Ryan Starr - If You Really Love Me

[elomasami]

She sould have went into fashion....Should would have been a great designer

[gatarharo]

3:13 awful sound!!!!!!

[gatarharo]

back then the talent wasnt that great but compared to everyone in this competition she didnt do bad ..but too me she sucked

[Meteorfreak101]

hahaha the outfit! cracking me up

[undeniablynikki]

Compared to this season's talent she's weak.

[mermaidofsuburbia]

I'll never understand what on earth she thought was sexy about tying bows on your arms. Seriously weird fashion sense.

[hardheadedidiot87]

@mermaidofsuburbia One word.... Aerosmith

[seventeenboi]

slut

[murderousbastard83]

She was a total babe and nothing else. Her voice was weaker than an old man with arthritis.

[MobHeataEnt]

Who the hell watches American Idol now without Paula and Simon, especially Simon.

[beaton10]

She may just have the best abs ever. lol

[mediblue9]

@beaton10 Umm! no abs, just tone

[beaton10]

@mediblue9 Yeah abs was the wrong word, I did mean her stomach is perfectly toned, like you rightly said

[meganlovescameron]

shes my cousin <3

[beaton10]

@meganlovescameron Seriously?!

[x3xRockStarrx3x]

whooo this was horrible... i'm going to get so many thumb downs

[TenaciousC21]

She is really pretty with an awesome body, an OK voice...and well, her fashion....eh. But then again, back then, you had to make due and she made her own clothes I believe. But she wasn't the worst singer, I will admit that!

[eagle1oz]

Ryan Starr hsa the most ultimately perfct voice of an angel. She has the most ultimately perfect cover girl fashion model perfect body, perfect face, perfect hair, and her own designed absolutely perfect outfit.

[Picardy]

Crack whores on ice

[MrCrayonInk95]

Shes a total slut. You got one chance to be the next amazing singer and she goes out and expects people to vote for her because she wears the least clothing possible

[RCmack]

I didn't watch American Idol during season 1. I didn't know about Ryan Starr back then.

After seeing her perform, I wish I had watched Idol's first season. I would have been on the phone for hours voting for Ryan.

[pinkycheeks]

for some reason i hate when they sings songs that i don't know.

[OkTheGroupTherapy]

OMG memories!! Idol used to be great.. Now it's horrible.

[RCmack]

@OkTheGroupTherapy Idol is worse this season, that's for sure.

Lilly Scott, Lacey Brown, and Alex Lambert were voted off way, way too early. It's too bad Idol didn't bring back Ryan Starr, Nikki McKibbin, Diana DeGarmo, and Kelly Clarkson this season. Each of them could have been a mentor to this year's contestants.

[footdesperado1]

yuucckkkk!

[STLUCIANIDOL91]

I've just noticed how goofy and lovable she can be...

I can be so prejudice; I'd just assumed that a girl who looked as commercial as she does would have bad attitude.

[ReneeNme]

Ryan has such a wonderful and controlled vibrato....Love that voice. Yes she is hot...So damned what ???

[Brd0320]

They dressed so trashy then.

[ReneeNme]

Whatever.

[955pokerface]

@Brd0320

it was her style

[wildfiretgh]

Wtf is wrong with people? She was terrible.. especially this performance. She was always a pretty face and a nice body.. that's about it. She lost herself in the melody and you could barely hear her.. and she was flat a lot. She was horrible lol.

[DiimplesAcapella27]

i think this wasnt that bad i like her voice.

[curlingiron7658]

Beginning was good, middle was horrible, end was really whiny...

[Neurosurgeryfuture]

first part was ok. When it speeds up, absolutly awful. Overall, i need painkillers now.

[aliceayrescloser]

I liked it. I think it was her only good perfomance!

[spoilermdc]

i would marry ryan tomorow.

[SuperPanetone]

amazing, damn u nikki mckibin :S

[lynbetty]

Cannot sing whatsoever - just kinda yells - but damn she is ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS!!

[ilovebellies2]

beautiful woman, great singer, and sexy beautiful bellybutton!! love your bellyshirts!!!!

[ourhiddenagenda08]

if i had a bod like that id be showing it off.... she has a great voice ... if you dont like watching her close your eyes an fucking listen

[280GabbrieLaNigga280]

ya is on crack it wasnt that bad.

you guys are hating cuase shes

gorgeous.

i mean shes no mariah carey.

but that was pretty good.

[xox07xox]

wtf is wrong with you ppl???

I think that was good

[dovebar76]

I hated it! No wonder why she was on The Surreal Life! She's crap! All she's got going for her is all that flesh she's always showing.

[andrew448888]

OMG that was pretty bad.

The Toya Alexis version WAS SOOOOO GOOOD!!!

[maraesa1000]

i think the horrible, slutty outfit spoiled a great performance.

[rockstAr31595]

Does she know how to wear anything not baring midriff?? Whatever, she isnt famous anymore anyways

[NYChica23]

Judging by Ryan and Nikki's wardrobe choices, showing as much skin as possible was the trend on season 1

[jsteezie420]

They dressed slutty in the first season

[BlingyDamon3]

yeah they really did, it was strange seeing that on american idol rewind and being like "where the hell are their clothes?!"

[Pablitchus]

Me gustó su presentación es muy buena. y ver que es de la primera temporada y yo recién me entero ^.^!!!

[100percentyobo]

Wow. Totally butchered a Stevie Wonder classic. She's pretty but singing is not her thing. What's up with all the strings she tied to her arms?

[ChrisMarquetteslover]

She is the BEST American Idol contestant!!!! The only other 1 is Amanda Overymyer.

[FootFly2]

Everyone who takes on a Stevie Wonder song has curage..its brave !!

[Getabrainfool]

uh, actually yes she is a model for Hot Topic.

[sydharp5]

Whoooooops,i just saw a video on here where shes modeling for Hot Topic,so i was wrong..I just wasn't aware of it..but shes never done VS.

[rachxann12]

she's not horrible, although that outfit is.

[laurelcarryyyy]

good voice,

discusting outfit

[melissawells]

pretty but not enough talent

[loirinhobeautiful]

Very Good!!!

[pointsandusky]

I believe this girl is modeling for Victoria's Secret now. Much better career choice I must say!

[swimminsccrbabe]

she models for hot topic too

[sydharp5]

She's never done Victorias secret or Hot Topic,She did Ed Hardy.

But yeah,I think she'll have great success modeling.

[idolcritique]

Absolutely !

[ktoret]

fuck her singing sucks she looks not bad eliot yamin put her dogy style when he sang that song

[MusicGuru12]

She is not good looking; she is not a good singer... Bad rendition of the song.

[KatzaPlayer]

PLAYBOY YES, AMERICAN IDOL NO.

[idolcritique]

Hahahahahahahaha !!! Well said !! ;)

[KatzaPlayer]

PLAYBOY YES, AMERICAN IDOL NO.

[lilmo3488]

talentLESS

just proves that looks can get you very far in this country

[kkkirschen]

unbelievably pretty

[stitchmorg]

@kkkirschen yea id hit it too

[ldfjkg]

Ryan Starr has one of the cutest noses in Hollywood!

[ConfessionalRose]

You guys are gay...she was the best singer in the first season and if she wouldnt had such bad song choices I bet she woulda beat kelly. BTW the first season had the most badass dressers...they look like true pop princesses.

[NYChica23]

I don't think she was the best singer out of all of the contestants. Kelly, Tamyra, Christina, and RJ are all superior in terms of vocal ability

[Stormiya]

How was RJ superior? His vocal range was distincly average (he has improved since) Christina wasn't much stronger then Ryan (She was my second favorite and I love her, I think she's unique but bu her voice was very thin.) Not dissing just don't get your logic when you say Superior in vocal ability

[idolcritique]

I would have to bring that down to Kelly and Tamyra in terms of superior vocal ability. Rest were just plain mediocre !

[itsmeanthony]

She look's good but i don't like her singing :)

[bunch39]

C thats how it is now a day it matter what u sound like its what u look like sooooooooo sad.

[tashoney]

always love the original covers...this was shitty work...

[momoshun]

what the hell is she wearing? Slutty much?

[Fredthedrummer21]

yea.. shes hot though... christ.

[drewfus1984]

she sings out of her nose and sounds like she has a snot bubble in the back of her throat-also kinda sounds manly-but she is hot

[Fredthedrummer21]

nice tits, I have to say.

[coolipop]

shes my all time favorite

[Lancerboi1986]

I really liked her...She was an early favorite from her round...round 1 I think. Itunes downloads don't really mean that much though...Everyone owns Kellys albums and singles, and they are on the radio...the only way to hear Ryans singles is to download them...that is why she has the most.

[TommyGDub]

She kind've reminds me of Cher...

[majesticstar]

the worst idol contestant ever in the history of idol william hung was a better candidate

[o0ber]

I always found her voice really wierd but I really liked her.

[masinindy]

She is middle of the road as far as American Idol singers go.

But, DAMN, she is arguably the hottest woman ever on American Idol, with Christina Christian being a close second!

[Kells87]

Honestly...if you compare her to the contenders that are on the show NOW...she would have kicked ass. She was way out of her league with Kelly and the others of the first season, but today, she'd do far better.

[peterparker32]

It was painful to hear her try hit the high notes. Like listening to nails scratching a chalk board.

And Ryan and the other dude look like a happy item. Thankfully, the producers decided only one person to host the show. Hahahahaha...

[AnacondaS1996]

Yes - she's very attractive and likely the reason why she made it as far as she did. Try listening to the audio with your eyes closed and tell me if you'd truly voter for her. I wouldn't.

[Jordishness]

Ryan made it through on her vocal ability. Haters are seriously jealous or just mean. She's great. Why hate?

[CheeesyFish]

The first season of AI had such terribly low standards. If anything, Ryan just made it through because of her body and clothes. Jeees.

[SgtSmax345]

Elliott Who? Ryan is AWESOME!!!!

[elysnow]

terrible.

[TSLeilaniMya]

Stevie's music doesn't really fit her voice or even style but she can sing and she is very talented!

[marquise2005]

This is one of the worst Idol performances ever! She is such a horrible singer! Go see either Elliot Yamin or Toya Alexis sing this song if you wanna hear some true singing!

[MinsiKid]

I absolutely freaking loved Ryan Starr

[charmed06]

why u gotta hate? I don't get how people like one or the other. I don't do itunes. I love both, but kelly is awesome! And she is pretty, ur blind! Yes, she can, she got all the way, w all the judges, and got praise EVERYTIME, no1 else has, plus second in WORLD idol.

[scrubs023]

ryan may have the most iTunes downloads but kelly has the most album sales

[AceOfHearts]

dont forget, according to like wikipedia and usa today,

RYAN STARR has sold the most downloads in iTunes out of all the american idols. and shes sold the most exclusive single downloads in iTunes..EVER!

[CoreyIversen]

Kelly isn't the only Idol Winner still with a career, considering Carrie Underwood is the most successful Idol Winner to date.

[tributevocalist]

Carrie Underwood rocks!! :)

[perfectestperson]

No, Carrie Underwood isn't. She is very successful, but Kelly has sold more than double the amount of CD's as her.

[Ghettosexy11]

keely is a super star with grammys and countless other awardsshe the only american idol that recived the most success and her albums sells equaily to mariah.

u cant knoc kelly she's doing it real big

[hpsimsoap92]

actually tamyra gray should of won. her first name isn't ryan it's tiffany. I loved ryan she was one of my favorites. if you really watched season you would know that kelly was ugly and couldn't sing :)

[thedustoflife]

Kelly is a beautiful woman, and if she can't sing, how come she's the only Idol winner who still has a successful career?

[McDuffie]

Shut up fucking bitch. Tamyra sucks at making music.

[iLoveCarlton]

No, she shouldn't of won. Kelly deserved to win.

[ExoticHawaiian4U]

OMG I LOVE HER SHE REMINDS ME OF A MODERN VERSION OF TAYLOR DAYNE SHE SHOULD HAVE WON!

[rylicious]

I like her because we share the same first name :-) but I also think Elliott was sooooo much better.

[babolo]

HEr first name is Tiffany.

[CoreyIversen]

Elliott is obviously better than her, but she eaasily sang this song MUCH better than Elliott did.

[FilipinoAllStar]

But she is much hotter than him haha

[FilipinoAllStar]

yikes....her voice is everywhere..

Elliot Yamin did it better

[AceOfHearts]

one of the best american idol performers! i love ryan starr!!!