@TheEnglandWC She would break JJ the Jet Plane, Starspangledbanner and Rocket Man. Canford Cliffs is no longer, and wouldn't have had a chance anyway. Frankel is a beast, but for pure speed, you want the Cav!
We haven't seen a sprinter like her in Australia; she is an unprecedented freak. I'm not sure the comparisons with Frankel are helpful - they are very different horses, racing in different distance ranges. It's like trying to compare the respective entertainment merits of The Wiggles with The Phantom of the Opera! Both are extremely successful in their genre.
Black Caviar is the top sprinter in the world but that's not Frankel's thing despite the fact he had a bunch of Group 1 horse gasping for air after only 3 furlongs in the Newmarket 2000 Guineas. BC was rated number 1 in the world by Timeform before Frankel came along now he is rated 7lbs superior to her. Doesn't take a genius to watch both run and see that Frankel is really exceptional and in a different class.May well be the best since Sea Bird II. Would you say BC is the best since Phar Lap?
When Frankel wins 13 on end, creates weight records and smashes races records at Group1 under handicap conditions, then he can be mentioned in the same manner. Starspanglebanner doesn't even rate in comparision. Having said that, I would like to see her race Rocketman both here in Australia and again overseas. Add Hay List and we would get a good idea how he would rate
To prove Black caviar is the best speed horse, she must race with Rocket and Jet plane, i dnt think caviar can win more then 2 length. And if black caviar win by a head or 1/2length, just prove she is one of the best spinter only, but not the best.
@TheEnglandWC She would break JJ the Jet Plane, Starspangledbanner and Rocket Man. Canford Cliffs is no longer, and wouldn't have had a chance anyway. Frankel is a beast, but for pure speed, you want the Cav!
themightyeythain 1 month ago
@TheEnglandWC jj the jet plane and starspanglebanner are the only ones that are or were sprinters, star is even an Aussie bred horse
BcHorseify 3 months ago
she beats the same old shit
HadleyReisMC 3 months ago
@HadleyReisMC sour grapes?did you back a horse to beat her?haha
scrappy5011 1 month ago
Shes winning but beating no one of note
Verity12ful 3 months ago
she's like the Usain Bolt of horses, lol
april2292 3 months ago
@TheEnglandWC Not a chance!
Jacceb 3 months ago
We haven't seen a sprinter like her in Australia; she is an unprecedented freak. I'm not sure the comparisons with Frankel are helpful - they are very different horses, racing in different distance ranges. It's like trying to compare the respective entertainment merits of The Wiggles with The Phantom of the Opera! Both are extremely successful in their genre.
DeathTaxBlackCaviar 6 months ago 3
Black Caviar is the top sprinter in the world but that's not Frankel's thing despite the fact he had a bunch of Group 1 horse gasping for air after only 3 furlongs in the Newmarket 2000 Guineas. BC was rated number 1 in the world by Timeform before Frankel came along now he is rated 7lbs superior to her. Doesn't take a genius to watch both run and see that Frankel is really exceptional and in a different class.May well be the best since Sea Bird II. Would you say BC is the best since Phar Lap?
FIST2k8 8 months ago
@FIST2k8 Yes, and if not, better.
themightyeythain 1 month ago
When Frankel wins 13 on end, creates weight records and smashes races records at Group1 under handicap conditions, then he can be mentioned in the same manner. Starspanglebanner doesn't even rate in comparision. Having said that, I would like to see her race Rocketman both here in Australia and again overseas. Add Hay List and we would get a good idea how he would rate
wasslic 9 months ago
@TheEnglandWC Maybe Frankel. She is an absolute gun. I think she will be beaten eventually, but she is one of the greats already.
chasersbf 9 months ago
To prove Black caviar is the best speed horse, she must race with Rocket and Jet plane, i dnt think caviar can win more then 2 length. And if black caviar win by a head or 1/2length, just prove she is one of the best spinter only, but not the best.
allthewaykenneth 11 months ago
@allthewaykenneth The Mighty Rocket man can beat her by 1 length .
mohawk548 10 months ago
OMG the scary thing is she seems to be getting better with every run!
Constance861973 11 months ago
@Constance861973 EXACTLY i mean, did you see her 12th race? that was AMAZING!
RuffianQueenOfRacing 10 months ago
@RuffianQueenOfRacing <---------Congenital Liar
mohawk548 9 months ago
@mohawk548 your a dumbass that obviously knows NOTHING about horse racing, so run along now back to your little pony! =P
RuffianQueenOfRacing 9 months ago
Rocket Man, Sacred Kingdom, J J The Jet Plane, One World, Starspanglebanner, you name it? They would all toil in this mare's wake, IMO.
GBeret83 11 months ago