Critics of this clip should check out the real life rescue in "Bondi Beach rescue." In that clip there are REAL lifeguards put under REAL pressure, and making some pretty dreadful mistakes with an unconscious, non-breathing casualty with no pulse. But here's the rub - they save the boy's life. Go figure.
I kinda like this video! :P Its accualty puts down a real situation. I mean your at a beach, you have lifeguards and First Aid, Drunk guy enters water, lifeguard saves, drunk guy goes uncouncious non-breathing, CPR done..!!
@GhostShell2007 Yes, it was staged for a video.. as the description states >.> However, what is wrong with that statement? In a park with more than just lifeguards, aka park rangers and others staff that needs to be informed of a rescue, what else would be a proper statement? "All [park name] units, we have a [activity] off of [stand]" Seems logical to me.
in my experience its a lot easier to sit back watch a video and comment on lifeguard flaws than to do the work your self. many people would be amazed with how many things they get wrong in any scenario. We all have our own protocol and our own reasons behind it. Criticism seems to come far to easy some times.
@ashishkumarsingh007 The current widely-accepted standard is that the search for a victim who has been submerged for less than an hour is considered a rescue; after an hour, it is considered a recovery. The longest documented time someone has been submerged and lived is 46 minutes.
Paaa!!! Cualquiera este video!! La prevencion la hace cuando la "victima" todavía ni se termino de meter al agua, sale a hacer un rescate que no se rescate de que porque la víctima no demuestra estar en peligro, y el segundo guardavidas que entra... sabe nadar? parece que no! Yo todavía no soy Guardavidas pero se que puedo hacer un mejor simulacro que este! No quiero saber en un caso real que pasa... Y me daría verguenza tener un "Lifeguard" con esa preparación
I went to atlantic city. This jerk kept going too far and the lifeguards took there boat out twice. it was sunny and the waves were huge; Then a big wave hit the boat and the lifeguards started drowning. Then 10 lifeguards came and rescued those 2 and the boy LOL.
@1337tiful You and the six people that "thumbed" this comment up are incorrect. I am a lifeguard... LIFE or LIMB. What is protecting the spine going to do if the person ends up dead. I am assuming you are/were Red Cross certified. People have died from procedures in your comment.
bueno.....de a 1 le hace una prevencion cuando la supesta victima esta c el agua en la cintura.... e inmediatamente entra al rescate, sin q la supuesta victima de signos de estar en peligro...desp miren como entra su compañero es un chiste...lo hicieron x internet al curso de guardavidas este video es malisimo tira abajo la labor de los verdaderos Guardavidas!!!!
Ese video es pura porqueria primero q nada ni son salvavidas d vdd pq la victima tiene q ponerce en un lugar seguro y el agua le da en la cabesa lo ahoga mas y la posicion super malisima tmbn no sirveeeeeennnnnnnnnnn..
@capsound123 sooooo wrong. You always suspect spinal. Only if it becomes unsafe for the victim or yourself do you resort to life over limb. Until then, you want to keep their limbs.
from my understanding this is a recreation for a school project where accuracy of lifesaving procedures is not needed but exaggerated for dramatic effect. you can CPR is not actually administered thus the situation was simulated.
Wow, a lot of these lifeguard videos on youtube, even the serious ones, show very flawed procedures and numerous mistakes. This video is no exception.
wwoow. first of all you should have swam out with a starting butterfly stroke... you should have approached with a rear grip because when a guest is suspected to be under the influence they can get rowdy. second of all CPR should be performed 125 feet away from the water. not right next to the tide lines. backboard wasnt needed. and carrying out of water was careless. please dont work at my waterpark :X
These responses are stupid, you can't even tell if they checked for an obstructed airway...which they shouldn't have to to begin with if the first 2 rescue breaths went in. CPR has a higher than 1% of revival if done correctly..though it looked like you had an AED there? You don't need a backboard unless you're suspicious of head or neck injury. Yeah, it wasn't the most accurate video but for a bunch of kids messing around it wasn't bad, you probably shouldn't expect Red Cross quality cinema.
For open water and certain waterpark settings, depending on who you're certified under it is recommended that you use a back board to remove the guest even if you do not suspect a spinal. In such a situation you would not strap the guest to the board or use the head blocks though.
However for the purposes of this video I'm going to assume accuracy was not their first priority, doing their school project was.
Not always. A major factor is the victims age. With an adult the chances of revival are slim to none. But for a child or infant, the chances of revival can actually be fair. Which is why for a child or infant 5 cycles (2 mins) of CPR should be preformed before calling 911 if you are alone and must leave the area. And it's not just about pumping blood. CPR keeps vital organs and the brain alive because of oxygenated blood, simply having blood flow wouldn't do much if its not oxygenated.
so may things wrong with this video! if your going to do it, make sure you do everything the RIGHT way...like checking for spontaneous breathing..and checking for an obstructed airway...and look like you know what your doing..
@wowow545d For Red Cross Waterfront lifeguarding, the backboard would not be used in this situation. I know there's different agencies(Ellis, YMCA, etc.) that may have different techniques, but the reason why there isn't a backboard used is because there was not a spinal injury suspected. If there was, they would have had a group of guards go in and strap him in first.
the reality is unless ur in a pool or a good swimmer in a rip current ur probs gonna be dead if u start drowning anyway and have to be recovered by a LG. I think the lifeguards did well in this educational video. You should remember that it isnt real life anyway so they wouldnt be totally belting it.
Also, you should bring the victim on to dry sand...if he is in full arrest the paramedics will need to hook up a monitor..they aren't going to do it so close to the water!
I wonder if this video is real...how come the secondary guards didn't take their cans? Why did the secondary swimmer wade out...has he never heard of "dolphining"? If the guy went unconscious it probably wasn't from drowning...
since you guys are talking about this can anyone tell what kind swiming styles you need to know to become a lifeguard or anything at all i need to know or what kind of trainig to get i would apriciate any info.
yes dixynormous1 is correct, it was for a project. The person was not actually drunk. Also, cymbalhoss, the staff at this particular lake are very well trained and had other guards watching the water and maintaining the first-aid station :) so what do you guys think about the video its self, my assignment was to tell a story using a single shot
-Dan
(also, any suggestions/requests for future videos?)
Yer mate just upload what you can it would be good to see some more decent raining vids on this site. :D Can I also suggest you try out:- [Pm me for site]there is forums on it and we have a few members from your side of the Atlantic aswell. (Sorry had to put spacesin it or im not allowed to post the comment
It's an inkling that you get, they probably smelt it too, don't forget they may ahve seen him staggering behind the camera. This looks like a setup anyway, like the guy said it was for his video project.
I am a lifeguard too and this is a joke
EIRExPETER 3 months ago
I am a lifeguard / Leisure Manager / RLSS Trainer Assessor.
Suspected spinal injuries and exactly what they are known as - SUSPECTED.
If someone's head is underwater, they are NOT BREATHING.
Priorities for treatment are as follows:
1. Breathing
2. Suspected Spinal Injury
3. Bleeding
4. Bones/Burns
Naturally if you have an arterial bleed, it pushes up in the priorities, but generally the above is right.
Choose life over death - Breathing over spinal.
DarrenHuseyin1 4 months ago in playlist pupurri e videos
This has been flagged as spam show
thumbs up for fake cpr
cottenmouthsnake 6 months ago
Critics of this clip should check out the real life rescue in "Bondi Beach rescue." In that clip there are REAL lifeguards put under REAL pressure, and making some pretty dreadful mistakes with an unconscious, non-breathing casualty with no pulse. But here's the rub - they save the boy's life. Go figure.
thedarg 10 months ago
1337tiful - not only did they SEE what happened, they videod it. Clearly no spinal.
thedarg 10 months ago
WTF..?
Why would you even pull him out of the water?!
supermec131 11 months ago
ale akcja ratownicza, patrzeć nie mogę..............
tutliputli1 11 months ago
aww, I was hoping this would be funny.
bananian 1 year ago
yes let put his head in the water and turn on an AED lol this fail
ace121791 1 year ago
I kinda like this video! :P Its accualty puts down a real situation. I mean your at a beach, you have lifeguards and First Aid, Drunk guy enters water, lifeguard saves, drunk guy goes uncouncious non-breathing, CPR done..!!
I like, Real-Life scneraio..
Lifeguardwwk 1 year ago
Fake lol..
"All units we have a rescue"? lmao!
GhostShell2007 1 year ago
@GhostShell2007 lmfaoo!
Lifeguardwwk 1 year ago
@GhostShell2007 Yes, it was staged for a video.. as the description states >.> However, what is wrong with that statement? In a park with more than just lifeguards, aka park rangers and others staff that needs to be informed of a rescue, what else would be a proper statement? "All [park name] units, we have a [activity] off of [stand]" Seems logical to me.
dangins89 1 year ago
in my experience its a lot easier to sit back watch a video and comment on lifeguard flaws than to do the work your self. many people would be amazed with how many things they get wrong in any scenario. We all have our own protocol and our own reasons behind it. Criticism seems to come far to easy some times.
nlaycox1234 1 year ago
ya lots of stuff wrong with this vid
aldamano9 1 year ago
can anybody says how much time a victim can survive underwater even waters can enter in there total body
ashishkumarsingh007 1 year ago
@ashishkumarsingh007 The current widely-accepted standard is that the search for a victim who has been submerged for less than an hour is considered a rescue; after an hour, it is considered a recovery. The longest documented time someone has been submerged and lived is 46 minutes.
havingfunhere 1 year ago
wow these lifeguards have done so many things wrong lol
kizzie916 1 year ago
Paaa!!! Cualquiera este video!! La prevencion la hace cuando la "victima" todavía ni se termino de meter al agua, sale a hacer un rescate que no se rescate de que porque la víctima no demuestra estar en peligro, y el segundo guardavidas que entra... sabe nadar? parece que no! Yo todavía no soy Guardavidas pero se que puedo hacer un mejor simulacro que este! No quiero saber en un caso real que pasa... Y me daría verguenza tener un "Lifeguard" con esa preparación
MrZ0D14C 1 year ago
FAKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
doareusiduhul 1 year ago
The guy write on comments that:
"This was made in summer 06, It was for a final in my mass media class. we had to tell a story with 1 shot... FUN :D "
And you say it's fake???? What do you want pal, to drown people for you to give exams with real victims???
andr3as5 1 year ago
I hate the wrong information!! In this case the author MUST write on description this :
LIFEGUARD SIMULATION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
doareusiduhul 1 year ago
hahahaha thats entertaining :D
emiy289 2 years ago
I went to atlantic city. This jerk kept going too far and the lifeguards took there boat out twice. it was sunny and the waves were huge; Then a big wave hit the boat and the lifeguards started drowning. Then 10 lifeguards came and rescued those 2 and the boy LOL.
TheTDIKatie 2 years ago
jajaja.. es cualquiera !! ..
no pueden cuidar ni un charquito de agua.
fredyjr07 2 years ago
You always suspect and take procedures of a spinal injury if you did not see what happened
1337tiful 2 years ago 6
correct!
BelgianGeneral 2 years ago 2
@1337tiful You and the six people that "thumbed" this comment up are incorrect. I am a lifeguard... LIFE or LIMB. What is protecting the spine going to do if the person ends up dead. I am assuming you are/were Red Cross certified. People have died from procedures in your comment.
osubuckeyes459 7 months ago
@1337tiful They saw what happened.
DarrenHuseyin1 4 months ago in playlist pupurri e videos
bueno.....de a 1 le hace una prevencion cuando la supesta victima esta c el agua en la cintura.... e inmediatamente entra al rescate, sin q la supuesta victima de signos de estar en peligro...desp miren como entra su compañero es un chiste...lo hicieron x internet al curso de guardavidas este video es malisimo tira abajo la labor de los verdaderos Guardavidas!!!!
keiper20 2 years ago
Ese video es pura porqueria primero q nada ni son salvavidas d vdd pq la victima tiene q ponerce en un lugar seguro y el agua le da en la cabesa lo ahoga mas y la posicion super malisima tmbn no sirveeeeeennnnnnnnnnn..
Finchero18 2 years ago
um no thats not true
u NEVER suspect a spinal injury, LIFE oover LIMBS
capsound123 2 years ago
if they are unconscious and you didnt see it happen, then you have to. Only in an unsafe situation do you risk life over limb
NoPenguinNoMayo 2 years ago 2
@capsound123 sooooo wrong. You always suspect spinal. Only if it becomes unsafe for the victim or yourself do you resort to life over limb. Until then, you want to keep their limbs.
rawrr216 1 year ago
That lifeguard sucks at butterfly stroke.
seigaru830 2 years ago
shes dolphining, its a rescue procedure used in shallow water faster than swimming......
Marcmannugget 2 years ago
mannn
I tough it was real!
sergiokhristian 2 years ago
wow this is an insulting joke....
freedomii6 2 years ago
That "drunk" guy made it pretty far out
Fakespy 2 years ago 2
from my understanding this is a recreation for a school project where accuracy of lifesaving procedures is not needed but exaggerated for dramatic effect. you can CPR is not actually administered thus the situation was simulated.
emmyemmyjojo 2 years ago
fake
a8wsomonoia 2 years ago
LAME!
tis2nwod 2 years ago
Wow, a lot of these lifeguard videos on youtube, even the serious ones, show very flawed procedures and numerous mistakes. This video is no exception.
theWall0719 2 years ago
wwoow. first of all you should have swam out with a starting butterfly stroke... you should have approached with a rear grip because when a guest is suspected to be under the influence they can get rowdy. second of all CPR should be performed 125 feet away from the water. not right next to the tide lines. backboard wasnt needed. and carrying out of water was careless. please dont work at my waterpark :X
nycraze03 2 years ago
These responses are stupid, you can't even tell if they checked for an obstructed airway...which they shouldn't have to to begin with if the first 2 rescue breaths went in. CPR has a higher than 1% of revival if done correctly..though it looked like you had an AED there? You don't need a backboard unless you're suspicious of head or neck injury. Yeah, it wasn't the most accurate video but for a bunch of kids messing around it wasn't bad, you probably shouldn't expect Red Cross quality cinema.
foodstamp73 2 years ago
For open water and certain waterpark settings, depending on who you're certified under it is recommended that you use a back board to remove the guest even if you do not suspect a spinal. In such a situation you would not strap the guest to the board or use the head blocks though.
However for the purposes of this video I'm going to assume accuracy was not their first priority, doing their school project was.
LifeguardGirl28 2 years ago
CPR has like a 1% chance or reviving the patron, all it does is attempt to continue pumping blood.
robsta2008 2 years ago
I heard it was 2%-5% and that's only if the patron has no pulse, in other words is clinically dead.
theWall0719 2 years ago
Not always. A major factor is the victims age. With an adult the chances of revival are slim to none. But for a child or infant, the chances of revival can actually be fair. Which is why for a child or infant 5 cycles (2 mins) of CPR should be preformed before calling 911 if you are alone and must leave the area. And it's not just about pumping blood. CPR keeps vital organs and the brain alive because of oxygenated blood, simply having blood flow wouldn't do much if its not oxygenated.
Canada18 2 years ago
Finally a correct answer!
beachxaddict 2 years ago
TIS SHIT WAS A HOT MESS
narkist123 2 years ago
so may things wrong with this video! if your going to do it, make sure you do everything the RIGHT way...like checking for spontaneous breathing..and checking for an obstructed airway...and look like you know what your doing..
AEDguard 3 years ago
Guys It wasn't correct why did u put the victims head in the water after the rescue?
11501490 3 years ago
when you put the victim down for cpr it helps not to put their head in the water.
stanman733 3 years ago 9
i remember watching the same video in media class when i was in high school. Bunch of my friends did vids.
myactseb 3 years ago
dude CPR ratio now is 30:2 not 15:2
kibal4ish 3 years ago 5
This video was done 2 years ago...
dangins89 3 years ago 2
@dangins89 so wuz ur comment
Jimmy90133 6 months ago
@kibal4ish 15:2 is only for little kids
dannyknaapalmere 3 weeks ago
so this is an actual reality video. its not a set up? am i correct?
Sammy72008 3 years ago
it is a set up.
if it was real they did a horrible job as the lifeguard.
crazy4urheart 3 years ago
Nawnawnaw,
lots of things wrong with this :/
Good for a high school class, though.
I guess.
DevilAshDMC 3 years ago
good although wheres the backboard?
wowow545d 3 years ago
for waterfront lifeguarding, there is no backboard used.
laurrrren 3 years ago
there...is no backboard.
what are you talking about?
smiggedy 2 years ago
What?
laurrrren 2 years ago
@wowow545d For Red Cross Waterfront lifeguarding, the backboard would not be used in this situation. I know there's different agencies(Ellis, YMCA, etc.) that may have different techniques, but the reason why there isn't a backboard used is because there was not a spinal injury suspected. If there was, they would have had a group of guards go in and strap him in first.
laurrrren 1 year ago
Good video...just thought it was kind of funny how she was doing the butterfly to rescue the victim, lol.
ALLtimate17 3 years ago
maybe butterfly is her strongest stroke?
1234jtpm 3 years ago
highschool but yeah :P
dangins89 3 years ago
ok i just realized this was scripted for a college assignment. how disappointing. pretty decent acting though
sweetbabynrs 3 years ago
So fake ... That guy would've been dead with their incredibly slow reaction time.
MZbeautiful66 3 years ago
the reality is unless ur in a pool or a good swimmer in a rip current ur probs gonna be dead if u start drowning anyway and have to be recovered by a LG. I think the lifeguards did well in this educational video. You should remember that it isnt real life anyway so they wouldnt be totally belting it.
dixynormous1 3 years ago
i hope these guys dont have to actually save anyone, the victim would be screwed
1Laxgoalie 3 years ago
lol. no pulse recovery? only a 4% chance of that w/o an AED. try again.
modelswanted007 3 years ago
Why did they put him right by the water?
DEM1571 4 years ago
its a fake lol
its just a trainning
supermanlevrai 4 years ago
Also, you should bring the victim on to dry sand...if he is in full arrest the paramedics will need to hook up a monitor..they aren't going to do it so close to the water!
aintnobodytrippin 4 years ago
I wonder if this video is real...how come the secondary guards didn't take their cans? Why did the secondary swimmer wade out...has he never heard of "dolphining"? If the guy went unconscious it probably wasn't from drowning...
aintnobodytrippin 4 years ago
dude, dolphining is not used by any competent lifeguard!!
its a waste of power!! Kraul or breast stroke is the ting to do
thecrowcsplayer 3 years ago 2
since you guys are talking about this can anyone tell what kind swiming styles you need to know to become a lifeguard or anything at all i need to know or what kind of trainig to get i would apriciate any info.
xhen12 3 years ago
Depends which country...
Definitely Breaststroke and Crawl!
In Germany Backstroke without using the arms.
Butterfly is a waste of energy, as is crawl or breaststorke with head out of the water.
thecrowcsplayer 3 years ago
Thank you!
xhen12 3 years ago
but crawl or breaststroke with head out of the water is essentially for the LG to see and reassure the casualty
dixynormous1 3 years ago
the chest compressions are not deep enough and too fast. they dont look real.
sweetbabynrs 4 years ago
oh yeah, so they should do real chest compressions on a live person should they? thatl help...
dixynormous1 3 years ago
The victim seemed to be swimming strongly when the first lifeguard went out to "save" him. Weird.
TomBrooklyn 4 years ago
whyyyyy would you lay his head near the water?? lol
maggieeex3 4 years ago
Correction Colin RESCUES Mike
dixynormous1 4 years ago
Have you guys seen the 'Colin Versus Mike' video on here? what do you think of it?
dixynormous1 4 years ago
She was probably porpoising, correct me if i'm wrong guys.
dixynormous1 4 years ago
Haha, it looks like the LG is swimming fly toward the start of her swim.
robopaul9 4 years ago
Speaking as a lifeguard, it's a nice training video. As a video maker, a one take, one scene story is tough.
CruzinChris 4 years ago
yes dixynormous1 is correct, it was for a project. The person was not actually drunk. Also, cymbalhoss, the staff at this particular lake are very well trained and had other guards watching the water and maintaining the first-aid station :) so what do you guys think about the video its self, my assignment was to tell a story using a single shot
-Dan
(also, any suggestions/requests for future videos?)
dangins89 4 years ago
Yer mate just upload what you can it would be good to see some more decent raining vids on this site. :D Can I also suggest you try out:- [Pm me for site]there is forums on it and we have a few members from your side of the Atlantic aswell. (Sorry had to put spacesin it or im not allowed to post the comment
dixynormous1 4 years ago
@dangins89 cool project
cmonutube 1 year ago
plus if al guards are on scene who is watching the kids playing marco polo
cymbalhoss 4 years ago
It's an inkling that you get, they probably smelt it too, don't forget they may ahve seen him staggering behind the camera. This looks like a setup anyway, like the guy said it was for his video project.
dixynormous1 4 years ago
how did the life guards know if he had been drinking?
rudly 5 years ago
you learn to read peoples body laguage on the job
cymbalhoss 4 years ago