all of you shoulda seen adam pascal doing this scene on stage, not only is his voice much better than this guys, but so his understanding of the intricacies of Roger's character
and his performances were incredibly emotional, not to say that this one's bad, but no one can beat the original Roger
Also, I love how the Reverend calls Mark, a straight guy, a 'queer' when there's the gay man he just kicked out RIGHT THERE. *shrug* Just found that interesting and a tad ironic.
everyone that was cast for the roles of roger,mimi,mark,maureen,joanne,collins angel and benny was perfect and the role of roger played by will chase was wonderful
Gaaah, Adam and Will. The chemistry the two of you have is unbelievable. X3 I love this cast to death. While the OBC may be, well, the ORIGINAL, that doesn't mean they are the absolute best. *is going to get shot for saying that* Love you, Adam and Will-3
I love how in this one Roger actually seems like he used to be on drugs, with a couple minor tweeker gestures. it makes it more realistic. Rather than adam pascal who seemes like he was always whining. and mimi is phenominal....at 4:30 when they show mimi it is a breathtaking moment....:)
@koolbeans72109 i feel the same way. the roger in the movie was always my favorite person but at soon as i head the rogers voice i was like omg its so much better
I just saw the Rent 10th anniversary version of this song... this cast does WAAAAAY better. They have so much raw emotion in every word! This just goes to show you that original doesn't always mean best!
Wow did Benny and Collins just go off hand in hand. Could another relationship be brewing? I love small things like that, not relevant, but quiet interesting.
I like Rent as a musical simply cause it has a very touching story....about a group of very close friends who try to surrive and nearly break apart in the end...but thankfuly don't.
Plus it's nice to have a 'sung through' musical (mainly sung through)
they took goodbye love out the movie because they said there was too much emotion for one film so that when you got to the bit where mimi died it didn't affect you as much. i listened tothe directors commentary on deleted scenes <---dork :)
they only cut off half of it n as much as i think it should have been in it chris columbus said that it was repeating wat was already said. The second part is like a personal goodbye between mimi n roger but it was decided that it wasnt needed because they where like arlready mad n angry at each other that it seemed hard 4 them 2 go from that 2 all teary again
Note to Will/Roger: stop with the nervous laughter in all of your lines. It doesn't make you look natural, it makes you look insensitive to the story and music and diminishes what the audience is capable of feeling for your character.
Well, I actually think that nervous laughter and harsh attitude make him appear like he tries to hide his pain, and that's the essence of Roger. It is until the end, when he thinks Mimi will die, that he breaks off and shows his true feelings. But I agree that he must take some extra acting classes :-)
I finally got why columbus deleted those scenes. it was because he wanted to make benny look bad. that´s why he gets rid of most of the taye diggs scenes. I still don't know why he cut halloween, though
i think it was more to do with the fact that in making films you have to sacrifice some plot lines- and the benny plot line didnt take priority. And goodbye love(the best bit) was cut because all the interaction between them previously in the film was spoken and was very straight and it didnt feel right for them to be singing at each other because it was less intimate- halloween I would guess similarly because mark hadnt been singing his narations previously it wouldnt feel right. i think anyway
I think it was a mistake to delete Goodbye Love. The story lost so much emotion and in the end, for anyone who doesn't know the musical (like myself, I watched the movie first and then got interested in the musical), it's kinda strange to see Roger in Santa Fe. It's too fast, the breaking up with Mimi and her depression is unexplained, and at the end I was like: "Hold on...what was the real conflict in this movie?"
They actually filmed Halloween and Goodbye Love, but I think they had to cut it for time. Shame, because I adore these songs. Rosario was great at singing Goodbye Love. That movie is like a child to me, haha.
one of my favourites part from this music play.
pikololulifuk 1 week ago
all of you shoulda seen adam pascal doing this scene on stage, not only is his voice much better than this guys, but so his understanding of the intricacies of Roger's character
and his performances were incredibly emotional, not to say that this one's bad, but no one can beat the original Roger
RoonskiLuv 1 month ago
I thik thah the movie doesn´t have the magic of the musical... I prefer this version
mafi047 1 month ago
Goodbye, Love is my favorite song. I'm always a basket case.
PeepsRule123 4 months ago
I LOVE THAT SHES IN COLD CASE NOW :)
WaNsTlo 5 months ago
1:11 AMASING!
blondie256x 5 months ago 4
The emotions from all the actors in this scene are just...It's so intense and I love it.
TheViciousCabaret 7 months ago
The only thing I prefer from the original Roger was the way Adam Pascal said 'poor baby'.
michygreen92 8 months ago
I can't believe this was cut out of the movie.
michygreen92 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Also, I love how the Reverend calls Mark, a straight guy, a 'queer' when there's the gay man he just kicked out RIGHT THERE. *shrug* Just found that interesting and a tad ironic.
EriksWanderingChild 8 months ago in playlist RENT 2008 Performance
everyone that was cast for the roles of roger,mimi,mark,maureen,joanne,collins angel and benny was perfect and the role of roger played by will chase was wonderful
nakaelah1 8 months ago
Comment removed
EriksWanderingChild 8 months ago
Comment removed
EriksWanderingChild 8 months ago
Gaaah, Adam and Will. The chemistry the two of you have is unbelievable. X3 I love this cast to death. While the OBC may be, well, the ORIGINAL, that doesn't mean they are the absolute best. *is going to get shot for saying that* Love you, Adam and Will-3
EriksWanderingChild 8 months ago
renee and will are amazing. i especially love how renee is crying by the end. RENT IS AMAZING!
westseniorhigh 8 months ago in playlist Rent Filmed Live on Broadway
U GET 2 SURVIVE...POOR BABY
Martichaj 8 months ago
RODGER'S VOICE CREEPS ME OUT
Martichaj 8 months ago
I love how in this one Roger actually seems like he used to be on drugs, with a couple minor tweeker gestures. it makes it more realistic. Rather than adam pascal who seemes like he was always whining. and mimi is phenominal....at 4:30 when they show mimi it is a breathtaking moment....:)
khalifisrandom 8 months ago
I love Roger's part from 1:10-1:20 and 3:30-4:10 and then i love mark's response
1mannyfan 9 months ago
I love Roger's part from 1:10-1:20.
1mannyfan 9 months ago
Am I the only one who finds it incredibally sexy when Roger says OH POOR BABY! ?
AutumnsEatingMyHair 9 months ago 2
"I can't believe this family must die" always gets me.
fleetfooted 10 months ago
@koolbeans72109 i feel the same way. the roger in the movie was always my favorite person but at soon as i head the rogers voice i was like omg its so much better
deadpig101 11 months ago
THE ORIGINAL BROADWAY CAST FOREVER. But I do love this cast except for Benny maybe.
maylaaaxbb 11 months ago
@maylaaaxbb I agree. Benny keeps taking these real DEEP breaths before he sings. I don't like that
Abonanno24601 10 months ago in playlist Rent: Live On Broadway
this roger is amazing!
littlekym88 1 year ago
this Roger is too ANGRY.
calliesaiyan 1 year ago 2
i feel bad for Mark, he's going to live while watching his best friends die
ofile2009 1 year ago 3
1 person didnt wanna say goodbye to love
gleekfan77 1 year ago
*should have been more intense
687nikki 1 year ago
The argument between mark and Roger shou
687nikki 1 year ago
4:12 is absolutly brilliant so pashionate
77anthonyh 1 year ago
wait where did Collins go?
why did he go with the Reverend/priest?
11blackroses 1 year ago
@11blackroses to pay for angels funeral
LittleMissTinkabell 1 year ago
Rodger looks like Ellen Degeneres.
zagityroo 1 year ago 5
I love this show
rogs49 1 year ago
Goodbye Love (L)
Porcelainfacex3 1 year ago
2:14, so cute!
nblsoccergurl 1 year ago
As much as I love Adam Pascal and Anthony Rapp, this Mark and Roger are gotdamn phenomenal, OMG.
Thekcweston 1 year ago 3
Does Benny have AIDS?
PeaceNdLovee 1 year ago
@PeaceNdLovee no he doesn't.
LttlqnQn205 1 year ago
I love how marks and Rogers voices harmonize in what you own
Toky0tikkle 1 year ago 4
I hate how ready Roger is to beat the shit out of Mimi in the beginning of Goodbye Love, it's ridiculous!
DevilMayClarify 1 year ago 2
Will Chase is the best Roger by far
nivekyarb 2 years ago 5
I love how Rogers voice breaks up at the end.
This is so emotial so authentik
No doubt that this is the best rent cast that there has ever been.
zuponafe 2 years ago 45
obc is pretty amazing tho i think that if you took will chase , the girl who plays mimi, and tracey toms and put them in obc it would be amazing
quickydmagicmexi 1 year ago 2
@zuponafe But Idina isnt Maureen, I wish she was, but this maureen is still great!
ACABERCROMBIE92 6 months ago
i'm sorry, i love this song but i always think "doesnt benny have a wife? why is he 'dating' mimi?"
WickedBratElphaba411 2 years ago
Oh my rent! I just noticed that. He is cheating on his wife. Lol
JonasHouse09 2 years ago 2
lmao, i didnt notice this until you said something.
kobacha 2 years ago
this is my favorite song. hands down.
ImInTroubleImaAddict 2 years ago 2
@ImInTroubleImaAddict Ditto =]
imaqt955 1 year ago
Mark=Favorite Character. I want his part!
killyjoy000 2 years ago
Yes the part of the Mark is indeed very cool but I have to say I would rather have the part of the Angel. I would die to be able to play this.
zuponafe 2 years ago
@killyjoy000 Oh my gosh...I wanna be Roger so bad hehe
elharolde11235 2 years ago
this is the most emotional part of the musical ::( i love it!!!
mileyfan1013 2 years ago 3
I almost cried in this scene.
LilaCaffee 2 years ago 4
This scene and The I'll Cover You Reprise the two most amazing and emotional pieces of theatre I have ever seen!
spursfan000 2 years ago 2
I just saw the Rent 10th anniversary version of this song... this cast does WAAAAAY better. They have so much raw emotion in every word! This just goes to show you that original doesn't always mean best!
nikkivan21 2 years ago 2
I can't stop listening to this song. RENT is one of the best musicals I've ever seen. It's so great. Johnathon Larson really knew what he was doing.
georgeypoo 2 years ago 4
Wow did Benny and Collins just go off hand in hand. Could another relationship be brewing? I love small things like that, not relevant, but quiet interesting.
JonasHouse09 2 years ago
So at 6:42 they're getting kicked off of the premises by... Joanne's dad?
smilininthe3rd 2 years ago
That's not Joanne's dad... the guy just plays multiple roles.
nikkivan21 2 years ago
@nikkivan21
i know, i just thought it was funny.
smilininthe3rd 2 years ago
jesus! at 1:10 that boy has pipes!!
NeonSunset23 2 years ago 2
@NeonSunset23
I went back to hear what you meant. It's better the second time. :)
JonasHouse09 2 years ago
@JonasHouse09
iknow he's pretty awesome
NeonSunset23 2 years ago
I like Rent as a musical simply cause it has a very touching story....about a group of very close friends who try to surrive and nearly break apart in the end...but thankfuly don't.
Plus it's nice to have a 'sung through' musical (mainly sung through)
Peadarisback 2 years ago
" I'll call, I hate the fall"
LOVE that line.
AlyssaLillian 2 years ago 2
I really think these actors fit their characters well, and I like the overall effect.
I think Roger is a little too angry though...he looks like he is about to slap the hell out of mimi lol
ForgottenHippie 2 years ago
I think the character is ready to slap the hell out of mimi to be honest XD
BlackValleyRequiem 2 years ago 2
@ForgottenHippie
The guy who is Roger is so into character. Amazing actors, all of them.
JonasHouse09 2 years ago 2
@JonasHouse09 This Roger is amazing.
gabrielawithlasers 2 years ago 2
I hate to say it, but I love this Roger more than the one in the movie, and mostly because of this scene.
koolbeans72109 2 years ago 69
@koolbeans72109 I know this roger seems so much more authentic and better
vermontstar 4 months ago
they took goodbye love out the movie because they said there was too much emotion for one film so that when you got to the bit where mimi died it didn't affect you as much. i listened tothe directors commentary on deleted scenes <---dork :)
HaNnAhBhAm 2 years ago
I love the fight between Mark and Roger, it's so sad and meaningful. And I love how Roger seems to feel bad about saying those things to Mark.
Wondercat95 2 years ago 6
2:15 - 2:21
its nice that there was sumthing funny in the sadness
i also luv the scene with benny
especially 7:01
broadwaysinger123 2 years ago
LOVE ROGER
naty717 2 years ago 7
Goodbye Love left me in tears. omg, why did they take that song out of the movie!
jackskellingtonsora 2 years ago 5
i think they said it was too long to go in the movie, but its in the deleted scenes :(
percycatmill5 2 years ago
they only cut off half of it n as much as i think it should have been in it chris columbus said that it was repeating wat was already said. The second part is like a personal goodbye between mimi n roger but it was decided that it wasnt needed because they where like arlready mad n angry at each other that it seemed hard 4 them 2 go from that 2 all teary again
baileyGirl166 2 years ago
Roger is such a badass. This person playing Roger is amazing, not necessarily better than the original, but still amazing.
jackskellingtonsora 2 years ago 7
Roger was so intense in this video!!!
HappeeHipee 2 years ago 6
i hate roger here its a good scene like but hes just so hateful
amie171 2 years ago
fhd
crazyhouse78220 2 years ago
yes lol it looked a little scary too
Danie216 2 years ago
I know it's like they do in an old horror movie
dramagal19 2 years ago
I love how Roger sings the part to Mimi. In the beginning. And i don't like Mark, but then, sometimes, i like him.
Maaike1994 2 years ago
Note to Will/Roger: stop with the nervous laughter in all of your lines. It doesn't make you look natural, it makes you look insensitive to the story and music and diminishes what the audience is capable of feeling for your character.
larrydildo 2 years ago
Well, I actually think that nervous laughter and harsh attitude make him appear like he tries to hide his pain, and that's the essence of Roger. It is until the end, when he thinks Mimi will die, that he breaks off and shows his true feelings. But I agree that he must take some extra acting classes :-)
GiselleKan 2 years ago 4
I finally got why columbus deleted those scenes. it was because he wanted to make benny look bad. that´s why he gets rid of most of the taye diggs scenes. I still don't know why he cut halloween, though
quiroz923 2 years ago 3
i think it was more to do with the fact that in making films you have to sacrifice some plot lines- and the benny plot line didnt take priority. And goodbye love(the best bit) was cut because all the interaction between them previously in the film was spoken and was very straight and it didnt feel right for them to be singing at each other because it was less intimate- halloween I would guess similarly because mark hadnt been singing his narations previously it wouldnt feel right. i think anyway
icclenomi 2 years ago
I think it was a mistake to delete Goodbye Love. The story lost so much emotion and in the end, for anyone who doesn't know the musical (like myself, I watched the movie first and then got interested in the musical), it's kinda strange to see Roger in Santa Fe. It's too fast, the breaking up with Mimi and her depression is unexplained, and at the end I was like: "Hold on...what was the real conflict in this movie?"
GiselleKan 2 years ago 5
They actually filmed Halloween and Goodbye Love, but I think they had to cut it for time. Shame, because I adore these songs. Rosario was great at singing Goodbye Love. That movie is like a child to me, haha.
thishatandyou 2 years ago 6
It's on the album but that's the only way it's acknowledged.
ritsfata 2 years ago
benny sounds way to happy after collins tells him about the dog, rofl.
camillesantiago 2 years ago
The line : "poor baby" always makes me laugh. I know I'm supposed to be sad, but who says that?!
TheQuestionBoy4 2 years ago
after mimi push roger here veary quitel say fuck
rocknroll20024 2 years ago
I love Will for Roger in this part. I kinda like the way he interpreted the character and scene :D
pamvillareal 3 years ago 2
love this song this song is harder than the orginial cast, the actors weren't sooo agressive especially Roger and Mimi's character
LibraBoo32 3 years ago 3
I cant wait to get this on DVD
idinakristinwicked 3 years ago
wheres part 15 with the reprise
JlynnS69 3 years ago
If you're talking about ill cover you reprise, it's in 15. If you're talking about halloween reprise, well, there isn't one
skiman93 3 years ago 2
yeah i saw it in part 15, i was having a blonde moment and couldnt find 15 but i got it thanks...love the vids!
JlynnS69 3 years ago