Added: 3 months ago
From: OnMusicGlee
Views: 744,493
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (688)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She did that bit from Funny Girl in the episdoe where Rachel finds out she's her mom...

  • Oh top two commenters... you and I have to talk about how to make sure the top comments aren't the same...

  • I love Idina Menzel singing lady gaga, she does it so well!

  • This is beautiful ok.

  • lovee ittt

  • if will gay in real life ????

  • so perfect..

  • IF YOU DONT LIKE GLEE OF ANY SONG DONT CLICK ON IT AND HIT THE DISS LIKE BOTTON

    THX EVERYONE WHO LIKES THIS

  • Totley forgot Glee coverd this I saw the link and was like "what and wear was I?" lol

  • gleek+monster=gleekster :)

  • so its a mash up of Lady gaga's song you and i and who is the other singer of you and i?

  • @pokespritemaker3 You and I by Eddie Rabbit...

  • Love this Mash up :3

  • Will and Shelby, way to teach those kids how it's really done!

  • this is true Glee version or fake?

  • @farizzimran887 it is the true Glee version!

  • @farizzimran887 it's true :)

  • I actually prefer this, maybe it's the womans voice because I can't resist it. I'm not a big fan of Gaga (no hate) so that's also a factor, but great song and happy for this cover.

  • Completely forgetting who had sung this with Will, I thought it was April for a second :\

  • @Nedread Idina Menzel, I LOVE HER

  • @Pauulitakeane same she was AMAZING in this and in wicked as elphaba!!

  • I don't think Matthew 's voice is suitable for this song... =.=

  • Im freaked up with the ball -.-

    Btw, I like it

  • Don't get me wrong, I LOVE GLEE. But I don't care for this one... I think it could have been done better.

  • Who sings? AMAZING; BTW

  • @drollloloo Matthew Morrison and Idina Menzel!

  • i dont know where are negative votes here! if u dont like glee dont click the video...Loving glee from Buenos Aires

  • I. WANT. MATT. AND. JAYMA. SING. THIS.

  • If Indina wasn't married I think Matt and Indina would be a really adorable couple

    BUT I WANT HIM WITH JAYMA

  • Shelby is amazing...

  • whit the last 'we made it' its just like rachels voice

  • Fabrizio and Elphaba <3

  • What episode when they sang this song?

  • @Blue72Warrior mash off, its in season 3

  • @Blue72Warrior 3x06

  • i like this,...but who sings the other you and i? i know that one is lady gaga's, but what about the other one?

  • @Raylynn3G

    maybe you are referring to the song of Scorpions - You and I

  • eu amo muito o glee .. principalment o Blaine ....

  • Comment removed

  • who in glee is singing this?

  • @AnUnbrokenHeart34 Idina Menzel and Matthew Morrison.

  • @AnUnbrokenHeart34 Will & Ms. Corekeran or however you spell her name.

  • @AnUnbrokenHeart34 it sound like santana and wiliam no ?

  • @Kassiedf you obviously haven't seen the episode,it is in fact shelby and will who sing this

  • @AnUnbrokenHeart34 Shelby Corcoran (Idina Menzel) and William Shuester (Matthew Morisson)

  • i Love glee <3!!!

    and i love these mashups!!

    These guys are just PERFECT!!!

  • I'm Thai

    and I really like this song by glee

    and original of gaga :D

  • To be honest, a GaGa song is too powerful for a mashup, which ruined this for me.

  • 好怪的歌

  • @victor79121 都说是Lady Gaga的歌了。

  • love tis mash up

  • Best mash up I think !

  • @tavgsr In my opinion the best mash up was Rumour has it/Someone like you. That was just perfect.

  • yeeaaaaaaaaaahhh something about baby you and I wooooooooooo me encanta!!!!

  • I'm a fuckin' little monster♥

  • Nice song! Btw check out my song YOu and I ( Not a lady gaga cover)

  • Honestly, I don't like this cover much....

  • whyyy is idina always singing the lady gaga songs, bahahahahahah

  • @leble123 welp, the writers give them to her

  • they always good for mixing two song and make it mash up!! Love it!!

  • Comment removed

  • Idina Menzel is always singing Lady Gaga on Glee

  • @MrLondon1992 ... she sings 2 songs of Lady Gaga, the rest are from other artists

  • <3 Love matthew Morrisons voice..so hot

  • @rawrgirl1001 maybe his voice, but the rest of him... ew

  • my cool nebraska guy

  •  just me and myself......and I.....

  • i think this is the first gaga song they actually made better....

  • The best song *___*

  • Lo, I will never understand why people who don't like Glee click on the videos....

  • @x0x0sammix0x0 because i heard glee did a cover of you and i and i got really angry.

  • @x0x0sammix0x0 That's simple. Let me explain…

    Hurting other people is one of life's greatest pleasures. Seriously… Sadism is a valid human capacity, just like curiosity, love, or despair. Try tying another person to a sturdy chair. Duct tape is easy. Cut off their clothes off with a knife, and apply 500 small binder clips from your local office supply store. It's an incredibly enjoyable way to spend a few hours.

    And assuming your victim was willing, you'll have a new friend.

  • they ruined the song -.-

  • Nebraska guy is look like a cowboy rockista :))

  • Rachel did absolutely perfect.~ c:

  • @nolegirl41 Rachel didn't sing it... Shelby (Rachel's biological mother) and Will did...

  • @nolegirl41 This isn't Lea Michele ("Rachel")....it's Idina Menzel ("Shelby"). That's why it sounds so good. :)

  • Amo esta y la de lady gaga

    estan las dos a su manera <3

    y eso lo amo <3

  • their voices sound so great together! and the mashup is just perfect !

  • @TwiiSimple auto-tuned voices tend to

  • Yeah ! little monster + Gleek = a perfect combination!

  • ...sorry people, but glee isn't trying to be better than anyone...

  • god this sucks

  • i love shelby voice

  • Unic.Epic.Perfect .

    So little monsters can kiss gleeks asses ...In a way way better than the crazy Lady Gaga :) Live with that...!!!

  • This was amazing. I love You and I from Gaga, and the cover was beyond perfect. Idina Mezel couldn´t have done it better.

    Monsters, calm down. I'm a monster a 100% but you have to admit that the cover was beautiful. And Mathew Morris was great too.

    The cover was beyond perfect. Epic.

  • what a fail cover. nothing beats the original

  • Can all the little monsters please calm down?!?!!? We all know that you need to protect your mother monster, but this is a GLEE song!!!! So can we please refrain from posting comments about how "Gaga is wayyyy better"! No cares who's better, everyone is here to listen to this AMAZING song!!! So please, quit with the comparisons! And for the people saying that Glee is better....you're wrong too! So just stop! ^_^

  • @KKSparklesSimmonz ahgreed

    I love them both, A Little Monster and a Gleek soo....

  • gLee's covers are always so much better than the originals :D

  • NO WAY!!GAGA is WAYY better.ALthough I LOVE the way they combined these two songs ;D

  • Better then Lady Gaga!

  • EPIC !! >_<

  • this is SO incredible! :D

  • i don't really like Gaga's version. so go GLEE

  • GOOD TRY GLEE, BUT, GAGA CAN'T BE IMITATED ;)

  • @BritneySpollo A cover is not an imitation. Run along now.

  • you go glen coco!

  • i love the song and who sing too

    

  • I remember when I first heard this...I love Gaga so much and I wasn't expecting it at all, I spazzed out and knocked over the puppy gate. :) Just a little story of how clumsy I am. <3

  • I like this song better then either of the originals..

  • i didn't know it was a mashup. i thought the title was a typo until i heard the song. great mashup. it blends well. :)

  • I prefer the strong voice of GaGa! But this version is good too :)

  • Beutiful!!

  • Whoa...im pretty sure ive been listening to this for hours and hours. just realized that :D

  • Better than Gaga!!

  • @ROD32ify excuse me? I don't think so :((

  • @ROD32ify disagree, but i love this mashup and idina's voice. XD

  • I didn't even realize this was a mash-up until I looked at the comments on this video. It blends so well!! It really works!!!

  • I just noticed its a mash up but I still LOVE IT <3 <3

  • I actually like this mash-up more than the mash-up of Rumour Has It/Someone Like You though :) GO GLEE

  • Perfect mashup , perfect voices = PERFECT SONG !

  • I love the acoustic version of this song so much!

  • The Lady Gaga version should have been by itself... And don't get me wrong, I LOVE Idina, but no one can cover this song and out sing Gaga...

  • Idina Menzel will always be Maureen from Rent to me but this song still kicks ass! love it!

  • Bleh. They ruined this with the different lyrics in my opinion. Idina still kicked ass (Matt turns me off for whatever reason. :/).

  • I love Glee...I LOve This SonG

  • Prefiro a versão da Lady Gaga , mas essa tb é boa

  • Will is ruining the whole mash up. :(

  • @Erikonable  without Will it wouldn't be a mashup ;)

  • is it normal that when i hear idina sing, i automatically become weak

  • Idena Menzel Rocked this song!!!

  • love it!

  • can someone please tell me who the hell is nebraska?

  • Comment removed

  • @japerrific09 Is a place or city or something like that look in google xD gg well hope it helps

  • @ChevoTheSun92 thanks

  • @japerrific09 It's a state in America:P

  • @japerrific09 Fail xD Nebraska=place.

  • @japerrific09 nebraska is a place lol

  • @japerrific09 Nebraska stands for Gaga's ex, who was from Nebraska (; *

  • @japerrific09 I hope you know its a state in The United States?

    I just have to ask, because you can never know about people on the internet..

  • @japerrific09 she's talking about a guy fromt he state of Nebraska.

  • @japerrific09 a state

  • @japerrific09 Alaska Nebraska from the simpsons :D

  • @dougnick781 are you on crack??? she was not only the original elphaba in wicked, but maureen in rent too... she is a broadway classic.... obviously youre tone deaf

  • @dougnick781 OMG...YOU'R GRAMMAR IS TERRIBLE!!!

  • @dougnick781 really? tell that to the people who gave her a tony.

  • @dougnick781 are you deaf!!!!!! she's a Broadway legend, she has a tony dear. what do you have?

  • Gaga and Glee, my two favorite singers mashed together? Could my day get any better? <3

  • Something about my cool Nebraska guy♥

  • Yeah this is good,but I wish there was a version where it was just Shelby and the other girls from the trouble tones singing GAGA!!!

  • @MrsCathyPotter202 lol totally agree ;)

  • Oooh Shelby's voice is A M A Z I N G!

  • AUGGGGGGGGHHHH

  • Shelby = Elphaba from Wicked. Thats why she is so amazing. <3

  • @MstrMonstar Don't forget Idina Menzel was Maureen in Rent! What a fantastic person....

  • I liked this mash-up! great combo of songs! I like shelby's voice

  • aaaah *-*

    

  • Just two words: AMAZING & EPIC!!!

  • The Female voice is anoying for this song.

  • @jachape1 dont insult Idina Menzel haha she is fantastic

  • @jachape1 R U DUMB NOT IT ISNT SHE IS AWESOME

  • I love Gaga's version, but this one's much better

  • When i heard this song with Lady Gaga i was like: its kind´a okay. And when i heard it on Glee i was like: OMG THIS SONG IS AMAZING!!!!

  • awesome they both are so talented

  • The song Just You and I (that they sing with Lady Gaga's You and I) is the sing my moan ddad danced together for their wedding, ADORABLE! I love this mash up. It is so amazing

  • who sings ?

  • Guys! amazing song

  • Who sings the other You and I, not the lady gaga one? the song mr schue sings at the beginning?

  • @PansyMalfoyParkinson I'm not sure I understand what you are asking. Anyway, in this version the other singer is Idina Menzel (Shelby, mother of Rachel).

  • @PansyMalfoyParkinson Eddie Rabbitt and Crystal Gayle :)

  • Hate the lyric change!!!

  • @beban10 They didn't change the lyrics - it's a mash up of TWO songs called You and I, one is Lady Gaga's and I'm not sure who's the other one is. Ly x

  • i love this mashed up so much! and of course matthew is so damn sexy.

  • Woooo, Nebraska pride. :D

  • I'm srry I don't like her voice

  • <