nice but choppy, somewhat like trying to play a 'lickbyneck' arrangement....jerky, and staccato where it shouldn't be......a chord for every note is not wanted at the expense of a rhythmic jazzy feel
Very weak and revealing criticism on the part of musicluvingguy. There is no "luv" in his commentary. This seems to be criticism from someone who is projecting their own frustrations into your amazing music; hence the foolish and snobby comments. At this level of musicianship a "rhythmic jazz feel" is not mandated. Adjectives like "jerky" and "choppy" are very suggesting of personal battles. I wish him the best like the rest of us. You are outstanding and thank you for your interpretation!
I think his harmony is very rich and colorful. Very nice voice leading. Also a very delicate delivery which is appropriate for this piece. Have you by chance uploaded your version of this classic tune? I would love to compare your arrangement against this one.
Thank you very much. I play guitar it's been 20 years, but I used to play rock'n'roll (only). I've been studying jazz for 4 years now. I quit playing rock and now my only concern is jazz.
Great chords.
MrJimdeb 1 year ago
nice but choppy, somewhat like trying to play a 'lickbyneck' arrangement....jerky, and staccato where it shouldn't be......a chord for every note is not wanted at the expense of a rhythmic jazzy feel
musicluvinguy 4 years ago
Thank you for the critic, it's always welcome. This arrangement was made by me - my only influence was Ted Greene.
About "lickbyneck" arrangement, I had never listened to it before.
guitarleal 4 years ago
Very weak and revealing criticism on the part of musicluvingguy. There is no "luv" in his commentary. This seems to be criticism from someone who is projecting their own frustrations into your amazing music; hence the foolish and snobby comments. At this level of musicianship a "rhythmic jazz feel" is not mandated. Adjectives like "jerky" and "choppy" are very suggesting of personal battles. I wish him the best like the rest of us. You are outstanding and thank you for your interpretation!
calicoolboy 3 years ago
musicluvinguy,
I think his harmony is very rich and colorful. Very nice voice leading. Also a very delicate delivery which is appropriate for this piece. Have you by chance uploaded your version of this classic tune? I would love to compare your arrangement against this one.
carvetop01 2 years ago
very smooth musical playing on a great old standard 5*****
freddym223 4 years ago
5 stars,awesome playing, such a good song. Mind if i ask how long you've been playing?
nomad05 4 years ago
Thank you very much. I play guitar it's been 20 years, but I used to play rock'n'roll (only). I've been studying jazz for 4 years now. I quit playing rock and now my only concern is jazz.
guitarleal 4 years ago
beautiful... nice touch & tone.
omobob 4 years ago
thats one of the most impressive versions i've heard on youtube. great work
illdoitagain 4 years ago