Global Warming Debate: Albert Gore vs Andrew Angus (Part 1)

[bigbrothershark]

i find this very thoughtful

too thoguhtful, maybe enoguh so that al gore himself made this!

what's your aim mr. angus?!

...good video

[andrewanguslive]

Some scientists argue:

X causes Y, therefore, Y causes X.

For example: Heat causes fire, then, fire causes heat.

My counter argument:

Fire is heat. Fire and heat are different forms of the same substance.

Hence, Heat causes fire (by friction) and fire causes heat (by radiation).

Therefore, Y causes Y, therefore, Y causes Y.

[kashphlinktu]

I hate to tell you but in a genuine debate Al Gore would tear you to pieces. Greenhouses are made of glass?? Quick, somebody give this guy the nobel prize! We had no idea! Of course greenhouses are made of glass. That doesn't mean that atmospheric gases can't trap infrared radiation.

[andrewanguslive]

Point 1: Greenhouse acts like a magnifying glass. The heat of sunlight is multiplied by the glass of the greenhouse.

Point 2: Greenhouse traps sunlight. The glass (of greenhouse) absorbs the heat from sunlight .

Hence, the greenhouse is warm during daytime due to glass primarily and not greenhouse gases.

[kashphlinktu]

Angus, you need to take your meds. I am making an educated guess here that you are schizophrenic; I would bet a lot of money that I'm right.

[andrewanguslive]

I am making a scientific guess...

You are a disciple of Hitler Al Gore....

I bet my last dollar that I am right.

he he he!!!!

[G0dsAssassin]

Gobal warming is bullshit, it's a scam to introduce more taxes onto the world. NO real scientists believe it, only bullshit wanabe scientists that go on TV to say it is true, lol what a joke

[musculargods]

You are right.....Al Gore is just trying to enrich himself by spreading global warming crisis hoax. ....

Hurricanes and floodings are natural phenomena that has happened for centuries....even without the car industry in the 1500s.

[G0dsAssassin]

Yes. There is no doubt that the planet is warming up and that the planet is changing but it's not caused from humans. Think about it, trees actually absorb CO2 and store it in their trunks. There is a natural amount of CO2 in the atmosphere and when humans release large quantities of it into the air we breath it does not float into space, if that was the case we would all be dead, it would kill the atmosphere, the trees and plants absorb it..

[goldenchocolate]

hello? andrewangus? I was wondering why you had suddenly stopped replying? I was thinking, "maybe he had a stroke?", but then I see that you're still alive...so, what's your answer? you suddenly stopped trying to prove that what I was saying was wrong, even though I constantly showed you it was

let me guess: you got tired of finding out you're wrong, so you pretend you "forget" to reply to my comment? haha, you pathetic case

[andrewanguslive]

I don't have time to discuss my ideas with people who are not trained in science and obviously a disciple of Hitler Al Gore.

he he he!!!!

[goldenchocolate]

lol andrew, you know as well as I do that that's a bunch of bullshit you just wrote

i simply out-debated you, and now you choose to stop debating. at least have the dignity to admit you might be wrong

[andrewanguslive]

1.

The moon has a daytime and nighttime like earth.

The moon is extremely cold (-150C) during the moon's night time.

The moon is extremely hot (107C) during the moon's day time.

Why is it the moon has a hot climate (107C) when NASA scientists discover there are no greenhouse gases in the moon's thin atmosphere?

The absence of greenhouse gases in the moon's atmosphere is one strong evidence that the greenhouse gases are not responsible for global warming on earth.

[colt45peterson]

the moon doesnt have a atmosphere like the earth's so that is why it is hotter than the earth. the earth's atmosphere repel some of the sun's radiation. duh

[BlueIcesevensix]

Great Video, love it!!!

Yea, it's about, money, control, fear, and power. Al Gore should never ever, have got the Nobel Peace Prize. He's such a joke, he was the same guy that was telling use that Global cooling was real in the 70's. That we better change our ways our we will all die. Fart Tax, yea like he's going to get money from me, the only thing he's going to get is 2 middle fingers in his face. I hope people get tried of him and his lies.

Thank's for informing me on this video.

[catmuses]

Al Gore is such a fraud... Al Gore is just making money out of his fake, alarmist theory of climate change crisis....

When glaciers melt in Arctic, the sea level will not rise since the amount of glacier that melt is just equal to the amount of water coming from the melting glaciers...

Al Gore is such a hoax!

[srvblueslvr]

Nobel Peace Prize is just a liberal award given to liberal issue activists. It has nothing to do with brilliant ideas that affect a positive change. Its been diminished by liberals and is used to promote in Al Gore's case.....a scam on the American people.

Kind of like the Miss USA pageant being reduced to a bunch of liberals pushing a homosexual agenda. Its not about the pageant its about the AGENDA.

Good Job Andrew

[andrewanguslive]

I do not understand why Norway gave the Nobel Prize for Peace to Hitler Al Gore when 30,000 scientists ( Oregon Petition) oppose the theory of humans cause global warming while only 3,000 UN-IPCCscientists supported theory of humans cause global warming.

[andrewanguslive]

Al Gore's war on carbon dioxide is pure insanity. LOL!!!!

[DavoT2]

Is it a fact that CO2 slows down radiation escape, thus retaining heat within the atmosphere?

[andrewanguslive]

Yes, CO2 slows down radiation escape. However, the heat of radiation is transformed into a different form of energy.

Gases like CO2 absorb infrared radiation and turns this radiation into "lift energy".

This is called the "Law of Conservation of Energy".

So, we don't have to worry about CO2 and other greenhouse gases.

Al Gore, Rajendra Pachauri and the IPCC scientists do not understand the "Law of Conservation of Energy". Ha ha ha!!!

[DavoT2]

So "lift energy" doesn't increase temps at all?

I thought that the reason we have our temps is because the atmopshere is one of the climate mechanisms, ie, the delay in the escape of radiation was what caused both weather and the average global temp.....?

[andrewanguslive]

The "lift energy" of gases is what makes gases rise up.

There is no increase in temperature when gases transform heat radiation into "lift energy".

In effect, gases helped reduce the heat in the atmosphere.

The ave day temp of the moon is 107C.

The ave day tem of earth is 14C.

The moon has a very thin atmosphere.

The earth has a very thick atmosphere.

The thick atmosphere of earth explains why the earth has a cooler climate compared to the hot climate of the moon!

[DavoT2]

I'll have to do more reading on the subject.....thanks for your input.

[maer069]

No mames que video tan más idiota y con falta de fundamentos del que hizó este video. Bueno un cordial vete a la verga el que hizó este video.

That video so but idiot and without foundations.

[andrewanguslive]

The US or NASA must send Al Gore to the moon so that Al Gore will see that the moon's hot climate is not caused by carbon dioxide.

[goldenchocolate]

um, no intelligent scientist such as Al Gore has ever said that the moon's temperature is caused by CO2. It's caused by the lack of CO2.

[andrewanguslive]

Al Gore claims that co2 is causing global warming......

2000 IPCC scientist claimed that CO2 is causing global warming.

Al Gore claims that humans are causing global warming by way of CO2...(anthropogenic theory of global warming).

It seems to me that you have not read Hitler Gore's book.

[goldenchocolate]

i already knew that...

and no, I haven't read his book, but I have read about him and his ideas

and the very fact that you compare hitler (do you even know what he did?) to a peace nobel prize winning man such as al gore is simply unbelievable...and every single person to whom I've told about you and your gore-hitler ideas has said the same thing...

[andrewanguslive]

Even Adolph Hitler was nominated with a Nobel Prize for Peace when the documentary film about Hitler won a German Film Prize.

You just do not know how dangerous Al Gore is..... What the Bible said: The devil will appear as an angel of light.

Do you know who led the anti-air pollution laws in Europe?

Answer: Adolph Hitler.

The similarity between Al Gore and Adolph Hitler is too amazing to be ignored!

[goldenchocolate]

yeah, sure, al gore has killed millions of people, and tried to ceate 1 single race on earth, thereby promoting racism and violence -_-'

and sure, believe the bible...something written thousands of years ago by plenty of different people over different times, many times mistranslated and censured, that contains tons of contradictions and completely false information

no wonder you're against global warming

[andrewanguslive]

Hitler killed million jews when he assumed President (Fuehrer) of Germany even though Hitler was never elected as President.

Al Gore will surely kill millions if Al Gore becomes President.

If you do not pay your taxes if you fart, then you will be placed in concentration camps...

Farting is not allowed by Al Gore!

'He he he!!!!

[goldenchocolate]

are you fucking serious? I seriously hope you're sarcastic or joking, or else you have a serious problem with knowing what is real and what is not

[andrewanguslive]

Fart is carbon dioxide....

Al Gore will tax your fart by way of CARBON TAX!

If you cannot pay your carbon tax, then do not fart.

If you fart, Al Gore will demand that you pay carbon tax or "FART TAX" !!!!

[goldenchocolate]

yes, farts do let out a very small bit of CO2, but human farting is responsible for such a small part that it can be easily ignored. The main contributors are industries and vehicles. And, to a smaller extent, cows, since all of them together, farting, creates a noticeable amount of CO2

[andrewanguslive]

Humans outnumber cattle....

So, humans contribute more fart than cattle.

Al Gore is the greatest farter on earth...

And so Al Gore is the greatest contributor of carbon dioxide on planet earth. (Ha ha ha!!!!)

[goldenchocolate]

yes but cow farts let out quite a bit more CO2

and yeah, sure, Al Gore contributes the most to global warming (sarcastic)

and yeah, fart jokes sure are funny (again, sarcastic)

[andrewanguslive]

Fact 1: The greenhouse is only warmer inside during daytime when the sun is present.

Fact 2: The greenhouse is cool inside during nightime when the sun is not present.

Hence, the source of heat inside the greenhouse is really sunlight and not the gas CO2.

In other words, the trapped heat inside the greenhouse is NOT PERMANENT because heat is only trapped as long as sunlight penetrates the greenhouse!!!

This is one fact that IPCC scientists do not know.

[ellonche]

"global warming" is a SCAM.

& Al Gore is HITLER

[goldenchocolate]

sorry, but all these arguments against global warming are general and non-precise. Why is globalwarming able to give me actual numbers with proof? Because global warming is the truth, and anti-global warming is just seeking an excuse for another useless conspiracy and keep selfishly using a hummer for going from the dining room to the kitchen...

damn redneck republicans

[andrewanguslive]

Here some facts:

a. earth's average day temperature is 14C

b. moon's average day temp is 107C

Question: What is causing the high temperature of the moon at 107 C when there are no factories and cars on the moon?

Answer: The CO2 is NOT CAUSING the high temperature in the moon. It is SUNLIGHT that is causing high temp of the moon.

The same is true for planet earth...

CO2 is not causing global warming.on earth...

It is sunlight that is causing global warming on earth!

[goldenchocolate]

if that were true, earth would have a higher temperature

and it's the rate of increased temperature that indicates unusual climate change

and I'm not the one to ask, as I know very little about the moon, but I'm willing to bet that there are explanations related to the composition of the moon and the way it retains solar heat

[andrewanguslive]

Research on wikipedia on the topic of MOON. Scientists discovered that the moon's average day temp is 107 C while the earth's average day temp is only 14 C.

And yet, there are no factories and cars in the moon..... No carbon dioxide producers in the moon...

The moon has a thin atmosphere... The earth has a thick atmosphere of around 50 miles in height .....

The idea that CO2 is causing global warming on earth is simply erroneous as revealed by the conditions in the moon.

[goldenchocolate]

wikipedia!? you get ur info from WIKIPEDIA!? Guess what; I get my proof of global warming from BBC, National Geographic, Scientific american, etc. Not from user (users such as yourself) created content.

btw, the Moon doesn't have an atmosphere to absorb sunlight like the Earth does, and so the surface gets very hot during the day, and very cold during the night.

MORON!!!

[andrewanguslive]

Wikipedia gets its source from both reliable contributors (NASA, Scientific American, etc. ) and non-reliable contributors....(Al Gore, and you, etc.)

Your logic (Moon has no atmosphere to absorb sunlight....) implies that the earth's atmosphere absorbs sunlight to COOL the earth. (ha ha ha!!!! )

If the earth has no atmosphere or has a very thin atmosphere, then the earth will have a hot temperture of 107 C like the moon....

YOU ARE INDEED a MORON....

[goldenchocolate]

yea, but the fact that it receives contribution from non-reliable people makes it an unreliable source

As for the temperature thing, it's only during the day that the surface temperature of the moon that is so warm, and that makes sense since there's almost no atmosphere to absorb it the sunlight!

The earth's thick atmosphere absorbs more sunlicht, so the surface temperature doesn't heat up as much. BUT, the very same atmosphere keeps the heat from escaping at night, so its not as cold

[andrewanguslive]

I. Again, your logic implies:

a. the atmosphere absorbs sunlight to COOL the earth from sunlight's temp of 107C down to earth temp of 14C.

Without the earth's atmosphere, we will be "fried humans" at 107C like in the moon.

II. Moon Atmosphere

NASA scientists reveal that the moon has a thin atmosphere called "LUNAR Atmosphere" ...

Research at nasa . gov / worldbook

Then, click: Moon.

[goldenchocolate]

for point a, what's wrong with that logic? It's the truth...just because you think it's not how it should work, doesn't mean it isn't.

Yes, there is an atmosphere, but it is so small that it could easily be neglected. Anyway, because the atmosphere is so small, it absorbs almost none of the heat produced by the sun

[andrewanguslive]

I. Your logic contradicts your claim

a. YOur claim: CO2 causes global warming or accelerates global warming

b. Your logic: Earth's atmosphere absorbs heat of sunlight to COOL the earth. The earth atmosphere reduces the heat of sunlight!

Therefore, CO2 does not warm the earth. It is still sunlight that warms the earth.

[goldenchocolate]

actually, that's not my claim. My claim is that CO2 prevents the earth from heating up to extreme temeperatures during the day, but it also traps heat inside the atmosphere, which is why it doesn't just get cold during the night. The problem is, there is more and more CO2, so more and more heat gets trapped.

And you forget that global warming is very little, but it's that even a little change in temp can cause huge problems (6°C warmer could be enough to wipe out humanity)

[andrewanguslive]

Liquids and gases behave differently...

When liquids absorb heat, the liquid becomes hot.

When gases absorb heat, the gas becomes cool !!!!

This property of gas  is called "endothermic property" .

Hence, gases like CO2 does not warm the earth. Gases like CO2 cools the earth...

[goldenchocolate]

that explains why air becomes colder when you climb up in altitude.

But as I said before, the heat that still goes to earth remains the same, and is then trapped, and there is more and more, which makes the earth warm up (again - not by a lot, but the slightest change in global temp can have drastic effects on earth and the environment).

[andrewanguslive]

The earth radiates heat when it travels around the sun.

Earth absorbs heat from sun's sunlight.

Earth releases heat when it travels around the sun.

Heat in = Heat out

Heat absorbed = Heat released.

The heat is not totally trapped inside the earth. The earth releases heat when it travels around the sun.

This is one fact that environmentalists do not know.

[goldenchocolate]

it does release heat, simply not all of it, and less and less is released

[andrewanguslive]

Your new claim: The planet earth is releasing les and less heat is another claim that is purely hypothetical....

Your first claim: 'CO2 warms the earth' is already demolished by YOUR OWN LOGIC.

Hence, Pachauri, Al Gore and the 2000 IPCC scientists are deceiving mankind with their "CO2 warms the earth" hypothesis.

[goldenchocolate]

how does my own logic demolish this claim? its not hypothetical; ever heard of GREENHOUSE EFFECT?

And I'm sorry if I have an easier time believing noble-prize winning people like Al Gore than some filipeno man who spends his whole time trying to convince youtube users that he, a man who gets his info from wikipedia, is smarter than these scientists.

and the reason it releases less and less is because of more and more CO2 (which traps the heat inside)

[andrewanguslive]

Greenhouse effect is a fallacy...

"Greenhouse effect" was coined by scientists who don't understand the "endothermic" property of gases.

The inside of a greenhouse is hotter than the outside of the greenhouse.

Why? Because the gas particles bump the solid glass of the greenhouse. But, the earth is not encircled by solid glass!!!

Take note: CO2 and gases (water vapor) can escape out or leak out of the earth !!!

This is another fact that Nobel Prize scientists do not know.

[goldenchocolate]

it's hot because the heat is stuck inside, NOT BECAUSE THE GLASS BECOMES WARM YOU TARD

[andrewanguslive]

Solids and gases behave differently.....

When solid (like glass) absorb heat, the solid becomes hot.

When gas (like CO2) absorb heat, the gas becomes cool. (like the atmosphere)

Solids react by exothermic process.

Gases react by endothermic process.

When gas bumps solid glass, the gas transfers the heat to solid glass and so the solid glass becomes hot.

This is another fact that Nobel Prize scientists do not know !!! ( ha ha ha ha)

[goldenchocolate]

you actually think they don't know about it?

the point is: what difference does the temperature of the glass or gas make when you're talking about how HEAT GETS TRAPPED INSIDE!!!

[andrewanguslive]

Fact 1: The greenhouse does not rotate on its axis.....

Fact 2: The planet earth rotates on its axis.....

Fact 3: When the planet earth rotates, the planet earths releases heat!!!!!!!

Fact 4: The greenhouse does not rotate on its axis, so, the greenhouse does not release heat !!!!!!!

This is one fact that IPCC scientists do not know! (he he he)

[goldenchocolate]

omfg, you simply don't understand how greehouse works, do you?

IT'S NOT THE GREEHOUSE GASES THEMSELVES THAT GENERATE HEAT!!!

and your logic is extremely childish. it's like saying that just because I'm pouring water in a bucket, automatically the only source of water in the bucket is me (when it could very well be someone else pouring water, rain, etc.)

and do you really think the IPCC scientists are dumber than you? seriously...

[andrewanguslive]

You don't understand how greenhouse works, obviously...

Your claims keep on changing...

Your NEW CLAIM "It is not greenhouse gases that generate heat"..

You are contradicting your FIRST CLAIM that CO2 accelerates global warming.

IPCC scientists are not all-knowing.

IPCC scientists made many errors in analysis.

Your claims are contradictory.

[andrewanguslive]

Your first claim: CO2 causes global warming.

Your new claim: CO2 does not generate heat....

Your claims are contradictdory.

Your claims are changing.....

These "all-knowing" scientists keep on changing their claims in order to justify their secret agenda to destroy the economy of oil-rich countries like Russia..... in the guise of protecting earth.....

ha ha ha...

[goldenchocolate]

omg, you don't read, do you?

CO2 warms up the earth INDIRECTLY. CO2 doesn't make the earth warm, it's the fact that it traps sun heat inside the atmosphere more and more, warming up the earth!!!

[andrewanguslive]

Omg..... Your claims keep on changing..

Claim 1: CO2 warms the planet earth..

Claim 2: CO2 accelerates global warming.

Claim 3: CO2 and greenhouses gases do not generate heat...

Claim 4: CO2 and greenhouse gases WARMS the earth INDIRECTLY by trapping the heat!

Stick to ONE CLAIM. You are contradicting yourself by making so many different claims.

What is your final claim? Claim 1, 2, 3, or 4?

[goldenchocolate]

actually, I never claimed those things, I simply wasn't very clear

I have always thought claim number 4, but claim 1, 2 and 3 are still true (but they do it indirectly).

[andrewanguslive]

Claim 1 is wrong since the sun is the primary source of heat on earth.

Claim 2 is wrong. Why? The atmosphere (water vapor and CO2) reduces the heat of sunlight as seen in lunar conditions.

Claim 3 is right. CO2 per se, do not generate heat.

Claim 4 is wrong. Why? My reply: CO2 COOLS the earth by trapping heat.

CO2 is like "FREON".

FREON absorbs or traps heat to cool the inside of the Refrigerator.

Al Gore and Rajendra Pachauri are demolished by my freon analysis.

[goldenchocolate]

yes, the isolating heat inside is true, but since the heat trapped inside is actually warm, a lot of the heat gets trapped inside (but in a frigde, it's cold air that's stuck inside -- how do you think a thermos keeps cold stuff cold and hot stuff hot?)

and unless you actually had a debate with Al Gore, you can't say your argument demolishes him or even call your video "debate: Albert Gore..."

[andrewanguslive]

Heat is trapped in greenhouse in three ways:

a. glass absorbs heat (exothermic process)

b. CO2 absorbs heat (endothermic

process) like freon.

c. glass also magnifies heat of sunlight like a "magnifying glass".

Hence, the trapped warmth/heat in greenhouse is really caused by glass (and not CO2 as many physicists and chemists think).

[goldenchocolate]

yeah, in greenhouses on earth, it,s caused by glass, but in this case, it's simply that CO2 blocks part of the heat (which explains why the earth isn't warm like the moon AND why warmth gets trapped inside the atmosphere)

and you didnt answer me concerning that debating al gore thing...

[andrewanguslive]

The debate between Al Gore and Andrew Angus is pure fiction. The debate is based on Al Gore's books and Andrew Angus's ideas.

Since Al Gore refuse to debate with other scientists like Fred Singer, I decided to make a video about a fictitious global warming debate to let the viewers of youtube see the serious errors of Al Gore's books.

[editor67]

Al Gore blames farmers for global warming. in his book....

Al Gore is insane....

[Hahahaahaaaa]

Funny one ;) What about the Ozone hole? And what about deforestation?

[andrewanguslive]

I am planning to release Part 2 of this Global Warming Debate between Al Gore Hitler and Andrew Angus

[Hahahaahaaaa]

What about the Ozone hole? And what about deforestation?

[JonThm]

We can fuse H2O, t ogive He, O anda lot of heat. By adding turbulence to high pressure water or steam.

[skylofts]

You might want to see environmentalchemistry(dot)com­/yogi/environmental/200611CO2g­lobalwarming(dot)html as to the role of CO2 and global warming!

[andrewanguslive]

I read the article of Roberta Barbala....

Carbon dioxide is not a problem......

Why?

Carbon dioxide becomes glacier if carbon dioxide reaches the polar region whether North Pole or South Pole!

This is fact that chemists and physicists failed to account in their analysis of the environment.

[skylofts]

According to the Secretary of Energy Steven Chu who is a Nobel-prize-winning physicist said California's farms and vineyards could vanish by the end of the century, and its major cities could be in jeopardy, if Americans do not act to slow the advance of global warming!

[andrewanguslive]

NOBEL Prize laureates are not all-knowing....If they win a Nobel Prize in physics , it is because of a "special knowledge" in physics and not their "general knowledge" in physics.

[FinkFonkFunkaal]

I like it also.

Thanks for taking a look at my global warming in 17 seconds.

I also looked at your web sites. Very nice!

It's you and people like you that know the written word is most powerful. Poetry, Novels and Short Stories that's where it all happens.

Best Always - FinkFonkFunkaal

[al2683]

I like it man, I'm right there with you on this.