Added: 3 years ago
From: fadedcinderella
Views: 78,257
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (159)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the book is totaly diffrent anyway.

  • This movie is only worth watching if you have Rifftrax

  • twilight won for best fight

  • it looks so.... low budget ):

  • i hate james he hurts bella and that sucks

  • not at all the same as the book

    But oh my god robert is so fitt

    i'd totally tap thatt.

  • urgh ffs.

    the book is so differnt.

    AND BETTER ¬_¬

  • @musiclovermimi so true

  • not the same as the book

  • i dont see where bella gets bitten could someone tell me wer?

  • thats not wat happens in the book

  • no book turned into the film is going to the same.. they said from the beginning it won't be the same, this scene is way better than the book!

  • loved this scene very action filled

  • N00000000000000000000000000000­00000000000000000000000000000 Poor Edward + Bella Fuck That Mutrherfuciing James!!

  • o thank u . . is it really him singing it ?

  • whats the song when they show the fire and bella has the flashback and stuff like that?? can someone tell me the song?

  • the song is

    Let Me Sign by Robert Pattinson

  • Twilight was awesome!!

  • then why did you watch this

  • u say that that means you are oops sorry jk

  • :)

    Can't friggin wait for the movie!! 5 days!!!

    Edward<3

    !!!!!!!!!!!!

    KICK HIS ASS ALL THE WAY TO THE MOON ED!!

  • I kno the movie gets changed around from the book but damn it was so much better when Edward came in later =(

  • oh my goshhh

    i can wait

    6 days left!

  • Awesome. can't wait til the movie. I need to read the books!!

  • KICK HIS ASS EDWARD

    overexcited =D

  • god i hate james! kick his butt edward!

  • in the book it happened in a dance studio didn't it?

    this doesn't look like a dance studio

    its looks like a church.

  • i think its supposed to be a dance studio

    if we watch they whole movie well see

  • GO EDWARD!!! KICK HIS ASS!!!

    sorry..got carried away...:D

  • KICK HIS ASS EDWARD!!

    Sorry, got a little carried away...

  • the only part i don't like about this is that they make him fly. that's stupid. it says in the book, he runs fast, doesn't fly... but everything else is amazing =] i'm so excited!!

  • no your right he doesnt fly but

    they can jump really far and that is what he is doing, like in breaking dawn they jump over across the river they dont fly

  • Twilight will be released in theaters November 21st!

    YAY, ITS COMMING EARLEY!!!

    go 2 SM's website if u dont believe me..lol there gonna have 2 change the info of the trailer ;)

  • I know when I first hear about it,

    I was soo happy :D

    so glad we get to see it way earlier ;P

  • um. thats not what happens in the book. she never sees him in the studio when james is around... she sees edward when she wakes up. and james is killed by jasper and emmet. and wtf? i imagined a smaller ballet studio. thats HUGE! well. i guess ill have to see the movie but reserve my comments cuz if not people at the movies are gona kill me jajaj

  • hah true but im acutally glad they showed alot more its makes it more scary and good that they show bella interacting with james and edward and all of that if you seen the full scence of this at comic con trust me you will love it

  • i think he's sexy Lol not as goos as edward but still

  • his head is too big for his body!

  • If I Don't Marry Edward Im Gonna Marry Robert Pattinson!! I read the book 5 times in a week! And Im Still Obsseesseedd!!

    Anyone who hasn't read it, I Strongly reccomend that you do!!!

  • god! wowee! he is a good actor its like he lets his guard down for one minute and he looks at her and just looks so completely in love with her and then he gets attacked...but it all works out ok in the end :D

  • this isn't what happened in the book =[[

    im not going to be liking this movie

  • me either its all wrong bellas not aspose to know shes bitten till she feels the burn later and she aspose to pass out from her head bleeding and edwards not even aspose to be there, whats up with the peper spray?.... and it doesnt even look like a dance studio, mirrors arnt in the middle of a dane stuio you would run into them and it looks like a frikin church, im gunna see the movie but i think ill be critisizing it alot

  • They showed the entire scene at comic con and yes,all of the things that happened in the book do indeed happen in the movie.

  • OMFG!! :39 to :40!!! listen!

    Edward says "I love you", But his lips dont move!!!! omfg....I NEED TO SEE THIS MOVIE!

  • Here, I'll type this... The following is a section near this scene.

    "Would you like to rethink your last request?" he asked pleasantly. His toe nudged my broken leg and I heard a piercing scream. With a shock, I realized it was mine.

    "Wouldn't you rather have Edward try to find me?" he prompted.

    "No!" I croaked. "No, Edward, don't--" And then something smashed into my face, throwing me back into the broken mirrors.

  • Yes that is written in the book

  • and yes,that almost-exact thing happens in the real scene.

  • Yeah, everyone, if you've seen the 4 minute clip that MTV did behind the scenes, there's still more to this scene. Like Bella getting her hand bitten, her being cornered by James, & even Bella screaming "No, Edward, don't!"

    [Which, BTW, is on page 450 of Twilight. I'm not sure how it will be interpreted in the movie, but in the book, when Bella shouts this it, she is screaming this for the camera. Remember, James is video-taping this, so it was a plea to Edward not to come hunt James down]

  • omgomgogmgomgomg he fits the character of edward perfectly!! i luv it!!

  • i love the way he looks at her .. when he like .. comes up from the beginning?

    in my opinion, he's perfect to play the part.

    bella's pretty good too. the action looks a little fake but i guess it's prolly gonna turn out better.

  • Oh my! I am so psyched! This movie is going to be amazing!!!

  • my god thats exciting. i was hyperventilating thoughout. haha

  • okay well thhnx bunches for posting this Fadedcinderella :) now me b off to finishing elcipse for the 20th time lolz :) <3

  • wow ..hmmm she doesnt even have the pepper spray on her its n her bag at home ...the rest its prety awsome cant what to see it he he says "Bella" what i can make out anywayz lol Stephenie Meyers ROCKS<3 cant wat untill Breaking Dawn comes out "jumps for joy"XD

  • *dances*

    omg. ily.

  • I wanna see more!!!!!! *bounces like a 2 year old*

  • I think the movie is going to be great, but I don't like James's character very much. His acting isn't what I would have expected.

  • i didnt like it...come on bella is stupid but not that stupid come on her pepper spray? and james flying? he supposed to run or jump but not float and come on edward isnt that stupid and bella didnt saw all that agg i hope the movie gets better because i want to see taylor lautner without shirt XD in new moon

  • well you have to know that bella always carries pepper spray and that is the only this should thought of, and james didnt fly he jumped, and how is edward stupid? and yes we know bella isnt suppost to see that but arent you excited that you get to see them fight?

  • yeah i know that but didnt like that, and i know he jumped but it was like fliying or something i didnt imagined it in that way, of course im excited but i dont want to be disappointed and i tought it would be better than this, and about edward he wouldnt stare at her in that way he would be faster that what i mean, i didnt like the way the director managed the scene thats all...

  • OMG i love edward!! i have to say though i dont like kristen stuart i dont get why nobody likes edward though i mean really he matches perfectly!! anyway i cant wait till twilight and breaking dawn come out

  • thats the scene in the ballet room right? where we learn about alice cuzza james?

  • go edward!!!

  • JAMES IS HOT! O_O he can push me on the floor any day lol

  • wow... i think i just wet myself :S

  • I. Am. So. Excited. I can't even talk..

    O_O;

  • how the heck did you get the clip!?! I want it bad!

  • I got it from Ever Glow

  • what the hell Edward was never there during tis.She gets the crap beat out of her first!They ruined my favorite scene in the twilight series!

  • you have to know that the scene is different!

    and she will get her hand bit and everything

    so no edward didnt ruin anything.

  • Yes but Edward wasn't meant to be in the scene they were supposed come suck the venom ,and burn james alive.Whatever the case ; I'm sure I will be satisfied anyways.

  • yeah thats true,

    but they dont burn james alive they never said anything other than Jasper & Emmett took him away and there was another blood, I dont remember them saying they burned him alive

    well I think he will suck the venom out,

    but its sweet to see Edward & James acutally fight.

  • it doesnt happen like that in the book what are they smoking in the ovie indusry now?

  • ok, people have to know that every movie that is based on the book isnt exactly the same, when they make it into a movie, you have to know that, movies have more detail and show you more books dont, it will probably be better

  • Wow!!! I can't wait to see the whole movie!! Oh, and I don't remember James saying that stuff to Edward. How did that end up happening? Just wondering, cause they didn't say that at all inside of the book.

  • yeah they didnt, but in movie they will show alot more detail cause they didnt show Bella acutally get bitten and they didnt show James dying so I love it! :P

  • why do they keep making them look as if they can fly? they cant!!

  • lol you have to remember they have super strenght so they can jump far, not really flying

  • doesn't bella get smashed againts the mirror in the book?

  • yes she does, but remember the scene was cut,

    so there are alot of things that we didn't get to see, but I dunno if she gets thrown into the mirror in the movie.

  • tht wuz awesome!!!!!

  • omg! i think people NEED! HAVE! to read the books before they watch the film, i re-read books before i watch a movie adaptation, helps you understand and appreciate the movie more..

    ooh n btw i didn't get to see this scene on mtv movie awards, oO did i miss it? or don't we get to see it in the U.K.?

  • one of the crew from an interview said, he has never seen a film script as identicle as Twilight, i mean obviously there will be some alterations, but remember in the book we didn't get any detailed description of how james was killed.. i mean i love the book, but the movie provides opportunites that the book couldn't, graphic effects etc..

    oh n have you guys seen the cover of Breaking dawn, i'm not too hype about it.. hmm maybe i'll grow to like it.

  • Thank you! someone who acutally understands!

    :P

    I acutally thought it was interesting

    but different, ive grown on it & acutally loved it, what t-shirt tattoo did you get in the book?

  • hehe.. its ks i'm loyal to twilight ahah well my interests xD..

    huh? wat t-shirt tattoo? n which book?

    wat do yu think the pawn & queen actually symbolises on the cover of B.D? x

  • well when you get the special edition eclispe

    in the back of the book it either has team edward or team jacob that you can iron onto a shirt

    I dunno, ive seen many theorys and they all sounds great but im really not sure, something to do with bella i think

    what about you, what do you think?

  • ooh.. nope im waitin 4 the paperbk version. i doubt id use the tattoo tho. wat did yu get?

    im nt sure either, i gess u kinda ave 2 understand chess to come up with a theory.

    .. oh n i keep 4gettin 2 ask wat is dat Bella was holdin in her hand at the beginning wasit pepper spray or sumfin lools? x

  • ohh, I got team edward!! so i was happy

    I dont know if you need to understand chess, but I guess it would be easier, but I dunno it could mean alot of things I guess,

    Lol no your right, it was pepper spray, she carries it all the time.

  • ahaha.. i can almost imagine 'Team dward' onlyy twilighters would understand =D

    man i need to read the book again, juss it's distracting when i get in2 a book, constantly dreaming..blocking the world out. nehoo/ gosh talkin 2 yu like im on msn or sumfin

    t.cares =]

  • Also, we cannot expect the movie to include everything in the book sadly, because producers and directors always seem to want to change things up. Hopefully it will be similar.

  • The script is different from the book because it is an adaptation of the novel. Twilight the Movie is based on Twilight--it's not going to be verbatim.

    Movies and books are two different mediums. Movies are visual and fast; books rely on imagination and can take their time getting to the point. Inner monologues and subtle body language are very hard to pull off in a movie, so they make it dialogue or cut it out entirely.

  • I like the scene However it's not what was in the book and is disappointing. I have dissected the books. And it will be sad that the movie will not live up to the book, however it will be special in its own way.

    I cannot wait till August 2nd to read Breaking Dawn, the first chapter sounds amazing.And it is sad that it will be the last book. I am equally excited for Midnight Sun which is coming out next spring.

    I felt like Bella as well even after putting the books down,these books are special

  • K! THNX BTW!

  • how many books r there, i can't get a hold of them yet! but seeing this clip made me understand more about it...

  • There are 3 books

    soon to be 4

  • LISTEN EVERYONE!!!!

    in 33seconds into the film her foot is broken you can see her holding it!

    and it doesnt show him breaking her foot to make suspence becuare Right Before edward comes in they cut scenes. YOU WELCOME! i am so good!!!

  • Um...i want the boooks out not the movie. People will skip the book like they did with Narnia and stuff. I wish they would finish the series then realease the movie cause my friends are going to watch the movie not read the book :(

    OH WELL

    life goes on

  • I think people who have read all the books like me :P will defintely cant wait till breaking dawn! to come out, but I think if people who dont read the books will only go see the movie, im sure the people who go watch this movie, will wanna go out and buy all of the books!!!

  • Cant wait!

    =]

  • Yess exactly! the book is amazing

    arrrghhh cnt wait nw, oh & isit just me, or do you guys feel kinda depressed reading New MoOn? =( i love it, just that i fell for Edward in twilight ( who didn't?) so i guess kinda felt like Bella in new moon, even when i've put the book down, LOL couldn't figure for few days hehe x

    xx

  • Yeah I felt sad reading New Moon,

    In some ways Im alot like bella, & it's strange when you figure out that you are :P

  • oh peoples they cut out parts of this scen, son this is not the whole tihng

  • i know Bella supposed 2 be unconscious while Edward etc kills James according the book.. but personally i think its pretty good like this, as we get to visually see the battle between Edward & James, it isn't described as much in the book, oo n i wana c Bella's reaction.. so im happy with the results.

    i love the pained expression on Edwards face.. aww =( lol

    xx

  • yeah I agree with you

    im glad that they are gunna show the fight,

    makes it more interesting,

    not saying the book is boring, saying

    it gives us more to look at in the movie

    :P

  • i think all movies based on books should follow the book exactly. But i think the movie will be OK.

  • yeah I wish they did,

    but it hard trying to do exactly what the book says cause of the graphics and all of that, and sometimes if they dont its better and maybe its not

    but I still think this movie is going to be awesome no matter what.

  • omg omg omg omg omg omg omg omg omg omg omg omg omg I can't stop jumping up and down!!!

  • I liked that so much. I can't wait until the movie comes out. They did a very good job. I like the actors too.

  • wow

    not so bad as i thought it would be!!! they all play the characters so well

    even robert who i had doubts about!

  • i want to see the same people that watched this video to vote for the twilight cast!!!

    on portrait magazine!!!!!!!!!!

    vote twilighterssssssss!!! vote

  • If you didnt like the scene, you have to admit the acting was outstanding. I think the acting is whats gonna save the film.

  • edward wasn't suppose to come til the very end!!!! but still looks like an okay movie even if they didin't stick to the book!

  • *spazzes*

  • Aaaaaargh!!!!I wanna see more!!!

  • why is everyone complaining so much about the movie? who cares if the movie is not the same as the book. if you guys haven't watched any other movies based on books then there is something wrong. so far what i seen on this clip i like it and i have beliefs that this movie will be good and i'll see it whether it's good or not because i support it and so should the other Twilight fans who have doubts about this movie. SO STOP COMPLAINING PEOPLE!!!

  • CAN NOT WAIT

  • edward's pretty! <3

    when they cast him, i thought, "ew. bleh. no way THAT actor can come anywhere close to perfect edward..."

    but he's good, i admit!

    and bella looks like the part, too! ^^

    even so, the movie will NEVER be as good or better than the book!!!

  • lol u figured ud check this out b4 u went to bed?

  • *faints*

  • I love the books, but this doesn't look so good. I'm not sure about this movie...not seeming to follow the book very well.

  • *dies*

    (L)

  • i love twilight and the other books

    love them

    this is horrible

    the effects are bad. the acting is bad.

    this isn't gonna be a good movie

    i hate it already

  • I think you should reconsider

    cause the scene is cut so we dont see the whole thing, trust me when you see the whole clip and the whole movie you will not disapointed!

    & I dont think you should base this clip on the whole movie

  • That's what I'm talkin about!!! You show em edward!!! By the way the guy who plays Edward does his facial expressions exactly right!!! His eyes was just like the way she described them in the book

  • Didn't any of you guys notice that Bella's hand WAS bitten?

  • i dont think i was bitten yet

    but it will be, ive seen many pictures of her lying on the ground with her hand bitten

    =]

  • Ever since it was made known that a film was being made, me and my friends have been hanging on to every peice of news, re-reading the book till we lose count. We expected magic, we expected to be blown away by the film, we expected it to be nearly as good as the book.

    I'm sorry to say to the film producers we are severly disapointed. This scene from the book couldnt be more wrong.

  • 1)Bella is half dead when Edward arrives and James has bitten her

    2)Edward arrives with the others by car

    3)These vampires do not fly! they run.

    4)Why strangle? vampires don't need air!!

    5)Bella is thrown into a mirror, shes barely touched!!!!

    This film is going to be a severe dissapointment to twilight fans everywere.

    And why is the film going to be rated PG, the majority of the readers are at least 15, this gives them room for a bit of blood and guts dosnt it!!!!

    Overall PATHETIC!!!!

  • you have to know that you cant base a film on a clip, and there is more in this scene then we saw,and the film is going to be different then the acutal book so yeah that might be a little disapointing, but in genereal the movie is going to be just as amazing as the book.

  • Yes i am aware that the film cant be the same but dosent it have to get the basics right???

    James biting her was one of the main bits and she was bleeding so badly the other cullens couldnt stand it! Disgraceful attempt

  • true, but remember this scene was cut so we haven't see it all yet, but in other promos and pictures she is bit so dont worry im sure when you see the whole thing you wil not be disapointed

    =]

  • they may not fly, but they CAN leap! Remeber? thet are hunters. they're meant to jump high

  • yeesh calm down, it still rocks anyway!!!!

  • that looks soooo good i cant wait!!!!!

  • OH DEAR LORD

    *dies to death*

  • AWESOME!!!! I can't flickin' wait. It's tourte.

  • i love the moment where Edward looks at Bella breathless. and where he kicks him awesome.

  • There will be changes, which I will get kind of miffed about.

    But if Stephenie Meyer is happy, then for the most part I'm sure I will be too =]

  • omg! I've been waiting 4 this 2 happen! It's amazing! I'm such a freakin fan of the series! The music when edward comes in is so breathtaking! It's like WOW! Get me an edward! I'm sooooo excited! This rocks! Go TWILIGHT!

  • um..why are they flying??? Anwway, the movie looks pretty good. You can't really judge the whole movie by just one scene but it looks good

  • they aren't flying,

    they have super strength

    so that is how they can jump so far and so high :P

    yeah your right people cant really judge the movie on one clip

  • well the look edward gives bella is not because hes mad.. he is trying to control himself because he smells bella's blood and could kill her very easily.

    its pretty different from the book..james is supposed to bite bellas hand to make it bleed.. but the movie is still going to be great.

  • He does, there is a flash in the middle.

    They skipped something

  • actually, this is only a min of the fight scene. Lots of backstage/promo vids have cuts and stills where it shows much much more to the fight scene that can obviously be shown in a min long clip. For example, I've seen the still of Bella's wrist bitten in many different promo vids. :) We haven't seen all of it yet...yeah, can't wait!

  • omg!! i really don like the changes, i mean of course i accepted that there was gonna be changes, but the way they changed it is so...arrrrrrrrrgh! but that does NOT mean i dun wanna see the movie. haih!

  • OH

    MY

    SWEET

    JESUS!!

    I'm so excited!

    this is going to be a really good movie!

    December better get here faster than 7 months

  • he already bit her , her hands bleeding and in the book he doesent even know jamems bit her until charisile told him so they dident rlly mess anthing up

    i love itt

  • I was a little confused by the look Edward gives Bella when he comes but its probably either because he's angry that she betrayed him or that he can smell her blood or something...but I think thats unlikely.

  • i think its the blood

    because if u have read the books u would

    know how edward iz and he would never think that in a time like this

    (plz dont take this as a mean comment

  • maybe both.

  • *SQUEAL*

  • ON MTV THEY MADE A VIDEO WITH ONLY 6 REACTIONS.

    ME AND MY FRIENDS ARE IN IT! we're the 3 girls just screaming ...2nd to last people.

    OH.MY.EDWARD. was it on T.V?

  • OH MY GOD!!! I have chills!! I can not wait. I am so excited. December needs to get here FAST!!

  • he isn't supposed to come until AFTER James bites Bella! they're already freaking screwing it up.

    but otherwise it looks amaaazing

  • well maybe they will just change it up a little.

    Only slightly though

    They better not screw the whole thing up or me and many people at my skool will be pissed

  • well you have to know that there

    is alot more in this scene that has been cut out, and I think the movie is going to be way different from the book so people are going to be disapointed but Im still excited to see the movie!!

  • ohmygoodness ...

    I can not get enough of this video ... Edward's facial expression when he see's Bella ... is PERFECT! Rob Pattinson = Edward Cullen

    And WHY oh why is James so damn sexy?! Seriously ... HOT

    <3

  • I know!

    James is so sexy being the bad guy

    he plays it soo perfect

  • The thing about Edward having no reflection is only in Bella's dream.

    And.. Mmmm! am i the only one who loves the manly noises James and Edward make when James hits Edwards head against the mirror??..GAH SO HOT!

    I LOVE ROBERT PATTINSON!!<33

  • wow i want 2 see thatt

    its my favorite book

    but wen james smashes edwards head against the mirror you can see his reflection. vampires aren't supposed 2 have reflections it even says in "new moon" that edward has no reflection.

    so wats up with that....

    anyway the movie looks good and i cant wait 2 see it. yay!!!! im soooooooo!!!!!!!! EXCITED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • It does? I don't recall that being said, at all. I remember them joking about Edward showing up in the pictures Bella was taking.

  • Ehh to be honest kirsten doesnt look at her best hopefully shes better with the rest. the special effects like the jumping look incredibly fake.

    but gosh rob was an amazing edward! hopefully he can save the movie

  • yes, im not 2 big on the how the camera iz jumping everywhere

    its hard 2 focus on anything.

    but oh well, its not like thats gonna stop me from luving this

  • Oh My God I was so excited before but know I'm super excited. Can't Wait!!!!!!!!

  • AAAAAAAAAHHHHH!!!!! I CANT BELIEVE I MISSED THIS!!!!! EEERRRR I AM SOOOOOOOOOOOO MAD AT MYSELF!!! thanks for uploading this!!!!

  • no problem!!

    I love twilight I will be putting up many more things to come

    =]

  • question, was that look he gave bella because of her blood sent? or was it that he thinks that he made her be in so much pain? i dont understand that.

  • sasukeluver82, probably both! I think we're seeing quite a struggle of emotion in Edward in that shot...

  • yeah, he is tend to do that alot. i cant wait for it to come out in theaters

  • ditto

  • OMGOMGOMG!!!! :'( i was really looking forward to this...but...but... :'( i hate to say it, but....it looks quite .... CRAP! :'( i hope the rest of the film, is good ...hmm. ah well breaking dawn out on 2nd of august :D

  • well, that was only a min long clip, lol...there's a lot more movie to be had yet

  • I love it. And that's putting it calmly...cause underneath I'm bubbling in excitement!! I'm trying to contain! 6 more months?!?!?! GAH! No way. lol Yeah, it's different from the book, but that's ok. As we all know, a movie adaptation is always slightly different compared to the book. The essence is very much there, and that's all I care about. Rob...holy crow, was awesome...I agree with KelleyH, the way he looks at her...it's smoldering with traces of heartache underneath...:) LOVE IT!

  • SHIT SHIT SHIT SHIT !

    I AM SO EXCIDED !

    :D

    :D

    :D

    I just died a little

  • Well, it's different from the book but still good. I didn't think Robert could really play Edward but after seeing some of the clips and behind the scene stuff, he fits him rather well. The looks he gives her are not only surprisingly sexy but also heartaching.