Added: 5 years ago
From: freezycold
Views: 421,735
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (841)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • what does the cross has to do with the performance here?

  • BRILLIANT DANCING!!!!!!!!

  • wow shes amazing!

  • Ousado !!!!

  • i want to know what she wants to express by being hung on a cross??? i want to know what this performance means.. :) anyone knows?

  • She is Protesting how our government ( and the world) looks past the AIDS epedimic. She clearly is showing how many children die from AIDS. Re-watch the video and i think you will understand...

  • hey thanks!! ;)

  • God is too far. Madonna is closer ,isnt it??

  • amazing, fantastic, beautiful, so fuckin beautiful (L)

  • amazingly...expressively..arti­stically...masterpiece..of fortunes and fates..with a beautifully sad song that ..brigs forth courage strength determination ... through accepting pain... and getting stronger... angels come in many forms...and madonna is a messenger to many people... a diva never to be 4gotten :)

  • This is one of the most beautifull perfomances ever; people must try to understand the message wich is given in this video. Trying to get over a very hard period, something we'll all have to do with sometimes!

  • ohh that's the meaning of this performance? hmm, interesting... :)

  • The woman is 50, she wouldn't be asked when she is retiring if she were working a normal 9-to-5 job. She isn't a grandmother, as her eldest is only 12. I find it hilarious that while people rag on her age, they don't tell Mick Jagger to stop touring (isn't he like 65 or something?). And without much help from the ageist radio stations, Madonna has managed to break records both on the charts and out on tour recently.

  • As I have said before, she doesn't need to retire but she does need to stop tying to shove her rotting crotch in everyones face(hung up). She needs to grow up. She's still the same attention grabbing whore she was when she started out except now she's 50. Even strippers and whores need to retire at a certain age. Doesn't mean she can't still sing...I take that back, she never really could sing. BTW Mick Jagger and his buddies look like fucking morons on tour.

  • so much hate...

    if you don't like her music, just don't listen/watch it.

  • I don't mind her music. It's the rest of her bs that I can't stand.

  • This is beautiful!!

  • OMG *-* 12 MILLIONS CHILDRENS!!!

  • Madonnas a fuckin fantastic performer!!! I didnt take my eyes off for one mesely second!!!

  • Those 12 million children are a religous issue not politcal

  • They're a moral issue, genius.

  • Great Dancing ! nice background video .

  • Brava Madonna.

  • !!!!!

  • thats terribly disrespectful

    dirty ole fart

  • She Is The Queen.

  • we all are sons or daughters of christ, god what ever is IT nAME

  • I mean a literal descendant of Christ not just a spiritual one.

  • yeah! and maodnna is the 2nd messias! :)

  • Keep your religious imperialism to yourself. I am most certainly not the son of your imaginary friend. While I practice tolerance toward his followers, Christ is not welcome in my life.

  • che cazzata

  • Emmanueline Xixaue

  • Anemmm vao tirar esse videoo! :C

  • No words.

    i woke up and i see all these things, since August 2006 in Rome, I havent been the same.

    Help to HEAL THE WORLD

  • I believe that Madonna and I are decendants of Jesus. I have always had this sixth sense about stuff that runs in my family. Maybe she thinks she is a decendant of Jesus also.

  • No one like Queen M! NO ONE!

  • This is the best Madonna song ever!! <3

  • Is she telling the world that she is HIV postitive by being hung on a cross? It fits with the words of the song?

  • she is sooooooo good and this song is great!!!!!!!

  • So is she a christian now because I keep hearing her changing her religion. I dont think joel osteen would agree with this. LOL!

    Dancing and stories were amazing

    Im surprised this doesnt have more hits for how controversial it was.

    Anyway I love you Madonna!!!

  • wow, those dancers were incredible. This video just gave me major chills.

  • song no.1 gooooooooooooood

  • madonna is jesus.

  • la repanocha

  • Madonna is not a religion hating bitch.

    First of all She does alot of work fro Africa... Racist? No.

    And she is a Kabbalist. Religion hating? No.

    Honestly, you need a frigging check before you go round throwing acusations like that.

    And I think this is the most repectfull act I have ever seen.

    you need to take a closer look at the meaning of this song and act.

  • I wasn't talking about her ImJustMark...

  • i agree with you. she just wanted to say,

    "hey world! stop hurting each other. let's all make peace, carry up our cross and help each others' nations!!"

  • even the devil wouldn't recognize you...

  • Wow... she's amanzing!!!

  • She is God!!!

  • amazing dancers,

    the first one looks like he's flying!!

    is crazy!

    im going to see her tomorrow here in buenos aires, im so happy <3 =)

  • who are the dancers? they rock!

  • The only point on having a religion is to help others in need. Nothing else. I dont care if you are or believe in whatever, just help at least ONE of those 12 million.

    That is the message.

  • i think this song is beautiful...and i think the crucifix was just a way to express herself...idk

  • The dancers are sooo good! I can't believe it.

    As for the crucifix.... I dunno, I think it's tacky.

  • Amazing,wondrous..and more more words like thaht......dancer#1 what is his name???

    PLEASEEE

  • she is the Queen.

  • is there anyone without sins ? do not judge her, and stop predicting her future ! she has already done much more than anyone else to 'save the world'. Madonna involves herself in many worlds issues, she prevents the global warming by her activity !! so don't tell bullshit!!

  • hell yes she is!

  • WOW! A total reinvention of this song.

  • nice

  • OMG, its was fantastic!!!!!

  • Madonna is God.

  • This song gives me goosebumps every time I hear it.

    Is the first dancer Cloud from I'm Going To Tell You A Secret?

  • yes it is

  • I've got the hole dvd. Nothing is censured. I think its beacuse I live in sweden and here we don't censure something (:

  • i have the dvd too and i am from mexico

    :DDD

  • the story on the dancer number 3 was about what..? pls do tell me...

  • The black guy is talking about the catch 22 situation of joining a gang.

    It seems so glamorous at first, but look at what ends up happening...

  • I'm Christian, I go to the Mass everyday + I pray the Rosary everyday. I don't see why Madonna is chocking. In contr, she's preaching Christianity in her concert & the msg of charity to all her fans + She's communicating Jesus words from the NewTestament to the whole world, like one of Jesus disciples. She's using her art, fame & influence for the GoodCause. Maybe her intention was to mock Christianity, but the result is different: she communicated Jesus message to many pers.: Love & Charity

  • I don't agree she is ofensive .. too bad Madonna

  • I love this song . I love her!!

  • For God's sake, she isnt trying to be God or Jesus!! Stop trying to "read" into it! She's doing what she does best, being controversial! And she's succeeded! Look how many of you are slating her. There's no such thing as "bad" publicity. It's when people stop making coments about her (good or bad)she has to worry.

  • the female dancer is too hot -_-'

  • what is the tune when the dancer is on..ive been wating to know it for ages its on loadsa things!

  • ekanze444

    Madonna, speaks a truth that in all of us and that is life is struggle. Life, is a heavy burned and I feel the pain of the dancers.

  • Right on Madonna. She nailed xtianity right to the "cross".

    Horrifying religion. Hateful religion. Unloving and uncaring.

    Hats off to you Madonna!

  • thats interesting, because we christians love you...

  • This was not an insult to Christians. End of.

    Someone told me it was, and there was no arguement as to why he found it offensive, just that "it is".

    Please eff off. It's imagery, learn to live with it.

  • She can mock any religion but I don't buy her "cockney" accent , like she was born British. WTF?. BTW im am Catholic, i am not offended by this video, at least it gives a message

  • Fantastic !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LOVE FROM FRANCE MADONNA AND I THINK ITS GREAT THAT SHE IS HEALPING THE POOR

  • Christians don't need someone like Madonna telling them to help the poor and the sick,Christians have been doing that for a long time. Whoever doesn't know that Aids is an epidemic, might be living under a rock and to help others in need. But Africa is not the only place with Aids, how about her own country US?

  • it´s not for Christians, it´s for us all. We all are taught to help, but who does in reality? Sometimes just a music show can be a little piece of sand staying in your mind and swimming out later to be a mother of helping idea which change to reality. And if you see statistics, Africa is not only place with AIDS? but the per cent of ill are killing there.

  • I don't see her as Jesus, or as God, she is not trying to guide us to Jesus because she doesn't believe in Him.

  • dear, is it really important for you? if she believes in God? That´s relation between her and God. We cannot see inside her heart and even people who could be called "nihilists" can guide us to God.

  • To all of those that are calling Christians haters, let me ask you this? what if your religion was being mocked? if your belives were trampled by people that don't believe in them like Madonna? she is a a kabbalist...

  • Madonna doesn't respect Christianity or its foundations, if she did she would use other methods to drive her message to people without using religion, how come she doesn't use anything Kabbalah on her presentations?

  • Madonna surprises me because she stopped being a Christian to enter into other religions and now is following the Kabbalah. For her to be using Bible New Testament scripture, which is the prime of Christianity, makes no sense to me. Specially when she uses the Crucifiction in a concert out of all places, Rome the Home of the Catholic Church, where the Pope lives, knowing that it would bring controversy and even a feeling of disrespect that the church might have.

  • respecting a church that doesnt give a phuck about 12 million orphand children while being the first world wide corporation? Im sorry to tell you this, but put that religion in your ass!

  • I CANT DO THIS

  • Wow that first guy is an amazing dancer!!

    But seriously Madonna, wtf? This chick is strait up crazy. Why is she on a cross?? That makes no sense. Is she seriously comparing herself, a washed up popstar, to the savior of millions of people? I'm not even Christian and I find this offensive.

  • is more offensive having a the vatican for no shit!!!

  • Madonna is God alive

  • I've heard a lot of bad things about this video ...but to me it all points to Jesus..I suppose you could take it wrong..but why?? Take the good message and make a difference with it!!!

  • Madonna is the Jesus Christ of the modern world.

  • No she is trying to point you to Jesus

  • wow..it was amazing!!!

  • Can somebody tell me please what she exactly says at the beginning? I belive we are messengers on earth... and all this part.

    I need it. Please!

  • I think she said "I believe in Angels. I am blessed by God to tell myself that I suffered that which to become who I am today."

  • wowowowow!!!!111

  • best dancers on earth!

  • 前面dancer跳舞ㄉ那一段粉不錯~與後頭瑪丹娜ㄉ演唱會很搭­配~演唱會現場音效一定更棒

  • I went to see this tour everywhere and I stayed in the same hotel with her and her crew. I met all the dancers, but the best and the nicest one who was so incredibly friendly and cool is the black guy with mohawk. So down to earth.

  • Mě se zdá, že tenhle videoklip je skvělej - a komu se to nelíbí - tak ať si to přeloží ....

  • the dancers are the best part

  • Does she really help african people ?

  • Great song, great show..it's amazing..

  • Yes,we try all together to help! Nice Video, nice Madonna.Respect!

  • God Bless you always Madonna for helping the poor

  • From the sublime to the ridiculous - to madonna

  • only madonna can do it...i love maddy

  • This is a total REINVENTION of the song. She made it modern. Total success.

  • im wearing a thorn crown for halloween!!! are you excited??

  • does anybody know the music that is playing before the godess sings??

  • olo to theme 7lofitissa legetai confessions by madonna....

    mia filh..:P

  • an les to kommati pou akougetai enw anevainei o stayros legetai live to tell by madonna....

    an les g to theme pou paizei prin mpei h "godess" sth skhnh einai to confessions panta apo madonna...

    mia filh:P

  • Great song, stunning performance.

    This is one of the million reasons why madoona is the best live performer ever.

  • the first performer was awesome...his act rele caught me

  • I know it's stupid but it actualy brought a pinch to my heart...

  • Great Madonna! great show!

  • PL: To było coś mocnego...

    EN: That was... amazing...

  • wow

  • powerful

    thought provoking

    touching

    done with

    love

    and people hate?

    to a world sick with ignornance

    get well soon

  • this perfomances great.

  • youve never smelt her

  • That dancer in the introduction just left me breathless.  I have never seen such outstanding dancing.

  • If I ran away, I'd never have the strength

    To go very far

    How would they hear the beating of my heart?

    Will it grow cold

    The secret that I hide, will I grow old

    How will they hear?

    When will they learn?

    How will they know?

  • a touching part of the song!! I love it :)

  • Ze is geweldig, She is great!!!!!

  • live to tell the secret I have know...

  • great cool ya!

  • paashaas? stumper!

  • Still one of the best performances she gave..

    it is like he voice is getter better as she gets older....

    En wat is hier nou schandalig aan...heeft iemand het alleenrecht op dit kruis of

    zijn jullie zo bekrompen....ga gewoon ergens

    in een hoekje wegkwijnen en dan zijn we ook van jou af.

  • jou kop is schandalig ja zeikerd

  • :S hoezo schadalig? zoo dom dat slaat nergens op.

    Krijg kippevel als ik dit zie!

  • Beautiful, amaaazing!

  • Harlot, that's what she is.

  • the humen jungle monkeys in africia need to die there scum

  • I think she isn't normal.

  • normal people are discusting! they have no much to tell or represent too ordinary!

  • we all agree with U, she is not normal !! SHE IS AWESOME !!!

  • I fail to see why this should be censored, even if you factor in those ignorant fundamentalists.

  • I dont speak so good english, so i don't understand what they say in the beginning

  • me too :]

  • What language do you speak?

  • I cried at the end those poor kids an all you racist funks

  • This segment is kinda cheesy..I love Live To Tell and this concert but Madonna only used this crucifix scene for attention and controversy.

  • I think she was trying to get attention, but to herself, to her message. If you have something important to say, then it´s better if the whole world is paying attention.

    Sometimes you have to slap people in the face to wake them up. It´s a good thing.

    Everything she does has a meaning. She uses a lot of metaphors ans symbols in all her works. I think she gave a great message of love, mercy and hope with this song. I´m glad the whole world was watching.

  • this is exellent congratulations madonna your concerts are the best!!!!

    I love!!!

  • why are people so scared of this performance?

  • we europeans like madonna!this is no musix anylonger...this is art!..and hey all those fanatic chritians pissed me off!

  • Have you all seen the group on Facebook? "Christians are Just Jealous that Madonna's Cross is Prettier than Jesus's" GREAT!!!!!!!!!! Some of us love god some love Madonna!!!!!!!

  • hermosoo, lejos la presentación con mas carga emotiva que he visto!

  • I say if it gets the message across do whatever you have to do in order to make people here.

  • Yes, damn it! The only right comment.

  • take it AS FAR AS YOU WANT I SAY !

  • it't great song, until she start singing...

  • BRAVO!

  • test

  • this video made me cry it's very serious

  • WOW Madonna is just AMAZING. I LOVE HER.

  • I think Madonna took it a  bit too far with this performance