Hypnotic video and song. More hypnotic together, I think. People are always interested in mysterious crimes. A kind of simple girl gets killed. Passion murder by a lunatic. And the thought that this might be based on a true story...
@Oceania123100 your queit correct there is more to this song then meets the eye. this song is comparible to the picture of dorian gray. the man loves the women with all his hearth, but only loves the beauty, not the content, so he ends up killing her to make sure her beauty is preserved
@Oceania123100 This song is popular because its really good for many reasons, but mystery is not one of them. When the song ends you can understand what happened so there is no mystery
@fdhdhdhgh Well, mystery is not to be solved but to be explained.You are right, we can clearly see what happened in the end. However, can we really explain why beauty is so killing sometimes? In any case any point of view has a right to exist! Let us simply enjoy this masterpiece!
I don't like this video... with him groping her and the snake and stuff... and she just seems so ugly and fake with her unnatural red hair and blood-red obviously fake lips... I don't think this great song can have any video that is good enough for it.
@kidsampsonsghost..... so your saying hes better than gaga... i dont think so iv never herd of the bloke..... anyways all a was sayin is kylie is awsome.... way better than that dude..... i just dont like his voice.....
@misiaaa90 I thought the same but you have to see it like a theatrical play, think also how many times they cut and laughed at mistakes, no one here is serious.
@Romania4trutine Yeah. I meant that the rose thing reminded me of a serial killer's signature, or like when people threw hats down on their victims or whatever. So I kind of picked that up, sort of.
@lukemccartney21 Haha. That guy is a music legend. Recently inducted into the Australian Recording Industry Association hall of fame. Sold millions of albums, credited with influencing thousands of successful bands and musicians. The opinion of a kid and Gaga fan like yourself (not really bagging her, she does some good shit and is a real artist, just not Nick Cave good) like yourself is probably not going to hold much water here. Kylie agreed to this because of his talent and fame.
@lukemccartney21 without Nick Kylie would never sound this good - brilliant song and a fantastic album. Get your head out of your ass and listen to something other than what is spoon fed to you by the record companies and hit radio.
would you agree you have never seen kylie looking so good ? check out nick cave /kylie and the pouges death is not the end and enjoy !! KYLIE IS NO TEENYBOPPER !! make your own mind up when u listen to that !! listen to the words and if your a bloke would you not want kylie waiting for you ? I FUCKING WOULD THATS MY IDEA OF HEAVEN !! is it yours be truthfull !!
I’m a big fan of Nick Cave and the bad seeds, Boys next door, The Birthday Party and Grinderman. I just did a review on The Birthday Party’s first album. It would mean a lot if you all checked it out. thenewmusiccollective.blogspot.com/
@Avenger4343 I find it more sickening that someone would use cancer, a terrible and nasty disease, to comment on something as mundane as a music video, no matter what the quality. I hope you never know anyone with cancer, not that I do not wish you to learn but I would not wish it on them
@bedheadx You must not spend much time on the internet. Cancer/Cancerous and the like are all terms used for things that spread and people find obnoxious or stupid.
Also Cancer isn't just a disease, there are many terms for "cancer". So calling something "a cancer" is pretty justifiable.
@bedheadx When you say cancer on the internet, you refer to the growing mass of useless and generally harmful material that is destroying the site or community in question. That is to say, the useless comments that no one but the poster and other idiots like, which spreads to other retards who are just in it for the gratitious ego-masturbation that comes from getting "thumbs up".
I have been a fan of Nick Cave for awhile. I met him in Toronto, where he signed his book for me. I wrote a review of The Birthday Party on my blog. Please check it out.
It is about murder, not love or suicide. He is a psycho, who lures her to her death down by the river. He murders her by bashing her with a rock, and then maybe drowning her. It is haunting, beautiful, and ultimately chilling.
One of the most haunting songs Kylie Minogue has ever done. Her vocals here are amazing & so unique, unlike anything she has ever done. She and Nick Cave harmonize gorgeously. Goth pop; that's the only way I can describe it. Kylie was a phenomenon even back then.
POV 1: On the third day he took me to the river, he showed me the roses and we kissed, and the last thing I heard was a muttered word, as he knelt above me with a rock in his fist.
POV 2: On the last day I took her where the wild roses grow she lay on the bank the wind light as a thief. And I kissed her goodbye, said all beauty must die, and I lent down and planted a rose 'tween her teeth.
(interpretation) in order to keep her eternally beautiful in his memories she must be sacrificed.
PJ Harvey got him back for this -.-
GospodjicaDecibel 1 month ago
adorei esta video!!!
magdy351 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
Justin Biber : Come Selena ! I will show you where wild rose grows up !
Selena Gomez : Fuck Off You bitch! You will Kill me With the Rock !
The4r4 1 month ago
More mysterious and menacing than romantic. Still though, nice.
lightlyone 1 month ago
@lightlyone Mysterious and menacing, romantic.... Same thing.
ChrissieBana 1 week ago
Hypnotic video and song. More hypnotic together, I think. People are always interested in mysterious crimes. A kind of simple girl gets killed. Passion murder by a lunatic. And the thought that this might be based on a true story...
viivis67 1 month ago
@starabijemiedrzwiami Elrond must have been really romantic when he was young XD
awesome56ist 1 month ago
I can't help it, but to me Nick Cave around 0:38 looks quite like Elrond from LotR :P
starabijemiedrzwiami 1 month ago
@starabijemiedrzwiami exacly! :D... znaczy sie dokladnie kurwa! :D
Pandrodorr 1 month ago
I think the video is so great and beautiful as the song is.
bellessaa 1 month ago 3
she is life and live
le00000000000000000 1 month ago
Kylie es so beautful.
eduard123aplee 1 month ago
Sick fuck killing her like that.
Tazwegian 1 month ago 2
Comment removed
NeonFelin 1 month ago
love this song and the video
deniro4270 1 month ago 2
80 people are not laid .. go get laid morons ! stop disliking song like this
waredetester86 1 month ago
This song is a like a mystery, which no one will ever comprehend!
Oceania123100 1 month ago 5
@Oceania123100 A guy kills his girlfriend at a river with a rock. Mystery solved
fdhdhdhgh 1 month ago 12
@fdhdhdhgh If everything were so easy, the song would never be so popular!!!
Oceania123100 1 month ago
@Oceania123100 your queit correct there is more to this song then meets the eye. this song is comparible to the picture of dorian gray. the man loves the women with all his hearth, but only loves the beauty, not the content, so he ends up killing her to make sure her beauty is preserved
azraelOdeath 1 month ago 3
@Oceania123100 This song is popular because its really good for many reasons, but mystery is not one of them. When the song ends you can understand what happened so there is no mystery
fdhdhdhgh 1 month ago
@fdhdhdhgh Well, mystery is not to be solved but to be explained.You are right, we can clearly see what happened in the end. However, can we really explain why beauty is so killing sometimes? In any case any point of view has a right to exist! Let us simply enjoy this masterpiece!
Oceania123100 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yeah!!! fucking heavy music /„/ \„\
FinGamer8675 1 month ago
in my opinion... he's had right killing this Beauty, didn't let hurt her by bad world...
faerdagon91 2 months ago
Is it odd I find this so romantic?
wantonladyful 2 months ago 31
@wantonladyful considering it's a romantic song i would say it's extremely weird and disturbing that you find it romantic. freak. jk
JohnTheRipper2 1 month ago
Sent from above.
passthemission 2 months ago
I don't like this video... with him groping her and the snake and stuff... and she just seems so ugly and fake with her unnatural red hair and blood-red obviously fake lips... I don't think this great song can have any video that is good enough for it.
Yoshimatey 2 months ago
you must be deaf to dislike such a wonderful song!
genytsir 2 months ago
The feeling of the song is magic. Kylie was the most beautiful in this video clip.
vvhtkl023 2 months ago
@vvhtkl023 The irony being it was during her unpopular phase. Though I liked her music more once she got away from SAW.
Decrosiana 2 months ago
the lyrics.. I love it!!!
smokerjill 2 months ago
Easily one of my favorite Nick Cave masterpieces! This entire record was absolutely amazing.
vat19com 2 months ago
This video has aged really well...
OrenjiDays 2 months ago 3
Nagyon szeretem
szuszi55 2 months ago
Me impresiona un poco el video... la cara de psycho de el, y Kylie muerta mientras el la toca... jaa miedo! Pero igual me encanta :P
sexwithmadonna 2 months ago
god damn my superficial impression of kylie minogue which saw her as a typical popstar, this puts her in a whole new light
willisepic 2 months ago
it's on TV right now in NL!
dscrd1 2 months ago
ZovuuuUUuuu me divlja ruuuUUuužaa...
Flake4kv 2 months ago 3
1:54 how sexy.
mollsies1 2 months ago
Minél jobban tudok angolul annál ilyesztőbb ez a cucc
11011011011100110 2 months ago
love this 'beautiful song,n nick cave ,hunky ;-)
jtjennyjoy14 2 months ago
JAG ÄLSKAR DEN HÄR LÅTEN FULLSTÄNDIGT MYCKET!!
Rijad90 2 months ago
да
kalvero1 2 months ago
love this song!!! kylie the best!!
zandyminogue 2 months ago
Just beautiful !
mariaanna511 2 months ago
great, great, great song!
nina4nina44 2 months ago
So very beautiful, I love that song! I have a list of the best singer-songwriter duets here: h t t p : // notnicolajames . wordpress . com
notnicolajames 2 months ago in playlist Duets
This has been flagged as spam show
If you like Nick Cave, Leonard Cohen or Johhny Cash, come and check my new stuff on my channel. I hope you like it.
J56official 2 months ago
Kylie never been better, or looked more beautiful than in this video, and Nick is making a great performance too.
MrRepulsiv 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
watch this guys: /watch?v=Gaq95ppzHrU
better than this original
ArmaDAARmin 2 months ago
Comment removed
ArmaDAARmin 2 months ago
wspaniała:) great song ;]
Fuegooo0800 2 months ago
1:53 rape face
uzaricanin07 2 months ago
Kylie is so very beautiful here....
SootImp 2 months ago
1:29 If the snake would have going down there im pretty sure she would have reacted..
dtiydr 2 months ago
Haha i had NO idea she was the vocalist in this song..
dtiydr 2 months ago
Comment removed
Torithecupcakegirl 2 months ago
<3
Behemoth221192 2 months ago
"said all beauty must die"
abdulalsheikh 2 months ago
necrofilia:|
lx1marinescu 2 months ago
beautiful music / i love his for 10 yers old
mrlifeL0ve 2 months ago
wtf is this?
managrey 2 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Kylie Minogue
Ohh Nick ! Still makes me lough, you are absolutely cool though .
MrCemGenc 2 months ago
she is like Ofelia from picture Johna Everetta Millaisa
primaverra19 2 months ago
SSSEXY SMALL CREATURE>......
mmmmmmm
SKARKIBANEZ 2 months ago
Wunderbares Video, ganz wunderbare Music ..... WUNDERBARE SCHÖPFUNG!
LIEBE KANN ENDEN, EGAL WAS MAN SICH VERSPRICHT!!!!
Marianne
PRTS5068 2 months ago
greatest song ever.
nlkatte 2 months ago
Lovely song! But the video and Nick scare the heck out of me
PCDizzle15 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
okay im sorry but what the hell is this??
TheDaniGBabe 2 months ago
@TheDaniGBabe Great music !!!
MEGAINDIEROCK 2 months ago 57
@TheDaniGBabe and an iconic video
jackcash94 2 months ago
@TheDaniGBabe Art.
godessceline 2 months ago
@TheDaniGBabe You've never been bludgeoned to death, by Nick Cave, down by the river. You just wouldn't understand.
troyltdtime 2 months ago
@TheDaniGBabe Very beautiful song <3
jonathanwillocq 2 months ago
best duo Nick ever made
agadigby 2 months ago
this is pure artistic genius! kylie's singing is so haunting and don't get me started on nick lol
feelthefever2468 2 months ago 2
Beautiful surrealism.
EmoryNectarine 2 months ago
love it, thank you nick cave !
silverwolf2061 2 months ago
Неебически круто.
hirurg1 2 months ago
I love this sonk!!!!!!!
1Ejka 2 months ago
@kidsampsonsghost..... so your saying hes better than gaga... i dont think so iv never herd of the bloke..... anyways all a was sayin is kylie is awsome.... way better than that dude..... i just dont like his voice.....
lukemccartney21 2 months ago
@lukemccartney21 Only people you've heard of are good.
kukmisu 2 months ago
This song is so beautifull but the lyrics scares me... And this creepy video... Theres so many different feelings in my head right now.
misiaaa90 2 months ago 24
@misiaaa90 I thought the same but you have to see it like a theatrical play, think also how many times they cut and laughed at mistakes, no one here is serious.
EpicsodeOne 2 months ago
Putting the rose between her teeth after he killed her sounds like a serial killer thing. This is a crazy song. But I agree; it's a haunting tune.
casarind1 2 months ago
@casarind1 the song is actually meant to be about a serial killer and his victim
Romania4trutine 2 months ago
@Romania4trutine Yeah. I meant that the rose thing reminded me of a serial killer's signature, or like when people threw hats down on their victims or whatever. So I kind of picked that up, sort of.
casarind1 2 months ago
so beautiful
MsAngelsgame 2 months ago
i love kylie like... but that guys voice is soooooooooooooo rubbish...
lukemccartney21 2 months ago
@lukemccartney21 Haha. That guy is a music legend. Recently inducted into the Australian Recording Industry Association hall of fame. Sold millions of albums, credited with influencing thousands of successful bands and musicians. The opinion of a kid and Gaga fan like yourself (not really bagging her, she does some good shit and is a real artist, just not Nick Cave good) like yourself is probably not going to hold much water here. Kylie agreed to this because of his talent and fame.
KidSampsonsGhost 2 months ago
@lukemccartney21 without Nick Kylie would never sound this good - brilliant song and a fantastic album. Get your head out of your ass and listen to something other than what is spoon fed to you by the record companies and hit radio.
newmusicblows 2 months ago
this is some freaky shit
Oranges8 3 months ago 4
Comment removed
Omar7amza 3 months ago
It may be about murder but, damn Nick Cave.... -blush-
OneofSilver 3 months ago 2
simlpe beautiful
bruni1106 3 months ago 2
i hate the first two comments
TheYes16 3 months ago 3
Comment removed
Alistarb25 3 months ago
would you agree you have never seen kylie looking so good ? check out nick cave /kylie and the pouges death is not the end and enjoy !! KYLIE IS NO TEENYBOPPER !! make your own mind up when u listen to that !! listen to the words and if your a bloke would you not want kylie waiting for you ? I FUCKING WOULD THATS MY IDEA OF HEAVEN !! is it yours be truthfull !!
bristolcityifcation 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I’m a big fan of Nick Cave and the bad seeds, Boys next door, The Birthday Party and Grinderman. I just did a review on The Birthday Party’s first album. It would mean a lot if you all checked it out. thenewmusiccollective.blogspot.com/
handspringmatt 5 months ago
can we please all agree to stop voting up comments like " 68 people didnt blah blah blah" that shit is cancer.
youthXattack 5 months ago 84
@youthXattack 75 people
mark01318 2 months ago
@youthXattack actualy the bigger cancer is that there are any dislikes
Avenger4343 2 months ago
@Avenger4343 I find it more sickening that someone would use cancer, a terrible and nasty disease, to comment on something as mundane as a music video, no matter what the quality. I hope you never know anyone with cancer, not that I do not wish you to learn but I would not wish it on them
bedheadx 2 months ago
@bedheadx .....
Avenger4343 2 months ago
@bedheadx You must not spend much time on the internet. Cancer/Cancerous and the like are all terms used for things that spread and people find obnoxious or stupid.
Also Cancer isn't just a disease, there are many terms for "cancer". So calling something "a cancer" is pretty justifiable.
MasterAsra 2 months ago
@bedheadx When you say cancer on the internet, you refer to the growing mass of useless and generally harmful material that is destroying the site or community in question. That is to say, the useless comments that no one but the poster and other idiots like, which spreads to other retards who are just in it for the gratitious ego-masturbation that comes from getting "thumbs up".
HeltOkejFilmer 2 months ago
All this beauty must die.
Ovumee 5 months ago 3
@EndlichinsLicht Not sure how you could live with being murdered...
Glaerdrune 5 months ago
Love it!
Melobione1 5 months ago
Kylie is so beautiful in this video
Liityx 5 months ago 7
piękne ...
4You668 5 months ago
eifachd es wunderschöns lied!
87babycake 5 months ago
Helen Sjöholm and Georg Wadenius sang this in a concert in April and it was wonderful.
maryjolly88 5 months ago
beautiful song.......
eleonora58r 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I have been a fan of Nick Cave for awhile. I met him in Toronto, where he signed his book for me. I wrote a review of The Birthday Party on my blog. Please check it out.
thenewmusiccollective.blogspot.com/
handspringmatt 5 months ago
This is the one and only song my husband has sung on singstar with me. We sounded crap but got to love him for trying :)
PipirikiShell 5 months ago
stealing this for my english essay. My thanks, Mr. Cave
himrawkz 5 months ago 2
the day kylie minogue became cool!
poegot 5 months ago
Kylie Minogue has such an amazing voice. Such a wasted talent gone into her solo material when she could have been producing music like this!
<3
gibboj94 5 months ago
supeeer
unomig1 5 months ago
Awesome
meczydusza1 5 months ago
I love Kylie doing this, it shows a completely different side to her!!
sarahbilton 5 months ago 5
It's very gothic :)
moonspellivo 5 months ago
this song is on the album "Murder ballads" all the songs are tributes to real murders!..
dee756 5 months ago
@dee756 I think the word "tribute" might be poorly chosen...
RuerlKhan 5 months ago
Kylie is so feminine,and sensual.
sanjica990 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kamelot version is way better*
FlamingRougeKiller 5 months ago
Kamelot version is w better
FlamingRougeKiller 5 months ago
When I was little, everytime when I saw this song... I was scared... don't know why :S
theodora899 5 months ago
They call me The Wild Rose
But my name was Elisa Day
Why they call me it I do not know
For my name was Elisa Day
evieexD 5 months ago 2
68 people didn't call her The Wild Rose
JeePSmash 5 months ago 7
@JeePSmash haha ione of good "dislike people coments haha
sivko23 5 months ago
Very exceptional combined voices between Nick and Kylie's
NoumaiosDeLaCampa 5 months ago
Ophelia's myth for ever into real sensitive hearts...
NoumaiosDeLaCampa 5 months ago
Beautiful!
Cave's ominious sounding voice and Minogue's sweet voice have a beautiful counter-balance.
This song still sounds good after all these years.
OzzInter 5 months ago
This is a lovely adaptation of Hamlets Ophelia scene
SweetlySinging 5 months ago
................Do you know where the wild roses grow
So sweet and scarlet and free?
WhereTheWildRoses79 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is the gayest song ever
matildad2011 5 months ago
omg i remember when this was on mtv, what year was that anyway?
it's funny how you never forget some music videos. love this song.
NAUSICAAs 5 months ago
You can see Kylie's arm move at 1:31
That snake must have scared her.
XD
omgsomanynamestaken 5 months ago
I'd "offer my life" for him to take, as long as he sang to me while doing it!
NylaScotia3239 5 months ago
I have just shed a tear listening to this... and I'm a guy.
MoonchildMindaugas2 5 months ago
@MoonchildMindaugas2 me too bro, me too...
TheMyEmo 5 months ago
What a great song!
dangeraldi 5 months ago
I love Harry Porter, the latest movie was great!!!!!
apon91 5 months ago
elia rising, sort sol ??? eller omvendt???
powerpedersen 5 months ago
Очешуительно!!!!!!!!
BigIMXO 5 months ago
Matti Hautameaki????? 0:34
SebatroxS9 5 months ago
moc hezké
jarmihot 5 months ago
nadal brzmi pięknie !!!!!
bambersy2000 5 months ago
In love with this song!! :)
AXnadi 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
geat song,
terrible vocals on both sides
got1320 5 months ago
@got1320 so controversial haha
selenanguyen89 5 months ago
@got1320 please explain? their vocals go perfect with the melody!!!!
Alistarb25 5 months ago
awesome song, prefer it sung by the gregorian chant guys. but great song about lust and murder
MrCripple04 5 months ago
Comment removed
Meistarinn95 5 months ago
great song! favorite:-)
Sternschnuppe709 5 months ago
i like it. it's great. : *
maybegoodbaby 5 months ago
It is about murder, not love or suicide. He is a psycho, who lures her to her death down by the river. He murders her by bashing her with a rock, and then maybe drowning her. It is haunting, beautiful, and ultimately chilling.
goldbookca 6 months ago 82
@goldbookca but he kills her out of love, he says "all beauty must die" and he kisses her goodbye........he indeed is kind of a psycho :|
wertnert 5 months ago
@goldbookca this history like Perfumer a lot :)
neverforgottenful 3 months ago
@goldbookca I think it has a link with The ballad of charlott dymond
TheAZIN08 3 months ago
ein lied das einem durch und durch geht egal wie man es sieht
vhu282 6 months ago
Beautiful! Who can say what this song? It is not he kill her? It was an accident? It's suicide?
If you know the text, whether it is possible to understand what the song? Write even in English. I understand. Please!
Minnifo 6 months ago
Красиво ! Кто может сказать о чем эта песня? Это не он ее убил ? Это несчастный случай? Это самоубийство?
Если знать текст, можно ли понять о чем песня? Напишите даже по-англ. Я пойму. Пожалуйста !
Minnifo 6 months ago
@Minnifo Oн сошел с ума, вот почему oн убил еe камнем. A tы слова найдешь, если ты впишешь "Where the wild roses grow lyrics" в гоогле ^^
scratchingeye 5 months ago
I've been on youtube for 2 years now and have in that time got around 1400 subscribers. It's more than I expected, but it doesn't get me noticed.
The only thing I ask of you is to go to my channel and look at one of my videos for 30 seconds, it would help a lot.
If you like it, subscribe, that also helps.
I have this dream of one day being successful, but I have a long way to go. Will you go with me? Thumbs up if you liked what you heard.
PatriciaDiru 6 months ago
One of the most haunting songs Kylie Minogue has ever done. Her vocals here are amazing & so unique, unlike anything she has ever done. She and Nick Cave harmonize gorgeously. Goth pop; that's the only way I can describe it. Kylie was a phenomenon even back then.
StageZineLovesKylie 6 months ago
Unbelievable how a song about murder sounded so good
tamirlevy100 6 months ago 2
POV 1: On the third day he took me to the river, he showed me the roses and we kissed, and the last thing I heard was a muttered word, as he knelt above me with a rock in his fist.
POV 2: On the last day I took her where the wild roses grow she lay on the bank the wind light as a thief. And I kissed her goodbye, said all beauty must die, and I lent down and planted a rose 'tween her teeth.
(interpretation) in order to keep her eternally beautiful in his memories she must be sacrificed.
LiteracyLabyrinth2 6 months ago
listen to cradle of filths 'nymphetamine' Am i the only one hearing it!?!
ScepticSnakebite 6 months ago
@ScepticSnakebite Yeah, I hear it too. I was wondering where do I know it from.
sedlin01 6 months ago