Added: 4 years ago
From: midcirclenine
Views: 6,020
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (67)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm not a squealy fangirl but I must say this was really excellent, and I liked the discreet use of non Whovian footage as well.

    I'd never heard this version of Kate Bush's song before but it's fine, fits better than her own would have.

    Well done.

  • There would neever be a cure my DT withdrawals. He just sooooo GORGEOUS AND ADORABLE IN EVERYTHING HE DOES

    Brillant video..Not much of a Rose Fan but This was Great!

  • You did this in WMM? Damn... I should stop making excuses.

  • I love it! May help cure my DT withdrawals. Liked the sneaky Secret Smile clips! GREAT WORK!!

  • on...my...goodness! that was awesome! i really don't go for the Rose/Doctor vids. (only 'cause there's just SOOOOOO many.) but this vid gave me chills. it's amazing what one good song and fantastic editing can do. WELL DONE!!!

    that's it...i'm subing!!!! XD

  • I have watched several Doctor Who videos which use this song, and this one is by far the best. This video just has a sort of....I don't know...electric feel to it. It is just charged with emotion that the other videos lack. I am very very impressed. Great job!

  • Beautiful job! Probably one of the best Doctor Who fanvids out there :) 5*.

  • honestly, i cried the first time i saw this.. great job!

  • such a great video! best i've seen in ages. really dark and fractured. x

  • Excellent! And you made this with 'Windwoes' Movie Maker... you're my hero.

    Thank you for sharing! :)

  • Great video! The music fit really well especially into some of the scenes where for a second you are mislead into thinking they are singing. One bit I'd be careful about for any Doctor Who fan is the bit where he is running out of the exploding building with Martha because I instantly made the connection that they had and forgot about Rose for a bit, I s'pose it's only me though. But otherwise BRILLIANT!!!!!!

  • heya this vid is amazing - definatly one of your best.

    only criticism is that when you bur/merge one clip in to another it seems to flash before my eyes abit - this is caused by the shot you are uding having a new camera angle as you merge making everything seemed rushed and the viewers eyes go crazy. its a real hard problem to deal with - i am still having problems with it on my vids.

    the secret smile clips worked real well

    you obviously have a talent for this

    keep up the good work!

  • OMG... Doctor WHo + Placebo = WIN.

    The clips are so perfect... I couldn't look away from this.

    And the 'Secret Smile' worked seamlessly into it. :)

  • awesome choice of clips!

    yeah I like movie maker, but its so limited.. plus takes forever to save then you realize whoops I wanted to change that.. sigh :P

  • I have never seen a video that has affected me more. Kudos to you- I'm extremely impressed and it's definitely one of my favorites!

  • That video is one of the best videos I have ever seen!

  • I am completely impressed!  You put together some fabulous clips, very good video quality, excellent song choice (never heard the Placebo remake before now). The juxtaposition of the Secret Smile clip with the Ten/Rose clip was very well done, and worked beautifully! You did a terrific job. I really need to learn how to do this.

  • WOW! I have never seen something so GREAT made with Windows Movie Maker! I LOVE IT!<3

  • Fabulous. :)

  • Incredibly wonderful!! lol.

    And I looooooooooooove the Placebo version of Running up that Hill, one of my favourite songs. So, in my opinion you made a perfect vid!!

  • Wow! What a powerful video. You did a great job of matching the emotion of the scenes with the lyrics of the song. I'm a huge fan of the original Runnin' Up That Hill by Kate Bush. Now I'm going to have to look up Placebo's version of it because it sounds like they did a bang up job of covering it.

  • almost cried, what's the song called?

    wiht love/ Hannah

  • it's called runnin' up that hill by placebo

  • Amazing

  • VERY cinematically done. I commend your work. The way you juxtapose different scenes to create a memory or a specific emotion is nicely edited and suits the idea.

  • I've watched this video about eight times over so far. Amazing work!

  • This video was amazing!

  • wow, that's incredible! i love it!

    really clever using that scene from 'secret smile' too!

    really great work!

  • Beautiful!

  • Wow.

  • excellent job. Can't wait til rose comes back.

  • Brilliant video... Well done!!

  • Very moving video, great song choice.

    Gobsmacked...

    Brilliant!

  • Wow, the raw emotion in this is amazing. Fantastic job.

  • this is brilliant

  • Oh god, this is amazing. I just watched it gaping... wow. Just really wow. I absolutely love this. So emotional... really overwhelming. You've done well on this!

  • Well, looks like everybody's said it. This is plain amazing. Even if you had troubles, which it doesn't show that you did, this turned out so well! I'm very impressed!

    P.S. What's the clip at 1:10 from? (It looks like some sort of Doctor Who special.) It's awesome and it totally fits the song.

  • it's david's dr. who trailer

  • i just wanna say that u make some of the best videos i've ever seen...all of them are phenomenal

  • brilliant manipulation of scenes!

  • Truly brilliant - look forward to future vids.

  • I have to admit I love this video. I like how you snuck the make out scene in there.  It looks just enough like Rose to really work. Great job!

  • That was really great. Placebo fits here perfectly, and it's sooo well done. Never delete this!

  • simply brilliant.

    i'm not a fan of Placebo, but this completely worked! *****

  • *stares* wow. just... wow O_O faved and 5*ed, and this is from an obsessed Nine fan. eh, cant think of anything more intelligent to say at the moment hehe

  • There are so many Ten/Rose tributes out there, but this one is fresh. You've chosen a really interesting cover of the Kate Bush classic "Running Up That Hill", for a start, and your editing is top-notch. Isn't it something that the clips of John Smith and Brendan Block stand out, because they are so clearly *not* the Doctor?

  • This is fantastic! Love the song! I'm gonna DL this!

  • wow this is real good i to give 5 stars bravo

  • -bodyflail-

    Brilliant, amazing, fucking AWESOME

    -standing ovation-

    Oh and the video was good as well

    -cheeky grin-

    regards,

    Your favourite person ^^

  • This is awesome like everyone has said before me, but it's brilliant use of music.

  • This is totally amazing. You've done a great job at editing the scenes and I really like the FX you used on it. Carry on with your great work. 5 stars for sure.

  • PLEASE DON'T EVER DELETE THIS VIDEO! It's so wonderfully angsty! I adore the song too!

  • Wow! That was quite good. And the snogging bit was absolutely perfect!

  • woha... truely amazing.

  • omg the doctor is a really big baby he crys so much looool

  • How brilliant, and I especially loved the idea with using the snogging scene from Secret Smile - it fit absolutely perfectly.

    Very well done. Favving and 5 stars :))).

  • You did a wonderful job on this. I loved the editing. Great song choice too.

  • Great song choice and excellent editing. Also love the fact that they use the word asunder...that word never gets used enough. Muy excellante love the vid ^^

  • wow, this is exactly like a house vid i saw. i LOVED this.

    WHEN WAS THE DOCTOR EVER SNOGGING SOMEONE IN THE DARK??

  • That's actually one of the two clips from 'Secret Smile' that I accidentally left out of the credits. Sorry for the confusion.

  • oh thanks!

  • Wow. Amazing emotion. I've found a new favorite!

  • This was fantastic!

    You did a beautiful job editing it and choice the perfect song.

  • <3. Srsly.

  • Oh this was absloutly brilliant!

    TEN/ROSE emotion me, everytime..

  • love it.

  • BRILLIANT! FANTASTIC!

    -The Doctor

    p.s. sorry to hear about your soul being stolen, I'll work on that!

  • Love it. The editing and effects had gone nicely with the tone of the vid. Way to go.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more