apnara debate kortai thaken ar ami ganta bar bar shuntai thaki.............crazy bangali------------nija kichu korta parea na kau kichu korla khali dosh khuja barai
part 2. Some of the Tagore's songs were taken from west. I dont think he dedicated it (at least i didn't hear) eventually he took it, and nobody asked any question.
Not for commercial purpose! that i seriously doubt. even the album is free, it is helping him to build his commercial career. who can argue!.
ok the verdict is: copy is something when u dont mention the original source and taking the credit of it but it might be used for commercial purpose. So all the talents stay in safeside
part 1. ok what's up. 1st the positives: bangla lyrics good, vocals, love it, catchy video. credit goes to them.
Is it copy! hmmmm. lets see. In 90s an album released called CopyR (might be copier). All the songs in that album were originally hit English songs. I think they were very honest saying it CopyR.lol. On the other hand, Kabir Sumon former Shumon Chakroborty sang Bob Dylan's Blowing in the wind in Bangla. it might be dedicated to dylan, but the album was for commercial no doubt.
not as nice as the original . the translation would have been even better if they concentrated on translating the feelings instead of literal translation . things like "morubhumir jhor" carries no significance in bengali !!
@Tauhid19 when it comes to knowing the bengali language , i am not ashamed to say that i do have some knowledge .
i would have definitely done it in another way if i were a singer . but im an artist , not a musician ( just a lovr of music ) .
but most importantly even if i knew music i wouldnt have gone into plain mimicry . i would have taken inspiration for something new and different rather than direct copy paste . thanks
@halleygoswami lets get it straight.Stop whining and giving excuses.It is not really important to know that are you an artist or a singer or even a bus driver.Before correcting what the singer(Suman) wrote here,write me a better lyrics then what he wrote and i wont say anything.This guys been singing for more than 16 years.He definitely knew what kind of jhor he was supposed to write.
@halleygoswami dude, before you give your so called "freedom of speech", you should know what youre talking about. He published this album in respect for John Denver. thats why he didnt change the lyric. If you know an alternative for morubhumir jhor, please let me know.
@maisun26 John Denver er gaan ta is supposed to be bettre. Its the original after all. There is no such thing as 'better than the original' kaaron original er moto kichu na. If I am to make a spoof, aamar effort ta jotoi bhalo houk na keno it'll never match the original. :)
@eesharc ~~ "shundor .... kintu john denver r song ta aro touchy" this was my comment i think...
but i don't understand, what was point in defining me? all have their personal choices. & one shouldn't expect it'll match with others... anyway; thanks
@preetamcsu: bro, its not copy..this album is dedicated to Jhon denver on his 7th death anniversary...commercial purpose e ei song gulo kora hoy nai.....whole album contains 12 songs of bangla version of Jhon Denvar songs..its not copy..got it??? respect the artist..otherwise u can compose a song & upload to youtube, so that we can judge u how talent u r!!
apnara debate kortai thaken ar ami ganta bar bar shuntai thaki.............crazy bangali------------nija kichu korta parea na kau kichu korla khali dosh khuja barai
shuvobau1 2 days ago
part 2. Some of the Tagore's songs were taken from west. I dont think he dedicated it (at least i didn't hear) eventually he took it, and nobody asked any question.
Not for commercial purpose! that i seriously doubt. even the album is free, it is helping him to build his commercial career. who can argue!.
ok the verdict is: copy is something when u dont mention the original source and taking the credit of it but it might be used for commercial purpose. So all the talents stay in safeside
rajon000 4 months ago
part 1. ok what's up. 1st the positives: bangla lyrics good, vocals, love it, catchy video. credit goes to them.
Is it copy! hmmmm. lets see. In 90s an album released called CopyR (might be copier). All the songs in that album were originally hit English songs. I think they were very honest saying it CopyR.lol. On the other hand, Kabir Sumon former Shumon Chakroborty sang Bob Dylan's Blowing in the wind in Bangla. it might be dedicated to dylan, but the album was for commercial no doubt.
rajon000 4 months ago
SOO amazing!!!!!!!!! :) :)♥
Elita's voice is soo soothing! :D
SelenaHudgens77 7 months ago
i love this song.ki addbhut feeliing hai ai ganta shunle.thangs to shumon bhai and anila apu for the song.
Tani260 9 months ago
not as nice as the original . the translation would have been even better if they concentrated on translating the feelings instead of literal translation . things like "morubhumir jhor" carries no significance in bengali !!
halleygoswami 10 months ago
Comment removed
Tauhid19 9 months ago
@halleygoswami if u think u r so talented bengali why don't u upload and translate " feelings". besides wat did jhon denver knew about a desert.
Tauhid19 9 months ago
@Tauhid19 when it comes to knowing the bengali language , i am not ashamed to say that i do have some knowledge .
i would have definitely done it in another way if i were a singer . but im an artist , not a musician ( just a lovr of music ) .
but most importantly even if i knew music i wouldnt have gone into plain mimicry . i would have taken inspiration for something new and different rather than direct copy paste . thanks
halleygoswami 9 months ago
@halleygoswami lets get it straight.Stop whining and giving excuses.It is not really important to know that are you an artist or a singer or even a bus driver.Before correcting what the singer(Suman) wrote here,write me a better lyrics then what he wrote and i wont say anything.This guys been singing for more than 16 years.He definitely knew what kind of jhor he was supposed to write.
Tauhid19 8 months ago
@Tauhid19 hello !!! im not here to say anything about his singing skills ! all i said was that the translation could have been even better .
so what if suman has been singing for 16 years ? that only establishes his singing skills and not his efficiency as a translator .
and surely everyone has a freedom of opinion ?!!!
i merely placed my opinion without any intention to prove or disprove anything . neither to fight over a such a petty thing over internet . thanks
halleygoswami 8 months ago
@halleygoswami dude, before you give your so called "freedom of speech", you should know what youre talking about. He published this album in respect for John Denver. thats why he didnt change the lyric. If you know an alternative for morubhumir jhor, please let me know.
Tauhid19 8 months ago
shundor .... kintu john denver r song ta aro touchy
maisun26 1 year ago
@maisun26 John Denver er gaan ta is supposed to be bettre. Its the original after all. There is no such thing as 'better than the original' kaaron original er moto kichu na. If I am to make a spoof, aamar effort ta jotoi bhalo houk na keno it'll never match the original. :)
eesharc 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@eesharc ~~ "shundor .... kintu john denver r song ta aro touchy" this was my comment i think...
but i don't understand, what was point in defining me? all have their personal choices. & one shouldn't expect it'll match with others... anyway; thanks
maisun26 5 months ago
Sudhu Sumon gaile joss hoito.
farhan020328 1 year ago
awesome
sohelshipu 1 year ago
@preetamcsu: bro, its not copy..this album is dedicated to Jhon denver on his 7th death anniversary...commercial purpose e ei song gulo kora hoy nai.....whole album contains 12 songs of bangla version of Jhon Denvar songs..its not copy..got it??? respect the artist..otherwise u can compose a song & upload to youtube, so that we can judge u how talent u r!!
adbhutseleti 1 year ago 14
its nice
kazidr 1 year ago
A good translation of one of the most immortal songs of all times by John Denver!
shafmun 1 year ago
copy korar o ekta limit thaka uchit. this is just terrible.
preetamcsu 1 year ago
"you fill up my senses" theke full copy-paste...
dikinan 1 year ago
the video could have been better......song is nice.....
shyfy100 1 year ago
Toma apnak onek thanks! Ato sundor akta song gift korar jonno!
Thx Sumon n Elita as well for present us thiss nice song!
sumon39 1 year ago
great effort ... kudos to everyone involved
drahman1976 2 years ago
not bad though, "Annie's song by John Denver" is the best..!! nice try tho...
Nitun001 2 years ago
anyway,,,,,,,,,,,,,,awsome VDO.................
nizum03 2 years ago
atleast theres no pretensions, and the translation is awesome
michaelarkengel 2 years ago 9
not too good
ali89reza 2 years ago
Nice try but did not bring that flavour... May be the first impression is the last impression
Susira1985 3 years ago
good try
Shishirhala 3 years ago