipegroupie 2 years ago 12
you are very welcome Stipegroupie :)
heidigretel 2 years ago
"a perfect circle of acquaintances and friends".
If this is your last video for now, then you chose a great song on which to stop(although I hope you'll start uploading videos again soon). :~)
TeethoftheHydra 2 years ago 11
thank you Teeth :)
heidigretel 2 years ago
this is probably the best version of Perfect Circle I've heard.
HagerTX 2 years ago 10
word
caybro 2 years ago
yes I agree :)
heidigretel 2 years ago
thank you for upload this...the best band in the world.....
francopersicurezza84 2 years ago 9
you are very welcome :)
heidigretel 2 years ago
Thanks Heidi for this video and all of your wonderful videos. Your channel's fantastic and I hope that someday you'll again start uploading videos. You've brought joy and happiness to more people than you'll ever know.
MsChildofvenus 2 years ago 12
thank you for kind words :)
heidigretel 2 years ago
I have this bootleg concert CD. Great to see the video. Written so many years ago and yet its still a beautiful song. Amazing how REM are able to extract such emotion with their music. Thank you for uploading this video and all the other amazing videos you have shared with REM fans all over the world. We GREATLY appreciate it.
scalzini26 2 years ago 13
thank you for kind words :)
heidigretel 2 years ago
Always loved this one, thanks for uploading.
TheGargantuanSock 2 years ago 8
you are always very welcome Sock :)
heidigretel 2 years ago