Miley Cyrus 'When I Look At You' On American Idol

[koolgirl2797]

awwwe she is sick give her a break

[Ruffian123Forever]

You know, despite Miley's various attempts to get attention of all kinds, I will say this: Her two greatest and most powerful performances were When I Look At You and The Climb.

[vasololgr]

SHE HAD A COLD THEN GUYS!!! LEAVE HER ALONG!! SHE HAD A COLD!

Thumbs up if you agree....

[NoyEspozanias]

2:32-2:57

[MileyCyruslover20]

the only reason she sounded sick is because she has A COLD!!! but if i had to rate this from a scale to 10 i would say a 8 out of 10!!

[jonilimjw]

What!? She's playing the piano!? I didn't know she could play ANYTHING.!

[vasololgr]

@jonilimjw she plays piano guitar...and drums (not good drums..)

[R1MVIDEOPRODUCTIONS]

i love this performance! :)

[money101girlfriend]

she sounds like she's just getting over a cold or something... don't get me wrong I love Miley... but not her best performance.

[vasololgr]

@money101girlfriend she had a cold!

[CanalAndyNiley]

Amazing¡¡¡¡She is the best no matter what they say i totally love this song¡¡¡I love she¡¡And if u dont like or if u had a problem with that dont put comments agresive this isnt of your bussines¡¡¡

[aphla9onN]

"don't you know,BABE"  .... what the hell

CRAP

[onu424]

first time to good at live miley

[r00x4n33]

I agree this performance is not perfect...but this song is so hard to sing ! Everybody can't sing like she does ! I don't really like Miley but I have to recognize that she does it, and well...!

[TamCORE]

Haters, just shut up. This girl is sooo talented. Her voice is so unique and she did a great job on this performance.

[TapaCentral]

SORRY! but Demi and Joe totally showed her up after her performance.. PONED!!! 

[1223Ilse]

ze is zoo nerveus!!

[ImErnaNaresa]

she sounds nervous.

[ayuadams]

She can't even pronounce properly. LOLL

[jkim4007]

She doesn't control her breathing well but she hits those high notes great!

[jkim4007]

Paige Miles and Aaron Kelly both love Miley! =)

[24lovesit]

This wasn't her best performance

[tameingraleat1]

God, that girl can't sing. I officially think I sing better than that. But since I'm not hot jailbait, she'll be the famous one.

[jkim4007]

@tameingraleat1 Can you hit those high notes clearly without hearing your voice crack?

[tameingraleat1]

@jkim4007 Yep. Sure can. I have a pretty decent vocal range and can sing the same song in several different octaves as long as it's not overly complicated.

[tameingraleat1]

@jkim4007 I just tortured myself by rewatching the video, and to me it sounds like a kid in a talent show that hasn't had any real voice training - she's not controlling her breathing, she doesn't enunciate, she doesn't shape her mouth correctly... the list goes on.

[jkim4007]

@tameingraleat1 That's not the point. Her VOICE sounds great, even though the other elements may be lacking. Besides, have you HEARD Make A Wave? Demi was great, but Joe? I'm a huge fan, but he really didn't do great.

[tameingraleat1]

@jkim4007 I honestly don't know what Make a Wave is. And I think we're going to have to agree to disagree. To me, Miley Cyrus's voice is like fingernails on a chalkboard. To you, it is not. To each his own.

[jkim4007]

@tameingraleat1 Make A Wave is a song performed by Joe Jonas and Demi Lovato on American Idol on the same episode as Miley Cyrus. Go check it out.

Yeah, lets disagree.

[xCiNDYYx3]

even though i dont really like miley cyrus. after seeing the last song it made me see her in a different light, kinda. and when she sings this, there's alot of emotion in the song and she has charisma.

[pyrolacey]

Miley only got fame because of her dad's fame. There are so many people who are way more talented who deserve what Miley has.

[joshuatification]

omg, for a moment, i tot she fell at 2:34.

[mariannetomagan]

she's great! that high note...woooooaaaaahhh is amazing!!

[IX19UT8O]

Beautiful song!!! Not for Miley, don't like her voice, never did. Who wrote it?

[jibpstar123]

her voice is much better on hr music video..but,still great!

GO MILEY!:DD

[Jelloxox]

I really want to like this girl but..I just cant. I like her as a person but this has gone way to far....whatever Im glad she has money in her pocket in this hard economy..there I said something nice.

[wenyen78]

I am amazed. She has so much emotions and stage presence. Have been watching this video several times now.

[wenyen78]

haha...her head banging...cute ! That's her trademark.

[n1doll]

I love her!!!!!!!!!!! This song is amazing, definetly one of her best!!!!

[fiercity04]

at least she puts emotions behind the song

[bradpackblue]

how on earth that ppl like her can be AI mentor? Either the producers of AI are going bonkers or America is running out of talent.

[sdarms111]

She might get to hollywood, but she isn't talented enough to even win Idol

[CrystalnMikaylaMusic]

seriously you guys who keep saying shes pitchy you try getting up on stage and you try doing that!

[free2peu]

She doesn't know to play at piano :) Her live sucks, she's not the most beautiful girl in the world but she's pretty. Anyway I like her husky voice but at singing... she is struggling :) As a conclusion ... she is the perfect example of forced media branding

[dustball3010]

Superb song, Miley have really nice voice but it's still really pitchy. I enjoy the performance thought. She still have a long way to go. Hopefully she doesn't end up in another sex video or britney spears.

[PutUpOrShutUp221]

why does this have a 3 star rating? like seriously, i used to hate miley cyrus, but she's clearly talented and this was a solid performance...

[AbbyFEEE12]

but.... She does say "when I look at chu" when she sings it live, which is kind of irritating.

and what is with the hair flipping? This is a power ballad, not a rock song or a flippy Hannah Montana song..

[AbbyFEEE12]

I love to hate her, hate to love her.

I obviously don't personally know her, but from what I have seen, I am not a Miley Cyrus fan.

BUT it is really hard to say I dont care for her after hearing this song. You can't deny that she sounds incredible and this song is amazing.

[lilmizperfect81]

can't even hear the lyrics clearly since shes like yelling

[Ultraforce777]

Wow, I underestimated her...but that doesn't mean I like her, she's still done alotta disappointing things, although this was a great performance.

[extrachanel]

You're DIVA !

[Mrmtjones]

she isnt bad. wow.

[mongolian50cent]

first i thought she did terrible but then i listen to it again it's kinda good actually

[clumsygirlboy]

shes not a stereo typical diva type.

shes a new one. if ur one of those "don't get it" u r a slow bitch

[SoWhat23345]

O_o

[jalene360]

not guna lie she looks really pretty but i honestly dont really like her LOVE THIS SONG THO!

[antisadism]

THe song be alright.

[glowingcat]

She may not be the best singer live; but considering she is only about 17, she is SO much better than many artists out their today. I actually thing the 'Nasal'-ness sort of suits her, though she has matured A TON after Hannah Montana.

[atarikg]

And your fan range consists of 11-16 stupid american girls.... Amen...

[atarikg]

Everybody needs inspiration and you need a dentist... And don't talk about life is not easy, bitch you are fricking rich and was born rich...So shut the fuck up..and learn how to sing, no one will remember you after 5 years...

[pibada2]

wtf she sounds like she's sitting on a damn vibrator

[boldgurl]

she is everywhere with this song. autotune is her friend in recordings. And her extensions are obvious... especially when she flips her head upside down.

[RapIsDeadly]

Miley is going to be someone that's remembered in 50 years....unlike Demi and Selena.

Miley has done very well for herself considering she's only 17. You haters are just so jealous of her.

[IKraidenI]

The only thing people would be jealous of is that he dad was famous so she is too, she isnt a good singer or a talented musician and if you think she is you need to get your hearing checked

[TheTrollMotor]

I'm not knocking miley but I've heard Idolers sing better so I guess it goes to show that with the right marketing there comes a point that it dosent matter how you sound sheople will love it.

[MelodicHearts]

Her voice vibrates too much. Kinda annoying. And it's kinda raspy. But she can hit the notes

[Tinxxo]

She sucks.. OBVIOUSLY

[FameUpdated]

@Tinxxo if she sucked do you think she would be worth over 300 million dollars? I believe not my friend.

[Tinxxo]

@FameUpdated  YEAH! She would.. because many of little children don't understand the concept of music. Remember the guy on american idol that sounded really bad? Yet a company hired him for his singing? the wong guy or whatever? He fucking sounded terrible yet made millions just because people got amusement out of him. Compare her to the rest of american idol singers.. she'll fail, compare her when she sang with Beyonce, MJ and Mariah Carey.. why you think she had such a small part? r_r;

[defJayyy]

@FameUpdated she's worth that much because of her dad, and her fangirls from hannah montana. do you not think there are better singers or actors than her? there are so many 17 year olds that could easily take her spot. she got lucky. don't say im jealous cause why would i be jealous of her? i dont want little boys running to me and calling me miles montana or something LOL

[FameUpdated]

@defJayyy ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Shes made more money then her dad will ever dream of making. fangirls from hannah montana? that to me makes it seem like shes working hard? And im pretty sure she is an amazing singer or she wouldnt be famous because if you think about it. Kids aren't tone deaf they can tell when someone is bad.... So Yes stop being jealous. Because thats exactly what you are.

[majolerulerulista]

hahahahaha funny comments on this vid

[MyNicoline]

Guys! She was sick ! I think she did pretty good

[ayameumino]

Her voice is rashpy, is she sick or something? Well she at least sung with passion...

[xhellion93]

she plays the piano? or is she just pretending to look talented lol it seems like a nice song but her voice ruins it..like seriously.

[snowalisious]

she actually has a rlly good voice, great vibrato and she can hold the notes really long....lol but i thought she like fell or sumthing at 2:34 i thought she fell lol :D

[arghmykneegrows]

how is she gonna be a mentor when she can't even sing

[Anekosanify]

@arghmykneegrows lolololol!!! i was thinking the same thing...even PAIGE the chick that got eliminated that episode can sing better then her, thats how bad she is...

[angoraization]

Help me to reach the goal of my young life, to be marydeutsch01's biggest fan!!!

PLEASE SEARCH FOR: THE HIP NUN and click on the first one!!!!

my hope is that she will become wildly popular thanks to me and maybe someday we will even become friends!!!

[cass2chk]

.....if she's one of the contestants i think she will be eliminated. She is a good mentor anyway...she knows how to ruin contestants.

[XCxOxDx4X]

Time to go burn my laptop.

[dripdroptearsstop]

she was actually great, this music suits her best, and she is totally a singer that is getting better with time, its great to see her grow. :D

[scrappycoco03]

digitally enhance:(

[TheSarahJade]

ooh

[PengaMangoMango]

It may be a little pitchy...but don't forget how high those notes are. I can't even imagine trying to sing notes that high. It's impressive.

[vbplaya72007]

She tried way to hard at this. Its almost like she thinks she is on the show and might win American Idol

[ShowJumper]

head banging? or seizure not sure

[hellohihi12]

She is really pitchy and kinda of nasaly. but maybe thats just her sound. i've never been a fan and i admit it.

[origamiist]

ITS REALLY weird when she does that XTREME headbang... lol

[dacurlytana]

she should cut her hair she wearn it as a top and whip....a trim wouldnt hurt

[dacurlytana]

she needs 2 cut her hair....at least a trim

[SaysDaniel]

I like how most people on youtube use the comments section to troll. It makes me laugh.

[ginasaharudin]

i think she did great !

[JimBobbyLouie]

she's awful.

[heatwave74]

You all complain about how she sings and how she looks and just about anything about her, But your asses are gonna be the ones on itunes next week buying her cd or at the theater getting tickets to her next movie cause your 8 year old tells you too LOL!!

So keep bitching but you might as well grab your wallet out and hand her 40 bucks! LOL!!

[NzNexus2]

LMAO!

[SexCyberGuideCom]

good

[momo112192]

she sounds horrific shes usually pretty good...maybe..

[xiluvparix]

get a haircut.

[xiluvparix]

fail.

[JohanGT]

she is not practicing... ¬¬ or what?

[DroppedGT]

im like wtf lol about everything to do with this...

[devinecrazy]

Miley is turning into a beautiful young woman. and i don't understand why some people say she's not talented she has a unique voice that makes her a star. it's not like oh wow amazing but seriously not bad at all... overall pretty good, she is going to have a long career.

[Passionofthetaint]

Booooooooooooooooooooo

[turner850]

:O she grew pubs finally

[Brista60045zl]

How long until she ends up on w.w.w.Celebrity-Autopsies.c.o.­m.

[ChrisChilin]

SHE SOUNDs awesome and she got hotter

[Nesha2233]

Why does she sound like that?? I agree with ChillChatUniverse the recorded version sounds much better.

[sursid13]

IF YOU HAVE NOTHING good to say then dont say it at ALL.

/On topic .. This song is so AMAZING live i really admire Miley's spirit when she makes crystal clear music like this.

[PurpleRaam]

Are you like 5 years old? Go fuck yourself.

[aznstar5o8]

why does she sound like that??!!

[amcbirds]

my dog can bark better than this!!

[TheBraveKitten]

2:34 what in the world is she doing?

[xiluvparix]

haha idk but the camera man wasn't expecting that hahahahahahhah

[sdmm1]

the whole banging her head in the air and grabbing her chest and like moving her head back and forth was way too much

[sdmm1]

I think she was trying too hard. i like her songs and stuff and i have nothing against her but i seriously think she was trying too hard and she was not good at all in this performance

[NzNexus2]

yes she was tryen too hard.

[Broodzak15]

sup puberty?

[ItsJeffreyShow]

i love miley

[ChillChatUniverse]

The recorded version is good.

[jessikuur]

wonder what simon thought about this performance

[JasplurProductions]

Ok I know alot of people hate Mile Cyrus I personally am not a fan but she sounds fine...COMPARED TO SOME PEOPLE WHO I AM NOT GOING TO SAY BECUSE MANY GIRLS LOVE HIM AND THIS WOULD PISS THEM OFF

[Hatchwork]

She was sick. She talked about it on Jay Leno. No I don't watch Jay Leno so don't troll me.

[Accordsir1]

damn! i thought biting my own balls was more painful...

[hevei]

damn, Im not buying her album no more

[tran5990]

not that good >.>, im not a hater at all, but this isn't that amazing :o

[timofmya]

o

wow

fantastic

[heatherisrickross]

o.

wow.

bad..

[Tvor1128]

I'm surprised how well that went. She was actually very good live. High notes sounded a bit strained but I commend her for committing to everything she did. Plus she's only 17. I also have to agree that she is so much better than Taylor swift live. She's no doubt better than all the Idol contestants.

[defJayyy]

@Tvor1128 better than the idol contestants? if she joined and she wasn't famous, simon would wooop her ass.

[foreverlove1015]

ok really?? its a ballad! you are NOT supposed to head bang and rock out to a ballad you talentless WHORE!

[badassadog]

i think she sings good. after all they gave taylor swift a grammy.

[TheAmazingSasha]

Love her dress

[batmanreborn81]

This girl can sing...

[CreepyboyProductions]

The poor thing tried but I love her studio voice. Its so good and fake!

[ObamaBobLaden]

go back to your pop country you're not a singer... and by the why is your face that big? It's like a big ball with a man voice.

[ParamoreVzla]

I don't like miley but this was decent

[linz812y]

im sorry but she cant sing..

[Flibbertigibbetify]

terrible

[moveaizu]

good performance(^^)d(^^)d

[xx1987xxx]

omfg I'm not a fan to this chick and I Think she's a bitch.

But jeeze give her credit. She's probably had many singing classes and got improved and at least she wore something appropriate and played the piano.

You gotta say that she is hard working girl ;)

So I say continue like this Miley.

[spokeshole]

I thought her being a "mentor" was a

stretch on AI's part.

[angakokpanipaq]

it's painful to watch her trying so hard to sing.

[TbaginANDBuck]

@angakokpanipaq Better than Britney Spears, how she lip syncs to her live songs. lmao

[MaximilianMontesa]

Her parents lied to her when they told her she could sing.

[lsusports005]

ur right she cannot sing at all... (sarcasm)

[playboybunny291]

u guys can hate but shes sound much better then tayolr swift when she perform live.

[xx1987xxx]

sooo true!

[BulldogManiaOfficial]

@playboybunny291 haha are you FUCKING high? really are you? just jealous that taylor is hotter then you is all it is.

[StubbornClock]

for miley cyrus, this is as good as performing live gets -_-

[BlueRebelArtist14]

One's again MILEY CYRUS SHOWED ...AMERICA SHE'S ABSOLUTELY ONE OF A KIND!.....<3<3<3 LOVE MILEY!

[stefanamzic]

im so sorry for miley,cause she has alot of haters...and she is really good,but these fucking haters wont shut up!

DIE!

[RaikariSpirit]

OMG horrible she would have never made it to top 50 if she joined American idol.

[banananito]

if sanjaya could....

[sexisfun000]

Why low ratings??

It's a nice song and she sing pretty well...

[jessds20]

horrible!!

[angiejacobsrs]

wow she's horrible live..so chipmunky and screechy!

[JensterKat]

She sounded much better once she stood up.

She sounded strained when she was sitting down...

Her voice does sound hoarse though.

Love her dress though.

& her voice has definitely improved.

Goood job!

[norcalriotgirl]

I wondered why they would have a person who cannot sing mentor but then it was for ratings. American Idol is so lame.

[sydneyca]

Uh, well, at least the dress designer & fitter knew that she tends to headbang to soft rock/country songs(really?????) so they loosened the the bodice of the (floor length) dress (that is reeally NOT headbanging attire)...(beginning to think etiquette schools need to be reintroduced into society)

[DavidArchuleta94]

Beautiful song,

& she looks gorgeous too, but it sounded really strain, like the notes were too high for her voice. However, I think this is one of her better live performances.

[Sokur22]

i really wanna know what the judges thought. its funny that she mentored people who are better singers than her. did anyone else watch joe jonas trying to sing hahaha.

[Mally1225]

A little pitchy dawg. LOL.

Whenever she sang "at you", I wanted to say bless you...it sounded like "achoo"

But I like the song...its pretty.

[playlojloreal1]

I though tmiley did great. You all made me think that I wouldn't finish the video even.

[smc2190]

she sounded a TON better once she stood up

[xanafanadu]

wow she's crap!!! how is she famous?!?!? she sounds like a beaver passing a kidney stone!!