It was still in when I went to see it, it was really creepy, but good too :) it fits in anyway, michael and jane are pretty bad brats before mary poppins comes, that's kinda the whole point :') xx
i saw the musical with this song in it. yes, i do admit it was a LITTLE scary, but it did get the message and it was my favorite part of the musical. so sad it is out of the musical now :(
This is really good music-wise, but I can understand why it was taken out. I've never seen the play, so I can't picture the scene. However, this song freaks me out, and I'm not exactly a little kid. "Children who refuse to learn will not return," is kind of nightmare fuel-ish to me.
@imafan25 the reason y they put it in was to scare the Banks children not scare the kids in audience so much that that's all they'll remember. I agree it is a loss but Playing the Game is still good
What?! They took it out because it scared kids? Isn't the point? What kind of douche would complain so much about this to the point the song would need to be changed? If it scares your kids leave them at home so the adults can enjoy the show the way the creators intended...
@imafan25. It's one thing to include scary segments in something that parents will expect to be scary. However, if you don't do research on the play itself and take your four year old to see Mary Poppins as their first Broadway show, you will be quite surprised, shocked, and upset to have a segment of nightmare-fuel right in the middle that forces you to leave when your kid won't go back after intermission because they are scared of the giant toys.
LOVE THIS SONG. First time I saw this I was freaked out but I watched it again and I really enjoy the creepiness of it. :P but then they ruined it and made "playing the Game" :(
Oh my gosh! A group at regional acting competion last year performed this... SO FREAKY!!!!!!!!!!! I understand why they took it out. It's disney... People expect it to be child friendly. But this is a flipping amazing song!
@emopinata12345 I doubt they'll ever release the rights. The production in New York and On Tour sells out nightly. But I would love to see an amateur company do it. Hope they release the rights but I seriously doubt it.
@theaterlover20 In the UK, the shows rights have been signed to Josef Weinberger, who licence a lot of shows that MTI have in the US... won't be long till their available over here. Am going to do it as soon as they're released!!
so they'll complain about a song about toys owning a court, but they won't complain about a Mary Poppins sending a mortal into hell in a bird cage??? WTF.
(No i am not bashing "brimstone and treacle" TIS MAH FAVE SONG!)
"Temper, Temper" is more frightening for children because they can relate to Jane and Michael. Whereas with "Brimstone and Treacle" it's not the case.
However I think this song should have stayed. If the child audience understand what's going on it will teach them a lesson. If they see someone getting punished for something when they're young it will cause them to not want the same thing to happen to them. Thus reminding them to hold their 'temper'
@mcflurrys46 Oh, so THAT'S why the song was different when I went to see the show live last Friday...I was really confused. xD "Playing the Game" was good, but this song is so much better. I really cannot stand some parents these days...compared to the Hunchback of Notre Dame, THIS is SCARY? come on
It was still in when I went to see it, it was really creepy, but good too :) it fits in anyway, michael and jane are pretty bad brats before mary poppins comes, that's kinda the whole point :') xx
rosie1244 2 days ago
OHMYGOD!! I did a dance to this in my old performing arts school called Stagecoach!!!
CrazyBeautifulLife00 3 weeks ago
This was my favorite song in the whole show. I saw it on Broadway when the song was still in, but I'm kind of disappointed nonetheless.
BTRgirl 3 weeks ago
Thos musical number is amazing! Definitely my favorite song of the musical.
It should have stayed in the show.
CitizenOfWonderland 1 month ago
Yeah, it was PRET-TY creepy... the hand in the dollshouse... BUT IT WAS STILL AWESOME
Coseepo 1 month ago
i saw the musical with this song in it. yes, i do admit it was a LITTLE scary, but it did get the message and it was my favorite part of the musical. so sad it is out of the musical now :(
kittykratz 2 months ago
Oh man this was my favorite song ):
sumutsu 4 months ago
While I love this song.... seeing it performed as a 16 year old freaked me out and I see why it was taken out
elisemarie93 5 months ago
gigs brought me here :P
xbabeeygirlx 5 months ago 2
@xbabeeygirlx such a banging beat!
NeAt0B0rRit0DUDE 5 months ago
Comment removed
Twitchy1o1 6 months ago
this reminds me of the first toy story, where Woody and co are freaking that Cid kid out
Twitchy1o1 6 months ago 2
i used to be petrified of this song :P
joseedee 7 months ago
Comment removed
MMshow1000 7 months ago
Yooou arrre haaaving a Mary Poppins hell dream!
texjoy86 7 months ago
Fucking parents ruining everything. They warned you! You all were idiots and brought your 3-year-olds anyway! STOP SHELTERING YOUR CHILDREN!
AkumuKeayo 7 months ago
This is really good music-wise, but I can understand why it was taken out. I've never seen the play, so I can't picture the scene. However, this song freaks me out, and I'm not exactly a little kid. "Children who refuse to learn will not return," is kind of nightmare fuel-ish to me.
animephoenix2468 9 months ago 4
I saw it in Czech Republic yesterday and it is pretty creepy, but nice song, I hope it won't be taken out, because I want to see this show again.
MarkiyC 10 months ago 2
This song freaks me out. XD
GaladedridDamodred 10 months ago 2
@imafan25 the reason y they put it in was to scare the Banks children not scare the kids in audience so much that that's all they'll remember. I agree it is a loss but Playing the Game is still good
EmmersEmily 1 year ago
i went to see the show when this song was in it it wasnt scary just a bit odd and freaky for a bit seeing large toys
xxepicsnailxx 1 year ago
it sounds like the toys are sending the kids to hell!!!
CodytheVictorian 1 year ago
What?! They took it out because it scared kids? Isn't the point? What kind of douche would complain so much about this to the point the song would need to be changed? If it scares your kids leave them at home so the adults can enjoy the show the way the creators intended...
imafan25 1 year ago 5
@imafan25 This is America, the great country of complainers. Of course they whined enough to have the song removed.
darklordmacavity 1 year ago 7
@imafan25. It's one thing to include scary segments in something that parents will expect to be scary. However, if you don't do research on the play itself and take your four year old to see Mary Poppins as their first Broadway show, you will be quite surprised, shocked, and upset to have a segment of nightmare-fuel right in the middle that forces you to leave when your kid won't go back after intermission because they are scared of the giant toys.
Benjamin1986980 10 months ago 6
@Benjamin1986980 On the plus side, they'll not lose their tempers so readily anymore. Which, really, is kind of the whole point.
GaladedridDamodred 10 months ago
giggs used this song in his song temper temper!!
CharlieReynolds93 1 year ago
LOVE THIS SONG. First time I saw this I was freaked out but I watched it again and I really enjoy the creepiness of it. :P but then they ruined it and made "playing the Game" :(
broadwaylifealways4 1 year ago
Oh my gosh! A group at regional acting competion last year performed this... SO FREAKY!!!!!!!!!!! I understand why they took it out. It's disney... People expect it to be child friendly. But this is a flipping amazing song!
elisemarie93 1 year ago
wen i saw it it was sooo creepy coz i woz bout 8
sproughticus 1 year ago
i saw this on stage... I really liked the scene!! :((( I cant believe they took it out
elphabastwin 1 year ago
A BIG LIPPED ALLIGATOR MOMENT... that doesn't exist anymore.
Maestrojosh87 1 year ago
This song is the BEST! The new song " Playing the Game" is good. But this is so much better.
broadwayfanaticxox1 1 year ago
this song isn't scary
bethflake 1 year ago
In our recital we had yesterday, we did a choegraphed dance number to this song, all dressed up as toys. It was awesome.
jenniaqua 1 year ago
Valentine was mad at Jane and Micheal and the other toys were angry too!
littlemisshyper1787 1 year ago
The Toys Were Alive!
littlemisshyper1787 1 year ago
Comment removed
emopinata12345 1 year ago
@emopinata12345 I doubt they'll ever release the rights. The production in New York and On Tour sells out nightly. But I would love to see an amateur company do it. Hope they release the rights but I seriously doubt it.
theaterlover20 1 year ago
@theaterlover20 In the UK, the shows rights have been signed to Josef Weinberger, who licence a lot of shows that MTI have in the US... won't be long till their available over here. Am going to do it as soon as they're released!!
krisrawlinson1 1 year ago
'Bout shit m'self.
KingSejong2 1 year ago 4
I think one of the reasons they took it out is because the actress who played Jane was totally freaked out by this. I don't blame her!
broadwaydude2378 1 year ago
I love this song!
There's a less scary version of the song in the Dutch version.....
But this is way better!
ChrissaaBadeendje 1 year ago
Awesome song this is. Can't believe they took it out :(
RCT3K 1 year ago 2
there is a song like this in the dutch version of the musical, but not as "scary".
downinthewater 1 year ago
I adore this number, and can't believe they've removed it from English versions.
They've kept this number in the 2010 Copenhagen production at Det Ny Teater, however, and I absolutely loved it!!
operafantomet 2 years ago
Did they remove it? It was in the London version of the show... it was very creepy I seem to remember.
Chachboon1 2 years ago
Man, this is SO much better than the replacement. Not cool.
bkev93 2 years ago 4
did they seriously took it out?
yumichanneko 2 years ago 3
it was pretty terrifying!
but i cant believe that its been cut :-(
ianhtigh 2 years ago 4
When i went to see the musical...this song was in here. >:( They had some (less creepy) song about "Playing the game" I WAS RIPPED OFF!
EABchannel333 2 years ago 18
They took Temper Temper out because fucking parents were complaining that it was too scary for kids and demanded to have it removed.
They DID warn them about this and obviously they didn't listen!
I was so angry too!! That's what made it great because it was close to the original story by PL Travers!
mcflurrys46 2 years ago 43
so they'll complain about a song about toys owning a court, but they won't complain about a Mary Poppins sending a mortal into hell in a bird cage??? WTF.
(No i am not bashing "brimstone and treacle" TIS MAH FAVE SONG!)
EABchannel333 2 years ago
"Temper, Temper" is more frightening for children because they can relate to Jane and Michael. Whereas with "Brimstone and Treacle" it's not the case.
However I think this song should have stayed. If the child audience understand what's going on it will teach them a lesson. If they see someone getting punished for something when they're young it will cause them to not want the same thing to happen to them. Thus reminding them to hold their 'temper'
CitizenOfWonderland 2 years ago
@mcflurrys46 tsk tsk..what a sad pc world we live in...
Luffyrulz09 1 year ago
@mcflurrys46 They put it back in because when i went it was there but a little boy started crying but his parents didn't complain
jesusfreaklol1 1 year ago
@mcflurrys46 Oh, so THAT'S why the song was different when I went to see the show live last Friday...I was really confused. xD "Playing the Game" was good, but this song is so much better. I really cannot stand some parents these days...compared to the Hunchback of Notre Dame, THIS is SCARY? come on
DuchessAliana 1 year ago
@mcflurrys46 i saw this with my cousin and this was in it i loved it
Austriamusicmix 7 months ago in playlist mary poppins
@EABchannel333 The way they staged it was freaking scary. You weren't ripped off..
JRipley15 3 months ago
I like this song its sounds amazing! this is awesome and thanks for uploading again
RentandWicked 2 years ago
my friend Megan Convery played Jane Banks in this. She said this scene, even though she knew the people, scared the HECK out of her to do!! :P
HayleyDawnluvsyhuu2x 2 years ago
You have a friend who played Jane? In a professional version? Cool!
GoilofdaNewsies 2 years ago
yeah it was in 2005, she was about 11 at the time :) and it was in the London West End version at The Prince Edward Theatre :)
HayleyDawnluvsyhuu2x 2 years ago
OMG i was one of those temper toys people, it was fun
emmiepig123 2 years ago 3
wow really at the same time / place?? so you knew Megan Convery??
HayleyDawnluvsyhuu2x 2 years ago
really thats awsome !!!! was it a proffesional show???
supercalifragili1000 2 years ago