No wonder he's the best!! he's so diverse he's learned indian classical drumming too!!! (the speech to hand drumming solo he does) See Ustad Allah Rakha & Zakir Hussain Tabla Solo Teental on youtube - a equally great drumming mastery 'duel'/pair
This might still be available on the Telarc label. It's with the Cincinnati Pops recorded in 1988. Other artists are Ray Brown, Dave Brubeck, Buddy Morrow, and Gerry Mulligan. There are 16 cuts backed by the Cincinnati Pops. If you like this cut, you'll like the CD.
i really don't get why the little emo guys love Travis and Joey so much. By the way, nu is not metal. Their both really talented drummers but really?? At least my generation with bonzo, peart and copeland had finesse that made them stand out.
Whoa hey now, Travis is good. Lets not rip on good drummers. But he isn't the best. If you want the best you have to listen to Bonham, Rich, Weckl and Gadd (I'm sure there are others you could add, but these four came to the top of my head).
OK CALM DOWN GUYS. I'm a drummer and I like plenty of rock AND jazz drummers. I know both drummers and I agree with Green, Travis Barker isn't a pimple on Ed E.'s ass.
Ed Shaughnessy was, and still is, one of the greatest drummers to date that I've seen. He didn't match up to Buddy on The Tonight Show, but he was damn close. The simple fact he sustained a competition against the greatest drummer known to mankind places him very close to the top of the pyramid. Travis Barker doesn't even come close to the greatest ROCK drummers, so comparing him to the jazz greats is that much more ridiculous.
I had a great chance to play with Mr. Shaughnessy when he played with our high school Jazz band. It was one of the most amazing experiences of my life. He was just awesome. Mid concert, just before his solo, he leaned over to me and said "Take a solo". Though my original training was Cello. I was also in the drum section. We all got a clinic from him. I took his hand drumming to heart. Still do it.
Travis Barker is a master a playing punk rock, this guy is a master at playing bebop. Travis Barker probably sucks at playing bebop, this guy probably sucks at playing punk rock.
I'm not really a fan of this genre. Although I admit he's got some interesting dynamics going on near the end . . . among other things. *looks up lyrics*
@travisBrulzz geez dude listen to some real drummers or buddt rich, gene krupa, art blakey max roach, john bonham and keith moon will come back to life and crap all over your dumb face and travis barkers.
Why does Travis Barker's name keep coming up on all these Buddy Rich videos anyway? That's like comparing dump trucks to semis. They're both haulers and they both have motors but they're not even remotely the same. Best is a relative term anyway. Who's a better guitar player; Chett Atkins or Eddie Van Halen? If you're playing country, Eddie's probably not your first choice...
For example Charly Antolini´s solo on sing, sing, sing with the RIAS Orchestra is much more entertaining, difficult, stunning than this simple rhythmic dumdumdum, this stuff I play for a warmup.
@whity72 well since your obviously the greatest drummer who's ever lived, why don't you post a video of your playing? you know, to grace us with your mastery, something that ed shaughnessy just wishess he could have. JACKASS
If one more angst ridden teenage with green hair says Travis Barker is the best drummer in the world i am going to punch a fucking wall. Pull your pants up and get some taste!
Eddy Shaughnessy merkt man einfach an, dass er die Musik liebt. Exzellenter Solist aber auch immer Band-Musiker. Ab 5: 40 geht er ab wie Schmitz` Katze.
I've played drums for many (30) years. Nowadays I play in a bigband (Yes I can read notes). I prefer to recognize drummers for their contribution to music, e.g. John Bonham, Phil Collins, Peter Erskine, Ian Paice, Steve Gadd, Gene Krupa, Ringo Starr etc. I like to be impressed when I watch and listen to technically brillant drummers as Buddy Rich. But I enjoy to watch and listen to drummers who plays as - e.g. Ed Shaugnessy. Keep up the good drumming ;-)
Do you play professionally in a big band??? Does that exist? Im just curious, I never see jazz anymore...besides standards (yuck) and just weird weird music
to fcmilsweeper9: I don't play professionally though I would like to. The Danish Radio Big Band (I'm from Denmark ;-) ) is a professional big band, Klüvers Big Band too. I'm sure you can find musicians (read drummers) who plays professionally in big bands - among the other bands, groups, sessions, etc. they play in too.
travis is good....so is ed.....why do all jazz videos with great jazz drummers end up with the name travis barker in it somewhere?......it makes no sense, people are just looking for a fight, if you don't like jazz don't listen
dude...c'mon...grow the HELL up... I <3 travis.... and he's good....but it's a TOTAL diff. genre.... and he'd prolly piss himself trying to learn krupa or rich...
why...you ask? Oh...well first...he'd have to learn TO KEEP HIS ARMS DOWN...
he can't do anything without looking like he's on his way to a rotator cuff injury :P
travisbarkerpwnsall, whoever you are, you need a little more experience on the drums ass hole. You don't have any idea what you're talking about. Get your head out of Travis' ass and smell a real drummer. Fuck you.
The video of Ed and Buddy playing on the tonight show is just... it's mind blowing. It'd be fun to be able to get the instrumentals of this song Sans the drums because I think this is my favorite Rendition of the song.
Travis Barker is a halfassed wanabe drummer... EVERYTHING he plays is simplistic and lacks any form of musical structure... A first year drummer could play anything he comes up with... Go pick of a drum and learn to be a musician before you go praising posers
buddy rich is the best and any good drummer knows that, however ed shaughnessy has worked with buddy and even buddy ritch says that this guy is awsome two amazing drummers, the best that ever lived!
first that is not even Eddie S trying to "prove" anything....just a few little mellow interludes on the skins. I know that travis barker is famous and newer than Ed...but, REALLY?
Ed S is a session playing, music reading drum wizard motherfucker for gods sake...you can't really mention the two in the same book...I have watched Travis on many occassions and he is certainly way better than I am....but really not in the same league as Ed.
@TBARKERISLEDGEND ....crack is really not a drug you should be smoking while watching videos of drummers on YouTube......it really makes you sound stupid...
@TBARKERISLEDGEND I like Travis Barker too. But He's nothing copmared to this guy or Krupa or Rich! Buddy Rich and Gene Krupa are Drum Gods! Oh and I think that Ulrich ins't all that good. His drumming isn't all that special. no offense.
Well, Ed's doing something very very few drummers can. He is playing with mallets, hard mallets, but just the same, few drummers could play this fast and for so long with mallets. For people who don't know: mallets are only used for tenor and bass drums (oh and tympani). Let's add on top of that: in the long solo he's holding the left mallet in the "classic" position, left hand palm horizontal, right palm down.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
some duechbag was trying to tell me tghis old fart can beat travis wat a crock of fucking shit dude can you belive theise fucking noobs travis wood wip the floor with this fucktard
@travisbarkerizdaman I've seen you commenting on several videos of actually talented drummers talking about how travis barker is blah blah blah and then gulp as you swallow his load. fuck off and go watch some gay porn. you obviously don't know shit about percussion even if you happen to play it which I pray to god that you don't.
@travisbarkerizdaman Buddy Rich was over the Hill and he still whipped everyone out there. Age means little to the Legends. Start looking up and readin, man.
Looked like Doc Severinson playing the trpt. solo. Eds drum solo was all Ed there's no Comparing to Gene. Gene was Gene, CAN'T COPY THAT but then again Ed has played with everyone and is one hell of a nice guy and swung the band great .
I wondered why Ed's snare drum seemed too lose power, tonally speaking, then I spotted those sticks cum beaters muffling the sound. He really needed a pair of Vic Firth 5As in my humble and even irrelevant opinion. Strangely one of the best Sing, Sing Sings I ever heard was by a schoolgirl band at Disneyland Tokyo who uncannily recreated the 1938 Krupa/Goodman classic. Still, nobody can beat that Krupa sound captured they say by a single overheard mike.
Thats true....check Barkers grip out....traditional when playing marching drums or on a pad....thats the proof...the links any of us who do with history and tradition on the drumset legacy. An instrument created here in the America in New Orleans. And Rich, Krupa, Shaugnessy, Bellson, Jo Jones are the fore fathers.....there are others and their hands they carry a proud American tradition. Barker knew Zildjian. Hed be the first to tell you. Have fun checkin it out , research the names youll see
I met Ed Shaughnessy before and after winning a local drumset competition back in '95, I had the opportunity to have lunch with him. I was 17 at the time. He didn't really impress me. In fact, He's the one who told me he doesn't like drummers who use dbl bass and that I still had a long way to go to be good enough for a late talk show band. Upon finishing our lunch and saying our farewells, I began walking away. I finally turned and told Ed, "look me up when you want to learn dbl bass."
I find it great, how people always comment that one's better than the other... xD
this guy plays in a big band, Travis barker (I know who he is) but I forgot what music they play (I'm a metalhead myself) so... you've got two COMPLETELY different styles of playing.. and both are really good. though I prefer Ed here. you can feel the swing in the music. btw: being a fast drummer, doesn't mean you're a good one.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
are you retarted or somthing what part of travis wood kick this noobs ass dont you fuckingunderstand buckweet yoru becoming a wise ass and i have been nown to make exampels out of ashols such as yourself
Perhaps it would be appropriate to explain that this performance, by the Cincinatti Pops Orch. is played as a musical tribute to the late Benny Goodman, Gene Krupa and Harry James ( plus the other fine musicians in Goodman's 1937 band ). They have been respectful to the original arrangement and Ed Shaughnessy has been totally respectful to Gene Krupa by just putting his own spin on the drum solo. Will anybody remember Travis Barker in 70 years time?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
youv been taking a lot of shit retart may i sugest you lisen to travis solo with 1 fucking arm and tell me that he canot punk out theise bitches with his fucking eyes close man your fucking stuipid
Travis Barker in my opinion is more of a performer rather than a truly gifted musician. The complexity, technique, style and variation of drummers like Buddy, Eddy, Dave (Weckl), Steve Gadd etc... Are a lot more appealing to me and motivating. I'm not trying to disrespect Travis here, but I think he's more about the image.
Oh and I'm 16 so there is no point in telling me that I'm just old and mentally stuck back in the old days :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
fuck you penis head travis barker wood fucking pwn the living shit out of this old geezer fuckface you need to chang the battery in your fucking heering aid you geezer
travisBrulzz. I don't know what you've got stuffed in your ears but just unstuff and listen to a great band propelled by one of the greatest drummers of all time with solos by two of the greatest instrumentalists Eddie Daniels and Doc Severinson.
This guy is truly one of the greatest drummers of all time. His technique is perfect.
But believe it or not, there is a swiss foreign exchange student at my school this year who BLEW THIS PERFORMANCE OUT OF THE WATER. I'm not even kidding... I mean i knew the kid was good but i herd him play this at a concert tonight and almost fell out of my seat and to top it off i had to follow him Dx
--Props to this drummer and thumbs down to any no talent wannabe drummer boy who has the gal to dis him
!!!! i have been looking for this song since i was 7. i always just glazed over the title whenever i found it cuz i didnt think this would be the one... but i clicked on it by accient and... let me just say, some accidents are good ^_^
Ah, so beautfiul. The Sound of true music, that is.
I agree 40x with you Insolence69.
How can things so different even be compared; they are like two opposite categories. And people should open their little tunnels to see what others might have to say.
I'm sure Travis and many other musicians of our time our great people, but in their own categories. Just like Ed is a great musician in Jazz. Everyone is titled to their opinions, but there is no necessity to start arguing over something that doesn't make sense. Don't compare two different things.
Not to mention, if you knew anything about the history of Jazz, you would know that some modern music is derived from Jazz and Blues.
Appreciate things, don't instinctively look for fallicies.
I'm tired of humans. All they do is argue in an illogical and uneducated manner.
It truly is disgusting and annoying to see sometimes.
Why can't everyone just take one second to understand the other person's point of view or the message some of these youtube videos are trying to get across?
Ed Shaughnessy, like many other great jazz musicians, is a significant figure of the 20th century. Why would you even begin to compare someone from our time, from another category of music, to Ed? Absurd.
I've seen Barker play, and while I'm a great jazz drumming fan, I've got to admit that he's good...really good!!, but still light years away from the talent of Rich, Bellson, and even Shaughnessy here.
His only flaw, as far as I can see, is his ignorant and vulger fan base that makes him seem as cruddy as they present themselves to be.
wow... Could you sound any more like a Travis Barker fanboy. Yeah, he's good, but this is one of the original jazz drum virtuosos, who were the first to really show people what drums could do. I'm sure if Mr. Barker saw what you wrote, he would point out the fact that you're a dumbass, since it's jazz greats like this one that insipred him do develop his style of drumming.
3.54-4.01...man i love how those classic drummers play, Ed doing that chop like he is pulling something with his right hand. OMG those drummer r like put their whole body with soul into rhythm itself! When i learn something new i also try to feel music not only in my head but with heart and soul! Don't bother with all those nubs saying jazz drummers r nothing. I play in prog metal band and my band always listen jazz and blues to pick up something new for prog metal
I used to love watching the Tonight Show when ! I was younger,and learning to play, and I loved the way Shawnee played ! I still do ! This cat realy swings !
do you seriouly just go around and bash other drummers and spam shit about travis barker? I've seen you do it in multiple videos. No one cares about a PUNK drummer in a JAZZ video.
Who the hell is Travis Barker?
holmer666 5 days ago
I'm sure this is with the Cincinnati Pops Orchestra. They did an album on the Telarac label.
darkoanton5 3 weeks ago
That Eddie Daniels can sure play the clarinet, as well. Both Ed's are amazing.
darkoanton5 3 weeks ago
7:15
browns99df 3 months ago
OUTSTANDING!
nighthawk6298 3 months ago
FUN. PURE FUN.
teachingfeller 4 months ago
No wonder he's the best!! he's so diverse he's learned indian classical drumming too!!! (the speech to hand drumming solo he does) See Ustad Allah Rakha & Zakir Hussain Tabla Solo Teental on youtube - a equally great drumming mastery 'duel'/pair
Slicktopher 7 months ago 2
So fantastic
JOENGhongchul 7 months ago
Anyone notice the Vic Firth MT1A-S Tenor Mallets??
Wiiman138 8 months ago
if you dislike this ur autistic, ive met ed saughnassy in person and got a signed drumhead from him...there is nothing to dislike about ed
TheBLACKopzombies 8 months ago
This might still be available on the Telarc label. It's with the Cincinnati Pops recorded in 1988. Other artists are Ray Brown, Dave Brubeck, Buddy Morrow, and Gerry Mulligan. There are 16 cuts backed by the Cincinnati Pops. If you like this cut, you'll like the CD.
waltermferguson 10 months ago
this is such a down syndrome solo once it gets to 7 minutes
OGyink 10 months ago
is there anyway you can send me the mp3 file?
307236 10 months ago
i really don't get why the little emo guys love Travis and Joey so much. By the way, nu is not metal. Their both really talented drummers but really?? At least my generation with bonzo, peart and copeland had finesse that made them stand out.
troutmask1970 11 months ago 4
Y isn't this stuff still played more. now we have screamo and pop, y can't we bring swing/jazz/the blues back to the mainstream. PLEASE
soccerwizard975 11 months ago
I upped Charly Antolini at this song v=mA-4_hLH2q0 , there you can see what a world class jazz drummer has to do. :)
whity72 1 year ago
I would LOVE to play this with a big band, I can't even begin to imagine what it would feel like!
jimbobmcgee 1 year ago
Whoa hey now, Travis is good. Lets not rip on good drummers. But he isn't the best. If you want the best you have to listen to Bonham, Rich, Weckl and Gadd (I'm sure there are others you could add, but these four came to the top of my head).
Bobbyeagle 1 year ago
OK CALM DOWN GUYS. I'm a drummer and I like plenty of rock AND jazz drummers. I know both drummers and I agree with Green, Travis Barker isn't a pimple on Ed E.'s ass.
drummingprince3 1 year ago 3
Ed Shaughnessy was, and still is, one of the greatest drummers to date that I've seen. He didn't match up to Buddy on The Tonight Show, but he was damn close. The simple fact he sustained a competition against the greatest drummer known to mankind places him very close to the top of the pyramid. Travis Barker doesn't even come close to the greatest ROCK drummers, so comparing him to the jazz greats is that much more ridiculous.
jetfreak4 1 year ago
Wanna hear a joke? Travis Barker.
khman8675309 1 year ago
best big band song ever hands down
funpow5566 1 year ago
I had a great chance to play with Mr. Shaughnessy when he played with our high school Jazz band. It was one of the most amazing experiences of my life. He was just awesome. Mid concert, just before his solo, he leaned over to me and said "Take a solo". Though my original training was Cello. I was also in the drum section. We all got a clinic from him. I took his hand drumming to heart. Still do it.
kashimokid 1 year ago
What year was this?
killergirls 1 year ago
Was that Doc Severson on the trumpet solo?
BaritoneCan1 1 year ago
great job !!!
lolo2669 1 year ago
remembers me of the mask.
pbeNON 1 year ago
I'm thinking that the master had an aneurysm halfway through his drum solo, considering the way he was scat singing.
tehgamer1 1 year ago
Drums have come a long way. Drumming has not.
Dredger1401 1 year ago
I do believe this is the Johnny Carson band from the tonight show.
Soundman37 1 year ago
Listen to him Fly
mrbdguard 1 year ago
Really impressive how Ed can play it easy!
ceboluga 1 year ago
Travis Barker is a master a playing punk rock, this guy is a master at playing bebop. Travis Barker probably sucks at playing bebop, this guy probably sucks at playing punk rock.
I'm not really a fan of this genre. Although I admit he's got some interesting dynamics going on near the end . . . among other things. *looks up lyrics*
AquariusCyclone 1 year ago 3
@AquariusCyclone
I dont think that someone can actually suck at playing punk rock.. , cause its too dawm easy :D
cavapudding 1 year ago
@cavapudding I disagree, punk rock drums requires the drummer to make a more excited and "active" tone, plus play at a very fast rate.
AquariusCyclone 1 year ago
@AquariusCyclone
Every drummer with a bit experience should be able to do that..
MrTodorsMusic 1 year ago
@cavapudding you oviuosly have not herd of a punk drumemr named travis barker he is fucking gfreat you dumbass
travisBrulzz 1 year ago
@travisBrulzz Travis Barker my ass..... look up some drummer with real skills, like Rodney Holmes and Jojo Meyer, crapface!
MrTodorsMusic 1 year ago
@travisBrulzz geez dude listen to some real drummers or buddt rich, gene krupa, art blakey max roach, john bonham and keith moon will come back to life and crap all over your dumb face and travis barkers.
funpow5566 1 year ago
@AquariusCyclone and besides, thats swing dumbass
cavapudding 1 year ago
@cavapudding Sorry about that, I don't listen to swing very much at all.
AquariusCyclone 1 year ago
It is for a reason Butch Miles and Gene Krupa may be remembered as the best..... drummerboys makes noise as a rule....
michaelklaber 1 year ago
He reminds me alot of my deceased grandfather, though he didn't play drums.
MYNAMETAYLA 1 year ago
isn't that erich kunzel conducting? RIP
sgtpepper1138 1 year ago
Why does Travis Barker's name keep coming up on all these Buddy Rich videos anyway? That's like comparing dump trucks to semis. They're both haulers and they both have motors but they're not even remotely the same. Best is a relative term anyway. Who's a better guitar player; Chett Atkins or Eddie Van Halen? If you're playing country, Eddie's probably not your first choice...
bmorgan2814 1 year ago
Ed Shaughnessy is a way better drummer then Buddy Rich
JediMichael2003 1 year ago
For example Charly Antolini´s solo on sing, sing, sing with the RIAS Orchestra is much more entertaining, difficult, stunning than this simple rhythmic dumdumdum, this stuff I play for a warmup.
whity72 1 year ago
@whity72 well since your obviously the greatest drummer who's ever lived, why don't you post a video of your playing? you know, to grace us with your mastery, something that ed shaughnessy just wishess he could have. JACKASS
Cpetrodrum 1 year ago
wow its even bigger than my balls
blackmaggoth 1 year ago
If one more angst ridden teenage with green hair says Travis Barker is the best drummer in the world i am going to punch a fucking wall. Pull your pants up and get some taste!
metube3489 1 year ago 7
this vid is all soloists... the ensemble as a whole is soo square
littlephoenix1115 1 year ago
EPIC SIDEBURNS
Ireg2post1 1 year ago 2
@Ireg2post1 i wholeheartedly agree, my friend.
YTSEjam812 1 year ago
drum solos at, 2:47, 3:38, 4:27, 5:40 (most epic)
voxriderallday 1 year ago
that clarinet was incredible
boosh1988 1 year ago
@boosh1988 The clarinetist here is the Legendary reedman Eddie Daniels ~
MarkR1957 1 year ago
Eddy Shaughnessy merkt man einfach an, dass er die Musik liebt. Exzellenter Solist aber auch immer Band-Musiker. Ab 5: 40 geht er ab wie Schmitz` Katze.
chacmool1st 1 year ago
brilliant ;-)
Fedtskind 2 years ago
I've played drums for many (30) years. Nowadays I play in a bigband (Yes I can read notes). I prefer to recognize drummers for their contribution to music, e.g. John Bonham, Phil Collins, Peter Erskine, Ian Paice, Steve Gadd, Gene Krupa, Ringo Starr etc. I like to be impressed when I watch and listen to technically brillant drummers as Buddy Rich. But I enjoy to watch and listen to drummers who plays as - e.g. Ed Shaugnessy. Keep up the good drumming ;-)
Fedtskind 2 years ago
Do you play professionally in a big band??? Does that exist? Im just curious, I never see jazz anymore...besides standards (yuck) and just weird weird music
fcmilsweeper9 1 year ago
to fcmilsweeper9: I don't play professionally though I would like to. The Danish Radio Big Band (I'm from Denmark ;-) ) is a professional big band, Klüvers Big Band too. I'm sure you can find musicians (read drummers) who plays professionally in big bands - among the other bands, groups, sessions, etc. they play in too.
Fedtskind 1 year ago
travis is good....so is ed.....why do all jazz videos with great jazz drummers end up with the name travis barker in it somewhere?......it makes no sense, people are just looking for a fight, if you don't like jazz don't listen
Bosphorus92 2 years ago 7
AWESOME
Lizzie5797 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no shit travis can blow him away shrimp dick get a fucking cleu retard
BLINK2BARKER 2 years ago
Amazing!!
as831d 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
travis barker is a drum god
detectivesyme 2 years ago
Please...go away and stay out of the gene pool too.
firstmusic00 2 years ago
travis barker is about as good as that pile of shit my dog took in the park compared to ed
gothrowsome2a 2 years ago 55
@gothrowsome2a
dude...c'mon...grow the HELL up... I <3 travis.... and he's good....but it's a TOTAL diff. genre.... and he'd prolly piss himself trying to learn krupa or rich...
why...you ask? Oh...well first...he'd have to learn TO KEEP HIS ARMS DOWN...
he can't do anything without looking like he's on his way to a rotator cuff injury :P
drumstudent06 1 year ago
travisbarkerpwnsall, whoever you are, you need a little more experience on the drums ass hole. You don't have any idea what you're talking about. Get your head out of Travis' ass and smell a real drummer. Fuck you.
GreenManDan13 2 years ago 30
@GreenManDan13 eddie shaughnessy was a legend on the drums oncde compared to buddy rich till he got pwned by him
pmccarthy1388 1 year ago
The video of Ed and Buddy playing on the tonight show is just... it's mind blowing. It'd be fun to be able to get the instrumentals of this song Sans the drums because I think this is my favorite Rendition of the song.
whitephoenix72 2 years ago
Enough with Travis Barker Already. Barker hasn't earned the right to be compared to these greats of Drumming.
Drumguy1988 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dipshit barker fucking pwns you dumbass
travisBrulzz 2 years ago
I wasn't talking about me Dumbass. Why don't you go pleasure yourself to Travis Barker.
Drumguy1988 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
get out of here if you dont like travis you fucktard
travisbarkerpwnsall 2 years ago
Get out of where. This isn't a Travis Barker Video Dumbass.
Drumguy1988 2 years ago 4
Travis Barker is a halfassed wanabe drummer... EVERYTHING he plays is simplistic and lacks any form of musical structure... A first year drummer could play anything he comes up with... Go pick of a drum and learn to be a musician before you go praising posers
DrumDrum83 2 years ago 3
buddy rich is the best and any good drummer knows that, however ed shaughnessy has worked with buddy and even buddy ritch says that this guy is awsome two amazing drummers, the best that ever lived!
drummerguyx 2 years ago
well he's no Gene Krupa..
akmarksman 2 years ago
first that is not even Eddie S trying to "prove" anything....just a few little mellow interludes on the skins. I know that travis barker is famous and newer than Ed...but, REALLY?
Ed S is a session playing, music reading drum wizard motherfucker for gods sake...you can't really mention the two in the same book...I have watched Travis on many occassions and he is certainly way better than I am....but really not in the same league as Ed.
Sorry
jasaggio 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i like barker and ulrich to beat this dude fucking ass
TBARKERISLEDGEND 2 years ago
@TBARKERISLEDGEND ....crack is really not a drug you should be smoking while watching videos of drummers on YouTube......it really makes you sound stupid...
briandrum1 2 years ago 4
@TBARKERISLEDGEND I like Travis Barker too. But He's nothing copmared to this guy or Krupa or Rich! Buddy Rich and Gene Krupa are Drum Gods! Oh and I think that Ulrich ins't all that good. His drumming isn't all that special. no offense.
alinadrummergirl 1 year ago
salt peanuts lol
Natalya1sFit 2 years ago
ahhhhh! I love it
ThAustinYagleProject 2 years ago
Ed truly is the MAN!! such a shame there aren't many more videos of him on youtube.
OzzyOsbourneRox 2 years ago
Well, Ed's doing something very very few drummers can. He is playing with mallets, hard mallets, but just the same, few drummers could play this fast and for so long with mallets. For people who don't know: mallets are only used for tenor and bass drums (oh and tympani). Let's add on top of that: in the long solo he's holding the left mallet in the "classic" position, left hand palm horizontal, right palm down.
Then he switches to sticks.
AustinStephens 2 years ago 4
I don't get what's up with this version! It's so square, those are mostly classical players on the job! It's not even swinging!
KJEStudios 2 years ago
Dude Travis isnt Half of The Drummer That This Guy Is!
mmaAMPHI13 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
some duechbag was trying to tell me tghis old fart can beat travis wat a crock of fucking shit dude can you belive theise fucking noobs travis wood wip the floor with this fucktard
travisBrulzz 2 years ago
you've got to be kidding me...
howmanyvideos 2 years ago
@travisBrulzz depends on what kind of solo it was
if it was a punk rock kinda solo then i agree
if it was a jazz solo travis would get destroyed. nuff said
mprata729 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dude travis would blow his ass away in jazz 2 travis studeid jazz that his his fucking roots this guy is over the hill
travisbarkerizdaman 2 years ago
@travisbarkerizdaman his roots were a drum core at his school. there's a big difference
mprata729 2 years ago
@travisbarkerizdaman I've seen you commenting on several videos of actually talented drummers talking about how travis barker is blah blah blah and then gulp as you swallow his load. fuck off and go watch some gay porn. you obviously don't know shit about percussion even if you happen to play it which I pray to god that you don't.
hitshitwithsticks 2 years ago 6
agreed. i couldnt say it better myself. travis is a good drummer but not the best,
Drummerboy6able 2 years ago 2
@travisbarkerizdaman Buddy Rich was over the Hill and he still whipped everyone out there. Age means little to the Legends. Start looking up and readin, man.
Boost34 1 year ago
Awesome performance! I love Ed's take on this song, and the individual flair he adds to it- he doesn't try to be Gene. Gene is Gene, Ed is Ed.
And who knew salt peanuts and mutton chops went so well together?
FortunaFortesJuvat 2 years ago 6
this guy is good but buddy rich is better
CommanderKeny62 2 years ago
@CommanderKeny62 even Ed would agree with that i'm sure. They were friends so......
sgtpepper1138 2 years ago
It'd be a kick to see Shaughnessy play for Led Zeppelin.
ironbuttermilk 2 years ago
He'd be bored out of his mind playing Zeppelin songs. Ed Shaunessy is a true jazz drummer.
mrmott44 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
All if you guys can suck my right nut mike portnoy tops all of your little craps
NateDG95 2 years ago
i love jazz 5/5 digging the chops eddie lol
Natalya1sFit 2 years ago
Looked like Doc Severinson playing the trpt. solo. Eds drum solo was all Ed there's no Comparing to Gene. Gene was Gene, CAN'T COPY THAT but then again Ed has played with everyone and is one hell of a nice guy and swung the band great .
PJMPercussion 2 years ago
Great! :)
NuEdg 2 years ago
BENNY HINN TRUMPET SOLO!!!!
aaroncheong 2 years ago
not the flare of gene infact not even close
backbeatbobby 2 years ago
very true, but Krupa couldn't have pulled off those glorious muttonchops.
MalevolentKoalaBear 2 years ago
I wondered why Ed's snare drum seemed too lose power, tonally speaking, then I spotted those sticks cum beaters muffling the sound. He really needed a pair of Vic Firth 5As in my humble and even irrelevant opinion. Strangely one of the best Sing, Sing Sings I ever heard was by a schoolgirl band at Disneyland Tokyo who uncannily recreated the 1938 Krupa/Goodman classic. Still, nobody can beat that Krupa sound captured they say by a single overheard mike.
Fnarge 2 years ago
Thats true....check Barkers grip out....traditional when playing marching drums or on a pad....thats the proof...the links any of us who do with history and tradition on the drumset legacy. An instrument created here in the America in New Orleans. And Rich, Krupa, Shaugnessy, Bellson, Jo Jones are the fore fathers.....there are others and their hands they carry a proud American tradition. Barker knew Zildjian. Hed be the first to tell you. Have fun checkin it out , research the names youll see
fess04 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
yeh dude barker is a fucking master of jazz and many styls of music he is simply the gretest drummer of alltime
Travisbarker4prez 2 years ago
You apparently haven't seen any BR clips.And IF you have..then you are a complete idiot man...
buddy92585 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I met Ed Shaughnessy before and after winning a local drumset competition back in '95, I had the opportunity to have lunch with him. I was 17 at the time. He didn't really impress me. In fact, He's the one who told me he doesn't like drummers who use dbl bass and that I still had a long way to go to be good enough for a late talk show band. Upon finishing our lunch and saying our farewells, I began walking away. I finally turned and told Ed, "look me up when you want to learn dbl bass."
blackie901 2 years ago
i still like gene krupa's version better
DrummerBoyJustin 2 years ago 2
I find it great, how people always comment that one's better than the other... xD
this guy plays in a big band, Travis barker (I know who he is) but I forgot what music they play (I'm a metalhead myself) so... you've got two COMPLETELY different styles of playing.. and both are really good. though I prefer Ed here. you can feel the swing in the music. btw: being a fast drummer, doesn't mean you're a good one.
GabrielDragulia 2 years ago
oh, and to add something. not being able to play the Travis Barker score on guitar hero, doesn't make him a good player, it makes you a bad gamer ^^
GabrielDragulia 2 years ago
Pure Awesomeness! I dream to be as good!
Drokot1 2 years ago
WOW!!!! What a performance!
Baritone04 2 years ago
travisBrulzz. Do you have any friends ?
onejagjeff 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
are you retarted or somthing what part of travis wood kick this noobs ass dont you fuckingunderstand buckweet yoru becoming a wise ass and i have been nown to make exampels out of ashols such as yourself
travisBrulzz 2 years ago
Oh yeh ! How do you plan to do that?
onejagjeff 2 years ago
travis barker sucks
chiefindianlung 2 years ago 6
I read in an interview that Travis Barker actually looked up to drummers like Buddy Rich,Dennis Chambers,Stewart Copeland and Ed Shaugnessy..
DrummerMan1966 2 years ago
you are a little bit crazy, ill be honest
brad93hotmailcom 2 years ago
yeah um travis is good and all but it's the style music you like. plus there are alot better than travis out there. he is definantly not the best
trevorr12321 2 years ago 3
Perhaps it would be appropriate to explain that this performance, by the Cincinatti Pops Orch. is played as a musical tribute to the late Benny Goodman, Gene Krupa and Harry James ( plus the other fine musicians in Goodman's 1937 band ). They have been respectful to the original arrangement and Ed Shaughnessy has been totally respectful to Gene Krupa by just putting his own spin on the drum solo. Will anybody remember Travis Barker in 70 years time?
onejagjeff 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
youv been taking a lot of shit retart may i sugest you lisen to travis solo with 1 fucking arm and tell me that he canot punk out theise bitches with his fucking eyes close man your fucking stuipid
travisBrulzz 2 years ago
Am I really supposed to understand the ramblings of an illiterate moron?
onejagjeff 2 years ago 4
Travis is pretty damn solo compared to other speed drummers.
Hell, the fastest, Mike Mangini, does far more than just play fast.
therisen77 2 years ago
Travis Barker in my opinion is more of a performer rather than a truly gifted musician. The complexity, technique, style and variation of drummers like Buddy, Eddy, Dave (Weckl), Steve Gadd etc... Are a lot more appealing to me and motivating. I'm not trying to disrespect Travis here, but I think he's more about the image.
Oh and I'm 16 so there is no point in telling me that I'm just old and mentally stuck back in the old days :)
KillerQueen247 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck you penis head travis barker wood fucking pwn the living shit out of this old geezer fuckface you need to chang the battery in your fucking heering aid you geezer
travisBrulzz 2 years ago
I don't know what you are on but you must be going for the MORON of the year award.
onejagjeff 2 years ago 4
travisBrulzz. I don't know what you've got stuffed in your ears but just unstuff and listen to a great band propelled by one of the greatest drummers of all time with solos by two of the greatest instrumentalists Eddie Daniels and Doc Severinson.
onejagjeff 2 years ago
i'm shaking my head at your ignorance :S.
BryanNhisLP 2 years ago
The Master is Gene of the song .
julesmonendrumface 2 years ago
this was real good.
but yeah, i think travis barker is one of the most over rated drummers ever.
whbdrummer 2 years ago 2
this was great till he started barking like a rabid dog at 7:20. now if he only knew how to shave!
Skimsoco76 2 years ago
This guy is truly one of the greatest drummers of all time. His technique is perfect.
But believe it or not, there is a swiss foreign exchange student at my school this year who BLEW THIS PERFORMANCE OUT OF THE WATER. I'm not even kidding... I mean i knew the kid was good but i herd him play this at a concert tonight and almost fell out of my seat and to top it off i had to follow him Dx
--Props to this drummer and thumbs down to any no talent wannabe drummer boy who has the gal to dis him
DrumDrum83 2 years ago
!!!! i have been looking for this song since i was 7. i always just glazed over the title whenever i found it cuz i didnt think this would be the one... but i clicked on it by accient and... let me just say, some accidents are good ^_^
coralaisly 2 years ago 3
fallacies* even.
Just enjoy it. Stop being ignorant. Damn humans.
Insolence69 2 years ago
Amazing :)
Ah, so beautfiul. The Sound of true music, that is.
I agree 40x with you Insolence69.
How can things so different even be compared; they are like two opposite categories. And people should open their little tunnels to see what others might have to say.
Ps. We played this for marching band :)
slinkiesandpie22 2 years ago
I'm sure Travis and many other musicians of our time our great people, but in their own categories. Just like Ed is a great musician in Jazz. Everyone is titled to their opinions, but there is no necessity to start arguing over something that doesn't make sense. Don't compare two different things.
Not to mention, if you knew anything about the history of Jazz, you would know that some modern music is derived from Jazz and Blues.
Appreciate things, don't instinctively look for fallicies.
Insolence69 2 years ago
I'm tired of humans. All they do is argue in an illogical and uneducated manner.
It truly is disgusting and annoying to see sometimes.
Why can't everyone just take one second to understand the other person's point of view or the message some of these youtube videos are trying to get across?
Ed Shaughnessy, like many other great jazz musicians, is a significant figure of the 20th century. Why would you even begin to compare someone from our time, from another category of music, to Ed? Absurd.
Insolence69 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
have you seen travis play dumbass travis would wip this geezer with 1 fucking arm you faget
BLINK2BARKER 2 years ago
I've seen Barker play, and while I'm a great jazz drumming fan, I've got to admit that he's good...really good!!, but still light years away from the talent of Rich, Bellson, and even Shaughnessy here.
His only flaw, as far as I can see, is his ignorant and vulger fan base that makes him seem as cruddy as they present themselves to be.
brandashusband 2 years ago
wow... Could you sound any more like a Travis Barker fanboy. Yeah, he's good, but this is one of the original jazz drum virtuosos, who were the first to really show people what drums could do. I'm sure if Mr. Barker saw what you wrote, he would point out the fact that you're a dumbass, since it's jazz greats like this one that insipred him do develop his style of drumming.
laganwielder 2 years ago
really good clarinet playin'
CzaryMaryBoom 2 years ago 2
3.54-4.01...man i love how those classic drummers play, Ed doing that chop like he is pulling something with his right hand. OMG those drummer r like put their whole body with soul into rhythm itself! When i learn something new i also try to feel music not only in my head but with heart and soul! Don't bother with all those nubs saying jazz drummers r nothing. I play in prog metal band and my band always listen jazz and blues to pick up something new for prog metal
slivovich 2 years ago
He is good Dang Shaughnessey nice Ludwig Kit
Glicksterbanddrum 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
have you even seen travis play retard?? travis fucking owns
travisBrulzz 2 years ago
yes, i have. he's got nothing on this guy. you're clearly not a drummer or know any drum history.
BigT307 2 years ago
I used to love watching the Tonight Show when ! I was younger,and learning to play, and I loved the way Shawnee played ! I still do ! This cat realy swings !
gyro62 2 years ago
Salt and peanuts indeed, man I wish I could've seen this guy live!
RollingStone000 2 years ago
Why is Travis Barker being brought up. He's a different style drumming altogether. I'm sick of seeing it.
Drumguy1988 3 years ago 3
What about the dickshits that brought up joey jordison in EVERY SINGLE DRUM VIDEO OF ANY STYLE? man, i hate those
nifunifasoa 3 years ago 2
yea the jazz clarinet takes skill and this guy is great...but i think the jazz clarinet fits in better on other songs
im rather partial to trumpet and trombone solos on this song
VitalWound 3 years ago 2
the director is getting into it man
megagamer44 3 years ago
he is awesome man
i got 2 versions of this song
the are both in my vids
megagamer44 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
travis wood wipe the floor with the fucknoob on the drums
travisBrulzz 3 years ago
really there wouldnt be a travis barker without what you call a noob on the drums idiot
frikkinawsome 3 years ago
do you seriouly just go around and bash other drummers and spam shit about travis barker? I've seen you do it in multiple videos. No one cares about a PUNK drummer in a JAZZ video.
SpenceMakeSense 2 years ago
Salt Peanuts, Salt Peanuts! I love that song! :)
maalth 3 years ago
GO DOC GO!!!
theangrytruckdriver 3 years ago
BRAVO!
johnbambammorgan 3 years ago
No matter how hard that clarinet player tries, he won't be able to make jazz clarinet cool . LOL teachin drums
rebsteen 3 years ago
agreed. needs some dips and drops
but the drumming... is just... too good for the band
trumpet sounded nice but didnt like the solo
pie5135 3 years ago
Jazz Clarinet sounds very cool and takes a lot of skill. (Just like other instruments)
Just because you dislike it doesn't mean other people do as well. Drums aren't for everyone, and neither is clarinet.
To each his own, my friend.
woofiny 3 years ago