At the end where it suddenly changes to live footage and is no longer an animation, I nearly cried it was so powerful at bringing home the realisation this thing really happened, what an incredible film.
Watching this film crushed my soul a little. Why can't we live in peace, to much death and sorrow ill never sleep comfortable at night knowing stuff like this still happens all over the world. Games like COD/Battlefield prepares the next generation for war which is sad but true.
According to Robert Fisk in his book "The Great War for Civilisation: The Conquest of the Middle East", pp.484,488–489, Israeli defence minister at that time Ariel Sharon and Chief of Staff Rafael Eitan met with the Lebanese Phalangist militia units, inviting them to enter the Sabra and Shatila refugee camps and telling them the PLO fighters were responsible for the assassination of their leader Bashir Gemayel. This is the core information that was neglected/distorted in this movie.
@Diala80 Re: "....core information...." You are speaking about a WAR in Libnan which was going on for several years before Israeli involvement ( internecine violence between religion,families, and clans, for CENTURIES , if you really know about the area). Very one sided view on your part about something which is deeply complex. Blaming Israel is very popular nowadays...and sometimes rightly...but the mess in Lebanon is of much larger history than our own lifetime..
@mozo73 My comment is not about "blaming" but rather about providing a correct picture of the massacren. The story is told by a former Israeli soldier who inquired about the "Truth" then produced the movie. The real photos from the massacre add a documentary nature to thr movie, hence the need for accuracy. I never said that Israel was, alone, responsible for the civil war in Lebanon (!), but it did play a core role in the massacre. The movie blames mainly the Lebanese for it.
@Diala80 Ah, I think I jumped the gun a bit in my response to you. Sorry !. I do think however that the movie portrays very accurately the Israeli view of what happened at Sabra and Shaltila, and the director/narrator was actually there. Perhaps Fisk is right in his assertions, perhaps he is wrong. Peace.
@clever50 shut the fuck up i am israeli and i never wish death to muslims or arabs like you do i got a few arabs friends neighbors we living in peace and we have no problem, stop hating you moron, politics and wars are much more complicated then religion or some thing simple like that, in israel's case its self defence and you cant argue with that.
@davidds0 you are isreali? well in that case i wish death upon you! are u jew aswell? well thats a pluss i wish you die a slow painfull dead!!!
if you wnat people to stop hating you monsters. well pealse look up the word defence before using it again (when isreali Merkava IV tanks occupy gaza its not defence its offence, when isreali f-16 bomb gaza its not defence its offence...)! and most of all WHNEN YOU MOSTERS KILL CHILLDREN AND TEENAGERS ITS NOT DEFENCE!
@clever50 Ignorance is such a blessing. Fleeing into your naive and limited world must be a nice change. I wish you the best of luck! You poor bastard!
@MrMREI hahahah its amazing how you call me poor and uneducated. however your ideas about me are not facts, you are mistaking me for someone poor refugee. haha no i am an upper-middle citizen of a wonderfull nation in europe. and franckly i know more english that all you retarded jewish mother fucking mosnters put together.... go drink some more child blood and stop bothering me!
@clever50 Ahhh yes. Your English is amazing! Do you want me to correct your mistakes or are you happy with being an ignorant moron! And what the hell is a upper-middle citizen?! But why even bother? Why even answer you? I wish one day people like you will be simply ignored and by that shut up! Once again enjoy your ignorant and limited world as long as you can! And please do us all a favor learn some proper English! Why the hell do you think I believe you are a refugee?
@clever50 Yeah I can kinda tell you like being a little idiot! And I am also very glad that you know my religion! Right on man! Keep your wondrous work up! And thank you for pointing out that i like killing babies.... maybe you don't mind me saying so but I love you man! Thanks for finally pointing out my true calling.. being a nazi-like jew who kills babies and eats them while drinking their blood!
@clever50 and what wonderful nation would that be i wonder? Could it be the one that attempted to annihalate an entire race of people? I'm thinking it probably is!
@samisacool1 i dont even have time to read you comments so ill say this, if you suoport isreal i wish death and diseas upon you, but if you hate them too, then we're good :D
@clever50 you know why are tou wrong??? Because no race is excent of some form of guilt...all races have killed, yours and mine included. That´s mainly because of religion, politics and big hatred full assholes like you. I dont think one race is better or worst than an other. We are all one sigle species HUMANS, thats why we ALL tend to act the same violent way, so stop bullshiting about "jew-monsters" and go and take a good look to your own race you´ll find that it isn´t any better than jews
@cinemaniac1127 i dont even have time to read you comments so ill say this, if you suoport isreal i wish death and diseas upon you, but if you hate them too, then we're good :D
@clever50 ok listin.. you wish death upon me? dont worry one day i will die.. and same you too.. because we all humans and we all die evantuilly, you only live once, unfortinalty you spend your time on wishing death upon people and religion, dont spand your life hating people it will get you no where, i wish you will understand this, i will not wish death upon you or anybody cus hating will just get me into bad mood and why would i do that? your just a pissed off youtuber, you cant harm me.
@clever50 fine were monsters we eat babies, we rape innocent weman ,were ugly ,we have long noses what ever... i dont care were one of the most hated people in the world, we have our own army and our own state to protect our selves... and you cant harm me. besides if calling me an ugly monster with long nose :D makes you feel better with your self then go ahead just do it.. you need help my friend ;D
@davidds0 I wish that hitler would have fininished what he started! when i see the pictures of the jews all starving and burning i cant help but to smile and say "one day, one day, it will happen again!"
@clever50 why are you enjoying being so anti semetic? plz answer honestly dont say some thing stupid like its because were monsters or some thing.. it must be some thing more deeper and serios
@clever50 Do you know what that word means? And why this obsession with the blood of kids? Clever50 :D well done! BTW... I love your name.. it fits your comments and you style to argue!
@blythklaire2 its like wishing buy some thing free.. get some thing with good things and no costs, its allmost impossble, for some thing good or neccesery you must fight and pay for it.. thats how it works in this world, no matter what there allways some thing negetive and positive.
I saw this film today, its definately a film that makes you think about how humans as a species can go about killing each other, well thats how i saw it anyway, great film though
I love this movie so much. Its very eyeopening, in a way, and very beautifully drawn and the like, but the story itself is not beautiful. Contrast, a wonderful element..
than you don't read enough books a newspapers... and especially you didn't hear what they say in the movie, these soldiers weren't israelian... they were christian arabs... who took vengeance at the muslims for killing Bashir... and israel doesn't kill innocent people... we are doing what we have to do to protect our country... we are fighting terrorism! and only terrorism... and sadly for us you don't know what is really terrorism means...
They are swimming, and they like to swim naked. I doubt it has symbolical significance. Soldiers swim naked, it feels good to take off your uniforms when they smell of weeks of piss, blood, and ball sweat.
I agree that its symbolic. cause its a scene taken out of his dreams.
But i think the meaning of this scene is that the naked (unprotected), young soldiers (all of them still kids) come out of the ocean, that protected them (like inside a big mother) and as they take their weapons and their uniforms, they losse their childhood and their innosence. They become soldiers and have to march into war.
Thats my opinion.
Hope my english is good enough so you could understand what i mean.
I know man.....it's strange. It's not sentimental nor is it touching.......but you know that reason why they're screaming and crying could conjure those emotions, just that you don't feel them because of the circumstances or the environment!
At the end where it suddenly changes to live footage and is no longer an animation, I nearly cried it was so powerful at bringing home the realisation this thing really happened, what an incredible film.
BloodW0rx2 1 month ago 3
MAX RITHCER has done it again!!!
Javismusicful 1 month ago
Watching this film crushed my soul a little. Why can't we live in peace, to much death and sorrow ill never sleep comfortable at night knowing stuff like this still happens all over the world. Games like COD/Battlefield prepares the next generation for war which is sad but true.
sk8ingdude69 3 months ago 3
@sk8ingdude69 I love battlefield, but I do agree it glorifies war. COD is far worse. It's a recruitment game.
AAV47 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No more war , no more bloodshed...
forzamicha46 6 months ago
According to Robert Fisk in his book "The Great War for Civilisation: The Conquest of the Middle East", pp.484,488–489, Israeli defence minister at that time Ariel Sharon and Chief of Staff Rafael Eitan met with the Lebanese Phalangist militia units, inviting them to enter the Sabra and Shatila refugee camps and telling them the PLO fighters were responsible for the assassination of their leader Bashir Gemayel. This is the core information that was neglected/distorted in this movie.
Diala80 6 months ago
@Diala80 Re: "....core information...." You are speaking about a WAR in Libnan which was going on for several years before Israeli involvement ( internecine violence between religion,families, and clans, for CENTURIES , if you really know about the area). Very one sided view on your part about something which is deeply complex. Blaming Israel is very popular nowadays...and sometimes rightly...but the mess in Lebanon is of much larger history than our own lifetime..
mozo73 4 months ago
@mozo73 My comment is not about "blaming" but rather about providing a correct picture of the massacren. The story is told by a former Israeli soldier who inquired about the "Truth" then produced the movie. The real photos from the massacre add a documentary nature to thr movie, hence the need for accuracy. I never said that Israel was, alone, responsible for the civil war in Lebanon (!), but it did play a core role in the massacre. The movie blames mainly the Lebanese for it.
Diala80 4 months ago
@Diala80 Ah, I think I jumped the gun a bit in my response to you. Sorry !. I do think however that the movie portrays very accurately the Israeli view of what happened at Sabra and Shaltila, and the director/narrator was actually there. Perhaps Fisk is right in his assertions, perhaps he is wrong. Peace.
mozo73 4 months ago
@mozo73 Peace!
Diala80 3 months ago
@mozo73 But I still think that the movie is a wonderful piece of art. :]
Diala80 4 months ago
Очищение типа-того.
7Jericho7 1 year ago
Обожаю этот фильм
komar1436 1 year ago
There are no best scenes in this movie. The entire movie is just great.
antialiasing38 1 year ago 25
the impact is so much stronger in Hebrew
chantoke 1 year ago 3
heyyyyy at 1:50 they were using machine gun sound effects from battlefield 1942!!!
randomguy199545 1 year ago
something is wrong with the title cuz whole movie is one best moment
wecks14 1 year ago
Ливан очень красивая страна !
wildwest610 1 year ago
i loved this movie so MUCH!!!!!!
asort3 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Death to isreal! an all jews!
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 shut the fuck up i am israeli and i never wish death to muslims or arabs like you do i got a few arabs friends neighbors we living in peace and we have no problem, stop hating you moron, politics and wars are much more complicated then religion or some thing simple like that, in israel's case its self defence and you cant argue with that.
davidds0 1 year ago
@davidds0 you are isreali? well in that case i wish death upon you! are u jew aswell? well thats a pluss i wish you die a slow painfull dead!!!
if you wnat people to stop hating you monsters. well pealse look up the word defence before using it again (when isreali Merkava IV tanks occupy gaza its not defence its offence, when isreali f-16 bomb gaza its not defence its offence...)! and most of all WHNEN YOU MOSTERS KILL CHILLDREN AND TEENAGERS ITS NOT DEFENCE!
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 Ignorance is such a blessing. Fleeing into your naive and limited world must be a nice change. I wish you the best of luck! You poor bastard!
MrMREI 1 year ago
@MrMREI hahahah its amazing how you call me poor and uneducated. however your ideas about me are not facts, you are mistaking me for someone poor refugee. haha no i am an upper-middle citizen of a wonderfull nation in europe. and franckly i know more english that all you retarded jewish mother fucking mosnters put together.... go drink some more child blood and stop bothering me!
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 Ahhh yes. Your English is amazing! Do you want me to correct your mistakes or are you happy with being an ignorant moron! And what the hell is a upper-middle citizen?! But why even bother? Why even answer you? I wish one day people like you will be simply ignored and by that shut up! Once again enjoy your ignorant and limited world as long as you can! And please do us all a favor learn some proper English! Why the hell do you think I believe you are a refugee?
MrMREI 1 year ago
@MrMREI I am happy being a moron, are you happy with being a blood driking monster? (aka jew)
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 Yeah I can kinda tell you like being a little idiot! And I am also very glad that you know my religion! Right on man! Keep your wondrous work up! And thank you for pointing out that i like killing babies.... maybe you don't mind me saying so but I love you man! Thanks for finally pointing out my true calling.. being a nazi-like jew who kills babies and eats them while drinking their blood!
MrMREI 1 year ago
@MrMREI nah you are not nazi like... being called a nazi is too good for you! i think the right and only word for you is jew.
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 Seems like the Nuremberg process wasn't thorough enough...
OnkelMickwald 1 year ago
@OnkelMickwald ye the mother fuckers should have been fixed up much better
clever50 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@clever50 You don't really get it, do you?
OnkelMickwald 1 year ago
@clever50 and what wonderful nation would that be i wonder? Could it be the one that attempted to annihalate an entire race of people? I'm thinking it probably is!
samisacool1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@samisacool1 i dont even have time to read you comments so ill say this, if you suoport isreal i wish death and diseas upon you, but if you hate them too, then we're good :D
Dath to isreal and ALL jews
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 you know why are tou wrong??? Because no race is excent of some form of guilt...all races have killed, yours and mine included. That´s mainly because of religion, politics and big hatred full assholes like you. I dont think one race is better or worst than an other. We are all one sigle species HUMANS, thats why we ALL tend to act the same violent way, so stop bullshiting about "jew-monsters" and go and take a good look to your own race you´ll find that it isn´t any better than jews
cinemaniac1127 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@cinemaniac1127 i dont even have time to read you comments so ill say this, if you suoport isreal i wish death and diseas upon you, but if you hate them too, then we're good :D
Dath to isreal and ALL jews
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 oh fuck you NAZI pig
EphraimRodrigez 1 year ago
@cinemaniac1127
How can this be? A sane person? And on youtube?
My applause to you for understanding how the world works, instead of picking on a race and being brainwashed by propoganda
SMan9090 7 months ago
@davidds0 MOSTERS! that is the only word for you people!
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 ok listin.. you wish death upon me? dont worry one day i will die.. and same you too.. because we all humans and we all die evantuilly, you only live once, unfortinalty you spend your time on wishing death upon people and religion, dont spand your life hating people it will get you no where, i wish you will understand this, i will not wish death upon you or anybody cus hating will just get me into bad mood and why would i do that? your just a pissed off youtuber, you cant harm me.
davidds0 1 year ago
@davidds0 hahahaahaha okej... however its not just me, you ugly people with your LOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG noses are the most hated people in the world.
correction, here i said your people i meant you monsters!
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 fine were monsters we eat babies, we rape innocent weman ,were ugly ,we have long noses what ever... i dont care were one of the most hated people in the world, we have our own army and our own state to protect our selves... and you cant harm me. besides if calling me an ugly monster with long nose :D makes you feel better with your self then go ahead just do it.. you need help my friend ;D
davidds0 1 year ago
@davidds0 I wish that hitler would have fininished what he started! when i see the pictures of the jews all starving and burning i cant help but to smile and say "one day, one day, it will happen again!"
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 why are you enjoying being so anti semetic? plz answer honestly dont say some thing stupid like its because were monsters or some thing.. it must be some thing more deeper and serios
davidds0 1 year ago
@clever50 Do you know what that word means? And why this obsession with the blood of kids? Clever50 :D well done! BTW... I love your name.. it fits your comments and you style to argue!
MrMREI 1 year ago
@clever50 dont worry one day every jew that is living at this moment will die as well but there will allways be more jews ! :D
davidds0 1 year ago
@davidds0 yei know... but i want you guys to suffer aswell :/
clever50 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
DEATH TO ISREAL AND TO AMERICA!
clever50 1 year ago
@blythklaire2 its like wishing buy some thing free.. get some thing with good things and no costs, its allmost impossble, for some thing good or neccesery you must fight and pay for it.. thats how it works in this world, no matter what there allways some thing negetive and positive.
davidds0 1 year ago
I saw this film today, its definately a film that makes you think about how humans as a species can go about killing each other, well thats how i saw it anyway, great film though
DevilBringer119 2 years ago
its the best of all times
starmannnn 2 years ago
I love this movie so much. Its very eyeopening, in a way, and very beautifully drawn and the like, but the story itself is not beautiful. Contrast, a wonderful element..
vampirekikikat 2 years ago 4
I wish muslims were not so obsessed with hating Jews.
capitalsho 2 years ago 2
capital its not every Muslim,10% doesn't count as every
kig132 1 year ago
10%! your fucking having a laugh.
capitalsho 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@capitalsho death to all jews and isreal!
clever50 1 year ago
@clever50 what if i said death to all muslims and arabs? what's the difference??? we're all human, there's just a religious difference!
orphans4christ 1 year ago
@orphans4christ well jews are blood sucking childkilling mother fuckers! you have to see my point here!
clever50 1 year ago
i wish isreal would stop killing insosent people!
clever50 2 years ago
than you don't read enough books a newspapers... and especially you didn't hear what they say in the movie, these soldiers weren't israelian... they were christian arabs... who took vengeance at the muslims for killing Bashir... and israel doesn't kill innocent people... we are doing what we have to do to protect our country... we are fighting terrorism! and only terrorism... and sadly for us you don't know what is really terrorism means...
RadioNuiPek 1 year ago 6
wow, these are really intense.
ribenawrath 2 years ago 2
i wish there would be no more war so we would stop losing our loved ones :-((
blythklaire2 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
3:34-4:20
Scream more chickens
kig132 2 years ago
douche.
GamingIsTheBest 2 years ago 3
such a douche
pocketsurprise 2 years ago
iva israel
lordon18 2 years ago
Когда они из моря выходят - сильный момент....
7Jericho7 2 years ago
I never saw a piece of art as intense as this movie
Ganymed88 2 years ago 51
I couldn't agree more, it really gets to you.
bajsiogat 2 years ago
@Ganymed88 me neither, at least not a picture. i made drawings of some scenes on the walls of my room, until i had no space for any other.
daynzka 1 year ago
i wish that the phalax keep defendig the world from those arabic extremists
Wintersverd 2 years ago
Beautiful movie!!
Show what happens to people during and after war and the effect on their lives!
Question: At the very beginging of the clips, why were all the men naked? I just don't get it that well.
williammoseleyfan101 2 years ago
They are swimming, and they like to swim naked. I doubt it has symbolical significance. Soldiers swim naked, it feels good to take off your uniforms when they smell of weeks of piss, blood, and ball sweat.
zenmaster72 2 years ago 8
@zenmaster72 You need to watch the movie. Cause you're wrong about this scene.
HeyNonyNonymous 1 year ago
@zenmaster72
I agree that its symbolic. cause its a scene taken out of his dreams.
But i think the meaning of this scene is that the naked (unprotected), young soldiers (all of them still kids) come out of the ocean, that protected them (like inside a big mother) and as they take their weapons and their uniforms, they losse their childhood and their innosence. They become soldiers and have to march into war.
Thats my opinion.
Hope my english is good enough so you could understand what i mean.
Chihab2112 1 year ago
@Chihab2112 Thats a good interpretation, and yes your english is fine :)
albettatrue 1 year ago
@zenmaster72
They are murderers...
rusignolo 1 year ago
That means, for me and my perspecive, that u born naked, from a tender and humid womb, then u born for war.
Wintersverd 2 years ago 2
I think its their "walk" from innocence to guilt. The litte pre-war boys becoming soldiers, who did their job
Bonygasse 2 years ago 2
My favourite part is the "I bombed Sidon" sequence.
TheShorelessC 2 years ago
i loved the part in the orchard with the music that went so well with the scene and yeah the dream part was great to simple but great
STUPIDRETARDS8527200 2 years ago
I personally think one of the best scenes in the film is the dream sequence with the giant sea woman.
LightStijn 2 years ago
I know man.....it's strange. It's not sentimental nor is it touching.......but you know that reason why they're screaming and crying could conjure those emotions, just that you don't feel them because of the circumstances or the environment!
titowasagoodman1980 2 years ago
The last minute of this clip is so simple, but so intense...
crikylife 2 years ago 6