Created YouTub account just to say that if you've ever heard Maynard talking, he's kind of "nasaly" (2:11 for example). Probably sounds so much different because he's mostly whispering using a condenser mic (Ala Brian Johnson of AC/DC) instead of his full vocal style using his regular weapon err mic of choice a regular dee old dynamic Sure SM57.
I was excited to hear another version of a great song, but this is total shit. I wish I had never clicked on this garbage. They completely stripped this song of all the emotion and anger and it blows!
To the ppl who appreciate this regardless of who sings it a bug thumbs up. to all the others GTFO and go suck that nasty faggot maynard off. i mean wtf? MAYNARD? nice name bro. Though it REALLY sounds like manson is it too farfetched to believe it is? Look at the history. oh and everyone sings like shit sometimes. <3
Someone said Maynards vocals surpass this any day... WRONG! Maynards FARTS surpass this. Don't even compare this off key the entire song, whispering little bitch "singing" to maynards. Any TRUE Maynard fan would tell you from the first breath this isn't Maynard.
I member downloading this years ago and it was labelled Terrible Lie (Tool Cover). Which was funny, because i dunno how someone could fucking think this is Maynard.
@LingLingX8 You know this song was awesome when it was NIN but these guys made it better by using their emotions to show what the song really means...
@IWillSexU oh whatever... if it is YAY for him. if it isnt YAY for whoever did it. you dont need to get all defensive saying that it is for a fact when you dont actually know that it is him. okay. so shut up and stop fretting. its not like im commenting on everything say that it is or isnt him. so just shut up.
You should be reported for posting this piece of shit saying it's tool or manson. You are the biggest duesche bag in the world. You need to hear this from somebody. I can't stress enough how horrible this is. Are you deaf or just stupid. Do the world a favor and GO KILL YOURSELF!!!!!!!!!!! hahahaha hahahaha hahahah hahahaha
@mattzoni1 you should probably learn how to spell "douche" before trying to call someone one. it's really not that complicated of a word. just sayin'.
You suck bad. And for everyone even thinking it's half way descent, really think about what your saying. This is horrible. I've never heard a bigger pile of shit in my life. This has got to be a joke. Are you deaf?? You should be ashamed of yourself for trying to trick people in to listining to this utter pile of SHIT!! Matter a fact GO KILL YOURSELF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I hate to even get in this stupid debate but it is Tool from thier Rarities and Covered album. Also featured on that album is a great version of No Quarter (zeplin). KMFDM also covered Terrible Lie you should check that out! lol
@spanielmom93 Thank you for teaching all these no lifes a lesson. It absolutely is tool. (maynard) Everytime I pull this song there's a bunch of idiots claiming that this is spooks ill. or next month it will be someone else.lol
Thank you GothenburgMetalhead for taking the time and effort to finally END the debate of who is singing this song. As you can clearly see from his/her video response the Artist singing this song is Spooks Illustrated seein that they have a website listing this song as theirs you can check for yourselvs.
This is off a Manson album filled with cover songs named From Highway to Hell... If this were Maynard you would know it without a doubt thinking it might be someone else...
Hey lineaea1, I agree with you; it doesnt matter to me who's singing this song, it is one of the best covers ever <3 Thx for psoting it and Merry Christmas! ^.~
You guys are REALLY retarded if you think this is Maynard! Granted this is a great rendition of this song but, THERE IS NO WAY IN HELL Maynard would reduce his vocal capacity to the amature stumblings of a "kid" who got "lucky"! Besides if you listen to this CAREFULLY you will hear that it is not even his magnificent diaphramic beltings (as further proven in 3:29 and onward of this video). WAKE UP!!! Nice song though!
Well if you listen to any of Mansons songs, you can tell this isn't him, derp. Obviously not Trent. But very well could be one of the numerous band mates or just Maynard fucking around when tapeworm was going on...because it does sound like a tacky version of his voice. Probably MCR though, lololololol.
And, incidentally, i totally agree with everyone who thinks my voice is lame. But, gimme a break, i was like, 16 at the time. Had I known the tune would have lived on for 11 years, i would have done more than one take.
I thought you voice was ok. I would love for you to re-record it though. Do more takes and fuse together the best ones. You know, all that studio magic mumbo jumbo. It would be awesome!
This is neither Manson nor Maynard. It's ME. I recorded this back in 1998 at my friend Darcy's house when we were in a pseudo-band called Spooks Illustrated. I can't believe it's made the rounds on the internet ever since. Bizarre. Completely blows my mind. So yeah, end of debate. Not Manson, not Maynard; Criss Wolfman.
#10 is listed as "NIN acoustic cover from 1988". "Terrible Lie" was first released on NIN's album "Pretty Hate Machine" (1989). In 1988 Brian H. Warner didn't even think of making music by himself and wasn't able to play any instrument. The recording quality is better than anything that Marilyn Manson & The Spooky Kids had recorded until 1993.
This "cover" is a hoax and was not performed by Marilyn Manson
"Terrible Lie" is often credited as performed acoustic by Marilyn Manson. The song was in fact performed by Spooks Illustrated. It is a cover, originally written and performed by Nine Inch Nails in 1989.
this is manson.....and that rigth, .... anyone who knows Tool would know this isn't Maynard...and he is great too.....but the voice of manson is really peculiar
this is definitely not maynard. Maynard's voice is WAY deeper and i have this song as an mp3 but can't find the info for it!! I'm just ocd like that that i have to have all of my stuff organized and named correctly.
I have it under "tool" just because i don't want it to be "unknown"
it's clearly not maynard or manson & quite frankly it's irrelevant any real music lover would appreciate the song 4 wot it is n not who does or doesn't sing it
Funny, I was thinking anyone who knows Tool would know this isn't Maynard, but some dude in his bedroom doing a pretty lame Maynard impression with some pretty bad recording equipment, and sloppy acoustic playing.
there's no way this is maynard, not even a chance, and it's not marilyn either, maynard would sing it very differently too, i think, but it's still pretty good, i enjoyed it.
I think it's pretty sad that people keeps saying that this is Maynard when you can look up and see that Manson did this on his "At Satan's Request" album.
again regardless of who it is it's still a good cover, though I don't hear MM in it at all, I can somewhat hear Maynard but again I don't think it's him either but it could be... Great cover of a great song
Ok, I've listened it to the end, and I'm sure it's neither MJK, nor MM, just listen the last part of song... Still, quite a decent cover though, made me think what could've Tapeworm Project been. Cheers! :)
i think its pretty sad that people cant look up and see that trent and maynard was in the studio with eacother in that band, tapeworm... if people knew this they would stop saying that manson did this...
Maynard and trent did it in a yellow sub under the sea with umpa lumpas while they were smoking crack and getting high on pcp. Of corse since the umpa lumpas got the copy rights trent and maynard could never take claim to it.. And everyone knows umpa lumpas cant come out in public or they will melt.
This is one of the best covors of this song on the internet, idc what anyone says about the vocals, if the vocals are that bad than make a better one yourself, but untill than im stickin with this one
how unbelievably obvious do you have to get.. NOT MAYNARD!! don't disgrace him with this shitty cover.. manson has not done anyone a favor here.. especially nin..
This is neither Keenan or Manson. This version doesn't touch Trent's with the generic chords and half hearted vocals. How was anyone ever even convinced this was either of them? Hahahaha
it is on the marilyns cover album: from highway to hell. But i have given up on trying to convince the people who says its not manson, but i am 100% positive that it is manson.
Check the discograpy or download the album or buy the album.
LISTEN TO THE END....if u still think its maynard then your crazy.. it sounds like a 15 yr old kid in his room with a one track recorder lol... DEFINETLY NOT maynard at all
Why can't we just appreciate the beauty of this song? Seriously, I don't agree with editorials but I don't agree with calling other people faggots because of what they listen to. I enjoy the cover and would prefer not to sit here all day and bitch about it. (162 characters remainging, so I didn't do a 500 character editorial, jerks.)
Jeez, the people commenting on this page really need to get a life. You're probably all a bunch of virgin 17-year-olds trying to make up for your inadequacies with your little 500-character editorials. You don't come off as smart, you come off as a bunch of pathetic faggots (and faggirls...)
Your comment.."the people commenting on this page really need to get a life."
So your not a person and you didnt comment on this page?
Stop being delusional.. your a hypocrite.. learn to fully comprehend a critism instead of lashing out with childish words like.."faggot" and "no i didnt" statements with no logical evidence to back it up.
lol what are you a angry insecure child who was neglected by their parents?
Again, you're the one who's telling people to stop having opinions, that's a hell of a lot worse than thinking a song is shitty. Music is something that's subjective, if you think the song is supposed to be sentimental and whiny, go right ahead. I don't. Stop telling me what I should and shouldn't think. You're fucking stupid if you think saying a song is shitty is affecting society as a whole. Wake the fuck up sweetie and realize there are bigger things going on.
I thought most people covered this "One person saying 'yada yada' doesn't mean 'yada yada'" moral dilemma in Elementary School. If you were the only person doing it, I wouldn't care.
Also, 'it sucks' and 'I think it sucks', are two completely different things. The way you say it drowns your words in more hypocrisy contradicting with your statement than anything I could hope to say.
hmm I have to say, you both have valid points, music is mainly preference as long as it maintains a solid tempo and is played along the lines of a time signature, but there are songs that have a lot more meaning when the person writing the song allows their emotion to carry it or others who strongly relate to the song have an emotional binding and release it in a musical form, I don't know if anyone can do that better than Treant did with this song, but in the end it is just a song.
This is sang in the same mannor as "something I can never have" by NIN. Full of emotion. I think its a good cover and 99% of you idiots out there cant even do anything close to what this unknown singer did. Show a little respect for the art and how it can be interept many ways.
I love how you use 'shit' like there is somehow an overbearing criteria for what people are allowed to enjoy and what they aren't. Tastes are subjective, you whiny bitch. Live with the fact that you're the odd one out, and most people enjoy this cover. Or keep saturating this page in your whiny shit. Whichever.
I love how you're bitching like a little emo girl about how the music industry sucks because my thoughts on a shit cover when you're the one oppressing other's opinions. Maybe if you don't like what I think of a song, you shoudn't read my comments. Last time I checked, as a citizen of the US, I have freedom of press, meaning I can type whatever the fuck I want.
Terrible Lie is meant to an aggressive, angry song, not some whiny cover with terrible vocals.
Freedom of the Press has nothing to do with making a whiny youtube comment. You're thinking of Freedom of Speech, common mistake my the uneducated.
Secondly, you're a cancerous tumor on the side of the music industry not because of your tastes but because of how you ignorantly project them across a medium like they should be written in stone.
Thirdly, you didn't write the song. Stop saying what YOU think it's meant to be like an ignorant twat.
Just to finish that up, if you think you can do better, than do it. By bet is that you can't though. You're the kind of uninteresting, petty, self-interested person that will sit and judge something from the safety of a computer monitor, while providing nothing to society of your own. Congratulations, you're a detriment to society as a whole.
Created YouTub account just to say that if you've ever heard Maynard talking, he's kind of "nasaly" (2:11 for example). Probably sounds so much different because he's mostly whispering using a condenser mic (Ala Brian Johnson of AC/DC) instead of his full vocal style using his regular weapon err mic of choice a regular dee old dynamic Sure SM57.
Anonerous 23 hours ago in playlist Tool
Agree with nedak. How could anyone mistake this for either MJK or Manson? Go to ANY of their other songs and compare. Herp derp, folks. Herp derp.
tnsraven 5 days ago
People seriously thought this was maynard? HAHAAHAHAHAA. Anyway, it's still good. But he's not singing it clearly.
libreg 6 days ago
Maynard is flawless. Its definately not him... It's some dude covering it, thats all.
whiteclover07 2 weeks ago in playlist Tool
This is Maynard, you dumb asses. Go choke yourself.
richiebest2 1 month ago
Honestly I dont think it is MJK because of a few times he falters...its still a good cover good job bro...so close
usafadb 2 months ago
I was excited to hear another version of a great song, but this is total shit. I wish I had never clicked on this garbage. They completely stripped this song of all the emotion and anger and it blows!
jhunterhenson 3 months ago
It's way too soft. It lacks the "anger" of the original.
Hey, you should cover something from cannibal corpse! :D
Liquocelot 3 months ago
This is so good.
madder66mortem 5 months ago
Sadly, only my girlfriend and I will know who really did this song. :) (p.s. you're all wrong. hahaha ~sturrs up the trolls).
Unleashed2k 5 months ago
To the ppl who appreciate this regardless of who sings it a bug thumbs up. to all the others GTFO and go suck that nasty faggot maynard off. i mean wtf? MAYNARD? nice name bro. Though it REALLY sounds like manson is it too farfetched to believe it is? Look at the history. oh and everyone sings like shit sometimes. <3
THEJAKEANATOR666 5 months ago
Someone said Maynards vocals surpass this any day... WRONG! Maynards FARTS surpass this. Don't even compare this off key the entire song, whispering little bitch "singing" to maynards. Any TRUE Maynard fan would tell you from the first breath this isn't Maynard.
MordecaiZ28 5 months ago
@MordecaiZ28 its a good cover stop being a total asshole
TheNineinchsnails 3 months ago
@TheNineinchsnails I'm guessing you're the talentless piece of shit that's singing this fuckhole of a song. It's a horrible cover.
MordecaiZ28 3 months ago
@MordecaiZ28 I bet you think you are cool for being a asshole on the internet
TheNineinchsnails 3 months ago
@TheNineinchsnails I'll be an asshole to your face and knock some fuckin sense into you.
MordecaiZ28 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MordecaiZ28 k internet bad ass
TheNineinchsnails 3 months ago
Comment removed
SmileTia33 6 months ago
Comment removed
SmileTia33 6 months ago
let me die...
quintenskevin 8 months ago
this is the best shit i ve ever heard. the guy who sing is unknow.
quintenskevin 8 months ago
This neither MJK or Manson...you have to be fucking retarded to hear the resemblance.
nedak 11 months ago 4
@nedak this is maynard.
JamieColeson 3 months ago
This is fucking rubbish
MythicShot 11 months ago
Horrible!
zyniker88 11 months ago
This doesn't sound like Maynard J. Keenan at all. Just thought I would share my two cents, even though it's been made clear that this ain't Tool.
Blockization 11 months ago
This is just awful! This doesn't capture the mood of the lyrics nor put a new spin on the original version. and the guitart playing... gimme a break
BjGard 11 months ago
it makes me laugh people think this is maynard =))
benevolentzombie 1 year ago
it's maynard.
MegaTeddyballgame 1 year ago
I member downloading this years ago and it was labelled Terrible Lie (Tool Cover). Which was funny, because i dunno how someone could fucking think this is Maynard.
sparkydeltorro 1 year ago
nope, i can't believe people can think that this is Maynard... Maynard's vocals surpass this any day!
neworder36 1 year ago
This song has the same melody as "The Scientist" by Coldplay. Hah.
SukiWukiDookie 1 year ago
@SukiWukiDookie you mean Coldplay ripped the melody from this. Because that's what Coldplay does. and this song has been around for over 20 years.
faded23 1 year ago
@SukiWukiDookie coldplay sucks so bad.
MegaTeddyballgame 1 year ago
Comment removed
SukiWukiDookie 1 year ago
THis Is Neither Maynard Or Manson.. Im Sorry Ut Neither of them sound like this ESPECIALLY MAYNARD hahahha
nineinchnails93 1 year ago
It's by the guy from Tool.
OhMyGodSANDWICH 1 year ago
It's obviously Justin Bieber.
InKa4484 1 year ago 11
this is maynard you douchbags
digitallysick 1 year ago 2
))))))
ClintJCL 1 year ago
hell, this song needs more aggression and power. Playing Terrible Lie acoustic is blasphemy :p
LingLingX8 1 year ago
@LingLingX8 You know this song was awesome when it was NIN but these guys made it better by using their emotions to show what the song really means...
beautyfulbecky 11 months ago
It acutually is on an unrelesed album but it Maynard solo! Not Tool or Manson. But it is for a fact Maynard!
Glassora 1 year ago
Even though i KNOW this isnt Maynard nor Manson, i still think this song sounds good either way.
painxisxanxillusion 1 year ago
Comment removed
IWillSexU 1 year ago
@IWillSexU oh whatever... if it is YAY for him. if it isnt YAY for whoever did it. you dont need to get all defensive saying that it is for a fact when you dont actually know that it is him. okay. so shut up and stop fretting. its not like im commenting on everything say that it is or isnt him. so just shut up.
painxisxanxillusion 1 year ago
Who the fuck thought this was Manson, that doesn't even begin to make sense.
adrenacrumb 1 year ago
You should be reported for posting this piece of shit saying it's tool or manson. You are the biggest duesche bag in the world. You need to hear this from somebody. I can't stress enough how horrible this is. Are you deaf or just stupid. Do the world a favor and GO KILL YOURSELF!!!!!!!!!!! hahahaha hahahaha hahahah hahahaha
mattzoni1 1 year ago
@mattzoni1 you should probably learn how to spell "douche" before trying to call someone one. it's really not that complicated of a word. just sayin'.
BreFgt 1 year ago
@mattzoni1 Apparently you have no idea what life truly is.. NIN was awesome this one is better when you get older you'll understand
beautyfulbecky 11 months ago
You suck bad. And for everyone even thinking it's half way descent, really think about what your saying. This is horrible. I've never heard a bigger pile of shit in my life. This has got to be a joke. Are you deaf?? You should be ashamed of yourself for trying to trick people in to listining to this utter pile of SHIT!! Matter a fact GO KILL YOURSELF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
mattzoni1 1 year ago
This sounds like Placebo's vocalist.
BASEfuckingLINE 1 year ago
@BASEfuckingLINE No way!
madder66mortem 1 year ago
wow you turned it into a pussy song.
V19torrent 1 year ago 2
to make an end : this is tool
aklista 1 year ago
Guys I just learned this was song is a cover done by Justin Beaver, not Maynard or Manson.
protip123 1 year ago
rofl this is not maynard anyone who has listened to tools first album can distinguish this!
dotslashsatan 1 year ago
singing? this is not maynard singing so shut up
xspacecadetx 1 year ago
this is not maynard or manson. it's an okay cover but maynard and manson are WAY better than this.
Glassandcandy 1 year ago
@MelodeathMetalcore i know XD thats y i did it
0NauGhT0 1 year ago
coz i just wana do this....maynards vocals on this song are amazing
0NauGhT0 1 year ago
i like this version more than the original one..
lovelovewed13 1 year ago
I hate to even get in this stupid debate but it is Tool from thier Rarities and Covered album. Also featured on that album is a great version of No Quarter (zeplin). KMFDM also covered Terrible Lie you should check that out! lol
spanielmom93 1 year ago
@spanielmom93 Thank you for teaching all these no lifes a lesson. It absolutely is tool. (maynard) Everytime I pull this song there's a bunch of idiots claiming that this is spooks ill. or next month it will be someone else.lol
nothingfeel99 1 year ago
@nothingfeel99 It's clearly not Maynard. Sounds nothing like him.
blackdakhma 1 year ago
Comment removed
bradlom80 2 years ago
@bradlom80 - its not Maynard either
DystopiasFall 2 years ago
im glad i fell for the "its maynard" myth.... this song is freaking AWESOME!!!!!!!!! :D
DystopiasFall 2 years ago
its not bad but it's definatly not Maynard and manson is a shitty singer this is better than manson
Sappy22889 2 years ago
@Sappy22889 don't be stupid this is manard
nothingfeel99 1 year ago
Thank you GothenburgMetalhead for taking the time and effort to finally END the debate of who is singing this song. As you can clearly see from his/her video response the Artist singing this song is Spooks Illustrated seein that they have a website listing this song as theirs you can check for yourselvs.
lineaea1 2 years ago
This is off a Manson album filled with cover songs named From Highway to Hell... If this were Maynard you would know it without a doubt thinking it might be someone else...
rigbchas 2 years ago
LOL this is NOT Marilyn Manson OR Maynard James Keenan
PROOF: watch?v=8f5c7k1gJSw
GothenburgMetalhead 2 years ago
Hey lineaea1, I agree with you; it doesnt matter to me who's singing this song, it is one of the best covers ever <3 Thx for psoting it and Merry Christmas! ^.~
tendersin 2 years ago
You guys are REALLY retarded if you think this is Maynard! Granted this is a great rendition of this song but, THERE IS NO WAY IN HELL Maynard would reduce his vocal capacity to the amature stumblings of a "kid" who got "lucky"! Besides if you listen to this CAREFULLY you will hear that it is not even his magnificent diaphramic beltings (as further proven in 3:29 and onward of this video). WAKE UP!!! Nice song though!
nickneff9 2 years ago
who the fuck even started the MANSOn thing? this is obviously Maynrd. however u spell it. obvious a fuck to me
NOTkwyteRITE 2 years ago
Well if you listen to any of Mansons songs, you can tell this isn't him, derp. Obviously not Trent. But very well could be one of the numerous band mates or just Maynard fucking around when tapeworm was going on...because it does sound like a tacky version of his voice. Probably MCR though, lololololol.
KA1NL 2 years ago
And, incidentally, i totally agree with everyone who thinks my voice is lame. But, gimme a break, i was like, 16 at the time. Had I known the tune would have lived on for 11 years, i would have done more than one take.
CrissWolfman 2 years ago
I thought you voice was ok. I would love for you to re-record it though. Do more takes and fuse together the best ones. You know, all that studio magic mumbo jumbo. It would be awesome!
ComaAlpha 2 years ago
I call bullshit mate
I know its neither, and it was a dude on his own, but we need more proof?
abyssus99 2 years ago
lame? r u kidding me dude? you call your voice lame when u actually got MILLIONS of people honestly believing u r Maynard James Keenan singing this?
GothenburgMetalhead 2 years ago
This is neither Manson nor Maynard. It's ME. I recorded this back in 1998 at my friend Darcy's house when we were in a pseudo-band called Spooks Illustrated. I can't believe it's made the rounds on the internet ever since. Bizarre. Completely blows my mind. So yeah, end of debate. Not Manson, not Maynard; Criss Wolfman.
CrissWolfman 2 years ago
tha shit. stop the comments here, bc thats all that cab be said
NOTkwyteRITE 2 years ago
not tool.
ozzilla45 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
its me singing
basilis6 2 years ago
This is Spooks Illustrated - Terrible Lie (NIN cover)
puresickdead 2 years ago
#10 is listed as "NIN acoustic cover from 1988". "Terrible Lie" was first released on NIN's album "Pretty Hate Machine" (1989). In 1988 Brian H. Warner didn't even think of making music by himself and wasn't able to play any instrument. The recording quality is better than anything that Marilyn Manson & The Spooky Kids had recorded until 1993.
This "cover" is a hoax and was not performed by Marilyn Manson
Anecm 2 years ago
another note, of what i found.
Terrible Lie"
"Terrible Lie" is often credited as performed acoustic by Marilyn Manson. The song was in fact performed by Spooks Illustrated. It is a cover, originally written and performed by Nine Inch Nails in 1989.
Anecm 2 years ago 7
it's DEFINITELY someone ELSE!!!
if someone said it's maynard or manson they don't have ears
fantastic piece
j0nnyr3ap3r 2 years ago
WICKED version of SONG!
ea76 2 years ago
I LOVE this.
emilyvsjwalkable 2 years ago
maynard is always drunk and he'll never sing something like that xD
1203adrianrasta 2 years ago
uhm,...well...i think tool would never have done something like that. never. just listen to that shitty improvising at 3:23
sickboyduke 2 years ago
i think its james blunt
sickboyduke 2 years ago
this is manson.....and that rigth, .... anyone who knows Tool would know this isn't Maynard...and he is great too.....but the voice of manson is really peculiar
Vampire235Leinhart 2 years ago
what if he was drunk
obscureface 2 years ago
Rootwitch right on....without some kid in his room....NOT maynard
carbonpoly 2 years ago
Comment removed
alienjesus2012 2 years ago
How could it be from 1988 anyway? Pretty Hate Machine was released in '89.
deeperthewound 2 years ago
Marilyn Manson
At Satans Request
Terrible Lie (Acoustic NIN Cover From 1988)
Chanelle185 2 years ago
this is definitely not maynard. Maynard's voice is WAY deeper and i have this song as an mp3 but can't find the info for it!! I'm just ocd like that that i have to have all of my stuff organized and named correctly.
I have it under "tool" just because i don't want it to be "unknown"
mikes2008 2 years ago
it's clearly not maynard or manson & quite frankly it's irrelevant any real music lover would appreciate the song 4 wot it is n not who does or doesn't sing it
cityboyjim 2 years ago
anyone who knows tool and apc can tell this is maynard
robertlport 2 years ago
Funny, I was thinking anyone who knows Tool would know this isn't Maynard, but some dude in his bedroom doing a pretty lame Maynard impression with some pretty bad recording equipment, and sloppy acoustic playing.
Rootwitch06 2 years ago
actually, i am SURE this is the Tool acoustic cover. rapidshare it!
orinsinclair 2 years ago
Who the hell sang this? Manson? Someone tell me please.
TheDivineVessel 2 years ago
Tool does a great acoustic cover of terrible lie, sounds much like this!
orinsinclair 2 years ago
no one can agree because no one fucking knows. i have it filed under artist unknown, along with the mysterious industrial cover of 'like a virgin'
alienjesus2012 2 years ago
there's no way this is maynard, not even a chance, and it's not marilyn either, maynard would sing it very differently too, i think, but it's still pretty good, i enjoyed it.
maynardminion 2 years ago
I think it's pretty sad that people keeps saying that this is Maynard when you can look up and see that Manson did this on his "At Satan's Request" album.
ibanezmaverickdude 2 years ago
This is not Maynard but it is very good.
electricfeline 2 years ago 2
maynard or no maynard, this is amazing. -.-
teenagezombie101 2 years ago
this is an amatuer singer, who just happens to be talented it all. Its not maynard or anyone else
randyds5 2 years ago
Comment removed
kingkoopahtown 2 years ago
Hey Jamma!
If you cant Appreciate Music enough to care, you can stick your head up your non careing ass!! =D
luzcifero 2 years ago
Don`t be stupid. I dont mean you are, but if you waste your life discussing about bullshit, you are gonna have a horrible death,
jamma 2 years ago
There's no way this is maynard
WRF713 2 years ago 2
yeah, he's trying to sound like Maynard but there's no fuckin way. I don't even think this fella is that good.
sparkydeltorro 2 years ago 2
Love this version so much better, love NIN version too but this one is just great=]
420Stonerchic420 2 years ago
I've heard this verson before!
but i cant find who ever made it!
sons of bitches! thanks for posting
luzcifero 2 years ago
this is Maynard
rupertstube 2 years ago
its not manson or keenan. neither of them suck this bad at guitar
sudajmahi 2 years ago 8
again regardless of who it is it's still a good cover, though I don't hear MM in it at all, I can somewhat hear Maynard but again I don't think it's him either but it could be... Great cover of a great song
SeanTx2 2 years ago 2
Ok, I've listened it to the end, and I'm sure it's neither MJK, nor MM, just listen the last part of song... Still, quite a decent cover though, made me think what could've Tapeworm Project been. Cheers! :)
humbaka 2 years ago 3
damn, i wish tapeworm came to be
randyds5 2 years ago
i think its pretty sad that people cant look up and see that trent and maynard was in the studio with eacother in that band, tapeworm... if people knew this they would stop saying that manson did this...
kpyrofreak 2 years ago
Sounds much more like Keenan than Manson, although I'm not sure if it's really someone else singing...
humbaka 2 years ago
Maynard and trent did it in a yellow sub under the sea with umpa lumpas while they were smoking crack and getting high on pcp. Of corse since the umpa lumpas got the copy rights trent and maynard could never take claim to it.. And everyone knows umpa lumpas cant come out in public or they will melt.
magnuslee2000 2 years ago 2
Sounds a bit like "The Scientist" by Coldplay...
Not Keenan.
Fergydew323 2 years ago
I wonder who REALLY did this and more so I wonder why they have never claimed it, its pretty good.
Mikemillering1 2 years ago
they were both amateurs at one point in their lives. you don't know if it's them or not. do you see them?..no, so you don't know
tannerss09 2 years ago
going from amateur to professional you're voice won't go from suck to great
mikes2008 2 years ago
What a beautiful song!!!!!!
lvaprile 2 years ago
This doesn't sound anything like Maynard or Manson, at all. It sounds pretty amateur-ish, honestly.
shinokugt 2 years ago
i guess im the only dumbass on youtube that has attempted to redo all the actual music to this song and atleast TRY to do it properly.
angie4josh 2 years ago
It's Maynard, I was there when he recorded it.
tannerss09 2 years ago
......
nin4lifefan 2 years ago
why all the tool imagery when this is a NIN song and clearly is NOT maynard?
jbphns 2 years ago
because it's a nin COVER :)
everybody should chill, and enjoy the song hehe
jegergammelnokspade 2 years ago
special track:D
kfgvulg3t43 3 years ago
maynard
crossraiyne 3 years ago
this is neither manson or maynard, just some private person i'd say. Great cover.
zejnulla 3 years ago
This is one of the best covors of this song on the internet, idc what anyone says about the vocals, if the vocals are that bad than make a better one yourself, but untill than im stickin with this one
Dragonheart2084 3 years ago
how unbelievably obvious do you have to get.. NOT MAYNARD!! don't disgrace him with this shitty cover.. manson has not done anyone a favor here.. especially nin..
calmzombie 3 years ago
It could be Jeordie/Twiggy. Sounds a lot like him.
Jaaaaam 3 years ago
lmao I can't believe any of you guys think it's Maynard.
Honestly, I always thought it was Manson, but until I searched the song up on here, and realized that no one knew. lol
I got it with one of the Manson albums so I figured it was him. But now I have no idea.
But it is OBVIOUSLY not Maynard. Jesus... Maynard sounds NOTHING like this... it's hilarious that anyone would say it's him.
XxPsYcHo66xX 3 years ago
this is not manson or maynard...manson doesnt sound anything like this 1st off...and maynars vocals wouldnt get fucked up later in the song so yea
perabola 3 years ago
it's manson's singing
Siusiakus1 3 years ago
Not Maynard. Maynard's voice is way more epic.
VanityInPerson 3 years ago
you're doing it wrong
mattkoon 3 years ago
This is neither Keenan or Manson. This version doesn't touch Trent's with the generic chords and half hearted vocals. How was anyone ever even convinced this was either of them? Hahahaha
speciesofpositive 3 years ago
This is 100% not maynard. If anyone thinks this is maynard, they are very clearly not a tool fan.
BellJH 3 years ago
I thought it was at first then after listening to it later on and after a few songs figured it wasnt, doesnt sound like manson either
dragoonmaster1781 3 years ago
is this manson or not?
chhampus 3 years ago
No. Seriously, do you think that wanker could ever sound like this? It's Maynard.
veloriumcaptain 3 years ago
it is on the marilyns cover album: from highway to hell. But i have given up on trying to convince the people who says its not manson, but i am 100% positive that it is manson.
Check the discograpy or download the album or buy the album.
bigbigstrid 3 years ago
although it is it is on their with an unknown artist
katmannsson 3 years ago
Beautiful
SteveVayne 3 years ago
LISTEN TO THE END....if u still think its maynard then your crazy.. it sounds like a 15 yr old kid in his room with a one track recorder lol... DEFINETLY NOT maynard at all
laynestaley1990 3 years ago
its def. not maynard, maynard would have sung it way better, plus the yells at the end would have been more epic if it was maynard.
salival7 3 years ago
Why can't we just appreciate the beauty of this song? Seriously, I don't agree with editorials but I don't agree with calling other people faggots because of what they listen to. I enjoy the cover and would prefer not to sit here all day and bitch about it. (162 characters remainging, so I didn't do a 500 character editorial, jerks.)
EpixMusic 3 years ago
dumb ass people
TOOLGODDESSTT 3 years ago
Jeez, the people commenting on this page really need to get a life. You're probably all a bunch of virgin 17-year-olds trying to make up for your inadequacies with your little 500-character editorials. You don't come off as smart, you come off as a bunch of pathetic faggots (and faggirls...)
aleistorchrist 3 years ago
since your commenting on this page trying to comeoff like a smart ass but come off as a pathetic faggot too...
so i assume your a 17 year old virgin trying to make up for your inadequacies?
LOL a people critisizing while being oblivious to the fact there on the same boat to.
You FAIL big time.
utube793 3 years ago
And YOU need to learn how to read, you little faggot. There's no hypocrisy in what I said.
aleistorchrist 3 years ago
Your comment.."the people commenting on this page really need to get a life."
So your not a person and you didnt comment on this page?
Stop being delusional.. your a hypocrite.. learn to fully comprehend a critism instead of lashing out with childish words like.."faggot" and "no i didnt" statements with no logical evidence to back it up.
lol what are you a angry insecure child who was neglected by their parents?
utube793 3 years ago
again..you FAIL big time.
utube793 3 years ago
Again, you're the one who's telling people to stop having opinions, that's a hell of a lot worse than thinking a song is shitty. Music is something that's subjective, if you think the song is supposed to be sentimental and whiny, go right ahead. I don't. Stop telling me what I should and shouldn't think. You're fucking stupid if you think saying a song is shitty is affecting society as a whole. Wake the fuck up sweetie and realize there are bigger things going on.
NatalyaNecro 3 years ago
Keep crying.
I thought most people covered this "One person saying 'yada yada' doesn't mean 'yada yada'" moral dilemma in Elementary School. If you were the only person doing it, I wouldn't care.
Also, 'it sucks' and 'I think it sucks', are two completely different things. The way you say it drowns your words in more hypocrisy contradicting with your statement than anything I could hope to say.
SnakeTheFox 3 years ago
hmm I have to say, you both have valid points, music is mainly preference as long as it maintains a solid tempo and is played along the lines of a time signature, but there are songs that have a lot more meaning when the person writing the song allows their emotion to carry it or others who strongly relate to the song have an emotional binding and release it in a musical form, I don't know if anyone can do that better than Treant did with this song, but in the end it is just a song.
-Mystic
MysticVisage 3 years ago
This is sang in the same mannor as "something I can never have" by NIN. Full of emotion. I think its a good cover and 99% of you idiots out there cant even do anything close to what this unknown singer did. Show a little respect for the art and how it can be interept many ways.
steamclean 3 years ago 3
agreed. it has the same depth of emotion, just shown in a different spectrum of emotion.
0withteeth0 3 years ago
seriously this is bullshit
robcrob 3 years ago
I don't care who the fuck it's by, it sucks.
Terrible Lie is meant to be an angry aggresive song, not some whiny bitch song.
NatalyaNecro 3 years ago
You're the cancer killing the music world.
SnakeTheFox 3 years ago
You're the reason there are still shit covers like this.
NatalyaNecro 3 years ago
I love how you use 'shit' like there is somehow an overbearing criteria for what people are allowed to enjoy and what they aren't. Tastes are subjective, you whiny bitch. Live with the fact that you're the odd one out, and most people enjoy this cover. Or keep saturating this page in your whiny shit. Whichever.
SnakeTheFox 3 years ago
I love how you're bitching like a little emo girl about how the music industry sucks because my thoughts on a shit cover when you're the one oppressing other's opinions. Maybe if you don't like what I think of a song, you shoudn't read my comments. Last time I checked, as a citizen of the US, I have freedom of press, meaning I can type whatever the fuck I want.
Terrible Lie is meant to an aggressive, angry song, not some whiny cover with terrible vocals.
NatalyaNecro 3 years ago
Freedom of the Press has nothing to do with making a whiny youtube comment. You're thinking of Freedom of Speech, common mistake my the uneducated.
Secondly, you're a cancerous tumor on the side of the music industry not because of your tastes but because of how you ignorantly project them across a medium like they should be written in stone.
Thirdly, you didn't write the song. Stop saying what YOU think it's meant to be like an ignorant twat.
SnakeTheFox 3 years ago
Just to finish that up, if you think you can do better, than do it. By bet is that you can't though. You're the kind of uninteresting, petty, self-interested person that will sit and judge something from the safety of a computer monitor, while providing nothing to society of your own. Congratulations, you're a detriment to society as a whole.
SnakeTheFox 3 years ago
You have freedom of speech, you're not the press.