Amanda Palmer and Neil Gaiman belong to a cult that opposes free speech and free movement. Scientology runs prison camps for its members, litigates enemies into silence and is responsible for suicides and suspicious deaths worldwide. Gaiman grew up being audited and intimidated himself and is used to lying. He may not even realize he’s a hypocrite. Scientology persecutes gay men and woman, by supporting Prop 8 in CA along with so many crazy scams and crimes I can’t list here.
@DocFrobnitz Oh wow, project much? You're one to talk, building a psychological profile off a stranger's moment of emotional hypoerbole, (on Youtube, no less). Your massive assumptions are much more indicative of your questionable own emotional state than mine. Moreover, I was talking about the power dynamics specific to parent-child relationships, but thanks for putting your sanctimonious Gender Cop's two cents in. I suggest you pay more attention to your social disability.
You made a stupid "snips & snails & puppy-dog tails" comment, I called bullshit on general principles, and you responded with a clearly-practiced rant that you really should read, if you can spare a minute of being honest - not with me, I'm just somebody on the net; just with yourself, right where you are sitting now. (What do you have to fear? Sugar, spice, everything nice?) Or is putting others down what you need to feel good about yourself?
@DocFrobnitz Yeah, I made an overly sentimental and generalizing remark about a favorite song by a then-favorite artist a couple years ago. Something that was so incredibly offensive to you that you took the time to post a self-righteous tirade about it. And you're telling me that I need to look at myself? My turn to call bullshit. You started things by putting me down, and why? You aren't going to change my mind about anything, and all you've proven is that you're kind of an dick.
You can whatsoever right after listening to this song check the oasis one and think that everyone has his ups and downs, However, how the fuck can a person be so inspirational in both cases? I'm guessing having fucking as a middle name woks after all. Thank you Amanada :)
@xritinyo "How can a person be so inspirational in both cases?"
Partly by having the talent to write and play their own inspirational songs.
And partly by playing covers of songs that inspired her. Like this one, whwhere she covers a Dillie Keane/Fascinating Aïda song. Or "I Want You, But I Don't Need You", where she covers a Momus song. If it moves her, she knows it will probably move other people listening to her cover it.
I understand with this song, that we are fools, we want to do silly stuff trying alone, then we get pregnant, and we cry alone. We want to avoid that our daughter suffers from that, but of course she wants to be alone "No hands" ....
@mightykaytor ... says someone who doesn't appear to understand girls OR boys.
People feel. Happy, sad, fearful, defiant, regretful. Nothing in those feelings has anything to do with gender.
But I have noticed that people who say such silly things often don't have (or don't understand) feelings of their own, so they imagine that everyone else is as messed up as they are.
Pay more attention to your own feelings, less to imagining that everyone else shares your emotional disability.
I said this on another of her videos - I love the way you can feel the music so much more through her expressions as she sings the lyrics. Even just the changes in her voice. It's so beautiful. AFP is an amazing artist and this is one of the hugest reasons.
The original is NOT by Camille O'Sullivan. It's by Dillie Keane and was written sometime in the mid 1990s. It's on "It, Wit, Don't Give A Shit Girls" by "Fascinating Aida", Dillie Keane's group, from 1997. It was also covered by Patti LuPone on one of her albums around 1999.
It's on "It, Wit, Don't Give A Shit Girls" by "Fascinating Aida" - you can find it on iTunes. It was written by Dillie Keane (lead singer of Fascinating Aida) and has been covered by Patti LuPone on her album "Matters of the Heart" too.
Gonna go tell my mum I love her.
amanangel95 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Amanda Palmer and Neil Gaiman belong to a cult that opposes free speech and free movement. Scientology runs prison camps for its members, litigates enemies into silence and is responsible for suicides and suspicious deaths worldwide. Gaiman grew up being audited and intimidated himself and is used to lying. He may not even realize he’s a hypocrite. Scientology persecutes gay men and woman, by supporting Prop 8 in CA along with so many crazy scams and crimes I can’t list here.
blackholenebula1 2 months ago
I can't believe how this song always gets me. Tears on my cheeks every time.
Amanda is the only one able to do that. <3
mascaraeyes89 2 months ago
Yeah just cried. That happened.
manofcertaindeath 3 months ago 3
@DocFrobnitz Oh wow, project much? You're one to talk, building a psychological profile off a stranger's moment of emotional hypoerbole, (on Youtube, no less). Your massive assumptions are much more indicative of your questionable own emotional state than mine. Moreover, I was talking about the power dynamics specific to parent-child relationships, but thanks for putting your sanctimonious Gender Cop's two cents in. I suggest you pay more attention to your social disability.
mightykaytor 3 months ago
@mightykaytor No, I don't project much, no need.
You made a stupid "snips & snails & puppy-dog tails" comment, I called bullshit on general principles, and you responded with a clearly-practiced rant that you really should read, if you can spare a minute of being honest - not with me, I'm just somebody on the net; just with yourself, right where you are sitting now. (What do you have to fear? Sugar, spice, everything nice?) Or is putting others down what you need to feel good about yourself?
DocFrobnitz 3 months ago
@DocFrobnitz Yeah, I made an overly sentimental and generalizing remark about a favorite song by a then-favorite artist a couple years ago. Something that was so incredibly offensive to you that you took the time to post a self-righteous tirade about it. And you're telling me that I need to look at myself? My turn to call bullshit. You started things by putting me down, and why? You aren't going to change my mind about anything, and all you've proven is that you're kind of an dick.
mightykaytor 3 months ago
Oh how I just cried watching that.
ginladyofluck 4 months ago
I don't understand why this isn't a classic right now with like a million hits. It's such a touching performance.
teenagesewer 4 months ago 5
This made me cry, it's so beautiful though....amazing...
cat1mouse2 4 months ago
Irish FTW.
TheGrimLurker 5 months ago
You can whatsoever right after listening to this song check the oasis one and think that everyone has his ups and downs, However, how the fuck can a person be so inspirational in both cases? I'm guessing having fucking as a middle name woks after all. Thank you Amanada :)
xritinyo 5 months ago 2
@xritinyo "How can a person be so inspirational in both cases?"
Partly by having the talent to write and play their own inspirational songs.
And partly by playing covers of songs that inspired her. Like this one, whwhere she covers a Dillie Keane/Fascinating Aïda song. Or "I Want You, But I Don't Need You", where she covers a Momus song. If it moves her, she knows it will probably move other people listening to her cover it.
DocFrobnitz 3 months ago
Tks, it is sublime!!!
tuchatucha1 5 months ago
Absolutely incredible. The passion in the song is so perfect <3
stephiola 5 months ago 2
She has such incredible charisma and her voice is so tender in this video... love it =)
RedRosesDead 6 months ago 2
lyrics?
brudswick 8 months ago
amanda palmer is a cornered furry animal with very sharp teeth and rocking tits.
brudswick 8 months ago 4
Creepy shit.
AvaAmbition 8 months ago 2
@AvaAmbition OMG LOLOL. I know right.
He face is like FNGLSDFGJBNSDFGJSNDFLG.
Lmfaooooo. xD
sarahlovesbc13 8 months ago
@sarahlovesbc13 wow die.
mascaraeyes89 5 months ago
OH GAWD. her emotions in this <3333
DreadfulAngel666 8 months ago
I understand with this song, that we are fools, we want to do silly stuff trying alone, then we get pregnant, and we cry alone. We want to avoid that our daughter suffers from that, but of course she wants to be alone "No hands" ....
That's what I see in this wonderful song
dragaca 9 months ago
anyone knows the chords to this song?
SwissBajee 1 year ago
Beautiful beyond comprehension.
SakuraRosalie 1 year ago
amazing and totally moving
hana19992kaii10 1 year ago
this song always makes me cry.
420jayne 1 year ago
this song always makes me cry.
420jayne 1 year ago
Unless that tear was awkwardly placed sweat that tear was a tear and it was beautiful and so is she <3
winnconway 1 year ago
Her cover of this effects me so much. I get goosebumps and tears every single time I listen to it....i'd say 10,000 of the views are mine ;)
jenea4279 1 year ago
This song is to girls what Old Yeller is to boys.
mightykaytor 1 year ago
@mightykaytor I'm a boy and I can relate to this song far more than Old Yeller
TheBohemianTenor 1 year ago 11
@mightykaytor ... says someone who doesn't appear to understand girls OR boys.
People feel. Happy, sad, fearful, defiant, regretful. Nothing in those feelings has anything to do with gender.
But I have noticed that people who say such silly things often don't have (or don't understand) feelings of their own, so they imagine that everyone else is as messed up as they are.
Pay more attention to your own feelings, less to imagining that everyone else shares your emotional disability.
DocFrobnitz 3 months ago
oh my god..... i'm speechless...
phoenixpaliggesia 1 year ago 2
Oh my.
BriarRoseTv 1 year ago
Oh, this made me cry. What a beautiful song, and how beautifully Amanda sang it. How incredibly special this is.
propertyofranger 1 year ago 2
This was crazy. I almost cried. Which is a big deal for me haha Powerful. You rock...
LongStoryxMike 2 years ago 3
im pretty sure i saw that too. towards the end right?
LongStoryxMike 2 years ago
Amanda Palmer killed Amanda Palmer.
AlwaysTeatime 2 years ago
Sammydoodle14: The same happened at the WKAP memorial service I attended. I think some people even held their breath during the entire song!
Alecksnl 2 years ago
i love AFP <3
PeachChannel 2 years ago
i watched this my mom and we both cried!
lostfan 2 years ago 4
she sang this in noho, you could hear a pin drop. Everyone had chills.
Sammydoodle14 2 years ago 8
its ok, but i much prefer camille o'sullivan. shes bril! :D
selenarihanna 2 years ago 2
Amanda's tears brought on mine. Utterly exquisite
shiffy74 2 years ago 44
Brilliant, but for me the american pronunciation tips it in Dillie's favour.
Boratlon 2 years ago
best AFP performance ... i love this song
TashaP1987 2 years ago 3
Perfect.
christukie429 2 years ago 8
Comment removed
mightykaytor 2 years ago 25
Im haunted by this song...* shivers* so wonderfully done!!!!!! IM PROPERTY OF AFP!!!
ifuckingloveher 2 years ago 9
Absolutely beautiful :)
artemisiacc 2 years ago 6
great video, beautiful song, amazing woman
ironcountry 2 years ago 4
amazing... she is so perfect and astounding. this song gives me tingles
smcwilly08 2 years ago 4
this is so haunting, so beautiful...she played it when i saw her live, and i just started crying...she is absolutely amazing.
beautiful.
radicalrainbowofdoom 2 years ago 3
This made me cry too. and gave me goosebumps..this woman is amazing.
loveatfirstfright00 2 years ago 2
This is absolutely amazing. <3
perhapsjd 2 years ago
oh shes crying.......and i cry.......
libertine00 2 years ago
I said this on another of her videos - I love the way you can feel the music so much more through her expressions as she sings the lyrics. Even just the changes in her voice. It's so beautiful. AFP is an amazing artist and this is one of the hugest reasons.
pixiepoppp 3 years ago
She is perfection.
pinkblack179 3 years ago
absolutely amazing
pinknpurple1093 3 years ago
Perfect, perfect, perfect.
imafuckingworkofart 3 years ago
this song made me cry last October, and it does again. wonderful.
jetsque 3 years ago 3
Check out original version by Camille O'Sullivan too (see video response above)
ScaryBiscuits1 3 years ago 2
The original is NOT by Camille O'Sullivan. It's by Dillie Keane and was written sometime in the mid 1990s. It's on "It, Wit, Don't Give A Shit Girls" by "Fascinating Aida", Dillie Keane's group, from 1997. It was also covered by Patti LuPone on one of her albums around 1999.
dodgydutch 2 years ago
The original version of this arrangement is by Camille. All due Kudos to Dillie (and Amanda). :-)
ScaryBiscuits1 2 years ago
No emotion? Look into her eyes...I see emotion.... 4:57
jenea4279 3 years ago 7
I love her so much...simply beautiful...
jenea4279 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
draws no emotion. utter failure
suhlott 3 years ago
Amanda Palmer and her music get more and more beautiful each time I see/hear them.
AstronautAnachronism 3 years ago 5
OH MY GOD!!! That song is sooo beautiful and breathe taking and wonderful. What Album is it on? I want it right away.
meb1982 3 years ago 3
I don't believe it is on an album yet, it is a cover, Dillie Keane wrote the lyrics.
jenea4279 3 years ago
Thank you
meb1982 3 years ago
:) your welcome
jenea4279 3 years ago
It's on a Fascinating Aida album. So if you want to hear the writer sing it, then grab that.
VonBlade 3 years ago
It's on "It, Wit, Don't Give A Shit Girls" by "Fascinating Aida" - you can find it on iTunes. It was written by Dillie Keane (lead singer of Fascinating Aida) and has been covered by Patti LuPone on her album "Matters of the Heart" too.
dodgydutch 2 years ago
Breathtakingly beautiful.
xoxTNTxox16 3 years ago 2
i always cry whenever i watch this...and i REALLY did when i saw her live. it is beautiful.
FranleyK 3 years ago 4
This song is just so... LOVELY!
CaffeinatedCassadie 3 years ago