@9876qwerty1234 Then you should have rephrased it to "best in today's pop chart business". I would agree. 'One of the best in the (whole) business'? Please.
Did anyone see the view this morning? They were saying that this preformance was too sexual to have on the show. Say what?!? I personally think the performance was beautiful and it wasn't overtly sexual at all (and I'm sure that I'm not the only one that thinks this). Barbara walters, why are you so old?
nO mAnChEs lady gaga estubo genial en american idol yo soy de la ciudad de mexico que afortunados son al poder verla te amo gaga y estoy en el limite de la gloria
ese saxofon no pega ni con moco en esa cancion... y por cierto esa caraja pa mi ya esta quemada... la musica no es igual q antes... esta peor que antes =S
I have to say pretty good performance I was really worried about being disapointed with a live performance if this song coz it's a ballad and I didn't think tooooo much cud be done with it but yet again mother monster prooved me wrong always trust in mother and be as free as you're Hair :L haha xD
Just what we needed someone else to encourage r young people to commit suicide. This was a totally out of order performance. This should be banned not praised.
@QueenVictoriam Pffft... Seriously? She isn't commiting suicide, is she? She's just PERFORMING. She isn't encouraging anyone! And if someone gets the urge to commit suicide because of this performance he's just bad in the head. It wouldn't be Gaga's fault. Your comment doesn't make ANY sense. Like, at all. You just bash the performance for the sake of it, because it's Gaga. Well, whatever. It was a great performance of a great song. Get over it.
@WaterKirin Considering it was the first time she was performing this song on stage, it was amazing. Not a mess at all. She's singing live, and these things happen. You go try to do it better. Jeeze...
@9876qwerty1234 One of the best in the business? Compared to who? Please give me some names of the others in the 'business' she is better than according to you.
@inasexymood i could name some myself, Britney spears, Kesha Katy, perry , madonna ,justin bieber, jenifer lopez ,nicole scherzinger,rihanna And many more , 1. Her Voive sounds better 2.her songs sound better as they are wriiten by herself unlike some of these monkeys , " and her performaces are always amazing And haveing seen nearly all of these live , Lady gaga's monster ball concert was the Damn Best !!
@LeebeKing I knew it. If those are the first and only names you can come up with, you are comparing piss to poop. Go broaden your musical horizon and come back to teach me about 'the best in the business'.
@inasexymood ,Cher , Mariah carey ,Madonna again , Kylie minogue, whitney houston , beyonce , barbra streisand , chritina agularia ,tina turner ,micheal jackson , i can go on for many hours if you like , Shes as good or better as any one of these people 99% of the time , if you think these or poop then you delusional
Amazing performance...her voice is amazing and the dance is beautiful,however ,the sax was REALLY disappointing! I think she should've just left the backtrack in that part...great performance though...
I'll never get over from that end!!!! OMGaga!!!! Who does that?!?! AMAZING!!! And I agree with @100Adalberto I looked like if the guy didn't had air! :S Horrible!!! And she looked a little bit nervous, but AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!
I was afraid to watch this song's performance. It´s a pretty song and I was afraid it were lost because of the costumes and the weird make up. But i liked it. she is so talented!
She doesnt sounds that well, sounds like she wants to cry :'( Maybe cause it was her first performance of the song as it is, and the stiry behind the song and her grandfather :S We love you gaga! Cry! You diserve it! Crying is such an amazing feeling, it's like an orgasm of feelings, most of the feelings get together when you cry, do it Gaga, you'll feel better if you cry. We love you! (:
@JoeBrandAG i agree, although she has performed it before (SNL), it must be difficult to sing without thinking of what inspired it. Ahhh i love her so much!
Lol!! This causes suicide? How? I -3 you Gaga:)
Chandler46017 7 months ago
nice
antoine1984 8 months ago
This single is very 80's! I liked the futuristic style of THE FAME
JordanpaivaJps 8 months ago
Axl Rose headband?
nandovt1 8 months ago
é uma diva mesmo,sempre,e sempre será ! *-*
MrLilian1993 8 months ago
O final foi massa...hehe...Tbm, com um show de talentos, Lady Gaga com certeza foi a artista mais a altura pra se apresentar...ELA ARRASAAA!!!!
michelleevinicius 9 months ago
Desafinou pra caralho pqp!
JedPop 9 months ago
Arrasou Gaga !! Muito Bom Nota 10
Julia9934 9 months ago
frefQFEWQFWEFWE
macbarny1 9 months ago
her voice is annoying in this one, but I like her.
napaztotal 9 months ago
Je t'aiime, GaGa ♥
LilMonsterKimi 9 months ago
superrrr!!!!! te amo gaga
sportacous 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this one going to be the next bad romance
TheMrPokerFace7 9 months ago
Goooooodd
swsidi 9 months ago
I really love it this is my fav. Song!!!!
123camello123 9 months ago
Lady gaga's performance was cool and he wasn't rubbing his dick on her on purpose that was part of the dance so y dont u shut up!!
09septemberbaby 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love lady gaga and her new song rox!!!!!
09septemberbaby 9 months ago
Of course there was a mess up at 2:31 because his dick was practically all over her and she was loving it
starrysky0614 9 months ago
Woah getting raped live EH? Hah
xXyowassupXx 9 months ago
amazing. thats all i can say....amazing. :)
ParaFreak33 9 months ago
i love it
tjhunt45 9 months ago
Like if you r on the edge with gaga :D
marcmcalind3n 9 months ago
The guy with Gaga is Mark from SYTYCD a few seasons ago. I'd like to be on "the edge" with him too. ;-)
hugbras 9 months ago
In her singin I mean. It sounded like she got ahead of the music for a sec
sportschickk93 9 months ago
Minor mistake at 2:31? Or was that planned. I'm not trying to trash lady gaga she's awesome. Just wondering haha
sportschickk93 9 months ago
And I liked the sax in this song :o)
fxaman 9 months ago
Another level of awesome :o) And the dancer is hot.. as always :o)
fxaman 9 months ago
That was amazing she sounded the same that means she is a true artist
We love u gaga don't change keep coming up with these amazing songs
tomsmonstermusic 9 months ago
Sweeet! Always amazing!!!that dancer thoe, had a nice body:)
cranberriedude 9 months ago
the saxophone man is good, what the fuck are you talking about? You just dont appreciate 90's music
HearWithoutPrejudice 9 months ago
gaga gained weight! hahaha! love yah! momma monster im a super fan from philippines were your best friend came from
magnificentimage14 9 months ago
@magnificentimage14 so what if she dfid, still looks great
HearWithoutPrejudice 9 months ago
Comment removed
CuteMichelle07 9 months ago
@CuteMichelle07 who are you to determine who should be more of what. If you where in her place u would have never made it this far.
HearWithoutPrejudice 9 months ago
@9876qwerty1234 Then you should have rephrased it to "best in today's pop chart business". I would agree. 'One of the best in the (whole) business'? Please.
inasexymood 9 months ago
Saxophone sucked. Everything else was good.
RobRedOne 9 months ago
ohhhhhhh my goddddd her voice is gorgeus like the record love you mother monster
MYGAGALIFE 9 months ago
Outstanding performance!
genesisinoa 9 months ago
saxophone FAIL
genesisinoa 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"You go try to do it better."
Sure. Ok.
She has no excuse for this kind performance on a big show finale.
There is a thing called "REHEARSAL".
JEEZE...
WaterKirin 9 months ago
Did anyone see the view this morning? They were saying that this preformance was too sexual to have on the show. Say what?!? I personally think the performance was beautiful and it wasn't overtly sexual at all (and I'm sure that I'm not the only one that thinks this). Barbara walters, why are you so old?
mymiddletoe 9 months ago
@mymiddletoe Ha! That's what a lot of people are saying. Personally, I think they're full of shit.
Albolu 9 months ago
bad voice!
elprincipito11 9 months ago
ella es la mejor cantante que ha surgido en este milenio =) Me encanrta!
8avril8 9 months ago
Sweet jeezus that woman can sing!
cendy304 9 months ago
Awesome!!!!! Love the song!!!!!!!
MJam87lover 9 months ago
Sounds tired
by1couture 9 months ago
ugh, so sick of her
DarkKrystof 9 months ago
@DarkKrystof then why the Fuck are you watching this video
tahleighVengenz 9 months ago
@tahleighVengenz well, she is good for a laugh.
DarkKrystof 9 months ago
nO mAnChEs lady gaga estubo genial en american idol yo soy de la ciudad de mexico que afortunados son al poder verla te amo gaga y estoy en el limite de la gloria
daniel89677 9 months ago
make up looks like cyndi lauper!!
great!! love that song.. love Gaga!!
JulianoCentena 9 months ago
This woman is incredible.
Llamallamaduck62 9 months ago 4
Gaga sweetie a new saxaphone player is in order! Great performance! ♥
GlamazonPhoenix5 9 months ago
this song is awesome! luv u mother monster!!
AceGotFingered 9 months ago
Lady Gaga is amazing. & her performances are unreal. i loved the ending :) ♥
xjs18x 9 months ago
Fantastic!! Great song!
tartadefresa78 9 months ago
Thanks for posting this! Awesome performance! Love to hear Mother Monster LIVE! She's really talented!
martinidelight1 9 months ago
Nothing special
brunoamamaria 9 months ago
omfg
xomisuraco 9 months ago
que sax fail! huahaauahuh
giovannik2508 9 months ago
that sax man should be FIRED !!!!!!!!!!!!
oussama17061991 9 months ago 27
Sax = Scheiße
anthonya241 9 months ago
Muita linda essa performance
1robertkurt 9 months ago
ese saxofon no pega ni con moco en esa cancion... y por cierto esa caraja pa mi ya esta quemada... la musica no es igual q antes... esta peor que antes =S
taxidermisto 9 months ago
:D ¡¡¡¡¡¡
geriithalgaga 9 months ago
fabulosa!
excaliburadonis 9 months ago
Me gusto muchooo
miguelto64 9 months ago 2
OMG the saxophone man SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!
Dhikababy 9 months ago 36
@Dhikababy jhjfjf
vbfxhgfhgfrhyrf
macbarny1 9 months ago
I have to say pretty good performance I was really worried about being disapointed with a live performance if this song coz it's a ballad and I didn't think tooooo much cud be done with it but yet again mother monster prooved me wrong always trust in mother and be as free as you're Hair :L haha xD
icamification 9 months ago
Powerful woman
1122paris 9 months ago
Just what we needed someone else to encourage r young people to commit suicide. This was a totally out of order performance. This should be banned not praised.
QueenVictoriam 9 months ago
@QueenVictoriam Pffft... Seriously? She isn't commiting suicide, is she? She's just PERFORMING. She isn't encouraging anyone! And if someone gets the urge to commit suicide because of this performance he's just bad in the head. It wouldn't be Gaga's fault. Your comment doesn't make ANY sense. Like, at all. You just bash the performance for the sake of it, because it's Gaga. Well, whatever. It was a great performance of a great song. Get over it.
Albolu 9 months ago
Thx for uploading the song :)
ChyNCollet 9 months ago
WOW! <3
javog1 9 months ago
i hate the sax ruin the song
geotube0890 9 months ago
this song is awful, sounds like a song off the movie "streets of fire"
GlossyShoes 9 months ago
OMG!!!, LADY GAGA HAVE THE BEST WEEK AN ARTIST HAD, 1ST ON SNL THEN ON AMERICAN IDOL, I,M A MAN BUT WISH I WAS HER FOR THIS WEEK. FANTASIC!!!!!!!.
P.S. THE SAX PLAYER SUCK!!
MrSOUTHEASTMANIA 9 months ago
She sings this song better when she's just sitting at the piano. She struggled to hit some notes here.
ShinySecret 9 months ago
LOL AT 1;27, the sax is doing some stupid shit, haha it's sooo fking funny!
I Só love gaga's performance... it's tooo bad the sax didn't played well, it's a VERYVERYimportant piece of the song.
cborg87 9 months ago
can't get enough of this, repeat, repeat, repeat!!! ♥
YvonneL4u 9 months ago
@9876qwerty1234 Immediate business? I thought you said 'one of the best in the business'?
Do you not sense the irony of calling her the best compared to Rihanna, Kesha, Katy Perry, JLo, Britney? I didn't know 'the business' was so limited.
inasexymood 9 months ago
mencanta!
tamara9513 9 months ago
woooo perfect
TheUchelo 9 months ago
Is that Jack Sparrow or Davy Jones?
WaterKirin 9 months ago
2:22-2:32
"I am on the edge, the (oops I`m too fast) edge..."
The performance was a mess with the saxophone included.
That`s why she killed herself at the end lol
WaterKirin 9 months ago
@WaterKirin Considering it was the first time she was performing this song on stage, it was amazing. Not a mess at all. She's singing live, and these things happen. You go try to do it better. Jeeze...
Albolu 9 months ago
Comment removed
WaterKirin 9 months ago
Comment removed
WaterKirin 9 months ago
I am so upset that american idol treat lady gaga not good every time :( this performance should be better if perform other show!
TheIstano 9 months ago
@TheIstano Lol because it's AI's fault?
inasexymood 9 months ago
the sax was a bit off to the song....but the performance of gaga was great :D
TheVermeercrisostomo 9 months ago
Great performance
nacho0506 9 months ago
@9876qwerty1234 One of the best in the business? Compared to who? Please give me some names of the others in the 'business' she is better than according to you.
inasexymood 9 months ago
@inasexymood i could name some myself, Britney spears, Kesha Katy, perry , madonna ,justin bieber, jenifer lopez ,nicole scherzinger,rihanna And many more , 1. Her Voive sounds better 2.her songs sound better as they are wriiten by herself unlike some of these monkeys , " and her performaces are always amazing And haveing seen nearly all of these live , Lady gaga's monster ball concert was the Damn Best !!
LeebeKing 9 months ago
@LeebeKing I knew it. If those are the first and only names you can come up with, you are comparing piss to poop. Go broaden your musical horizon and come back to teach me about 'the best in the business'.
inasexymood 9 months ago
@inasexymood ,Cher , Mariah carey ,Madonna again , Kylie minogue, whitney houston , beyonce , barbra streisand , chritina agularia ,tina turner ,micheal jackson , i can go on for many hours if you like , Shes as good or better as any one of these people 99% of the time , if you think these or poop then you delusional
LeebeKing 9 months ago
Suck, nothin special on this show.
aamf2u 9 months ago
God, GaGa is GREAT!
Hobott 9 months ago
OMGaga perfeitaaaaaaaaaaaa performance!!! ♥
juhhannah 9 months ago
I love lady gaga this is better than the biebs
Rockinrowie 9 months ago
Her voice is wack as hell. She has no fucking stage presence besides her clothes. Clarence needs to get it together too.
inasexymood 9 months ago
i hate Gaga's dancer
LittleMonsterSubTeam 9 months ago
OMG, Is that really Clarence Clemons? His performance was REALLY bad... What the hell happened?
GaGa was amazing and the idea of the "edge" was awesome. I hope she's ok after that fall lol
craigaffer1 9 months ago
i hate her, but i have to say this live perfomance is awesome, she sounds perfect !!
bunngo94 9 months ago 5
let's kill that sax guy lol
kisamekaulitz 9 months ago
@kisamekaulitz lmao is he clarence clemons???? what the heck happened with him?
JocJav 9 months ago
Love u GAGA! I must be a freak but I think GAGA looks hot in here!-3:)
Bubba2744 9 months ago
i'd really like to see her as a normal person, not as the "something" she is
elvisientosivle 9 months ago
Lady Gaga was DRUNK! #LOL
ChrisWhiteDM 9 months ago
She needs to fire that saxophone player! But than that, flawless performance!
kakumei77 9 months ago 3
her voice is weird and the sax failed. =/
but i like the idea of the apresentation.
rluzz 9 months ago
Como dice ELLEN FANTASTIC!
pokoyoh 9 months ago
Sax fail ANDDD she wasn't singing on point at certain parts.....
CriticKid 9 months ago
Amazing performance, but sax?? \fail
Mauriciopaparazzi 9 months ago 2
Amazing performance...her voice is amazing and the dance is beautiful,however ,the sax was REALLY disappointing! I think she should've just left the backtrack in that part...great performance though...
AngelGaga13 9 months ago
@WarholBitch Mark is gay.
Newreligion100 9 months ago
@Newreligion100 I know. Jeremy Hudson is his boyfriend, right?
I mean as partners in dance.
warholbitch 9 months ago 3
That kiss between her and Mark was awkward
Newreligion100 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
that hat better be in her next music video
silverkenon 9 months ago
@ordepavila Ela se perde um poquinho na parte que vai tocar teclado.
glo5lima 9 months ago
OMG! Is that Mark from SYTYCD Season 4. Love him! I'm glad he's getting jobs. New SYTYCD season coming this thursday, can't wait.
PrincessShinju 9 months ago
That was so freaking awesome!
The sax guy didn't know how to play the solo :/
PinkFairytale17 9 months ago 3
I'll never get over from that end!!!! OMGaga!!!! Who does that?!?! AMAZING!!! And I agree with @100Adalberto I looked like if the guy didn't had air! :S Horrible!!! And she looked a little bit nervous, but AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!
StephiiCrotte 9 months ago
@StephiiCrotte exactly! I thought the same thing
100Adalberto 9 months ago
I was afraid to watch this song's performance. It´s a pretty song and I was afraid it were lost because of the costumes and the weird make up. But i liked it. she is so talented!
MrCuchio 9 months ago
sax = shit! S:
100Adalberto 9 months ago 56
GaGa Perfect ! #PawsUpBornThisWayComeToBrasil *--*
Italogago 9 months ago
The shitty sax player ruined it.
furrycrittr 9 months ago
@furrycrittr yea! i was like "oh no, i think she's tired..." and then the sax part came... *dies*
kisamekaulitz 9 months ago
@kisamekaulitz hahah. it sounded so wimpy and unprofessional. was that not the original player or was he nervous?
furrycrittr 9 months ago
Horrível
tallessouzaaa 9 months ago
@tallessouzaaa igual sua mae neh vagabunda
TheFameKillsXX 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@tallessouzaaa igual sua mae neh vagabunda +1
warholbitch 9 months ago
AWESOME!
wjsrldud12 9 months ago
She doesnt sounds that well, sounds like she wants to cry :'( Maybe cause it was her first performance of the song as it is, and the stiry behind the song and her grandfather :S We love you gaga! Cry! You diserve it! Crying is such an amazing feeling, it's like an orgasm of feelings, most of the feelings get together when you cry, do it Gaga, you'll feel better if you cry. We love you! (:
JoeBrandAG 9 months ago
@JoeBrandAG i agree, although she has performed it before (SNL), it must be difficult to sing without thinking of what inspired it. Ahhh i love her so much!
furrycrittr 9 months ago
BrazilLovesGaga
caamilaparra 9 months ago
The sax fail. :/
glo5lima 9 months ago 46
Sounds just exactly like the studio version. Mr Clemons could be better on the sax, but it didn't blot of the performance.
warholbitch 9 months ago
GAGA + MARK = HOTTEST COUPLE EVER!!!!
warholbitch 9 months ago 4
Is she human? So damn perfect!
warholbitch 9 months ago
não combinou o saxofone
andrecuqui 9 months ago 2
Gaga The Best ♥
HirodelViento 9 months ago
Linda, Arrasou :)
AndriellyAlcantaraMa 9 months ago
droga de saxofonista
narutosask 9 months ago
Perfeito, foda, epico...
narutosask 9 months ago
Arrasooou, gostei muito do fim
iagohenriquee1 9 months ago
muito linda e o dancer sempre tbm né *_*
angelll19 9 months ago
Nossa, estava muito linda *--*
ThierryGhisleri 9 months ago
lindaaaa ahasou perfeita divaaaa
JOSE3585 9 months ago
adorei a perfomance!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
BRAZIL LOVES YOU!!!!!!
s2s2s2s2s2s2s2
play19center 9 months ago